This one struck a personal chord with me. I just lost my grandfather to COVID recently. I never got to say goodbye to him after they put him in a medically induced coma. To say me and my grandfather were close would be an understatement, he was like a second father to me. And to see him go in such a way tore me apart. But I did eventually realize that he wouldn't want me to grieve forever, and I am still trying, but it is indeed very hard.
I always loved vinal scratch... Though I heard a theory that vinal and Octavia were siblings not dating... Meh I guess it's up for personal interpretation considering that most likely Hasbro will never confirm it one way or another on the show...
I loved listening to this fanfic, I didn't cry through it, I did feel a bit sad though, and when I read the comments, that's when I started crying. I think that this was amazing, there's not much more to say, other than, I LOVED it 😁.
I honestly cried when I saw the end, the picture of Suki, as it reminded me of how I just lost my dog a few weeks back. Her name was Ginger, and we've had her for 15 years, I was only 4 years old when we first got her as a puppy, and from then on she was like a little sister to me. A few months back, she began to have problems with her back legs, they lost pretty much all muscle mass, and eventually she declined to not really being able to stand up by herself anymore. She would cry if she was on her own and couldn't get up, so we would have to help her up. It broke my heart to see such a once happy, and lively dog, laying on the floor all day, with that sad look on her face. We put her down on April 8th of 2017, and throughout the entire time at the vet, her family was there with her, including one of my closest friends, who had known her for 7 years, our house being like her second home. My mom and I held her paws as she was injected. I expected for her to greet us when we got home from the vet, and continued to expect that everytime I got back home, from being outside of the house. I would also expect to see her in her usual spots as well. Not only that, but i've been the only one in my family to have frequent dreams with her in them, as they just don't seem to be going away, so the memory and feelings are fresh in my mind still. I feel that this may be because i keep her collar hanging above my bed in my room. I miss her so much, and I hope that wherever she is, she's happy.
Wait, so there's a few questions I have within the first two minutes. 1. If the Elements of Harmony can ONLY be used when they're all together, then how did they work against Rarity? I'm assuming that the thing that possessed Rarity is the Nightmare, the same thing that possessed Luna and turned her into Nightmare Moon (though the comic continuity is a bot wonky). 2. Even if the Elements did work against Rarity, why did they...kill her? I'm gonna quote Antony C here for a moment. "So, one minute, these magical rocks are turning people to stone, and the next they're kicking ponies off the planet, but oh, lickity split, BRAINWASHING, loud as you please, followed by more vitrification and-does this sound any bit harmonious to you?" We know that the Elements can do some pretty nasty things to those who are evil: Banishment, petrification, etc. But never kill. I think the only time we've seen an antagonist get killed was Sombra, but he was exploded by the blast of the Crystal Heart, not by the Elements. AND THESE ARE QUESTIONS I ASKED IN THE FIRST TWO MINUTES!
The heart wrenching story telling by you and the superb efforts by all the players left me a sobbing mess. >_< Darn it Scribbler, I know better but I have an unquenchable need to listen to you tell these stories.
I swear the Month of Lurve brings with it some of the corniest dialogue I ever hear and I love it. By no means do I mean to belittle the subject matter, losing a loved one is a terrible thing. I recently bore witness to its effects on the faces of my own family when a close family friend passed away. I was not afflicted by his passing as I barely knew him, simply because I'm a wall flower and generally don't engage other people in social environments. Also on another note, unlike a clothing store for a species that primarily walk around naked a music store actually sounds like it could turn a profit!
I really enjoy this story Scribbs. It was sad. But uplifting. My older sister passed away last year in Sept. I miss her dearly. But I know she wants me to move on. She'll be always be my heart. Thank you for this story Scribbs.
Good job with the reading. You actually made me cry. Not many people reading stories like this can do that to me. As much as I would like to check out more, I think I should stay away from the sad stuff for now.
Good job on the fanfic reading Scribbler you made my heart to shatter to pieces and make me cry like i only did during the firefly one Maternal i think it was
I have never heard a sader tale in my life,i love that it made me cry so much! And also suki isnt realy gone,accuatly i think if you believe hard enough you will understand that she and you will meet agein.#Remember Suki
*Sniff* >< the ending song got me *sniff* i know how u feel fluttershy.... T.T waaa i miss my friend beth! i miss purelife, and i miss my dog meshia the doberman *sniff* there any ponies i could hug on here?
Wait.....ApplePie & RariShy?! that's... Interesting. Personally I'm not for the rings on a necklace. It just doesn't feel like something that they'd do. The earrings in eachothers cutie marks would be more personal. Again, another case of two of my favorite fics not being at all related but plausible; A Silent House (Octavia & Vynal) with this as the second piece. I get the feeling that in a way? What little of rarity's soul gave Octavia her blessing to become the new element of generosity and to live in her home. OctiVynil 4life! Though of the mane6? AppleShy, TwiShy, AppleSparkle, & RarTwi.
This made me so depressed, like this whole day today I felt so sad just thinking "She was going to ask her to marry her but couldn't".Also the idea of the cutie mark earrings was great but made it worse for how she couldn't give them to her herself. Overall this fucked me up pretty bad.
Rarishy is literally the most sensible ship out of all the Fluttershy ships. Rarity and Fluttershy are seen together more than Fluttershy and anyone else. RD is too brash to be Flutters’ partner. Rarity and Flutters complement each other well, in elegant confidence and feminine gentleness respectively. They’d be quite a soft couple.
![Pony Tales [MLP Fanfic Reading] Love Will Tear Us Apart (sadfic/romance - Cadence/Shining)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OIG4Ua_gE2Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![Pony Tales [MLP Fanfic Reading] Love Will Tear Us Apart (sadfic/romance - Cadence/Shining)](/img/tr.png)
![Pony Tales [MLP Fanfic Reading] 'A Darling Little Secret' by Gusto Starstorm (SLICE-OF-LIFE / CUTE)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I5xkhFoqIxw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Pony Tales [MLP Fanfic Readings] The Visiting Hour (grimdark)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qTt85JEIEHg/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Double [MLP Grimdark Reading]](/img/1.gif)
Thank you Octavia. Thank you so much for that words. Poor Vinyl and Rarity. Great but sad video Scribbler.
Do u still loce octavia
i don't even ship this and there are still tears in my eyes...
Same
I’m not a brony anymore but damn I love this
I'm not crying! I just have something in my eyes!
Random pony: what's in your eyes?
TEARS!!
😂
Same here and I don't even like rarity
@@Cayden356that's not funny!
This one struck a personal chord with me. I just lost my grandfather to COVID recently. I never got to say goodbye to him after they put him in a medically induced coma. To say me and my grandfather were close would be an understatement, he was like a second father to me. And to see him go in such a way tore me apart. But I did eventually realize that he wouldn't want me to grieve forever, and I am still trying, but it is indeed very hard.
Wow! Octavia is giving good advice to Fluttershy and helping her move on.
I'm not crying, I'm not crying.............. DAMN IT SCRIBBLER!!!
The Wasteland Brony you should know better to come here and not expect to cry 😭
Loyalty I know I should but I can't help it! 😭
*grab your wings and blow my nose on it*
T.T the ending song got me.... WAaaaaa
Queen MeowTigeress DO YOU MIND?!
*flaps my wings to rid of mucus*
T.T sorry *sniff*
Ugghhh, note to self, headphones next time. I don't need my neighbors calling the police cause of that shriek in the beginning.
TheMasterLHeart really????
Wow
Daaammnnn, your neighbors need a chill pill
Lmao
that just wow
no...I'm not crying!..*WHO KEEPS PUTTING BOWLING OF ONIONS HERE?!*
Flamethrower 928 Sorry, those are mine *eats onions*
Alex Olmsted can I have some?
Flamethrower 928 you can have one of mine, I'm crying too Much I have loads *eats onion as tear rolls down my face*
EmoKidRants95 Gimme dem onions ;-;
These aren't tears of sadness I've just been cutting onions I'm making a lasagna....... for one 😢
DAMN IT Scribbler, You made me cry again :(
Eeeek! That little Pinkiejack cameo was the cutest thing ever >
Well... that was a real struggle for me to hold back tears.
is it bad that im more upset that Vinyl is dead than i am about Rarity?
Tryce Fire pegisus no
Tryce Fire pegisus no, I'm the same
nope
Tryce Fire pegasus nop
I always loved vinal scratch...
Though I heard a theory that vinal and Octavia were siblings not dating... Meh I guess it's up for personal interpretation considering that most likely Hasbro will never confirm it one way or another on the show...
Probably one of the most powerful fics I've ever listened/read. This is really well made, and it even made me emotional.
I loved listening to this fanfic, I didn't cry through it, I did feel a bit sad though, and when I read the comments, that's when I started crying. I think that this was amazing, there's not much more to say, other than, I LOVED it 😁.
I honestly cried when I saw the end, the picture of Suki, as it reminded me of how I just lost my dog a few weeks back. Her name was Ginger, and we've had her for 15 years, I was only 4 years old when we first got her as a puppy, and from then on she was like a little sister to me. A few months back, she began to have problems with her back legs, they lost pretty much all muscle mass, and eventually she declined to not really being able to stand up by herself anymore. She would cry if she was on her own and couldn't get up, so we would have to help her up. It broke my heart to see such a once happy, and lively dog, laying on the floor all day, with that sad look on her face. We put her down on April 8th of 2017, and throughout the entire time at the vet, her family was there with her, including one of my closest friends, who had known her for 7 years, our house being like her second home. My mom and I held her paws as she was injected. I expected for her to greet us when we got home from the vet, and continued to expect that everytime I got back home, from being outside of the house. I would also expect to see her in her usual spots as well. Not only that, but i've been the only one in my family to have frequent dreams with her in them, as they just don't seem to be going away, so the memory and feelings are fresh in my mind still. I feel that this may be because i keep her collar hanging above my bed in my room. I miss her so much, and I hope that wherever she is, she's happy.
That one got me at the end, and I loved that song, Good job.
this is bad
this almost made me cry. like when i was at the end of this video i felt tears tugging in my throat. So good!
Wait, so there's a few questions I have within the first two minutes.
1. If the Elements of Harmony can ONLY be used when they're all together, then how did they work against Rarity? I'm assuming that the thing that possessed Rarity is the Nightmare, the same thing that possessed Luna and turned her into Nightmare Moon (though the comic continuity is a bot wonky).
2. Even if the Elements did work against Rarity, why did they...kill her? I'm gonna quote Antony C here for a moment.
"So, one minute, these magical rocks are turning people to stone, and the next they're kicking ponies off the planet, but oh, lickity split, BRAINWASHING, loud as you please, followed by more vitrification and-does this sound any bit harmonious to you?"
We know that the Elements can do some pretty nasty things to those who are evil: Banishment, petrification, etc. But never kill. I think the only time we've seen an antagonist get killed was Sombra, but he was exploded by the blast of the Crystal Heart, not by the Elements.
AND THESE ARE QUESTIONS I ASKED IN THE FIRST TWO MINUTES!
Oh goooodh...tears go back ehere u came from....damn Scribbler this is beatiful reading
I love this fanfiction story. It's beautiful and sad.
"Remember me as I had been, and not how I had become..."
Amazing story with a great message I needed to hear. Nice work.
The heart wrenching story telling by you and the superb efforts by all the players left me a sobbing mess. >_< Darn it Scribbler, I know better but I have an unquenchable need to listen to you tell these stories.
I swear the Month of Lurve brings with it some of the corniest dialogue I ever hear and I love it. By no means do I mean to belittle the subject matter, losing a loved one is a terrible thing. I recently bore witness to its effects on the faces of my own family when a close family friend passed away. I was not afflicted by his passing as I barely knew him, simply because I'm a wall flower and generally don't engage other people in social environments.
Also on another note, unlike a clothing store for a species that primarily walk around naked a music store actually sounds like it could turn a profit!
It's been awhile since I honestly cried about something.
Everyone's just like, "I'M NOT GONNA CRYYYY"
But I'm like, "Nice song at the end."
I really enjoy this story Scribbs. It was sad. But uplifting. My older sister passed away last year in Sept. I miss her dearly. But I know she wants me to move on. She'll be always be my heart. Thank you for this story Scribbs.
This was a sad but beautiful story. Keep up the good work Scribbler.
Good job with the reading. You actually made me cry. Not many people reading stories like this can do that to me. As much as I would like to check out more, I think I should stay away from the sad stuff for now.
I’m not crying I’m-
OK IM CRYING THERES NO POINT IN LYING ITS SO SADDDDD.
I'm not crying,someone's cutting onions,STOP CUTTING ONIONS SCRIBBLER! WAHHH!
Is it weird to say that scribblers voice is soothing
SO AWESOME!!!!!!
You really know how to bring on the feels
when i cry... that's when u know that was a flawless performance! 😢
Wait... So Applejack and Pinkie are engaged even though they are cousins? Or did this come out before that episode?
Filming Cashmere before that episode, but after the Nightmare Rarity thing
+Filming Cashmere some cousins sometimes marry
Filming Cashmere I think it did come out before that episode… and then they found out they were cousins 😂🤣
Even then, the connection is likely so far apart that it wouldn't even really matter.
Ehem* "Sweet home Alabama!!!"
Oh Scribby that was deep..oh my goodness I feel you Fluttershy in someway.. dang..
Beautifully done as always.
Nightmare Rarity >< Damn it.
NIGHTMARE MOOOOOOOOOOOOO
How did this even happen
Okay i admit i teared up at the end :'(
1. super cool to see some rare mane 6 ships!
2 .AAAAAAAAAAGGHHHH BOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Good job on the fanfic reading Scribbler you made my heart to shatter to pieces and make me cry like i only did during the firefly one Maternal i think it was
God dang scribbler you and your music
Thumbnail made me think it was an Octaviashy fic XD
This was a great fic with a great dramatic reading. Well done.
That's what I was thinking aswell
if you put on subtitles when she says ,,pony tales read by scribbler,, it will write ,, tony can read ice cream,,. Maby it works only for me?
Dragon fly I got "ponytails red-eye scribbler."
@@jennibeanthesweetsqueen5245 me 2
The Pinkiejack bit is cute!!
I have never heard a sader tale in my life,i love that it made me cry so much! And also suki isnt realy gone,accuatly i think if you believe hard enough you will understand that she and you will meet agein.#Remember Suki
*Sniff* >< the ending song got me *sniff* i know how u feel fluttershy....
T.T waaa i miss my friend beth! i miss purelife, and i miss my dog meshia the doberman *sniff* there any ponies i could hug on here?
Queen MeowTigeress I'm here for you. You may not know me personally, but that doesn't matter.
q.q *hugs back*
T.T *hugs ya tightly*
Queen MeowTigeress you can hug me
Aww here you go **Hugs**
Dang it Scribbler you got me crying 😭 and I hardly ever cry.
Thank you. I too, lost my partner. I didn’t get to say goodbye. But, I did love him, even though things were not good at all between us. 🌸🦄💧
JezzaRat has done a good job as Octavia. But I was kinda hoping that Scribbler voiced her.
But regardless this is still a good reading tho. Good job 😉
Oooh... Imagine if this was connected to the fic "Safe"
-crys- THIS WAS AMAZING!!!! PLEASE DO MORE LIKE THIS!!!!
that end... and that song... THAT'S ILLEGAL
So very sad Amazing job on this 🥺🤧🤧🤧
I don’t ship rarity and fluttershy but I can’t stop crying
Damn Scribbler your fanfics are just... touching TwT
Lol a pidgin just strolled in calmly to my hotel room like he owned it. 😂😂😂😂😂
omg this is so touching...GOOD JOB! I LOVED IT!
Wait.....ApplePie & RariShy?! that's... Interesting. Personally I'm not for the rings on a necklace. It just doesn't feel like something that they'd do. The earrings in eachothers cutie marks would be more personal. Again, another case of two of my favorite fics not being at all related but plausible; A Silent House (Octavia & Vynal) with this as the second piece. I get the feeling that in a way? What little of rarity's soul gave Octavia her blessing to become the new element of generosity and to live in her home.
OctiVynil 4life! Though of the mane6? AppleShy, TwiShy, AppleSparkle, & RarTwi.
well this was beautiful.
lovely job everyone
Was this written before it was revealed that Pinkie and Applejack were related?
Yes
At first me: I'm not gonna cry
After me: *sobbing*
I ain't crying it's.... It's FOR GODSAKE THIS JUST TO MUCH!!!
THE FEEEEEEELLLS why why you gotta do this?
😢😢 this one hits me evertime thank you Scribbler ❤️🇬🇧💙.
Kind Regards AuraKnight
😭😿 Rarity! 😭 I can't s-stop crying! Por Suki rip you both 😭
finally a rarity and fluttershy ship.cause i ship em ^^
*when your a big fluttercord shipper*
CELESTIA DAMN IT I CRIED!!!!!! YOU'RE TOO GOOD SCRIBBLER!!!!
Sally Hirst i didn't cry :/
I love this fanfic i also really want to know if i can get the song at the end... Its so beautiful to me.
The song is called “Words Fall Apart”
Why am I here after watching Ep 6 of Friendship is Tragic?!?!?! Oh my heart!!!
So sad 😭
I'm crying and I'm ok with this
I can't cry now... My mum is say next to me ;-;
Best pony died...
*many tears*
Also, Vinyl...
Derpy Hooves Aren't they the same pony?
good job scribbler
I promise I tried not to cry, I really tried but was too hard and Rarity was my favorite character😢😭
even though I don't ship RariShy... this is one of my favourite readings!
or Flutterity wether people call it that
Don’t mind me I’m just sobbing in the corner
Flutetershy! Too much not enough to much not enough perfect...!😙a!a!a! chew. Oh even her sneeze is adorable.
Finally, a rarishy fan fiction!
Aren't Apple Jack and Pinkie cousins?
Omg it made me cry i wish there was a part 2
I not going to be crying, I'm not going to be crying.... WHY AM I EVEN TRYING! *sobs*
how tf did you do the shriek at 6.48
oh jesus I can tell this was written before pinkie pie and applejack are confirmed to be cousins
sweet home alabama
great job everyone!
I just realized pinkiejack is canon in this story
This made me so depressed, like this whole day today I felt so sad just thinking "She was going to ask her to marry her but couldn't".Also the idea of the cutie mark earrings was great but made it worse for how she couldn't give them to her herself. Overall this fucked me up pretty bad.
OH MY GOD THE TEARS WON'T STOP!!!!!!
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
you uploaded this video after my birthday
Clarisse Santiago wait, your birthday is the 16th of Feb? (same Here )
Wubcake... interesting. I thought it was vana....
Mellon😏
That song at the end though.
this story is awsome and adorable but the ships are weird
dead runer agree very much agree if I shipped fluttershy with any of the mane 6 I would of chosen Rainbow Dash
Enchanted Tales same
Meh
Enchanted Tales Personally I would have RD and AJ.
Rarishy is literally the most sensible ship out of all the Fluttershy ships. Rarity and Fluttershy are seen together more than Fluttershy and anyone else. RD is too brash to be Flutters’ partner. Rarity and Flutters complement each other well, in elegant confidence and feminine gentleness respectively. They’d be quite a soft couple.
way good,,, /)
im not crying.... nope nope not at all ( hides im my hair)
jennifer west * crys inside* i am not crying
I'm not crying, I'm sweating through my eyes!
Do u get these from watt pad and can u read vampire septiplier fabrics please ?
I'm horrible. Someone tells me that someone close died, I reply, "That's just how the world works."
Oh so this time Octavia gets to live but rarity doesn’t huh