Yeah absolutely! If he stopped the drinking he'd not only save tens of thousands of calories but also he'd actually do stuff and move more! I wouldn't walk or go swimming when I was drinking. Now I get bored so I go out for a walk of an evening!
As someone with an eating disorder, these programmes actually give me ideas, the health implications don’t even worry me, i’ve just started eating lunch and dinner again, so on the road to recovery, fingers crossed!
Shows like this are dangerous, and promoting such fad diets as potentially healthy is scary. Eat well and eat lots, food is too good and tasty to not eat it - even the healthy food. I hope your recovery goes well and you enjoy what you eat!
Absolute nonsense. Measuring a diet in calories is ridiculous and wanting a medical professional to direct something they have no training or knowledge in is equally ridiculous. Plenty of people have fasted for extended periods of time and come out better for it.
@@MHSMagicLuver If you're measuring what you eat in calories you're not even at the starting line. Stop eating carbohydrates and processed food and the rest will take care of itself.
Yes binge eating & overeating is often linked to emotional deregulation. This makes it harder to lose weight or maintain it. The root of the issue has to be dealt with. For my friend it was childhood SA. The minute a man would show any s3xual interest in her when she was getting skinnier she would get triggered & start binge eating. She was never able to get her weight under control until a therapist made her connect the pattern. She is now doing great.
I agree, I have lost large amounts of weight but can never keep it off, had a gastric bypass but still put weight back on. Even when I was very thin I was not happy still had the same depression and low self esteem. Until mental health is addressed any weight loss will fail.
I rather lose the weight slowly because I know I have a better chance at keeping off long term. I'm not a professional, but I feel crash dieting sets people up for long term failure. Losing weight should be about changing your lifestyle long term, not to lose 1 stone in 2 weeks without really learning how to change for a healthy balanced life. So far I've lost a bit over 10 stones over the last couple years. I do not follow fad diets. I learned to eat smaller portions, I gave up none of the foods I enjoyed, I just enjoy them in moderation. And for me this method has worked well. (I'm working with my doctor to make sure I'm doing my weight loss in a healthy way.)
And this is why people say diets don't work. They do these dumb crash diets and then go right back to their bad eating habits that made them gain the weight in the first place.
@@guardiansanimalrescuestate7289 I'm about 130. I've been down to 100 as an adult and it was terrible. But I'm also about 5.4 and shouldn't be much below 110 at the lowest anyway.
I tried to do the Lighter Life diet but only lasted 3 days because it was torture, I was on 500 calls a day and felt like I was being starved. Nothing is worth that.
As someone who is technically dieting, this show is the most dangerous one I’ve seen ever. Fad diets are not healthy no matter how you dress it up and the majority of people won’t keep that weight off because the eating habits have not changed for the better, just changed temporarily to something unsustainable. Lose weight slowly but changing how and what you eat to something you can sustain and live by is the best way to diet. You won’t fit into the pair of jeans a size or two smaller in a week but with sustainable lifestyle changes you can in a few months and stay that way.
Based on the comments, I think I'll skip this video, however... I do feel motivated to go back to fasting & light weight lifting! It works! Depression made me quit, and I don't think Depression gets to win anymore!
I'm so confused you're promoting crash dieting by talking about how awesome it is to finally get results while also trying to say it's dangerous and deadly what message are you trying to spread you're sending mixed signals
@@getin3949 This is a myth, look at studies on fasting, our body isn't against quick results. There is no mechanism in body that measures if results are too fast, this isn't how our body works.
We have to acknowledge that whole picture to be able to address it, it's a reality that you can get visual results on crash diets, however, you've lost more water weight than you accounted for, and you've put unnecessary stress on your body, especially your heart and liver, You haven't changed your eating habits in the long term and your body has just experienced a hunger episode so you're statistically doomed to gain all the weight back and more. None of the facts above is going to tramp over that crash diets can show results and this is the sole reason this method of weight loss has been around for the last 80 years.
530 calories!? Dr now doesn’t ever prescribe that for his severely obese 600 lb patients! Wtf. I mean if it works for somebody it works! But the issue will lie in the maintenance
It will work, absolutely....but so does eating 2 Snickers and calling it a day. Neither is not sustainable or healthy and you'll probably feel terrible in the process.
@@MHSMagicLuver I eat 500 cals a day and i don't gain it back easily. You gain 3-5 pounds of water weight from introducing carbs again, then it stays stable as long as you stay at maintenence calories (around 2000 for me)
Crash diets are great for a quick fix, but they don't teach you how to eat properly. That's why so many people lose and gain quickly. Diet is a nasty word, we should all strive to find a healthy food plan, and exercise plan that works best for each one of us. The very best to everyone reading this comment. You can do it! 💛
the standards haven‘t changed only the acceptable maybee, adults doing crash diets would be bizarre today, how they don‘t see the health problems in their joints, intestines and hormones coming as result of regular starvation and excluding food groups
Currently in the grip of an ED and it’s actually helpful seeing how normal people react to diets that encourage ridiculous, extreme and restrictive rules and behaviours. There really is a massive difference between normal and ED thinking…
A diet of only 530 calories a day is a starvation diet. As soon as a person starts eating normally again the weight will come back greater than before.
16:22 you can’t weigh your self for one day and say “I’ve lost 3lbs!” My weight can shift 5lbs in day with water weight, food, going to the bathroom. This is so sad. What have we become in the name of thinness? 😞
@@DX-dit is normal tho lol sometimes I be 5kg more the next day and that’s def more then 5lbs. Most of the time it’s 2-3kg tho but sometimes even 7kg when I drink a lot of water
@DX-d it is completely normal. Food weighs in your stomach, along with water and your body retaining water. I weigh 5lbs more at night than in the morning. + woman have periods. Before my period I weight up to 4 lbs more ontop of that
When I was in high school some guy at my work that was few years older than me told me I would look better if I lost a few pounds. I was at a normal weight at the time. It really hurt my feeling and I thought that if I did lose a few pounds him/everyone would like me more. After I started losing weight everyone was complimenting on how good I looked so I continued to lose more and more. I dropped over 20lbs. I’ve struggled with body issues ever since. I am in my 30s now but I still struggle.
I’m sorry this happened to you ❤ Men are *never* our friends… if a man suggests something to you that’s a personal attribute situation (like weight loss, hair, makeup, nails, fashion) DISMISS THEM. They create mental health problems in girls and women like they get paid bonuses for it. Don’t listen to these hateful men
I’m trained dietitian and to be honest I’m quite frustrated and even angry 😡. Human metabolism is really complex and many people are making millions of spreading misinformation or half truths about the subject. Naturally weight loss diets are the most popular and always will be. I would be really happy if the government would put some regulations and restrictions how these diets and books are advertised and published, then I wouldn’t see so many disasters and complete distractions in human life.
If you only eat a certain way to lose weight and then go back to how you were eating before, it won't stay off, obviously. You also have to address emotional issues and trauma or you'll just keep getting reeled back into dysfunctional eating. Otherwise, I don't see a problem with eating a certain way for a short period of time to lose weight. But you really have to be mindful when you eat and also make sure to honor your hunger. Being ravenous is only going to cause you to sabotage yourself.
14:34 it always irritates and shocks me to see overweight professionals giving diet and nutrition advice with confidence! Are we supposed to act blind ?!
You're not supposed to not consume any calories at all. The fasting that's recommended is intermittent fasting, which just means you don't eat after a certain time (usually 5pm), and then start again the next day at, like, 7am. Even a hardcore fast is not 0 calories, but you're right that it's very low-calorie and not good for you.
I have actually never been on a " diet". I have pretty much always stuck to the "eat when you're hungry" rule, and eat what I want. I may have spaghetti for breakfast or toast for dinner. I've never had a weight problem, and I am satisfied after eating what I fancy.
It's amazing how different all our bodies are. My boyfriend struggles to gain weight. One of his life's dreams was to join the army but no matter what he eats he is still under weight. He's tried supplements and diets from doctors, diets from the internet, eating 6 peanut butter sandwiches day along with regular meals and nothing worked. For me on the other hand, especially since being on my meds, if I try intuitive eating I eat too much and gain weight. I also crave sweets and junk food. The only thing I've found that works for me is a keto diet because it cuts out sugar and carbs which for me reduces cravings. I don't really consider it a crash diet though because it's long term. I make sure I eat mostly veg and some clean protein and some healthy fats. I really think that all our bodies are different though and what works for some people might not work for others. If I do intuitive eating then I hover between 80 and 85 kgs which for my height is over weight. I'm on a bit of a health binge at the moment and hoping to get down to 60. At the moment I'm at 74. I'm incorporating intermittent fasting and a bit more light exercise like walking.
I don't subscribe to the the average diet because my specialists have been wrong so often. Food is food. We, as agricultural humans , made scheduled eating from farmer's schedules. I have no problem eating eggs with dinner , nor fruits for breakfast. I work overnights, so seven thirty in the morning is my dinnertime. Food is food, and works how you work it.
My first diet was at the age of 8, 1500 calories a day as made to follow by a doctor. This started my up and down cycle of different diets over the past 48 years. This is my last chance, I have submitted my application for bariatric surgery where 80% of your stomach is removed.
I’m on 1500 calories a day and tbh, it’s rather easy as long as you make sure your meals are below 500 calories and you add tons of veg to make sure you feel full and satisfied. But also… no 8 year old should be on a diet. I was put on multiple diets growing up and none of them would stick because I wasn’t in the right frame of mind to do it. It’s only now at the age of 26, I’m finally capable of following through and sticking to it. All the foods and sugary drinks I’ve cut out aren’t even missed anymore. Lost over a stone in weight in less than two months and by the looks of it, it isn’t stopping anytime soon. I wish you luck with your weight loss journey. Just remember, the person who enjoys the destination isn’t going to go as far as the person who enjoys the journey.
im on a diet excluding gluten, lactose due to intolerance and any chemical additives due to allergies. still! i can watch my weight go up but what made me happy always and what i got back to last year is intermittent fasting. even up to 3 days. it works wonders.! there’s a lot of studies available now about how to approach it, please remember about minerals during the day if you try that
Have you tried carnivore/animal based? You should look into RUclips channels where extremely overweight people have lost weight on these diets. It’s satiating and you don’t think about calories at all.
I was on a juicing diet and was rapidly losing weight. Then I came down with Crohns Disease. One of the most terrifying experiences of my life. I don’t know, nor do the doctors, whether correlation = causation, in my case. I stopped the juicing immediately and began eating my regular food to control the Crohns Disease symptoms, while waiting for my medication. That was 12 years ago. I still don’t know if the juicing components in themselves caused it, i e too much acid; chemicals in the soil; or I was set up for it for other reasons. Now I just take my Rx meds 3x daily and try not to speculate too much, just feel grateful that the medication works.
I use to drink coffee a about 9 cups working 17hrs nights shifts in a nursing home. Now i only drink 2 cups and 1 decaff. People can change, but boy that guys alcohol consumption is beyond addiction, he should replace some with water, juice, diet soda, decaffs etc. Did that grandma say she use to take 50 laxatives a day? 4 is max isnt. That lady doing a keto pee test, was it necessary to show the whole toilet scene? Wheres the privacy gone.
@@sharonchorley1311 sorry, I was referring to extended fasting, ranging from 36-72 hours. Calorie deficit alone makes me cold and exhausted, but extended fasting, after working up to it, makes me energetic and happy.
Anyone here looking for weight loss do it safely This is what I did and lost almost 5 stone in a year and I made a lot of mistakes Eat normally for a week and track the calories Take off 250 - 500 calories a day off the total so if your eating 3000 a day eat 2500 A deficit of 500 calories a day can lead to 3500 calories a week or 1LB of weight loss Do this with some resistance training to maintain muscle mass and you’ll achieve your goal slowly but safely Also coach greg is an amazing weight loss RUclipsr I definitely recommend
This documentary really failed to prove the point it should have made. They should have followed the dieters after their crash diets to show how people regain the weight from being overly restrictive and the science behind that. The message could be to make small and gradual lifestyle changes, but instead they just glamorized these starvation diets. What a bummer.
People should not put all their self worth on what they weigh because that is a bad idea because when you look good you are happy and then when you feel you don't then you most likely end up having mood swings and most likely it will lead to poor mental health
People make losing weight so complicated nowadays. All you have to do is eat in a calorie deficit and exercise and don’t restrict ur calories to stuff like 500 or 1000 because then you’ll just binge eat the weight back.
Why not simply reduce your caloric intake by sheer 500kcal per day, start walking, hiking, swimming, light cycling, even 15-30 minutes of light excercise every day will result in a weight loss in a month. Why do people always go to extremes, do dangerous unsustainable diets that are impossible to sustain over longer periods instead of little by little eliminating bad habits like sodas, candies, fried foods... combine it with light excercise and higher intake of vegetables... You'll develop healthy eating habits over time, stop your craving, get in the better shape and be actually healthy and fit 🤷 it's extremely easy to lose weight and keep it off, people are just lazy, stupid and want express results just focused on the appearance instead of their health and well being....
They don't, most ppl try doing that, and it doesn't work. If you will just cut calories you will be hungry, add exercise to that, you will be even more hungry. Your body will reduce your BMR so you will likely have to reduce calories even more, also body will release hormones that will make you want to move less. It can work for few kg for somebody that is healthy but doesn't work for most ppl. Think about it, why would you need to restrict calories? What controls how many calories you are eating? Your hormones do, if you will arbitrary limit calories you work against your body, and that isn't easy or smart or sustainable in the long term.
Because people are stupid especially fatties and would just consume 500 calories of carbs and sugar. Then two hours later wonder why they are still hungry. ❤❤🎉🎉😂😂
(80/20) healthy meals 80% exercise 20% Monday to Saturday, Sunday I gave myself a day off to enjoy what ever l wanted to eat and then back on with the plan. But boy l looked forward to my Sundays.
@@KraszuPolis you're right that people feel hungry when running a calorie deficit, but that is the only way to lose weight. The problem people have is that they cannot handle hunger as as they are simply not used to it! All you really need to do is eat the right amount of calories for your height and desired body composition, and you will lose weight until you reach the correct composition.
This is how you healthily lose weight. Caloric deficit and weight lifting. You can either measure how many calories you regularly eat in a week and drop 500 calories from that or do a macro calculator which is more of an estimate. Stick to those calories for at least 2 weeks and see how you do. A healthy goal is 1-2lbs a week. Start with minimal cardio but heavy weight lifting if possible (this is also good for your bones). After at least a couple weeks if you hadn’t lost weight, drop ahout 100-200 calories. Once you are losing weight keep those same calories and cardio until you stop losing weight for at least 2 weeks. If you stop losing, drop calories by 100 and/or increase cardio by 5-10 minutes. Continue. Do a max of 4-6 months in a deficit, and then do a reverse diet for at least 6 months. After that you can go back into another deficit
Here is an idea.....I was 400 lbs im now 200lbs! How? slow changes at first! but mainly eating 2200 Cals a day as I got closer to 200lbs i went down to 2000 cals a day! I still eat everything just less at a time lol.
If george just cuts out the booze he'll lose weight that week anyway without going on a crash diet so the results are inaccurate. As week one is usually water weight anyway. Weight loss slows after the initial water whoosh.
So this series is from 2011. I magine in 2035 people watching dieters from 2023 eating keto and carnivor and fasting 16 hours, how rediculous it will seem
I came to this after listening to RoyTaylor's diabetes diet. Basically, he says prediabetes or diabetes can be put into remission by quickly dropping 15-20kg. He advocates 600 calories of shakes and soups plus a small 100 calorie meal (a salad etc to break the monotomy of a liquid diet)...so 700 cals/day and no exercise for a max of 12 weeks or until blood sugar is normal. He doesn't seem to recognize that it's a crash diet (he's an endocrinologist) and therefore does not address these kinds of issues raised here. Watching this to see if it can be done safely and maintained.
I did it as I had diabetes but using Michael Mosleys 800 calories a day plan of real food. I didn't feel all that hungry, I did it for 10 weeks, the weight came off and the diabetes went into remission. Since then I've stuck to avoiding simple carbs and the weight is staying off.
@@morematcha No surprisingly. When I've tried to do the 5/2 diet I gave up because I was so hungry but doing it every day I didn't. I did drink a lot - miso soup, Herbal teas, coffee with a dash of milk, water with slices of cucumber, cider vinegar in warm water.
It’s not the diet working. You’re eating in a calorie deficit. THAT is why you’re losing weight. Anyone can lose weight on a starvation diet if 500 cals week. But what happens when you come off it? Hmmmm…. Why not eat proper food and stop snacking every 10 min. Exercise. Even walking will work. Make a lifestyle change for sustainable weightloss.
Crash diets are stupid . The simplest changes help lose weight . Eat as many vegetables as you like , a small portion of carbs , a portion of proteins , a fruit and drink water or tea ( or coffee ) . Don't ever go for seconds and fill a normal size plate . Don't over fill the plate , don't pile food up . Don't eat from a bowl you would increase portions . Walk 30 min a day at least and you are good . I'm 76 and lost 17 pounds since mid march ( I put on 20 pounds when I stopped smoking 3.5 years ago ) .
Dietician is giving a lot of bad advice......making anyone drink a lot of water without electrolytes is horrible......might rise to serious issues even in the short term.
George’s alcohol consumption should worry him a lot more than his weight!
Exactly 💯
He is alcoholic
He’s an alcoholic.
He's gonna have alcohol withdrawal
Yeah absolutely! If he stopped the drinking he'd not only save tens of thousands of calories but also he'd actually do stuff and move more! I wouldn't walk or go swimming when I was drinking. Now I get bored so I go out for a walk of an evening!
A bottle of vine, a gin-n-tonic and a can of beer a day isn't "likes his drink", it's alcoholism.
this!! Wtf
@@leromera7223 one glass of wine is the limit for women daily, a bottle and other stuff on top will destroy your liver
@@arikalamari19not every night. There is a weekly limit. Ideally one should not drink at all, or only a few times a year.
Just being Brit.
As someone with an eating disorder, these programmes actually give me ideas, the health implications don’t even worry me, i’ve just started eating lunch and dinner again, so on the road to recovery, fingers crossed!
Shows like this are dangerous, and promoting such fad diets as potentially healthy is scary. Eat well and eat lots, food is too good and tasty to not eat it - even the healthy food. I hope your recovery goes well and you enjoy what you eat!
@@louise8219 it really is, i need to stop watching these things during my recovery, it’s not healthy. Thank you so much for your kind words :)
I was told I had an eating disorder, even though I ate when I was hungry. Tirned out
Turned out I had a blood and bone irregularity.
Good luck!!!
Any diet that requires less than 1000 calories a day, unless directed by a medical professional, is absolutely ridiculous.
Agree. Or even under 1200. And even that’s super low! Even for me at 120lbs and 5’0, I don’t even go to 1200. My lowest is 1350 or 1400.
Absolute nonsense. Measuring a diet in calories is ridiculous and wanting a medical professional to direct something they have no training or knowledge in is equally ridiculous. Plenty of people have fasted for extended periods of time and come out better for it.
@@MHSMagicLuver If you're measuring what you eat in calories you're not even at the starting line. Stop eating carbohydrates and processed food and the rest will take care of itself.
My doctor recommended to have 1000 to 1200 per day. Said im obese at 4.9 height. So I am trying to lose 15kg to get to 55kg.
Since I had a hysterectomy last month my diet sucks
This is just eating disorders with extra steps. 530 calories a DAY?!? Absolute insanity.
If it’s not for a long time it’s not insane. Some foods u can eat a lot before u ate 500cal
Did we really need to see the lady weeing on the toilet?
Apparently yes.
Overeating is related to mental health. Unless you deal with the mental health, nothing will stick.
Yes binge eating & overeating is often linked to emotional deregulation. This makes it harder to lose weight or maintain it. The root of the issue has to be dealt with. For my friend it was childhood SA. The minute a man would show any s3xual interest in her when she was getting skinnier she would get triggered & start binge eating. She was never able to get her weight under control until a therapist made her connect the pattern. She is now doing great.
Very correct, weight is usually a symptom of something else.
Also modem diets esp sugar are addictive
@@Bexstarartist dairy is more addictive
I agree, I have lost large amounts of weight but can never keep it off, had a gastric bypass but still put weight back on. Even when I was very thin I was not happy still had the same depression and low self esteem. Until mental health is addressed any weight loss will fail.
I rather lose the weight slowly because I know I have a better chance at keeping off long term. I'm not a professional, but I feel crash dieting sets people up for long term failure. Losing weight should be about changing your lifestyle long term, not to lose 1 stone in 2 weeks without really learning how to change for a healthy balanced life.
So far I've lost a bit over 10 stones over the last couple years. I do not follow fad diets. I learned to eat smaller portions, I gave up none of the foods I enjoyed, I just enjoy them in moderation. And for me this method has worked well. (I'm working with my doctor to make sure I'm doing my weight loss in a healthy way.)
And this is why people say diets don't work. They do these dumb crash diets and then go right back to their bad eating habits that made them gain the weight in the first place.
OMG, even my Nutritionist put me on a 1200 calorie per day, 630 is insane for anyone!!
@@getin3949 unfortunately anyone can call themselves a nutritionist. That doesn't mean they really know what they're talking about.
@@aniE1869right, dietitians are degreed and licensed, nutritionists are not.
How much do u weigh?? I’m 100 pounds. U have to stick with the diets.
@@guardiansanimalrescuestate7289 I'm about 130. I've been down to 100 as an adult and it was terrible. But I'm also about 5.4 and shouldn't be much below 110 at the lowest anyway.
Just because you are only allowed steak and yoghurt in your diet does not automatically mean you have to combine the two on the same plate 🤢
don't knock it, meat and greek yoghurt go amazing together....I mean i've never seen anyone use THAT much yoghurt.
@@NotSoProKitty Same! Looks great to me!! She could also have a side of cheese
It was probably similar to beef and sour cream.
Sounds like a recipe for gout, tbh.
Might be good with savoury yoghurt and spices
I tried to do the Lighter Life diet but only lasted 3 days because it was torture, I was on 500 calls a day and felt like I was being starved. Nothing is worth that.
You felt like you were being starved -because you WERE being starved!
George could've lost it soo quickly by cutting alcohol and limiting eating out/takeaways
I totally dig the 2000s vibes in this documentaries. The science seems to be from the 2000s as well though... xD
The eyebrows too 😅
I have a feeling it was filmed a while ago, looking at the fashion and some of the cars and the style of the video
Couldn't agree more; this doctor needs to update her nutrition research. Cals in = Cals out is sooooooooo 2000's
@@dorothyrodehutskors4724calories in
As someone who is technically dieting, this show is the most dangerous one I’ve seen ever. Fad diets are not healthy no matter how you dress it up and the majority of people won’t keep that weight off because the eating habits have not changed for the better, just changed temporarily to something unsustainable. Lose weight slowly but changing how and what you eat to something you can sustain and live by is the best way to diet. You won’t fit into the pair of jeans a size or two smaller in a week but with sustainable lifestyle changes you can in a few months and stay that way.
Based on the comments, I think I'll skip this video, however... I do feel motivated to go back to fasting & light weight lifting! It works! Depression made me quit, and I don't think Depression gets to win anymore!
I'm so confused you're promoting crash dieting by talking about how awesome it is to finally get results while also trying to say it's dangerous and deadly what message are you trying to spread you're sending mixed signals
This video is just plain nutz, this is a quick fix and your body will not like it. Especially if your health isn't great to begin with.
😂😂😂 so true!
@@getin3949 This is a myth, look at studies on fasting, our body isn't against quick results. There is no mechanism in body that measures if results are too fast, this isn't how our body works.
We have to acknowledge that whole picture to be able to address it, it's a reality that you can get visual results on crash diets, however, you've lost more water weight than you accounted for, and you've put unnecessary stress on your body, especially your heart and liver, You haven't changed your eating habits in the long term and your body has just experienced a hunger episode so you're statistically doomed to gain all the weight back and more. None of the facts above is going to tramp over that crash diets can show results and this is the sole reason this method of weight loss has been around for the last 80 years.
530 calories!? Dr now doesn’t ever prescribe that for his severely obese 600 lb patients! Wtf. I mean if it works for somebody it works! But the issue will lie in the maintenance
It will work, absolutely....but so does eating 2 Snickers and calling it a day. Neither is not sustainable or healthy and you'll probably feel terrible in the process.
It’s dangerous. And they will gain it back easy.
@@MHSMagicLuver I eat 500 cals a day and i don't gain it back easily. You gain 3-5 pounds of water weight from introducing carbs again, then it stays stable as long as you stay at maintenence calories (around 2000 for me)
Crash diets are great for a quick fix, but they don't teach you how to eat properly. That's why so many people lose and gain quickly. Diet is a nasty word, we should all strive to find a healthy food plan, and exercise plan that works best for each one of us. The very best to everyone reading this comment. You can do it! 💛
The irony is by 2023 body standards none of these people seem overweight.
the standards haven‘t changed only the acceptable maybee, adults doing crash diets would be bizarre today, how they don‘t see the health problems in their joints, intestines and hormones coming as result of regular starvation and excluding food groups
I'm from the netherlands, some of these people still look massive to me.
Really? I'm from England and they all look overweight apart from the daughter where I would consider chubby or bordering onto chubby
Currently in the grip of an ED and it’s actually helpful seeing how normal people react to diets that encourage ridiculous, extreme and restrictive rules and behaviours.
There really is a massive difference between normal and ED thinking…
A diet of only 530 calories a day is a starvation diet. As soon as a person starts eating normally again the weight will come back greater than before.
Not always
Only if 'normal' is calorie surplus.
Eat little less, not after 6pm, move a lot, quit alcohol (it is pure sugar/calories). Worked for me.
16:22 you can’t weigh your self for one day and say “I’ve lost 3lbs!”
My weight can shift 5lbs in day with water weight, food, going to the bathroom. This is so sad. What have we become in the name of thinness? 😞
5lbs in one day is not normal.
@@DX-d Yes, I agree, that's not water weight.
@@DX-dit is normal tho lol sometimes I be 5kg more the next day and that’s def more then 5lbs. Most of the time it’s 2-3kg tho but sometimes even 7kg when I drink a lot of water
@DX-d it is completely normal. Food weighs in your stomach, along with water and your body retaining water. I weigh 5lbs more at night than in the morning.
+ woman have periods. Before my period I weight up to 4 lbs more ontop of that
@@lbar9720it is. You should be drinking about 6 pounds (100+ oz) of water per say
When I was in high school some guy at my work that was few years older than me told me I would look better if I lost a few pounds. I was at a normal weight at the time. It really hurt my feeling and I thought that if I did lose a few pounds him/everyone would like me more. After I started losing weight everyone was complimenting on how good I looked so I continued to lose more and more. I dropped over 20lbs. I’ve struggled with body issues ever since. I am in my 30s now but I still struggle.
I’m sorry this happened to you ❤
Men are *never* our friends… if a man suggests something to you that’s a personal attribute situation (like weight loss, hair, makeup, nails, fashion) DISMISS THEM.
They create mental health problems in girls and women like they get paid bonuses for it. Don’t listen to these hateful men
What body issues have you struggled with? Toosexyexia?
I’m trained dietitian and to be honest I’m quite frustrated and even angry 😡. Human metabolism is really complex and many people are making millions of spreading misinformation or half truths about the subject. Naturally weight loss diets are the most popular and always will be. I would be really happy if the government would put some regulations and restrictions how these diets and books are advertised and published, then I wouldn’t see so many disasters and complete distractions in human life.
Ahhh! Jane Horrocks aka Bubble from Ab Fab. i would know that voice anywhere (narrator)
She looked so familiar!!!
She narrated the video.@@justine8387
i knew ittttt!! 🩷🩷🩷🩷
lol it’s always amusing when the diet *experts* are a little bit chunky themselves. ❤❤🎉🎉😂😂
Actually it’s irritating and I don’t take them seriously. She’s obese and giving diet advice with conviction!!!
Go back in a months time. See how many of them have piled the weight back on and a lot more too. That’s the vicious circle
If you only eat a certain way to lose weight and then go back to how you were eating before, it won't stay off, obviously. You also have to address emotional issues and trauma or you'll just keep getting reeled back into dysfunctional eating. Otherwise, I don't see a problem with eating a certain way for a short period of time to lose weight. But you really have to be mindful when you eat and also make sure to honor your hunger. Being ravenous is only going to cause you to sabotage yourself.
That is why Keto/Carnivore diet works best for me.
14:34 it always irritates and shocks me to see overweight professionals giving diet and nutrition advice with confidence! Are we supposed to act blind ?!
Everyone is freaking out over 530 calories but fasting is super common now. For the record, that would be zero calories.
You're not supposed to not consume any calories at all. The fasting that's recommended is intermittent fasting, which just means you don't eat after a certain time (usually 5pm), and then start again the next day at, like, 7am. Even a hardcore fast is not 0 calories, but you're right that it's very low-calorie and not good for you.
Size 20 to size 14 is insane and setting yourself up to fail.
I have actually never been on a " diet". I have pretty much always stuck to the "eat when you're hungry" rule, and eat what I want. I may have spaghetti for breakfast or toast for dinner. I've never had a weight problem, and I am satisfied after eating what I fancy.
Make sense
It's amazing how different all our bodies are. My boyfriend struggles to gain weight. One of his life's dreams was to join the army but no matter what he eats he is still under weight. He's tried supplements and diets from doctors, diets from the internet, eating 6 peanut butter sandwiches day along with regular meals and nothing worked. For me on the other hand, especially since being on my meds, if I try intuitive eating I eat too much and gain weight. I also crave sweets and junk food. The only thing I've found that works for me is a keto diet because it cuts out sugar and carbs which for me reduces cravings. I don't really consider it a crash diet though because it's long term. I make sure I eat mostly veg and some clean protein and some healthy fats.
I really think that all our bodies are different though and what works for some people might not work for others. If I do intuitive eating then I hover between 80 and 85 kgs which for my height is over weight. I'm on a bit of a health binge at the moment and hoping to get down to 60. At the moment I'm at 74.
I'm incorporating intermittent fasting and a bit more light exercise like walking.
I don't subscribe to the the average diet because my specialists have been wrong so often. Food is food. We, as agricultural humans , made scheduled eating from farmer's schedules.
I have no problem eating eggs with dinner , nor fruits for breakfast. I work overnights, so seven thirty in the morning is my dinnertime. Food is food, and works how you work it.
I am practicing this too.
I'm the same eat whatever i fancy, don't care for time of day.
its better to have 1500kcal diet a day for a month streak than to have 800kcal for 3 days only... thats absurd
My first diet was at the age of 8, 1500 calories a day as made to follow by a doctor. This started my up and down cycle of different diets over the past 48 years. This is my last chance, I have submitted my application for bariatric surgery where 80% of your stomach is removed.
You were put on a diet at the age of 8?!!! So you learn that food is your enemy. No wonder you went on a yo-yo cycle. I'm truly sorry.
I’m on 1500 calories a day and tbh, it’s rather easy as long as you make sure your meals are below 500 calories and you add tons of veg to make sure you feel full and satisfied. But also… no 8 year old should be on a diet. I was put on multiple diets growing up and none of them would stick because I wasn’t in the right frame of mind to do it. It’s only now at the age of 26, I’m finally capable of following through and sticking to it. All the foods and sugary drinks I’ve cut out aren’t even missed anymore. Lost over a stone in weight in less than two months and by the looks of it, it isn’t stopping anytime soon.
I wish you luck with your weight loss journey. Just remember, the person who enjoys the destination isn’t going to go as far as the person who enjoys the journey.
im on a diet excluding gluten, lactose due to intolerance and any chemical additives due to allergies. still! i can watch my weight go up but what made me happy always and what i got back to last year is intermittent fasting. even up to 3 days. it works wonders.! there’s a lot of studies available now about how to approach it, please remember about minerals during the day if you try that
Have you tried carnivore/animal based? You should look into RUclips channels where extremely overweight people have lost weight on these diets. It’s satiating and you don’t think about calories at all.
Why are you measuring what you eat per day in calories, your body isn't a furnace.
Taking 50 laxatives a day is way different than dieting - wow
Why would you pay every week ?
You can count calories by yourself … i don’t get it
coffee stops hunger, it doesn't make me hungry
I was on a juicing diet and was rapidly losing weight. Then I came down with Crohns Disease. One of the most terrifying experiences of my life. I don’t know, nor do the doctors, whether correlation = causation, in my case. I stopped the juicing immediately and began eating my regular food to control the Crohns Disease symptoms, while waiting for my medication. That was 12 years ago. I still don’t know if the juicing components in themselves caused it, i e too much acid; chemicals in the soil; or I was set up for it for other reasons. Now I just take my Rx meds 3x daily and try not to speculate too much, just feel grateful that the medication works.
I use to drink coffee a about 9 cups working 17hrs nights shifts in a nursing home. Now i only drink 2 cups and 1 decaff. People can change, but boy that guys alcohol consumption is beyond addiction, he should replace some with water, juice, diet soda, decaffs etc. Did that grandma say she use to take 50 laxatives a day? 4 is max isnt. That lady doing a keto pee test, was it necessary to show the whole toilet scene? Wheres the privacy gone.
16:01 It Is.
Cold Pressed Juices Are Perfectly Fine.
I Even Use Mine As A Smoothie Base With Frozen Berries, Cherries And Mango.
00s television was WILD.
Someone should introduce them to fasting. Even less calories but with health benefits , mood improvements, and less hunger!
Fasting is just creating a calorie deficit. The times of day you eat make no difference. When you're asleep you're fasting anyway.
@@sharonchorley1311 sorry, I was referring to extended fasting, ranging from 36-72 hours. Calorie deficit alone makes me cold and exhausted, but extended fasting, after working up to it, makes me energetic and happy.
The steak slathered with yogurt looked no bueno.
It just looked relatively good compared to the meal that lady drank from a cup
Much more delicious if the beef is raw, served with salt, lemon, and sour cream
But why would her friend buy a size 14 dress when she's actually size 20? That's crazy
I’m wondering if that was the biggest size offered in that style of dress
Repost but I'm here for it
Anyone here looking for weight loss do it safely
This is what I did and lost almost 5 stone in a year and I made a lot of mistakes
Eat normally for a week and track the calories
Take off 250 - 500 calories a day off the total so if your eating 3000 a day eat 2500
A deficit of 500 calories a day can lead to 3500 calories a week or 1LB of weight loss
Do this with some resistance training to maintain muscle mass and you’ll achieve your goal slowly but safely
Also coach greg is an amazing weight loss RUclipsr I definitely recommend
Could do without the constipation photos.
I’m literally just watching this and have already said “No that’s a bad idea” multiple times and I’m only 4 minutes in
This is HORRIFIC MISINFORMATION. Ketosis is not "starvation mode" and protein does not cause gout. Wow. Just wow, that's terrible.
This documentary really failed to prove the point it should have made. They should have followed the dieters after their crash diets to show how people regain the weight from being overly restrictive and the science behind that. The message could be to make small and gradual lifestyle changes, but instead they just glamorized these starvation diets. What a bummer.
Fine line between intermittent fasting and crash dieting.
People should not put all their self worth on what they weigh because that is a bad idea because when you look good you are happy and then when you feel you don't then you most likely end up having mood swings and most likely it will lead to poor mental health
People make losing weight so complicated nowadays. All you have to do is eat in a calorie deficit and exercise and don’t restrict ur calories to stuff like 500 or 1000 because then you’ll just binge eat the weight back.
Why not simply reduce your caloric intake by sheer 500kcal per day, start walking, hiking, swimming, light cycling, even 15-30 minutes of light excercise every day will result in a weight loss in a month. Why do people always go to extremes, do dangerous unsustainable diets that are impossible to sustain over longer periods instead of little by little eliminating bad habits like sodas, candies, fried foods... combine it with light excercise and higher intake of vegetables... You'll develop healthy eating habits over time, stop your craving, get in the better shape and be actually healthy and fit 🤷 it's extremely easy to lose weight and keep it off, people are just lazy, stupid and want express results just focused on the appearance instead of their health and well being....
They don't, most ppl try doing that, and it doesn't work. If you will just cut calories you will be hungry, add exercise to that, you will be even more hungry. Your body will reduce your BMR so you will likely have to reduce calories even more, also body will release hormones that will make you want to move less. It can work for few kg for somebody that is healthy but doesn't work for most ppl. Think about it, why would you need to restrict calories? What controls how many calories you are eating? Your hormones do, if you will arbitrary limit calories you work against your body, and that isn't easy or smart or sustainable in the long term.
Because people are stupid especially fatties and would just consume 500 calories of carbs and sugar.
Then two hours later wonder why they are still hungry. ❤❤🎉🎉😂😂
@KraszuPolis your Diet influences your hormones though.
(80/20) healthy meals 80% exercise 20% Monday to Saturday, Sunday I gave myself a day off to enjoy what ever l wanted to eat and then back on with the plan. But boy l looked forward to my Sundays.
@@KraszuPolis you're right that people feel hungry when running a calorie deficit, but that is the only way to lose weight. The problem people have is that they cannot handle hunger as as they are simply not used to it!
All you really need to do is eat the right amount of calories for your height and desired body composition, and you will lose weight until you reach the correct composition.
34:03 Nope! That's B.S. Because It Will Make You Want The Junk Food More Not Less. 🙅🏼♀️
These diets are ridiculous…
I love these shows great work 😀👍🙏 go girls with your diet 👍🙏
Plain and simple dont diet just eat healthy
This is how you healthily lose weight. Caloric deficit and weight lifting.
You can either measure how many calories you regularly eat in a week and drop 500 calories from that or do a macro calculator which is more of an estimate. Stick to those calories for at least 2 weeks and see how you do. A healthy goal is 1-2lbs a week. Start with minimal cardio but heavy weight lifting if possible (this is also good for your bones). After at least a couple weeks if you hadn’t lost weight, drop ahout 100-200 calories. Once you are losing weight keep those same calories and cardio until you stop losing weight for at least 2 weeks. If you stop losing, drop calories by 100 and/or increase cardio by 5-10 minutes. Continue. Do a max of 4-6 months in a deficit, and then do a reverse diet for at least 6 months. After that you can go back into another deficit
God damn everyone in this documentary was delightful...
Starving yourself is starving yourself whether you call it a crash diet or fasting
It’s refreshing to hear that first woman take full responsibility it’s a rare thing in overweight people I find. Most of them make 10000 excuses.
There is 52 weeks in a year so if you spend £100 a week on a diet in a year that is just under just £52000 that is a lot of money
Here is an idea.....I was 400 lbs im now 200lbs! How? slow changes at first! but mainly eating 2200 Cals a day as I got closer to 200lbs i went down to 2000 cals a day! I still eat everything just less at a time lol.
These diet documentaries are my addiction.
I'd like to see their weights 4 days after these crash diets.
Perfect TIMINGGGGGG
If george just cuts out the booze he'll lose weight that week anyway without going on a crash diet so the results are inaccurate. As week one is usually water weight anyway. Weight loss slows after the initial water whoosh.
I want to lose weight but I'd never try any of these diets cause they look sad.
So this series is from 2011. I magine in 2035 people watching dieters from 2023 eating keto and carnivor and fasting 16 hours, how rediculous it will seem
500 cal per DAY?? excuse me?
Those friends are hilarious I want a show of them
Buying a dress that is too small for your friend is just nasty.
This whole thing feels like it comes straight out of the 2000s 😂
I think it came out on TV at least 10 years ago. Maybe 15.
If these people would just calculate the maintenance calories of their ideal weight and stick to those, they'd be fine.
Wiring your mouth shut?!😅 I was expecting she would say she was on a liquid diet NOT help her take smaller bites of food!
I came to this after listening to RoyTaylor's diabetes diet. Basically, he says prediabetes or diabetes can be put into remission by quickly dropping 15-20kg. He advocates 600 calories of shakes and soups plus a small 100 calorie meal (a salad etc to break the monotomy of a liquid diet)...so 700 cals/day and no exercise for a max of 12 weeks or until blood sugar is normal. He doesn't seem to recognize that it's a crash diet (he's an endocrinologist) and therefore does not address these kinds of issues raised here. Watching this to see if it can be done safely and maintained.
I did it as I had diabetes but using Michael Mosleys 800 calories a day plan of real food. I didn't feel all that hungry, I did it for 10 weeks, the weight came off and the diabetes went into remission. Since then I've stuck to avoiding simple carbs and the weight is staying off.
@dianacoles1017 you didn't feel hungry?
@@morematcha No surprisingly. When I've tried to do the 5/2 diet I gave up because I was so hungry but doing it every day I didn't. I did drink a lot - miso soup,
Herbal teas, coffee with a dash of milk, water with slices of cucumber, cider vinegar in warm water.
It certainly works for WLS patients.
Good grief, the damage these people are doing from these crash diets
It’s not the diet working. You’re eating in a calorie deficit. THAT is why you’re losing weight. Anyone can lose weight on a starvation diet if 500 cals week. But what happens when you come off it? Hmmmm…. Why not eat proper food and stop snacking every 10 min. Exercise. Even walking will work. Make a lifestyle change for sustainable weightloss.
Wireing your jaw shut should dangerous as it would possibly be dangerous
10:27 As Do I.
Aloe Vera Sounds Enticing. 🌿
Marela is lovely ❤
Crash diets are stupid . The simplest changes help lose weight . Eat as many vegetables as you like , a small portion of carbs , a portion of proteins , a fruit and drink water or tea ( or coffee ) . Don't ever go for seconds and fill a normal size plate . Don't over fill the plate , don't pile food up . Don't eat from a bowl you would increase portions . Walk 30 min a day at least and you are good . I'm 76 and lost 17 pounds since mid march ( I put on 20 pounds when I stopped smoking 3.5 years ago ) .
I’ll eat 10kg veggies and gain weight then
When was this filmed?
I'm going to guess around 2002-2006
Laxatives to expel everything you ate? That's not a crash diet that's literally bulimia??
66 quid a week to starve, no thanks!
OMG
"I am constipated because of all the meat (that has no fibre at all) I think I am going to switch to fish (that has no fibre at all)
😄😊😊😊
Meat doesn't constipate. Fibre is unnecessary 😂
Exercise is very important in weight loss. This show gives me motivation! 😃
Porridge in water that's not porridge that's gruel it sounds horrible and would possibly make you sick 🤢
I love lorrella shes awsume ❤
Did she say to avoid creating Ketones? 💀
Wait why does that not make sense? I don't know anything lol
This show promotes so much miss information, it is so entertaining. Promoting any diet under 1300 is crazy ballz and is totally unsustainable
13 stone to roughly 15 stone is a healthy weight for a 6ft 2 adult male
Steak and yogurt????????????????? 🫨 no.
Why can’t George have decaf coffee???
Dietician is giving a lot of bad advice......making anyone drink a lot of water without electrolytes is horrible......might rise to serious issues even in the short term.
39:30 Bon appetit!
I prefer the only healthy foods diet