When someone is well aware, kind and humble it is easier for him to make others fall in a trap with words. Then just like magicians they switch cards to establish religion order.
Dont know what to say but enjoyed this conversation a lot . Btw I m neither a Muslim or atheist but I loved the way Hamza present his thoughts. Well I I neither believe or disbelieve in God coz i dont know if he is there or not.
میرا عقیدہ ہے کہ اگر اللہ نہیں ہے تو پہر میں بھی نہیں ہوں اور کچھ بھی نہیں ہے لیکن اللہ ہے تب ہی تو میں ہوں اور سارا جہاں ہے ۔۔۔ الحمد للہ علی نعمة الاسلام
Tumhai Hamza abbasi jese log hi lajawab ker saktey well done Hamza abbasi ic mulhid ko jawab deny k liye Jo apni her video Mai bra scholar bna phirta Hy 👍👍👍👍👍
Hamza Ali abbasi Dharma k ishwar k taraf isahara kar raha hai. Na ki islami allah Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai. Abhi murti pooja par aao. Muhammad ka gaand suar bhagwan maare ya suar ka gaand muhammad. Mera point ye hai ki kon murti idol symbol ko zayada manta hai. Dekho tumhe kitni mirchi lagi muhammad k naam par. Asli murti puja ye hai. Hindu to apni murti apne hathon fek aata hai. Kyuki usko pata asli ishwar ka. Wo murti ko ishwar nhi samjh raha balki uski Bhawana murti k jariye se ishwar se jud raha hai. Chahe to wo apni bhawna ko bina murti k bhi ishwar se jod sakta hai. Islamic fake allah bina muhammad k kisi kaam ka nahi. Mai murti par thook kar ishwar aradhna kar sakta hoon. Tu muhammad par thook kar allah ko yaad nahi kar sakta. Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye. Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma 1400 se zayada granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai. Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se. Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.
To be honest if islam was just believing in one God and his prophet ( although not fpllowing 7th century customes) along with praying no one would have any problem it is only when certain things become dogma then there is a problem
***شکریہ اسلام*** اسلام نے عورت کو حد سے زیادہ قیمتی چیز بناکر جنس کے طور پر پیش کرکے مرد سے بہت دور کیا اسی لیے سب سے زیادہ ٹھرکی مرد بھی آپ کو اسلامی ممالک میں ملیں گے عورت اتنی بھی قیمتی نہیں کے پردے میں چھپائیں عورت بھی مرد کی طرح ہی ہے عورت بھی وہی بدبودار پاخانہ میں اور پیشاب کرتی ہے جو مرد کرتا ہے کوئی ہیرے موتی نہیں نکلتے عورت کے پیٹ سے۔ یورپی ممالک میں عورت کو ایسے مرد سے چھپایا نہیں جاتا اور اسی لیے وہاں کامرد پاکستانی مسلمانوں کی طرح ٹھرکی نہیں پے۔ جب کی یہاں پاگل کتے کہ طرح زبان نکال کے عورت کے پیچھے بھاگتے ہیں لیکن جوتے پڑتے ہیں بلاک کیے جاتے ہیں کیونکہ عورت کو حد سے زیادہ قیمتی جو بنا دیا ہے اسلام نے۔ مرد کی ایک کتے جتنی قیمت نہیں ہے پاکستان میں۔۔۔شکریہ اسلام ۔۔۔شکر ہے میں پاکستان سے باہر ہوں۔۔۔۔۔
جو آخرت کے مقابلے میں دنیوی زندگی کو پسند رکھتے ہیں اور اللہ کی راہ سے روکتے ہیں، اور اس میں ٹیڑھ پن پیدا کرنا چاہتے ہیں۔یہی لوگ پرلے درجے کی گمراہی میں ہیں۔ سورۃ ابراہیم، آیت 3
Han bhaio yeah Haris bara fitna hy or ise Hindu Raw wale chala rahy hy Islam k against me..... Dekhte nahe ho videos me last me bheek mangta hy k mujhy support Karo or pesy lagao mujh pe me tmhara kaam kr rha ho..... Haram zada 👍
The more i watch your videos the more i am motivated to get to know Islam and look for answers to the questions you ask and i am finding God more and more i hope one day i gather enough proofs and develop a debate against you.
@@sajiddawar000 Consider a person who marries a woman and has children. Then consider another man who didn't marry his woman but had children with her. According to science (logic), there in no difference between the two but according to religion (Islam) one is living a halal life and the other one is living a Haram life. If religion and science can't agree on this simple point then how can you say that "Religion without science is blind. Science without faith is lame."
@@ahmadtariq3927 People like cliches. People who try not to think in terms of cliches can see the stupidity of this nonsense. Even if a famous scientist is supposed to have said this. One can spend one whole life time just parroting what others said. So for such people this will make sense, but not to those who would like to go into details.
Very good Hamza Ali , you have almost reached God by application of your scientific temper , now you can know God fully only provided God also moves one step towards you , hold on .
Hamza Ali abasi thanks for this argument. You nailed it. You made him speechless. Allah jab chahy imaan ata kare ya dil par mohr laga de. I really hope for haris not to go too far from where there is no coming back. May Allah guide him to the right path.
@@zanubfuckermohamed6186 did not get you, and if Allah has the power then it should already be rectified by him, right, but not as there is no God called Allah exist.. It was made by a man called Mohammed who just wanted to get famous and get the power. Then why Allah did not save Mohammed and his whole family, think about it..
Mujhe is conversation se ek baat Samajh me agaya ki kaise 2 civilized log discuss karte hai , dikkat tab shuru hoti hai jab personal faith hum dusron pe thopne lagte hai, Bhai conversation discussion karne aap me ek dusron ke liye respect badhti hai jisse aap convinced na ho to bhi koi dikkat nahi.
i REALLY APPRECIATE MR HAMZA ALI ABBASI.... GREAT ANSWERS...... GREAT JUST GREAT..... I LIKED VIDEO JUST BECAUSE OF HAMZA ALI ABBASI.... NOW YOU BECOME IN MY GENIUS PERSONS LIST..... GOD BLESS YOU......
Great conversation, the people who are carious about the matters n striving to decode the natural laws instead of spirituality , such a people are God on n in the world I mean the scientists, science bless you guys,
after listening to him, i completely understood y his fellow actors don't like him because he seems more interested in speaking sense then doing gossips.
@AIZHDAN House UN to indian atrocities ko b accept ni karta jo tm log pichly 30 saloon se kashmir mein kr rhe ho, jo tmri army ne 10k se zyada aurtoon ka rape kia hy, america jisne iraq mein carpet bombing kr k millions ko qatal kia hy, terrorist to usko b koi nahi kehta, ye chooran kaheen aur ja k becho
@AIZHDAN House tum indians har jaha ghusa karo, na tmre mtlb ka topic hy na tmri koi opinion hy us k barey mein tm hafiz saeed ko har jagah rotey raha karo, dunia kis sbse bari army se kuch log control nahi hotey, apni army ko galian do ja k
“There is only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle and other is that every thing is a miracle”. -I choose to believe life’s every aspect is a miracle, I don’t need more proof than what I witness around us. Khalil Gibran wrote that even our creator envy’s us looking at the beauty of his creations just for just us; I don’t want to waste my time and energy trying to prove what will be never ever be proven.
@@angeldarshana4573 nhi Universe God ki hai,,,Jahan ka wo akaila wahid Malik hai,noted agr khuda ziada hotay to unka apna jhagra hi khtm na hota,,,ab insano k pas Jo k fana hony walay Hain kch taqat agyi hai to wo kasay dunya Mai apni man maani Kar rahay Hain,,,to Allah ek hi hai,sab kch continuesly ek hi circle Mai chal raha hai,,, Allah be humko banaya sab kch ata Kia,socho agr yeh zindgi hi na hoti to why kch soch nhi,,,jasi bi zindgi hai naimat hai mere Allah Pak ki,,,Mano Jo haqq hai pehchano Jo haqq Sach hai,,, please wrong sides ko choro,, Allah k banday ho usi ko mano
@@ANILVERMA-pu6xw Bhai wo Gadhi pe baith k ud jayega, jaise inka mohammad sapne me gadhi pe baith kar uda tha or ye fuddu log uske sapne hi sunte sunte mar jayenge. Muhammad ne kabhi koi chamtakar ni kiya kisi 1 bande k samne. Wo Sare chamtkar sapne me karta tha.
Salute to Hamza Ali Abassi to delivered such a great “phakki” to this desi atheist. The universe is not an accident, the more you try to dip in it the more complex it will be and there is no end of such findings.
Hamza Ali abbasi Dharma k ishwar k taraf isahara kar raha hai. Na ki islami allah Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai. Abhi murti pooja par aao. Muhammad ka gaand suar bhagwan maare ya suar ka gaand muhammad. Mera point ye hai ki kon murti idol symbol ko zayada manta hai. Dekho tumhe kitni mirchi lagi muhammad k naam par. Asli murti puja ye hai. Hindu to apni murti apne hathon fek aata hai. Kyuki usko pata asli ishwar ka. Wo murti ko ishwar nhi samjh raha balki uski Bhawana murti k jariye se ishwar se jud raha hai. Chahe to wo apni bhawna ko bina murti k bhi ishwar se jod sakta hai. Islamic fake allah bina muhammad k kisi kaam ka nahi. Mai murti par thook kar ishwar aradhna kar sakta hoon. Tu muhammad par thook kar allah ko yaad nahi kar sakta. Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye. Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma 1400 se zayada granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai. Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se. Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.
Our understanding is limited by space time Any thing we try to fit into that framework, where as the reality is too complex for the human brain to understand Imagination beyond our limitations is simply precluded.
Basic source is simple but manifestation is complex. Basic being is simple but knowledge is complex. Consciousness is simple but mind is complex. Nothing is simple but something is complex. Experience is simple but explaining is complex.Silence is simple but talking is complex.Logic is complex but paradox is simple. Belief or disbelie is complex but trust is simple.
پڑھے لکھے سمجھدار ملحدوں سے عاجزانہ سوال: بالفرض خدا نہیں ہے تو مسلمان (یعنی خدا کے اگے اپنا سر تسلیم خم کرنے والے) کو بھی کوئی نقصان نہیں ہو سکتا اور نہ ملحد کو۔ اور اگر اس کائنات کا خالق موجود ہے تو مسلمان تو بچ جائے گا۔مگر ملحد ؟؟؟ یعنی خدا کی زات پر ایمان رکھنے والے کو کسی بھی صورت نقصان نہیں۔مگرملحد کی پروبیبلٹی تھیوری (probability theory) کے مطابق 50/50 چانسز ہوئے۔ ۔ لہذا سمجھدار کون ہوا ؟؟ سائنس کا ادھورا علم ملحد بناتا ہے۔ مگر مکمل علم خدا کی زات پر ایمان پختہ ترین کر دیتا ہے۔
واہ یار بڑے پتے کی بات کی آپ نے مگر کوئی نئی بات نہیں کی. یہ کئی صدیوں پہلے پاسکل نامی آدمی نے کی تھی. اس کا جواب ہے کہ چار ہزار سے زیادہ خداؤں میں سے کسی ایک کے ہونے کی probability کیا ہے. اوپر جا کر اگر بھگوان یا اپولو مل گیا تو کیا جواب دیں گے ؟
@@healthyonline1785 Everyone is free to think whatever they want. Nobody have any right to impose their thoughts, believes to others... Your thoughts, beliefs are " there is NO GOD"... You should keep it with yourself... Not to force others to think like you, believe like you... Itne khoobsorat design ki gai ye life be-maqsad nahi ho sakti..Never.. Ek glass water ka rakh do, billions year baad bhi wo water he rahy ga automatic wo PEPSI nahi bane ga....jab ke itni bari multiuniverse automatic he create hogai apke khyal mein... 🤔
@@arhamleo1 no disrespect but the counter argument is what about young children born with life threatening diseases such as cancer, barbarity in animal world, storm , fire, supernove, destruction ,floods, earthquakes, abnormalities in human bodies, a hungry child right now dying somehwer in the world, an innocent child being physically abused, a worm eating away a child eye in Africa These are all aspects of nature as well
scientist ek point k baad details directly nahi dekh sakte isiliye chije tough ho jati hai samajhane me jitna andar ghusoge utna aur is bat ka advantage religious log lete hai science ko nicha dikhane ke liye ... lekin hume samajhna chahiye ki its like limit concept of maths. x=0 aur limit of x approaching to zero dono bilkul alag chije hai. scientist are digging deeper and deeper every decade but we dont review and understand their improvements honestly. Have patience, we are reaching close to answers to all questions. Arriving finally at them will take lot of time. Maths me Fermats little theorem prove karne me 350 sal lag gaye, Riemann hypothesis , Goldback conjecture abhi tak prove nahi sekado sakon se ho paya iska matlab nahi ki kabhi nahi prove ho payega. We actually never live forever to see the answers of all the questions. One day, every question meets its proof.... patience does that for sure
اس ویڈیو میں بہت بار اس چیز کو نوٹ کیا شرمندہ ہونے کے باوجود شرمندہ نہیں ہو رہا بے چارہ جہاں چلا گیا ہے یہ کسی کے ساتھ ہونا نوے فیصد ممکن ہے وہ تو بناتے ہی ملحد ہیں
@@UsmanSadiq303 Hamza Ali abbasi Dharma k ishwar k taraf isahara kar raha hai. Na ki islami allah Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai. Abhi murti pooja par aao. Muhammad ka gaand suar bhagwan maare ya suar ka gaand muhammad. Mera point ye hai ki kon murti idol symbol ko zayada manta hai. Dekho tumhe kitni mirchi lagi muhammad k naam par. Asli murti puja ye hai. Hindu to apni murti apne hathon fek aata hai. Kyuki usko pata asli ishwar ka. Wo murti ko ishwar nhi samjh raha balki uski Bhawana murti k jariye se ishwar se jud raha hai. Chahe to wo apni bhawna ko bina murti k bhi ishwar se jod sakta hai. Islamic fake allah bina muhammad k kisi kaam ka nahi. Mai murti par thook kar ishwar aradhna kar sakta hoon. Tu muhammad par thook kar allah ko yaad nahi kar sakta. Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye. Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma 1400 se zayada granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai. Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se. Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.
i am an indian ,i am proud to be an Hindu and i believe in it totally . i dnt like islam nor do i take it as an Religion ... but i found Hamza Ali as good Intellectual in terms of Scientific Knowledge, his whole arguments is a reflection of Vedas, he shud learn more about vedas. nice conversation and haariz i support u as atheist for exposing the Islam and as a true Liberal.
Hahaha,,I m Muslim and proud to be a Muslim,,, and fallowing the true religion of God, that is Islam,, you want to off this light by your desire that will never happen except you feel bad,it will reach each and every corner of the universe,,lol
Haaris and Abbasi, listening to you brief talk, what you are essentially pondering is that .. 1) did energy exist before matter or 2) it was matter first that produced energy or 3) some one controlled what came first and then the other followed and the vivcious process of big bang, contraction and black holes now exist for ever? Essentially the argument of Abbasi is that someone set the process for creation of universe and its now understood events. Hence Abbaasi believes that manipulator can be called God. Haaris, argues that there is nothing to proove what came first and who manifested the process? Hence the process is organic and incidental and no god exist. Beyond a point it is difficuilt to draw the arguments for both sides to a pointing conclusion because : a) much of our understang of galactical events are based on several theories floated by different scientists to support their understanding of big bang or black holes, expansion or contraction etc Much of predictions or predicted history of universe is based on interpolation or extra polation of limited observation of data, which is absolutely nothing in terms of timeline of our universe. b) beyond a point no body in the past or present could explain, atleast in logic, who and how every thing was put in motion? And it is possible that this fact led to the formulation of the concept of God so that the discussion can be put to a close atleast till more investigation or information is available to prolong the debate further. Essentially our ignorance is what is termed as God ....and may be the day we come to know the facts (?) We will be God ourselves. Therefore instead of thinking of aakhrat or trying to proove existance or no existance of God, life would be simple to live organically and not be led or manipulated by some goofy stories of the past. When I say past, the time line of existance of life on earth several million of years. So the stories of last 1400 yrs or 2000 yrs or 10000 yrs do not matter at all ......Civilsations existed for million of years not only on earth but in other planets and we should focuss on the way to a more liveable world now and co habitaion in future
بسم اللہ الرحمن الرحیم انرجی کی اِس طرف مادہ ہے سائنسدان انرجی کی صرف مادی جانب تک جا سکتے تھے انرجی کی دوسری جانب نور ہے اور نور مادی شے نہیں ہے اس کو چھوا نہیں جا سکتا ۔ جہاں سائنسدان کا سفر ختم ہوتا ہے وہاں سے سالک کا سفر شروع ہوتا ہے۔
The point here is if there is a creator, then he didn't create well. For example, somewhere it rains a lot and some areas no rain of significantly less rain etc.
Hamza knows just enough science to confuse himself,,, as its rightly said little knowledge is dangerous. Most of his scientific facts were his own assumptions which had nothing to do with actual scientific phenomenas.Looks like he wants to believe in creationism and he uses everything in his access to try to be relevant but fails miserably as he clearly is biased towards Creationalism.
This debate is like what comes first egg or hen. In Hinduism time is cyclical not linear. Science also talks about big bang and big crunch. things happens and get vanished and again happen eternal.
اللہ ایک ہے اس کا کوئی شریک نہیں۔ اس کے علاوہ کوئی عبادت کے لائق نہیں۔ وہی تمام جہانوں کا خالق و مالک ہے۔ اس کے تمام رسول برحق ہیں۔ محمد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم اس کے آخری نبی ہیں۔
YOU ARE NO KNOWLEDGE OF QURAN...... YOU HAVE NOT EVEN FULL KNOWLEDGE OF SCIENCE.... TUM WO KABOOTER HO JIS NE BILI KO DEKH KER ANKHEIN BAND KER LI HEIN.
So basically what Hamza is telling us to stop questioning and stop enquiring. He is basically making a case for Pascal's wager. Even if we accept his explanation,why İslam?
@@exhindu4340 accha point h apka. . Aur courage b h apme. . Warna is waqt to dusre logo ka Hindu banne la time h. Jo ban nahi rhe to Kam se Kam dikha to rhe hn unke jaisa banke.
@@BabarUhsmani nonhindu bina Dre apni jgh kayam rhe unhe Hindu jsa bnne k zrurt nhi he usul k lie hlak b hona PDE to ho jao pr apne usul Mt choro. Ex Hindu bnne k vjhse meri Hindu log mazmmt krte he but me apni jgh kayam hu.i don't care wht Hindus think of me. Muj mallum he me sahi hu.
Allah Most High is al-Khaliq from all eternity, independently of creation being or not being in existence. “He was All-Knowing when there was nothing to be known; All-Powerful when there was no object of power; All-Seeing when there was nothing to be seen; All-Sustaining when there was nothing to be sustained; Creator when there was nothing created” (Ibn Khafif)
Mr. Abbasi's example of Coca-Cola is totally a fallacy. He thinks that if a water kept for longer time could not make it into Coca-Cola. But why would simply a water get transformed into Coca-Cola, it may get transformed into some other thing which we can't assume. It is Abbasi's pre-assumption if Coca-Cola then God. He is already with a state of thought of Coca-Cola then God only. But it can be something else and it does not need any act of God.
The beauti of sceintist is that he or she is flexible to accept at certain point he or she does not know about existent, but a religious person thinks his book knows all the answers without making any logical sense and takes it as threat to his own existence if somebody puts his books claims to test , because he identifies himself with that religion, thats y his ego doesnot accept logical reasonings of sceince
Aisa nahi h. . Pr chakkar ye h ki jab athiest bole we don't know to to believer accept krte hn. Jab believe bole we don't know to atheist kahte hn kyun nahi pata pata hona chahiye the.
The best argument for gods is the argument from design which has been debunked by Charles Darwin's evolution by natural selection hypothesis (now theory)
Favourite line of Darwin and darwinists is : . Million and billion of years. . Ab krlo pata Kya hua tha keese hua tha kyyun hua tha. TumhAri kkhud ki zindggi jayadda se jayada 70-80 saal ki h.
Hamza Ali Abbasi :-
gave all answers
Harris Sultan :-
MAY BE , MIGHT BE , THATS OK , OK OK THATS FINE , I ALREADY TOLD!!!!!!!
Hamja ali bahut badhiya baat kah raha hai par vah jo kah raha hai vah islam kuran mohammad aur alla ki bat nhi hai usne to vedo ki baat ki hai
@A Wanderer we know nothing about it 😂😂😂😂
A Healthy Debate.. Hamza Abbasi clarifying So Beautifuly..
ALLAH is One.. 👍
Proud To be Muslim
What one? 🤫😂
Allah,khuda,muhmad,==muhmad,(muhmad,hee,allah,muhmad,hee,khuda)
Allah,khuda,muhmad,==muhmad,(muhmad,hee,allah,muhmad,hee,khuda)
The arguments given by Hamza leads me to Islam. Wow great sense of science.
Mai Muslim hun.. Aur mujhe 101% yaqeen haike Allah hai... Mere ankh se maine badha mircale dekha hai
I am an Atheist but I enjoyed the conversation and one more thing Hamza is very well informed. I think he should debate more.
When someone is well aware, kind and humble it is easier for him to make others fall in a trap with words. Then just like magicians they switch cards to establish religion order.
Dont know what to say but enjoyed this conversation a lot . Btw I m neither a Muslim or atheist but I loved the way Hamza present his thoughts. Well I I neither believe or disbelieve in God coz i dont know if he is there or not.
So you are an agnostic
The Respect Of Hamza Abbasi has much increases after this video.
Hatts Off 👍😙
میرا عقیدہ ہے کہ اگر اللہ نہیں ہے تو پہر میں بھی نہیں ہوں اور کچھ بھی نہیں ہے
لیکن اللہ ہے تب ہی تو میں ہوں اور سارا جہاں ہے ۔۔۔
الحمد للہ علی نعمة الاسلام
Yaay app ka aqeeda hay to hum sab ko is pay koi itraz nsheen par jab doosray apnay aqeeday ka batatay hain to tab ap kion aitraz karatay ho
Apka kya aqeeda hai ?
@@umaralikhan7012 it is a personal question as i believe religion is personal matter
Ok sir
@@eyewitness3010
کونسا علی بھائ ؟؟
great hamza i am enough convinced with your argues to return to believer
, thank you so much
دوست اگر آپ مزید جاننا چاہتے ہیں تو میرا مشورہ ہے کہ آپ جاوید احمد غامدی کے چار لیکچر ہیں وہ سن لیں۔ existence of GOD
اللہ تعالیٰ ہمیشہ آپ کو ایمان و سلامتی عطا فرمائے۔ (آمین)
welcome back home bro.
# Abdul ahad
.
To discuss more you can discuss with me.
Hamza bhi nay bhut acha mu tora kon kon agree kRta hy
Hahah.. Hamja jo bol raha he wo use rataya gya he aur kuch nhi...
Hamza Bhai you are too good I will find a new way of life God is the science of univers.
Tumhai Hamza abbasi jese log hi lajawab ker saktey well done Hamza abbasi ic mulhid ko jawab deny k liye Jo apni her video Mai bra scholar bna phirta Hy 👍👍👍👍👍
Aby chutye tery Muhammad ka sooraj to pani k chashmy me ghorob hota he doob mar maa baap k deen k pujari.
Hamza Ali abbasi Dharma k ishwar k taraf isahara kar raha hai. Na ki islami allah
Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai.
Abhi murti pooja par aao. Muhammad ka gaand suar bhagwan maare ya suar ka gaand muhammad. Mera point ye hai ki kon murti idol symbol ko zayada manta hai. Dekho tumhe kitni mirchi lagi muhammad k naam par. Asli murti puja ye hai. Hindu to apni murti apne hathon fek aata hai. Kyuki usko pata asli ishwar ka. Wo murti ko ishwar nhi samjh raha balki uski Bhawana murti k jariye se ishwar se jud raha hai. Chahe to wo apni bhawna ko bina murti k bhi ishwar se jod sakta hai. Islamic fake allah bina muhammad k kisi kaam ka nahi. Mai murti par thook kar ishwar aradhna kar sakta hoon. Tu muhammad par thook kar allah ko yaad nahi kar sakta.
Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye.
Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma 1400 se zayada granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai.
Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se.
Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.
To be honest if islam was just believing in one God and his prophet ( although not fpllowing 7th century customes) along with praying no one would have any problem it is only when certain things become dogma then there is a problem
***شکریہ اسلام***
اسلام نے عورت کو حد سے زیادہ قیمتی چیز بناکر جنس کے طور پر پیش کرکے مرد سے بہت دور کیا اسی لیے سب سے زیادہ ٹھرکی مرد بھی آپ کو اسلامی ممالک میں ملیں گے
عورت اتنی بھی قیمتی نہیں کے پردے میں چھپائیں عورت بھی مرد کی طرح ہی ہے عورت بھی وہی بدبودار پاخانہ میں اور پیشاب کرتی ہے جو مرد کرتا ہے کوئی ہیرے موتی نہیں نکلتے عورت کے پیٹ سے۔
یورپی ممالک میں عورت کو ایسے مرد سے چھپایا نہیں جاتا اور اسی لیے وہاں کامرد پاکستانی مسلمانوں کی طرح ٹھرکی نہیں پے۔
جب کی یہاں پاگل کتے کہ طرح زبان نکال کے عورت کے پیچھے بھاگتے ہیں لیکن جوتے پڑتے ہیں بلاک کیے جاتے ہیں کیونکہ عورت کو حد سے زیادہ قیمتی جو بنا دیا ہے اسلام نے۔
مرد کی ایک کتے جتنی قیمت نہیں ہے پاکستان میں۔۔۔شکریہ اسلام ۔۔۔شکر ہے میں پاکستان سے باہر ہوں۔۔۔۔۔
@@Smart665 lol love the anger
جو آخرت کے مقابلے میں دنیوی زندگی کو پسند رکھتے ہیں اور اللہ کی راہ سے روکتے ہیں، اور اس میں ٹیڑھ پن پیدا کرنا چاہتے ہیں۔یہی لوگ پرلے درجے کی گمراہی میں ہیں۔
سورۃ ابراہیم، آیت 3
Hamza is brilliant. He make haris speechless. Wo alag bat he k haris smjh k smjhna ni chah rha tha
Such jan kar bhi khud ko dusry sy bather sabit karna ye hota hi asla extersim. Jo y hariss kar raha hy
Bilkul.. ye bht bara fitna he or propaganda krke innocent logon ka iman khrab kr rha he
Han bhaio yeah Haris bara fitna hy or ise Hindu Raw wale chala rahy hy Islam k against me..... Dekhte nahe ho videos me last me bheek mangta hy k mujhy support Karo or pesy lagao mujh pe me tmhara kaam kr rha ho..... Haram zada 👍
Hamza Ali Abbasi's argument seems to me more in line with Agnosticism.
I think you should read HAZRAT ALI RADIALLAHO TALLAANHO QOUTES ON THIS TOPICS... ALLAH O AKBAR
ISLAM ZINDABAAD
Maa chudaaye Islam - other than virgin pussy promise - that shit is crazy bruh....if real.
The more i watch your videos the more i am motivated to get to know Islam
and look for answers to the questions you ask and i am finding God more and more i hope one day i gather enough proofs and develop a debate against you.
+923039130359 WhatsApp
Let's have discussion about God
We are on same page captain
Or may be u reached to god also
@@syedmuhammadsibtain tu atheist hai ya christian
Science need proof.
Religion need believe.
Religion without science is blind and science without religion is lame.
@@sajiddawar000
Consider a person who marries a woman and has children. Then consider another man who didn't marry his woman but had children with her. According to science (logic), there in no difference between the two but according to religion (Islam) one is living a halal life and the other one is living a Haram life. If religion and science can't agree on this simple point then how can you say that
"Religion without science is blind.
Science without faith is lame."
@@ahmadtariq3927 People like cliches. People who try not to think in terms of cliches can see the stupidity of this nonsense. Even if a famous scientist is supposed to have said this. One can spend one whole life time just parroting what others said. So for such people this will make sense, but not to those who would like to go into details.
My believe is in proof.
I think more or less every enlightened mind want the same.
science needs proof? but it doesn't has a proof, they want us to believe on an unproved theory
Very good Hamza Ali , you have almost reached God by application of your scientific temper , now you can know God fully only provided God also moves one step towards you , hold on .
This is best compliment.nothing is creat without created.
Hamza Ali abasi thanks for this argument. You nailed it. You made him speechless. Allah jab chahy imaan ata kare ya dil par mohr laga de. I really hope for haris not to go too far from where there is no coming back. May Allah guide him to the right path.
72 randi in brothal of allah?? Broker of prostitute is mohamed??
Hehe then y Allah did not make humans as Muslims by birth. Please answer
@@sadhanachoudhary1585 muslim becomes by circumcision of their private parts.not by birth.
@@zanubfuckermohamed6186 did not get you, and if Allah has the power then it should already be rectified by him, right, but not as there is no God called Allah exist.. It was made by a man called Mohammed who just wanted to get famous and get the power. Then why Allah did not save Mohammed and his whole family, think about it..
Stupid. You are biased enough to believe that Hamza defeated Harris. Both have some beliefs which can't be proved.
Great Argument Mr. Abbasi!👍
Stupid 6 sal ki bachi, 72 hoore , flat earth 🌎 stupid
You both guys are good and just another step towards truth keep it up more brain storming needed
Mujhe is conversation se ek baat Samajh me agaya ki kaise 2 civilized log discuss karte hai , dikkat tab shuru hoti hai jab personal faith hum dusron pe thopne lagte hai, Bhai conversation discussion karne aap me ek dusron ke liye respect badhti hai jisse aap convinced na ho to bhi koi dikkat nahi.
Hamza Ali abbasi ko tedX mein dekho ye hi baat badi khoobsoorati se boli hai.
ALHUMDULILLAH Muslim ❤
LA ILAHA IL ALLAH MUHAMMAD UR RASUL ALLAH ☝
i REALLY APPRECIATE MR HAMZA ALI ABBASI.... GREAT ANSWERS...... GREAT JUST GREAT..... I LIKED VIDEO JUST BECAUSE OF HAMZA ALI ABBASI.... NOW YOU BECOME IN MY GENIUS PERSONS LIST..... GOD BLESS YOU......
Well done Hamza Ali Abbasi.👍👏😆
Masha Allah,Jazakallah.
May allah guide us all
Hamza Ali Abbasi ! Very Strong Argument.
Great conversation, the people who are carious about the matters n striving to decode the natural laws instead of spirituality , such a people are God on n in the world I mean the scientists, science bless you guys,
This is what I call a healthy debate....
Hamza Ali abbasi very humble person...
One of your best debate 👍
Be a seekers not a believer
Be a Believer who Seeks the truth.
Hearing Mr Abbasi I am reminded of a great writer who said - much reading makes a wise man wiser, and a fool more foolish.
Glad to know that there are some intelligent youthias too, like Harris Sultan & Hamza Ali.
Hamza... Yrr..Literally Intellectual more than i thought....
@AIZHDAN House a gya yahan b indian apni bhraas nikalney
after listening to him, i completely understood y his fellow actors don't like him because he seems more interested in speaking sense then doing gossips.
@AIZHDAN House UN to indian atrocities ko b accept ni karta jo tm log pichly 30 saloon se kashmir mein kr rhe ho, jo tmri army ne 10k se zyada aurtoon ka rape kia hy, america jisne iraq mein carpet bombing kr k millions ko qatal kia hy, terrorist to usko b koi nahi kehta, ye chooran kaheen aur ja k becho
@AIZHDAN House tum indians har jaha ghusa karo, na tmre mtlb ka topic hy na tmri koi opinion hy us k barey mein tm hafiz saeed ko har jagah rotey raha karo, dunia kis sbse bari army se kuch log control nahi hotey, apni army ko galian do ja k
@AIZHDAN House bas kar bongian marna, na kisi bat ka sar na pair
kash es mulhid Haras shitan ko Humza ali abbasi ki bat samgh a jati.well done humza Ali abbasi Allah tala ap ko salamat rakhy.
Allah khud bhosdika kuch kar nahi sakta ... Jiske nam me hi talla laga hua ho wo kya krega?
Agar kursi hai tu koi banane wala hai to uske hath bhi hai tu uska sharir bhi hai Harish Sultan you are a genius 👍
Uski height Kya thi?
.
Uska colour kesa tha?
.
Wo naram Dil tha ya sakht Dil tha ?
.
So on....
لفظ: ملحد
معنی: منفرد نظر آنے کی اک ناکام کوشش، جس میں خودبخود ہر شئہ کے ہونے کا یقین خود کو بھی نہیں ہوتا
Great comment.
Wonderful debate 😎 love you both,
“There is only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle and other is that every thing is a miracle”. -I choose to believe life’s every aspect is a miracle, I don’t need more proof than what I witness around us. Khalil Gibran wrote that even our creator envy’s us looking at the beauty of his creations just for just us; I don’t want to waste my time and energy trying to prove what will be never ever be proven.
In small words,,jab khud ko samjho gy to God ko pa lo gy,,, seriously
God is energy jo hamare andar hi h kan kan m h universe hi god h☁😊
@@angeldarshana4573 nhi Universe God ki hai,,,Jahan ka wo akaila wahid Malik hai,noted agr khuda ziada hotay to unka apna jhagra hi khtm na hota,,,ab insano k pas Jo k fana hony walay Hain kch taqat agyi hai to wo kasay dunya Mai apni man maani Kar rahay Hain,,,to Allah ek hi hai,sab kch continuesly ek hi circle Mai chal raha hai,,, Allah be humko banaya sab kch ata Kia,socho agr yeh zindgi hi na hoti to why kch soch nhi,,,jasi bi zindgi hai naimat hai mere Allah Pak ki,,,Mano Jo haqq hai pehchano Jo haqq Sach hai,,, please wrong sides ko choro,, Allah k banday ho usi ko mano
Mera Lowda pe hai God , dekhega!? Too aja dikhata terko...🤣🤣
@@angeldarshana4573 👍👍👍
Don't let fanatics talk too much otherwise you'll always lose
exactly .
True he is clearly loosing.
Hamza ali abbasi you r rocking
Chutiya ha too kyunki too is video ko mulla banke hi dekh rha ha n ki beech ka aadmi
Bhai beech ka nahi banna Tu hi ban beech ka
@@AamirKhan-rj8ps Han to gadhi🐐 par beth ke ud 😜😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@ANILVERMA-pu6xw Bhai wo Gadhi pe baith k ud jayega, jaise inka mohammad sapne me gadhi pe baith kar uda tha or ye fuddu log uske sapne hi sunte sunte mar jayenge. Muhammad ne kabhi koi chamtakar ni kiya kisi 1 bande k samne. Wo Sare chamtkar sapne me karta tha.
Hamza Ali Abbasi Great Job...
Salute to Hamza Ali Abassi to delivered such a great “phakki” to this desi atheist.
The universe is not an accident, the more you try to dip in it the more complex it will be and there is no end of such findings.
Hamza Ali abbasi Dharma k ishwar k taraf isahara kar raha hai. Na ki islami allah
Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai.
Abhi murti pooja par aao. Muhammad ka gaand suar bhagwan maare ya suar ka gaand muhammad. Mera point ye hai ki kon murti idol symbol ko zayada manta hai. Dekho tumhe kitni mirchi lagi muhammad k naam par. Asli murti puja ye hai. Hindu to apni murti apne hathon fek aata hai. Kyuki usko pata asli ishwar ka. Wo murti ko ishwar nhi samjh raha balki uski Bhawana murti k jariye se ishwar se jud raha hai. Chahe to wo apni bhawna ko bina murti k bhi ishwar se jod sakta hai. Islamic fake allah bina muhammad k kisi kaam ka nahi. Mai murti par thook kar ishwar aradhna kar sakta hoon. Tu muhammad par thook kar allah ko yaad nahi kar sakta.
Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye.
Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma 1400 se zayada granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai.
Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se.
Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.
Beliver are more ignorant
---Hamza ali
Allah SWT has chosen Humza for a bigger purpose.
Hamza Ali Abbasi is quite right. Haris and Abdullaj observe everything wrong and bad designed in the universe.
From this whole argument I can come to the conclusion that, origin given by the sanatan dharma is great, so I can proudly say I am a sanatani (Hindu)
Lol your snatan dharam is way more worse than jihadi Islam it teach discrimination zaat paat
@@sk....3049 aap atheist ho Kya ?
Aakhir h Kya sanatan dharam ?
Are you a believer in Advaita?
Our understanding is limited by space time
Any thing we try to fit into that framework, where as the reality is too complex for the human brain to understand
Imagination beyond our limitations is simply precluded.
Basic source is simple but manifestation is complex. Basic being is simple but knowledge is complex. Consciousness is simple but mind is complex. Nothing is simple but something is complex. Experience is simple but explaining is complex.Silence is simple but talking is complex.Logic is complex but paradox is simple. Belief or disbelie is complex but trust is simple.
Great work Sir Hamza
Nice Hamza Ali abbasi
Thank you
Hamza did it!
Hamza Ali Abbasi
Very strong arguments ...
Belief is not truth.
Nothing more to say or argue!
Good.
Love you hamza ali abbassi
پڑھے لکھے سمجھدار ملحدوں سے عاجزانہ سوال:
بالفرض خدا نہیں ہے تو مسلمان (یعنی خدا کے اگے اپنا سر تسلیم خم کرنے والے) کو بھی کوئی نقصان نہیں ہو سکتا اور نہ ملحد کو۔
اور اگر اس کائنات کا خالق موجود ہے تو مسلمان تو بچ جائے گا۔مگر ملحد ؟؟؟
یعنی خدا کی زات پر ایمان رکھنے والے کو کسی بھی صورت نقصان نہیں۔مگرملحد کی پروبیبلٹی تھیوری (probability theory) کے مطابق 50/50 چانسز ہوئے۔ ۔
لہذا سمجھدار کون ہوا ؟؟
سائنس کا ادھورا علم ملحد بناتا ہے۔ مگر مکمل علم خدا کی زات پر ایمان پختہ ترین کر دیتا ہے۔
واہ یار بڑے پتے کی بات کی آپ نے مگر کوئی نئی بات نہیں کی. یہ کئی صدیوں پہلے پاسکل نامی آدمی نے کی تھی. اس کا جواب ہے کہ چار ہزار سے زیادہ خداؤں میں سے کسی ایک کے ہونے کی probability کیا ہے. اوپر جا کر اگر بھگوان یا اپولو مل گیا تو کیا جواب دیں گے ؟
@@healthyonline1785 Everyone is free to think whatever they want. Nobody have any right to impose their thoughts, believes to others...
Your thoughts, beliefs are " there is NO GOD"... You should keep it with yourself... Not to force others to think like you, believe like you...
Itne khoobsorat design ki gai ye life be-maqsad nahi ho sakti..Never..
Ek glass water ka rakh do, billions year baad bhi wo water he rahy ga automatic wo PEPSI nahi bane ga....jab ke itni bari multiuniverse automatic he create hogai apke khyal mein... 🤔
@@arhamleo1 no disrespect but the counter argument is what about young children born with life threatening diseases such as cancer, barbarity in animal world, storm , fire, supernove, destruction ,floods, earthquakes, abnormalities in human bodies, a hungry child right now dying somehwer in the world, an innocent child being physically abused, a worm eating away a child eye in Africa
These are all aspects of nature as well
Healthy Online bhagwan ya apolo walon ka To bhala ho jay ga😜😜😜
@@irumfatima2368 jee bilkul 😊
Great Argument Mr. Abbasi!
Good hamza
scientist ek point k baad details directly nahi dekh sakte isiliye chije tough ho jati hai samajhane me jitna andar ghusoge utna aur is bat ka advantage religious log lete hai science ko nicha dikhane ke liye ... lekin hume samajhna chahiye ki its like limit concept of maths. x=0 aur limit of x approaching to zero dono bilkul alag chije hai. scientist are digging deeper and deeper every decade but we dont review and understand their improvements honestly. Have patience, we are reaching close to answers to all questions. Arriving finally at them will take lot of time. Maths me Fermats little theorem prove karne me 350 sal lag gaye, Riemann hypothesis , Goldback conjecture abhi tak prove nahi sekado sakon se ho paya iska matlab nahi ki kabhi nahi prove ho payega. We actually never live forever to see the answers of all the questions. One day, every question meets its proof.... patience does that for sure
ہم ٹینشن اور شرمندگی کے تاثرات دیکھ سکتے ہیں۔
حارث سلطان کے چہرہ پر۔
Or kyaa, Hamza in ko achy sy janta hy in k mind k mutabik answer dy rha hy ise leye 😂
Sahi bole
bilkul
اس ویڈیو میں بہت بار اس چیز کو نوٹ کیا شرمندہ ہونے کے باوجود شرمندہ نہیں ہو رہا بے چارہ جہاں چلا گیا ہے یہ کسی کے ساتھ ہونا نوے فیصد ممکن ہے وہ تو بناتے ہی ملحد ہیں
@@UsmanSadiq303 Hamza Ali abbasi Dharma k ishwar k taraf isahara kar raha hai. Na ki islami allah
Islam ka one God dhong aur jahiliyat hai. Bahut hi simple soch walon k liye hai. Jo ki question na kare. Question Aur logic par bilkul khada nahi utarta. Aur Sanatan dharma ka ekeswarvad authentic question aur logic par har yug kaal time me khada utra hai.
Abhi murti pooja par aao. Muhammad ka gaand suar bhagwan maare ya suar ka gaand muhammad. Mera point ye hai ki kon murti idol symbol ko zayada manta hai. Dekho tumhe kitni mirchi lagi muhammad k naam par. Asli murti puja ye hai. Hindu to apni murti apne hathon fek aata hai. Kyuki usko pata asli ishwar ka. Wo murti ko ishwar nhi samjh raha balki uski Bhawana murti k jariye se ishwar se jud raha hai. Chahe to wo apni bhawna ko bina murti k bhi ishwar se jod sakta hai. Islamic fake allah bina muhammad k kisi kaam ka nahi. Mai murti par thook kar ishwar aradhna kar sakta hoon. Tu muhammad par thook kar allah ko yaad nahi kar sakta.
Arab ya Europe ka one God toh copy hai simple hai chhota hai aur Arab Europe k jahiliyat k daur me banaya gaya tha. Waha k bilkul hi murkh aur barbar janta k liye.
Mai koi master nahi hu Sanatan dharma ka but mai in mazhab wale kisi bhi maulana ya padri ko 30 minute me nirutar kar dunga. Kyuki quran hadis me koi logic nahi blind faith wali Baat Hai. Jabki Sanatan dharma 1400 se zayada granth har vishya par vistar se charcha hai. Sirf ek maha granth Mahabharat hi ek lakh se zayada shlok hai.
Isliye samajhdar ko jab pata chal jata hai ki jo doyam darze ki copy hum Bhartiya Muslims ya Christians follow karte hain wo toh hamare apne desh me lakhon salon se maujud hai par hame us se alag kar diya gaya kisi conspiracy ki wajah se.
Toh kyu na hamara apna bahut hi uche darze ekeswarvad apnaya jaye aur desh duniya me maan samman paya jaye. Dusre desh dusre culture ka one God ek allah ka concept jo kachha pakka hai usko apna kar mazak bane, bezzati aur Maar kaat wali zindgi mili. Yahi soch samjh kar alim aur padri fir se Sanatan dharma me aa jate hai. Jab unko koi yah sach batane wala rasta dikha dete hain. Islam internet ka information age nahi jhel payega. Ab satya ko chhipaya nahi ja sakta. Internet ki wajah se Islam ka ant ho jayega.
Zabardast hamza
i am an indian ,i am proud to be an Hindu and i believe in it totally . i dnt like islam nor do i take it as an Religion ... but i found Hamza Ali as good Intellectual in terms of Scientific Knowledge, his whole arguments is a reflection of Vedas, he shud learn more about vedas. nice conversation and haariz i support u as atheist for exposing the Islam and as a true Liberal.
Hahaha,,I m Muslim and proud to be a Muslim,,, and fallowing the true religion of God, that is Islam,, you want to off this light by your desire that will never happen except you feel bad,it will reach each and every corner of the universe,,lol
Hamza you just blown him away
Haaris and Abbasi, listening to you brief talk, what you are essentially pondering is that ..
1) did energy exist before matter or
2) it was matter first that produced energy or
3) some one controlled what came first and then the other followed and the vivcious process of big bang, contraction and black holes now exist for ever?
Essentially the argument of Abbasi is that someone set the process for creation of universe and its now understood events. Hence Abbaasi believes that manipulator can be called God.
Haaris, argues that there is nothing to proove what came first and who manifested the process? Hence the process is organic and incidental and no god exist.
Beyond a point it is difficuilt to draw the arguments for both sides to a pointing conclusion because :
a) much of our understang of galactical events are based on several theories floated by different scientists to support their understanding of big bang or black holes, expansion or contraction etc Much of predictions or predicted history of universe is based on interpolation or extra polation of limited observation of data, which is absolutely nothing in terms of timeline of our universe.
b) beyond a point no body in the past or present could explain, atleast in logic, who and how every thing was put in motion? And it is possible that this fact led to the formulation of the concept of God so that the discussion can be put to a close atleast till more investigation or information is available to prolong the debate further.
Essentially our ignorance is what is termed as God ....and may be the day we come to know the facts (?) We will be God ourselves.
Therefore instead of thinking of aakhrat or trying to proove existance or no existance of God, life would be simple to live organically and not be led or manipulated by some goofy stories of the past. When I say past, the time line of existance of life on earth several million of years. So the stories of last 1400 yrs or 2000 yrs or 10000 yrs do not matter at all ......Civilsations existed for million of years not only on earth but in other planets and we should focuss on the way to a more liveable world now and co habitaion in future
Hamza sahib is always best......!
شاباش حمزہ علی عباسی
Nice discussion
Hamza we love you ❤❤
Hamza ( Giving logical points in whole discussion)
mulhid ( no i i i , yes i i i , listen i i i)
Being very unbiased to the debate, I think Hamza Ali Abbasi was more logical in hia argumentation.
حمزہ نے ثابت کردیا کہ مسلمانوں میں بھی دم ہے...
بسم اللہ الرحمن الرحیم انرجی کی اِس طرف مادہ ہے سائنسدان انرجی کی صرف مادی جانب تک جا سکتے تھے انرجی کی دوسری جانب نور ہے اور نور مادی شے نہیں ہے اس کو چھوا نہیں جا سکتا ۔ جہاں سائنسدان کا سفر ختم ہوتا ہے وہاں سے سالک کا سفر شروع ہوتا ہے۔
کوئی تو ہے جس نے اس ساری کائنات کو بنایا وہی خدا ہے وہی خدا ہے اور وہ ایک ہے۔
The point here is if there is a creator, then he didn't create well. For example, somewhere it rains a lot and some areas no rain of significantly less rain etc.
Hamza knows just enough science to confuse himself,,, as its rightly said little knowledge is dangerous. Most of his scientific facts were his own assumptions which had nothing to do with actual scientific phenomenas.Looks like he wants to believe in creationism and he uses everything in his access to try to be relevant but fails miserably as he clearly is biased towards Creationalism.
What do you believe ?
@@BabarUhsmani humanity
This debate is like what comes first egg or hen. In Hinduism time is cyclical
not linear. Science also talks about big bang and big crunch. things happens and get vanished and again happen eternal.
But hen and egg both do exist and whosoever came first did it come out of nothing without any intent or out of itself? That's the question
Hen comes first as God made the beings not eggs.
Hamza bhai v. Good
Nice
God says :God is love.
اللہ ایک ہے اس کا کوئی شریک نہیں۔
اس کے علاوہ کوئی عبادت کے لائق نہیں۔ وہی تمام جہانوں کا خالق و مالک ہے۔ اس کے تمام رسول برحق ہیں۔
محمد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم اس کے آخری نبی ہیں۔
Potential infinily complex
To b an atheist 1 needs guts to go against massive number of people following any form of religion.
Creator koi bhi ho but I believe that muhammad ka banaya hua Allah creator nahi h
"Proud ex-muslim"
Ryt creatr se kbhi galtiya nhi hoti jbki mohmmd ke khuda me to gltiya hi gltiya aisa lgta hai jaise halat hote the us hisab se sab hota hai...
YOU ARE NO KNOWLEDGE OF QURAN...... YOU HAVE NOT EVEN FULL KNOWLEDGE OF SCIENCE.... TUM WO KABOOTER HO JIS NE BILI KO DEKH KER ANKHEIN BAND KER LI HEIN.
AT LEAST YOU KNOW ACCEPT THERE IS A CREATOR..... IF YOU DONT BELIEVE ON MUHAMMAD PBUH.... NOW YOU ARE CERTIFIED KAFIR...... GET READY FOR HELL ...
@@jasminenetworks8204 and you don't have knowledge of English.
Allah already wasted my 25 years so fuckoff to allah
So basically what Hamza is telling us to stop questioning and stop enquiring.
He is basically making a case for Pascal's wager.
Even if we accept his explanation,why İslam?
@A Wanderer Exactly!
Islam zindabad ☪️☪️☪️ ....
Science need proof
&
Religion need believe
Hamza 👍
Atheist is making arguments for the sake of argument but not for understanding.
Respect u bhai love from atheist of india
How can you be an ex hindu?? This term can never exist
#ex Hindu
Ab jab hinduism peak pr h aap kyun chorh rhe hn ?
@@BabarUhsmani gr koi buri chiz peak pe ho to kya use nhi chorna chaie
@@exhindu4340 accha point h apka.
.
Aur courage b h apme.
.
Warna is waqt to dusre logo ka Hindu banne la time h. Jo ban nahi rhe to Kam se Kam dikha to rhe hn unke jaisa banke.
@@BabarUhsmani nonhindu bina Dre apni jgh kayam rhe unhe Hindu jsa bnne k zrurt nhi he usul k lie hlak b hona PDE to ho jao pr apne usul Mt choro. Ex Hindu bnne k vjhse meri Hindu log mazmmt krte he but me apni jgh kayam hu.i don't care wht Hindus think of me. Muj mallum he me sahi hu.
Allah Most High is al-Khaliq from all eternity, independently of creation being or not being in existence. “He was All-Knowing when there was nothing to be known; All-Powerful when there was no object of power; All-Seeing when there was nothing to be seen; All-Sustaining when there was nothing to be sustained; Creator when there was nothing created” (Ibn Khafif)
Mr. Abbasi's example of Coca-Cola is totally a fallacy. He thinks that if a water kept for longer time could not make it into Coca-Cola.
But why would simply a water get transformed into Coca-Cola, it may get transformed into some other thing which we can't assume.
It is Abbasi's pre-assumption if Coca-Cola then God. He is already with a state of thought of Coca-Cola then God only. But it can be something else and it does not need any act of God.
The beauti of sceintist is that he or she is flexible to accept at certain point he or she does not know about existent, but a religious person thinks his book knows all the answers without making any logical sense and takes it as threat to his own existence if somebody puts his books claims to test , because he identifies himself with that religion, thats y his ego doesnot accept logical reasonings of sceince
Aisa nahi h.
.
Pr chakkar ye h ki jab athiest bole we don't know to to believer accept krte hn.
Jab believe bole we don't know to atheist kahte hn kyun nahi pata pata hona chahiye the.
Hamza ali abbasi gave you good logical points you were failed to prove your point
Science says we explores the hidden things modify them but not creates .
दोस्तों कुदरत को समझने के लिये वेदो को पढना ही पडेगा
Tumko kudrat samjh agaya hai??
@@rumtech4277 वेद पिंपल को नदियों जंगलों और जानवरों ओर यज्ञों को करने ओर रक्षा करने के लिए व्यवस्था है ओर ये नेचर ही है
Behen upne bedo sayed samjha nai nothing is something
The best argument for gods is the argument from design which has been debunked by Charles Darwin's evolution by natural selection hypothesis (now theory)
Favourite line of Darwin and darwinists is :
.
Million and billion of years.
.
Ab krlo pata Kya hua tha keese hua tha kyyun hua tha. TumhAri kkhud ki zindggi jayadda se jayada 70-80 saal ki h.
Haris ki bolti band hogai aj Alhamdulillah...
In sha Allah ap waps aaengy islam ki taraf mujhy yaqeen hai
Nice hamja
Creation and creator is not separated