Is Saying "Ya Muhammad" a Sin? || Dr Muhammad Salah

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 янв 2025

Комментарии •

  • @noahboah2310
    @noahboah2310 2 месяца назад

    The Muslims who say Ya Muhammad they believe that only ALLAH creates the help. So it’s totally different. And Allah teaches us in Quran that He creates Reasons which we can use. But the Muslim knows that Allah created the reasons, the result and everything. The Christian’s believe that Jesus is Creator, which is shirk.

  • @gamekid2420
    @gamekid2420 6 месяцев назад +2

    Shaikh you are not well informed
    Do you know what the Sahaaba RA cried during the battle against Musailymah qazzab… do you know
    Yaa
    It was YA Muhammada
    Infact they cried using his name
    Surely they knew more islam than you, infact Abubakr RA ordered them to do so because the enemy was also crying Allah hu Akbar
    So do u mean you know islam more than Abubakr RA and Khalid bin Waleed RA who was infact in the battle

    • @ayaansiciid765
      @ayaansiciid765 6 месяцев назад

      I Never hear what you said! Give me
      proof?

    • @gamekid2420
      @gamekid2420 6 месяцев назад

      @@ayaansiciid765 hear what
      U don’t know your history
      Go and look for it
      I am not here to spoon feed you

    • @ayaansiciid765
      @ayaansiciid765 6 месяцев назад +2

      @@gamekid2420 That is proof that you don't know what you talking about!!! But Don't say anything about religion unless you have A dalil (evidence).

    • @gamekid2420
      @gamekid2420 6 месяцев назад

      @@ayaansiciid765 I know how the Wahabis are close minded
      You won’t look for it yourself
      Here it is
      mām Ibn Kathīr says that on the occasion of the battle of Yamāmah, yā Muhammadāh (O Muhammad, help us) was the battle-cry of the Muslims. He adds that during the war, Khālid bin al-Walīd picked up the flag, and passing through the army positions, set out towards the mountain of Musaylimah, the Liar. He waited there for him to turn up so that he could kill him. Then he returned and, standing between the two armies, he shouted:
      I am the son of al-Walīd. I am the son of ‘Āmir and Zayd.
      Ibn Kathīr further adds:
      Then he raised the battle-cry current among the Muslims, which was ‘yā Muhammadāh’ (O Muhammad, help us).[13]
      In this tradition the Muslims are relying on the Prophet’s means and calling him for help, and the Muslims who are committing this act are the Companions. Thus to call the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) for help and rely on his means was a practice of the Companions.
      [13]. Ibn Kathīr, al-Bidāyah wan-nihāyah (5:30).

    • @gamekid2420
      @gamekid2420 6 месяцев назад

      @@ayaansiciid765 here read
      Imām Ibn Kathīr says that on the occasion of the battle of Yamāmah, yā Muhammadāh (O Muhammad, help us) was the battle-cry of the Muslims. He adds that during the war, Khālid bin al-Walīd picked up the flag, and passing through the army positions, set out towards the mountain of Musaylimah, the Liar. He waited there for him to turn up so that he could kill him. Then he returned and, standing between the two armies, he shouted:
      I am the son of al-Walīd. I am the son of ‘Āmir and Zayd.
      Ibn Kathīr further adds:
      Then he raised the battle-cry current among the Muslims, which was ‘yā Muhammadāh’ (O Muhammad, help us).[13]
      In this tradition the Muslims are relying on the Prophet’s means and calling him for help, and the Muslims who are committing this act are the Companions. Thus to call the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) for help and rely on his means was a practice of the Companions.
      [13]. Ibn Kathīr, al-Bidāyah wan-nihāyah (5:30).

  • @humptydumty4975
    @humptydumty4975 6 месяцев назад +1

    True

  • @gamekid2420
    @gamekid2420 6 месяцев назад

    How ignorant the saudi trained scholars can be

    • @learnsulook4147
      @learnsulook4147 6 месяцев назад

      @@gamekid2420 these are spawns of khawarij

    • @gamekid2420
      @gamekid2420 6 месяцев назад +2

      @@learnsulook4147
      Imām Ibn Kathīr says that on the occasion of the battle of Yamāmah, yā Muhammadāh (O Muhammad, help us) was the battle-cry of the Muslims. He adds that during the war, Khālid bin al-Walīd picked up the flag, and passing through the army positions, set out towards the mountain of Musaylimah, the Liar. He waited there for him to turn up so that he could kill him. Then he returned and, standing between the two armies, he shouted:
      I am the son of al-Walīd. I am the son of ‘Āmir and Zayd.
      Ibn Kathīr further adds:
      Then he raised the battle-cry current among the Muslims, which was ‘yā Muhammadāh’ (O Muhammad, help us).[13]
      In this tradition the Muslims are relying on the Prophet’s means and calling him for help, and the Muslims who are committing this act are the Companions. Thus to call the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) for help and rely on his means was a practice of the Companions.
      [13]. Ibn Kathīr, al-Bidāyah wan-nihāyah (5:30).

    • @LisaD-yy4gq
      @LisaD-yy4gq 4 месяца назад

      ​@@gamekid2420That's incorrect. You can only call and ask for help from God not a person or a Prophet.

    • @AllthewayupG
      @AllthewayupG 3 месяца назад

      @@gamekid2420 God And prophet are not equal Only we say ya Allah swt To ask help.

    • @AllthewayupG
      @AllthewayupG 3 месяца назад

      @@LisaD-yy4gq I don’t know what people are doing online but this is really odd

  • @learnsulook4147
    @learnsulook4147 6 месяцев назад

    Then imam bukhary is spreading shirk