帝女花之香夭 Fragrant Sacrifice 任白名曲Yam Kim Fei and Bak Suit Sin
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 янв 2011
- This is probably the most well-known excerpt from the most-watched Cantonese Opera in the world. I have supplied English subtitles here, hoping that those who are not familiar with this language can enjoy it too.
I have uploaded another version before, performed by the students of these two actresses.
帝女花 is a Cantonese Opera first made into a movie in 1959, starring Opera singers, Yam Kim Fei (任剑辉) and Bak Suit Sin (白雪仙), both ladies, but Yam impersonated a man in all her movies.
The Emperor of the Ming dynasty had just approved of his future son-in-law who won the heart of his daughter with poetry. At that moment, The Ching army attacked and took over the palace. The Emperor committed suicide with his family but Princess Cheung Ping survived. To win the favour of his subjects, the new Emperor of the Ching dynasty adopted the Princess and proceeded with the grand wedding. To show their loyalty to the Ming emperor, the newly-weds take their own lives on their wedding night. The Cantonese Opera is too beautiful to be translated. Something will be "lost in translation." The Song here, 香夭 (Fragrant Sacrifice) is the grand finale of the opera, sung on the wedding night, the couple are dressed in exquisite finery. The Princess and her groom express their love for each other and their loyalty to the former dynasty, especially the late Emperor, before they take their own lives, drinking wine poisoned with Arsenic.
I have added English subtitles for my friends here on youtube. Hope you will like this as much as I do. Regards, Jeremy
向任白 兩位藝術家 致敬， 想當年 不 識 欣賞粵劇， 如 今 年紀 長了 才識欣賞， 感謝 任白 兩位 粵劇 藝術家 大師， 留下 寶貴 的演繹 給 我們 欣賞 真是 百聽不厭 百看不厭， 兩位相當之匹配 任姐 瀟灑 俊朗 仙姐 美麗嬌艷， 而且 演技 真是無人可及， 前無古人 後無來者 衷心感激 給我們寶貴的 精神 糧食 祝 仙姐 身體康泰
是的，我也是，小的时候，会唱几句，可是后来才明白歌词的意思。
0000⁰😊😊😊⁰0⁰⁰⁰⁰😊😊😊😊😊😊
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
幼時不識事，今日痛在心。亡國喪親，陳出骨肉情大於夫妻愛，又以身殉國殉情，互相回應，感人肺腑，聽之為此而動容。任白造手利落，關目傳情，以及唱腔細腻，曲調蒼凉沉厚，不瑰自推出以來，深入民間，乃自隨移民散落海外，傳遍國際戲劇界!
同意你的说法。谢谢留言。
東大門歷史文化公園但有好多野食的話語與韓國😅😅😅
I am not Chinese and this is the first time I am hearing Chinese opera. This one sounds very good, and the singers are well trained.
点解我咁鍾意任劍輝,除了靚仔唱腔極之好聽外還有是演技自然流暢、感情十足令人睇到有種共鳴感,任姐您真係好正嘅👍👍👍👏👏👏😘😘😘❤️❤️❤️
谢谢观赏，留言。👍👏😘❤️
認同👍❤🙏💯
任是女的
任白 兩位 藝術大師 雖然 ，任姐 離世 已經有 29年 仙姐 一直 都 懷念 至愛的 任姐， 他兩位給人的 印象 係 清高 ，她倆, 無私奉獻 培養 雛鳳鳴 仙姐 有句 令人心痛的說話 任姐 永遠都在她、 心中 冇人可代替， 他用情 至i深， 希望 徒弟們 不要 辜負 恩師的栽培， 人生在世 最 緊要 做一個 有本心的人呀
谢谢留言。如果世界上，人人都有本心，这世界会好得多。
雖是幾十年前的戲服和頭飾，现在看一樣漂亮，任白十分登對，後來無人，好戲之人
谢谢留言。我从小就看到大，听到大。大了之后才明白歌词的意思。
I love this opera. I remembered seeing this as a child in the early 60s with my mum and remembered this scene. What a wonderful sight!
Thank you, David for watching and commenting. Me, too. I saw it a few times with my mom. This movie was made the same year I was born, so I could remember the times I saw reruns of the movie. My mom is not around anymore. I miss her. For as long as I could remember, I had wanted to translate the song so that more movie and music fans could enjoy it. ❤
@@CanaanOptical2024 Thanks for sharing! I remember listening to song when I was a child, not knowing what they were singing and yet loved to listen to them.
憶起當年睇任姐的舞台劇，非常開心任姐击塲震憾全塲她真係一個迷倒众生的藝術家無架子，高貴大方，好有氨質，使人怀念，
谢谢分享你的意见，我这是陪妈妈去戏院看过，有时过一两年，又会再来上映的。我可能看过几次吧。记不起了。
百看不厭
👌👍❤️🙏💯
百聽不厭
👍👍👍💯💯💯❤️🙏🙏🙏
今時今日再睇都仍然非常感動, 絕對不能取替, 無人能及....💖💖💖💖💖💖👍👍👍👍👍👍
谢谢观赏，留言。
百看不厭
👍👍👍❤️🙏💯💯💯
經典之作,超越時空,「任白」令人永遠難忘,永遠鍾情的一雙才子佳人
是的，她们的确在世上全部华人的心理留下深刻的印象。
任白真是絕配 , 真係百聽不厭
Kuok Hang Tai, 你好，谢谢留言。
百聽不厭 👍❤️🙏💯
02/10/22
向任劍輝白雪仙兩位粤劇演藝家致敬
n
谢谢留言。我记得小时候，街头巷尾到处可以听到她们的唱片，那时真是太流行！
呢班人在这段精彩任白名曲講什麽政治呢已成过去，好与不好'大家有眼睇的，但今心目中都係讚賞一级藝術大師任劍輝小姐
其实不只是好莱坞把事实美化，历史上结局不是这样的。
好戲連場，錦上添花，百聽不厭！！！
谢谢
好戲好曲，今日還在看, 經典之戲, 不停看！還有李後主百聽不厭的粵曲經典，真係無懈可擊。
謝謝觀看，留言。這部電影和我同歲。我從小陪媽媽去電影院看。舞台表演卻沒有看過。媽媽已經不在了。這部電影永遠有人欣賞。媽媽也永遠在我心上。
任姐的戲寶冇得頂，唱得非常有感情，聽得很豪味
她们两人都是观众的偶像。
👍❤️🙏💯
任姐，仙姐的帝花百看百聽都不会厭
谢谢，Eva, 你说得对，这部电影和我同年。我从小听到大，虽然没有看过他们舞台上表演，但是，陪妈妈到戏院看这部电影很多次。任白的帝女花永远长存，妈妈永远活在我心上。
確是百看不厌
202008
@@CanaanOptical2024 o
任劍輝/白雪仙版最經典！兩位大師絕配，唱功已經到了神級，崇拜任白！好嘢，好正的經典名作！感人肺腑，原人原景，百聽不厭，百看不厭…！永遠都咁好聽，代代成為經典！
胡春儀 田7卜卜卜卜
胡春儀 看看人家唱的词，再看看你打的字，你们现在把广东话变得越来越不像汉语了
的确，我从小听到大。陪妈妈去看了这部电影好几次。那个年代，没有录影带，光碟。好的电影，每隔一两年就会重来在戏院里再上映。
向台主致敬能讓任白迷观裳咁多任白电影及戲曲，非常感謝台主。
别客气。谢谢观赏。
百看不厭 懷念任姐
👍💯❤️🙏
好歌不厭百回聽,任白真正最佳拍檔,,
你说得对，他们这对，电影也好，舞台表演也好，全世界无论哪一个角落，都非常卖座。不好意思，这么迟回复你的留言，因为很久没有到这网页来浏览。
向两位任白大師致敬，永遠怀念您
谢谢留言。
The most beautiful aria ever Cantonese Opera repertoire written by Tong Teck Sung
Thank you, Choy Mun Khiong. The most well-known as well.
仙姐果然是仙姐！声！色！藝！真是後無來者！
谢谢留言。仙姐的确是难得的艺人。
不好意思，迟迟未回复，我已经几年没有上网浏览这网页。
真係超好聽, 無法取代, 百聽不厭
谢谢观赏，留言。这部电影和我同岁。每隔一两年，它就在电影院再上映，所以，我从小就陪妈妈看，只是没看过舞台表演。妈妈已经不在了。这首歌常常重听，妈妈也永远在心上。
👍❤️💯🙏
雖然任姐姐上了天家**但歌曲還在全世界同這平台播放♡
Their art will live on for many generations to come.
任白戲寶
精彩絕倫
百看不厭
2個師父之戲宝，好廳前無古人，後無來著👍👍👏👏
-
Dhdidhd BFidhiss，你说得对。的确是前无古人后无来者！
不好意思，迟迟未回复，我已经几年没有上网浏览这网页。
不愧為一代宗師！任白真是絕配！
R Lam 恶魔
合眼用心聽 真令人 聽到落淚同感悲哀呀……
CHl*CHUNG TlNG 对，很悲伤！
我也有同感。
她两的确演得很投入。
粵語藝術之瑰寶
谢谢留言。小时候，好的电影会在戏院重复。我陪妈妈看了好几次。妈妈不在了，是非常想念她。不好意思，迟迟未回复你的留言，好久没有用 RUclips了。
Thank you, Alice. Our family spoke Cantonese too. I was one of the two among my siblings, educated totally in English. This song fascinated me from the time I first heard it. I learnt Chinese through usage and most probably because I valued what my parents taught me, reading and writing in Chinese even before I started school. I'm glad you enjoyed this. Thank you for taking time to comment.
11u7
❤❤❤❤
任白名留香江，除了藝術精湛，造手步法唱功精益求精外，社會公益及扶腋後輩亦不遺餘力。任劍輝真是爐火純青。是香港粵劇的楷模人物。不敢說後無來者，但成就應超越了很多前輩。是嗎？
说的对。谢谢分享。
前無古人💐後來無者🙏绝戀歌曲👍👍👍
谢谢你，🍔🤡🍺🤠
，谢谢留言，谢谢观赏。我看了你写的留言，念出来，有点不顺，但是我不敢肯定什么地方不对。所以上网搜索，原来是这样 - 前无古人，后无来者
(前無古人，後無來者) 😊🙏👌❤️
好喜欢聽任姐唱寸心盼望能同合葬呢段好動聽-真係超好聽，你哋不防再细心重聽
平呀門巷，真是無人能及原唱/段段好聽敬慕任劍輝小姐
非常同意，香夭是一首好感动的歌，我尊敬的任白合唱。可以説是绝配。
每當听到呢首歌，我会想起任姐的唱做，令我常怀念
谢谢。
任劍輝白雪仙演藝天衣無缝
由細睇到老，己經睇咗幾拾年，現在還在睇，百聽百看不厭，經典中的經典
谢谢观赏，留言。
Great Kwangtung heritage beautiful people language culture music amazing iconic singers Yam Kim Fei and Bak Suit Seen so proud being half Cantonese myself maternal side xxxxx
Hi, there, Meiling, thank you for watching and commenting. I'm glad you like it. Me, too, I'm proud of my heritage.
agree with you for the Cantonese bit. cantonese is the best chinese dialect.
中國歌劇代表是粵劇，粵劇代表是帝女花，已寫入世界歌劇史，為世界歌劇史所承認。唐滌生赴日旅遊，入戲院看越劇，得靈感，重新編輯帝女花，劃時代貢獻，把粵劇推向最高峰
谢谢留言。
好淒美的片段！曲好，詞高，人美，可惜後無來者，誰還能比她們更強的呢？
no one. the best ever !
kammy8989 回不去了
沒有
唐滌生先生名作品之一，前無故人後無來者，以成絕響 。
百看不厭
👍💯❤️🙏💯
My grandmother in China loves to listen to these. As I am typing this out my mom is singing to it as she remember how many times she has listened to it in her old home.
Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts. This movie was made the year I was born. As a child I accompanied my mom to watch it well into my early adulthood. (When I was just a toddler, our whole family must have gone for it together as it was a custom to go as a family but I was too young to remember. As my elder siblings grew up, they gradually stopped coming along.) Those days, movies that were popular would return to the screens after one or two years, like "The Sound Of Music," "Gone With the Wind" and so on. My mom has passed on but this movie is still popular and I'm glad people all over the world enjoy this excerpt.
HI TAMAKI.
I am 68 years old now and remembered reenacted with a playmate as a child many of these excerpts. We embraced the music, singing, costumes, and choreographies. First time watching on RUclips and thanks to your subtitles in English it made clear what the story was about and I cried time over time. Like Romeo and Juliet. The opera singing and music still moves my soul. Thank youl
Thank you, Dahlia for your lovely comment. I'm really touched and encouraged by this sharing of your thoughts. Reading your short message makes me feel that the hard work and hours I put in were worthwhile. God bless you and keep you healthy, safe and joyful each day! ❤
I remember singing this when I was 4 with my grandmother. Brings back wonderful memories.
Simply amazing.
These two were the superstars of Cantonese opera movies.
This particular song and movie scene executed by them cannot be done better by others.
Many others have covered this but none came even close to their performance. These two...their standard, really almost god like.
真是一首百聽不厭的粵曲經典！
John Bewley
後無來者
John Bewley 祝福
@@coraleung7339 o,.
分吳
不用
真是經典🎉🎉
谢谢，的确。
任白倆位唱得十分好聽,,,,,,真係百聽不厭,,,,,,,Thanks for sharing!>>::::)))))
嘉喜鳴1328 hi
谢谢留言！Welcome. 🙏💕❤️
兩位藝術家的表演。希望現今後起之秀 多多f研究兩老的細節表演。唔好只顧曲詞。指定手勢 欣賞和學易兩老的細緻演繹任白戲寶 傳至今日 演的人無敗數。但 好多只能學演劇情 演不出劇中味多以交代了事。我可以誇亞嗲一句。她最傳神們
感恩观赏，留言。谢谢你分享你的意见。
I remember finding the full opera on youtube. it was one of the last old chinese operas that i found for my grandpa and grandma to watch before he passed away.
I'm glad you found that. I have found and downloaded the stage performance by these two actresses' disciples. I'm sure you are aware that the male lead and heroine are both played by ladies. So are the two leading couple in the stage performance. BTW, the stage performance like the original vinyl recordings are about four hours long.Thank you for sharing your experience.
The best of the best. No one can compare with them, especially those called themselves '閨秀'。They don't know how to sing at all, but 互相吹捧！
90後表示，好感動
是的，我从小就听到大。
Although I am no expert in Cantonese or Cantonese Opera, something about this just speaks to me and resonates with me. I especially like these lines poetic lines: 唉惜花者甘殉葬 (because it sounds like this is the moment where she realises her learned husband to be is willing to sacrifice his life) and 合欢与君醉梦乡 (because it is tragically romantic).
Thank you. I'm glad you enjoy it. It was so much a part of my life. The movie is my age. Those days, before home movie players were invented, good movies were screened again after a couple of years. So throughout my growing years, I accompanied my mother to the movie theatres to watch this film. My mother is not around anymore but she lives on in my heart.
I love this kind of song since l am a little girl. Now l am 70 but still loving. 💕💕💕
Thank you, Christina. I'm glad to read your comment.
我每日都在观裳任白两位大師的歌剧
你太幸福了。
看一回哭一回，慘有缘無份，十世姻緣，
thank you for sharing this excerpt. I am very grateful for the English subtitles. The dynamic between the 2 megastars is obvious and their facial expressions so moving. My mum was a fan of Cantonese opera and sang this song a lot. I am so glad to come upon this video - it brings fond memories of my mum who passed on many years ago.
Thank you for watching. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I'm glad you enjoy the subs. My mom was a fan too. ❤❤
任姐 you are the best !
Thank you for your thoughts, 任姐 was a great "actor." Indeed, as a lady, she sang in a very amazingly tender way that men could not. She could express emotions in a tender speaking voice that men could not. By far she was the most popular leading man in a way that men and women could not be. She was the best "male" opera singer there was, topping other "real" leading men.
@@CanaanOptical2024 yes, it's true. I never boring to look her opera 🙏
好經典 , 兩位演繹得淋漓盡致 , 真係無懈可擊 , 百看不厭 , Thanks for sharing。。。
谢谢留言，他们对粤剧艺术的贡献将永远流传世界上。
Welcome。Sorry for the late reply。I've been away from RUclips for some time。
This is a pair made in heaven! When either paired with someone else, the chemistry was just not there!
I remember reading about this in The Search for Modern China, and I recall Mr. Spence writing that the officials witnessing this play, the senior officials that were alive during the Ming resistance would cover their faces with their sleeves to hide themselves showing emotion. I can see why.
I followed my father to watch this movie during my childhood days. After several decades, watched again. It really helped to bring back all the fond memories. I really like it.
Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts. Me, too. The movie comes back to the theatres quite regularly and I watched it with my mother. I miss her. ❤❤
經典一曲 永莫難忘
望君須記取 藝人代代香
月华宫外帝女香，含樟树下驸马血。
迟迟未回复信息。好久没浏览RUclips，请见谅。
Truly a piece of art, after so many years I can still enjoy this musical performance :-)
Can’t stop listening to this, the Chinese lyrics are so meaningful. English translation is v impressive too
Thank you Crystal. I'm glad you like my English translation. From my childhood days, as I listened and watched the movie, the English translation would occur to me and go round and round in my thoughts. When I started using RUclips soon after it started, I decided to translate and upload the excerpt. It was quite a lot of work and I learnt editing the video by trial and error, so it took quite some time.
The 3 that dislike this video must be LadyGaga fan..
This opera was and still the best opera ever made. It's a Classic! A Masterpiece. Good job for uploading it. Thankyou very much.
要有一定經歷才能欣賞這詞的美
谢谢留言。这电影跟我同年，小时候，好的电影会在戏院重复。我陪妈妈看了好几次。妈妈不在了，是非常想念她。不好意思，迟迟未回复你的留言，好久没有用 RUclips了。
兩個字....精彩..謝謝有心人...!
This is the very first time l see n hear this famous opera. Beautiful customs n great performance. 👍👍👍 Long live the Chinese opera !!!
Thank you, Michele for watching and commenting. This is iconic of Hong Kong and Chinese tradition. I'm glad you like it.
Beautiful Cantonese Language ..so proud to be half Cantonese Kwangtung mother side .
I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for your lovely comment. Do you speak Chinese? 🙏❤️🎤🎼🎶🎵
@@CanaanOptical2024 simple conversational Cantonese
I have flashbacks of my grandparents would take me to these Chinese Opera concerts!now they are gone.just a bittersweet memory.it was joyful when grandparents were my company.😭😭😭😫😫😫 i guess i will enjoy this alone or with friends if they are around and not busy.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Benny. 🙏💌
This movie was made in the same year I was born. My mom loved movies. Growing up I accompanied her to watch this several times. Those days good movies return to the theatres every couple of years. My mom has passed on. She will live on in my memory. 💟🙏
任姐幾時睇妳都系好睇。
谢谢留言。我从小就是 帝女花迷，那时候，陪妈妈去看电影。舞台表演就没看过。妈妈已经不在了。每次听到帝女花就想念她。
百看不厭的任白好戲
谢谢观赏，留言。
香港電影有李小龍，把中國之武術傳揚海外，而粵劇中有任劍輝演譯了無數的文人雅仕，把中國人的優良品德，忠、孝、節、義完全表揚無遺！作為中國人的我們，實在很感驕傲，更希望把這崇高的精神延展下一代！
一Y
kk chan p
I'm
mei see Wong /。g好屿
呀姐，說話唔洗講到咁大。
Wallace Ng 你唔識嘢/就無謂嘈，請讓路
帝女花 任 白 至 經典之作！🎉 好喜歡❤👍👏🌺
❤🧡
一舉手，一投足，唱得哀怨，令我入迷，真是至高境界，
你不觉得词曲也是一流的吗？
永强李 就係極品中極品、要向帝女花全體人員敬謝)对任姐同仙姐鼓掌
她们演的很投入。
Eva Kwan vu ça vacu
´Y
百看不厭
202009
小時很多盛會，除了能免費看之外！整個場地鑼鼓震天、小食叫聲、香火瀰漫、氣氛熱鬧之下，對小朋友說必定樂而忘返的！
很好啊！真有趣！长大后就是童年的美好回忆吧！
無法取代的經典
对，是完美的演出。
認同 👍❤️🙏
2021
真是天造地設，无懈可击嘅绝配。
月华宫外帝女香，含樟树下驸马血。
谢谢留言，迟迟未回复信息。好久没浏览RUclips，请见谅。
@@CanaanOptical2024 客氣。有緣千里能相識，冇緣隔鄰不相逢！
感谢英文翻译！这段真的太美了，极致的悲剧美学。我以后也可以介绍给外国朋友了！
谢谢留言，谢谢分享，希望你的朋友们也会欣赏。
@@CanaanOptical2024 您翻译得真好！有些地方我我即使用中文也解释不好，比如“待千秋歌赞注驸马在灵牌上”这句，反而看英文一下子明白，对，就是这个意思！
很多人演过，但没一个比得上任白。
仙姐非常投入。你看过她们没穿戏服的那场义演吗？
Superb and excellent ! So far no body can surpass Yam & Pak in Cantonese opera’s performance and singing, and the beauty of Yam, the male actor!! The best of the bests in Cantonese operas 👍👍👏👏
My dear mate. I can't agree more. However Yam was a female actor who played a male role in most of her performances. Cheers Grace 😄
Thank you for taking time to comment.
感人悲壯的愛情故事。
这粤剧比我年纪大。以前，好电影常常在戏院重复。我陪妈妈看了好几次。从小我就喜欢这主题曲。
任白真是空前絕後啊，每當看到“將柳蔭當做芙蓉帳”，我都極為感動
marsfermi 任白.任白.我們永遠愛你倆.
Sui Ying Wong 支特你
我 也是这一句“將柳蔭當做芙蓉帳”，直击心灵，这句真是写得绝妙，浪漫！
一個( 落街冇錢買麵包 )的年代 ! 上一個世紀. 1965年的相近. [ 唐滌生 ]之名曲. 萬人迷的[ 任 ] 與 白. 唱做了一段粤語戲寶〈帝女花之香夭〉! 配上了子喉平喉. 好曲慢慢的唱. 市場反應. 嚟喇一個滿堂紅 ! 真是做老闆好個做戲老官 ! 這一次的唱做. 花旦白雪仙. 子喉如行雲流水去啫 ! 也成了仙腔. 小生[ 任劍輝 ] 以平喉啖定的演繹. 其神韻 ! 是似老闆比似駙馬為多. 當年的政治氣氛( 香港 ) ! 做老闆常遇上二種事情. 黑暗者貪污. 白明者捐獻. 而港督[ 葛亮洪 ]他每多有善長人翁嘅 ! 為善者. 必有[ 任劍輝 ] 她也 ! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
谢谢观赏，留言。
Thank you so much. I've loved watching this as a child, so fascinated with the beauty of the actors, sets & costumes but I've never really understood why they died until now. Do sad. I still belive that the 2 roses are actually them! Thanks again!
任姐真好嘢，
对呀。她的演技一流，唱功非凡 。
認同
I'm not an expert of chinese opera, but I really love Yam Kim Fai as male lead because of her unique voice that cant be replicated by anyone else.
Yes, you are right. She does have a beautiful voice. When my mom told me she was a lady and only plays the part of men in Opera, I found it hard to believe. Lately I've seen her playing female roles in old black and white Cantonese movies. I'm not an expert in Cantonese Opera either. We don't have to be to enjoy some of them. Thank you for commenting and I'm glad you enjoy it.
The two maestros. Their performance is classic!
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
欽稱粵曲瑰寶,顛峯聲藝之選！
Absolutely brilliant, exquisite Cantonese opera classic by 2 superb super stars! Great cheers sad deep respect for them!
Thank you, Raymond. These are matchless masters of their art, talented and hardworking. Indeed they are worthy of respect. Sorry for the late response. I have been away from RUclips for some time.
Thanks for the English subtitles...well done 👍👍👍
Thank you, P & B for taking time to comment. You are welcome. It's my pleasure.
百聽不厭，不愧粵曲經典
John Bewley ㅈ
ㅇㅅㅇ
百看不厭
202006
聽極不厭 !
谢谢留言。的确，从小就听到大。
不好意思，迟迟未回复，我已经几年没有上网浏览这网页。
Haunting, heart wrenching and oh so so very beautiful. Thanks so much that I could still enjoy this...when i was young this was like the ultimate love, now i just enjoy the music and dream that such love do exists
Perhaps such love does exist but not for everyone. Thank you for your lovely comment.
2 great singers. Love them. ❤️❤️❤️
Yes, Yam Kim Fai (Ren Jianhui) is awesome. She had made many successful Cantonese Opera movies with other opera-singer-actresses as well, notably Fong Yim Fun (Fang Yanfen)
this is the best rendition of this evergreen soulful song. these 2 were at their Best.
Excellent translation, Jeremy.
You have helped many to understand the finale of this opera acted by 2 magnificent actresses who were never equaled.
Thank you, Ricoh Flex. I'm glad you liked it.
GBU
Jeremy
ricoh flex 一
Now it needs to be translated in Tagalog and Spanish.slowly and gradually all the languages of the world be translated to clearly understand this musical.unless you know the cantonese language good for you.i understand English and Cantonese.i have many latin and filipino friends.some know neither English or Cantonese🥺🥺🥺
Thanks so much for the English subtitles ..... It helps me to realize how much excellent culture and art I am missing. It would be lovely to have more operas with subtitles like this but I'm sure it would take a great deal of work because there are so many operas .
Gee, I totally recall when my grandpa was playing this Cantonese opera everyday
失落沙洲徐家瑩
Thanks for your thoughts. Sorry for the late reply. I've been away from RUclips for a long time. This movie was made when I was born. Those days, popular movies return to the screen every one or two years. I watched a few times with my mom as I grew up. The recording could be heard everywhere we went from shops to homes and it was on the radio often.
谢谢留言。对不起，迟迟未回复，很久没有来到 RUclips 了。
granddad has very good taste indeed.
I am glad that I speak Vietnamese and understand some Chinese words, so it is much easier for me to infer the beauty from English translation than those who aren't familiar with Sinistic languages. Thanks a lot for uploading this.
Two legends at their very best! Thanks for the upload and translation.
Thank you for taking time to comment. Sorry for the late reply.
任白, 唐滌生, 波叔,麥炳榮, 鳳凰女等都是香港非常珍貴之寶, 回看5,60年代, 香港人生活比大陸更加艱苦, 這些人諦造出粵劇的奇蹟, 香港有今日其實是上一代的努力, 並不是因為英國人的管治好,
舊時的口號：聽話要聽黨的話，唱歌要唱革命歌。
讀小學時大人不鼓勵聽流行歌，說是靡靡之音，而粵劇被批評含有毒素。
牛頭唔搭馬嘴，人哋講「香港有今日其實是上一代的努力, 並不是因為英國人的管治好」，係香港人努力，你邊句睇到「毛澤東」？政治魔人，咪沾污呢度啦！香港6,7,80年代文化藝術輝煌，係因為市場開放，又有大量人才流入香港。全球化＋網絡年代，以香港作為本位既文化藝術，已經走到頭。
50.60年代大陆人不苦啊，不过是被活活饿死而已
六十年代係最多大陸人偷渡來香港。
如果不是是英国人的管治，是共产党管治，会有这些博大精深的中华文化的承存和发扬光大吗？
I like! We like! Thank you Jeremy for providing the English subtitles to this sad but beautiful song
Thank your for watching and your encouraging response. 👌👍🙏✌️🕊️