I have to ask Robert - what is unique about tech jobs and medical professionals? Nothing. H1B is not a O-1 Visa, which is genius level. What is the point of going to MIT or Medical School in the USA if cheaper labor will undercut you? Its not about NO immigration ever, but if we are saying America First - is it America First as long as you are happy with $60K a year? Im not a critic, but I remember a 60 Minutes report from about 7 to 10 years ago that focused on the Medical professionals. Even claiming the corporations would hold their passports so they couldnt leave. If Elons a genius with exceptional knowledge and achievement, his Visa should have been an O-1. H1B was never about the best of the best. Is it that GenX through GenZ are not motivated? Public School became all about passing tests focused on certain material to get money for the school. It hasnt been about educating Americans since at least the late 80s to early 90s. Some states practice 'social promotion' where instead of holding students back a grade until they learn the material, they move on 'socially' and graduate high school functionally illiterate. I could see how H1B could be necessary until they fix Education - but they need to tell us that, and not just "Yeah, I do it too. I take advantage of it too."
I work in tech. It is 100% not about not having the skilled labor pool in the US. It is twofold. It is bad HR that cannot figure out how to hire for skilled tech positions. They hire based on diversity quotas or AI algorithms reading resumes. In general, tech focused people don't have the skillset to make really clean and pretty resumes, so they get ignored more often despite actually having the correct skillsets for the job. The second issue is bad management. The vast majority of people managers in the tech field are promoted for reasons other than being the best at getting their people set up to do their jobs. They are good at being deceitful about metrics to make it look like they are doing a better job than they are, or they are good at brown nosing their boss to make that person look good. While not inherently bad traits, they more often than not work counter to developing a skilled workforce. So, rather than have a constantly improving team that develops a better product, they have to reduce costs to show "improved efficiencies", which leads to needing to hiring "higher quality" staff at lower prices. So, they import labor that will work for lower money. There is also a large amount of exploitative labor. Because visas are tied to the employment, the employee is incentivized not to report violations. If you hire a "full time" position but then require that person to work 80+ hours a week, then technically they are working two jobs for half the salary.
@OhSnap-kb9vr I believe 60 Minutes did an episode on the medical profession. Basically the teaching hospitals and universities were given financial incentives for choosing foreign candidates to teach/train as doctors. So like 75% of doctors in a given group were from other countries. This is like telling Americans not to bother. Not unless they want to allow opening up more medical schools, which they've fought against in the past.
I never liked Laura Loomer but she should be allowed to voice her opinion in a free and democratic country. Loomer today, You tomorrow. First They Came For....
These people attacking her, like Barnes and Elon, are trying to silence people they don't like and telling people not to listen to her. What we need less to hear from is people like Vivek who is clearly anti-American. Laura is fighting for America.
Voiced doesn't mean listened to, which is Barnes' point. Loomer should be ALLOWED to speak, but her credibility is such that no one should listen. That was his point, not that she shouldn't be allowed to speak.
Why do you think that? You can criticize Musk for plenty. I don’t believe he would ever run from a debate. The man lives to tell everyone what he knows. He loves to debate.
Eric's tweets were responding to Vivek. I expect Vivek would have more time/capacity to engage in a formal debate of that kind, aside from anything else.
@@SusanBaileyAmazingEstate Eric Weinstein did a full study on H1B. Its been abused and full of untruths. Barnes and VIVA are just talking with opinions. Weinstein has the facts.
BTW, Barnes is really giving Bannon no credit here. Bannon got trump elected. It was his ideas and his connection to Americans that helped Trump truly understanding what he was intuiting. So saying Elon did more than Bannon every did is actually insane. Elon voted for BIden after all.
Elon did do alot to help Americans. Starlink to Appalachia, helping get people to the polls in PA, actually campaigning etc. Perhaps Bannon should have been mentioned too but Bannon isnt part of the main topic which is the H1B Visa. Also, its not a contest. All help getting rid of this administration is greatly appreciated. 🥰
Anyone who was a cannon follower was already in the bag for trump. Elon reached the middle ground, hell.elon reached everywhere through Twitter, he gave everyone right of che Guevarra thier voice back
@@austinfackender SURE. BUT IS NO TRUMP WITHOUT BANNON. IT NEVER HAPPENS. HE'S NEVER THERE. THERE'S NOTHING FOR ELON TO CHANGE DIRECTION TO. NO OUTLET. HILLARY WAS ELECTED. THEN GOD KNOWS WHO BUT ANOTHER DEMOCRAT WITHOUT BANNON/TRUMP
Viva, who says you can't do both at the same time, illegal immigration AND stop abuse of H1B importing of foreigner workers to replace American workers? You make it sound like we have to continue to let in foreigners to take American jobs because both tasks can't be completed at the same time.
No one, but that ain't his point. His point is that legal immigration should be reformed, not banned. I personally believe that the whole illegal part of this screaming match is just a red herring to distract from that binary.
@@oliveoil7642 I’ll pass. Just north of me is Frisco, TX. Schools there are now over 50% Indian. It’s gotten ridiculous how many Americans Indians have replaced in the tech field in the DFW metroplex area in Texas.
@@JohnDoe-dr9ffsuch bs. Trump needs to stay america first - we need to debate & hash out the meaning of that. Imo it should mean putting American citizens first - not American corporations first.
I have two decades experience in IT, the first half of that as active duty enlisted. My experience of working with H1B workers was mixed. Most were there for the right reasons but the corporations treat them like indentured servants. H1B was supposed to be a stop gap to improving our homegrown options, but in the half decade since I left the workforce the education system HAS collapsed bottom-up.
I worked in big tech for 10 years and retired as a sr project manager. The far right actually nailed the problems in tech. They hire h1b at 1/3rd the wage a native American would ask. Then treat the h1b worker as an indentured servant. 80+ hour work weeks on call 24/7. Its China lite, not America.
Then don't lie. I've worked in Big Tech for longer and still work there. H1Bs are not treated like that. It would be illegal to do so and the H1Bs would have a tremendous labor case with a big payday against any company that did that to them. Right now, people are working long hours in Big Tech because of all of the layoffs, and this is all people not just H1Bs. No one wants to be in the next wave.
Aside from national security, another issue that hasn't been fleshed out properly is the impact it has on other countries. Canada poaches a lot of doctors from other countries. That's to deal with our doctor shortage. Our doctor shortage (and yes, I'm gonna say it) is largely a gender issue. Male or female, it costs the taxpayer the same to train a GP. The return on investment? Male doctors work more hours per day, per week, per year and per lifetime than female ones. They're also more willing to specialize. My sister has extremely steady hands. Her sutures were always perfect. When she got her MD, they begged her to specialize in cosmetic or pediatric surgery. She was like, "by the time I'm finished training in a specialty, my biological clock will be jangling and I'll be taking a bunch of time off." All but two of the doctors at my clinic are from Lebanese. Do you think health care is MORE accessible in Lebanon than it is in Canada? Does anyone think Lebanon has such a surplus of doctors that they're happy to invest in their training only to see them emigrate? My husband's allergist is Nigerian. Same thing. Is Nigeria so overflowing with specialists that they can afford to train them and then just give them away?
hey GWW great post, ive always felt the same. we essentially are bribing doctors to leave the nation that invested lots of money into the infrastructure that allows them to achieve these qualifications. its immoral, we need homegrown solutions, not bandaid solutions
It's brutal. And somehow they've bought about 1/3 of the businesses in my small town of 9000, now 12,000. The places they now own completely suck too and all of em drink and drive
Barnes lying straight out of the gate: "...this has always been Trump's position", except when it WASN'T; he said he would end H1B visas in the debates prior to 2016.
People voted to reduce immigration, not to replace illegal immigration with legal immigration. Also skilled doesnt mean theyre good at their job, it doesnt mean they have experience, skilled means they have finished a trade school, college or university as compared to menial labor.
Reducing illegal immigration is what was promised and what was delivered in 2016. We have rational reasons to believe now that it will be any different. The argument is solely between those who want to reform legal immigration and those who want to ban all immigration. The allusion to illegal immigration is a red herring to distract from the argument of should we reform or ban legal immigration.
Comment around 17 minutes is the reason I can’t totally accept Vivek’s initial statement. While yes our education system has major problems (that’s why I home school) there are far too many occasions where the natives are forced to train their foreign replacements, indicating they are more than capable to do the job. The h1b salaries are also not reflective of the true market value, making it crystal clear this is about cheap labour not some spectacular talent (which I’m sure does still happen but are now the minority of h1b). Furthermore, if the STEM education in America is so appalling, why do foreigners pay a premium to attend our universities to receive degrees in engineering, IT, etc., and then subsequently stay here after becoming employed? Lastly, the rhetoric surrounding h1b would not have become so hostile if we didn’t have solid proof that the tech sector was deliberately discriminating against white males for the past decades (see James Damore, big tech censorship, etc) This is personal, whites are being targeted for destruction, and like our forefathers, we aren’t going to sit back like pussies and let it happen without a fight.
You haul to understand the white man has constantly been told he can't have this or that job because of affirmative action. Jess also been told that Americans didn't want to work in the field. Another life. This is the dame argument the slave holders used to keep slavery alive.
Do they make absolutely sure that there are no Americans that can take the jobs that are being filled by H1B visa holders? If not, that tells you everything that you need to know. Qui bono?
@fdprobie8554 Nope, as noted they'll post an advertisement in a newspaper, on a wall in the break room, or in a less than public space. Just to say they did. Also, they can post a job on Dice, etc. but make the filters so specific that no one local can apply for. Based on what I've seen, recruiters will tell prospective candidates to add things to the resume to male sure they get through. I don't unless it's something I've done or know. But I bet others don't care.
There are plenty of ghost jobs, they put up advertisement, filter anyone without specific keywords, demand insane experience and hang it up for months so they can say nobody can fill the role and htne its a-ok to hire somebody without all of the above requirements.
In 2020 I looked into how to migrate to Sweden. The rules were….1) have a bank account there 2) have housing (which they said good luck on a Swede renting to a noncitizen) 3) have to have skills in jobs they needed filled (Nursing was one). 4) have to speak their native language (even though, for the most part, they speak English) So that meant I would not be able to move there! I have hard time speaking any language other than English. The other is I’m just a factory worker, no skills in medical.
Just identify with a third world man of fighting age and they’ll let you right in… Sweden is the gRape capitol of Europe because of the’cultural enrichment’ they’ve gotten… we need to fight it.
If only you spoke Arabic, and lacked even factory work skills. You could walk straight in & have the Swedish govt put you up at Swedish taxpayer's expense.
Well I spent over a year learning to code, only to never once be given even a response to any of the apps I put in. I gave up a while ago, but I am sure it never got better. Was a waste of time to learn to code, and I am sure if the H1B situation was different I would have at least gotten an interview.
It's the HR department I can assure you. I am a highly skilled and experienced Amwerican Elctro/mechanical designer and I can't get a look at my resume.
@@RS-hh3et No, I can't; I am dsylexic and a terrible typist but I checked the spelling on my resume better than a yt comment but thanks for all your wisdom there sport.
If the argument is that the H1Bs are cheap labor, then why not require that they be paid the same as locals and contribute the same to the system to offset that advantage. More incentive for employers to ensure that job applicants are actually qualified to do the job right and qualified applicants get paid their worth discounting national security and cultural issues. But more importantly, fix the education system so the locals are more competitive.
I never trusted him since I found out he had taken Paul Soros money for college.... the guy was already about 2 million dollars rich, it's not like he needed that money to complete his education.
Yeah. I was pretty disappointed in many voices on this including viva. What I took as these people grifting was not even mentioning Elons banning of all these people which was the most egregious of all of it. So we fought so hard to have a “free speech” and now are king can just decide to ban people cause he gets his feelings hurt. My dad was a programmer and anyone who knows anything about this is that Indian programmers are hot better, they are more affordable for corporations. I’m glad Elons finally was backed into a corner, saying “ok they should be payed what American workers get paid with a form of tariff added so corporations have to pay more for them” (paraphrasing) he could have lead with that, we wouldn’t have been so suspicious.
What is interesting/instructive is that he unintentionally gave an insight into the mythic narrative that the US Brahmin community uses to each other to self-justify the otherwise ludicrous (and unjustifiable) degree of wealth and success that they enjoy through the absolutely massive amounts of nepotism, corruption and discrimination that they routinely practice as they collectively conspire to exploit the country for their own mutual benefit.
Should Libya hire Libyan doctors over Canadian ones to make sure Libyans are employed? If you are better than an American at rocket science, Elon should be able to hire you, or else that American company will be worse off.
Barnes nailed it. US schools treats "nerds" badly, usually violently. Foreign schools don't. US students aspire to be sport stars, YT influencers, anything that looks like easy $$s. Foreign students aspire to be CEOs, doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc.
No thanks. Certain kids treat high achievers badly out of jealousy, this is something true across countries and across all time. The schools aren't upholding jocks, this is a tired old trope. It's an excusal to further push down the productive people already here, and cut their wages by getting foreign labor.
@@alek4811 Vivek is not the first to say it nor notice it. It may have even been the NYT that, a few years ago, noted that when polling US vs Chinese students, there was a profound difference in future occupational outlooks. And it didn't favor the US.
@@brianmack6285this is laughable and naive. The CCP isnt letting everyone into schools, they will all be loyalists of some form or another, they will all be more skilled at whatever they are studying than the average of their peers to get in, and any communication from China to the NYT is certainly from the CCP. If you asked the same group of people here in America youd likely get the same answers (like you would if you went to China and asked the average chinese citizen and not a party member.
I’m glad Barnes is doing well. Has he spoken about his health issue? He says he’s fine and moves on. Is that him being stoic or keeping his private business private?
Well in reality, musk barely qualified for h1b,. he got bachelor of science in economics in 1997 which he got in us and claims to have bachelor of science in engineering from 1995 which in reality is bachelor of arts in physics which he got in 1997.
@@aurorab6796 thats not the point, when he came over he wouldnt qualify for h1b. Ill go further he still doesnt qualify for o-1, elons no genius and im less familiar with vivek but ill hazard a guess he wouldnt qualify either.
Immigrants work hard, but the quality of their work is poor. I would prefer to pay more and employ Americans. Overall the living standards of Americans will rise if we employ Americans.
Viva just said he agrees that oblivious MAGA Republicans are gullible... he said he can't disagree with that statement, so that means he agrees that MAGA people that have a problem with Elon and Vivek importing foreigners to take American jobs are "oblivious MAGA Republicans who are gullible". So, he's saying we are ill-informed, but he is here to lecture to us and teach us bigots what is what.
@@angelmartin7310 he's a jackass tgat can his happy ass back to Canada. He lost his country by being a coward...now he wants us to bow down. I'll hold for Barnes but I'm done with this clown.
@@hilkmeister1382 No, Stew Pid. He's saying he agrees with the guy that there are MAGA people who are gullible because they are angry for Elon and Vivek putting FOREINGERS FIRST. You want me answer, STOP IMMIGRATION. Just stop it. Work out the problems and get rid of the illegals and all those taking American jobs and many years from now open it up to legal immigration again, very carefully, slowly. You don't like that, who cares.
Elon praised the nerd from Saved by the Bell. Bad example as Zack, the cool kid, blew Screech out of the water on the SATs, scoring over 1500 compared to the “nerd’s” score of like 1200. Bottom line, the cool kid was FAR smarter than the nerd Elon was praising. The notion that nerds end up running things when they grow up just isn’t true because nerds often lack the necessary leadership skills to run successful businesses.
Hey Vivek, show your true colors and trade H1B visas for Pharma patent reform. Greed works both ways brother. Your got rich off patents which are, by definition, anti competitive and anti free market. Limit them to 5 years max, or shut the hell up about free markets. Hypocrite.
@@christiansgrignoli3351 Sure but 20 years for patenting a plant? or chemical from the congo? Libertarians disagree. At the most give 5 yrs. Or, 5% royalty payment from anyone who wants to use any patent.
The video of the woman walking up to JT is phoney as hell. First of all he has several layers of security, so she would not have been able to just walk up to him. The security around him would mean that his locations are planned in advance, and security cleared hours in advance. So that is fake. No way a random woman just called to him and then walked across a parking lot to him. Then there’s the matter of the autos in the parking lot. He travels everywhere with a motorcade. This is just theatre.
Viva. People are just showing the similarities between cheap labor for big agriculture (cheap illegal labor) vs h1b bit tech big pharma (cheap legal labor)
The problem isn't the H1B visa itself, the problem is the lack of scrutiny, enforcement, and penalization, when it is abused, not used for it's intended purpose.
There is no way I want anyone in my house, around my kids, or working in my yard who receives a low wage. It isn’t safe because desperate people do desperate things. Pay fair wages to everyone.
Thats a socialist trope. Poverty doesnt create criminality. Bad morals, bad culture do. All of my anscestors were destitute by my standards. Period. Most of them were fantastic people. And people should be paid fairly. Which happens most of the time leaving just the trope rattling in your head. Simple as
@@missykins3193 poverty is not the root cause of criminality. And apparently i cant name the root philosophy you derive that trope from without censorship. But i’d wager you know it as you speak it
I've worked with a few people on H1B visas. One was phenomenal with his skills, the majority of the rest are trash. But Elon did explain it right, minimum salary requirements and a higher Visa fee charged to the corporations.
This is all besides the point. Nobody voted because they want H1B increased. The government was given a clear mandate. However, they instead choose to focus on an issue that there is clear pushback over. This alone is enough to show that they do not have the American citizens' wellbeing as their main focus.
All the "guestworker" visas should be ended. The Einsteins and Von Brauns can be "parolled" in on a case by cases basis. The education system here will never be "fixed" until there is no other option. In a world where 3 different billionaires have their own space program American citizens don't need to "fix" their immigration system for the benefit of foreigners or the billionaires.
That woman who confronted Turdeau, I'd say she held back. She should really have let him have it and should not have stopped at just telling him to F off. Canadian's need to get more excited.
If there's no qualified American, you go with an H1B. The problem is, that's not what happens. At least not in Canada, where we have a similar system. It took FOREVE for my husband to get his first engineering job, despite having earned the most versatile, and most challenging, engineering degree offered in Canada. His cousin got a degree in civil engineering, and after nearly a year of not a single interview finally said "fuck it" and took a job pruning trees. If you look at the job postings, what you'll see is the inevitable result of H1B abuse (and other foolish HR practices). Thousands of inexperienced new Canadian graduates are competing for a handful of entry level jobs. THOSE jobs are going to H1Bs. The postings for experienced engineers languish unfilled for months, often for more than a year. Because Canadian engineering grads were pruning trees instead of accumulating experience as engineers. It's short term gain that will inevitably lead to long term pain.
@hilkmeister1382 I agree, but the debate should be done before the bill is signed. Once signed, it'll be a bear to get reversed. And, what about the next POTUS reversing Trump's work?
@ We have time, 2 years in fact, to get this right BECAUSE of that. Better to take time now and get it right than to rush something through. Also a POTUS doesn’t have the power to overturn law and with the kicking they got I doubt they will try to play the other side of illegal immigration so soon.
1:09:54 Viva I'm sorry but Ontario is not liberal It is conservative It just happens to be Toronto's is mostly liberal outside of Toronto it's mostly conservatives it just happens miraculously that the liberals win with mail in ballot in certain areas
1:18:30 FinCEN rule, not IRS. It’s been driving accountants crazy because we’re all afraid of the state bar suing us for unauthorized practice of law if we help our clients with this 😂
H1-B was never designed for "unique set of skills". It is for workers who have a bachelor's degree, which in India is the same as an associates degree in the US because High School ends at age 17 and IT schools are 3 years. The great majority of the H1-B software engineers could be replaced by smart, industrious, community colleges graduates. I have been working as a software developer since before there was an H1-B visa. We used to have lots of musicians working in software. Music and code require similar skills. There is nothing about Indian culture that makes them better software developers than any other culture. They come from a country that prints enough money to always keep their currency low compared to the USD, and that is the "secret sauce" of the Indian developer.
It's only a matter of time before jobs are more automated. It's not really anything you can stop Just as the printing press grows, so do jobs become obsolete. If isn't done by the US will be done by others.
its okay to have legal immigration, but this should be open to all foreigners to apply to see if they qualify, these special deals special visas have to go, these benefit the corporations not the country as a whole, no more special rights and deals, they are creating a caste system
@@hilkmeister1382 Unlike you who calls anyone who doesn't agree with Elon and Vivek racists and what not. It doesn't matter, you are not worth listening to. A complete waste of time talking to sell-out traitors.
I'm an Airbnb owner with 18 units in Nova Scotia. My units are pet friendly but pets not allowed on furniture or bedding. I've operated 6 years and have (overall) excellent service from Airbnb...if you dont want anautomated response you need to use a telephone to contact a real person at Airbnb. My units are priced 30-35% below hotels who always escalate their prices in high season. Each of you are citing single negative experiences....Barnes if you were a founding member and only had one bad experience...is that enough to defame the organization? Doesn't seem fair to me
Wish that you guys had Tim Dillon on. He literally went through a similar situation with AirBnB, and has a background in real estate. He's also funny as hell and has an interesting perspective.
Kiff is a mistranslation of an Afrikaans word (South African language that developed from the Dutch settlers) Gif which is a name for weed. English speaking people in Durban couldn't pronounce gif so said kiff, which became a slang word for cool/awesome etc, so Kiffness is like saying awesomeness. (The g in gif is pronounced similar to the cr in croissant)
No they are not in the minority. Most of MAGA 66% agrees with no immigration or use of the HB-1 Visa. I dont agree with Barnes, I think he is sometimes a week behind the events as they occur. On this one Bannon is right again.
There is a range of solid middle ground to debate. I agree with bannon. Barnes is very reasonable here. We need to flesh out what america first means - putting American citizens first above the multinational corporations profit
@jeffreycordova9082 to this point, I think there is a range of solid middle ground that would make many ppl happy- where we get the cream of the crop & keep Americans holding onto most of the good jobs. H1b is being gamed & manipulated for awhile now. I did not know this
Listening to Viva this morning for the first time in a while. This whole defense of immigrants in a skilled position is a bit unsettling. The issue isn't The skill, it's the loyalty. Viva, you have a very American type spirit, despite having been born in Canada. You also have an intelligent voice. So we are happy to welcome you. But you are an exception. The plain fact of the matter is that the last 100 years or so of US immigration policy has led to egregious abuses, and subversions of the culture. A culture which you have expressed that you value highly. America needs a moratorium on these policies of immigration, because it has been abused. And the abuse drastically supersedes the benefits you continue to point out at this point. I am giving you the benefit of the doubt that this is just naivety, but you sound bought, and should really reflect on your points and the broader picture.
Robert, I've been following you, as the only constitutional lawyer I'd seen, since Kyle, who has consistently told the truth. There is a group of RUclipsrs who need a constitutional lawyer. They may pull it of on their own....but I feel it would behove you to pay attention. Lane Mayers Channel For Social Change, the Reluctant Prophet, and several other youtube channels would draw your attention to police and judicial malfeasance that, I believe, you would find interesting. Please investigate. Yours truly, -Mree
Never thought I would find myself in a position to provide Robert with information - in this case BOI. Sorry for the long data dump but it shows the clown show regardless this law. Robert is referencing the first federal case in which the district judge in Alabama found in favor of a specific group. The big news occurred in the 5th circuit on December 6 when a district judge ruled the whole act of Congress unconstitutional. Emergency appeal by Garland to a 3 judge appeals court panel that ruled on December 23 that the previous decision was a stayed and the act was constitutional. Then, on December 27 the full appeals court overturned the 3 judge panel and stated it unconstitutional. In the meantime FinCen (BOI) website says you can voluntarily provide the information. This whole department and its database now with all of the private information they have collected needs to be e eliminated by Doge and the data destroyed (as much as you can destroy digital info- hahaha). The Trump DOJ needs to let this law lie dead in the water.
I have to ask Robert - what is unique about tech jobs and medical professionals? Nothing. H1B is not a O-1 Visa, which is genius level. What is the point of going to MIT or Medical School in the USA if cheaper labor will undercut you? Its not about NO immigration ever, but if we are saying America First - is it America First as long as you are happy with $60K a year? Im not a critic, but I remember a 60 Minutes report from about 7 to 10 years ago that focused on the Medical professionals. Even claiming the corporations would hold their passports so they couldnt leave. If Elons a genius with exceptional knowledge and achievement, his Visa should have been an O-1. H1B was never about the best of the best. Is it that GenX through GenZ are not motivated? Public School became all about passing tests focused on certain material to get money for the school. It hasnt been about educating Americans since at least the late 80s to early 90s. Some states practice 'social promotion' where instead of holding students back a grade until they learn the material, they move on 'socially' and graduate high school functionally illiterate. I could see how H1B could be necessary until they fix Education - but they need to tell us that, and not just "Yeah, I do it too. I take advantage of it too."
Tech and medicine are also extremely vulnerable and exploitable failure points for a foreign power to monopolize.
I work in tech. It is 100% not about not having the skilled labor pool in the US. It is twofold. It is bad HR that cannot figure out how to hire for skilled tech positions. They hire based on diversity quotas or AI algorithms reading resumes. In general, tech focused people don't have the skillset to make really clean and pretty resumes, so they get ignored more often despite actually having the correct skillsets for the job. The second issue is bad management. The vast majority of people managers in the tech field are promoted for reasons other than being the best at getting their people set up to do their jobs. They are good at being deceitful about metrics to make it look like they are doing a better job than they are, or they are good at brown nosing their boss to make that person look good. While not inherently bad traits, they more often than not work counter to developing a skilled workforce. So, rather than have a constantly improving team that develops a better product, they have to reduce costs to show "improved efficiencies", which leads to needing to hiring "higher quality" staff at lower prices. So, they import labor that will work for lower money. There is also a large amount of exploitative labor. Because visas are tied to the employment, the employee is incentivized not to report violations. If you hire a "full time" position but then require that person to work 80+ hours a week, then technically they are working two jobs for half the salary.
@OhSnap-kb9vr I believe 60 Minutes did an episode on the medical profession. Basically the teaching hospitals and universities were given financial incentives for choosing foreign candidates to teach/train as doctors. So like 75% of doctors in a given group were from other countries. This is like telling Americans not to bother. Not unless they want to allow opening up more medical schools, which they've fought against in the past.
I never liked Laura Loomer but she should be allowed to voice her opinion in a free and democratic country.
Loomer today, You tomorrow. First They Came For....
These people attacking her, like Barnes and Elon, are trying to silence people they don't like and telling people not to listen to her. What we need less to hear from is people like Vivek who is clearly anti-American. Laura is fighting for America.
Voiced doesn't mean listened to, which is Barnes' point. Loomer should be ALLOWED to speak, but her credibility is such that no one should listen. That was his point, not that she shouldn't be allowed to speak.
@@hilkmeister1382 From the posts I've seen, Loomer is right. Is she lying about some things? No idea.
@aurorab6796 Loomer has a long history of stirring up crap and lying. She COULD be right but like the boy who cries wolf, she has no credibility.
I believe she was kicked off twitter cuz she published the home address of some twitter people who pissed her off.
The difference between H1B workers and American workers is about $40,000,
Eric Weinstein said he’d debate Musk on the H1B visas...I have a feeling Elon won’t take him up on it.
Why do you think that? You can criticize Musk for plenty. I don’t believe he would ever run from a debate. The man lives to tell everyone what he knows. He loves to debate.
Eric's tweets were responding to Vivek. I expect Vivek would have more time/capacity to engage in a formal debate of that kind, aside from anything else.
Actually it was Vivek he was talking to. I don’t hold my breath for either one to debate Eric tho.
@@SusanBaileyAmazingEstate Eric Weinstein did a full study on H1B. Its been abused and full of untruths. Barnes and VIVA are just talking with opinions. Weinstein has the facts.
Yeah Eric told a story about this a few years back - how the scientific lobby wanted to undercut American scientists wages
BTW, Barnes is really giving Bannon no credit here. Bannon got trump elected. It was his ideas and his connection to Americans that helped Trump truly understanding what he was intuiting. So saying Elon did more than Bannon every did is actually insane. Elon voted for BIden after all.
Elon did do alot to help Americans. Starlink to Appalachia, helping get people to the polls in PA, actually campaigning etc. Perhaps Bannon should have been mentioned too but Bannon isnt part of the main topic which is the H1B Visa. Also, its not a contest. All help getting rid of this administration is greatly appreciated. 🥰
@@posmoo9790 To be fair, you are giving more credit to Bannon than you are to God. Bannon doesn't deserve any more credit than me or Trump.
I have never watched Bannon and most have not either. So giving him credit for Trump getting elected is a HUGE stretch.
Anyone who was a cannon follower was already in the bag for trump. Elon reached the middle ground, hell.elon reached everywhere through Twitter, he gave everyone right of che Guevarra thier voice back
@@austinfackender SURE. BUT IS NO TRUMP WITHOUT BANNON. IT NEVER HAPPENS. HE'S NEVER THERE. THERE'S NOTHING FOR ELON TO CHANGE DIRECTION TO. NO OUTLET. HILLARY WAS ELECTED. THEN GOD KNOWS WHO BUT ANOTHER DEMOCRAT WITHOUT BANNON/TRUMP
Viva, who says you can't do both at the same time, illegal immigration AND stop abuse of H1B importing of foreigner workers to replace American workers? You make it sound like we have to continue to let in foreigners to take American jobs because both tasks can't be completed at the same time.
Over complicating the solution. It's really easy: adopt the immigration standards as the entirety of the entire f****** third world.
No one, but that ain't his point. His point is that legal immigration should be reformed, not banned. I personally believe that the whole illegal part of this screaming match is just a red herring to distract from that binary.
@@hilkmeister1382 He's saying the H1B is the one being used to distract from the illegals, pay attention.
I think you need to listen again.
@@timpeters3228 My hearing is fine. You need listening comprehension.
I don’t want the USA to look like India.
If those Indian workers are so vital, corporations can pay triple the taxes and additional tariffs for them.
All you need to do is come to Canada! My small town used to be diverse now it is New Delhi!
@@oliveoil7642 I’ll pass. Just north of me is Frisco, TX. Schools there are now over 50% Indian. It’s gotten ridiculous how many Americans Indians have replaced in the tech field in the DFW metroplex area in Texas.
@@JohnDoe-dr9ffsuch bs. Trump needs to stay america first - we need to debate & hash out the meaning of that. Imo it should mean putting American citizens first - not American corporations first.
I have two decades experience in IT, the first half of that as active duty enlisted. My experience of working with H1B workers was mixed. Most were there for the right reasons but the corporations treat them like indentured servants. H1B was supposed to be a stop gap to improving our homegrown options, but in the half decade since I left the workforce the education system HAS collapsed bottom-up.
Justin Trudeau; Have a wonderful day ma'am.
Me: Not with you as PM!
I worked in big tech for 10 years and retired as a sr project manager. The far right actually nailed the problems in tech. They hire h1b at 1/3rd the wage a native American would ask. Then treat the h1b worker as an indentured servant. 80+ hour work weeks on call 24/7. Its China lite, not America.
We're not "far right". We're just right. It's the commie left that calls us far right.
@@DV80syes which is where this person came to troll from..lefties are incapable of debating...they will cancel someone first
Then don't lie. I've worked in Big Tech for longer and still work there. H1Bs are not treated like that. It would be illegal to do so and the H1Bs would have a tremendous labor case with a big payday against any company that did that to them.
Right now, people are working long hours in Big Tech because of all of the layoffs, and this is all people not just H1Bs. No one wants to be in the next wave.
Aside from national security, another issue that hasn't been fleshed out properly is the impact it has on other countries.
Canada poaches a lot of doctors from other countries. That's to deal with our doctor shortage. Our doctor shortage (and yes, I'm gonna say it) is largely a gender issue.
Male or female, it costs the taxpayer the same to train a GP. The return on investment? Male doctors work more hours per day, per week, per year and per lifetime than female ones. They're also more willing to specialize.
My sister has extremely steady hands. Her sutures were always perfect. When she got her MD, they begged her to specialize in cosmetic or pediatric surgery. She was like, "by the time I'm finished training in a specialty, my biological clock will be jangling and I'll be taking a bunch of time off."
All but two of the doctors at my clinic are from Lebanese. Do you think health care is MORE accessible in Lebanon than it is in Canada? Does anyone think Lebanon has such a surplus of doctors that they're happy to invest in their training only to see them emigrate?
My husband's allergist is Nigerian. Same thing. Is Nigeria so overflowing with specialists that they can afford to train them and then just give them away?
hey GWW great post, ive always felt the same. we essentially are bribing doctors to leave the nation that invested lots of money into the infrastructure that allows them to achieve these qualifications. its immoral, we need homegrown solutions, not bandaid solutions
It's real simple.Just look what happened to canada.
It's brutal. And somehow they've bought about 1/3 of the businesses in my small town of 9000, now 12,000.
The places they now own completely suck too and all of em drink and drive
@@PretENDOgolf We have companies owned by Japan and South Korea here.
Barnes lying straight out of the gate: "...this has always been Trump's position", except when it WASN'T; he said he would end H1B visas in the debates prior to 2016.
I was looking for this! You're correct.
When and where, time and date
@@VicKryMeg CNN Republican debate, if you listen to Kim Iversen's latest video on it, she plays the clip in the first couple of minutes.
People voted to reduce immigration, not to replace illegal immigration with legal immigration.
Also skilled doesnt mean theyre good at their job, it doesnt mean they have experience, skilled means they have finished a trade school, college or university as compared to menial labor.
He hasn't removed a person yet and now he's replacing Americans with foreign workers.
Even their quality of college talent was low. They were placed where they had not idea of the task plus a huge language miss match.
Reducing illegal immigration is what was promised and what was delivered in 2016. We have rational reasons to believe now that it will be any different. The argument is solely between those who want to reform legal immigration and those who want to ban all immigration. The allusion to illegal immigration is a red herring to distract from the argument of should we reform or ban legal immigration.
Like most things, people exploit loopholes. We know they'ed let in too many people who shouldn't be here. Even if lefties aren't involved in it.
We voted to end illegal migration freeloading off of social services.
Barnes is a good voice to balance things out. I enjoy his perspective.
Don't always agree with him but he makes you think
Great stuff as always. Barnes is so right to introduce the concept of caste into the debate.
Comment around 17 minutes is the reason I can’t totally accept Vivek’s initial statement. While yes our education system has major problems (that’s why I home school) there are far too many occasions where the natives are forced to train their foreign replacements, indicating they are more than capable to do the job.
The h1b salaries are also not reflective of the true market value, making it crystal clear this is about cheap labour not some spectacular talent (which I’m sure does still happen but are now the minority of h1b).
Furthermore, if the STEM education in America is so appalling, why do foreigners pay a premium to attend our universities to receive degrees in engineering, IT, etc., and then subsequently stay here after becoming employed?
Lastly, the rhetoric surrounding h1b would not have become so hostile if we didn’t have solid proof that the tech sector was deliberately discriminating against white males for the past decades (see James Damore, big tech censorship, etc)
This is personal, whites are being targeted for destruction, and like our forefathers, we aren’t going to sit back like pussies and let it happen without a fight.
You haul to understand the white man has constantly been told he can't have this or that job because of affirmative action. Jess also been told that Americans didn't want to work in the field. Another life. This is the dame argument the slave holders used to keep slavery alive.
Do they make absolutely sure that there are no Americans that can take the jobs that are being filled by H1B visa holders? If not, that tells you everything that you need to know. Qui bono?
@fdprobie8554 Nope, as noted they'll post an advertisement in a newspaper, on a wall in the break room, or in a less than public space. Just to say they did. Also, they can post a job on Dice, etc. but make the filters so specific that no one local can apply for. Based on what I've seen, recruiters will tell prospective candidates to add things to the resume to male sure they get through. I don't unless it's something I've done or know. But I bet others don't care.
There are plenty of ghost jobs, they put up advertisement, filter anyone without specific keywords, demand insane experience and hang it up for months so they can say nobody can fill the role and htne its a-ok to hire somebody without all of the above requirements.
In 2020 I looked into how to migrate to Sweden. The rules were….1) have a bank account there 2) have housing (which they said good luck on a Swede renting to a noncitizen) 3) have to have skills in jobs they needed filled (Nursing was one). 4) have to speak their native language (even though, for the most part, they speak English)
So that meant I would not be able to move there! I have hard time speaking any language other than English. The other is I’m just a factory worker, no skills in medical.
Just identify with a third world man of fighting age and they’ll let you right in… Sweden is the gRape capitol of Europe because of the’cultural enrichment’ they’ve gotten… we need to fight it.
If only you spoke Arabic, and lacked even factory work skills. You could walk straight in & have the Swedish govt put you up at Swedish taxpayer's expense.
Why would swedes want you in there country? Nothing personal to you. More European countries & america need to act like Poland.
Well I spent over a year learning to code, only to never once be given even a response to any of the apps I put in. I gave up a while ago, but I am sure it never got better. Was a waste of time to learn to code, and I am sure if the H1B situation was different I would have at least gotten an interview.
Robert Barnes is an impressive person in his thinking. Well reasoned and pretty middle of the road. Kudos good sir.
The Deliberate Dumbing Down of America is a book that chronicles this issue. I mean, the US has a literacy problem. It never used to!!
It's the HR department I can assure you. I am a highly skilled and experienced Amwerican Elctro/mechanical designer and I can't get a look at my resume.
HR makes lawyers look like saints.
Maybe because you can't spell
@@RS-hh3ethes just making a quick yt post.. no need to be am asshole. He likely has 20 iq points on you
Sorry to hear that. I hope trump does find a good balance
@@RS-hh3et No, I can't; I am dsylexic and a terrible typist but I checked the spelling on my resume better than a yt comment but thanks for all your wisdom there sport.
If the argument is that the H1Bs are cheap labor, then why not require that they be paid the same as locals and contribute the same to the system to offset that advantage.
More incentive for employers to ensure that job applicants are actually qualified to do the job right and qualified applicants get paid their worth discounting national security and cultural issues.
But more importantly, fix the education system so the locals are more competitive.
Vivek just ruined any political career he may have wanted. I wouldn't vote fir him as dogcatcher
I never trusted him since I found out he had taken Paul Soros money for college.... the guy was already about 2 million dollars rich, it's not like he needed that money to complete his education.
Yeah. I was pretty disappointed in many voices on this including viva. What I took as these people grifting was not even mentioning Elons banning of all these people which was the most egregious of all of it. So we fought so hard to have a “free speech” and now are king can just decide to ban people cause he gets his feelings hurt. My dad was a programmer and anyone who knows anything about this is that Indian programmers are hot better, they are more affordable for corporations. I’m glad Elons finally was backed into a corner, saying “ok they should be payed what American workers get paid with a form of tariff added so corporations have to pay more for them” (paraphrasing) he could have lead with that, we wouldn’t have been so suspicious.
Say fake maga dems
What is interesting/instructive is that he unintentionally gave an insight into the mythic narrative that the US Brahmin community uses to each other to self-justify the otherwise ludicrous (and unjustifiable) degree of wealth and success that they enjoy through the absolutely massive amounts of nepotism, corruption and discrimination that they routinely practice as they collectively conspire to exploit the country for their own mutual benefit.
Should Libya hire Libyan doctors over Canadian ones to make sure Libyans are employed?
If you are better than an American at rocket science, Elon should be able to hire you, or else that American company will be worse off.
Let Eric Weinstein debate these fools
He told this interesting story about a conspiracy to decrease US scientists wages
Barnes nailed it. US schools treats "nerds" badly, usually violently. Foreign schools don't. US students aspire to be sport stars, YT influencers, anything that looks like easy $$s. Foreign students aspire to be CEOs, doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc.
No thanks. Certain kids treat high achievers badly out of jealousy, this is something true across countries and across all time. The schools aren't upholding jocks, this is a tired old trope. It's an excusal to further push down the productive people already here, and cut their wages by getting foreign labor.
He was restating what Vivek said.
@@alek4811 Vivek is not the first to say it nor notice it. It may have even been the NYT that, a few years ago, noted that when polling US vs Chinese students, there was a profound difference in future occupational outlooks. And it didn't favor the US.
@@brianmack6285this is laughable and naive. The CCP isnt letting everyone into schools, they will all be loyalists of some form or another, they will all be more skilled at whatever they are studying than the average of their peers to get in, and any communication from China to the NYT is certainly from the CCP. If you asked the same group of people here in America youd likely get the same answers (like you would if you went to China and asked the average chinese citizen and not a party member.
BARNES IS. BRILLIANT. HE SHOULD BE TOTALLY INVOLVED IN THIS ARGUMENT BETWEEN BANNON AND ELON
🙄🙄🙄
Enjoy your family. Thanks for all you do.
I’m glad Barnes is doing well. Has he spoken about his health issue? He says he’s fine and moves on. Is that him being stoic or keeping his private business private?
It has not always been trumps position barnes
Vivek and Elon, if they are geniuses, are not H1B, they would be O1. That is my understanding.
We all know - they are being deceitful on purpose.
Well in reality, musk barely qualified for h1b,.
he got bachelor of science in economics in 1997 which he got in us
and claims to have bachelor of science in engineering from 1995 which in reality is bachelor of arts in physics which he got in 1997.
@@davoodoo8042 He came over on a student visa, not an h1b. Did he overstay his student visa?
@@aurorab6796 thats not the point, when he came over he wouldnt qualify for h1b.
Ill go further he still doesnt qualify for o-1, elons no genius and im less familiar with vivek but ill hazard a guess he wouldnt qualify either.
@@davoodoo8042 Point is he's lying.
Immigrants work hard, but the quality of their work is poor. I would prefer to pay more and employ Americans. Overall the living standards of Americans will rise if we employ Americans.
Viva just said he agrees that oblivious MAGA Republicans are gullible... he said he can't disagree with that statement, so that means he agrees that MAGA people that have a problem with Elon and Vivek importing foreigners to take American jobs are "oblivious MAGA Republicans who are gullible".
So, he's saying we are ill-informed, but he is here to lecture to us and teach us bigots what is what.
He's a fool. Importing the middle class labor force is even worse.
@@angelmartin7310 he's a jackass tgat can his happy ass back to Canada. He lost his country by being a coward...now he wants us to bow down. I'll hold for Barnes but I'm done with this clown.
You are a fool. He is saying you're too busy screaming to see the argument: Do we ban LEGAL immigration or reform it? That is the discussion.
@@angelmartin7310 Even though that was what they took issue with.
@@hilkmeister1382 No, Stew Pid. He's saying he agrees with the guy that there are MAGA people who are gullible because they are angry for Elon and Vivek putting FOREINGERS FIRST. You want me answer, STOP IMMIGRATION. Just stop it. Work out the problems and get rid of the illegals and all those taking American jobs and many years from now open it up to legal immigration again, very carefully, slowly. You don't like that, who cares.
Viva and Barnes are best when they do Viva and Barnes
Elon praised the nerd from Saved by the Bell. Bad example as Zack, the cool kid, blew Screech out of the water on the SATs, scoring over 1500 compared to the “nerd’s” score of like 1200.
Bottom line, the cool kid was FAR smarter than the nerd Elon was praising.
The notion that nerds end up running things when they grow up just isn’t true because nerds often lack the necessary leadership skills to run successful businesses.
That intro continues to suuuck...fast-forward.
I skip to Barnes.
I don't mind it other than it gets old.
@@hilkmeister1382 It's a bit too long. Needs to cut it.
@Selvarin My brother has hair that long. It is fine.
@@hilkmeister1382 The intro. THE INTRO needs to be ✂️. Not Viva's hair, haha.
Ireland has been importing indian IT workers wholesale for US IT companies who set up in Ireland to avoid taxes.
Hey Vivek, show your true colors and trade H1B visas for Pharma patent reform. Greed works both ways brother. Your got rich off patents which are, by definition, anti competitive and anti free market. Limit them to 5 years max, or shut the hell up about free markets. Hypocrite.
Idk if that holds. Ya need some form of patent to incentivize investment of long term high risk projects- otherwise the npv doesn't work
@@christiansgrignoli3351 Sure but 20 years for patenting a plant? or chemical from the congo? Libertarians disagree. At the most give 5 yrs. Or, 5% royalty payment from anyone who wants to use any patent.
The video of the woman walking up to JT is phoney as hell. First of all he has several layers of security, so she would not have been able to just walk up to him. The security around him would mean that his locations are planned in advance, and security cleared hours in advance. So that is fake. No way a random woman just called to him and then walked across a parking lot to him. Then there’s the matter of the autos in the parking lot. He travels everywhere with a motorcade. This is just theatre.
I think so too. Set up so he could get victim points.
Yep
Stop saying the only qualified tech workers have college degrees.
Viva why can't they just come in the way you did? Why do we have to subsidize and expedite it?
Viva. People are just showing the similarities between cheap labor for big agriculture (cheap illegal labor) vs h1b bit tech big pharma (cheap legal labor)
The intro music is horrible.
Elon Snowflake ❄️....and Vivek Swampy can't be trusted...I lost deep respect from both of them.
Viva, he was a "Christian" naturally the corrupt government would deny his asylum.
The problem isn't the H1B visa itself, the problem is the lack of scrutiny, enforcement, and penalization, when it is abused, not used for it's intended purpose.
You are defending the indefensible. Canada is a great example of how this goes pear shape.
elon lying
There is no way I want anyone in my house, around my kids, or working in my yard who receives a low wage. It isn’t safe because desperate people do desperate things. Pay fair wages to everyone.
Thats a socialist trope. Poverty doesnt create criminality. Bad morals, bad culture do. All of my anscestors were destitute by my standards. Period. Most of them were fantastic people. And people should be paid fairly. Which happens most of the time leaving just the trope rattling in your head. Simple as
What is a low wage?
@@jeulihonodel7626 Minimum wage. Whatever you yourself would do the job for is what you should probably pay.
@@missykins3193 poverty is not the root cause of criminality. And apparently i cant name the root philosophy you derive that trope from without censorship. But i’d wager you know it as you speak it
@@jeulihonodel7626 poverty is not the root cause of criminality
Majority of H1B visas are obtained by Indian tech companies based in the USA and guess which type of workers they hire?
I've worked with a few people on H1B visas. One was phenomenal with his skills, the majority of the rest are trash. But Elon did explain it right, minimum salary requirements and a higher Visa fee charged to the corporations.
This is all besides the point.
Nobody voted because they want H1B increased. The government was given a clear mandate.
However, they instead choose to focus on an issue that there is clear pushback over. This alone is enough to show that they do not have the American citizens' wellbeing as their main focus.
All the "guestworker" visas should be ended. The Einsteins and Von Brauns can be "parolled" in on a case by cases basis.
The education system here will never be "fixed" until there is no other option.
In a world where 3 different billionaires have their own space program American citizens don't need to "fix" their immigration system for the benefit of foreigners or the billionaires.
That woman who confronted Turdeau, I'd say she held back. She should really have let him have it and should not have stopped at just telling him to F off. Canadian's need to get more excited.
If there's no qualified American, you go with an H1B. The problem is, that's not what happens. At least not in Canada, where we have a similar system.
It took FOREVE for my husband to get his first engineering job, despite having earned the most versatile, and most challenging, engineering degree offered in Canada.
His cousin got a degree in civil engineering, and after nearly a year of not a single interview finally said "fuck it" and took a job pruning trees.
If you look at the job postings, what you'll see is the inevitable result of H1B abuse (and other foolish HR practices).
Thousands of inexperienced new Canadian graduates are competing for a handful of entry level jobs. THOSE jobs are going to H1Bs.
The postings for experienced engineers languish unfilled for months, often for more than a year. Because Canadian engineering grads were pruning trees instead of accumulating experience as engineers.
It's short term gain that will inevitably lead to long term pain.
Barnes needs to speak with Trump
For what purpose as no offense cannot see what he would offer
Ever time one party gets in control they start fighting among themselves and very rarely gets anything done.
Democrats don't.
Oops, the mask slipped a bit... "useless theology degree."
I agree. But, what are a unique set of skills? General office work isn't a unique set of skills. Special eye surgery could be. So which is it?
Something we should debate, which was the point.
@hilkmeister1382 I agree, but the debate should be done before the bill is signed. Once signed, it'll be a bear to get reversed. And, what about the next POTUS reversing Trump's work?
@ We have time, 2 years in fact, to get this right BECAUSE of that. Better to take time now and get it right than to rush something through. Also a POTUS doesn’t have the power to overturn law and with the kicking they got I doubt they will try to play the other side of illegal immigration so soon.
Looked this up # 3 major us social sciences
#6 engineers
#7 computer tech.
1:09:54 Viva I'm sorry but Ontario is not liberal It is conservative It just happens to be Toronto's is mostly liberal outside of Toronto it's mostly conservatives it just happens miraculously that the liberals win with mail in ballot in certain areas
well said Viva !!! 🙏🥰🐢
1:18:30 FinCEN rule, not IRS. It’s been driving accountants crazy because we’re all afraid of the state bar suing us for unauthorized practice of law if we help our clients with this 😂
Big tech cares more about mars than America
H1-B was never designed for "unique set of skills". It is for workers who have a bachelor's degree, which in India is the same as an associates degree in the US because High School ends at age 17 and IT schools are 3 years.
The great majority of the H1-B software engineers could be replaced by smart, industrious, community colleges graduates.
I have been working as a software developer since before there was an H1-B visa. We used to have lots of musicians working in software.
Music and code require similar skills.
There is nothing about Indian culture that makes them better software developers than any other culture.
They come from a country that prints enough money to always keep their currency low compared to the USD, and that is the "secret sauce" of the Indian developer.
We have had season workers in America for centuries. As far as food.
It's only a matter of time before jobs are more automated. It's not really anything you can stop Just as the printing press grows, so do jobs become obsolete. If isn't done by the US will be done by others.
H1B visas are part of the President’s responsibility, Viva. 😢
its okay to have legal immigration, but this should be open to all foreigners to apply to see if they qualify, these special deals special visas have to go, these benefit the corporations not the country as a whole, no more special rights and deals, they are creating a caste system
Great thing to have a debate about. It's too bad that the demagouges will scream traitor at anything but total ban.
@@hilkmeister1382 Unlike you who calls anyone who doesn't agree with Elon and Vivek racists and what not. It doesn't matter, you are not worth listening to. A complete waste of time talking to sell-out traitors.
It should benefit me not hurt me. Politicians forget they work for us to benefit citizens.
No, we need to close.
@@TwistedQuestionMark your right we need to shut it all down at least until all the corruption is purged..
I think he should have. said: "Thank you! You...uh...cluck!"
Thanks Viva. ❤
I thought pardons MUST carry a name of person.
I'm an Airbnb owner with 18 units in Nova Scotia. My units are pet friendly but pets not allowed on furniture or bedding. I've operated 6 years and have (overall) excellent service from Airbnb...if you dont want anautomated response you need to use a telephone to contact a real person at Airbnb. My units are priced 30-35% below hotels who always escalate their prices in high season. Each of you are citing single negative experiences....Barnes if you were a founding member and only had one bad experience...is that enough to defame the organization? Doesn't seem fair to me
It’s just healthy debate y’all. The Left WANT the Right to fight, don’t give them that.
We have some Left right in the MAGA movement who do just fine splitting the base on their own, Vivek and Elon.
@@DV80s definitely not the demagouges screaming traitor.
So just be a doormat on issues you don't agree with? That's really stupid.
@marcusantoninus1838 your misrepresentation him. He is saying he wants healthy debate not a screaming match
Happy New Year, Gentlemen.
Sounds like Airbnb might be a good one to short? 🤪
So adding worker does not lower the overall wage level.
This is true whether it’s soldiers returning from war or immigrants looking to make a living.
Can Biden pardon a group of people without a name? Don’t people have to be pardoned on an individual name basis?
Wish that you guys had Tim Dillon on. He literally went through a similar situation with AirBnB, and has a background in real estate. He's also funny as hell and has an interesting perspective.
Kiff is a mistranslation of an Afrikaans word (South African language that developed from the Dutch settlers) Gif which is a name for weed. English speaking people in Durban couldn't pronounce gif so said kiff, which became a slang word for cool/awesome etc, so Kiffness is like saying awesomeness. (The g in gif is pronounced similar to the cr in croissant)
Barnes is on fire again! Woot!
Viva’s version of hell - being muted on his own podcast 😵💫😵💫😵💫
As I recall Viva wasn't gonna cut his hair 'till covid was over. ......well?
Covid isn't over yet, part 2 about drop
@SharkJumper88 trust viva to think ahead.
I have 3 friends across 3 states that have contracted Covid in the last 2 months😢
No they are not in the minority. Most of MAGA 66% agrees with no immigration or use of the HB-1 Visa. I dont agree with Barnes, I think he is sometimes a week behind the events as they occur. On this one Bannon is right again.
There is a range of solid middle ground to debate. I agree with bannon. Barnes is very reasonable here.
We need to flesh out what america first means - putting American citizens first above the multinational corporations profit
What's your source on that number? If like to see that. Is there a distinction between no immigration at all, some immigration, etc?
@jeffreycordova9082 to this point, I think there is a range of solid middle ground that would make many ppl happy- where we get the cream of the crop & keep Americans holding onto most of the good jobs. H1b is being gamed & manipulated for awhile now. I did not know this
Absolutely.
CANADIAN CENSORSHIP
Listening to Viva this morning for the first time in a while. This whole defense of immigrants in a skilled position is a bit unsettling. The issue isn't The skill, it's the loyalty. Viva, you have a very American type spirit, despite having been born in Canada. You also have an intelligent voice. So we are happy to welcome you. But you are an exception. The plain fact of the matter is that the last 100 years or so of US immigration policy has led to egregious abuses, and subversions of the culture. A culture which you have expressed that you value highly. America needs a moratorium on these policies of immigration, because it has been abused. And the abuse drastically supersedes the benefits you continue to point out at this point.
I am giving you the benefit of the doubt that this is just naivety, but you sound bought, and should really reflect on your points and the broader picture.
Robert, I've been following you, as the only constitutional lawyer I'd seen, since Kyle, who has consistently told the truth. There is a group of RUclipsrs who need a constitutional lawyer. They may pull it of on their own....but I feel it would behove you to pay attention. Lane Mayers Channel For Social Change, the Reluctant Prophet, and several other youtube channels would draw your attention to police and judicial malfeasance that, I believe, you would find interesting. Please investigate.
Yours truly,
-Mree
Nope you want a lawyer, call one hf
No help to keep your home , and moving in people from over seas. Open boarders and amass homelessness in country, dynamics, o.k.
Bannon is right.
Tesla obtained 724 H1B visas this year. Can you say "conflict of interest"?
Her name is Emily Duggan and she did a classy job
Viva are you immigranting?! 🎉
Never thought I would find myself in a position to provide Robert with information - in this case BOI. Sorry for the long data dump but it shows the clown show regardless this law.
Robert is referencing the first federal case in which the district judge in Alabama found in favor of a specific group. The big news occurred in the 5th circuit on December 6 when a district judge ruled the whole act of Congress unconstitutional. Emergency appeal by Garland to a 3 judge appeals court panel that ruled on December 23 that the previous decision was a stayed and the act was constitutional. Then, on December 27 the full appeals court overturned the 3 judge panel and stated it unconstitutional. In the meantime FinCen (BOI) website says you can voluntarily provide the information. This whole department and its database now with all of the private information they have collected needs to be e eliminated by Doge and the data destroyed (as much as you can destroy digital info- hahaha). The Trump DOJ needs to let this law lie dead in the water.
Is Elon an American?
Yes newbie he is
@@VicKryMeg when exactly was he naturalized? Has he been voting?
Dave smith washed lara loomer in the isreal/Palestine debate. Why do so many J push chaos?
I know you are cross Viva but he was with his children, I would have omitted the F words and just told him it was time he retired as he isn't wanted.
Michiu Kaku explains the situation very well if you want to look that up?
Michiu Kaku the cosmologist is getting into politics?
Viva is a BOSS-!! The man that brings Truth-^^^^ Thanks again Young man****
Love the intro Viva!
Woke right would be a rhino. Or would fit the rino profile with added wokeness.lol
There's no woke right. It's a dumb phrase put forth by lefties who want to remain relevant to their lefty friends.
Then why not just say Rino?
Woke right is the zionist right. How woke left treats lgbt & minorities- is how woke right treats jews. They are willing to censor speech