“Kashmir hum ne khud Khoya” - agar Jinnah Sb. (Mmerhoom) kuch aur zinda rahte to jaisa namasayad halat mein Pakistan liya, waise he Kashmir + haasil kerte magar early maut ke ba’ad Sons of the Soil Pakistan per qabiz hogaye aur phir jo Pakistan ka Hal hua aur HO RAHA hai woh azher menashams hai. Zayada bolna gunah hai!
Jinna sahab is hero all hindu 🐄🛐🛕🙏❤while gandhi nehru is pinnacle of shame and traitor for we hindus of world ❤me being a proud 🇧🇩Bangladeshi hundu too❤
Elder brother also slaps younger brother in case of mischief and the younger brother behaves properly and doesn't hit back elder younger. So start behaving like a younger brother.
Being an Kashmiri, I suggest Pakistan administration donot waste your time, we have lost every thing our properties,lives each and everyone and we donot have any trust on Pakistan,even no can come forward now ,It is better for Pakistan not to raise this issue now, we are happy with India .No can trust on Pakistan now,
Dono country's apna apna dekhen .. india 🇮🇳 caa laagu kare Pakistani hinduo ke liye and Pakistan caa laagu kare indian Muslims ke liye .. border per itni badi deewar banaye india ki Pakistan se air bhi nahi aaye ..
आ गया नमक हराम बड़े दिन बाद अपनी मनहूस सकल लेके मैं तो उस राकेश वाद्य को खोज रहा हूं जो इस के प्यार मे मरा जा रहा था इस नमक हराम को पाक में कुछ भी बुरा नहीं दिखाई देता b j p और मादी मे इसको हिन्दू दिखता है पर अपने मे कुछ नहीं दिख रहा
My question is from prof shahab that why Muslims league thought that British looters are their well wishers and Hindu Sikhs are not theirs own but enemy . Whereas Germans came close but not punjabistan of that side of Radcliffe line. That may be lack of education but well educated Muslims broken united India.
All Islamic political parties were against partition even Jinnah sahib was not support of partition. Muslim population of India were minority they wanted to protection and security of rights and shares according to population percentage. Congress Birahman politicians were in favor of partition for sake of Birahman interest or Raam Raaj, rule of upper class Hindu cast. They become successful in 1947, after partition India became Hindu Rashtra. Congress had rejected all proposal of federation of India. 1, Muslim demanded amendment in 5 points of Nihru report. 2, Jinnah sahib was demanded 14 points, within federation of India. 3, Cabinet mission plan by British government for solution of political unrest, within federation of India. 4, Union of Indian states like constitution of USA, proposal by Azad. All proposals were rejected by Congress then Jinnah sahib was demanded partition for safety and security of mslm majority nations of India. Before partition out of 11 provinces muslim were majority in 5 provinces and Hindu majority 5 provinces and one was Aadivasi Odessa province. Chief commissioner 6 provinces and princely states. Congress were responsible for partition and allegations leveled on Jinnah sahib. Check history through Google.
Mahatma gandhi was shame for all hindus while as Bangladeshi🇧🇩 hindu we touch feet 👣of G8 Jinnah for Action 🎬of Partition ❤that helped us to keep surviving ❤ with Truth of 2 nation ❤
Well islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan ganduudin namazi Pakistan is ready to pimp there begairat behaya raped and converted musalmina ammi khala behen and there 6 year old betiyan named ayeshas for there halala at shahhen Bagh for imdad and bheekh so what more can they offer😂😂
Who can confirm with authenticity that this happened what Dr is saying. The factual position is that Mount Batten had already ordered sending India Army in Kashmir after dubious annexation instrument of Raja with India. if Sardar Patel was negotiating a deal over Hyderabad verses Kashmir, . That means that things were already decided between Nahru and Mountbatten to annex Kashmir after forcing Raja under coersion to sign Instrument of accession to provide cover to their nefarious design . All three states were annexed by India on gun point. Mount Batten being Spreme Commander if both Armies, did allow Indian Army to capture Kashmir whereas Pak Army Chief refused to deploy Pak Army in Kashmir to counter Indian forces under the pretext that Mount Batten did not allow him to deploy Pak Army
He is a highly educated well read political analyst what you are saying shows your typical khinzeer e katmoon ignorance Pakshmullah forces attacked kashmir state first but jinnah was unfortunate like many mullahs in history who was bitten by a wild pig the same wild pig had bitten aurangzeb babur khilji Stop giving Musalta logic
Why was India 's Independence Preponed from 1948 to 1947 ? Why did Mountbatten suddenly declare that the Partition of India would take place with inexplicable haste on August 15, 1947, almost a year ahead of schedule?
Yes we accept India as big brother but big brother is always not at vintage position in some cases Big brother has to become a punching bag. Does India like to become big brother- a punching bag?
As per Arabi political ideology book Quran, believers can not have nonbelievers as his brother, father and friends. Arabi political ideology book Quran divides humanity into believer and nonbelievers (kafir). Muslim can not have anyone not following this Arabi political ideology book Quran as his brothers. Wuran is a book that damages blood relation based on their faith. Therefore you are Arabi ZEHNI GHULAM
What is the use of this nonsense talk, if you can't change anything in your own country.That's why people become angry from people like these even Ishtiyaq Ahmed gets a lot of heat. Useless people whose only agenda is to sell books.
India and pakistan are two sovereign countries and should try to resolve their dispute without the shadow of the division of united india, considering each other point of view.
100%. That is the mature way to move forward for mutual benefit and harmony. The question is whether the pak army allows that to happen. I think with Trump coming to power next year, the funds tap to pak army will turn off even more and their control over pak reduced. We want a soft border. I want to visit sites in pak, you want to visit india. We want trade flow as well.
جناح جمہوری تھے شیخ عبداللہ کو نصیحت کی تارا سنگھ کے پاس گیے اسے نصیحت کی ۔کیا یہ سب اقدام کور ایشو پر توجہ نہں کہلاتے لیکن سازش جیتی آج کشمیری اور سکھ جن مشکلات کا شکار ھیں اسمیں ان نام نہاد لیڈروں کا حصہ ھے
Elder brother also slaps younger brother in case of mischief and the younger brother behaves properly and doesn't hit back elder younger. So start behaving like a younger brother. Convert Ghumman 😂😂 has to be in Pakstan so firstly says "dono taraf" (chronic prob of false equivalence in Pak) then he says 70:30 mistake ratio is "point of view" 😂😂😂
@@karolbagh3793 Ghar wapsi to tumhari bhi honi chahiye, 4th and 5th century AD main Tum sab bhi to Buddhism chhorr ker saanp baander haathi chuhe poojne lage the, Buddhist temples ko mandir bana Dala, Buddha ke statues ko new devi devta main convert Kiya, later central Asian rulers labeled hundreds of your different local religions Hindu for their own convenience.
@@karolbagh3793 Hinduism is nothing but a convenient word for Muslim kings who captured and ruled India, to sum up hundreds of nonsensical religions practiced among locals.
@@arifsaleem5467aap kyon Arabi ZEHNI GHULAM ban gaye. Arabi Allah, Arabi rasool, Arabi hadith, Arabi Quran, Arabi sahaba, Arabi ajaan, Arabi treaty Arabi tareekh, Arabi battle. Sab juch arabi. Apna kuch bhi nahi. You even can not do ibadat in hindi or Urdu since Arabi Allah does not understand hindi or Urdu. Come back to Hinduism. You are not arab or turk. Why adopted a false/artificial identity?
اشتیاق احمد صاحب کی بات سے کچھ حد تک سہمت نہیں ہیں ۔ جناح صاحب بہت دور اندیش شخصیت تھے ۔ حیدراباد دکن کے نظام کو جو مشورہ دیا تھا وہ بہت بہترین تھا۔ جھوناگڑھ کے بدلے کشمیر لینا چاہئے تھا۔ حیدراباددکن کے بدلے مشرقی پاکستان کے شمال اور مشرق میں انڈیا کے اسام اور متصل ریاستیں ھندو اقلیتی ابادی کا ایک بڑا صوبہ اسام تھا ۔ اس کو چین انڈیا کی جنگ میں شامل ھوکر فوجی طاقت سے حاصل کیا جا سکتا تھا ۔ برما کا اراکان مسلم علاقہ بھی شامل ھوتا۔ اگر اس علاقے میں ریفرنڈم ھوتا تو کبھی بھی ھند کی سپورٹ نہیں ھوتی ۔ مسلم ابادی 35%, کرسچن 12%, بدھ 8% دیگر 02% تھے ۔ ھندو 40% تھے ۔ مشرقی و مغربی پاکستان ایک طاقت سے انڈیا کے دونوں اطراف موجود ھوتے .. جناح صاحب کی نظر افغان پر بھی تھی ۔ بھوٹان اور انڈیا کی طرح افغان بھی پاکستان کا دفاعی نظام مارکیٹ اور کرنسی ایک ھوتی ۔ اج کا پاکستان 65 کروڑ ابادی کا طاقتور دیش ھوتا۔ ڈاکٹر اشتیاق احمد کی یہ بات درست ہے کہ لیاقت علی خان سے لیکر بعد کی ڈکٹیٹر شپ والی قیادت نے سیاسی فیصلے کرنے میں بہت غلطیاں کیں جس کا خمیازہ بھگتنا پڑ رھا ہے ۔
You guys also converted from Buddhism to assorted idol worship of different animals and imaginary figures as recently as the 4th or 5th century AD, few more centuries later hundreds of those religions was collectively labeled as Hinduism by invader kings from central Asia for their own convenience, you may check with the science journey channel for more details.
The hatred these converts have for the land of their ancestors is mind boggling 😢😢😢😢
💯✔
It because Hindus are chu who give respect to Pakistani
@@vg82khinzeer e katmaan
Pakistan occupied Jammu & Kashmir (including GILGIT BALTISTAN) will soon be liberated, reunited and reintegrated with BHARAT 🪷🇮🇳🪷
Hindus are secular by it's nature as Muslim are peculiar ardent. Modi must go for Hindu nationalism.
“Kashmir hum ne khud Khoya” - agar Jinnah Sb. (Mmerhoom) kuch aur zinda rahte to jaisa namasayad halat mein Pakistan liya, waise he Kashmir + haasil kerte magar early maut ke ba’ad Sons of the Soil Pakistan per qabiz hogaye aur phir jo Pakistan ka Hal hua aur HO RAHA hai woh azher menashams hai. Zayada bolna gunah hai!
Muslims ki history hai biG brother ho ya younger brother dono ki garrdney uthari hai apnne Interest k leye. Mashallah inshallah
Muslim ke bat nahe ,
They were Turkish (Mughal /Mangol) afghan and Iranian rulers occupied india by force .
@@muneerahmed7530 to hero to aap logone banaya hai bhai 🙂
Jinna sahab is hero all hindu 🐄🛐🛕🙏❤while gandhi nehru is pinnacle of shame and traitor for we hindus of world ❤me being a proud 🇧🇩Bangladeshi hundu too❤
"Ap ne Sweden chale jana hai, mene Pakistan me he rehna hai" 😂😂
Elder brother also slaps younger brother in case of mischief and the younger brother behaves properly and doesn't hit back elder younger. So start behaving like a younger brother.
Being an Kashmiri, I suggest Pakistan administration donot waste your time, we have lost every thing our properties,lives each and everyone and we donot have any trust on Pakistan,even no can come forward now ,It is better for Pakistan not to raise this issue now, we are happy with India .No can trust on Pakistan now,
Dono country's apna apna dekhen .. india 🇮🇳 caa laagu kare Pakistani hinduo ke liye and Pakistan caa laagu kare indian Muslims ke liye .. border per itni badi deewar banaye india ki Pakistan se air bhi nahi aaye ..
आ गया नमक हराम बड़े दिन बाद अपनी मनहूस सकल लेके मैं तो उस राकेश वाद्य को खोज रहा हूं जो इस के प्यार मे मरा जा रहा था इस नमक हराम को पाक में कुछ भी बुरा नहीं दिखाई देता b j p और मादी मे इसको हिन्दू दिखता है पर अपने मे कुछ नहीं दिख रहा
राकेश वाद्य जी देखा लो अपना प्यारा और बुलाओ इस नमक हराम को
Indian Muslims will not go
@@leenajohn136 why
Because they will cry we are suffering in INDIA.but they know they are safe in INDIA and get best education food and freedom
Dr Istiaq Ahmed is honest and judicious in his analysis. Always treat to listen to his research work.
But still he blames India to some extent
My question is from prof shahab that why Muslims league thought that British looters are their well wishers and Hindu Sikhs are not theirs own but enemy . Whereas Germans came close but not punjabistan of that side of Radcliffe line. That may be lack of education but well educated Muslims broken united India.
All Islamic political parties were against partition even Jinnah sahib was not support of partition.
Muslim population of India were minority they wanted to protection and security of rights and shares according to population percentage.
Congress Birahman politicians were in favor of partition for sake of Birahman interest or Raam Raaj, rule of upper class Hindu cast. They become successful in 1947, after partition India became Hindu Rashtra.
Congress had rejected all proposal of federation of India.
1, Muslim demanded amendment in 5 points of Nihru report.
2, Jinnah sahib was demanded 14 points, within federation of India.
3, Cabinet mission plan by British government for solution of political unrest, within federation of India.
4, Union of Indian states like constitution of USA, proposal by Azad.
All proposals were rejected by Congress then Jinnah sahib was demanded partition for safety and security of mslm majority nations of India.
Before partition out of 11 provinces muslim were majority in 5 provinces and Hindu majority 5 provinces and one was Aadivasi Odessa province.
Chief commissioner 6 provinces and princely states.
Congress were responsible for partition and allegations leveled on Jinnah sahib.
Check history through Google.
Mahatma gandhi was shame for all hindus while as Bangladeshi🇧🇩 hindu we touch feet 👣of G8 Jinnah for Action 🎬of Partition ❤that helped us to keep surviving ❤ with Truth of 2 nation ❤
Yes we thank jinnah for taking away the junk from india. You guys are a nuisance
Even if India no want PoK but but what to do PoK wants to merge with India.
Did Pakistan accept India as elder brother ?
Yes they too did. The same bhai and chaara!
Well islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan ganduudin namazi Pakistan is ready to pimp there begairat behaya raped and converted musalmina ammi khala behen and there 6 year old betiyan named ayeshas for there halala at shahhen Bagh for imdad and bheekh so what more can they offer😂😂
He is one of the greatest historians of indo-pak.
Jabardasti ??? Mediocre writer
@@vg82
A stinking Tunni spotted.
Voice quality not good ..too much echo ..too annoying..
Ghumman is jatt sikh last name in east punjab Converted Muslim Akmal Saab. Very good video. Dr Saab always good
Who can confirm with authenticity that this happened what Dr is saying. The factual position is that Mount Batten had already ordered sending India Army in Kashmir after dubious annexation instrument of Raja with India. if Sardar Patel was negotiating a deal over Hyderabad verses Kashmir, . That means that things were already decided between Nahru and Mountbatten to annex Kashmir after forcing Raja under coersion to sign Instrument of accession to provide cover to their nefarious design . All three states were annexed by India on gun point. Mount Batten being Spreme Commander if both Armies, did allow Indian Army to capture Kashmir whereas Pak Army Chief refused to deploy Pak Army in Kashmir to counter Indian forces under the pretext that Mount Batten did not allow him to deploy Pak Army
He is a highly educated well read political analyst what you are saying shows your typical khinzeer e katmoon ignorance
Pakshmullah forces attacked kashmir state first but jinnah was unfortunate like many mullahs in history who was bitten by a wild pig the same wild pig had bitten aurangzeb babur khilji
Stop giving Musalta logic
اللہ پاک کا لاکھ لاکھ شکر ھے کشمیر تم بد بختوں سے نہیں ملا
اللہ تعالٰی کا شکر ہیں کہ ہم کشمیری عوام پاکستان کے ساتھ نہیں ہیں
Why was India 's Independence Preponed from 1948 to 1947 ?
Why did Mountbatten suddenly declare that the Partition of India would take place with inexplicable haste on August 15, 1947, almost a year ahead of schedule?
Kis baat ka big brother? 1947 bloodshed banned every good relation chance between india Pakistan
After all a Pakistani is a Pakistani.
Yes we accept India as big brother but big brother is always not at vintage position in some cases Big brother has to become a punching bag. Does India like to become big brother- a punching bag?
As per Arabi political ideology book Quran, believers can not have nonbelievers as his brother, father and friends.
Arabi political ideology book Quran divides humanity into believer and nonbelievers (kafir).
Muslim can not have anyone not following this Arabi political ideology book Quran as his brothers.
Wuran is a book that damages blood relation based on their faith. Therefore you are Arabi ZEHNI GHULAM
What is the use of this nonsense talk, if you can't change anything in your own country.That's why people become angry from people like these even Ishtiyaq Ahmed gets a lot of heat. Useless people whose only agenda is to sell books.
سچ بات یہ ہے کہ ہم نے کشمیر خود کھودیا سچ بات یہ ہے کہ ہم نے باقی ماندہ وجودبھی کھو دیا ہے
India and pakistan are two sovereign countries and should try to resolve their dispute without the shadow of the division of united india, considering each other point of view.
100%. That is the mature way to move forward for mutual benefit and harmony. The question is whether the pak army allows that to happen. I think with Trump coming to power next year, the funds tap to pak army will turn off even more and their control over pak reduced. We want a soft border. I want to visit sites in pak, you want to visit india. We want trade flow as well.
* Kashmir Kashmir ,you lot couldn't look after what you got, you would have ruin the Kashmir*
Pak should get out Pok ASAP🇮🇳🇮🇳
جناح جمہوری تھے شیخ عبداللہ کو نصیحت کی تارا سنگھ کے پاس گیے اسے نصیحت کی ۔کیا یہ سب اقدام کور ایشو پر توجہ نہں کہلاتے لیکن سازش جیتی آج کشمیری اور سکھ جن مشکلات کا شکار ھیں اسمیں ان نام نہاد لیڈروں کا حصہ ھے
Ishtiaq ji you are telling mistakes 3 and 7 of India and Pakistan , which are those 3 mistake of India please describe .
Thank you sir.
Elder brother also slaps younger brother in case of mischief and the younger brother behaves properly and doesn't hit back elder younger. So start behaving like a younger brother.
Convert Ghumman 😂😂 has to be in Pakstan so firstly says "dono taraf" (chronic prob of false equivalence in Pak) then he says 70:30 mistake ratio is "point of view" 😂😂😂
Know pok is coming un development pak good for India 🇮🇳
Mr Akmal doesn't wants listen
Faults and mischievous of Pakistan whole country is like that only
Mohammed Ali Jinah Kabhi jail nahi gaya Puri Azadi ki Ladai ko sabotage ker dia
घुम्मन पंजाबी जाट
Bharat me musalman reh sakte the toh batwara kyun Kiya,
Batwara ho hi gaya hai toh Bharat mein musalman kyun hai.
What are you going to do about it?
@@arifsaleem5467 Ghar Vapsi hogi
@@karolbagh3793
Ghar wapsi to tumhari bhi honi chahiye, 4th and 5th century AD main Tum sab bhi to Buddhism chhorr ker saanp baander haathi chuhe poojne lage the, Buddhist temples ko mandir bana Dala, Buddha ke statues ko new devi devta main convert Kiya, later central Asian rulers labeled hundreds of your different local religions Hindu for their own convenience.
@@karolbagh3793
Hinduism is nothing but a convenient word for Muslim kings who captured and ruled India, to sum up hundreds of nonsensical religions practiced among locals.
@@arifsaleem5467aap kyon Arabi ZEHNI GHULAM ban gaye.
Arabi Allah, Arabi rasool, Arabi hadith, Arabi Quran, Arabi sahaba, Arabi ajaan, Arabi treaty Arabi tareekh, Arabi battle. Sab juch arabi. Apna kuch bhi nahi.
You even can not do ibadat in hindi or Urdu since Arabi Allah does not understand hindi or Urdu.
Come back to Hinduism. You are not arab or turk. Why adopted a false/artificial identity?
Musalti one side thinking England mai kya ho Raha hai
Kashmir kashmiriyoo nay khud lerr ker Azad Kiya thaa Pakistan nay Jang nahi larriii
O bahi Pakistan NY Kashmir k liy 4jangain lri Jo Kashmir ha wo Pakistan ki wja sy Azad hoa ni to Indian army k zulm ap b brdast krty
Kashmir ka chapa chapa ksmiri bahiyon ka ha or sary kashmiri bahi Pakistani Hain or Kashmir Pakistan ki sehrag ha
Inshallah
اشتیاق احمد صاحب کی بات سے کچھ حد تک سہمت نہیں ہیں ۔
جناح صاحب بہت دور اندیش شخصیت تھے ۔ حیدراباد دکن کے نظام کو جو مشورہ دیا تھا وہ بہت بہترین تھا۔
جھوناگڑھ کے بدلے کشمیر لینا چاہئے تھا۔
حیدراباددکن کے بدلے مشرقی پاکستان کے شمال اور مشرق میں انڈیا کے اسام اور متصل ریاستیں ھندو اقلیتی ابادی کا ایک بڑا صوبہ اسام تھا ۔ اس کو چین انڈیا کی جنگ میں شامل ھوکر فوجی طاقت سے حاصل کیا جا سکتا تھا ۔ برما کا اراکان مسلم علاقہ بھی شامل ھوتا۔
اگر اس علاقے میں ریفرنڈم ھوتا تو کبھی بھی ھند کی سپورٹ نہیں ھوتی ۔ مسلم ابادی 35%, کرسچن 12%, بدھ 8% دیگر 02% تھے ۔ ھندو 40% تھے ۔
مشرقی و مغربی پاکستان ایک طاقت سے انڈیا کے دونوں اطراف موجود ھوتے ..
جناح صاحب کی نظر افغان پر بھی تھی ۔ بھوٹان اور انڈیا کی طرح افغان بھی پاکستان کا دفاعی نظام مارکیٹ اور کرنسی ایک ھوتی ۔
اج کا پاکستان 65 کروڑ ابادی کا طاقتور دیش ھوتا۔
ڈاکٹر اشتیاق احمد کی یہ بات درست ہے کہ لیاقت علی خان سے لیکر بعد کی ڈکٹیٹر شپ والی قیادت نے سیاسی فیصلے کرنے میں بہت غلطیاں کیں جس کا خمیازہ بھگتنا پڑ رھا ہے ۔
Jinnah k followers jinnah per phd nhi kr skthe mashallah jinnah azim leader haha haha
Ghumman, a convert, lost person. Living an immoral life. How do these people, look in the mirror?
You guys also converted from Buddhism to assorted idol worship of different animals and imaginary figures as recently as the 4th or 5th century AD, few more centuries later hundreds of those religions was collectively labeled as Hinduism by invader kings from central Asia for their own convenience, you may check with the science journey channel for more details.
@RS… : yeh woh bezameer loge hain jinhennAllah SWT mirror mein khud ko dekhne ki taufiq nahi deta! Hope you understand this much Urdu/Hindi!
Big Brother ???
Joke
Jinah sahib considered the kashmir ,the bearer cheque or ripe fruit .Astagfiruulah
1947 me kaha se Azad Kashmir aaya Professor saab....????