@JulianaChong-ti9gd it's there job to dance and sing, but coachella is not about dance bro, and they should sing while dancing, but even in there encores? they are not dancing but their vocals us so freaking ugly
@@Aespasm2024 hanya disana,di berbagai acara dia bagus bagus saja(bahkan mujin memuji akan bakat dia akmu juga,sekelas penyanyi yang sama hebatnya memujinya dan kamu malah menghinanya?),bahkan saat dia live di weverse dan mengcover lagu lagu dia tetap bagus dia sering cover live bahkan kemarin dia melakukan nya dan vocal nya tetap sangat bagus,di encore dia hanya 2 yang tidak stabil dan bahkan hanya di lagu easy saja karna nada rendah selain di situ tetap dia bagus banget,sudah banyak bukti tidak perlu tutup mata,jangan hanya beberapa kesalahan kamu mengecap nya buruk dia juga manusia jangan dangkal
I'm an NSWER and Yunjin gets the edge because she supports her head voice and can support up to B4 in her mixed, yes Kyujin and Sullyoon have higher stamina, but neither of them have supported the head voice register
Lily B Hae B- NinNing C+ Monday C+ Winter C Yunjin C Chisa D+ Sullyon D+ Kyujin D+ Miyeon D+ Liz D+ Juria D+ Giselle D+ Karina D (and there are more idols) In addition to the fact that the vocal range is not everything in the vocal, it is also the vocal technique)
Please, stop thinking about vocal range as one and only criterion for the level of vocal skill. As professional vocalist and vocal teacher I'm so sad to see this mistake again and again. The only thing worse than this is “if a vocalist sings high notes, then she sings WELL”. Gosh... 1. Lily 2. Haewon 3. Ningning (up to this point everything was fine, but then errors started) 4. Sollyun 5. Monday from Weekly 6. Liz from Ive 7. Winter 8. Kyujin 9. Sieun from StayC 10. Miyeon from (G)-IDLE Yunjin good at ACADEMIC vocal. Her pop vocals technique is pretty weak, right now she's just average pop singer, as Hanni from New Jeans. BTW, I can't understand why Hybe didn't use her skills properly. And I'm not sure we can call XG "k-pop"... They are Japanese group.
Jika kamu menilainya hanya karna kesalahan nya kemarin maka itu sangat dangkal,selain di sana dia bagus bagus saja,lihat dia di acara live lain nya babe lee mujin contohnya acara yang sama dengan sullyoon yang di tayangkan
yes ok, she isn't the best at live singing, but she's an opera singer, if u have ears, u would hear her in that clip and tell that she's actually professional like fr-
@user-ul7mm4ru8k that's most definitely just a trick that sounds good to a wide public. After hearing her singing this awful live, I can't believe that her opera-style was legit. She couldn't even sing her own solo songs standing perfectly still with guitar. That's a shame. She's not an opera singer, she was just trained to be one at some point, but in no sense this education was finished.
@@lemon3391its not just about support range. Eminem has a wider range than Whitney Houston but does that make him a better singer💀 there's other criterias like Dynamics, Agility, Technique sm more to consider than just support ranges
NOTE :
I DID NOT PUT ALL THE FOURTH GENERATION GROUPS, I PUT A SPECIFIC NUMBER OF THEM
I'VE PUT :
LE SSERAFIM
NEW JEANS
NMIXX
AESPA
GIDLE
ITZY
IVE
XG
-------
THE RANKING :
1. LILY (NMIXX)
2. HAEWON (NMIXX)
3. NINGNING (AESPA)
4. WINTER (AESPA)
5. YUNJIN (LESSERAFIM)
6. SULLYOON (NMIXX)
7. KYUJIN (NMIXX)
8. JURIA (XG)
9. CHISA (XG)
10. KARINA (AESPA)
-----
VOCAL RANGE
1. LILY (B)
2. HAEWON (-B)
3. NINGNING (C+)
4. WINTER (C/C+)
5. YUNJIN (C)
6. SULLYOON (-C)
7. KYUJIN (-C)
8. JURIA (D+)
9. CHISA (D+)
10. KARINA (D+)
Kyujin is D+
Miyeon???
Ningning C+/-B
Karina / Giselle D+/-C
didn't you see yunjin coachella vocals? still kyujin and sullyoon are below her? are you serious?
Secara support range tier yunjin emang lebih,dia hanya kurang stabil di sana,lain dari sana dia bagus bagus saja
Yunjin c
Sullyoon d+/c-
Actually dancing step can make a people being not stable like unforgiven dance step
@JulianaChong-ti9gd it's there job to dance and sing, but coachella is not about dance bro, and they should sing while dancing, but even in there encores? they are not dancing but their vocals us so freaking ugly
@@Aespasm2024 hanya disana,di berbagai acara dia bagus bagus saja(bahkan mujin memuji akan bakat dia akmu juga,sekelas penyanyi yang sama hebatnya memujinya dan kamu malah menghinanya?),bahkan saat dia live di weverse dan mengcover lagu lagu dia tetap bagus dia sering cover live bahkan kemarin dia melakukan nya dan vocal nya tetap sangat bagus,di encore dia hanya 2 yang tidak stabil dan bahkan hanya di lagu easy saja karna nada rendah selain di situ tetap dia bagus banget,sudah banyak bukti tidak perlu tutup mata,jangan hanya beberapa kesalahan kamu mengecap nya buruk dia juga manusia jangan dangkal
I'm an NSWER and Yunjin gets the edge because she supports her head voice and can support up to B4 in her mixed, yes Kyujin and Sullyoon have higher stamina, but neither of them have supported the head voice register
I knew you are kidding when you put yunjin above sullyoon
Monday from Weeekly left the chat...
Admin only knows popular groups lmfao
1•Lily (B)
2•Haewon (B-)
3•NingNing (^C+/B-)
4•Monday (^C+/B-)
5•Winter (^C)
6•Yunjin (C)
7•Sullyoon (C-)
8•Kyujin (^D+/C-)
9•Giselle (^D+/C-)
10•Miyeon (^D+/C-)
What about XG??
I'm pretty sure giselle is still a solid D+
1. Nayeul (B+)
@@AsMaria-ix1ox haha she is tier B
Lily B
Hae B-
NinNing C+
Monday C+
Winter C
Yunjin C
Chisa D+
Sullyon D+
Kyujin D+
Miyeon D+
Liz D+
Juria D+
Giselle D+
Karina D
(and there are more idols)
In addition to the fact that the vocal range is not everything in the vocal, it is also the vocal technique)
kyujin is literally main dancer & lead rapper (same for karina) and she’s here, i’m so proud of my nmixx girls
4 nmixx members ❤
bro forget about kepler main vocalist and purplekiss
Please, stop thinking about vocal range as one and only criterion for the level of vocal skill. As professional vocalist and vocal teacher I'm so sad to see this mistake again and again. The only thing worse than this is “if a vocalist sings high notes, then she sings WELL”. Gosh...
1. Lily
2. Haewon
3. Ningning
(up to this point everything was fine, but then errors started)
4. Sollyun
5. Monday from Weekly
6. Liz from Ive
7. Winter
8. Kyujin
9. Sieun from StayC
10. Miyeon from (G)-IDLE
Yunjin good at ACADEMIC vocal. Her pop vocals technique is pretty weak, right now she's just average pop singer, as Hanni from New Jeans. BTW, I can't understand why Hybe didn't use her skills properly.
And I'm not sure we can call XG "k-pop"... They are Japanese group.
Jika kamu menilainya hanya karna kesalahan nya kemarin maka itu sangat dangkal,selain di sana dia bagus bagus saja,lihat dia di acara live lain nya babe lee mujin contohnya acara yang sama dengan sullyoon yang di tayangkan
what about pink fantasy yechan?
@@CerealBoxiee she's an amazing vocalist, unfortunately people don't pay much attention to nugu groups no matter how talented they are :/
Karina is much better than Sieun though, are you only counting vocal line.??
@@heartyiwe cant just rank vocal solely by vocal support, sieun has better technique than karina
Liz should be here
Lilyyyyy❤❤❤❤
Giselle and Karina are both in the same place while Giselle is a bit better and and Chisa is above Juria
Giselle is so underrated 😢
Giselle ain’t better than Karina..
@@Faisa_123 she is
Yunjin 😂
yes ok, she isn't the best at live singing, but she's an opera singer, if u have ears, u would hear her in that clip and tell that she's actually professional like fr-
@user-ul7mm4ru8k that's most definitely just a trick that sounds good to a wide public. After hearing her singing this awful live, I can't believe that her opera-style was legit. She couldn't even sing her own solo songs standing perfectly still with guitar. That's a shame.
She's not an opera singer, she was just trained to be one at some point, but in no sense this education was finished.
What about kep1er?
Giselle is better than Karina in terms of vocals. It's just that she doesn't get vocal parts
Obessed with Karina's voice >.
Bruh placing Chisa and Juria below Kyujing, Sullyoon and Yujin was a crime
Kyujin do not put it with the top 20 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Monday? Chaehyun ? Sihyeon ?
goeun and swan from purplekiss left the chat
Monday, Minseo, Jungwoo, Yechan?
1 ParkRose❤
But, XG isn't even kpop...
it never said kpop, it just said top 10 vocalist
But he mentions that he is from the fourth generation. What would XG be like from the fourth generation without being K-pop? 🤔
Sullyoon kyujin above yunjin
Even chaewon
No way yunjin 5
I mean, if you put (G)I-DLE and IVE in the ranking, Miyeon and Liz should be in top 10 😭
Nope
Both are around high weak
@@lemon3391its not just about support range. Eminem has a wider range than Whitney Houston but does that make him a better singer💀 there's other criterias like Dynamics, Agility, Technique sm more to consider than just support ranges
The aduacity to put Chisa and Juria in low rank
this is a top 10 best vocalist not a top 10 4 t gen vocalist ever
3gen
5th tem pliss
Liz?
Also the 2nd last one was so good
My girl Monday should be there 😔
Xg - not kpop..
XG is highest vocalist!!
No way you've put Yunjin here... she can't sing live, all that opera thing was some bull apparently.
Xg isn’t a kpop group :) they’re a jpop group promoting in Korea
it never said kpop, it just said top 10 vocalist
@@mamamoofrvr they’re obviously talking abt K-pop or a lot of the idols on here wouldn’t be here. It also says 4th gen, a kpop term..
Kep1er
Belle?
Karina it's better than Yujin , liz from Ive . Better than Miyeon from Gidle ? Umm , no way .
I wonder why you don't have miyeon in
Sullyoon is D+ and kyujin is D+ or D and karina is better than her
I'm not sure about kyujin but sullyoon is a solid C-
@@rubyjaneluvbot no
WHERE THE FUCK IS ITZY
Nmixx>>>
Chisa is better than Juria
Purple kiss goeun is better than Karina
Xg kpop grubu değil kanka nasıl listeye ekliyorsun? Ayrıca ningning haewondan daha iyi
chisa is a better singer than juria, and as much as i love xg, their vocals aren’t that good😪
Giselle is better than Karina and Chisa is better than Juria
- Giselle better Karina
- Kyujin, Sullyoon, Bae, Jiwoo better Than Yunjin
Winter>ningning and haewon
Are you talking about technique or are u talking abt ur fav vocalist
vocal tone wise I would prefer winter but technique wise it's haewon > ningning > winter