composer for like half of everything here I appreciate the in depth analysis, and yeah I agree with like half of it. we started v2 wanting to improve but lost interest halfway through so it doesn't feel like we did the mod justice, because well, we didn't. we just kinda gave up tbh also Lunatic's voice is not a modified Fleetway, it's an entirely new chromatic (oh btw dark puddle's instrumental DOES include a piano)
Hi, lady y artist here Just going to say off the bat, there is a much, much better mod called monika.exe+ in the works and as a dev for both teams, it has so much more passion going into it. In the actual mod, there was absolutely no passion going into it, and was basically made for clout. After a while, Stamps and Fazer started falling out of the mod, and the passion behind everything was all lost. The only really good thing about it was some of the art, but a lot of it was made very quickly and hurriedly to get it out. despite this, there were periods where not a single message was sent in the dev server for weeks, and no work was done at all. It was only really kept alive because we had like 2 things to do, and didn't want all the work to go to waste. The message about the mod being "never meant to be taken seriously" was just to save face so that we could put out something that was pretty much just for clout. If we had put more effort into the mod, it probably could have been good, but eh. Also god stamps's remixes sucked lmao
I just found you because youtube recommended me this exact video and i have to say, your videos are pretty high quality! You definitely deserve more than just 50-something subscribers, i will be sure to watch any and all new videos coming from you moving forward.
Technically Vs Monika.EXE The Last Festival Would Actually Take The DDLC Aspects Now So We Can Hope For A Better In This One Final Update For Vs Monika.EXE
I discocered your channel, watched some of your videos and I have to say, you're a great at making analysis videos. As a request could you make an analysis video of the Trollge files?
you didn’t need to specifically call me out on Lunatic’s sprites, dude :( i know it was a joke & admittedly they could be better but it still feels rude for you to do so
I disagree with so, so... SO much of what you said about the mod 😅. Although, I can acknowledge some points. Like how the sprites for the Dokis mirrored the original Sonic.exe poses with almost no unique change to them. Although, FNF is full of mods that take songs and replaces the original singers with different characters from other existing mods. That's exactly what a BETADCIU is, if you've ever watched one. It's a single song that's sung by many different characters from all over the modding community. Sometimes people just want to see their favorite characters sing different songs and nothing more. Monika.exe could've easily just been DDTO sprites and vocals pasted onto the Sonic.exe mod with nothing else added and it would've been completely fine since most mods do this as a normal thing. But they decided to go the extra mile and add more to the mod with custom sprites, vocals, and etc. I'd say that Monika.exe less "copied" and more like "mimicked" the Sonic.exe mod. The poses and vocals were a bit uninspired, but they still put in the work to make new sprites and adjusted vocals when they could've easily ignored changing all of that. I always felt that the mod was just supposed to be DDLC characters singing Sonic songs. And not a Sonic.exe inspired mod that did it's own thing. I'd say that Mario's Madness is a perfect example of a mod that takes inspiration from Sonic.exe while being totally unique. It even has it's own "Too Slow" and "You Can't Run" and they feel so similar, yet so different from the original songs! Monika.exe is NOT Mario's Madness. And lastly, I can't believe how much you hate Lunatic Monika! She's my favorite character in the whole mod! 😩 I didn't like her much in V1. Now THAT was the epidemy of "uninspired". But I fell in love with her in V2. Her sprites, vocals, and expressions felt so cool to see. And I think her not feeling like Monika herself and not copying Fleetway is a GOOD thing. If you know Fleetway, then you'd know that he's an evil personality of Sonic that emerges whenever he goes Super. They are 2 different people. Lunatic being nothing like Monika is the point. She's NOT Monika. She's a more aggressive personality of her, just like Fleetway is to Sonic. And where as Fleetway is an angry and bloodthirsty version of Sonic, Lunatic's personality seems to take on a sort of "Harley Quinn" joyful psychopath type. Lunatic being so different from Monika let's her mirror Fleetway's character so well. While her carefree quirkiness couldn't be more polar opposite to Fleetway's ragefull and violent personality. Similar, but still unique. I believe that Lunatic is the best example of an inspired, yet not copied, character in this entire mod! And I'm so sad to hear that she's your least favorite.
If I wanna be honest, I don’t think Monika.EXE V2 isn’t that bad. But I have to say that it could have been better. The sprites for Lunatic are much more worse. I really don’t like them. Same goes for chromatic scales. I like Lunatic chromatic. But I really dislike Asmodeus chromatic. As for Lunatic, I would like to point out that she shouldn’t be like Monika. She isn’t just a Monika powered up. You really should check the wiki (of course if you didn’t check it) As for remixes, I really liked them. But my only complain would be that it could have had more ddlc references. For example, in Undeletable, instead of Green Hill zone use your Reality motif. But this is just my opinion. I understand the devs not wanting to continue this project, since it is a mod mostly inspiered by Sonic.EXE (and kinda copied) but ddlc and due to loosing motivation. But I still like it. It’s not bad, but it could have been a little better.
composer for like half of everything here
I appreciate the in depth analysis, and yeah I agree with like half of it. we started v2 wanting to improve but lost interest halfway through so it doesn't feel like we did the mod justice, because well, we didn't. we just kinda gave up tbh
also Lunatic's voice is not a modified Fleetway, it's an entirely new chromatic
(oh btw dark puddle's instrumental DOES include a piano)
Hi, lady y artist here
Just going to say off the bat, there is a much, much better mod called monika.exe+ in the works and as a dev for both teams, it has so much more passion going into it. In the actual mod, there was absolutely no passion going into it, and was basically made for clout. After a while, Stamps and Fazer started falling out of the mod, and the passion behind everything was all lost. The only really good thing about it was some of the art, but a lot of it was made very quickly and hurriedly to get it out. despite this, there were periods where not a single message was sent in the dev server for weeks, and no work was done at all. It was only really kept alive because we had like 2 things to do, and didn't want all the work to go to waste. The message about the mod being "never meant to be taken seriously" was just to save face so that we could put out something that was pretty much just for clout. If we had put more effort into the mod, it probably could have been good, but eh. Also god stamps's remixes sucked lmao
bruh
well geez thanks man
@@SuperStampsFOUND YA!
I just found you because youtube recommended me this exact video and i have to say, your videos are pretty high quality! You definitely deserve more than just 50-something subscribers, i will be sure to watch any and all new videos coming from you moving forward.
Technically Vs Monika.EXE The Last Festival Would Actually Take The DDLC Aspects Now So We Can Hope For A Better In This One Final Update For Vs Monika.EXE
This is a really great analysis video and u sound cool
13:50
Just wanted to point out that too smol is not a 3.0 remix, in fact it's a remix from [A2] called "internet speed".
You haven't heard fo the version 1
The one you've heard WAS version 2(really)
I discocered your channel, watched some of your videos and I have to say, you're a great at making analysis videos. As a request could you make an analysis video of the Trollge files?
I have been considering the Trollge Files for quite some time. I am sure that I will be discussing it at some point.
you didn’t need to specifically call me out on Lunatic’s sprites, dude :( i know it was a joke & admittedly they could be better but it still feels rude for you to do so
I thought you did pretty good on the lunatic Sprites!
Maybe do a video on DDTO bad ending or mistful Crimson Morning.
I disagree with so, so... SO much of what you said about the mod 😅. Although, I can acknowledge some points. Like how the sprites for the Dokis mirrored the original Sonic.exe poses with almost no unique change to them.
Although, FNF is full of mods that take songs and replaces the original singers with different characters from other existing mods. That's exactly what a BETADCIU is, if you've ever watched one. It's a single song that's sung by many different characters from all over the modding community. Sometimes people just want to see their favorite characters sing different songs and nothing more.
Monika.exe could've easily just been DDTO sprites and vocals pasted onto the Sonic.exe mod with nothing else added and it would've been completely fine since most mods do this as a normal thing. But they decided to go the extra mile and add more to the mod with custom sprites, vocals, and etc.
I'd say that Monika.exe less "copied" and more like "mimicked" the Sonic.exe mod. The poses and vocals were a bit uninspired, but they still put in the work to make new sprites and adjusted vocals when they could've easily ignored changing all of that.
I always felt that the mod was just supposed to be DDLC characters singing Sonic songs. And not a Sonic.exe inspired mod that did it's own thing.
I'd say that Mario's Madness is a perfect example of a mod that takes inspiration from Sonic.exe while being totally unique. It even has it's own "Too Slow" and "You Can't Run" and they feel so similar, yet so different from the original songs! Monika.exe is NOT Mario's Madness.
And lastly, I can't believe how much you hate Lunatic Monika! She's my favorite character in the whole mod! 😩
I didn't like her much in V1. Now THAT was the epidemy of "uninspired". But I fell in love with her in V2. Her sprites, vocals, and expressions felt so cool to see. And I think her not feeling like Monika herself and not copying Fleetway is a GOOD thing.
If you know Fleetway, then you'd know that he's an evil personality of Sonic that emerges whenever he goes Super. They are 2 different people. Lunatic being nothing like Monika is the point. She's NOT Monika. She's a more aggressive personality of her, just like Fleetway is to Sonic. And where as Fleetway is an angry and bloodthirsty version of Sonic, Lunatic's personality seems to take on a sort of "Harley Quinn" joyful psychopath type.
Lunatic being so different from Monika let's her mirror Fleetway's character so well. While her carefree quirkiness couldn't be more polar opposite to Fleetway's ragefull and violent personality. Similar, but still unique.
I believe that Lunatic is the best example of an inspired, yet not copied, character in this entire mod! And I'm so sad to hear that she's your least favorite.
Do you think you can find a link of arbitrary code execution instrumental? Because I have been trying to find this all over RUclips.
If I wanna be honest, I don’t think Monika.EXE V2 isn’t that bad.
But I have to say that it could have been better. The sprites for Lunatic are much more worse. I really don’t like them. Same goes for chromatic scales. I like Lunatic chromatic. But I really dislike Asmodeus chromatic.
As for Lunatic, I would like to point out that she shouldn’t be like Monika. She isn’t just a Monika powered up. You really should check the wiki (of course if you didn’t check it)
As for remixes, I really liked them. But my only complain would be that it could have had more ddlc references. For example, in Undeletable, instead of Green Hill zone use your Reality motif.
But this is just my opinion. I understand the devs not wanting to continue this project, since it is a mod mostly inspiered by Sonic.EXE (and kinda copied) but ddlc and due to loosing motivation. But I still like it. It’s not bad, but it could have been a little better.
did you read the wiki at all
its vary bad in my opinion because they just copied sonic exe mods and id prefer the monika bad ending mod
I like EXE
It’s a cover mod