I want nothing more than to hear Jon sing Inevitable now with the progress he's made in voice lessons since TGWDLM, he was great there but given how much he improved in NPMD I just know it would be phenomenal
i think you could probably tell him you want that since he was looking for what people want on his youtube channel. he has a lot of comments but it’s worth a shot
To be fair to AVPSY, they did pretty damn good considering how little time they had to learn it. I also probably would have ranked it pretty low, but you have to admit that it’s impressive all things considered.
The only Starkid ending I don't like is Trail to Oregon, and it's just because it feels awkward and rushed. But the music is still a banger, which gives it an excuse in my opinion
I can get that, but I feel like the transition from "You Gotta Go" to "Naked in a Lake" is a bit of a non-sequiter by design, and if you disregard the transition into it, "Naked in a Lake" is a fitting ending for the show that builds on the events of the rest of it. Still though, it's a fair take
I will be honest, as somebody who LOVES NPMD, it’s my favorite of the musicals, first I ever watched, love all the characters, and though the ending I think is great in a writing sense and I enjoyed it, and the song was GOOD, but if we’re rating on quality of the song musically and nothing else, I think this ranking is extremely solid
AVPSY was def the worst for the live performances but the recorded versions of Days of Summer that they've got on spotify go HARD edit: got too excited, no.6 for the other version of it is fair lmao
As the world’s biggest DDMD fan, I’m glad it got a middle spot on this list. What If Tomorrow Comes, Christmas Day, and Inevitable is such a good top three.
the duality of loving ddmd a lot but then seeing the rest of the ranking and knowing its right because INEVITABLE?? TOMORROW WILL COME?? MAKE THE MOST OF IT??
Number 2 and 1 are so based!! I would’ve ranked 1001 nights and beauty higher but I have massive twisted and starship bias. vhscc is so overlooked by the Starkid fan base despite how amazing it is, so I love to see it so high up in your rankings. Also, inevitable is definitely number one so great pick, chills every time. Lauren kills it with the acting there too it’s perfect.
Inevitable being #1 is correct. I’d put WITC at #3 and DDMD at #2. I know it’s kind of cliche to put the three Hatchetfield musicals in the first three slots but I really think they deserve it. Inevitable is just a fucking great song and the acting from Lauren and Jon is amazing. Dirty Dudes Must Die was such a fun throwback to Max’s villain song and the ending gives me chills. What If Tomorrow Comes is just such a chilling song all-around. Beautifully sung too.
My ranking because why not 1. Inevitable 2. Dirty Dudes Must Die 3. I wanna be your friend forever 4. Finale MAMD 5. Not alone 6. A thousand and one nights 7. Tommorrow Will Come 8. Days of Summer OG 9. Finale Firebringer 10. Naked in a Lake 11. Back on Top 12. Beauty 13. Days of Summer Senior Year (Not seen the Christmas Special)
a perfect ranking, and happy birthday! now if you'll excuse me, i need to get back to my eight millionth rewatch of the 2023 vhs christmas carol digital ticket (i can't believe i like that version of the christmas day finale even more than the original!)
Hey first ranking I completely disagree with! But that’s not a bad thing tbh, I would’ve put Not Alone reprise a lot higher personally but we all have our own preferences and opinions🤷♀️🫶
Days of summer from AVPSY at last? No. No. That should have been above Back On Top, Beauty, One Thousand And One Nights, and Super Friends, what if tomorrow comes, and Naked In A Lake. (Also “Finale/Making Love” should be in #1)
What if tomorrow comes Inevitable A thousand and one nights Dirty dudes must die Christmas Day Make the most of it Back on top Beauty Days of summer Not alone Naked in a lake Finale Super friends
Inevitable is the only right answer. My soul still hasn't recovered from it
Agreed. Kicks me right in the chest every time I watch it.
So real, Lauren does such a good job it’s insane
Agreed!!!
The difference between What if Tomorrow Comes and Inevitable in Vibes really shows the difference between Horror Comedy and Comedy Horror.
my top 3 are
1. Tomorrow Will Come
2. Dirty Dudes Must Die
3. Inevitable
the hatchetfield soundtracks are so great
Same
@@quirrelmortsI agree
I agree with Tomorrow Will Come at the top!
Hatchetfield stan (same)
but the way i always cry whenever a thousand and one night reprise plays makes me want it to be higher
yeah me too. I really love the way the audience cheer at the end
lauren lopez's acting in inevitable is showstopping. i absolutely adore her performance in that
Part of why that song is such a show stopping number
@@_SoySauce22 a real show stopper
I want nothing more than to hear Jon sing Inevitable now with the progress he's made in voice lessons since TGWDLM, he was great there but given how much he improved in NPMD I just know it would be phenomenal
i think you could probably tell him you want that since he was looking for what people want on his youtube channel. he has a lot of comments but it’s worth a shot
Dirty Dudes Must Die is definitely my favorite finale. It's just so ironic, dark, and fits the show so well. Plus it's insanely catchy.
its more iconic than the other ones imo
That has got to be Angela from Smosh!!!
It is!
To be fair to AVPSY, they did pretty damn good considering how little time they had to learn it. I also probably would have ranked it pretty low, but you have to admit that it’s impressive all things considered.
The transition of quality difference from MAMD to NPMD is insane to me, love how far they’ve come 🥹
Also perfect ranking, no notes
The only Starkid ending I don't like is Trail to Oregon, and it's just because it feels awkward and rushed. But the music is still a banger, which gives it an excuse in my opinion
I can get that, but I feel like the transition from "You Gotta Go" to "Naked in a Lake" is a bit of a non-sequiter by design, and if you disregard the transition into it, "Naked in a Lake" is a fitting ending for the show that builds on the events of the rest of it. Still though, it's a fair take
There really isn’t a bad one tbh
I don't know, the phasing on Dirty Dudes Must Die may be a bit awkward but it's the only one that gives me chills, and that puts it at #1 in my book.
My life mission is to get friends crazy enough to flash mob people by singing la dee da da day.
That has now been offically added to my bucket list.
STOP this is also a dream pf mine
No cause same
in the greatest way possible youre literally the watchmojo of the starkid fandom
haha i’ll take it
I will be honest, as somebody who LOVES NPMD, it’s my favorite of the musicals, first I ever watched, love all the characters, and though the ending I think is great in a writing sense and I enjoyed it, and the song was GOOD, but if we’re rating on quality of the song musically and nothing else, I think this ranking is extremely solid
AVPSY was def the worst for the live performances but the recorded versions of Days of Summer that they've got on spotify go HARD
edit: got too excited, no.6 for the other version of it is fair lmao
i love the difference in rankings between the two days of summer(s). it is so accurate lol
Its def not my favorite but Naked in a lake does get stuck in my head way more than i would like to admit
As the world’s biggest DDMD fan, I’m glad it got a middle spot on this list. What If Tomorrow Comes, Christmas Day, and Inevitable is such a good top three.
the duality of loving ddmd a lot but then seeing the rest of the ranking and knowing its right because INEVITABLE?? TOMORROW WILL COME?? MAKE THE MOST OF IT??
Firebringer's final song is so good I always forget how much I love it till I hear it again
I just rewatched firebringer and tbh the music went so hard for no real reason
Number 2 and 1 are so based!! I would’ve ranked 1001 nights and beauty higher but I have massive twisted and starship bias. vhscc is so overlooked by the Starkid fan base despite how amazing it is, so I love to see it so high up in your rankings. Also, inevitable is definitely number one so great pick, chills every time. Lauren kills it with the acting there too it’s perfect.
Thousand and one nights being so low is CRAZY
!!!!!
Inevitable being #1 is correct. I’d put WITC at #3 and DDMD at #2. I know it’s kind of cliche to put the three Hatchetfield musicals in the first three slots but I really think they deserve it. Inevitable is just a fucking great song and the acting from Lauren and Jon is amazing. Dirty Dudes Must Die was such a fun throwback to Max’s villain song and the ending gives me chills. What If Tomorrow Comes is just such a chilling song all-around. Beautifully sung too.
My ranking because why not
1. Inevitable
2. Dirty Dudes Must Die
3. I wanna be your friend forever
4. Finale MAMD
5. Not alone
6. A thousand and one nights
7. Tommorrow Will Come
8. Days of Summer OG
9. Finale Firebringer
10. Naked in a Lake
11. Back on Top
12. Beauty
13. Days of Summer Senior Year
(Not seen the Christmas Special)
Super Friends will always be my number 1, but I dig this list!
this ranking is so real
a perfect ranking, and happy birthday! now if you'll excuse me, i need to get back to my eight millionth rewatch of the 2023 vhs christmas carol digital ticket (i can't believe i like that version of the christmas day finale even more than the original!)
thank you!!! i’m definitely going to watch it later :)
Had a visceral reaction to days of summer being last, I love it so much
Okay I let you off for putting the original higher I didn't realise you'd split them
Glad to see what if tommorow comes getting the love it deserves
I wish the not alone reprise was higher, I'm a life time quirrel and voldy fan but love the list
look at my username… it’s about the song itself not the scene lol
Days of summer makes me cry everytime I hear it. Idk why.
the way i went into this knowing full well it would be inevitable because it is a MASTERPIECE
MAMD should have been higher
Hey first ranking I completely disagree with! But that’s not a bad thing tbh, I would’ve put Not Alone reprise a lot higher personally but we all have our own preferences and opinions🤷♀️🫶
I would’ve put it much higher but it’s so short and I was trying to base it more on sound not what’s happening in the scene
@@quirrelmortsThat is completely fair!🫶
INEVITABLE AT 1 SO TRUE
Happy birthday!!
also another amazing list, love seeing you back on RUclips!!
thanks!!!! i love being back!!!
THANK YOU FOR PUTTING VHS CHRISTMAS CAROL AT 2 THAT IS SUCH AN AMAZING MUSICAL!!!! u got my top 3 exactly
dirty dudes is on 2 for me but i agree with the rest!!!!
This is so nice, just a nice lil compilation of amazing Starkid finale, just spent nearly ten minutes singing along, had a good time 👍
wholeheartedly agree with top 3. it couldn't be anything else but those.
I was surprised at what if tomorrow comes at number 3 because I love it so much but after seeing your top 3 I agree, perfect ranking
happy birthday!!
thank you!!!
i love that you included vhs cc !
it’s my favorite show!!!
Happy Birthday!🎉
thanks!!!
HOW IS THE TWISTED SONG SO LOW!! CRIME I SAY GET THIS WOMAN BEHIND BARS NOW!!
Ok MAMD was robbed
thanks for the video and happy birthday!
you’re welcome and thanks!!!
Naked in a Lake would be higher in the list, but only because I directed and played Mother in it this year 😅
What were the names in your production?
they're all lovely :)
HAPPY BIRTHDAY 🥳
thank you!!!!
I’m going with an all-Hatchetfield top 3.
HOW DARE YOU PUT DIRTY DUDE MOST DIE SO DOWN!!!!
pd: I haven't finished the video xD
Can't believe not alone reprise wasn't higher
honestly same
Days of summer from AVPSY at last? No. No. That should have been above Back On Top, Beauty, One Thousand And One Nights, and Super Friends, what if tomorrow comes, and Naked In A Lake. (Also “Finale/Making Love” should be in #1)
What if tomorrow comes
Inevitable
A thousand and one nights
Dirty dudes must die
Christmas Day
Make the most of it
Back on top
Beauty
Days of summer
Not alone
Naked in a lake
Finale
Super friends
Sorry but the Not Alone Reprise deserved better
Happy Birthday. Great ranking video - amazing as always.
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
thank you!!! happy christmas and new year 😁
Happy birthday 🎉
thank you!!! 😁
Happy birthday 🎉
thank you!!!