I wonder why? 🤔 it certainly couldn't be because they wanted the public distracted and focused on that and not on Biden's accusations. Certainly not. Especially since there's going to be elections again in 2024. Our world is run by clowns 🤡 , and we keep falling for their tricks, lies and false promises each and every time.
It's a too dangerous mission and the titan occupants knew that. They signed a contract, in other words no one needed to help them, which is a good thing. We were supposed to let them sink and just leave them there. The government was actually extra nice that day for at least bringing something back up to the surface.
Literally microseconds. This whole story is bogus and should focus on Stockton Rush and the massive hubris that trailed this Princeton legacy like toilet paper stuck to your shoe after you go to a poorly maintained public bathroom. Stockton Rush came from a very wealthy family, that had long gone to Princeton. He had degrees in mechanical and aerospace engineering, when what he needed was degree in marine engineering and naval architecture, as well as 10 -20 years in the Nuclear Submarine navy. It's one thing to risk your life, it's quite another to risk the lives of others who don't know any better. The public trusts engineers and as such we cross bridges and board airplanes because we trust that what they build is safe. The National Society of Professional Engineers, whose members sign off on drawings of bridges and buildings, states that “Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public.” In Canada, many engineers wear the iron ring, after swearing to “not henceforward suffer or pass, or be privy to the passing of, bad workmanship or faulty material,” as written by Rudyard Kipling and first used in 1922. Instead, we got lots of bragging about all the things he had done, such as fly DC-8s without being able to independently corroborate it. His money, privileges, and connections caused things in life to be greased for him. Sadly this caused him to think he knew things he didn't. I see much Dunning-Krueger effect here. @AMYTT
When the implosion happened, their death was instantaneous. Before the sub imploded, they had awareness of the problems going on...they knew , they were in trouble. They were trying to go back to the surface but the sub did not oblige. It was barely going up, while cracking in the structure. They were not likely physically affected as they had air to breathe, but likely they were afraid, they would not make it back to the surface.
He is basing all of this off some text that was released and supposedly claimed to be the leaked communications between the sub and the ship. None of these documents were verified, a lot of people believe that they were just made up. It's easy to Google and find, but it isn't official and is most likely just some idiot kid that wrote it up
That's what i'm wondering as well. Maybe the sound was caught by the titan's transport boat, or some other long distance equipment. Not necessarily the rescue team. Pretty sure i remember there being talk of a military equipment far away detecting the implosion. This being confirmed or not, idk.
Death was for sure instant.. but the question is if they got lost for a couple hours before sub finally imploded or were they just dead the minute they lost contact.
I can’t imagine how incredibly terrifying they must’ve been feeling when they weren’t going to be rescued in time, and their lives were about to end. Prayers for the losses and their families.
I hate being scared. As in surprised. So I would've been a mess waiting for something to scare the hell out of me. In reality I would've been dead quicker than it could even be processed. Pure anxiety
The ship is creaking and cracking, and about to implode from some of the most extreme pressure on earth. ''Quick, bang on the hull with that crowbar.''
maybe they were banging on the Titanium end cap (but not the window) because all these videos say the carbon fibre was the source of the weakness of the vessel, and the Titanium end caps themselves were fully intact
@@planetluna9554 I was about to say this. Previous passengers on the Titan sub said that is creaked and cracked* and banged as it got deeper. A frightening ride by all accounts. *the sound. Not actually cracking.
@@planetluna9554 not in this case.. the bangs they're referring to were being heard for hours, if not days, after contact was lost.. not to mention they picked up the implosion on acoustics too.. before this banging.. it's more likely this was the sound of debris hitting the ocean floor, or bouncing off something than it was people banging trapped alive inside..
this is the first time we actually got to listen to it edit: maybe im tripping? i thought this was the first time the actual audio was released to the public
Yea but if i don't remember incorrectly, they reported a lot of potential banging sounds, some which were both inconclusive and some which were found to come from other sources. If the investigation team has released this as a potential sound that possibly could have come from the titan so long after the event, it's probably because they now have more sure reasons to believe so. So yes. Old news with possible stronger evidence.
👱🏻♀Is it possible that they didn’t die instantly when the sub imploded ? and they kept banging on the wall after the sub imploded and died instantly . 🤔 Perhaps they swam to the Titanic and joined the survivors there . LoL 😂 🤣😂🤣😂 Great reporting
I remember thinking there was a chance they were alive, stuck at the bottom of the ocean and the banging was an attempt at morse code, but yeah, that thing imploded and that's instant death. Like, INSTANT instant. Doesn't get any more instant than that.
Exactly so i don't understand the video making it sound like they were banging. The ship was descending and breaking apart. The Navy confirmed. They don't know what hit them because it happened faster than they could blink. They just know there in the afterlife on the next blink.
The implosion happened in half the time it takes the brain to process pain. They were reduced to misty blood before their brain even knew they were dead
If that was them making scheduled rhymic banging sounds to try and communicate, wouldn't it make sense to bang the SOS morse code? They had a captain with them so I'm 100% sure at least one person there would be familiar with morse code.
We watched him throw it aside.....so weird, an Xbox controller. Is that the best he could do ? He was cutting corners while charging 250K, for the ride. Shish. An expensive burial at sea.
I hear many people confuse implosion with explosion. Explosion happens when the inside pressure increases pushing the walls OUTSIDE until the walls give way. Implosion happens when the OUTSIDE pressure is greater than the pressure inside forcing the Titan sub to be CRUSHED UNDER PRESSURE.
you forgot to mention instantaneously.. that is a key component of implosion.. there's crushing and then there's implosion.. just like there's expansion and then there's explosion..
Something probably went wrong with the submersible and they lost communication and control -- and that might have lasted a while. But once the hull ruptured - they were dead in an instant.
That timing has been evaluated between the time the communication stopped and the moment a military ship picked up a spike . They figure out, it was the implosion and it was not, long after, the contact was lost. That is good news as they did not linger too long, wondering if they could make to the surface. The implosion took a fraction of a second, without any pain.......they were gone.
We already know they didn't make it to the bottom before the vessel imploded because of the range of debris that was scattered.. if the banging that went on for days was actually theirs, this would mean they'd have made it to the ocean floor where the vessel would then be resisting the maximum amount of pressure it would endure. So this story is hard to believe in the first place..
The entire situation is horrifying. It's a great example of "just because you can, doesn't mean you should." It gives me anxiety when I imagine myself in their shoes, living out in real time this situation. Its crazy and hard to believe this is for "fun" and "educational." The Titanic is a corpse! It's decaying at the bottom of the ocean floor. Not much is left currently to look at anyway. It just doesn't seem worth the risk of your life. 😔
The part that gets me the most is that they couldn't even see the ship with their own eyes, there were no windows. They watched everything from a screen. It's no different than watching footage of the Titanic. They could have stayed near a beach, a foot away from the surface, driven around in cirlces while watching Titanic videos and none of them would even know the difference. It's like if you went on vacation and spent the entire time in a small hotel room and watched someone livestream going out and actually doing things. What is even the point? You don't need to be there!
That's way too clear to be possible "knocking sounds" coming from inside the sub considering it's got a fiber glass body and it's thousands of feet down
They knew they had trouble going back up. They had aborted the dive and were trying to go back to the surface, but it was going very slow while making structural noises.
That's actually false and as assumption at best. That transcript was fake and it was standard to drop ballast precisely where they did. They always did that
@@halroxdynasty8683 The guy that piloted M370 was suicidal. Historically, there's been many instances of suicidal pilots who took everyone down with them. This guy was a pilot all his life, and he even had a pilot simulator that he would play when he wasn't working. Theory is that he test drove many flights trying to find a route that would put him outside of radar. He never finished the route in the last game he played because he never intended to. So he knew exactly when and how to disappear so his legacy can be romanticized as a great mystery. Then he crashed in the ocean in the middle of nowhere.
Nah Stockton can rest in distress, it's 100% his fault with all the shortcuts and risks he took, that involved other people's lives. The other four however I hope rests peacefully.
The only comfort is even if it was them, it imploded so fast they didn't even know they were dead. So yes they were probably banging knowing something was wrong but when it did happen they were gone before they knew it. I guess it's some comfort
This might sound bizarre, but when I tried to imagine a sudden death without the slightest bit of forewarning--just an instantaneous end of one's existence--I found that even more disturbing than having at least an inkling before hand that one's end was nigh. I don't mean that I hope the passengers experienced terror. But Stockton Rush? Oh, yes. And I'm sure he did.
didnt we hear bout this month ago when it happen last yr i almost positive we heard bout this all b4 so what yall mean this is jus newly released recordings smh
The US Coast Guard and US Airforce searched for the lost submersible. Why didn't the US Navy participate in the search? The US Navy already knew there were no survivors. A US Navy submarine was listening on SONAR and heard when the submersible imploded. The US Navy knew there was no hope for the submersible.
“Most” of the time, multiple branches will not work together or at least divide up the tasks for an operation. In this case, the coast guard had assets in the water while the Air Force offered aircraft in the search. Also, the navy likely didn’t have assets close enough like the coast guard did, so it was just natural that the CG would take the lead
@@jamesbulldogmiller But what’s the submarine going to do??? Navy subs don’t reach anything past 600 meters compared to deep sea submersibles. The Navy did pass the information to the coast guard about the possible implosion they detected. That’s about all you can do
@@jamesbulldogmilleryes but what we consider close isn’t what a submarine might consider close. They detected them via sonar and some sonar sounds can travel hundreds of miles if not more. So that sub could have been a hundred or more miles away
They knew in their hearts what happened, but on the off chance they heard some random piece of sea trash or an outer component of the submersible implode, rescue crews had to keep searching. That’s why they didn’t tell everyone what they heard.
Even if it was one them banging ,it would not metter there was no way to help them at that depth. By the time any rescue reached the sub it would be to late
It is very possible they may have been alive for some time before the implosion. We just don't know what happened and likely never will. A total power loss is possible, which would have caused them to descend into an implosion. Either way, people love to dismiss everything and say "they went out fast". You simply don't know that.
That's most likely what happened so basically, they were sinking and didn't know exactly when it would implode AND that's when it imploded. It's true it was an instant, but they knew they were in danger.
I have read the information they gave us, that came from the mother ship. They were communicating and going down at a rather fast rate. Before they got close to the Titanic, the sub was seriously cracking so they decided to abort the dive and go back up. That was a problem as it was going up very slowly. The mother ship got in touch with the engineers, wanting to know, what they could do to go up faster. In the mean time, the communication between the sub and the mother ship stopped. That specific time was picked by a military ship that was monitoring sound waves in the ocean, nearby. They figured out, the spike they witnessed , happened at the time, the communication stopped. So ? it was the time of the implosion. They blew up , when they stopped communicating. It is a good sign as they did not mentally "suffer" very long. They had air, so they were breathing, just concerned about not going up, fast enough. That was it. Indeed the implosion killed them in a fraction of a second. No time for pain........gone.
@@-xxMelissaxx- Oh that's great, surely you can link these sources that state the Titan imploded IMMEDIATELY after comms loss and did not have any form of power loss at all. I'm willing to learn, show me the way.
Not true. Nato has audio of the sun imploding. It was within a few hours of leaving the surface. The sound has been analysed and is definitely an implosion. This noise is days later. Who knows who or what was doing this.
They say it in the very last sentence of the video - the sub imploded, and everyone died instantly. They were crushed so quickly and forcefully that there is 0 chance for any survivors. Unless the knocking is morse code for SOS or something like that, it wouldn’t change my mind
It was actually slow and painful, imagine sticking your head in a vice and slowly closing it shut, the eyes will pop out, skulk slowly crack, lungs decompress, body will feel like its boiling, eventually the head will explode like a grenade.
The death was so fast it probably was painless and they didn’t even know what happened. However the pure fear of knowing something was wrong and we’re in trouble and there’s no escape would be horrific! RIP
No, they died instantly. It's literally impossible for anyone to die gradually from a deep sea implosion at depths that deep. However, they likely knew something was terribly wrong and must've been absolutely terrified.
I doubt it was from the sub, mainly because it was in a solid rythem. And im sure I heard the sound was picked up after they confirmed the sub had imploded?
@LegitLaughs1 I mean does their lives really matter itbwas a bunch of rich men who stuck themselves in a tuna can for no other reason other then they were so rich they could
Pssst, They heard the Banging on Sonar Every 15-30 Minutes and Said that the Day It IMPLODED. However They Died Instantly as The Submersible Imploded, Banging was to tell Sonar they were in Trouble and a Plea for Help However once the Hull Breached it was Instantaneous Death and They Never Felt a Thing. So this is NOT NEW, infact it is the same thing that has been said OVER and Over and Over for a Year Now..
IF they lived long enough, repeating the message at certain intervals makes more sense than randomly banging frantically to get attention. But they died in the quick implosion- it wasn't them.
They might have known they were in trouble. *But the actual implosion happened so fast that their brains wouldn't have had time to process anything before disintegrating.*
Imagine if it wasn’t actually instant and instead they were being slowly crushed for 10 to 20 seconds in super deep water in pitch black and no way to escape drowning, that would be terrifying
@@anonymoususer1824 I know that’s why I’m saying “imagine” obviously at those depths it’s instant… I’m saying it as in imagine how much more scary it would be if it wasn’t instant and you were crushed and drowned in super deep pitch black water
I thought the implosion occurred before the search began? Unless it coincidentally didn't implode until they ran out of oxygen, there's no way that sound could have been made by humans on the Titan.
It was from someone/something else. Sound travels very far and efficiently in water. Since it was every 30 minutes it was probably someone who had a routine job. The US military heard the implosion and I believe the mothership did too.
1. When in the overall timeline was the banging heard 2. Just how consistent were the banging noises (same banging pattern at very precise intervals?) Not sure I’ve seen definitive answer to these simple questions.
If the two sets of two bangs we hear in the audio clip release were repeated at least 3 times at exactly 30 min intervals, I don’t think anyone could argue that they weren’t man-made sounds. Repeating twice is highly suspicious, 3 times is conclusive.
It's probably just more pieces of the sub breaking and imploding. There's no way someone could survive down at that pressure especially once the sub imploded
i doubt its from one of the passengers being in complete darkness you lose the ability to track time, no human will be able to do such tone in a constant 30 minutes cycle.
when I was growing up I had a digital watch that could display the time in the dark and it probably cost $30 at most I'm sure billionaires can afford a watch I think even sometimes older analog watches even from before I was born had glow in the dark material, so they would illuminate in the dark
Those banging sounds could have been something else. Since they lost communication around 3500 feet deep, that’s probably when the sub imploded. I find it highly unlikely after losing communication that they made it to the seafloor in complete darkness without the submersible imploding.
What I don’t understand is that the media and the government were dragging out a rescue mission knowing the fate of the Titan.
I wonder why? 🤔 it certainly couldn't be because they wanted the public distracted and focused on that and not on Biden's accusations. Certainly not. Especially since there's going to be elections again in 2024.
Our world is run by clowns 🤡 , and we keep falling for their tricks, lies and false promises each and every time.
It's a too dangerous mission and the titan occupants knew that. They signed a contract, in other words no one needed to help them, which is a good thing. We were supposed to let them sink and just leave them there. The government was actually extra nice that day for at least bringing something back up to the surface.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
The media was only reporting what they were told
Better to fund that than Ukraine.
My stomach literally is in knots as I imagine the sheer terror they must have all felt of their impending doom. Absolutely horrible!
Lies.
It’s bone chilling in all honesty…I love the titanic but hearing this on tv made my whole body shake and churn inside, truly was a tragedy.
My stomach is filled with joy as I think about them turning into slime
It was instant hun
Literally microseconds. This whole story is bogus and should focus on Stockton Rush and the massive hubris that trailed this Princeton legacy like toilet paper stuck to your shoe after you go to a poorly maintained public bathroom. Stockton Rush came from a very wealthy family, that had long gone to Princeton. He had degrees in mechanical and aerospace engineering, when what he needed was degree in marine engineering and naval architecture, as well as 10 -20 years in the Nuclear Submarine navy. It's one thing to risk your life, it's quite another to risk the lives of others who don't know any better. The public trusts engineers and as such we cross bridges and board airplanes because we trust that what they build is safe. The National Society of Professional Engineers, whose members sign off on drawings of bridges and buildings, states that “Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public.” In Canada, many engineers wear the iron ring, after swearing to “not henceforward suffer or pass, or be privy to the passing of, bad workmanship or faulty material,” as written by Rudyard Kipling and first used in 1922. Instead, we got lots of bragging about all the things he had done, such as fly DC-8s without being able to independently corroborate it. His money, privileges, and connections caused things in life to be greased for him. Sadly this caused him to think he knew things he didn't. I see much Dunning-Krueger effect here. @AMYTT
It imploded, not “exploded.”
I dont blame her it really isnt that serious of a description
@@myththenightmarefox3307 two different things though.
@@myththenightmarefox3307 ok @liesthedaydreamcat. Words have meaning, even if you don't.
Yes "imploded" is the correct term. But "imploded" "exploded" either way 5 lives were lost so I don't think exact wording is important here.
@@InsanitysApex You really woke up and chose to insult someone on the internet.🤦♂
When the implosion happened, their death was instantaneous. Before the sub imploded, they had awareness of the problems going on...they knew , they were in trouble. They were trying to go back to the surface but the sub did not oblige. It was barely going up, while cracking in the structure. They were not likely physically affected as they had air to breathe, but likely they were afraid, they would not make it back to the surface.
Ghosts don't exist, ghosts:
Good summary. No need to read any of the other comments here.
great summary thank you
How do you know this were you there
He is basing all of this off some text that was released and supposedly claimed to be the leaked communications between the sub and the ship. None of these documents were verified, a lot of people believe that they were just made up. It's easy to Google and find, but it isn't official and is most likely just some idiot kid that wrote it up
They were dead long before the rescue mission even started, no way that sound is from them banging on the haul.
That's what i'm wondering as well. Maybe the sound was caught by the titan's transport boat, or some other long distance equipment. Not necessarily the rescue team. Pretty sure i remember there being talk of a military equipment far away detecting the implosion. This being confirmed or not, idk.
Exactly. They even have audio of the implosion waaaay before this recording.
Nah they felt every moment of it.
Yeah banging from the haul
@@reznikdavis3180 it was literally one moment. It was a millisecond, literally not enough time for the brain to register pain.
First they said it wasn’t instant but by the end they said they died instantly.. That’s some quality reporting 👍
2:04 minuets worth.
Inside Edition is just a tabloid. It's not real journalism.
It would have been basically instant.
Their death was instant, but getting to that point where the sub imploded took some mins
Death was for sure instant.. but the question is if they got lost for a couple hours before sub finally imploded or were they just dead the minute they lost contact.
I can’t imagine how incredibly terrifying they must’ve been feeling when they weren’t going to be rescued in time, and their lives were about to end. Prayers for the losses and their families.
They knew they could not be rescued, well, the pros, knew. The tourists ? hmmm.
My prayers to them too😢
I hate being scared. As in surprised. So I would've been a mess waiting for something to scare the hell out of me. In reality I would've been dead quicker than it could even be processed. Pure anxiety
The ship is creaking and cracking, and about to implode from some of the most extreme pressure on earth.
''Quick, bang on the hull with that crowbar.''
funny....but yeah, it is what it sounds like.......people making crazy assumptions.
maybe they were banging on the Titanium end cap (but not the window)
because all these videos say the carbon fibre was the source of the weakness of the vessel, and the Titanium end caps themselves were fully intact
Couldn’t the bangs just be the submersible creaking and cracking before Imploding?
@@planetluna9554 I was about to say this.
Previous passengers on the Titan sub said that is creaked and cracked* and banged as it got deeper. A frightening ride by all accounts.
*the sound. Not actually cracking.
@@planetluna9554 not in this case.. the bangs they're referring to were being heard for hours, if not days, after contact was lost.. not to mention they picked up the implosion on acoustics too.. before this banging.. it's more likely this was the sound of debris hitting the ocean floor, or bouncing off something than it was people banging trapped alive inside..
we already knew about this banging lol it was the navy. this is MONTHS old news.
this is the first time we actually got to listen to it
edit: maybe im tripping? i thought this was the first time the actual audio was released to the public
Yea but if i don't remember incorrectly, they reported a lot of potential banging sounds, some which were both inconclusive and some which were found to come from other sources. If the investigation team has released this as a potential sound that possibly could have come from the titan so long after the event, it's probably because they now have more sure reasons to believe so.
So yes. Old news with possible stronger evidence.
@@sourrlemonsno its not man. It's been out 😂
👱🏻♀Is it possible that they didn’t die instantly when the sub imploded ?
and they kept banging on the wall after the sub imploded and died instantly .
🤔 Perhaps they swam to the Titanic and joined the survivors there .
LoL 😂 🤣😂🤣😂 Great reporting
@@sourrlemons no once they heard it they released a statement saying that it could be them or a animal doing clicks under water or just the debri
I thought it was released before. What do you mean just released audio?
There was audio originally released but it was investigated and it was determined to be just a whale cutting a fart
Watch the video they explained it
That was fake
They made it into a MP3 file
@@BrianShaneRushtonlol
My heart still aches for the youngest passenger.
Peer pressured by his 1d10t father
He was banging, "S.O.S" with his rubik cube...
They lost all lights & heat hours before implosion.
They were blind & freezing
I wouldn't call his father an idiot@@jwill5892
I remember thinking there was a chance they were alive, stuck at the bottom of the ocean and the banging was an attempt at morse code, but yeah, that thing imploded and that's instant death. Like, INSTANT instant. Doesn't get any more instant than that.
Exactly so i don't understand the video making it sound like they were banging. The ship was descending and breaking apart. The Navy confirmed. They don't know what hit them because it happened faster than they could blink. They just know there in the afterlife on the next blink.
That's what I was thinking of what might of happened that day.
The implosion was instant but they knew it was compromised
The speed of the implosion was the most merciful way to go. At least....
The implosion happened in half the time it takes the brain to process pain. They were reduced to misty blood before their brain even knew they were dead
If that was them making scheduled rhymic banging sounds to try and communicate, wouldn't it make sense to bang the SOS morse code? They had a captain with them so I'm 100% sure at least one person there would be familiar with morse code.
My thoughts, exactly.
. . . - - - . . .
Probably ego. "Everything is fine. Nothing to worry"
He was banging the Xbox controller
We watched him throw it aside.....so weird, an Xbox controller. Is that the best he could do ? He was cutting corners while charging 250K, for the ride. Shish. An expensive burial at sea.
😂😂😂😂😂
Lmfao
Naaaaaaa😩🥴
Bro😂😂😂
This is one time when it pays to be poor.
Damn right....
And/or smart.
I don't see myself doing this stupidity even if I had all the money in the world. I don't see how money would compromise safety logic
It pays to have common sense.
Or just have brain cells
Final destination: the sub
Small price. Only 250,000 ....no refunds.
I would pay to see that.
@@TaylorKnightCosplay too horrible....nightmares
Pretty Accurate! By the way there's a new movie coming up this year I think.
@@TaylorKnightCosplay Pretty sure there will be a movie.
i only feel bad for the 19 year old. the rest were basically asking for it.
Same cus he didn’t even want to go but went for his dad to make him happy cus he was so obsessed with the damn titanic
I feel bad for his mom.. she lost two lives and is still alive to deal with that loss..
why feel bad shes alive @@KremitDeFrog
@@KremitDeFrog her billions will help mend the wounds. That kind of money keeps you warm at night. Cozy
@@CELESTINOXZwasn’t it Father’s Day too?
I hear many people confuse implosion with explosion.
Explosion happens when the inside pressure increases pushing the walls OUTSIDE until the walls give way.
Implosion happens when the OUTSIDE pressure is greater than the pressure inside forcing the Titan sub to be CRUSHED UNDER PRESSURE.
you forgot to mention instantaneously.. that is a key component of implosion.. there's crushing and then there's implosion.. just like there's expansion and then there's explosion..
1:02 "the world held its breath", damn bro that got me
He knew exactly what he was doing 💀
Something probably went wrong with the submersible and they lost communication and control -- and that might have lasted a while. But once the hull ruptured - they were dead in an instant.
That timing has been evaluated between the time the communication stopped and the moment a military ship picked up a spike . They figure out, it was the implosion and it was not, long after, the contact was lost. That is good news as they did not linger too long, wondering if they could make to the surface. The implosion took a fraction of a second, without any pain.......they were gone.
We already know they didn't make it to the bottom before the vessel imploded because of the range of debris that was scattered.. if the banging that went on for days was actually theirs, this would mean they'd have made it to the ocean floor where the vessel would then be resisting the maximum amount of pressure it would endure. So this story is hard to believe in the first place..
The entire situation is horrifying. It's a great example of "just because you can, doesn't mean you should." It gives me anxiety when I imagine myself in their shoes, living out in real time this situation. Its crazy and hard to believe this is for "fun" and "educational." The Titanic is a corpse! It's decaying at the bottom of the ocean floor. Not much is left currently to look at anyway. It just doesn't seem worth the risk of your life. 😔
The part that gets me the most is that they couldn't even see the ship with their own eyes, there were no windows. They watched everything from a screen. It's no different than watching footage of the Titanic. They could have stayed near a beach, a foot away from the surface, driven around in cirlces while watching Titanic videos and none of them would even know the difference. It's like if you went on vacation and spent the entire time in a small hotel room and watched someone livestream going out and actually doing things. What is even the point? You don't need to be there!
@@goosepapoose8666they do have a window
It would have been the SOS signal if it was done by someone onboard, and it would have been done much more frequently than every 30 minutes.
I feel bad for Nargolet and the kid, but I'm glad Stockton Rush had to suffer for his arrogance and stupidity.
That's way too clear to be possible "knocking sounds" coming from inside the sub considering it's got a fiber glass body and it's thousands of feet down
The intervals of EVERY 30 min were displayed, however, and they sounded on purpose with the rhythm of it. Still, it is a sad tragedy…
it imploded right after they lost contact💀
yes, that timing was evaluated with the sonar from the Navy ship. It matched the time the communication between the sub and the mother ship, ended.
“Hol up the controls not working”
*bang….bang bang bang*
*Dies instantly*
Nope! They were dead before they realized what happened...
Nope! They were clearly ascending
They knew they had trouble going back up. They had aborted the dive and were trying to go back to the surface, but it was going very slow while making structural noises.
Yea the implosion happens in half the time it takes for the Brain to process pain. They was misty blood before their brains even knew they were dead
@@J.Mingsy92fear doesn’t need pain to register though.
That's actually false and as assumption at best. That transcript was fake and it was standard to drop ballast precisely where they did. They always did that
Doubt it. Navy even conveyed they heard the implosion. Rush even said before the tragedy that loud banging sounds were coming from aft.
Who knocks then waits 30 min to knock again? "In their last desparate moment."
Nobody
Inside edition producers, script writers, and reporters.
I’d choose the Glasgow wonka experience over this
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Don’t forget: the CEO of OceanGate said “safety was overrated”
He followed in the footsteps of the guy that piloted the Malaysian plane.
@@juliusseizure5705
Don’t forget the CEO of Boeing, as well.
@@juliusseizure5705Wait what was the story on the that
@@halroxdynasty8683 The guy that piloted M370 was suicidal. Historically, there's been many instances of suicidal pilots who took everyone down with them.
This guy was a pilot all his life, and he even had a pilot simulator that he would play when he wasn't working. Theory is that he test drove many flights trying to find a route that would put him outside of radar. He never finished the route in the last game he played because he never intended to. So he knew exactly when and how to disappear so his legacy can be romanticized as a great mystery. Then he crashed in the ocean in the middle of nowhere.
@@syncretictakeout2842
Too bad we can’t ask him for clarification…
Rest in peace to Stockton Rush, Hamish Harding, Shahzada Dawood, Sulaiman Dawood and Paul Henry Nargeolet
definitely not rush
Nah Stockton can rest in distress, it's 100% his fault with all the shortcuts and risks he took, that involved other people's lives. The other four however I hope rests peacefully.
Naw, Rush can blow me.
The only comfort is even if it was them, it imploded so fast they didn't even know they were dead. So yes they were probably banging knowing something was wrong but when it did happen they were gone before they knew it. I guess it's some comfort
This might sound bizarre, but when I tried to imagine a sudden death without the slightest bit of forewarning--just an instantaneous end of one's existence--I found that even more disturbing than having at least an inkling before hand that one's end was nigh. I don't mean that I hope the passengers experienced terror. But Stockton Rush? Oh, yes. And I'm sure he did.
didnt we hear bout this month ago when it happen last yr i almost positive we heard bout this all b4 so what yall mean this is jus newly released recordings smh
They're just trying to keep engagement up.
Just say you didn’t watch the whole video before commenting lol
yes we did. It is all news...
Even if this is fake, they don't care.
A documentary is coming out… this is for ratings
The US Coast Guard and US Airforce searched for the lost submersible. Why didn't the US Navy participate in the search? The US Navy already knew there were no survivors. A US Navy submarine was listening on SONAR and heard when the submersible imploded. The US Navy knew there was no hope for the submersible.
“Most” of the time, multiple branches will not work together or at least divide up the tasks for an operation. In this case, the coast guard had assets in the water while the Air Force offered aircraft in the search. Also, the navy likely didn’t have assets close enough like the coast guard did, so it was just natural that the CG would take the lead
@@thedesertrat_9514
The US Navy submarine was close enough to hear the implosion.
@@jamesbulldogmiller But what’s the submarine going to do??? Navy subs don’t reach anything past 600 meters compared to deep sea submersibles. The Navy did pass the information to the coast guard about the possible implosion they detected. That’s about all you can do
@@jamesbulldogmilleryes but what we consider close isn’t what a submarine might consider close. They detected them via sonar and some sonar sounds can travel hundreds of miles if not more. So that sub could have been a hundred or more miles away
They knew in their hearts what happened, but on the off chance they heard some random piece of sea trash or an outer component of the submersible implode, rescue crews had to keep searching. That’s why they didn’t tell everyone what they heard.
They were banging the xbox controllers trying to get them to work.
Does it make a difference?
Thats what Stockton said when he was banging his x-box controller, trying to get it to work.
@@thebrowns5337pretty good....
It's a Hellish Tale, but we always seem to get jokes..🤔
Even if it was one them banging ,it would not metter there was no way to help them at that depth. By the time any rescue reached the sub it would be to late
👍😂🤣
They weren’t knocking, they were too liquified to be able to 😂
Like a dripping sound? 🤔
I was a bit appalled at your comment, but then I had to add a bit more. Forgive me😬😊
I think at the time they heard the knocking, the sub had already imploded. So, it was not them......
It is very possible they may have been alive for some time before the implosion. We just don't know what happened and likely never will. A total power loss is possible, which would have caused them to descend into an implosion.
Either way, people love to dismiss everything and say "they went out fast". You simply don't know that.
That's most likely what happened so basically, they were sinking and didn't know exactly when it would implode AND that's when it imploded. It's true it was an instant, but they knew they were in danger.
They literally do know that... Learn the facts.
I have read the information they gave us, that came from the mother ship. They were communicating and going down at a rather fast rate. Before they got close to the Titanic, the sub was seriously cracking so they decided to abort the dive and go back up. That was a problem as it was going up very slowly. The mother ship got in touch with the engineers, wanting to know, what they could do to go up faster. In the mean time, the communication between the sub and the mother ship stopped. That specific time was picked by a military ship that was monitoring sound waves in the ocean, nearby. They figured out, the spike they witnessed , happened at the time, the communication stopped. So ? it was the time of the implosion. They blew up , when they stopped communicating. It is a good sign as they did not mentally "suffer" very long. They had air, so they were breathing, just concerned about not going up, fast enough. That was it. Indeed the implosion killed them in a fraction of a second. No time for pain........gone.
@@-xxMelissaxx- Oh that's great, surely you can link these sources that state the Titan imploded IMMEDIATELY after comms loss and did not have any form of power loss at all.
I'm willing to learn, show me the way.
Not true. Nato has audio of the sun imploding. It was within a few hours of leaving the surface. The sound has been analysed and is definitely an implosion. This noise is days later. Who knows who or what was doing this.
Stockton Rush : ''A true fighter against the tyranny of safety regulations''
A rogue gone wrong.
Twitter: "The 'people' who stomp and dance on people's graves"
Now STOCKTON is in heaven: Fightin' the system like a true modern day ROBIN HOOD...!!!
😅😅😅
Mr. CEO believed that they would respawn in a different location, as he was piloting the ship using an Xbox controller.
Before it imploded sure, but once it imploded they didn’t even know what happened it was over so quick … The pressure that deep is insane
That “imploded”.😢
Can you imagine a death so painless you dont even realize what had happened and you just stop existing..
Could be the passengers kicking the captain's ass?
😁😂🤣
😭😭😭
goddmanit 😂
They didn't even know how to communicate SOS.
This whole thing is beyond ridiculous.
This is not the first time we’ve heard this! They were talking about this banging interval during the search.
They say it in the very last sentence of the video - the sub imploded, and everyone died instantly. They were crushed so quickly and forcefully that there is 0 chance for any survivors. Unless the knocking is morse code for SOS or something like that, it wouldn’t change my mind
unless systems failed prior to the implosion, and they started knocking
Once the sub imploded they died instantly but we don’t know how long they knew they were in trouble and trying to get back up.
@@d4ever649 Yes we do.
That’s not Morse code for SOS. It’s dot dot dot dash dash dash dot dot dot.
@@evilsharkey8954 well, maybe not everyone knows morse code for SOS
They were tapping in Morse Code a warning not to attend the Willy Wonka Experience
You win lol
Three long knocks, three short knocks, is code for SOS. If they were knocking, they would have knocked the SOS code
its the HULL cracking.... oh lord.
No, it's HAUL. Stockton Rush was using a repurposed U-HAUL trailer and an Xbox. Both highly trusted brands.
It was actually slow and painful, imagine sticking your head in a vice and slowly closing it shut, the eyes will pop out, skulk slowly crack, lungs decompress, body will feel like its boiling, eventually the head will explode like a grenade.
You were there huh?
its not slowly it was instantly they were clamped into puddles of blood and guts
It’s been one year since we talked about the submarine story.
I wanna ho down there to understand what happened 😢.
@@dbapto6994 Then you might meet the same fate.
@@GreenYoshi3881 whoa whoa whoa????
it’s been 9 months
@@Mattster8159 the titan went down almost 2 yrs ago.....get over it
Imagine being stuck on the ocean floor, hearing the cracks and the sounds of the ocean before being imploded for god know how long
The death was so fast it probably was painless and they didn’t even know what happened. However the pure fear of knowing something was wrong and we’re in trouble and there’s no escape would be horrific! RIP
Why would someone trapped in the deepest ocean knock rhythmically and every 30 minutes?! They would be freaking out and knocking non stop
Their final act of kindness they left behind was becoming instant lunch for some lucky filter feeders nearby 😂😂😂
It was a buffet dinner
Laughing at their death. Hmm
@OttoByOgraffey it was just a lighthearted and good natured joke, don't get upset at me
@@OttoByOgraffey laughing is just another coping mechanism for death...
@@somnuswaltz5586 I'm sure the ppl trapped in the mini-sub cracked a few jokes on the way down to hell.
It shows 5 knocks / pops
5 people on board
Sounds like 5 of them exploding
That knocking was a reminder that your cars extended warranty is up
Does it even matter now??? And every 30mins? If you think your gonna die, you dont take a 30min break between "cries for help"
Yes! The news person gave it such weight: "Every. Thirty. Minutes."
No, they died instantly. It's literally impossible for anyone to die gradually from a deep sea implosion at depths that deep. However, they likely knew something was terribly wrong and must've been absolutely terrified.
Ultimate anticipation build and then it's over before you even have any clue. Wild when you think about it
It's terrifying to think they knew what was happening.
literally has to be the scariest feeling ever
I will point out as someone with a water heater near my room that metal can make rhythmic noises on their own
They recorded 5 knocks / pops
5 people on board , sounds like all of them imploding and turning into pink mist
This is the titanic ghost banging the titanic to let them out
cute.
I would've been unboarded that thing so fast if the captain showed me he was driving with an knockoff madcatz controller.
I never would've set foot on that thing.
What’s more horrible people actually started hating and were glad there dead because they were rich it’s sad 😢😢
that was the sound of stockton rush banging the xbox controller on the hull trying to get it to work.
I doubt it was from the sub, mainly because it was in a solid rythem. And im sure I heard the sound was picked up after they confirmed the sub had imploded?
mystery sound.
Let it go
No. People still can't let the Titanic go so why should we let this go
Why? Should their story not be told? Should the world not know their story? Their lives mattered whether you care or not.
@LegitLaughs1 I mean does their lives really matter itbwas a bunch of rich men who stuck themselves in a tuna can for no other reason other then they were so rich they could
Yet you still cry for breathing Floyd. LMAO 🤣
@@Litandharryginnyfacts lol we dont care about the rich over here, they dont care about us
Banging on the hull? It was carbon fibre, experts wrote off the possibility of it being Titan early on for this reason.
like this comment cause why not
The diversity submarine build turned out as expected. A catastrophic failure.
They knew what was going to happen. The glass probably started to crack and there was a slight buckle in the metal and then gone in a second.
Pssst, They heard the Banging on Sonar Every 15-30 Minutes and Said that the Day It IMPLODED. However They Died Instantly as The Submersible Imploded, Banging was to tell Sonar they were in Trouble and a Plea for Help However once the Hull Breached it was Instantaneous Death and They Never Felt a Thing. So this is NOT NEW, infact it is the same thing that has been said OVER and Over and Over for a Year Now..
I feel like if it was them, it wouldn't be consistent, and there'd be more panic behind the banging.
IF they lived long enough, repeating the message at certain intervals makes more sense than randomly banging frantically to get attention. But they died in the quick implosion- it wasn't them.
They might have known they were in trouble. *But the actual implosion happened so fast that their brains wouldn't have had time to process anything before disintegrating.*
Either way, Rush wouldn't have to worry about brains proccessing anything.
Imagine if it wasn’t actually instant and instead they were being slowly crushed for 10 to 20 seconds in super deep water in pitch black and no way to escape drowning, that would be terrifying
That's literally not how it works lol
@@anonymoususer1824 I know that’s why I’m saying “imagine” obviously at those depths it’s instant… I’m saying it as in imagine how much more scary it would be if it wasn’t instant and you were crushed and drowned in super deep pitch black water
It didn't explode... it imploded🤦♂️ how can you mess up like that within 3 seconds?😂
I'm glad that the owner was there ,that greedy ass
it’s stockton rush angrily banging the logitech controller because of malfunction
I don’t believe this is them banging. It is widely accepted the sub imploded within hours of decent. They had all perished before the search began.
Right off the bat, you’re wrong. YES, They absolutely died instantly! That’s how an implosion at that depth works!
I didn’t know u guys posted your stories. 👍 Sometimes I miss your show
This isn't the first time this was released.
those banging noises were the passengers banging stockton rush's head against the side of the hull.
I ve never been so fascinated by stories like this like this one
Rush didn't listen to the experts telling him "No"
I thought the implosion occurred before the search began? Unless it coincidentally didn't implode until they ran out of oxygen, there's no way that sound could have been made by humans on the Titan.
That's why we should make very distinct code sound like a tune of a very distinctive children song
It already exists.SOS. Three long, three short, etc
It was from someone/something else. Sound travels very far and efficiently in water. Since it was every 30 minutes it was probably someone who had a routine job. The US military heard the implosion and I believe the mothership did too.
WOW I had completely forgotten about this 🙏🏾🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️
"maybe with a wrench?"...Inside Edition always hard hitting with the facts lmao
1. When in the overall timeline was the banging heard
2. Just how consistent were the banging noises (same banging pattern at very precise intervals?)
Not sure I’ve seen definitive answer to these simple questions.
If the two sets of two bangs we hear in the audio clip release were repeated at least 3 times at exactly 30 min intervals, I don’t think anyone could argue that they weren’t man-made sounds. Repeating twice is highly suspicious, 3 times is conclusive.
Exploded? Think you mean implode as it's crushed not expanded
🤓
It's probably just more pieces of the sub breaking and imploding. There's no way someone could survive down at that pressure especially once the sub imploded
i doubt its from one of the passengers being in complete darkness you lose the ability to track time, no human will be able to do such tone in a constant 30 minutes cycle.
when I was growing up I had a digital watch that could display the time in the dark and it probably cost $30 at most
I'm sure billionaires can afford a watch
I think even sometimes older analog watches even from before I was born had glow in the dark material, so they would illuminate in the dark
@@justanobody0 Aight did not think that far...
Sounds like the guy was smacking the game controller off the wall out of anger🤣
Those banging sounds could have been something else. Since they lost communication around 3500 feet deep, that’s probably when the sub imploded. I find it highly unlikely after losing communication that they made it to the seafloor in complete darkness without the submersible imploding.
There should’ve been some sort of floating system that could be automatically pulled and brought it to the surface
there was
The banging was the navy not the titan submersible