What is Autopilot, really?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 май 2024
- Some say The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has taken an overly deferential approach to industry in an era of profound automotive innovation, one that promises to make driving easier but creates new risks on the road. Nearly a decade since Tesla first rolled out Autopilot, the agency has yet to set basic standards for self-driving technology.
“Their risk-averse approach to regulation puts drivers at greater risk on the road,” Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), who has long called for more safeguards for driver-assistance systems, said in an interview. “They live in fear of potential criticism or opposition, and that’s just no way for a regulator to view the world. The Elon Musks of the world are not going to just sit still.”
If we add a legal definition to autopilot, can companies like Tesla be sued for false advertising?
can but won't be charged, I assume ... unless we push for it
but we don't care about Epstein's list so will we care about autopilot definitions/Tesla?
Wouldnt Tesla just pay enough senator to make the definition of autopilot the thing that thye do?
I imagine they’ll just change the name of it once the regulations change. Very unlikely that it would be retroactive
No they can't be charged because laws don't work retroactively.
@@mariox204 But they have and have cancelled "Autopilot" features. The thing is if there is a legal definition, Tesla can't twist theirs
The facts that it’s literally 10 people as well….
I’d say ten times that number would be more reasonable
@@KSHAWKTo give permission? 1 person is enough.
@@adenm89631 person would review every such system then give permission? The backlog would be insane
As a non-American, I am flabbergasted to know how underfunded an organization can be when it is literally an organization about cars in a country so deeply reliant on cars.
The same people who love car dependency are the same people who want less government oversight on their vehicles
More public transit, better managed bus systems, and a pedestrian centric infrastructure development is the correct trend
You think that’s underfunded look at our social security system
Banks contract previously convicted bank robbers to do security analysis all the time. Bad analogy aside, he is right. Companies need to be regulated by an unbiased independent like the IEEE or they will just do the bare minimum to maximize sales.
A better analogy was how the EPA used to literally just ask natural gas companies how much was lost to methane leaks... and that went exactly as you'd expect
Banks do contract bank robbers, but not on whether or not they meet a given governmental regulation - more about whether or not the regulation is insufficient and that more stricter controls would be beneficial.
Why do you think any company should do more than a bare minimum? I mean they can if they want but the regulations have a set of requirements that need met, not some magical more amount.
@@sumduma55 The bare minimum is much smaller than we often expect it to be, and it's *definitely* a problem if the company gets to define what the bare minimum is.
@ZT1ST I don't think you understand. If the law or rule says do not rob banks, all I have to do is not rob banks. I don't have to surpass that threshold and donate time or money to some charity in addition to be in compliance.
Seriously, I love that your group at the post do these videos. Thank you, for putting out good information in a fun way.
Btw, famous DuPont (the people who made Teflon) were told to self certify aswell, and got away a lot like deeming the chemical safe, and illegal dumping.
On a totally unrelated note: that jacket looks so great!
Knitwear prophet. White v-neck sweater vest worn as a shirt never forget!!
The name autopilot was chosen deliberately because it’s already an established term with clear limitations.
We understand already that autopilots are fine for everyday flying, but when pilots are doing something intensive or if something goes wrong, they fly the plane by hand.
This is roughly what we need to do with self driving cars already - the name sets more realistic expectations than something like “autodrive” which might lead consumers to believe the whole process is fully automatic and will never require intervention.
Me who lets my dog drive,
Yeah I got the advanced model
Want to upgrade to an eagle next, just got to find one 👍
This works even better if you name your pupper "Otto."
When my mind goes into autopilot while driving, cars seem to crash a lot. Must be a programming error
Yeah, it’s definitely programming
Tire wear is also self certified also. i think there are many products that are self certified.
Natural and artificial are both defined by the FDA for food. That’s actually a huge misconception.
Yes, but there's a lot of wide open spaces for what's considered "natural" - room enough to "autodrive" a Tesla through.
Also, if you've got that song by The Chicks in your head, you're welcome!😆
@@notorioustori Love the reference, but the regulations are actually pretty tight. CFR 21 Section 101.22 defines natural and artificial for flavoring and coloring.
For example subpart A(3) states: "The term natural flavor or natural flavoring means the essential oil, oleoresin, essence or extractive, protein hydrolysate, distillate, or any product of roasting, heating or enzymolysis, which contains the flavoring constituents derived from a spice, fruit or fruit juice, vegetable or vegetable juice, edible yeast, herb, bark, bud, root, leaf or similar plant material, meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products, or fermentation products thereof, whose significant function in food is flavoring rather than nutritional. Natural flavors include the natural essence or extractives obtained from plants listed in §§ 182.10, 182.20, 182.40, and 182.50 and part 184 of this chapter, and the substances listed in § 172.510 of this chapter."
This isvhow we had the pipline breakage tuat lead to the "junk shot". The safety contact everyone had to have was the same person copy-pasted into each oil company's website. Unfortunately he'd been dead for years and none of the "self-regulating" companies took notice. So no, they shouldn't be allowed to determine that for themselves. The threshold would be beneath the floor level.
Self certify is the same thing the FAA did with Boeing and look how that turned out 😭😭😭
My Dad always used to say that the most dangerous place in the state of Connecticut was the space between Richard Blumenthal and a camera.
This in my opinion is something that doesn’t need regulation, at least in teslas, autopilot requires you to be paying attention to the road already, and if you aren’t and something happens you can’t plane the autopilot. The same should go for other cars.
If we're going to regulate human drivers why should we not also make sure computer drivers are up to standard? Anything that has autonomous control of a moving death machine should at least be checked out before going to the consumer.
10 PEOPLE???? 10!???
My local Wendy's has more employees than a government agency
A little misleading. Self certify just means that the OEM is responsible for ensuring they comply. They can still face heavy penalties if caught. It's more like "The bank doesn't lock the vault, but if you steal and get caught, you're still going to jail."
Yeah, it will be fine....
Self certification is fucking ridiculous. No company in history will admit to wrongdoing on it's own.
In Europe it's much simpler. Autopilot is illegal :D
I tend to take internal certifications with a grain of salt.
Sounds like how the building industry operates.
New tecnologies take time to be understood and then regulated.
they just need more
...kickback$
Insurance companies have been regulating safety systems in cars for a really long time. I don’t really see this as an issue as long as autopilot is being regulated by someone
This stops being news when you don't understand self certification. It's a question of how liable the company will be held if it fails to meet standards. Having someone else certify doesn't equal better, and certainly isn't guaranteed.
It is amazing how much the goverment screws up, but we still think that giving them more power will make things actually work😂
self-driving cars are inevitable. They will replace most transportation jobs, and the US economy is not prepared for that
I self certify that my box car is safe
Promoting TikTok is unethical, y’all should remove the bottom part of that sign. Loved the bit though 👍
Whats with people saying “Oh he expensed X/Y” ?
What did Washington post do☠️
We need self driving cars so kids can gamble online via loot boxes while they are on their way to school.
The "natural" on all products is such a sham, it enrages me. Oooooofffff
I'm using Autopilot in LA traffic and it's AMAZING!!
Tesla is saving lives people....
No, Tesla is causing accidents and killing people. That's just a proven fact.
10 people are responsible for federal driving laws... yeah, they need help.
What’s with the “bank robber” bullshit? It’s a “self certify”, as in they certify themselves that they are following the regulations. Thus it would actually be like a normal civilian “certifying” that they aren’t going to rob a bank.
10 people in charge of keeping the most rich conniving and powerful companies in check. Sounds like something the government would do. It’s the same thing with doing your taxes the government never gives enough manpower resources for people to actually double check whether rich people are evading taxes or not but it’s very easy to catch a person who makes maybe 150,000 or less compared to trying to go through a billionaires tax records
I'm okay with Volvo self certification...but GM self certify, Heck No!!!!
Tesla is literally requiring a subscription for self driving, now what if tesla deactivates self driving on your car when you are on the highway, or just deactivates it even tho you physically cannot drive a car fully because of your handicap...car companies using subscriptions should be fined for 110% of their income the last decade
Tesla autopilot means basically the same thing as plane autopilot; it can take care of most functions, but you still have to pay attention, and if something nonstandard happens, the pilot has to immediately take control again. I don't know where people got the idea that autopilot (as a term) means full, total, constant computer control.
Now, Full Self Driving, THAT'S a terrible and misleading name.
Got to love the capatlist mindset; "just relaese it, well figure out the laws as we get the lawsuits"
A comment for the algorithm.
Apparently NHTSA is supposed to be pronounced "nitza". Because it doesn't matter if people understand you, as long as it's less than 3 syllables. /sarcasm
This food is natural… naturally artificial 😂
What words mean is the dictionary's job. It is up to the government to use the dictionary to be clear in their intent. 📖
Is this normal?
Or Boeing certification of their own planes #faa
But……. freedom………..
You eatched =3 when you were younger
Be careful about the conracts you don't sign or explain well. Learn more. ❤
Wow bias might be showing with that analogy.
No don't give anything more power in the government
that self-certify shit is SO DUMB. You're supposed to have experts on Government Payroll look at the shit then say whether or not it meets the standards placed by the government
Am i first what there is no comments wlso cool short also why is there a timtok in the backround
Or like asking a genocidal Apartheid state to certify that they're not committing genocide. Germany probably would have done the same thing given the option.