Only one I disagree with is urchins. I think the Tuxedos, Variegated (Pincushion), and Rock urchins are all great and reef safe. I love my captive bred urchin, and I collected the rock urchins from Hawaii. I hardly ever see them, but they come out at night and are super hardy. If frags are stable then they usually never knock them over. I guess the one flaw is picking up frags (mine hasn’t, but one day he might)
Worst impulse purchase was a small Synapta maculata (sold as "Jersey sleeves"), which I was told would make a great scavenger. A little of bit of research made me realise that there was no way I could cater for a sea-cucumber that would reach the size of a boa constrictor. Fortunately I was able to return it.
I had a pencil urchin which literally took over my 55 gallon tank. That little urchin did everything from murder a bunch of flame scallops by moving a massive rock on his own (breaking all their backs), to drilling a hole into the shell of my baby horseshoe crab and eating it. It was adorable but was responsible for so much death........ Flame scallops are beautiful creatures - provided you don't have an urchin to murder them. Sea apples are beautiful creatures too - not sure they belong in a tank however.
Sea cucumbers deserve a (dis)honorable mention. Little bit of an anecdote here but; When a small time pet shop in my town started to sell salt water stuff & had up a display tank, I talked with one of the owners about it. Turns out one of the 3 owners had gone on a whim and wanted a salt water tank, but figured he might as well use it as a business opportunity so he put it in the store and the other 2 owners were on board despite not knowing much about it, since only one other shop in a 50km radius had salt water stuff. Had a sea cucumber in it because he insisted on it apparently, knowing the risks according to one of the other 2 owners I spoke to. Next time I swung by out of curiosity a few weeks later, the display tank was gone. Asked about it and turned out the sea cucumber got overly ambitious in it's exploratory manners and got itself stuck against the output flow, happened overnight & it kamikazed the entire tank. Sure they're silly little things and fun to look at sometimes but I don't think a living moving log that's filled with toxins & irritants is worth those small benefits.
Though I disagree with a few topics you've discussed in several videos of yours, I still find your videos entertaining and knowledgeable. Some seem a bit more opinionated instead of factual, however it all still comes together in a direct and educational teaching. Stay well my friend from across the pond. Much love from Southern USA. ❤
My Peppermint Shimp which was a preventative for Aiptasia started eating LPS so had to go! I also probably won't replace my urchins if they die, they like rearranging things too much! 🤣 They did help through the ugly stages when the tank was maturing though!
U probably didn’t get the right species, as there’s a couple that don’t eat corals (wurdemanni I think) while others do such as the Atlantic peppermint shrimp
Mine are all the aptasia but also ate a beautiful rock flower anemone and started to eat a colony of frogspawn. He’s about to go bye bye or find a new home.
Why even mess with peppermint shrimp for aiptasia, when you can get berghia to do the job? The upfront cost can be a little steep but they get the job done and reproduce readily. I actually made money off mine.
had rbta's forever with clowns , in fact the only nems I've ever had consistency with; great characters, I do respect them far more than corals, I think just because they scuttle about :)
@@NinjaSushi2 they like just the perfect amount of flow and nutes over them whilst still being able to peek at the light so it can be anywwhere, tho usually i think they prefer an overhang whth thier feet in shade :)
Thank you for your honesty ! I have had a sand sifting arcaster starfish for 6 months and its legs are now shortening. I thought i was doing something wrong or that it was starving. I tried to give it some pellets / frozen food/ nori but it is moving away. You only gave me the answer : it is HARD to keep it on the long run no matter what…
Woke up to my conch upside down thrashing on an absolutely destroyed bubble coral which started a crash that cost half my tank. Love them, but never again.
Thanks mate! You are a fantastic presenter. Honesty is the great motivator. Paly's are wonderful, but I won't ever get them again. A simple Lighting change stressed the colony I had. It wiped out my tank with it's toxin. I have a ricordea left though. The fish survived as well.
Pistol Shrimp. I can't keep ANY coral on my sandbed without it smothering them with sand; Snipping at them or dragging frags into its cave. Had 4 giant coco worms on one side of the tank for a year until one day my pistol shrimp made its way over and ripped them all to shreds over a span of a few days.
4:53 remember the captive bread ocellaris clownfish don’t even host with anemones at all unless trained to. And I have seen ocellaris host with a bubbletip after sharing the same tank for years, so it doesn’t really matter what kind of anemone you use they’re all equally hard to get them to host with.
i love hermit crabs when i got into saltwater that was my 1st tank i had 4 or 5 diff kinds of crabs in my tank and turbo snails both did and do great together. snails have lived 2 to 4 years and never had any of my crabs eat them or even pick on them. most times just climb all over them and go for a ride. it all about the feeding. keep the crabs full and wont mess with other stuff in tank
My reef tank was doing really well, and I wanted a challenge. So I went to my LFS and bought a beautiful fire scallop, I put it in my tank, and it moved to the top of a rock and opened up, looking absolutely beautiful! I wake up the next day, it was completely open and was torn apart by the clean up crew, it died overnight. 😭
He’s pretty accurate, def double edge sword with all of these.. respectfully I say sea urchins are one the best inverts you can have if your system can handle it
Hermits aint an issue if you get Dwarf Blue Legs or Scarlet Reef Hermits. Use Banded Trochus snails instead of Turbos, Astrea ect... as when these fall Banded Trochus can re-right themselves instead of being easy pickings for a hungry hermit. Another trick with Hermits is to add some small snail shells to your tank for them to up grade to as they get bigger. Youll have a much better success rate and unlike other snails I have gotten Banded Trochus to lay eggs and reproduce regularly in my tanks the last 22 years. A lot of what you said about RBTA/BTA's is truer than not. I add them first to my tank before corals first of all. I also sculpt my rock work so that I have a couple of high points in my tank and various light intensity levels and flow. I then allow my RBTA to find its happy spot and they usually stay there pretty consistently about 95% of the time in a suitably aged tank. RBTA/BTA's will host 14 different species of Clownfish even if they dont normally in the wild. If you must get a Anemone choose the right anemone for your clownfish, and know this is for the more advanced hobbyist and not something for the beginner or someone new to the Hobby. If you clown doesnt want to host and you got the right anemone...tape a photo of a clown fish hosting in an anemone close to your anemone on the tank glass and the captive bred Clowns will usually figure it out pretty quick. I am so with you on the Urchin and the Lobster!!! They are usually a disaster waiting for a place to happen.
Some of my "not no but hell no's" are....Eels, Urchins, Octopus, Jellyfish, Cuttle fish. These are tough to keep, short lived or more for the expert aquarist in my opinion.
@@NinjaSushi2 Octopus's are too cool, just short lived and escape artist to the Nth degree. But fascinating none the least! Cuttlefish fall into that same category.
Something I regret buying and will not get again is a bi color blenny. I didn’t realize these guys eat SPS. I was wondering why my sps frags kept dying and all my parameters were where I wanted them.Passing by the tank and see my blenny going to town on a birds nest frag.
pretty solid list and i had bad experiences with most creatures on it. one that i would include is the Sally Lightfoot crab. they were considered reef safe and were heavily encouraged as cleaners back when i was new to the hobby. and they are excellent cleaners. but once they reach a certain size, they decide scavenging is no longer enough. out of nowhere, they can go predatory and become killing machines that make quick work of shrimp, other crabs, and small fish. and they're lightning quick as their name suggests. incredibly difficult to catch and remove
You can get a basic setup for less than $400 but this hobby will eventually have you wanting to spend more and more. I always said I would be satisfied with just two clowns and a decorative shrimp. 3 years later I probably blew close to $4000 in coral, small invertebrates and equipment I said I'd never want.
I have a formia red star. Had him forever. The trick is to feed them. Twice a week I feed him mysis, rotifers, and Cyclopes. Put the food right under them and they will live happily
The sand sifting star needs a minimum of 3 inches of sand bed in my experience and Need it to constantly be somewhat dirty if the bed is to cleanor they will die I drop a few algae wafers and bury them in the sand once every 2weeks
Strange, up north it seems the smooth skin Brittlestars (including the killer Green ones) are always referred to as "Serpents" & the non-smooth ones as Brittlestars.
My worst purchase HAS to be a chromodoris nudibranch, they only eat 1-2 species of sponge, and those sponges that it eats aren’t available in the hobby, making them impossible to keep. after a week it nuked my tank. I feel bad, knowing that it got taken out of the wild where it had a chance to live.
I'm going to have to disagree with the bta. Like with any other animal for a reef aquarium, you need to plan. For bta's it's best to introduce them while the tank is pretty empty. Try to find a spot they like and they shouldn't move as much. Use a power head protector to eliminate the risk of the nem turning into a milkshake. Make sure your corals are movable just in case it decides to take a hike. I really think bta's are gorgeous animals that just have a bad rep because of impulse buys and not planning ahead. Also urchins can be a pain but they are amazing clean up crew.
I had hermits with a puffer fish, sold the puffer to get corals, without app the extra food for them to eat that the puffer left behind, they to tearing apart my acans
@@PazLeBon but that's the point with clean up crews that I think Ryan's trying to make, people buy them to do a job then once the jobs done they starve and turn on other things. It's a learning process people shouldn't need to go through. I replaced the puffer with about 8 fish thinking they'd be fine but pellets and mysis isn't the same is half a clam shell
Worst purchase was a red foot algae snail in the early days. I bought it b/c it was pretty. It starved my turbos and all but 2 astreas that I had to trick into eating seaweed to keep alive and kept getting stranded on power cords from eating the algae off if them, refusing to come off for long until it starved to death as well. 55gal tank. Way understocked before the mass die off, I kept it that way ever since.
I have had so many different clowns that have never seen an anemone and they all took to the BTAs immediately. Also, when they go for a “hike” they don’t kill everything they touch. When they find a place they like then they start, but you usually have a day or two to move them. Other than that great video! (Although, in a good system coralline algae grows faster than a urchin can eat it.)
Newbie here; by no means am I saying they're bad as a species, but I bought a little feather duster a little while ago that only lasted 5 days. I dosed phyto feast daily, ensured it was in a good position, and it seemed happy during that time. Then one day it didn't come out of it's tube, nor the day after that. I decided to investigate and found nothing but an empty tube; definitely the worst invert I've purchased so far.
I have 2 red fromia, an orange linkia, and a dalmation linkia for almost a year and all seem to be doing good. I’m wondering if it has to do with the age of the tank because the tanks were over two years old when I first put them in there.
I bought 3 hermits as my first ever purchases. The ones with bright blue striped legs. All three are still going strong but I am sure they eat my snails! Could I put them in the sump or do they need good light?
Far worse than any of these, is anything that poses a serious threat to your personal safety. A saltwater supplier a few miles from my home learned about this when an unannounced specimen of Blue Ring Octopus turned up in an invert shipment. That one was VERY quickly donated to a public aquarium facility. They weren't going to sell that to a member of the public no matter how much money they were offered.
@@Guthumphred the small ones after a split are too small for the clowns too, so they end up splitting again down the line. Ideally we remove small ones til they are big enough to host
I have a 40 gallon anemone/softie tank. The solution to avoid BTAs being blended by a powerhead or wavemaker is pretty simple - I rely entirely on the return for flow. If I wanted to add a wavemaker, I would just choose one with an anemone guard. In my experience they just don’t need a large amount of flow. I would certainly think twice about having BTAs in a tank with valuable corals though. I don’t care if mine sting the fairly common softies I have. That said, that hasn’t happened yet, and there is a grand total of six BTAs in there!
0:50 not all hermit crabs are recommended for cleaning crew because people who know what they're doing would only recommend blue legged hermits or red legged hermits that are tiny and couldn't kill a turbo snail if it's life depended on it.
Who doesnt love hermit crabs? but even me who is a fresh water fish keeper who can only dream of one day owning a tank big enough for a 3 spotted damsel fish and being able to afford a salt water set up knows hermit crabs are hell to keep, most crustaceans and shrimp are even in fresh water fish keeping but the hermit crab is notoriously hard to keep alive apparently.
I literally left a dwarf zebra hermit crab (Calcinus laevimanus) in my refugium and forgot it about it, yet it still thrives. All it has to eat are algae and food scraps falling down from the main tank. I am guessing you are referring to terrestrial hermit crabs.
Just thought my gladiator clowns were weird as they choose to live in a branching hammer coral when they are surrounded by about 40 rbta 😡😡👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻good advice once again👍🏻
@@torispencer7237 fair enough.. to be honest tho,I have prob had as many mystery snail deaths if there's been hermits or not :D They are one of those 'easy' things thatseem to catch certain folk our for whaever reason
Sally lightfoot crabs. That's my only personal regretted invert. "Reefsafe-ish" is a crappy kind of gambling to play and when one does decide to, it may go on a murderous rampage and just annihilate whole coral colonies in one night that they ignored for 2 years. Crazy little bastards and an absolute nightmare to remove from the tank
I disagree with urchins and nems. Nems really only start to suck when they split. Getting them out is hard. But I have been very fortunate to have them find a spot and stay there for months and months, and my clowns live in 3 of them currently.
Why did you show and identify the coral banded shrimp, and not mention it? I have kept them with cleaner shrimp for 32 years in countless tanks with zero issues. Why did you show it?
They filter-feed on phytoplankton and other tiny particles in the 2-20 micrometer particle size range, which are normally lacking in reef aquaria. Normally, they starve to death in captivity.
Pretty ridiculous comment in the video about hermit crabs vs. snails. Yes, hermit crabs will kill snails when they want a new home. Solution? Scatter some empty appropriately sized empty snail shells in your tank. It's just that easy.
I rehomed my urchins today after a year because they were consuming every speck of coralline that appeared! Really liked them otherwise, but I want some of that purple goodness.
Why did you single out bubble tip anemones almost all anemones have the same problems and a way worse choice are harlequin shrimp because they only eat starfish
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
UK Coral Frags - www.prestigereef.co.uk
Aquarium Consultancy Service - prestigereef.co.uk/collections/merchandise/products/1-hour-consultancy
No benefit from sounds in background !
Only one I disagree with is urchins. I think the Tuxedos, Variegated (Pincushion), and Rock urchins are all great and reef safe. I love my captive bred urchin, and I collected the rock urchins from Hawaii. I hardly ever see them, but they come out at night and are super hardy.
If frags are stable then they usually never knock them over. I guess the one flaw is picking up frags (mine hasn’t, but one day he might)
lol it IS funny watching them carry peoples frags away lol
@@PazLeBon hippity hoppity your frag is my property
Worst impulse purchase was a small Synapta maculata (sold as "Jersey sleeves"), which I was told would make a great scavenger. A little of bit of research made me realise that there was no way I could cater for a sea-cucumber that would reach the size of a boa constrictor. Fortunately I was able to return it.
WHAT!
😂😂😂😂😂😂
"Feed me mother!"
I had a pencil urchin which literally took over my 55 gallon tank. That little urchin did everything from murder a bunch of flame scallops by moving a massive rock on his own (breaking all their backs), to drilling a hole into the shell of my baby horseshoe crab and eating it. It was adorable but was responsible for so much death........ Flame scallops are beautiful creatures - provided you don't have an urchin to murder them. Sea apples are beautiful creatures too - not sure they belong in a tank however.
Sea cucumbers deserve a (dis)honorable mention. Little bit of an anecdote here but;
When a small time pet shop in my town started to sell salt water stuff & had up a display tank, I talked with one of the owners about it. Turns out one of the 3 owners had gone on a whim and wanted a salt water tank, but figured he might as well use it as a business opportunity so he put it in the store and the other 2 owners were on board despite not knowing much about it, since only one other shop in a 50km radius had salt water stuff.
Had a sea cucumber in it because he insisted on it apparently, knowing the risks according to one of the other 2 owners I spoke to.
Next time I swung by out of curiosity a few weeks later, the display tank was gone. Asked about it and turned out the sea cucumber got overly ambitious in it's exploratory manners and got itself stuck against the output flow, happened overnight & it kamikazed the entire tank.
Sure they're silly little things and fun to look at sometimes but I don't think a living moving log that's filled with toxins & irritants is worth those small benefits.
Though I disagree with a few topics you've discussed in several videos of yours, I still find your videos entertaining and knowledgeable. Some seem a bit more opinionated instead of factual, however it all still comes together in a direct and educational teaching. Stay well my friend from across the pond. Much love from Southern USA. ❤
My Peppermint Shimp which was a preventative for Aiptasia started eating LPS so had to go!
I also probably won't replace my urchins if they die, they like rearranging things too much! 🤣
They did help through the ugly stages when the tank was maturing though!
U probably didn’t get the right species, as there’s a couple that don’t eat corals (wurdemanni I think) while others do such as the Atlantic peppermint shrimp
Yeah I bought them from an lfs that had bred wurdemanni so knew the species well and he was sure they where true peppermints but they still ate LPS
My peppermint shrimp would tear open my anemones to get the food I had just fed them 😭
Mine are all the aptasia but also ate a beautiful rock flower anemone and started to eat a colony of frogspawn. He’s about to go bye bye or find a new home.
Why even mess with peppermint shrimp for aiptasia, when you can get berghia to do the job? The upfront cost can be a little steep but they get the job done and reproduce readily. I actually made money off mine.
had rbta's forever with clowns , in fact the only nems I've ever had consistency with; great characters, I do respect them far more than corals, I think just because they scuttle about :)
My BTA is on the side of my aquarium right now. Never knew they'd stick to the side of the glass but it's been there for weeks. Lol must like it.
@@NinjaSushi2 they like just the perfect amount of flow and nutes over them whilst still being able to peek at the light so it can be anywwhere, tho usually i think they prefer an overhang whth thier feet in shade :)
Thank you for your honesty ! I have had a sand sifting arcaster starfish for 6 months and its legs are now shortening. I thought i was doing something wrong or that it was starving. I tried to give it some pellets / frozen food/ nori but it is moving away. You only gave me the answer : it is HARD to keep it on the long run no matter what…
I am with you on Hermit crabs. The Arrow head crab for me was an eating machine and not in a reef friendly sort of way either.
Woke up to my conch upside down thrashing on an absolutely destroyed bubble coral which started a crash that cost half my tank. Love them, but never again.
Thanks mate! You are a fantastic presenter. Honesty is the great motivator. Paly's are wonderful, but I won't ever get them again. A simple Lighting change stressed the colony I had. It wiped out my tank with it's toxin. I have a ricordea left though. The fish survived as well.
Thanks for tips. I just started my reef tank a few days ago I had an idea to bring urchin but I advised not.anemones too
All of them on the list aside from the anemone and starfish are recommended for begginers
Not all anemones are bad, I have been recommended flower anemones are safer than bubble tip
Pistol Shrimp. I can't keep ANY coral on my sandbed without it smothering them with sand; Snipping at them or dragging frags into its cave. Had 4 giant coco worms on one side of the tank for a year until one day my pistol shrimp made its way over and ripped them all to shreds over a span of a few days.
kills zombie snails too :(
4:53 remember the captive bread ocellaris clownfish don’t even host with anemones at all unless trained to. And I have seen ocellaris host with a bubbletip after sharing the same tank for years, so it doesn’t really matter what kind of anemone you use they’re all equally hard to get them to host with.
i love hermit crabs when i got into saltwater that was my 1st tank i had 4 or 5 diff kinds of crabs in my tank and turbo snails both did and do great together. snails have lived 2 to 4 years and never had any of my crabs eat them or even pick on them. most times just climb all over them and go for a ride. it all about the feeding. keep the crabs full and wont mess with other stuff in tank
My reef tank was doing really well, and I wanted a challenge.
So I went to my LFS and bought a beautiful fire scallop, I put it in my tank, and it moved to the top of a rock and opened up, looking absolutely beautiful!
I wake up the next day, it was completely open and was torn apart by the clean up crew, it died overnight. 😭
oohh, thats so sad :(
completely agree with your assessment. I dont keep shrimps either. They just steal food from my corals if they are not feed 1st.
Can you trust... a mysid shrimp?
He’s pretty accurate, def double edge sword with all of these.. respectfully I say sea urchins are one the best inverts you can have if your system can handle it
Hermits aint an issue if you get Dwarf Blue Legs or Scarlet Reef Hermits. Use Banded Trochus snails instead of Turbos, Astrea ect... as when these fall Banded Trochus can re-right themselves instead of being easy pickings for a hungry hermit. Another trick with Hermits is to add some small snail shells to your tank for them to up grade to as they get bigger. Youll have a much better success rate and unlike other snails I have gotten Banded Trochus to lay eggs and reproduce regularly in my tanks the last 22 years. A lot of what you said about RBTA/BTA's is truer than not. I add them first to my tank before corals first of all. I also sculpt my rock work so that I have a couple of high points in my tank and various light intensity levels and flow. I then allow my RBTA to find its happy spot and they usually stay there pretty consistently about 95% of the time in a suitably aged tank. RBTA/BTA's will host 14 different species of Clownfish even if they dont normally in the wild. If you must get a Anemone choose the right anemone for your clownfish, and know this is for the more advanced hobbyist and not something for the beginner or someone new to the Hobby. If you clown doesnt want to host and you got the right anemone...tape a photo of a clown fish hosting in an anemone close to your anemone on the tank glass and the captive bred Clowns will usually figure it out pretty quick. I am so with you on the Urchin and the Lobster!!! They are usually a disaster waiting for a place to happen.
Some of my "not no but hell no's" are....Eels, Urchins, Octopus, Jellyfish, Cuttle fish. These are tough to keep, short lived or more for the expert aquarist in my opinion.
@@raywells2858 eels are too bad though they can be picky eaters. Always wanted a Cuddle fish!
@@NinjaSushi2 Octopus's are too cool, just short lived and escape artist to the Nth degree. But fascinating none the least! Cuttlefish fall into that same category.
Something I regret buying and will not get again is a bi color blenny. I didn’t realize these guys eat SPS. I was wondering why my sps frags kept dying and all my parameters were where I wanted them.Passing by the tank and see my blenny going to town on a birds nest frag.
Subbed cause everything you say is no doubt 100% spot on. I'm right now getting my bta back to my lfs.
pretty solid list and i had bad experiences with most creatures on it. one that i would include is the Sally Lightfoot crab. they were considered reef safe and were heavily encouraged as cleaners back when i was new to the hobby. and they are excellent cleaners. but once they reach a certain size, they decide scavenging is no longer enough. out of nowhere, they can go predatory and become killing machines that make quick work of shrimp, other crabs, and small fish. and they're lightning quick as their name suggests. incredibly difficult to catch and remove
Agree on the hermit. Mine dwindled down to one and he eats every clean up crew I put in.. he even survived 6 months in the sump..
Always wanted to have these creatures as a pet. Never had the money so here I am watching the videos...
You can get a basic setup for less than $400 but this hobby will eventually have you wanting to spend more and more. I always said I would be satisfied with just two clowns and a decorative shrimp. 3 years later I probably blew close to $4000 in coral, small invertebrates and equipment I said I'd never want.
You are totally on point
Thanks for sharing. Great insight.
I have a formia red star. Had him forever. The trick is to feed them. Twice a week I feed him mysis, rotifers, and Cyclopes. Put the food right under them and they will live happily
The sand sifting star needs a minimum of 3 inches of sand bed in my experience and Need it to constantly be somewhat dirty if the bed is to cleanor they will die I drop a few algae wafers and bury them in the sand once every 2weeks
Loved this video fab facts included for newbies too
Strange, up north it seems the smooth skin Brittlestars (including the killer Green ones) are always referred to as "Serpents" & the non-smooth ones as Brittlestars.
I’ve had a sand sifting star fish for just over a year and I’ve only been reefing two years 😃
sand you mean
My worst purchase HAS to be a chromodoris nudibranch, they only eat 1-2 species of sponge, and those sponges that it eats aren’t available in the hobby, making them impossible to keep. after a week it nuked my tank. I feel bad, knowing that it got taken out of the wild where it had a chance to live.
nudi's are on the least at risk list so don't feel too bad :)
I'm going to have to disagree with the bta. Like with any other animal for a reef aquarium, you need to plan. For bta's it's best to introduce them while the tank is pretty empty. Try to find a spot they like and they shouldn't move as much. Use a power head protector to eliminate the risk of the nem turning into a milkshake. Make sure your corals are movable just in case it decides to take a hike. I really think bta's are gorgeous animals that just have a bad rep because of impulse buys and not planning ahead. Also urchins can be a pain but they are amazing clean up crew.
My flame scallop gets clean by my neon goby I think it’s fine it’s moved spots twice in 3 months
Really, really good video! 😀👍👍
I had hermits with a puffer fish, sold the puffer to get corals, without app the extra food for them to eat that the puffer left behind, they to tearing apart my acans
i might eat them if you starved me too
@@PazLeBon but that's the point with clean up crews that I think Ryan's trying to make, people buy them to do a job then once the jobs done they starve and turn on other things. It's a learning process people shouldn't need to go through. I replaced the puffer with about 8 fish thinking they'd be fine but pellets and mysis isn't the same is half a clam shell
@@Mark-hb2zy yeahh all good, ijust figured you could have added food for them ;)
I Have each and every everts he mentioned , and they doing FINE !
Worst purchase was a red foot algae snail in the early days. I bought it b/c it was pretty. It starved my turbos and all but 2 astreas that I had to trick into eating seaweed to keep alive and kept getting stranded on power cords from eating the algae off if them, refusing to come off for long until it starved to death as well. 55gal tank. Way understocked before the mass die off, I kept it that way ever since.
Norrisia norrisii
It's a coldwater snail too. Maybe its metabolism was out of wack.
i have seen some wild coral frags were i live they are so pretty they aren’t as rare as you would think seeing them in the wild
I have had so many different clowns that have never seen an anemone and they all took to the BTAs immediately. Also, when they go for a “hike” they don’t kill everything they touch. When they find a place they like then they start, but you usually have a day or two to move them. Other than that great video! (Although, in a good system coralline algae grows faster than a urchin can eat it.)
4:41 I thought that was a brute 55 gal bin
Newbie here; by no means am I saying they're bad as a species, but I bought a little feather duster a little while ago that only lasted 5 days. I dosed phyto feast daily, ensured it was in a good position, and it seemed happy during that time. Then one day it didn't come out of it's tube, nor the day after that. I decided to investigate and found nothing but an empty tube; definitely the worst invert I've purchased so far.
The bubble tip is great for hosting clowns. Poor choice for number 1.
I have 2 red fromia, an orange linkia, and a dalmation linkia for almost a year and all seem to be doing good. I’m wondering if it has to do with the age of the tank because the tanks were over two years old when I first put them in there.
Bubble tips have always hosted any clowns I’ve kept.
5:12 what was the name of coral that ate the clown fish?
Catalaphyllia? An elegance?
thanks 4 u r tips !
I bought 3 hermits as my first ever purchases. The ones with bright blue striped legs. All three are still going strong but I am sure they eat my snails! Could I put them in the sump or do they need good light?
your hermits or your snails?
I have three bubble tips, with two clowns living in them for the last 7-8 years. The only problem is that they split, so I've given away 5-6.
Far worse than any of these, is anything that poses a serious threat to your personal safety. A saltwater supplier a few miles from my home learned about this when an unannounced specimen of Blue Ring Octopus turned up in an invert shipment. That one was VERY quickly donated to a public aquarium facility. They weren't going to sell that to a member of the public no matter how much money they were offered.
My percs host my bubbletips, I say bubbletips as I started with one and now have nearly 30 !!!!! Grrrrrrr , now I want them all out !!!! Lol
if you have a guest at your house, who is the host?
I have a similar issue with my rose bubble anemones clownfish love them in multiple tanks but man do they love to split.
@@Guthumphred
the small ones after a split are too small for the clowns too, so they end up splitting again down the line. Ideally we remove small ones til they are big enough to host
I have a 40 gallon anemone/softie tank. The solution to avoid BTAs being blended by a powerhead or wavemaker is pretty simple - I rely entirely on the return for flow. If I wanted to add a wavemaker, I would just choose one with an anemone guard. In my experience they just don’t need a large amount of flow.
I would certainly think twice about having BTAs in a tank with valuable corals though. I don’t care if mine sting the fairly common softies I have. That said, that hasn’t happened yet, and there is a grand total of six BTAs in there!
I laughed so hard on the Reef lobster bit....LOL
0:50 not all hermit crabs are recommended for cleaning crew because people who know what they're doing would only recommend blue legged hermits or red legged hermits that are tiny and couldn't kill a turbo snail if it's life depended on it.
I hate my hermit crabs, I have one that is really cool, but my red tipped hermit crabs just kill stuff
(snails, shrimp, etc)
Who doesnt love hermit crabs? but even me who is a fresh water fish keeper who can only dream of one day owning a tank big enough for a 3 spotted damsel fish and being able to afford a salt water set up knows hermit crabs are hell to keep, most crustaceans and shrimp are even in fresh water fish keeping but the hermit crab is notoriously hard to keep alive apparently.
I literally left a dwarf zebra hermit crab (Calcinus laevimanus) in my refugium and forgot it about it, yet it still thrives. All it has to eat are algae and food scraps falling down from the main tank. I am guessing you are referring to terrestrial hermit crabs.
Astrea snails on the glass and blue legged hermits on the bottom. None have ever eaten any of my snails.
0:35 what kind of hermit crab is that? with the big black & white claw
Calcinus laevimanus
Reduced my hermits from like 10+ to 1 small one
I've had 2 sandsifting starfish in a 125 litre for over a year now. Worried to move them over to my 770 litre now.
0:34 I LOVE HERMIT CRABS >:(
You’re so funny but also so right. I answered, “Yes, I’ve had starfish that have lived for very, very long.” And then, “……yes, I have no idea why.” 😂
welp..... WE GOT'EM
Just thought my gladiator clowns were weird as they choose to live in a branching hammer coral when they are surrounded by about 40 rbta 😡😡👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻good advice once again👍🏻
It’s taken me six reef tanks to realise life is so much better for my snails and LPS corals without hermit crabs and shrimp.
most things will eat smails sometimes if they are hungry, be they fish or verts. Doesnt make them the natural choice
@@PazLeBon I know but removing the snails “apex predator” in your tank cuts down carnage 🤭
never actually associated snall deaths with hermits... were just oneof those mysteries we deal with so who knows :)
Agreed. I know what they're capable of. I'd rather not find out if that's true from experience
@@torispencer7237 fair enough.. to be honest tho,I have prob had as many mystery snail deaths if there's been hermits or not :D They are one of those 'easy' things thatseem to catch certain folk our for whaever reason
Emerald crabs. They say reef safe, but I've purchased them multiple times just to find out they would trap and eat my fish and pick at my coral.
My ocelaris live in my sherman BTA'a. The only issue I have is they reproduce too much and take over
question: did you say that catophilia coral kill fish?
OK what is the best anemone for a porcelain anemone crab?
I would say sand stars are pretty good
Im glad u mention hermit crabs indeed never again throwing coral around monsters are them
I have a bubble tip that host my orange and black clownfish
wait what ate your clownfish?
Good list
Thoughts on pistol shrimp?
Whew me and my long tenticle anenome are safe.
Since i dont own a bta.
Sally lightfoot crabs. That's my only personal regretted invert. "Reefsafe-ish" is a crappy kind of gambling to play and when one does decide to, it may go on a murderous rampage and just annihilate whole coral colonies in one night that they ignored for 2 years. Crazy little bastards and an absolute nightmare to remove from the tank
I disagree with urchins and nems. Nems really only start to suck when they split. Getting them out is hard. But I have been very fortunate to have them find a spot and stay there for months and months, and my clowns live in 3 of them currently.
Why are flame scallops a terrible choice?
They filter-feed on phytoplankton and other tiny particles in the 2-20 micrometer particle size range, which are normally lacking in reef aquaria.
100% agreed with the damn hermit crabs 😤
Why did you show and identify the coral banded shrimp, and not mention it? I have kept them with cleaner shrimp for 32 years in countless tanks with zero issues.
Why did you show it?
I’m sorry bud but all of my clownfish have been hosted by my bubbletips.
Probably flame scallop. I love it and it’s not that bad but it keeps blowing my sand around
Wait why are flame scallops bad? They look so cool.
They filter-feed on phytoplankton and other tiny particles in the 2-20 micrometer particle size range, which are normally lacking in reef aquaria. Normally, they starve to death in captivity.
ive done nothing and my tank was dead for like a year and the sandshifting survived and lived for almost 4 years
Conches, always climbing on my rocks and knocking down my sps corals and suffocate them to the sand 🫤
Pretty ridiculous comment in the video about hermit crabs vs. snails. Yes, hermit crabs will kill snails when they want a new home.
Solution? Scatter some empty appropriately sized empty snail shells in your tank.
It's just that easy.
I rehomed my urchins today after a year because they were consuming every speck of coralline that appeared! Really liked them otherwise, but I want some of that purple goodness.
Haha, and I also rehomed my BTA today too! Mainly because I wanted the real estate.
@@so_so_reef how did you get the BTA out?
coralline badness. Kills your pumps, motors etc and sucksup the desired nutes from your tank, if it waaas green people would cry :)
My lobster is to shy for any thing you said soo i guess there all diffrent hes 5 years old now bought as a baby
Lol maybe she
I’ve found out that if I feed the star fish a shrimp every two days , they service
What Ate your platinum clown male ??
Catalaphyllia coral, AKA Elegance Coral
@@kwajrod thank you
🤣🤣 I bought a reef lobster 2 weeks ago and im yet to see it
Hey your that guy from the Reef Dork show
Hermit crabs full stop. They have full soccer hooligan energy and drive my whole tank nuts.
I think number 1 is why anemone and clownfish only tanks are becoming popular.
hmm.. blue damsels, Six line wrasses, (relentless bullies) some annoying hermit crabs that just annoy some corals like duncans, alveoporas.
My reef lobster killed every fish in my 100 gal a total of 8 kills mans was insane
I've had all of those problems if only you made this video 2 years ago lol
Maroon clownfish host bubble tip anemones in the wild.
Why did you single out bubble tip anemones almost all anemones have the same problems and a way worse choice are harlequin shrimp because they only eat starfish