Titanic's Ghosts Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024
- Documentary about the recent attempts to identify some of the victims retrieved from sea after the Titanic was lost.
FAIR USE NOTICE: This video may contain copyrighted material. Such material is made available for educational purposes only. This constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law.
The unknown child has now been proven not to be Eino Viljami Panula as was previously thought and the epilogue states. They have now absolutely identified the unknown child as 19 month old Sidney Leslie Goodwin. The Goodwin's were third class passengers on the Titanic. They were a English family headed for a new life in Niagara Falls, N.Y when they all perished. A pair of shoe's kept from the recovered body ( held in the Maritime Museum of the Atlantic) and re-examination of the DNA by the U.S. Armed Forces DNA Identification Laboratory in Maryland proved that Sidney was the unknown child. The shoes had been saved by Clarence Northover, a Halifax police sergeant in 1912, who helped guard the bodies and belongings of the Titanic victims, according to the museum's website. All of the recovered victim's clothing were burned to stop souvenir hunters. Northover couldn't bring himself to burn the little shoes, and when no relatives claimed them, he put the shoes in his desk drawer at the police station. In 2002, his grandson Earle Northover donated them to the museum. These shoes were too large for a 13 month old to wear, and were a big clue that the only other contender, Panula, was not the unknown child. The new DNA tests found a marker that proved with 98% certainty that Goodwin was the unknown child. This positive identification means that out of his parents Frederick and Augusta, and five siblings, little Sidney's were the only remains recovered. The family have not changed the headstone to bear Sidney's name. They feel that the tombstone of the unknown child represents *all* of the children who perished on the Titanic, and have left it that way in their honor.
They need to change the name because that is the child laying there. He deserves to be recognized. He can still represent ALL CHILDREN who died on the ship.
Trust me ..he doesn't care..it's what the family wants that's important .
Thanks so very much for sharing this extra information!! I can't help but come back again and again to this documentary to see wh
To see what additional information and comments c an shed more light on these ppeople. They are all equal in God's grace...canvas bag at sea, or satin lined coffins with a name for the headstones. He knew them all : )
cisio64123 I
As an update, the unknown child is now proven not to be Eino Panula but Sidney Leslie Goodwin an 19 month old English boy.
Rowan Hunter so sad
I had a relative on the Titainc. His name was Charles Ingram. He was a crew member working as a trimmer. According to records, he is buried at Halifax as well. He was died so young. He was just around 20 years old.
+Thuglife Pikachu I am so sorry for your family. I know that there is no way you can remember him but still it is a horrible thing on its own but more so because of the thought that it happened to family. Can I ask what a trimmer is?
+Rachel Clark Trimers work at the very bottom of the ship . They split the coal surply in half to equal the weight so it doesn't capsize the ship.
Press X to doubt
@ARE YOU FEELING LUCKY PUNK as yes.....the stupid ugly troll shows up to spew his venom......a base creature concerned only with his stupid genitals and those of others. Wow....what an asset you feel you are to the world. Too bad your mistaken.
Rest in peace, Charles.
We visited the cemetery in Halifax this past summer. Looking at the line of grave stones still brings a great sadness...
R.I.P
All of the people who lost there lives on Titanic
😭
Some say that he only time we are all the same is when we are born and when we die, We are all born naked and we depart taking nothing from this world. Being a king or a street sweeper, we are all the same, my friends.
+Bira Seraphico Very true.
yup
a street sweeper has.more dignity...I agree to what.you said in the opposite direction as kings are usually deviates and scumbags..street sweepers...mostly family men and dignified people who believe in right for its own sake...while kings believe in "might makes right"..
Bira Seraphico well said. we come into this world with no possessions and we leave it with no possessions. ain't that sumthan.
Why would some think because you are poorer you are more dignified? Many kings and queens have dignity as well.
Can't imagine how scary it must have been to be on the ship.. especially for the third class passengers, who were stuck on there.
Yeah the police on the boat were asswholes
+Ben Dzialak Hey ! They died to
+misterepictamale ! Shut it
+Keziah Reeves yeah I know they were still assholes even though they kinda were serving the country...
+misterepictamale ! I don't they were told NOT TO SAVE people's life's!! You have a lot to learn kid
The rich still think the poor are dogs, that hasnt changed. Wish i could say it wasnt still that way. I guess it has always been and will always be that way
The poor are still treated this way, today, nothing much has changed
HOW SICK IS IT, TO SEPARATE HUMAN BEINGS INTO "CLASSES", BASED ON THE AMOUNT OF MONEY EACH POSSESSES?!?
Yup, and here in the UK a person's standing in society is still measured by how much their house is worth. The more their property is worth - the more they get respected, believed, taken serious. Even if one applies for jobs, the prospective employers google one's address - and if one lives in a property that's not worth a lot, one doesn't stand a chance getting that job.
Many people in the UK (in England at least) still believe that the poor are poor because they are too stupid and lazy to better their situation, whilst at the same time social mobility is impossible because the system is set up to keep the poor in poverty.
And anyone who is poor, or assumed to be poor, still gets treated with contempt, looked down on, fobbed off, chased away, and automatically assumed to be criminal, uneducated, a troublemaker, unreliable, unemployed and unemployable, untrustworthy and retarded.
@@MissPresley69it’s not sick, it’s commerce! Not a single person was forced on that ship! Yes it’s horribly tragic what happened to all of the people, but to call the pricing of cabins on a commercial ship “sick” is ridiculous. The investors who paid to build this ship wanted a return on the investment. There is nothing wrong with that.
They should have realized that calling The Titanic an "Unshinkable ship'" or that "not even God himself could sink her" was a recipe for disaster.
True that it is as if they were challenging God almighty
Titanic *hits iceberg*
The ship staff: it was at that moment they knew, they FuKcEd uP
No one is ever quoted saying "not even God can sink this ship" please don't get your history from the movie titanic!
A petty god took offence and killed 1500 people to prove his destructive "powers"?
no make believe deity had anything to do with it.
The story of Titanic allways brings me to tears,I just can't imagine the horror those people went through,R.I.P to all who perished on her
Amen to that.
Rip everyone that died on the titanic
This is so devastating . We only have one body and one life to live, and for their one body to be in an unmarked grave to never be identified or visited by loved ones because they don't know where u r? There is nothing more devastating :'(
Jacklyn Sweets They should dig up the graves, and perform DNA tests on ALL bodies and compare them with surviving family descendants who have valid stories about losing a loved one...This would put an end to the speculation!!! We HAVE the technology whey dont we USE it??? Maybe someone will dig them up one day and DNA test the remains of the descendants as well, and bury them together...
Katie K. All graves all flooded, the bodies rotted to nothing.
Alison Scott Those people had already gone on to meet God. They aren't in the graves. Please don't worry, their spirits are at rest.
This is the case with hundreds of hurricane Katrina victims. They're buried in unmarked graves in one of the oldest cemeteries in the country. I went there on a cemetery tour and it's eerie to think that these people from the 21st century are buried along side people who died from the plague hundreds of years before.
This is a very touching documentary of the disaster--perhaps the most moving one. The narration is very delicately done with sensitivity.
Sad story. I wish everyone could be identified.
Great documentary, thankful to those who helped those lost & maybe restless souls, there IS hope in mankind !
RIP to all the children who dead on the Titanic😩😞🙏
What about the men and the woman ... Rich .. Poor .. Old.... Young it doesn't matter those people lives where in that captions hand and he was in such a god dam rush to get to America 1500 of the people out off 2200 souls were killed on the RMS Titanic in 1912 rip to you all
Amen 🙏
This was a great documentary,it is very sad that one little boy was the only child they found in the water back in 1912...thanks for the upload!
Its ashame that even back in those days a life was worth more if you were rich. Everyone is equal weather you are rich or poor or in between. We atleast learned from that disaster. I think it is really cool how some 90 years later we can use DNA from bone fragments to determine who they are, amazing.
Burial at sea is not the same as 'throwing the bodies into the sea'. It would have been done in a respectful manner in the context of a proper burial service.
The fact is, bodies don't last, even ff they aren't buried at sea. They are usually either cremated or buried in the earth to rot away and dissolve. What matters is respecting the human dignity of the people they once were, and a proper burial at sea does that.
my great great grandmother was on the titanic sadly she died on it too cause she was 3rd class her name was edith peacock and with her 2 kids that died with her too so sad
So sorry about your great great grandmother :(.
omg go on people who died on the titanic and it will show a peacock family not sure if its yours but lady 2 kids were in it so maybe also very sorry for that loss
dogs studio
I'm so sorry
dogs studio so how is she your great great grandma if her kids weren't able to grow up & have children
D C2184 she might of had other kids that survived the sinking idk
I couldn’t image how sad and creepy it must have been seeing all those bodies floating in the water
that small boy's grave plot, funeral, coffin, and headstone were all paid out of the pockets of the recovery ship crew. he was the only third class passenger corpse to be brought back. they called him their unknown babe.
We are born unequal...but die equal.
Proves wealth can’t always save you.
Wealth means nothing once we die.💔
It's VERY upsetting that many of these people were never found. All of their loved ones only had memories, nothing to go and grieve to. It's terrible to think that bodies were also thrown over board because of class. They do have names that matter, and we can only pray that the survivors and victims are together again. All the survivors has passed on. The Titanic truly took everyone down with her now. That little boy story was touching to hear now. It's amazing that he was IDed.
Cursed be those responsible and those who did not supply the ship with enough lifeboats....such a tragedy....
I know what you mean, but back then the Titanic had more than what she was required to carry. Originally Thomas Andrews had planned on having over 60 boats on Titanic. He was overruled.
I don't think they would have saved everyone because of the time it took to put the boats down if they had enough boats.
the main people I feel sorry for that died from the titanic are the little babies and children...its messed up...kids don't deserve to die especially in teagic deaths like that...the poor things...even imagine how frightened and scared they were...I never wanna be in a situation like that with my little one
Billie Springer: I am so sad, depressed, and traumatized for the dogs that drowned!! That REALLY hurts me!!!😭😭😭😭
Billie Springer- That would be a drag. I wonder how many people died locked in their cabins? Like all tragedies, this was a combination of factors leading to disaster. One or two different what ifs, and the damn ship wouldn't have sank! Little wonder it's stayed in the public's imagination all these years! It's the human drama that still weighs heavy in people's hearts.
Me too!! So much senseless carnage .. It ALL disturbs me, greatly!! STILL.
@@minivegana1355 I have a special place in my heart for the woman that refused to get in a life boat without her dog. She sacrificed her life to comfort her terrified beloved pet.😪🐶❤
Billie Springer - "kids don't deserve to die" - ah, so everyone who is not a child does???
You first or you are a hypocrite!
the baby was later identified as sidney goodwin. the entire goodwin family perished that night
that music makes it hard to hear the narrator and others talkin on the video
I was born and raised in Southampton and I still live there. This disaster is so much worse when it's on your doorstep. The film always breaks my heart because I know that really happened
I thought the child was identified as Sidney Leslie Goodwin.
+cleftheart It was I believe in 2010-11. I visited Halifax last month, there is now an added plaque at the bottom of the original marker with his name.
What a sad thing to have to identify family. Very sad.
And then there was that ridiculous movie by James Cameron. Just disgusting.. And all those that made money on that degrading movie will pay in Hell.
+Lynn Purcell that movie was beautifully made
why disgusting. I know you may feel for the dead and their families. But i think he did a lot to bring back the titanic to present day . We know better how it may have sunk, and the history remains alive. I was always intrigued by the titanic and my interest was spiked after the movie. Besides james cameron only wanted to make a movie. He was telling a story along the way too..YOu know hollywood, they always try to exaggerate. But then , they are out to make hits andmoney. I enjoyed the movie,
It's odd how some people have to die horrible tragic deaths such as the Titanic passengers,while others simply pass away in their sleep...smh
Benny Danielz: Gosh!!! I know!!!😭😭😭😭😭
I am happy that they have found some of the peoples names that where lost on the titanic. it is a blessing that some of the unmarck graves will now have a name.
I feel so bad for all these lost but such an amazing documentary thank you so much for uploading this.
Can't believe how tragic this is. Those who helped did all they could and did what was right. Spoke to a bloke who went down to the wreck about ten years ago. He said there would be nothing left soon. We have to get all the answers now.
I think this is so sweet that current relatives of the deceased still cares about their loved ones that they never knew. So, sad!
No, I'm pretty sure they concluded (sometime after this) that the unknown child was Sidney Goodwin, from England.
Rip titanic and all her memories and people
There we 107 children under 10 traveling on the ship,if I’m not mistaken. 832 passengers and 685 crew perished.
in 2001, while recovering from a stroke, I had the honor to meet dr. Robert ballard, the man who found her in mystic, Connecticut. what a great guy. I've met many celebrities at various car shows, and races, but meeting dr. ballard, is my coolest!!!
This video was tough to watch but necessary!! Auesome!! Rest In Peace Titanic!!!!
for those of you wondering in the end of the video where they identify the child as Eino Viljami Panula that turned out not to be true and he was eventually identified as Sidney Leslie Goodwin if you don't believe me you can google it.
I did enjoy this video thank you for postingt jerra1234!
When you call a ship “Unsinkable” but then you see what happens on the night of April 14th 1912 😲
My Grandma Grace was 3 month old
Woooooooooooooow
rest in peace.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
It's so sad that so many people add to die and the poor poor young boy that as no name I just wanna turn the clocks back and save him
The Titanic could have sank from mirage were the look out people did not see the iceberg because the kind of night it was
What frame rate is this? Some really low number? :-P
It infuriates me to see S.S. Titanic.The Titanic was a Royal Mail Steamer.NOT a States ship!!!Hence the correct way of addressing her is The R.M.S.Titanic.
Pisses me off how the poor were treated back then. Seriously whats the point of retreieving the bodies if you're just going to throw them back into the sea!? No wonder so many bodies werent found!!
My entire life ive kept the titanic in my heart and to know that we'll never find countless bodies is absolutely heart breaking. Money shouldnt have been a factor back then. Poor or rich, they had living families who just wanted their safe return. Rest in peace
Eino Viljami Panula, based on DNA testing of three teeth and a small, weathered bone. [6] However, with improved DNA testing available in 2007, Canadian researchers at Lakehead University in Thunder Bay tested the child's HVS1, a type of mitochondrial DNA molecule, and it did not match the Panula family DNA extracted from the exhumed remains and DNA provided by a surviving maternal relative helped positively match the remains to Goodwin, and the re-identification was announced on 30 July 2007.
its amazing that people are still fascinated by the titanic.
There have been two world wars and countless genocides since 1912 where unknow bodies lay but not much is done to return there bodies to loved ones especially loved ones who personally knew the deceased
RIP to everyone who died on the Titanic
And to the great ship itself
They hit the iceberg on 14th april at 11:40 pm, and finally sank at 2:20am of april 15th...
The body of the unknown child is really one-year-old Sidney Leslie Goodwin
R.I.P Titanic who lost there live and thank you for all the people who lived to tell there story's my heart goes for all of you people
I am a Titanic fanatic and also from Thunder Bay, I had no idea that some remains were sent to my city
My oldest great grandmother (on my dad's side) was born the year the Titanic set sail on it's first and last voyage.
+Vesentrin Mine was too. She was born just a few weeks before the sinking.
+DisWldFrk90 My great grandpa was born on April 15, 1912
Jessica Bottrell
Wow. What a coincidence.
My grandmother was born in 1912 too. Her uncle died on the Titanic.
+Piper Holland That's awesome!
The really sad part is when they went to exhume the graves for DNA, they were flooded. These poor souls were drowned, and now rest in water. :(
I heard from another documentary that someone at White Star said that if they put more boats on the ship the passengers would be scarred, thinking that the ship has so many boats because they are expecting something to happen to it.
It must have been a terrifying sight 😱
So sad unknown baby is still unknown, may all these souls rest peacfully.Thank 4posting .SJLondon England.
It was later realised to be Sidney Leslie Goodwin
So sad what these people went through all those years ago. The terror and fear they must of felt knowing they were going to die. The children scared the mothers in panic so sad. If only Titanic took measures to make sure all passengers could make out safely. So sad to know many victims pulled from the water went unidentified leaving the families in grief all their lives. Glad to know the child was identified though so one family can have peace. R.I.P Titanic & Her victims
Its pretty sad that they only found one childs remains in the sea when there were many other children who died on the titantic but there bodies were never recovered from the sea.
Small children left on board would have been pulled down by the downdraft created and wouldn't have resurfaced.
It's really sad that those people died now look at ships today the have more life boats for every person and they run a drill before leaving
+Lizzy Bucalo It always takes a tragedy to improve safety. That's the really sad thing.
+Lizzy Bucalo it was preplanned.. done on purpose read the truth about the titanic
It seems crazy that the number of lifeboats used to be determined by a ships TONNAGE, not number of people onboard! The equation apparently worked for many years until the dawn of giant ships, like the Titanic. The top end of the lifeboat calculation was a specific tonnage & above. No one dreamed how big liners would eventually become, demanding new standards!
+DisWldFrk90 yes it's sad but true.
same as dangerous roads etc
+Cathy Vickers In 1912 The Board Of Trade made the rules Those rules dated back to about 1895.
When the Titanic sank and the ship split into then the lights went out before and it was all darkness nothing else and you can hear the screams of the people who were in the water because the water was 28 degrees and 30 mins you would freeze to death and the people holding on for dear life knew they didn't have a chance! They probbaly said my god this is it! They didn't have any lifeboats and the third class passengers had no chance! I am sure the bodies sunk into the sea when Titanic went down and then so did they! So many people, women, men, children, dogs, babies, and the crew and the band played on when Titanic sank. They went out till the end. I think that there are ghosts at the bottom of Titanic those souls who are not at rest! It was a beautiful ship
So much misery and death from a lump of ice. Those last moments cannot be imagined, all they were doing was trying to build a better life and fate had other ideas.
RIP to all the ppl who died and to the ship it's self
RIP to everyone and to the the great ship itself.
These murdered victims*cry out for truth*. The SHIP was altered a midships in the month before it sailed. Board of Trade Document L.L. 21288 refers. Mass x Velocity, 20,000 tons x 22 knots, then full speed astern. Its enough to rip an already badly damaged ship in two. !!!
A lot of graves get flooded... didn't want to ruin your comment, but it is a very common thing for graves to be flooded, though also very sad.
How sad yet ironc that water would wash away 2 of the graves remains :(
at 18.20 they start showing film of the olympic in new york what is this to do with titanic ? you can even see the replaced steel plates from its accident
R.I.P. to all who lost their lives and futures
It has always been such a tragic accident . I can not imagine what they felt.
they can't switch names just like that in a matter of weeks, it takes MONTHS for the paint they used to dry (they had several different layers) along with waterproofing which took quite a while.
at 1:33 that man looks like he is asleep but obviously he isnt and he was frozen but its amazing how he was preserved...he looks exactly as he did about 100 or so years ago ????
;)
Not smiling because of the people who died, but because this video is enjoyable.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭i am still crying in 2016
Don't know why I clicked on this, so depressing. What will always bother me about this is the grim story of entire immigrant families being wiped out and any hopes of a new life dumped to the icey bottom of the North Atlantic. Worse that their bodies were never recovered or even identified for a proper burial.
I can't help but think of the numerous scenarios that could have gone down for them whether they were separated, lost in the maze inside the ship or getting on the decks just as the all the life boats were gone. The Goodwins, Sages, Anderssons, Panulas and numerous others didn't deserve this fate smh
if they were all as well preserved I find it impossible to believe they were not able to identify such vast numbers of the departed.
It is very touching what those men on that ship that was recovering those bodies did for that precious unkown child. They have my respect
pure arrogance sank this ship!!! poor people rip!!!!
I hear you, bro.
28:28
The only way we’ll ever be able to identify the unidentified now is a Time Machine.
(Bad King John and Richard the Lionheart were equally evil to me which is why I refuse to use their names or that of any monarchy, the idea of which is stupid and utterly ridiculous.)
money thing is just as same as it was back than to day sadly..
may i ask without anyone having a go or taking the mik y are they buried in candida when they was closer to ireland or whateva seem a bit far away from where she sunk aint it?
+every1hatesme100 Good question I was thinking the same thing myself. They should have all been taken back to the country where they was from.I just don't sees how any of them can be resting in peace.
+every1hatesme100 they were 4hrs away from the united states.. i thought ..new england boarder which canada runs along ..they were headed to new york city/boston
Im watching this because last night i had a dream about ghosts and many of them said they were on the titanic some were scary and some lovely.
All those poor people , The third class passengers were treated appallingly, many never stood a chance, These children should have been prioritised, some were, but many were not. I will never understand the class society, what makes a wealthy person any better than a poor person ?, The class system still applies today, but in times of tragedy, there should never be such a disgusting system in place. A banker should never have priority over a toilet cleaner.
Thanks for posting this wonderful documentary! A pity that the narrator is so bad to the point of being annoying.
Rip All who perished on the Titanic
so sad!
Not everyone were recovered. For a few months after the sinking passing ships would report individual bodies still floating in the sea.
I'd be willing to bet, given how fast ocean currents work, that at least 1/3 to 1/2 of Titanic's victims floating on the ocean were never found. They drifted until the canvas lifejackets rotted, then broke off, and sank.
It was a matter of practicalities to let those bodies sink. They didn't have a way to preserve them like they could today. At least long enough to get back to land. Imagine spending two weeks at sea with a hold full of decaying corpses. Not a nice thought. The bodies left behind had probably began to decay or had been unidentifiable due to injury or sea critters.
we're learning about titanic at school this helps me get not into about titanic plus if you type in on RUclips animation of titanic sinking a 10 year old boy said I was on the titanic in 1912
I wouldn't be in 1st class I'm not rich I wouldn't be in the 3rd class cuz I'm not poor I would be in the 2nd class cuz I can afford socks
This is a bit outdated...The ending misidentified the Unknown Child...but a newer identification identifies him as Sidney Leslie Goodwin
I feel bad for thoose people and the ghost part is the scary thong about this
+shashawna Reger What ghost part must have missed that part lol.
Hah yeah idk
I did see a few yrs. make this program on tv 1 night like 1 of those unsolved mystery shows this woman bought a piece of coal that came from the Titanic & she was in her kitchen & she said an older man started appearing at her kitchen window standing outside staring in at her dressed in like that period of clothing.She said he just looked like he would have been 1 of those men that was over the boilers feeding it coal.Scary huh I thought so anyhow I would have put something up over my window so I didn't see him nomore & just pray to God that he make him go away.