Requested by Patreon Supporter: Cranman, umi, matteuscarraro, twilydia Support me/Make a Request: randomk.me Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/random_k
@@Mr_Err3 Are you crazy? Literally everyone was trying to make their version of next level/savage after they got released + spicy was the song of the summer 2023
@@Mr_Err3 Gidle is irrelevant and everyone in their group sucks and flopped. Yuqi sucks. Soyeon hasn’t written a good rap in years. Miyeon is irrelevant, only mentioned when BP is. Soojin flopped. Minnie is being deported back to Thailand where she will live off the scraps lisa throws her every 2 years and Shuhua can’t even manage to get a character in Korea let alone her home country. Aespa’s Bside had more streams than in gidle’s titles..
Proper lines wise this is the most fair tt line distribution but timer wise spicy is more fair. NingNing has around 31, winter 47. Here nn has 52 (the move,move,move is nn) and Karina 34
They all had the chorus , and they all sung whiplash. Good enough to me. Definitely NingNings era, though in the video I couldn’t help pay attention to winter, she just gave off this aura of badass and cvnty ❤️🔥
Giselle has actual lines, less than 10% from the main vocalist, which is great. Also, her fit suits her! As a Ningmeng(OT4 stan as well), I hope that Aerishines will enjoy this era and set aside the treatment they felt(which is valid), I fear it may overshadowed the complaints and will lead to less satisfaction as whole…
I'm just confused as to why giselle doesn't get the main rap part. Instead, it goes to the main vocalist. Love nn, winter and karina. But giselle last real rap was in the girls, and it's sad.
Ningning’s part was in no way a rap tho… (unless you mean in drama and not here). I agree that Giselle doesn’t get rap parts but if we’re talking about this song then there’s no real rap
@@doublethenunyeah exactly… Giselle fans don’t look me in the eye and tell me you’d be happy with sme giving her that part as a “rap” nor should you be since she’s capable of much more (imo I like her singing parts more than the lackluster chanty parts that she usually gets because it displays some semblance of talent at least)
@@qwertynumbersix it did make sense its just frustrating because she doesn't get any full rap parts and anything close is shared among the other members usually (like nn part here, and they eat it up don't get me wrong) but she doesn't get many vocal lines either because everybody in the group is so talented 😭😭😭 and then she likely won't get many center dance moves coz of the hate she got for so long yknow 🤷♀️
Ty I was confused as hell about who was who and I been listening for hours this clears things up. I just discovered the group tody Karina seems to be my bias Thanks! but next week it might be another member LOl this happens a lot to me... Went through all bts members as bias and finally Jimin became my bias for the past 3 years XD
Because again my dear Giselle with so few lines, she is a good rapper and singing but they never give her that recognition, hopefully soon they will give her more 😢
u sound so fcking stupid, Karina has 34.84 and Giselle 34.21 like, not even a second of difference? y’all like to complain over nothing 😭 if Karina was last no one would say anything but since it’s Giselle… it’s like the world is ending
Giselle's fans already wake up from their fantasy, if she loved to rap so much, her new single DOPAMINE would have been more rap than vocal, when would they think with their brains?
girl she doesnt have to stick to one thing, shes an idol not a box. just bcs she didnt wanna rap in her solo song doesnt mean she doesnt want to at all? and same applied vice versa. like man learn to have some nuance. and i dont even like giselle
@@mediverge If you don't like Giselle, why do you think so? I never said I don't like Giselle, it's her fandom that's already getting old, what are you complaining about? If she had more screen time, she has said that she likes singing more than rapping.
@@Lqmwl literally who cares omfggg they all shined they all are trending and getting a check at the end of the day. and i promise u giselle dont gaf. 5 seconds is not the end of the world
If we switched Ning's "rap" with Gigi's part right after, the line distribution would've been like this: 2ning: 44.3 Winter: 40.6 Giselle: 40.4 Karina: 34.2 I wouldn't have been equal, but it would've been fair considering their positions(1. Main vocal, 2. Main vocal, 3. Main Rapper, 4. Lead Rapper). Plus, it would've made sense following their positions( the rapper gets the "rap", and the vocalist gets the vocal part). Not hating tho, the song is a bop, but i wish sm would improve the line distributions a little bit
This is definitely Giselle‘s era and Winter slay with her high note I‘m very happy that Ningning got a rap verse so we know she can rap and Karina‘s vocals stood really out in the second pre chorus
@@fawkiouuuggWhich was a vocal line. I know all of them are all rounders, but I really wish SM gave that rap line to Giselle, or at least shared it with Ningning given they have a shared scene which is kinda reminiscent of their succeeding lines in Drama. Ningning got that full rap and then a full vocal line on the next prechorus which is kinda ‘unfair’ to Giselle. But again, I’m just glad Giselle ate this comeback.
@@gorgeousspears971 producers don't really strictly follow the positions. i mean if you check new bsides ningning barely sings there. they decide based on how much someone's tone and pronunciation fits certain part, if it gives enough "character" they're looking for. ningning's voice and style with vocal fry sound very provocative and sassy which fits the lines that are calling out someone
I think all whip-whiplash lines should be sung by Giselle because her voice is most suitable for this part and song, also her voice is the best in all chorus. ( 2:34 and her "been bad" is best).
its funny cause i only realized how much ning2 sang just now, and giselle has such a presence that even with the smallest line she still stole this era
1:14 I found this part very empty just with Ningning, both in the choreography and listening to the music, this part was practically screaming to be two people singing and I think Giselle would fit in well here with Ningning Btw those "yeah" ad libs They switch between Ningning and Winter, it's just the two of them who do this part :)
At least Giselle literally stood out and shined with her pink hair in this comeback. I am pleased with that... Although her vocal tone suits the song the most, she got a little bit fewer lines...
This is pretty fair but I think Giselle should have the rap in 2nd verse and let Ningning sing the "I deliver I can promise im the coldest" part and the prechorus. SM should give Giselle a full rap line she is the rapper of the group my gosh SM
what I love about aespa is that they're like the only 4th gen girl group so far who releases a song more than 3 mins hence the last member would get at least 20+ seconds and the gap with the most lines isn't that far compare to other groups who had 40+ seconds for most lines and 9 seconds or less for the least line
Requested by Patreon Supporter: Cranman, umi, matteuscarraro, twilydia
Support me/Make a Request: randomk.me
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/random_k
FIRST
FALTAN LAS DEMÁS KILL IT, Y LAS OTRAS 😢😢
i fear giselle isn’t getting a full rap verse anytime soon but at least she stood out the most to me! i saw her a lot in the mv
1:14 could’ve been given to giselle i hate sm
@@valarieistoocute agree
why do y’all ride so hard for a racist???
@@valarieistoocutei agree but like at the same time ningning ate that part up 😭
@@stanbtspeople you can't be talking when you stan bts
Giselle: Finally I don't have least li-
Karina: Whip-Whiplash
Fr
HELP
lmao
HELPPP
One line gave her whiplash
I don’t know why I thought Giselle had the most lines :( maybe its cuz she shined so muuuuuch in the mv
Proof that line distribution aint everything! Giselle definitely had the most iconic and memorable line delivery
Be for real girl
@@jessep9929what? she shined a lot…
she still had a lot of lines.. her and karina have basically the same amount. this line distribution is perfectly fine
Why they give the main rapper most lines when there’s main vocalists?
Ningning is literally the highlight 🔥 2:18
2:18
yea no one's touching aespa... supernova, amargeddon, the solos, & now whiplash all within 6 months is a NASTY run.
spicy.. drama.. supernova.. armageddon.. hot mess.. the solos and now whiplash is actually crazy work.
Aespa's first good year ☺️
Because honestly before, well they existed... And that's it.
@@Mr_Err3be so fr… next level and savage were literally some of the most iconic and memorable songs of 2021 aespa have ALWAYS been great
@@Mr_Err3 Are you crazy? Literally everyone was trying to make their version of next level/savage after they got released + spicy was the song of the summer 2023
@@Mr_Err3 Gidle is irrelevant and everyone in their group sucks and flopped. Yuqi sucks. Soyeon hasn’t written a good rap in years. Miyeon is irrelevant, only mentioned when BP is. Soojin flopped. Minnie is being deported back to Thailand where she will live off the scraps lisa throws her every 2 years and Shuhua can’t even manage to get a character in Korea let alone her home country. Aespa’s Bside had more streams than in gidle’s titles..
Their most fair line distribution, we cheer! Giselle and Winter era for me!
Proper lines wise this is the most fair tt line distribution but timer wise spicy is more fair. NingNing has around 31, winter 47. Here nn has 52 (the move,move,move is nn) and Karina 34
of title tracks its near the top but if were counting bsides im unhappy is their fairest for sure
ningning’s era since supernova, as it should be! her amazing talent and performance deserves to be treated as the MAIN 🖤
Ningning and Giselle ate SO BAD this era😭😭😭
Ikrrrr
FRR soo fancy and glamour 😖😖😖❤❤
Yeah I feel like they fit more to a concept like that than the AI concept
I think Winter ate more than ning2x
karina too tho
My Ningning slays every time ❤
if I don't hear whiplash at the next vogue korea runway, idk what I'm doing
Supernova, Armageddon, hot mess, solos, and now whiplash
This is aespa's year
ningselle's era definitely
They all had the chorus , and they all sung whiplash. Good enough to me. Definitely NingNings era, though in the video I couldn’t help pay attention to winter, she just gave off this aura of badass and cvnty ❤️🔥
Winter’s parts stood out the most to me, and all the girls absolutely killed it this cb, as expected ❤️
NINGNING!!
Giselles era for sure💅🏻
I LOVE THE DISTRIBUTION, imo better than armageddon
2ning slayed
you can just say ning lmao it's her real last name
Giselle defently stood out more this comeback compared to previous releases.
However NingNing is the one owning this era for sure.
Exactly like her rap verse is the highlight of the song
NingNing’s era, I feel. Models are praying she doesn’t quit being an idol
THIS IS 100% GISELLE ERA ‼️‼️
@@eaJ.205 yeaaa Giselle is rly carrying 2024 atp
NING NING FOR SURE.
@@Vickysoon its her/his opinion
@@Vickysoongo away and make your own comment
definitely not Armageddon @@eaJ.205
Whip-whiplash
Giselle has actual lines, less than 10% from the main vocalist, which is great. Also, her fit suits her!
As a Ningmeng(OT4 stan as well), I hope that Aerishines will enjoy this era and set aside the treatment they felt(which is valid), I fear it may overshadowed the complaints and will lead to less satisfaction as whole…
I'm just confused as to why giselle doesn't get the main rap part. Instead, it goes to the main vocalist. Love nn, winter and karina. But giselle last real rap was in the girls, and it's sad.
Ningning’s part was in no way a rap tho… (unless you mean in drama and not here). I agree that Giselle doesn’t get rap parts but if we’re talking about this song then there’s no real rap
@@doublethenunyeah exactly… Giselle fans don’t look me in the eye and tell me you’d be happy with sme giving her that part as a “rap” nor should you be since she’s capable of much more (imo I like her singing parts more than the lackluster chanty parts that she usually gets because it displays some semblance of talent at least)
Idk if any of that made sense
@@qwertynumbersix it did make sense its just frustrating because she doesn't get any full rap parts and anything close is shared among the other members usually (like nn part here, and they eat it up don't get me wrong) but she doesn't get many vocal lines either because everybody in the group is so talented 😭😭😭 and then she likely won't get many center dance moves coz of the hate she got for so long yknow 🤷♀️
Giselle getting her lines IM SO HAPPY FOR HER 🥲💗💗💗💗
Giselle last chorus
She ate ✨🩶
NING NING THIS ERA IS FOR U MY QUEEN 🩷
No
The coolest video of line distribution ever! U did great edit!!
They all ate but Giselle ate down fr
Nahh
Oh this is Ningning and Giselle's era ❤❤ let's keep supporting Mys 🥹
I think it’s winters era
@@stayhydrated123 yes !!! I think Winter served too but Ningning and Giselle just captured my attention more!!
Winter short hair looks very very stylish
Woah _riiiiight _as I was looking up whiplash line distribution this video pops up 🤯🤯
Thanks for this! Hope you'll do their other songs in the album as well. Specially, flowers, flights not feelings and just another girl 😍
Winter and Giselle 🤍🩶🖤🤎💜🩵💙💚💛🧡🩷❤️❤️🩹❤️🔥❣️💟💕💞💓💗💖💝💘💌
giselle has said that she likes to sing so idk why everyone is complaining about her not getting a rap verse
Probably because even her vocal lines aren't that long, so they're hoping she gets a long rap yknow since it fits best with her position
Ty I was confused as hell about who was who and I been listening for hours this clears things up. I just discovered the group tody Karina seems to be my bias Thanks! but next week it might be another member LOl this happens a lot to me... Went through all bts members as bias and finally Jimin became my bias for the past 3 years XD
Line distribution is great but I must say Giselle is killing it this comeback.
I always trust in your line distributions!
Giselle being last again on the comeback she owned💔
I don't think she needs a lot of lines to shine like this era she's shining the most
Getting the killing parts matters more, she really ate it up esp with that last chorus!
Thank you for always providing perfect distribution❤️
OH QUEENQUEEN WE FCKING LUV YOU
Giselle era 🗣️🔥
Because again my dear Giselle with so few lines, she is a good rapper and singing but they never give her that recognition, hopefully soon they will give her more 😢
Shut up lol she got the same lines as karina
She has many lines this comeback, what are you talking about.
she has the same amount of lines as Karina lmao
u sound so fcking stupid, Karina has 34.84 and Giselle 34.21 like, not even a second of difference? y’all like to complain over nothing 😭 if Karina was last no one would say anything but since it’s Giselle… it’s like the world is ending
This is not a competition.
Stop being so childsh and stream Whiplash.
ningning ate
winter whole song in backsound : yeah yeah yeah
Karina s pre chorus is on repeat tbh 😭😭
giselle and ningning's era
2:48 무리해도 -> 다가와도
Giselle's fans already wake up from their fantasy, if she loved to rap so much, her new single DOPAMINE would have been more rap than vocal, when would they think with their brains?
girl she doesnt have to stick to one thing, shes an idol not a box. just bcs she didnt wanna rap in her solo song doesnt mean she doesnt want to at all? and same applied vice versa. like man learn to have some nuance. and i dont even like giselle
@@mediverge If you don't like Giselle, why do you think so? I never said I don't like Giselle, it's her fandom that's already getting old, what are you complaining about? If she had more screen time, she has said that she likes singing more than rapping.
@@Lqmwl literally who cares omfggg they all shined they all are trending and getting a check at the end of the day. and i promise u giselle dont gaf. 5 seconds is not the end of the world
@@mediverge When her fans continue to protest about Giselle this and giselle that, it means her fans know she isn't shining enough and still want more
@@wersagikartopawiro7078 and what are sm and everyone else supposed to do about that. like baby maybe shes just not as charismatic and thats ok
If we switched Ning's "rap" with Gigi's part right after, the line distribution would've been like this:
2ning: 44.3
Winter: 40.6
Giselle: 40.4
Karina: 34.2
I wouldn't have been equal, but it would've been fair considering their positions(1. Main vocal, 2. Main vocal, 3. Main Rapper, 4. Lead Rapper). Plus, it would've made sense following their positions( the rapper gets the "rap", and the vocalist gets the vocal part).
Not hating tho, the song is a bop, but i wish sm would improve the line distributions a little bit
sm so afraid to give giselle a rap cause they know everyone will talk about it nonstop
@@grayhunter1602what a lie lol since she was given pink hair to stand out
lol you clearly know nothing about the story behind her pink hair for this cb, so just stfu
@@anisaafsar4528that's not a lie to this day ppl can't stop talking about when she rapped in savage😭
Not you giving Karina nothing in this mv and song
1:13 ningning slayed 💋
Whip-whiplash ❤
2:48 umm I think it's not murihaedo?
Anyway, thanks for the line distribution❤
I love the new glow design! ❤
Thanks youuu❤❤❤❤
1:44 oh my god
screentime would be also interesting.. I think Winter has the least screentime of all
This is definitely Giselle‘s era and Winter slay with her high note
I‘m very happy that Ningning got a rap verse so we know she can rap and Karina‘s vocals stood really out in the second pre chorus
Did you just know that Ningning can rap? Hasn't he already shown it?
@@wersagikartopawiro7078 I know that Ningning can rap and she also rap in a song but this time she got the main rap part I think
I think 1:13 should be Giselle's, but Ningning did well at the same time. :D
well giselle had the line right after so that’s probably why she didn’t get it
It wasn't even a rap bozo
@@fawkiouuuggWhich was a vocal line. I know all of them are all rounders, but I really wish SM gave that rap line to Giselle, or at least shared it with Ningning given they have a shared scene which is kinda reminiscent of their succeeding lines in Drama. Ningning got that full rap and then a full vocal line on the next prechorus which is kinda ‘unfair’ to Giselle. But again, I’m just glad Giselle ate this comeback.
@@gorgeousspears971 producers don't really strictly follow the positions. i mean if you check new bsides ningning barely sings there. they decide based on how much someone's tone and pronunciation fits certain part, if it gives enough "character" they're looking for. ningning's voice and style with vocal fry sound very provocative and sassy which fits the lines that are calling out someone
@@gorgeousspears971Ningning is all rounder
FINALLY THIS MASTERPIECE'S LD! 🎉
I think all whip-whiplash lines should be sung by Giselle because her voice is most suitable for this part and song, also her voice is the best in all chorus. ( 2:34 and her "been bad" is best).
never been so fast
X2
Igloo kiss of life pleaseee😊
The distribution is so fair OMG, this is why i love aespa
Every member will shine
This line distribution is quite fair. Everyone shined here. æspa always serve banger and banger. Can’t wait to see more from them.
Finally! Someone who talks about everyone not just Ning and giselle
@stayhydrated123Late but thank you!
Winter era, she ate
its funny cause i only realized how much ning2 sang just now, and giselle has such a presence that even with the smallest line she still stole this era
Giselle is getting what she deserves ❤😊
Nothing? Bc she’s in last again which is just sad
@@stayhydrated123so it's mean she deserves the last?
@@wersagikartopawiro7078 No, i mean the screen time and lines 😂
a giselle com mais de 30 segundos meu deus 😭😭😭🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
1:14 I found this part very empty just with Ningning, both in the choreography and listening to the music, this part was practically screaming to be two people singing and I think Giselle would fit in well here with Ningning
Btw those "yeah" ad libs They switch between Ningning and Winter, it's just the two of them who do this part :)
At least Giselle literally stood out and shined with her pink hair in this comeback. I am pleased with that... Although her vocal tone suits the song the most, she got a little bit fewer lines...
Aespa ain't stopping with their bangers and I love that ❤
This is pretty fair but I think Giselle should have the rap in 2nd verse and let Ningning sing the "I deliver I can promise im the coldest" part and the prechorus. SM should give Giselle a full rap line she is the rapper of the group my gosh SM
GIGIII ERAAAAAAAA❤❤❤❤ MY LOVE
지젤은 타이틀에서 파트를 많이 못받아서 아쉬움… 타이틀도 꽉 채워서 내줘 스엠아 ㅠㅠ
holy balls this song is like if vouge and untouchable had a kid
I thought the line distribution would be like this:
1-Ningning
2-Giselle
3-Karina
4-Winter
I don't know why
lately Ningning and Giselle have been showing off their superstar ability on music videos. They always are the moment
3:02
Giselle: Oh yes! I'm 3rd
Karina: Mmmhh.. honey I don't think so
Ning Ning's "Yeah" at 1:29 really dirves carzy ❤
Gigi my love my bias FOREVER ❤❤❤
No because why did random_k actually get this right BEFORE live preformances.. even the hard to identify adlibs omg
I just noticed an error in the last line of karina, supposedly "다가와도 can't touch that"
Can you pls eyes on you by seventeen pls 😢
I want purple kiss - on my bike song in line distribution & lyrics too.. 🥺🥺
That prechorus goes so hard
NING NING ERA FOR SURE WITH GISELLE 🌸✨
Giselle 💓💓💓
4 minutes ago ❤😊
Giselle and Ningning era for sure
they still ate so bad after supernova, armageddon, and hot mess. give an applause to those who worked on their songs 👏
I swore Giselle had the most lines 😂 but finally she was the one who shone the most in the MV
Please do kill it and flowers its hard to differentiate adlibs
2:41 "move-move-move" is Ningning.
It's even an exaggeration to say, but in this case, Karina totals 34.04 seconds, right?
what I love about aespa is that they're like the only 4th gen girl group so far who releases a song more than 3 mins hence the last member would get at least 20+ seconds and the gap with the most lines isn't that far compare to other groups who had 40+ seconds for most lines and 9 seconds or less for the least line
STREAM WHIPLASH❤❤❤
Когда же настанет то время... Чтобы хотя бы в одной песне, Жизель дали рэп куплет и у нее будет больше всех партий... Ах, мечты мечты...
Despite giselle having the least lines, this was DEFINITELY her era(along with ningning) she stood out so much in this comeback
They’re the actual queens of kpop
Come on we need a titletrack where Giselle isnt last😭
Btw Giselle owned this era for sure!
It’s pretty fair tbh karina and gigi are tied and over 30 seconds is a pretty good ratio not complaining
she was the last but had the best lines imo. this was her era, her tone is amazing in this song.
@@sandipansadgunrizal1900 yeah thats right but pls Giselle is always last
the racist is last as she deserves
@@stanbtspeople so you think calling other people racist doesn’t make you one? Delulu