Editorial with Sujit Nair | Freebies Vs MGNREGA | PM Modi | Schemes

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 126

  • @rama91152
    @rama91152 3 дня назад +29

    A very noble work you are doing Mr. Nair! God bless you 🙌. I agree with you completely.

  • @reggiedias9231
    @reggiedias9231 3 дня назад +7

    100 % agree.

  • @arjunr1061
    @arjunr1061 3 дня назад +15

    We love your journalism. Keep going strong

  • @syedmunir2259
    @syedmunir2259 3 дня назад +13

    Best Editorial in recent month.
    Hats off.

  • @roystongonsalves1389
    @roystongonsalves1389 3 дня назад +14

    Sir, you stand for the Poor. Well done keep speaking on the topic. You voice will be heard

  • @sangeetajames3257
    @sangeetajames3257 3 дня назад +3

    Absolutely correct

  • @lourdumary5915
    @lourdumary5915 3 дня назад +4

    Sujith, you are not just journalist. Selecting the priority needs if India's rural poor, and other current issues, you have become a conscience keeper of our nation with your high moral ethics.
    🙏❤️

  • @yasminfinlay8018
    @yasminfinlay8018 3 дня назад +10

    Thank you Sujit for not giving up on the MGREGA scandal.

  • @Anway-NeverGiveUp
    @Anway-NeverGiveUp 3 дня назад +24

    The issues of today are:-
    1. HUGE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE.
    2. HUGE EMPLOYMENT CRISIS.
    3. CLOSE OF 15 LAKHS INDUSTRIES.
    4. NO AUTOMATED PRODUCTION & MANUFACTURING SECTORS.
    5. NO RENEWABLE ENERGY SECTORS.
    6. NO SOCIAL DIGNITY, NO ECONOMICAL DIGNITY, NO CULTURAL DIGNITY, NO POLITICAL DIGNITY.
    7. LACK OF PRODUCTIVE AND INNOVATIVE ENGINEERING SECTORS, ROBOTIC TECHNOLOGICAL SECTORS, AUTOMATION SECTORS & BUISNESS SECTORS, FOODING AND CLOTHING SECTORS, AUTOMATION & TRANSPORTATIONAL SECTORS.
    8. NO DEVELOPMENT OF AGRO EGINEERING SECTORS.
    9. NO DEVELOPMENT OF CULTURAL INSTITUTIONS FOR DEVELOPMENT OF PEOPLE OF SOCIETY.
    10. NO DEVELOPMENT OF PRODUCTIVE AND POGRESSIVE HEALTHCARE SECTORS.

  • @rachnagupta8346
    @rachnagupta8346 3 дня назад +12

    Relevant topic. Employment generation or employment linked incentive prog are slowly withdrawn.

  • @mariapetma
    @mariapetma 3 дня назад +6

    This govt is already ready to freeze growth everywhere with very bad thinking.
    I totally stand with you and express our feelings for all our brethren and your editorial daily. Why opposition also not demanding and the social media at large.🙏🙏🙏

  • @suryamanoharm4782
    @suryamanoharm4782 3 дня назад +2

    You raised a very important issue, I sincerely appreciate your efforts.

  • @alphonsageorge7677
    @alphonsageorge7677 3 дня назад +2

    You are so inspiring

  • @thiruvalluvarguru
    @thiruvalluvarguru 3 дня назад +9

    Just because this was brought in by UPA Govt and since it bears the name of the father of our nation, this Govt is bent upon to close it.😮

    • @praveenpayiran
      @praveenpayiran 3 дня назад

      the gov wants its majority to be struggling to make a living or you will start questioning where the country is heading and will be difficult to brainwash you this applies to both BJP and Congress the only difference between them is the speed at which they crush you!

  • @sureshnair4268
    @sureshnair4268 3 дня назад +5

    Very good editorial.

  • @alwynsudhakar6633
    @alwynsudhakar6633 3 дня назад +1

    Very well Said Sir

  • @samueljoseph2821
    @samueljoseph2821 3 дня назад +5

    Along with you Sujit ji and other well wishers,I too beg to the government not to weaken MGNREGA!

  • @meijianngamkamei3324
    @meijianngamkamei3324 День назад

    This channel really stood for the true principle of India..keep up the good work sir👍

  • @SanjayPatil-qi4jm
    @SanjayPatil-qi4jm 2 дня назад

    Agreed 100 percent

  • @charlotterodrigues1436
    @charlotterodrigues1436 2 дня назад

    Well done Sir. I am with you.

  • @BaijuSadasivan
    @BaijuSadasivan 3 дня назад +3

    Salute you, Mr. Nair for this video....

  • @ravinderbedi1031
    @ravinderbedi1031 3 дня назад +2

    10:25 Sir I salute your journalism which is great open mind or all

  • @Flodnonngg
    @Flodnonngg 3 дня назад +2

    Thankyou Mr Niar... For your stand with the job card holders in our country 🤝👍 MGNREGA Improve our economic growth.

  • @PraveenKumar-om1fm
    @PraveenKumar-om1fm 3 дня назад +2

    Thanks

  • @pailaksiar3904
    @pailaksiar3904 3 дня назад

    Jai Hind... A very noble work Sir🎉🎉🎉

  • @ssnugy9508
    @ssnugy9508 3 дня назад +3

    sir i respect you for fighting for our population who cant afford food not many journalist are doing it now a days ... i do believe the Freebie culture is harming us more than we think, people are not equipped with the tools to think coz no education building block hi gayap hai kaha public ko samjhega, i feel like keep them uneducated to rule easy is a scheme

  • @Gulabo-qg1qn
    @Gulabo-qg1qn 2 дня назад

    It's so important

  • @SameerPatra-ld1iu
    @SameerPatra-ld1iu День назад

    Very good episode, Mr Sujit. Our privileged class doesn't have any empathy for the poor and destitute. The popular misplaced belief in karma and merit prevents the better off from caring about those at the bottom rung. We need more humans like you among us. Maafiveer ke pujak will not understand the values of Ambedkar, Nehru, Phule, Periyar, Bhagat, and Gandhi.

  • @mohamedAli-oe1fi
    @mohamedAli-oe1fi 3 дня назад +3

    Thanks Sir, for your faithful and deep concern for the poor people life. Very few media is covering about this precarious situation. Extracting work and not paying is to me is sinful.
    Modi Government has launched many new schemes for the development they are all moving inch by inch for want of funds.
    We are good in putting the cart before the horse. Before allocating the required fund we introduce a scheme for seeking publicity and it stops midway.
    MGNREGA is very sorrowful and pathetic state, where the poor people livelihood is hit very heavily and their survival is a question mark and may lead to suicide. Hope the government take the issue seriously and save the poor who live in abject poverty.

  • @raghuarmani8341
    @raghuarmani8341 3 дня назад +2

    Manmohan was brilliant. This government is just dismantling all good institutions vindictively

  • @geoffreygabriellapitchen3003
    @geoffreygabriellapitchen3003 День назад

    You're the best sirji

  • @tarhkakuhura7972
    @tarhkakuhura7972 3 дня назад +2

    Mgnrega is the best scheme in universe 🎉🎉

  • @sheriefernandez6217
    @sheriefernandez6217 3 дня назад +2

    So cant the opposition use this as a tool ? Why isnt this being highlighted by the opposition? The opposition has no focus, they start something and then they falter

  • @sjyothis
    @sjyothis 3 дня назад

    Good points

  • @kcr5289
    @kcr5289 3 дня назад +2

    I am a banker from Kerala.50% of the MANREGA benificieres here have networth of at least 20lacs.Many have multiple credit facilities with the Bank

    • @ugramatyugram6117
      @ugramatyugram6117 3 дня назад +1

      I'm from Karnataka, here contractors are getting the money and not giving to labours.

    • @coconutpunch123
      @coconutpunch123 3 дня назад +1

      Put the credible data. I am also from kerala. Most of MNREGA workers are poor or lower middle class people.

    • @coconutpunch123
      @coconutpunch123 3 дня назад +1

      Liar

    • @kcr5289
      @kcr5289 3 дня назад

      ​@@coconutpunch123Sir, this is so common in all govt.schemes, it's not about MANREGA only,as a government employee I have been getting ration items throughout,how does one justify this.

    • @coconutpunch123
      @coconutpunch123 3 дня назад

      @@kcr5289 in kerala if you are government employee you will not get subsidised items from ration shops. Know your facts first. Liar

  • @cbdsouza73
    @cbdsouza73 3 дня назад +3

    No matter how much you join your hands they will not hear you. They don't care about the people

  • @nathanjagan7283
    @nathanjagan7283 3 дня назад +1

    Baghavad Gita specifically discusses as to when it is appropriate to give or take gifts in real life!

  • @SPD6901
    @SPD6901 3 дня назад

    Recent interview of ASIAN PAINTS CEO said this exactly in different words…
    He said - “i don’t know where these GDP figures are coming from, the demand is lower even in festival season’’
    What he meant was there is disposable income (money ) with people how can they spend. This is what i am observing clearly across tier3 and lower cities and villages- just look at demand for second hand bikes … people are willing to buy even 10-15 year old with only condition that it runs
    The ladki bahin scheme or any scheme that gives higher PR focusses on moving village capital towards cities.
    Eg. ladki bahin has no boundaries of village and cities but MGNREGA has
    The BJP believes it has core voter base across cities hence toll fee waiver etc . A prominent economist in MH said now for comfort of Mumbai people , the village man have to pay. The govt is going to reimburse the IRB company of its loss of toll revenue - who is going to pay?
    Previously person using the mumbai roads was paying but now each person of maharshtra has to pay…
    This faulty belief in TRICKLE DOWN ECONOMICS is gonna destroy our villages…

  • @jamespereira1202
    @jamespereira1202 2 дня назад

    Your thoughts should reach in every house.

  • @helencarvalho4999
    @helencarvalho4999 3 дня назад +3

    What is the other way to enforce the scheme if this government delays the payment

  • @lakshmananrajjk1989
    @lakshmananrajjk1989 3 дня назад +1

    After being so HIGHLY QUALIFIED why pm is talking only hindi or pakistani islamic urdu everywhere

  • @rakeshmishra425
    @rakeshmishra425 3 дня назад +1

    मनरेगा में पैसा के बदले अनाज मिलना चाहिए ताकि यह गरीब की योजना बन सके

  • @bm8292
    @bm8292 3 дня назад +1

    Many tribals are not holding the aadhaar card as they are not aware of their rights and benefits.
    I know a lady aged around 60 who has no identity to avail of social benefits given by the. Government.

  • @georgetimothy7819
    @georgetimothy7819 3 дня назад +1

    Any scheme associated with Mahatma Gandhi and Congress seems to be allergic.

  • @geoffreygabriellapitchen3003
    @geoffreygabriellapitchen3003 День назад

    I also support your request to the PM Mr Modi

  • @sandeepdhanote5008
    @sandeepdhanote5008 3 дня назад

    Sitting in Delhi, I also want MGNREGA to continue, least all the rural poor migrate to Delhi in search of employment......

  • @SureshKumar-xc8up
    @SureshKumar-xc8up 3 дня назад +1

    Bjp against thisxscheme,likes schemes 4 corporates

  • @rigeshyogi
    @rigeshyogi 2 дня назад

    If politicians have conscience, this will be a different India.

  • @sabihakhan7659
    @sabihakhan7659 2 дня назад

    Sahi idea hai. Don't let the poor beg, let them work and get paid

  • @richmondkharumnuid7125
    @richmondkharumnuid7125 3 дня назад +1

    Ate my dinner.. Filled my stomach but I wasn't satisfied, Why because our beloved PM face was not on my hard earned dinner... 😂😂😂😂

  • @ushashivpuri4835
    @ushashivpuri4835 3 дня назад +1

    They have destroyed a poor mans respect..They made them beggars.
    Sry this corrupt govt cant do anything without corruption and self motive.
    I also support Mnrega!!.

  • @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
    @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 3 дня назад +1

    Sooner or later there will always be a cost for free stuff - Will Leamon
    What is lost thro freebies will be made up thro other taxes -

  • @rajkumarganesan9417
    @rajkumarganesan9417 3 дня назад +2

    Modi has proved that Adani and Ambani conglomerates r the real patriotic and not MANDRIGA payments to the rural communities suffering of the poor. Shame for Modi and Dr Parakala Prabakar's wife Nirmala Seetharaman.

    • @praveenpayiran
      @praveenpayiran 3 дня назад

      just like she said about the onion prices, she doesnt eat onions so she doesnt care, she will say she doesnt get job in mgnrega so she doesnt care

  • @praveenpayiran
    @praveenpayiran 3 дня назад +2

    mgnrega has ruined agriculture in tamilnady which was already facing labor shortage we have severe unskilled labor shortage and this scheme is worsening it the wages were reasonable before it came and it has quadrupled since then but the produce prices have hardly increase for example about 15 years ago it was 5 to 8 rupee for climbing 1 coconut tree and the coconut then was sold for 5 to 7 rupee now for the same tree climbing costs 30 to 35 rs and the coconuts cost 8 to 11 this has made agriculture more and more unviable and we need to improvise to keep the income from going down its only a mater of time people start giving up some have already given up, this scheme is good for north where unskilled unemployment is shy high but a death sentence for the southern states which faces unskilled labor shortage and high unemployment in skilled sector the problems in all of india is not the same

  • @ongyep1phom925
    @ongyep1phom925 3 дня назад

    Sir please to clarify (mgnrega)job cards beneficiary to receive the payment or the panchayat or council's right to deduct the amount from the beneficiary.

  • @shivasubrahmanya6190
    @shivasubrahmanya6190 3 дня назад

    this is difference between affordable and nonaffordable

  • @igssang
    @igssang День назад

    Why a worker is deleted there will be a reason

  • @Satish-ei5to
    @Satish-ei5to 3 дня назад +3

    One reason why India is amongst the major corrupt country is because rulers have made a habit of free bee to common man and so corruption has become a way of life and working for earning is secondary.

    • @coconutpunch123
      @coconutpunch123 3 дня назад

      So you are saying indians are not working or earning?
      Typical chaddi blaming people for problems created illitaerate leaders like modi and mohan bhagwat.

  • @remopaulraj7604
    @remopaulraj7604 3 дня назад

    What is a freebie in a democracy like india.... The wealth belongs to its citizens... The one who govern have become kings instead of public servants and call names like freebies....

  • @abrahamjacob6096
    @abrahamjacob6096 3 дня назад

    A scheme for Helping rural poor, then why Central is not interested.

  • @RUSSELRAJ-o9t
    @RUSSELRAJ-o9t 3 дня назад +2

    Great but you know he is adament he won't listen 😡

  • @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23
    @ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 3 дня назад

    Local got has a role to play in providing a minimum number 100 of days work in rural area - The aim is to enhance the livelihood in villages - The scheme is funded by the central govt ( 75%) -

  • @sebastianmascarenhas4231
    @sebastianmascarenhas4231 3 дня назад

    MGNREGA, the people working under this scheme attain a sense of satisfaction, they have earned their living. Freebies are a form of quid pro quo, you scratch my back I will scratch yours.

  • @joealpers1564
    @joealpers1564 3 дня назад

    Mr. Nair by you saying about Mgnrega and asking the present government to realese funds for the above . Let me tell you it will be put under the rug. Joe

  • @beenamarakkar8450
    @beenamarakkar8450 3 дня назад

    Not only. cleaníng every state

  • @ugramatyugram6117
    @ugramatyugram6117 3 дня назад

    Middleman or small contrators are claiming work done money and they are not paying to labours, thats why govt stopped it.

  • @Adv.JhilamJindal
    @Adv.JhilamJindal 3 дня назад

    Entire parliament must pass 5 PC CTC for GOV employee
    Not 6 7 PC lakh lakh PM salary to 143 cr
    GOV will save 5 L CR PER month
    Will reduce
    Petrol gas diesel electricity prices
    Food grain sugar price immediately for 143 Cr all including 3 Cr GOV employee
    1 decision will benefit all VOTER not only 3 Cr GOV employee getting salary from 143 cr direct indirect tax

  • @sweswarupini9732
    @sweswarupini9732 3 дня назад

    Pay for work is best process

  • @sunandanrao220
    @sunandanrao220 3 дня назад

    The people who watch you are educated people whereas the freebies are given to the people who doesn't follow English.
    I request you to do such videos in Hindi as well for non English population to understand.

    • @coconutpunch123
      @coconutpunch123 3 дня назад

      Adani is the biggest freebie eater in india

  • @coconutpunch123
    @coconutpunch123 3 дня назад +1

    This modi regime is a disaster.more than 500 people died in wayanad disaster. Still this modi regime didnt give a penny for wayanad only because kerala is a south indian state and not a "double engine" state

  • @josephthyparampil2858
    @josephthyparampil2858 3 дня назад

    But Mr Nair, who will convince Modi govt, why even Nitish is not raising voice, even if Bihar has most of the poorest villages in the country.

  • @philipdsilva8517
    @philipdsilva8517 2 дня назад

    BJP is not interested in MGNREGA scheme , since the scheme was launched for weaker sections of society by Congress Govt. The scheme beneficiaries are always vote for congress/TMC/NCP(sp). This govt can delete ineligible beneficiaries but encourage eligible beneficiaries to make effective. In order to get name of Modi he is launching various schemes. He is doing disservice to the weaker sections in event of not funding above scheme.

  • @ravinderbedi1031
    @ravinderbedi1031 3 дня назад

    Freebies are u rooting from beginner to work and there prestige, give them work and pay what is true way of helping

  • @d.dcosta8771
    @d.dcosta8771 2 дня назад

    Do we have to stop down so much like you want ... (We respect your view point)
    ..... Shame on our people n country any which way for damning our poor n marginalized.
    Disgusting

  • @prashantshah1396
    @prashantshah1396 2 дня назад

    Shame on us to have elected modiji 3 times.

  • @elginjosec
    @elginjosec 3 дня назад

    Sir they are not newly launched schemes, they are all renamed, repackaged and relaunched schemes 😂

  • @shamakrai3310
    @shamakrai3310 3 дня назад

    You forgot one important point, maybe you can't say it on screen without solid proof. But, one major reason why BJP cut the allocation of MGNREGA is - because it can re-inforce our ancient casteist culture back.
    If many people begs against Narendra Modi (whose pr team trying hard to portray him as God), definitely our society will eventually develop superiority-inferiority complex. Even Arun Govil (now an MP) said during election rally that if BJP gets 400+ seats, they'll change the whole legal system of India.
    When the sanghis are again & again brainwashing the public for historical revisioninsm, we can't deny that Modi's vision is not evil.

  • @mariavaz9054
    @mariavaz9054 3 дня назад

    Botani projects has gifted our Papu ,Marwin and secretary of Sancole panchayat ln goa

  • @sabinaabraham7088
    @sabinaabraham7088 2 дня назад

    Isn’t this what AAP is doing by giving jobs to the municipality workers Mohala clinics school teachers . Why did the LG stop the wages ? Did you ever question that act of the center. Mantega has no designed work so easy inside step. But not one channel asked why AAP works was derailed ?
    Modi is an ace Schemer with no work done under it . He has brought down every scheme that is not BJP’s

  • @pukkandan
    @pukkandan 3 дня назад

    Are you being intentionally obtuse, or just ignorant? Non-partisan third party studies have shown again and again that less than 20% of the fund assigned to NREGA actually gets to the hands of the intended recipients. That's why it's being downsized in favor of much more efficient schemes.

  • @mallichithirala251
    @mallichithirala251 3 дня назад

    Why are you begging sir people of this country cast their vote for cast Creed and also for money especially in Southern States.

  • @kalyani_7
    @kalyani_7 3 дня назад

    🫡🫡

  • @DCM2463
    @DCM2463 3 дня назад +1

    Inspite of all the problems in the country the people are still voting for the same party. The people got what they asked for.

  • @79kmph
    @79kmph 2 дня назад

    Kahana kya chahte ho bhai

  • @RKV0785
    @RKV0785 3 дня назад

    This anchor believes he is speaking to fools.
    Indians have become knowledgeable.
    This subject has been debated by Economists in the UN form and suggested to all governments , to adopt a few " FREEBIES" as per the procedure & circumstances prescribed by these Economists. Former RBI governor Raghuram Rajan has also talked about it . Central Government schemes are in accordance with the accepted norms.
    Delhi, Karnataka, Punjab, Teluguana, West Bengal, HP, and Kerala government are in debt crisis . Because, these are harmful tonthe economy and misuse of tax payers money