Thank you Tom, Blue15bomber and Viola. I'm so happy that I got to make this! THIS is how I wanted Edward and James in CGI and I'm so happy to have finally made it!!
@@ThomasTheorist Ah, OK. Well, if it was Old Slow Coach, it's cool to see her in Tracks to Big Adventures and I hope we can see more of her in the future. However, I hope you don't mind me saying this, but I believe Old Slow Coach would be perfect with Emily and her coaches, especially after watching MH1994's video, The Missing Coaches. Until then, take care and keep up the good work!
You gotta admire James’s determination to get this train delivered. Despite getting dirtier, James still kept going and even asked for help when he was defeated. That’s the best James story I’ve seen in a long time! The ending had me touched too. I give this a full on 10/10! 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😄
I really enjoyed this episode! I cracked up at the 'Jedward' jokes, I like how there's an old-shaped Henry easter egg in the background, and I like how James' character was written in this, as well as his dynamic with Edward. The message he gave to Gordon about being a branch line engine and the latter deep inside fully respected that is just so wholesome. Dependable, reliable, we all know James is great! Also, it is surprising to see Gordon let out of his shed. Maybe he apologized to Mr. Percival off-screen, so he was allowed to pull the express again alongside Rebecca part-time.
Gordon, James and Henry may have had their share of arrogant moments, but they are not the same character at all. Henry has a fascination for nature, James enjoys simple work, even if he finds good annoying and Gordon deep down cares about his friends and would do anything for them.
Legitimately one of the best if not THE best James story in the whole damn fandom, you don’t know how refreshing it is to see a James story, fandom or official, where James A. ISN’T an awful jerk throughout B. actually comes out on top in the end, instead of the typical “James gets taken down a peg and everybody laughs at him” ending!
This feels like the end that James never got for his character arc. This honestly feels like he has been humbled in a sense. He started out mimicking Gordon and thinking that mainline engines were everything, but ended coming to the conclusion that he is really a branch line engine. Along with that it feels like the type of episode that might actually be in the railway or the tv series. This was really great and I love seeing this side of James that I personally have never seen.
I feel like this is genuinely challenging the actual Thomas and friends series in quality and story. The only think that might make it better is if the faces actually were animated, but I honestly think the facial expressions are better because it brings a bit of nostalgia to it. (for me at least) This was incredible to watch and I can't wait to see more, the dynamic between James and Edward was amazing!!
That was a brilliant episode. James having a day where he thinks he can do things without help. But then he sticks up for Edward and understands how useful he is and how Edward should be more appreciated. I was surprised at the last bit at the end 🙂.
I love this series as it feels like a continuation after season 24 of the CGI series. but with more original writing and better storytelling for older fans like me!! Keep up the great work there ThomasFan2002!!
Since James is my absolute favourite, this is the best portrayal I haven seen so far! Absolutely love how he stands up for Edward, very well made amazing video. This gives his character a lot more depth than any of the new series ever can, the character development took a huge step with this and gives us an idea how he really feels inside.
I loved this episode because James wanted to be a branch line engine and gave a speech to everyone at Tidmouth Sheds about having different roles to play on the railway and Gordon gave a smile about that, and Edward helping James pull a heavy goods train to Barrow in his red undercoat is a reference to Henry Sees Red when Henry helps with the Express.
The way he delivered his speech had a lot of “coming out” vibes to it; which can be relatable to a lot of people. I enjoyed it very much and I think I speak for all of us when I say that the Rev. W. Awdry would be extremely proud of this moment 😇
15:27 Now this is the best character development of James ever. The themes here and flashbacks are perfect. Now this is an episode we have missed of years. Really good my man.
This was a very good episode. It's nice to see James and Edward working together again (for the first time in years) and I was ecstatic to see BoCo again! Plus, I like that James was willing to take the goods train despite his paintwork being ruined and that he stood up for Edward, which shows quite a bit of growth on his part.
This is one of my most favorite episodes by far. It really paints James in a better light than the CGI series did. While James still has an attitude, he works hard even if he’s dirty, but he also knows when to ask for help. I’d love to see more Edward/James episodes!
This was such a good story!! I really like the dynamic between Edward and James because it shows how good of friends they are, despite the disagreements they had in the past. The Jedward joke was also a treat, given how funny it is. Plus, I like how the size difference is shown between the two engines; Basically Edward being smaller then James, as stated in canon. I think that's because either I've missed it in what TTTE content I've seen, or It's really not shown and it's hard to tell who's smaller. Anyway, Great job and I can't wait to see what episode is next! :D
I'll admit I am not a huge fan of James. But this episode really brought out the best in him. And seeing the dynamic between him and Edward is an amazing development for their characters. And seeing Gordon at the end smile at the end shows that he is happy and proud of James. Not that he'll ever admit it out loud.
One of the few great things from the HiT era was how James and Edward eventually became partners. This episode brought that aspect back in such a beautiful way. Bravo!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Possibly some of if not the best Thomas-related media to ever enter our world. I actually prefer this to the Classic Era, specifically for the more drawn-out and hard-hitting character growth arcs and the sense of adventure in Thomas' side of the story as a neat little way to break the tension.
D'aww, that was really touching, especially James and Edward's heart to heart at the end. :) Also nice to see Gordon ultimately be happy for James' decision in the end. I wonder how James is gonna take to branch line work, or how not having him on the mainline is gonna affect work there. 👀 🤔 And Boco! A mainline engine goes back to the branch, and a branch line diesel goes on the mainline; perfectly balanced as all things should be. Haha ⚖️ Pleasent surprise to see 'Redward' too, I don't think I've seen that outside of Victor Tanzing's vids.
y'know, seeing james finally growing as a character and being less self obsorved after so many years of him being so egotistical, is honestly sooo good and so heartwarming. honestly this was probably the best way to end james character arc that i've ever seen, so glad you could deliver something that so many still haven't done yet, thank you so much. 😊😊
1 thing I often missed from the cgi era was seeing James & Edward together. While I do dislike the Hit model era these days, 1 thing I really enjoyed was seeing the two of them team up and work together as it was a common thing in that era compared to the classic era. A fine job indeed, and a very great episode I didn't expect to enjoy. Well Done!
God do I wish this was the real continuity this series has been so good also I love that it's tied back to the adventure begins aswell love it love it love it
Im in love with this episode! I always liked the thought of james being on a branch and now its finally true. (hopefully its going to improve his attitude).
This truly feels like a culmination of James' character development. I remember watching The Unlucky Tug's "Sodor's Finest" video on James, where he was described as an engine whose high opinion of himself lead him to see himself as on par with Gordon, an express mainline engine, even though James himself was just a medium mixed-traffic engine - i.e. a poser with a bit of a Napoleon complex. It also mentioned how James's relationship with Edward evolved - at first, James felt emasculated by Edward and tried to one-up him before gaining his respect and seeing him as a peer. Here, we see the endpoint of that journey. Here, James is finally able to put his work before his paintwork, he's willing to accept who is, and he is nothing but caring and considerate towards Edward - a true friend. James has come along way from where he started. He's a much older and wiser engine now - almost a bit like Edward. But he'll always be our James. This series is just wonderful at showing the characters at the end of their journeys - Gordon passing the Express baton to Rebecca after making sense of a fast-changing world, Henry pulling off his most heroic feat before gracefully retiring to Vicarstown, and now this. Thank you. These are the Thomas stories we never knew we needed.
James will also still be vain because that's the kind of engine he is. Gordon still pulls the express but shares it with Rebecca. The Fat Controller never said that he'II step down from it.
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 I didn’t say that James wouldn’t still be vain. I just meant he’s more mature than he used to be. And the fact that Gordon is willing to share the Express regularly marks a huge shift in character - I mean, he loves the Express like a father loves his son, and is just as protective of it.
Wow I’ve always wanted someone to atleast do something like this with James and here it is u did ! Like I love this episode really good like fr also yey James is James and yey he’s a branch line guy! And omg Gordon with that smile indeed he has grown 😅
Well, I gotta say, that was really good. James keep working, the Brendam project and Edward helping him in his new red coat. I'm a bit surprised at James becoming a branch line engine in the end. Main line suits him and he doesn't think fondly of branch lines any more. Hopefully his vainty is still mantained regardless of his development.
Hmm, well that's a unique voice for James. Makes a nice change to be honest. Kinda gives me Starscream vibes, which i find amusing as i always seem to do a Starscream impression when doing a James voice.
I think this has to be my favorite episode so far, I love James’ character development and I love the callbacks to the RWS/TVS recreations. James thinking he could pull the train himself and having to except Edward’ help, (side note I love the S8 theme recreation that was nice) and then there’s the scene where James sticks up for Edward and tells the worker to basically piss off. I also love James’ speech about how it’s ok to be a engine from the mainline, branchline, or other was pretty deep for James as well as the contrast of Edward and James’ paint and their personalities clashing and the BoCo and old slow coach cameos are ones I didn’t expect but am glad it did and I think I saw Henry’ old shape if I’m correct. I know I keep saying this but it’s really going to be hard to choose my favorite episode
James grew so much, and finally he gets his branchline work. In Sodor's finest, Mr. The unlucky tug was said "James and Edward is an equal partner.". And man, this episode is prove it. Just like season1, 2, 10, and 20, James and Edward was an equal partner. What a wonderful episode! 👍
Fantastic. Loved how James wanting a branch line is touched upon again. It has me reflecting on "Journey Beyond Sodor." James should have been pleased to be running Thomas' branch line. After all, he was even doing his favorite job - pulling passengers. A missed opportunity in JBS to touch upon it again. Thank you for taking it on.
I just love this episode on like James is being like a grumpy and showoff Engine but now here he seems changed and moved on to something new to help others and Redeemed himself.
Very nice episode as always Thomasfan2002. It is very nice to see that James is finally now working on a branchline which he always wanted to do back from the movie The Adventure Begins but this time he is working with Edward. Plus, it is also very nice to see that Boco is staying on Sodor for good.
This episode teaches the lesson of no matter what role you have you need to play that part and j am glad that this episode develops james' character and that he grows from tad conceited and very vain to a lovable branch line engine
That was the most brilliant amazing James story I’ve ever watched!! This is how James should have been handled then in the BWBA version!! The dynamic between him and Edward is truly spectacular and the ending where James chooses to be a branch line engine was beautiful!! Bravo once again to the team behind TTBA!! 😃😃😃
This is genius. I’ve seen some people complain about how James is not “James” in this episode, but I disagree. This is still the James we know and love. However, he’s also not the typical James we are used to. That’s because he’s now grown as a character. How many times did we see James get into trouble in result of him ignoring advices? Too many times. This changes everything. This episode is the payoff to all those stories teaching James to listen to others. He finally learns that he is not perfect and “Splendid” as he comes out to be, and that he needs someone to guide him into the right direction, who is Edward. The visual of Edward being red and James being blue is just brilliant. It shows that James has now matured, like Edward. At the beginning of the episode, when he gets covered with blue paint, he’s the typical James we know, complaining about his appearance. However, at the end of the episode, he doesn’t care anymore. Because he’s just appreciating Edward’s help, and is now saying HIMSELF that the appearances doesn’t matter as long as they are really useful. And at the end of the episode, James is now LEAVING the “Three Big Engines,” and is now joining the Edward’s branch line gang. On itself, it’s a very nice story. But that’s not all. Going back to the “Three Big Engines,” it seems like each of them are getting a nice ending to themselves. Henry started as the sickest and the most pathetic engine, and in this series, he becomes a absolute chad and does the legendary “Super Rescue”. James started as a character that only thinks about himself and thinks he is the best. However, in this episode, he finally learns to listen and admit that he is not perfect, and that he needs a guide. And now it seems like Gordon is the only one of the “Three Big Engines” left to get a nice, happy ending to his important part of life. The “Three Big Engines,” the engines who always thought they were above others, are finally maturing, and are now getting ready to open a new chapter of their lives…
Outstanding work, wow! :D I love the moral of the story and the improvements that have been made to the characters, scenery, music and each episode that you upload!!
Well, bud, after watching your latest episode of Tracks to Big Adventures, I have to say that this was another great episode you put together and the story was also great as well, starting with the flashback to The Adventure Beings when James went off the rails and got his red paint, but lost Annie and Clarabel as well as his branch line to Thomas and James then arrives to Wellsworth, surprising Edward and Nia, who was being told how James got his red paint, to which James then says that Mr. Percival has asked him to help with the refurbishment at Brendam Docks and Nia asks Edward if he could take her passengers, but James reminds Nia that Edward's going to the Steamworks and Nia takes her passengers instead. However, the next day, when James picks up the goods train, Carly drops the blue paint on James and he feels embarrassed, but when he realizes he can't pull the heavy train by himself, he refuses help from Boco and Nia before he crashes into some stone trucks at Whiff's Waste Dump and when he comes to a stop at a function as Stanley arrives with his passenger train, he finally goes to the Steamworks and asks Edward, whose boiler is painted red, for his help in getting the train to the mainland, to which Edward does and they both pull the train to the mainland, but when they arrive, the yard manager goes off on Edward and James defends Edward by saying that he's a really useful engine to which as they head back to Sodor, Edward asks James if he would like to help on Edward's branch line and while James says he's a mainline engine, he's trying his best not to admit he would like to work with Edward, Nia and Boco on the branch line, but when they arrive back at Tidmouth Sheds, after James talks to Mr. Percival, Mr. Percival then announces that James will be helping out with the new extension to Brendam, thus becoming one of the main engines to run the extension and when Gordon says that a mainline engine working on the branch line is pathetic, James proudly says that he's a branch line engine while also reminding everyone to be thankful for the jobs you have, such as Percy pulling the mail train, Gordon with the Express and Thomas and Edward with their branch lines and as James leaves, Gordon smiles while James thanks Edward for always helping everyone even though no one appreciates it, to which Edward then tells James that he could have taken Nia's passengers, stayed at the Steamworks and taken the abuse from the yard manager, but he didn't because of James and after Edward tells James he doesn't like conflict, James just says that he was just being James. Basically, Edward and James have that big brother-little brother dynamic with Edward playing the role of big brother and James as the little brother. Also, before I forget, was that Old Slow Coach Nia was pulling when she took her passengers to the zoo? And do you know what happened to your Change of Pace video? All-in-all, in the end, that was another great episode you put together for Tracks to Big Adventures and I look forward to seeing what you have planned next as well as seeing how well Edward, James, Nia and Boco do all working together on Edward's branch line, so until then, keep up the good work, bud!
This is a fantastic story, a great adaptation. This really shows the true personality about James, it's almost like it's his finale episode for some reason. Fantastic job on the video.
All of this character development... it's insane. Toby retiring to Ulfstead Castle, Daisy returning to Ffarquhar and James working on Edward's Branch Line? It's written in a way that makes fair amounts of sense, unlike what Mattel did. And I am *HERE...* for it.
Can I just say one thing... THIS SERIES IS FUCKING GORGEOUS!! Seriously, this is soooooo much better than BWBA 😭 How Thomas actually ends up going on a world tour with Sir Topham Hat instead of by himself, how Rebecca is actually a character I feel like I can root for, how everyone from the show actually shows emotion when Thomas leaves, how the characters actually FEEL like the characters we all know and love, especially Gordon, you got him so right in this series, the actual fan service with every old character eventually returning and having an influence on the plot in each episode; I just can't believe how much I'm loving every single episode I watch and I will stay tuned for more to come!! ❤️❤️
The characters actually FEEL like the characters we all know and love in the Brenner era mostly since they return to their original characters from Series 17 onwards thanks to Andrew.
You and everyone else involved with this are amazing! I don’t think BWBA was the worst thing in TTTE, but this is Definitely a big improvement! Kudos to you.
As much as i love gay couples, i do have to agree with the replies on this one. I have never seen them and will never see them as a couple. They're more like brothers to me...
This is quite a character study of James the red engine and him questioning quite profoundly how does he really want to feel important/useful. It was pretty neat taking and possibly expanding upon his desire to have a branch line from the adventure begins; then resenting Thomas for earning his branch line. Quite an imagined character arc for James where he finally stands up to Gordon instead of trying to match him all the time; while recognizing the friend he has in kind Edward.
Thank you Tom, Blue15bomber and Viola.
I'm so happy that I got to make this! THIS is how I wanted Edward and James in CGI and I'm so happy to have finally made it!!
Hey, bud. I don't know if it was or not, but was Nia pulling Old Slow Coach when she dropped off her passengers at the zoo?
@@curtisblevins1462 🤔
@@ThomasTheorist Ah, OK. Well, if it was Old Slow Coach, it's cool to see her in Tracks to Big Adventures and I hope we can see more of her in the future. However, I hope you don't mind me saying this, but I believe Old Slow Coach would be perfect with Emily and her coaches, especially after watching MH1994's video, The Missing Coaches. Until then, take care and keep up the good work!
This would be a perfect episode for the revival era.
All In Vain already covers it.
The look of pride on Gordon’s face at seeing James stand up for himself and other was so touching!
“Gordon knew what James meant by being proud to be a branch line engine.
Deep down, he agreed.”
Being James is definitely the most James thing in the world. I mean, there’s so much James
I'm just surprised James wants to be blue just because Edward is given a coat of red paint.
Especially with his vanity.
You gotta admire James’s determination to get this train delivered. Despite getting dirtier, James still kept going and even asked for help when he was defeated. That’s the best James story I’ve seen in a long time! The ending had me touched too. I give this a full on 10/10! 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😄
Well said man.
The way James stood up for Edward is so heartwarming.
It is indeed that yard manager was rude but after getting a bigger scolding from James I think he reflected on multiple things
Yes indeed🥰
Yep. Thats the james i know and love
Facts
I really enjoyed this episode! I cracked up at the 'Jedward' jokes, I like how there's an old-shaped Henry easter egg in the background, and I like how James' character was written in this, as well as his dynamic with Edward. The message he gave to Gordon about being a branch line engine and the latter deep inside fully respected that is just so wholesome. Dependable, reliable, we all know James is great!
Also, it is surprising to see Gordon let out of his shed. Maybe he apologized to Mr. Percival off-screen, so he was allowed to pull the express again alongside Rebecca part-time.
Writing this episode was crazy, but I'm glad we've managed to make it work. Huge thanks to Thomastheorist and Violarules!
I really like how it turned out
And this, is how you write character development. I know I’m late, but bravo.
He’s a really splendid engine. That’s our James.
I like how their colors are reversed by the end, Edward's front is red and James's is blue, very nice touch!
Gordon, James and Henry may have had their share of arrogant moments, but they are not the same character at all. Henry has a fascination for nature, James enjoys simple work, even if he finds good annoying and Gordon deep down cares about his friends and would do anything for them.
Legitimately one of the best if not THE best James story in the whole damn fandom, you don’t know how refreshing it is to see a James story, fandom or official, where James
A. ISN’T an awful jerk throughout
B. actually comes out on top in the end, instead of the typical “James gets taken down a peg and everybody laughs at him” ending!
This is James’ best episode in any era FOR ALL TIME, my hats off to whoever wrote it.
Aww thanks!
This feels like the end that James never got for his character arc. This honestly feels like he has been humbled in a sense. He started out mimicking Gordon and thinking that mainline engines were everything, but ended coming to the conclusion that he is really a branch line engine. Along with that it feels like the type of episode that might actually be in the railway or the tv series. This was really great and I love seeing this side of James that I personally have never seen.
This should have been James's arc in the book series.
And how! Awdry would’ve been proud 😊
I feel like this is genuinely challenging the actual Thomas and friends series in quality and story. The only think that might make it better is if the faces actually were animated, but I honestly think the facial expressions are better because it brings a bit of nostalgia to it. (for me at least) This was incredible to watch and I can't wait to see more, the dynamic between James and Edward was amazing!!
I love this!😁
Nice callbacks to The Adventure Begins and James and the Coaches!
This is what should have happened in the show!
That was a brilliant episode. James having a day where he thinks he can do things without help. But then he sticks up for Edward and understands how useful he is and how Edward should be more appreciated. I was surprised at the last bit at the end 🙂.
Me too
I found it very interesting how the yard master didn't realise that Edward originally comes from the Furness railway and was painted red
@@eliotreader8220 maybe he's a diff yard master. From a long time ago
Same
I love this series as it feels like a continuation after season 24 of the CGI series. but with more original writing and better storytelling for older fans like me!!
Keep up the great work there ThomasFan2002!!
I love that James finally fulfills his dream of running a branchline
Godspeed to that beautiful red engine
Since James is my absolute favourite, this is the best portrayal I haven seen so far! Absolutely love how he stands up for Edward, very well made amazing video. This gives his character a lot more depth than any of the new series ever can, the character development took a huge step with this and gives us an idea how he really feels inside.
I loved this episode because James wanted to be a branch line engine and gave a speech to everyone at Tidmouth Sheds about having different roles to play on the railway and Gordon gave a smile about that, and Edward helping James pull a heavy goods train to Barrow in his red undercoat is a reference to Henry Sees Red when Henry helps with the Express.
Indeed
And because James is blue and Edward is red
The way he delivered his speech had a lot of “coming out” vibes to it; which can be relatable to a lot of people. I enjoyed it very much and I think I speak for all of us when I say that the Rev. W. Awdry would be extremely proud of this moment 😇
15:27 Now this is the best character development of James ever. The themes here and flashbacks are perfect. Now this is an episode we have missed of years. Really good my man.
This was a very good episode. It's nice to see James and Edward working together again (for the first time in years) and I was ecstatic to see BoCo again! Plus, I like that James was willing to take the goods train despite his paintwork being ruined and that he stood up for Edward, which shows quite a bit of growth on his part.
Not only is James still in character but has a big character development
Quite the nice world building episode this is. Feels like great closure for James and a realistic direction for him an old steam engine
This is one of my most favorite episodes by far. It really paints James in a better light than the CGI series did. While James still has an attitude, he works hard even if he’s dirty, but he also knows when to ask for help. I’d love to see more Edward/James episodes!
Am I allowed to cry...? This story touched me. Truly a beautiful story for our splendid red engine, James.
As a HUGE james fan, this is the best episode you've made yet !
This was such a good story!! I really like the dynamic between Edward and James because it shows how good of friends they are, despite the disagreements they had in the past. The Jedward joke was also a treat, given how funny it is. Plus, I like how the size difference is shown between the two engines; Basically Edward being smaller then James, as stated in canon. I think that's because either I've missed it in what TTTE content I've seen, or It's really not shown and it's hard to tell who's smaller. Anyway, Great job and I can't wait to see what episode is next! :D
I'll admit I am not a huge fan of James. But this episode really brought out the best in him. And seeing the dynamic between him and Edward is an amazing development for their characters. And seeing Gordon at the end smile at the end shows that he is happy and proud of James. Not that he'll ever admit it out loud.
This is definitely something that would belong in the Railway Series. And I was not disappointed!
This is the most beautiful series I have ever seen this dude should have been hired as writer
I like how this episode feels like a rewrite of the S11 episode Dirty Work and S20 All in Vain meshed into one.
@Tim Jones Or Dirty Objects with James breaking two tar wagons.
Love how James of all engines sticks up for Edward when he was being insulted by that rude Foreman on the mainland
One of the few great things from the HiT era was how James and Edward eventually became partners. This episode brought that aspect back in such a beautiful way. Bravo!!
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Now I fully watched it, I can say that this is peak TTBA visually and storywise. Splendid job on the episode man. I really liked it
Possibly some of if not the best Thomas-related media to ever enter our world. I actually prefer this to the Classic Era, specifically for the more drawn-out and hard-hitting character growth arcs and the sense of adventure in Thomas' side of the story as a neat little way to break the tension.
D'aww, that was really touching, especially James and Edward's heart to heart at the end. :) Also nice to see Gordon ultimately be happy for James' decision in the end.
I wonder how James is gonna take to branch line work, or how not having him on the mainline is gonna affect work there. 👀 🤔
And Boco! A mainline engine goes back to the branch, and a branch line diesel goes on the mainline; perfectly balanced as all things should be. Haha ⚖️
Pleasent surprise to see 'Redward' too, I don't think I've seen that outside of Victor Tanzing's vids.
This is going to be epic Thomasfan2002. I cannot wait for the new episode of Tracks To Big Adventures.
By far my favorite episode of this series of yours. Jedward feels tbh, and this is the James character development we deserve!!!
Excellent story! Had so many heart touching moments in it too.
y'know, seeing james finally growing as a character and being less self obsorved after so many years of him being so egotistical, is honestly sooo good and so heartwarming.
honestly this was probably the best way to end james character arc that i've ever seen, so glad you could deliver something that so many still haven't done yet, thank you so much. 😊😊
This an awesome James episode, & the James & Edward dynamic just gets better & better
That was so amazing! I really loved James’ character development!
1 thing I often missed from the cgi era was seeing James & Edward together. While I do dislike the Hit model era these days, 1 thing I really enjoyed was seeing the two of them team up and work together as it was a common thing in that era compared to the classic era. A fine job indeed, and a very great episode I didn't expect to enjoy. Well Done!
I love James' voice in this. Whoever voices him would be perfect for my series.
Rebecca is going to kill Gordon whenever he said
a mainline engine running on a branch line
Mainly because that’s what her class was designed to do-
God do I wish this was the real continuity this series has been so good also I love that it's tied back to the adventure begins aswell love it love it love it
"On a scale of 1 to 10 how bad does it hurt?"
"Eleven..."
👏😂
Im in love with this episode! I always liked the thought of james being on a branch and now its finally true. (hopefully its going to improve his attitude).
That may be so but his main trait will always be around. Some things never change you know. Wait and see I suppose.
This truly feels like a culmination of James' character development. I remember watching The Unlucky Tug's "Sodor's Finest" video on James, where he was described as an engine whose high opinion of himself lead him to see himself as on par with Gordon, an express mainline engine, even though James himself was just a medium mixed-traffic engine - i.e. a poser with a bit of a Napoleon complex. It also mentioned how James's relationship with Edward evolved - at first, James felt emasculated by Edward and tried to one-up him before gaining his respect and seeing him as a peer. Here, we see the endpoint of that journey. Here, James is finally able to put his work before his paintwork, he's willing to accept who is, and he is nothing but caring and considerate towards Edward - a true friend. James has come along way from where he started. He's a much older and wiser engine now - almost a bit like Edward. But he'll always be our James.
This series is just wonderful at showing the characters at the end of their journeys - Gordon passing the Express baton to Rebecca after making sense of a fast-changing world, Henry pulling off his most heroic feat before gracefully retiring to Vicarstown, and now this.
Thank you. These are the Thomas stories we never knew we needed.
James will also still be vain because that's the kind of engine he is. Gordon still pulls the express but shares it with Rebecca. The Fat Controller never said that he'II step down from it.
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 I didn’t say that James wouldn’t still be vain. I just meant he’s more mature than he used to be. And the fact that Gordon is willing to share the Express regularly marks a huge shift in character - I mean, he loves the Express like a father loves his son, and is just as protective of it.
@@williamjeffries5074 Glad to hear some assurance. How to keep development despite mantaining traits in later episodes is a question of how.
Wow I’ve always wanted someone to atleast do something like this with James and here it is u did ! Like I love this episode really good like fr also yey James is James and yey he’s a branch line guy! And omg Gordon with that smile indeed he has grown 😅
Well, I gotta say, that was really good. James keep working, the Brendam project and Edward helping him in his new red coat. I'm a bit surprised at James becoming a branch line engine in the end. Main line suits him and he doesn't think fondly of branch lines any more. Hopefully his vainty is still mantained regardless of his development.
What a truly beautiful episode that was perfect for James' character development
Hmm, well that's a unique voice for James.
Makes a nice change to be honest.
Kinda gives me Starscream vibes, which i find amusing as i always seem to do a Starscream impression when doing a James voice.
I believe Piece of Jakey VA voiced James in this.
Great work again my guy! Love the creativity here!
I think this has to be my favorite episode so far, I love James’ character development and I love the callbacks to the RWS/TVS recreations. James thinking he could pull the train himself and having to except Edward’ help, (side note I love the S8 theme recreation that was nice) and then there’s the scene where James sticks up for Edward and tells the worker to basically piss off. I also love James’ speech about how it’s ok to be a engine from the mainline, branchline, or other was pretty deep for James as well as the contrast of Edward and James’ paint and their personalities clashing and the BoCo and old slow coach cameos are ones I didn’t expect but am glad it did and I think I saw Henry’ old shape if I’m correct. I know I keep saying this but it’s really going to be hard to choose my favorite episode
Wow. I never thought I'd be laughing to Edward dropping the F-bomb. Brilliant.
This is a wonderful.
James grew so much, and finally he gets his branchline work. In Sodor's finest, Mr. The unlucky tug was said "James and Edward is an equal partner.". And man, this episode is prove it. Just like season1, 2, 10, and 20, James and Edward was an equal partner.
What a wonderful episode! 👍
Absolutely Stunning episode. James’s character development was amazing.
Fantastic. Loved how James wanting a branch line is touched upon again. It has me reflecting on "Journey Beyond Sodor." James should have been pleased to be running Thomas' branch line. After all, he was even doing his favorite job - pulling passengers. A missed opportunity in JBS to touch upon it again. Thank you for taking it on.
This episode feels like a combination but with Pouty James and Henry's sees red
Wow now this is what I truly believe James' character is I love this interpretation you guys did such an amazing job
I just love this episode on like James is being like a grumpy and showoff Engine but now here he seems changed and moved on to something new to help others and Redeemed himself.
I like it when James defended Edward after the Yard Manager bad mouthed about poor Edward like that.
When has James never stowed away from being James! 😂 no for real though this was a fun episode
Very nice episode as always Thomasfan2002. It is very nice to see that James is finally now working on a branchline which he always wanted to do back from the movie The Adventure Begins but this time he is working with Edward. Plus, it is also very nice to see that Boco is staying on Sodor for good.
You never let us down Tom.
Don’t let COPPA stop you from making these amazing videos. You always have our support.
I think I can tell how this will go between Wise Edward and Vainful James.
The way when they are at Barrow Edward says Like "good bye :)" and James is like "U RUDE PERSON >:( "
This episode looks amazing. James and Edward swap colors. And Gordon is allowed out of the sheds.
This is everything I wanted to see from a James episode. He went from tipical James to becoming wise, self determined and responsible like Edward
This episode teaches the lesson of no matter what role you have you need to play that part and j am glad that this episode develops james' character and that he grows from tad conceited and very vain to a lovable branch line engine
Then he wouldn't be himself without vain any more.
I can't wait for this episode! Maybe James will finally meet Nia?
😀
Who’s that coming down the track make way for James hooray for James!
Knowing James always the showing off, when I guess this is what happen when Thomas is away
Good gracious - Gordon smiling!
That was the most brilliant amazing James story I’ve ever watched!! This is how James should have been handled then in the BWBA version!! The dynamic between him and Edward is truly spectacular and the ending where James chooses to be a branch line engine was beautiful!! Bravo once again to the team behind TTBA!! 😃😃😃
James' appearances in Series 23 and Series 24 are fine.
This is genius. I’ve seen some people complain about how James is not “James” in this episode, but I disagree. This is still the James we know and love. However, he’s also not the typical James we are used to. That’s because he’s now grown as a character. How many times did we see James get into trouble in result of him ignoring advices? Too many times. This changes everything. This episode is the payoff to all those stories teaching James to listen to others. He finally learns that he is not perfect and “Splendid” as he comes out to be, and that he needs someone to guide him into the right direction, who is Edward. The visual of Edward being red and James being blue is just brilliant. It shows that James has now matured, like Edward. At the beginning of the episode, when he gets covered with blue paint, he’s the typical James we know, complaining about his appearance. However, at the end of the episode, he doesn’t care anymore. Because he’s just appreciating Edward’s help, and is now saying HIMSELF that the appearances doesn’t matter as long as they are really useful. And at the end of the episode, James is now LEAVING the “Three Big Engines,” and is now joining the Edward’s branch line gang. On itself, it’s a very nice story. But that’s not all. Going back to the “Three Big Engines,” it seems like each of them are getting a nice ending to themselves. Henry started as the sickest and the most pathetic engine, and in this series, he becomes a absolute chad and does the legendary “Super Rescue”. James started as a character that only thinks about himself and thinks he is the best. However, in this episode, he finally learns to listen and admit that he is not perfect, and that he needs a guide. And now it seems like Gordon is the only one of the “Three Big Engines” left to get a nice, happy ending to his important part of life. The “Three Big Engines,” the engines who always thought they were above others, are finally maturing, and are now getting ready to open a new chapter of their lives…
Are their traits still intact per chance?
Indeed
Beautiful story about James.
James's speach was heartwarming
Outstanding work, wow! :D I love the moral of the story and the improvements that have been made to the characters, scenery, music and each episode that you upload!!
Well, bud, after watching your latest episode of Tracks to Big Adventures, I have to say that this was another great episode you put together and the story was also great as well, starting with the flashback to The Adventure Beings when James went off the rails and got his red paint, but lost Annie and Clarabel as well as his branch line to Thomas and James then arrives to Wellsworth, surprising Edward and Nia, who was being told how James got his red paint, to which James then says that Mr. Percival has asked him to help with the refurbishment at Brendam Docks and Nia asks Edward if he could take her passengers, but James reminds Nia that Edward's going to the Steamworks and Nia takes her passengers instead. However, the next day, when James picks up the goods train, Carly drops the blue paint on James and he feels embarrassed, but when he realizes he can't pull the heavy train by himself, he refuses help from Boco and Nia before he crashes into some stone trucks at Whiff's Waste Dump and when he comes to a stop at a function as Stanley arrives with his passenger train, he finally goes to the Steamworks and asks Edward, whose boiler is painted red, for his help in getting the train to the mainland, to which Edward does and they both pull the train to the mainland, but when they arrive, the yard manager goes off on Edward and James defends Edward by saying that he's a really useful engine to which as they head back to Sodor, Edward asks James if he would like to help on Edward's branch line and while James says he's a mainline engine, he's trying his best not to admit he would like to work with Edward, Nia and Boco on the branch line, but when they arrive back at Tidmouth Sheds, after James talks to Mr. Percival, Mr. Percival then announces that James will be helping out with the new extension to Brendam, thus becoming one of the main engines to run the extension and when Gordon says that a mainline engine working on the branch line is pathetic, James proudly says that he's a branch line engine while also reminding everyone to be thankful for the jobs you have, such as Percy pulling the mail train, Gordon with the Express and Thomas and Edward with their branch lines and as James leaves, Gordon smiles while James thanks Edward for always helping everyone even though no one appreciates it, to which Edward then tells James that he could have taken Nia's passengers, stayed at the Steamworks and taken the abuse from the yard manager, but he didn't because of James and after Edward tells James he doesn't like conflict, James just says that he was just being James. Basically, Edward and James have that big brother-little brother dynamic with Edward playing the role of big brother and James as the little brother. Also, before I forget, was that Old Slow Coach Nia was pulling when she took her passengers to the zoo? And do you know what happened to your Change of Pace video? All-in-all, in the end, that was another great episode you put together for Tracks to Big Adventures and I look forward to seeing what you have planned next as well as seeing how well Edward, James, Nia and Boco do all working together on Edward's branch line, so until then, keep up the good work, bud!
Now THIS is a 3-Strikes Formula episode done right!
This is a fantastic story, a great adaptation. This really shows the true personality about James, it's almost like it's his finale episode for some reason. Fantastic job on the video.
We've come a long way since Apology Impossible. Best episode of this series. Hands down :D
Major character growth!
I would argue that James' voice is much better than the official voice from the CGI Era
Wow..I absolutely love James and Edward in this series..
All of this character development... it's insane. Toby retiring to Ulfstead Castle, Daisy returning to Ffarquhar and James working on Edward's Branch Line? It's written in a way that makes fair amounts of sense, unlike what Mattel did. And I am *HERE...* for it.
If only we could have a meeting with Mattel to make this the canon version of BWBA.
Eh, Daisy would return to Harwick when Thomas returns so her on Ffarquhar is only brief.
This episode to me is one of the best fan made stories.
A great episode, especially with James
Nia's livery is just everything, I love her in red!
And this story was just absolutely epic.
Same
Can I just say one thing...
THIS SERIES IS FUCKING GORGEOUS!! Seriously, this is soooooo much better than BWBA 😭
How Thomas actually ends up going on a world tour with Sir Topham Hat instead of by himself, how Rebecca is actually a character I feel like I can root for, how everyone from the show actually shows emotion when Thomas leaves, how the characters actually FEEL like the characters we all know and love, especially Gordon, you got him so right in this series, the actual fan service with every old character eventually returning and having an influence on the plot in each episode; I just can't believe how much I'm loving every single episode I watch and I will stay tuned for more to come!! ❤️❤️
The characters actually FEEL like the characters we all know and love in the Brenner era mostly since they return to their original characters from Series 17 onwards thanks to Andrew.
You and everyone else involved with this are amazing! I don’t think BWBA was the worst thing in TTTE, but this is Definitely a big improvement! Kudos to you.
this is so well written. James and Edward are almost like an old married couple
I think their like Father & Son.
@@HomerPenguin5516 I believe they're like grandpa and grandson. In James's Beginning James called Edward grandpa
As much as i love gay couples, i do have to agree with the replies on this one. I have never seen them and will never see them as a couple. They're more like brothers to me...
This is quite a character study of James the red engine and him questioning quite profoundly how does he really want to feel important/useful. It was pretty neat taking and possibly expanding upon his desire to have a branch line from the adventure begins; then resenting Thomas for earning his branch line.
Quite an imagined character arc for James where he finally stands up to Gordon instead of trying to match him all the time; while recognizing the friend he has in kind Edward.
That smile Gordon did.
I was hoping the next episode would be the one with Peter Sam but this is going to be funny for the most part
Some like that
What a beautiful end and what a wonderwel moment when james stood up for edward in the steam workshop and when that man achter like this 🥰🥰🥰🥰
man i always dreamed the day James would be branchline engine and work alongside Edward. Good show Good show :)