Retcon Wars: Who Owns The Story - Harry Potter

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 янв 2025

Комментарии • 4

  • @deadcell66
    @deadcell66 7 дней назад +3

    The Cursed Child is as cannon as any fan fiction written by any random person. Rowling just okay'ed it, she didn't write it.

  • @slamtilt01
    @slamtilt01 6 дней назад

    The Wizarding World is Jo Rowlings creation. It is a world she created. In saying that. Fans are only too happy to show their love for her work, by creating their own unique stories that use the Wizarding World’s story elements.

  • @Tsukasa829
    @Tsukasa829 7 дней назад

    Firmly in the "author controls canon" camp. I always thought Rowling rectonning her own story was weird and just done for attention. I can't write a fan fiction, no matter how popular, and have it count as official lore.

  • @ltGargoyle
    @ltGargoyle 7 дней назад

    JK rowling own the IP. its her stories to tell. I did not read the cursed child or the fantastic beast, i do not follow her retcons or potter world stuff where she says this or that about the characters. like how Dumbledore was gay. I do not care, the books were written through harrys eyes, and he should not have known about Dumbledores sexuality as his student.
    its her stories. what started as me reading to my son gave me lasting memories. i loved the books. enjoyed the movies. but that story was told and i did not need to carry on with it. there were plot holes and things that just dont work if you look at the world building with any sense. but to a child or a person who is just enjoying the story for what it was 7 books building on what was written before the current one its fun. think time turners. We could have saved the potters with one of those.