My NHL Top DEFENSEMAN Tier List

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
  • My weekly NHL Tier List is here and today I will be looking at every single Top Defenseman in the NHL. In these tiers I will rank each player based on how well they have performed as the top guy for their team. This Tier List is filled with some amazing players who have all proved themselves in one way or another. Be sure to comment other NHL or Hockey related Tier Lists you would like to see and Subscribe to Jimmy Hockey for more NHL News and Breakdowns.
    TikTok:
    www.tiktok.com...
    Instagram:
    / jimmyhockeyy
    #nhl #hockey #stanleycupplayoffs #icehockey #hockeyhighlights #montrealcanadiens #hockeyvideos #goldenknights #edmontonoilers #nhlplayoffs #nhlhockey #connorbedard #chicagoblackhawks #vancouvercanucks

Комментарии • 67

  • @jimmyhockey
    @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад +1

    What do you think of My NHL Top Defenseman Tier List? Also comment what Hockey Tier List You would like to see next!

    • @quixMPG
      @quixMPG 13 дней назад +3

      You should do a goalie tier list, but Adam fox is underrated I think he’s the best category (Canucks Fan). The list is good though.

    • @Theearthisflat13
      @Theearthisflat13 13 дней назад

      You should do a tier list ranking contenders for the next 5 years

    • @johnward896
      @johnward896 13 дней назад +1

      @@quixMPGif Josi isn’t in the best tier, then fox shouldn’t be either

    • @SportspIus
      @SportspIus 13 дней назад

      Do best Depth Teams.

    • @jadenmiedema
      @jadenmiedema 9 дней назад

      @@quixMPG more like overrated

  • @Shanedoessports
    @Shanedoessports 13 дней назад +10

    Bro that was weegar not Anderson

  • @mariovaccarella6854
    @mariovaccarella6854 2 дня назад

    Great Video

  • @HockeyguyLiam
    @HockeyguyLiam 13 дней назад +6

    Fox should be with Hughes and makar

    • @johnward896
      @johnward896 13 дней назад +4

      If Josi isn’t in best tier, fox shouldn’t be either

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад +2

      Fox is good with guys like heikanen and Mcavoy, I think Hughes and Makar have just shown us another level offensively while still being solid defensively

    • @mikepanick9362
      @mikepanick9362 13 дней назад +1

      If Fox didn’t get knee checked by Aho and Jarvis…….

    • @AKORPSE
      @AKORPSE 13 дней назад

      @@jimmyhockeyI definitely agree, coming from a rangers fan as well

  • @BP21_
    @BP21_ 11 дней назад +2

    Josi should be up with Cale and Hughes.

    • @jadenmiedema
      @jadenmiedema 11 дней назад

      Nah

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  10 дней назад

      He is elite but I think Makar and Hughes have the slight edge over him

    • @BP21_
      @BP21_ 10 дней назад

      @@jadenmiedema Yes.

  • @mariovaccarella6854
    @mariovaccarella6854 2 дня назад

    Not only is it because I'm A Big Chicago Blackhawks Fan, but, while I agree with you about the fact that Seth Jones isn't living up to his Contract, I think that was given the fact that, in Chicago's acquiring him, it was prior to The Rebuild. When he was acquired from Columbus, Stan Bowman had Chicago in A Building A Cup Contender Mode, thereafter, following The Kyle Beach Fallout, The New GM, Kyle Davidson, put them in Rebuild Mode. Moreover, while Jones is predominantly A Big Offensive Defenseman, in the last year, he's gotten better in his Defensive Skills & is on A Team that has been plagued with injuries, not to mention that they weren't good at the scoring if goal, other than with Connor Bedard & few others. Therefore, for the reasons I've cited, I think Seth Jones should be placed higher, albeit only 1 Tier above where you placed him. Let me know what you think

  • @quixMPG
    @quixMPG 13 дней назад +1

    Your videos are amazing

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад +1

      Thank you appreciate you watching🙏🏻

    • @quixMPG
      @quixMPG 13 дней назад

      @@jimmyhockey No problem!

  • @natalieloveshockey
    @natalieloveshockey 13 дней назад +1

    If Fox didn't get knee checked by Aho and Jarvis, I think he should have been in the best tier with Hughes and Makar. He was just over a point per game player this past season, playing 72 games and having 73 points, and if he played those ten more games I feel he would have been at least 85 points. And his game is still very good defensively and is just 3 years removed from being a Norris Trophy winner.

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  12 дней назад

      I am a huge Fox fan and think he is just ever so slightly below the other two guys in the best tier. Don't get that twisted he is still a top 3 d man in the NHL.

  • @mikepanick9362
    @mikepanick9362 13 дней назад +1

    Check Hamilton’s plus/minus, it’s ridiculously bad.
    In addition to your point about him being injury prone, he’s been traded multiple times for a reason.
    Top 4.

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад

      Sure but plus minus isn’t the most reliable stat to be fair. Despite being traded a few times I think Hamilton is still the best defenseman on the Devils, and when he is not on the ice the team is a lot worse defensively. I still think he’s a good top line defenseman just has to stay healthy

  • @dangdelucia
    @dangdelucia 13 дней назад +2

    rasmus dahlin is so sick, heavily underrated solely because he plays for buff

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад +1

      I think he should be a favorite for the Norris next season, Buffalo is going to take a step soon and it will be because of Dahlin

  • @hockey_all_star5895
    @hockey_all_star5895 13 дней назад +1

    Dunn is probably elite but definitely good

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад

      I have him as a top 4 guy, I like him as a player but if he is your best option I don’t see a team winning a cup

  • @mcj44
    @mcj44 12 дней назад

    Morrissey is awesome defensively

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  10 дней назад

      He’s good defensively, he is awesome offensively

  • @phillytheflyerable
    @phillytheflyerable 12 дней назад

    Do defensive defenseman

  • @Gergentine
    @Gergentine 13 дней назад

    Morrissey is waaaaaaay too low. He completely carries Winnipegs defense. Started as a defensive defenseman consistently outsmarting larger players to steal pucks, never out of position, and wickedly fast. The last two years he's become the offensive guy because Pionk can't figure out how to be the offensive defenseman while not being a liability. Now Morrissey just does everything. Winnipegs defense looks better than it actually is mainly due to him overperforming. He's between bouch and Hedman. Doesn't have Hedmans size or accolades, but better defensively than Bouchard while producing similar offensively on a much worse team. He's a defensive defenseman at his core though.
    Also, Dahlins is a bit low, too. I'd put him around the same place.

  • @andrewchenevert249
    @andrewchenevert249 11 дней назад

    The disrespect on matheson thats crazy

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  10 дней назад

      I understand but in comparison to other top guys he just isn’t in the same class, still a great player

    • @GGMang1337
      @GGMang1337 9 дней назад

      In fantasy banger leagues, Matheson is solid until Hutson takes his place on PP1

  • @PREDHEAD.NashvilleIsBetter
    @PREDHEAD.NashvilleIsBetter 13 дней назад +1

    I think montour is Seattle's beest d man

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  12 дней назад

      At this point yes but I think Dunn will still be their top line D man

  • @matthewkabel6246
    @matthewkabel6246 12 дней назад

    Fowler's nowhere near Anaheim's best defenseman

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  10 дней назад

      But he is still listed as that on this list, you could argue that they consider him the number 1 guy with Zellweger, and Mintyukov both being so young

  • @janbogumil
    @janbogumil 13 дней назад

    That mystery Vegas defenseman was in fact Shea Theodore who I would consider to be one of the best dmen in the league can't stay healthy though as most Golden Knights do
    And that was not Rasmus Andersson it was Weegar

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  13 дней назад

      That’s who I was missing, either way I still then Pietrangelo and Hannifan are better number 1 options than theodore

    • @janbogumil
      @janbogumil 13 дней назад

      Maybe I feel they are all worthy 1st dmen

  • @caseyjones5930
    @caseyjones5930 13 дней назад

    So Seider doesn’t have to make the playoffs to get to the elite tier? Maybe cause I’ve only especially watched his games against Ottawa but he played pretty poorly in them.

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  12 дней назад +4

      He has been the only constant for that Red Wings defensive unit since he's arrived in Detroit, maybe I'm over eager with the elite tier but I will stand by my pick

  • @phillytheflyerable
    @phillytheflyerable 12 дней назад

    What is ekblad doing there and not forsling

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  10 дней назад

      Not sure, I think Forsling is easily their best but they listed Ekblad as the top so that’s what I went with here

  • @Zacklemz15
    @Zacklemz15 13 дней назад

    How the hell can a 60+ points defenseman be considered bottom 4 ?!

    • @jimmyhockey
      @jimmyhockey  12 дней назад

      Because points isn’t the only factor when judging a defenseman… they have to be good at defense too

    • @andrewchenevert249
      @andrewchenevert249 11 дней назад

      @@jimmyhockeyhes good defencively as well

  • @Canucksnate
    @Canucksnate 13 дней назад +2

    Quinn Hughes is by far the best defensemen

    • @havenless3551
      @havenless3551 13 дней назад +8

      Doesn't clear Makar sadly, debatable if he clears Josi, I'd still take Heiskanen over Hughes personally

    • @Canucksnate
      @Canucksnate 13 дней назад +1

      @@havenless3551 what are you talking about Hughes is way better than makar and heiskanen

    • @Venxm_Hockey
      @Venxm_Hockey 13 дней назад +2

      No hate but this is delusional Nate, love ya man but this isn’t right.

    • @frost2551
      @frost2551 13 дней назад +3

      Least biased Nucks fan, this was his first truly great season and it’s still way too early to call him the best defensemen

    • @Canucksnate
      @Canucksnate 13 дней назад +1

      @@Venxm_Hockey he’s way better than your Evan poochard 🤣