Anna Nemzer - Putin Started a War on Russian Media and the Truth Early in the 2000s and it Continues
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 май 2024
- Anna Nemzer is a Broadcast Journalist at the Russian oppositional news network TV RAIN. She has produced an extraordinary series of documentary videos on key moments in Russia’s return to autocracy under Putin, and stages in the consolidation of his power over society and the media.
----------
LINKS:
pen.org/user/annanemzer/
/ tvrain_english
----------
BOOKS:
Prisoner, Hardcover and Kindle (2016)
www.amazon.co.uk/Prisoner-Ann...
----------
ARTICLES:
www.atlanticcouncil.org/event...
----------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL:
www.buymeacoffee.com/siliconc...
/ siliconcurtain
----------
TRUSTED CHARITIES ON THE GROUND:
Save Ukraine
www.saveukraineua.org/
Superhumans - Hospital for war traumas
superhumans.com/en/
UNBROKEN - Treatment. Prosthesis. Rehabilitation for Ukrainians in Ukraine
unbroken.org.ua/
Come Back Alive
savelife.in.ua/en/
Chefs For Ukraine - World Central Kitchen
wck.org/relief/activation-che...
UNITED24 - An initiative of President Zelenskyy
u24.gov.ua/
Serhiy Prytula Charity Foundation
prytulafoundation.org
NGO “Herojam Slava”
heroiamslava.org/
kharpp - Reconstruction project supporting communities in Kharkiv and Przemyśl
kharpp.com/
NOR DOG Animal Rescue
www.nor-dog.org/home/
----------
PLATFORMS:
Twitter: / curtainsilicon
Instagram: / siliconcurtain
Podcast: open.spotify.com/show/4thRZj6...
Linkedin: / finkjonathan
Patreon: / siliconcurtain
----------
Welcome to the Silicon Curtain podcast. Please like and subscribe if you like the content we produce. It will really help to increase the popularity of our content in RUclips’s algorithm. Our material is now being made available on popular podcasting platforms as well, such as Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
I'm so pleased to see Anna Nemzer on Silicon Curtain. Her podcast on Anna Politkovskaya was outstanding and very moving. It reminded me that whatever we think of Russian society, there are still Russians who are extraordinarily good and heroic.
👍👍👍
I just wanted to thank you for your kind words. Me & you live continents apart . Yet we think the same. Warm regards from London.
I was living under Russia occupation... never again!!!!!!
Poor you. Must have been horrible
@@carolwilliams8511 was. . And now people in Slovakia voted russian friend PM.... Unbelieveble..🙈
@@carolwilliams8511 Wish you to the front lines Carol !
Anna is an incredible inspiration to me as an Australian , who needs to know these details of Russian politics and life.
Depressing but inspiring.
Thank you
Excellent
He is not happy unless everyone is under his thumb.
And even then he looks like a miserable old s*d.
Thank you, Johnathan, for your presentation!
Wonderful conversation!
Always very informative. Keep up the good work.
Much appreciated!
Thanks, Jonathan.
Straight questions.
SC is the most impressive in-depth interview series on any topic I have ever seen and particularly on Russia/Ukraine/World topics.
a brilliant interview. Anna bridges over so pure, human, clear.. like a fresh mountain like river. thanks for what you do, giving light to this voices. wish you 100 mio followers ❤
In the past I thought russia would be democratic, not anymore. My county has lost it's bearing, but sanity is slowing coming back. Russia is a global menace period.
You are absolutely right. And it's tragic for the world.
Thanks for all your work! Yet another great guest!
I love it! Truthful!❤
Very good
She is a delight, I hope you have introduced Anna from Russia to Anna from Ukraine. I know that they will both get much from a friendship. When Anna says she has no hope I completely understand. It is so frustrating to not be able to help. I feel so much angst. I want to reach out to her and console her. I don't know where she is, but she would be in danger if in Russia. In a couple of years, when a Bradly might arrive in Red Square on it's own steam, Anna must work with Anna to re-invent Russia in the image of young Russian's dreams. "Russia" will be managed from Kiev, (which pre-dates Moscow as a regional centre by hundreds of years), for 100 years. Let's face it, Putin has killed Russia again, and the Russian people need a break. What a nightmare it is. But, (now talking to Anna from Russia), there is always hope, yes, this will end. YOU must survive, keep your head down. Come to live in London if you are not already here. Or go to Ukraine, but I would do this later when the war is won. No thoughts of suicide. No, you are an absolute gem, a diamond. The world will be lost without people like you. What we now still call Russia will be lost without you. If you die, or were murdered, then I would be lost. I agree with a post I briefly read in these comments; you are an inspiration. Absolutely. You are a light in the darkness. Fink is ok, (joking here) but you are deeper, more integrated emotionally and intellectually, and, if you are Russian; consider yourself Russian, and if you also want to reform Russia, then you must join forces with Anna ("from Ukraine") as together, you are a light that allows me to see Putin's passing, and the waking of damaged, zombified Russians who will recognise their own dreams in your writings, and who will need your love and understanding. So. You must survive. Random bombs must be avoided, and you must NOT become a target for this narcissistic regime.
[Narcissists are damaged individuals who must, one way or another, give themselves a feeling of worthiness by their "achievements", in the broadest sense of the word. Why? Because they do not feel a sense of self-worth by their own thoughts and feelings. This natural self-valuing function is the very thing that is broken.]
Anna thank you for doing this .Im in Canada and have had this Attitude since I lost friends and family to Fox News since late 80s -Mid 2000ths. Haven't listened yet but wanted to thank -You 🇨🇦☮️👐👣
Best interviews!
Thanks Jon
👍👍👍
Thanks Jonathan. Great, great choice for an interview. I have been watching Anna's outstanding 'Total Recall' series on the TV Rain channel. They are excellent. Anna is an insightful commentator and superb speaker. I know it is easy to say this with hindsight, but a big mistake by Russia (and Yeltsin) was to allow creatures of the Soviet security apparatus to hold positions of power after the fall of Communism. They might have been the most competent technically, but they would never allow a pluralistic or democratic system to emerge. Putin obsesses about 'unity' - as in one people, one empire, one leader. Anna makes a good observation that the cynical criminal Putin regime is based on lack of logic - any idea or policy is only for the purpose of keeping and expanding power, so can be changed or ditched at any time for that purpose. If truth does not exist for the Kremlin, then any lie is feasible and permissible. So, it is impossible to trust the Putin regime or reach any true modus vivendi. And of course the seeds of conspiracy theories (about responsibility for the war lying outside Russia) fall on earth that has been well fertilised in Russia for generations by prejudice and Marxism Leninism.
Thank you, Jonathan, for inviting Ana Nemzer to this interesting conversation.
🇺🇦 Перемоги і миру всім українцям! 🇺🇦
An honor for a Russian to be among the guests of this podcast.
A very interesting and very educated interview. thanks to both of you !
Thank you. See you on "Anna from Ukraine" channel. Keep up the good work.
good work
🇺🇦🙏🇺🇸
👍👍👏👏
Thank you, Jonathan and Anna. Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦
what a lovely woman ..
Anna Nemzer is a journalist, writer, and documentary filmmaker studying the historical memory of wars in the post-Soviet space. She is a scholar at Bard College, and a co-founder of the Russian Independent Media Archive (RIMA) dedicated to the preservation of all Russian independent media as the most important evidence of the era. She is now a presenter on TV Dozhd (aka TV-Rain - formerly the only independent TV channel in Russia, now working in exile),
Excelent
Great stuff Jonathan.
Thanks!
Thank you! 🙏
Very nice
Thanks for hosting this illuminative duscussion.
One of the things Anna raises is the challenge of maintaining hope in times these times. Perhaps she could take some comfort in words attributed to that great Russian storyteller, Anton Chekhov, who is quoted as working with the motto "without hope and without despair"(*)
Keep plugging away Anna ✊
(* quote extracted from, "Raymond Carver - Dreams Are What You Wake Up From", Electric Cereal, RUclips, 39:00min)
Somewhere in the Politics Aristotle remarks that if you want to be a really effective tyrant you need a really good imaginary threat, and if it’s on the other side of the world so much the better. Nobody will be able to tell you’re lying. So true.
That goes for the West as well as Russia
Have her on more often
Great interview !
I remember we couldn’t get russian television on our channels anymore, and it was explained that it was because something was off. I did not really get it, before the big attack on Ukraine. I am looking forward to more in depth explanation.
Always happy to comment on this excellent channel and every pro Ukraine vlog. 🇺🇦💛💙Slava Ukraini.
💛💙💜💙💛 listening uninterrupted 😁
🇺🇦 🌏 🇬🇧 🇺🇸
Thank you Jonathan and Anna ..from Italy ..
People like Anna could transform Russia for the better, if only they were allowed to flourish in such an otherwise toxic regime .. what is Chinese media like ,we don't hear much,do they have an equivalent of tv-rain? thanks SC.
They've got a country, it's called Taiwan.
They used to have another one, called Hong Kong, but the democratic world has been just idling its thumbs whilst everything went to...
FSB=KGB=FSB
Great questions and amazing guests, welcome all to Silicon Curtain!! 😀xxx
I really like Anna, she's very insightful and interesting to listen to.
You do a great job and always ask incredible questions
"Diaspora", like "mass migration" is a simple idea the manifestation of which is the movement of a population geographically, most likely to other states. The cultural reasons for diaspora can be complex, and just as is gloriously explained by the two cultural guardians above. Guardian angels. Thank you Jonathan for this wonderfully enlightening video.
U know ive admired ur work. This lady is nice and pretty good communicator
Jon: You are a leader. A warrior. A man. Please understand how we admired your debate with the duplicates the supplicants on your recent debate. Very tough. Recall Hitch: unafraid. Unafraid in the face of horror. … very few like you.
Appreciate. Revisit the narrators and push back just like u did. Stay strong.
Good listening to two people familiar with Russian media go into some depth on the topic. Anna's commitment to continue despite a lack of hope is inspiring. May she see a better Russia emerge.
👍👍👍
She is heaps cool.
V interesting 👍
Great Interview!! I remember listening to a lecture by Prof Tim Snyder from Oct 28, 2022, at Boston University about Genocide in Ukraine: "Genocide is underway. If we don't see it, the failure is ours." (on his substack) That was when truth smacks you in a way that is undeniable and you must face it. The ideology, the logic, the terrorism, the Russian playbook that was underway and the genocidal strategy was suddenly REAL. Every action Putin has done (either before or since) - I can see it. No amount of media manipulation changes (for me) that pure EVIL.
Finding hope is certainly difficult even as an onlooker from way “down under”, but it can stay solid when separating hope from all expectations no matter which direction the war goes. Then it becomes a decision, perhaps even a declaration like “ I stand for hope”. 🤔
And everybody knew it yet nobody suggested we should not engage/do business with that guy.
" If you tell the Truth, you don't have to remember anything" : Mark Twain
👍🇺🇲🇺🇦🇬🇧🇨🇵
She managed not to answer any of your questions. Or by not doing it, in a way she did.
she's a true thinker.
Bs
Putin Coronation 🤣
Well it was certainly no election and all the free world should refuse to recognise its legitimacy.
i click like is my comment thanks for your work
Da Comrades; We will pretend to tell truth and you will pretend to believe!
It's shameful that silicon curtain, Johnathan MS Pierce,Greg Terry,The Professor and Operator Starsky know the most information and yet get the least coverage.
Say a lot of people cannot listen to and follow intelligent debates or talks.
Rotating enemies a la 1984..
Yes.
"Professor Dugin". Nemzer is talking about the professor of Moscow Lomonosov University Dugin, the follower of Ilyin - Hitler Nazi ideologi. This alone means that that MGU, which Nemzer has attended herself, it's not really a university, but the outhouse in the shape of one of the stones skyscrapers
Long live the West! SLAVA UKRAINE! from Italy ❤❤
☮️
what a beautiful beautiful Russan lady ..
I've intended wondered if Putin; during his East German posting knew or worked with Merkel. As we learnt all East Germans had a close association or extended influence with the Stanzi did Putin have some leverage with her which affected her policies towards Russia
🇦🇺💙💛✌ 🇺🇦 Despite YT's instant removal of so many pro Ukraianian comments, demonetizing or outright removal of so many channels, the world is still supporting Ukraine.
к станку ее, и пусть въеживает.
🎯🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🎯😉
Brilliant of you to have Anna Nemzer on! 🙏 Even tho SC has become a strident propaganda channel, I'm still grateful for the gems you include.
What is the Azov idiology?
The Black Swan of the Russian Revolution
by PR Gregory · 2017 · - A black swan is a metaphor for an event that comes as a surprise, has a major effect, and is understood only with the benefit of hindsight.
Rain on, Anna! The world is a wonderful place!
Is it just me who sees a lot of similarity with trump?
Only one real opposition in russia is - RDK and Russian legion ... They fighting for Ukraine. This madam is nobody 😂😂😂 don't play russian game you will loose
Is the "Sasha Meets Russia" RUclips account Russian propaganda?
It’s all propaganda
Nemzer is propaganda too. Not kremlin propaganda, but the propaganda of the russian „opposition“.
at the begining of this war I listened to a BBCradio4 documentry on putins early life . embarrased as a taxi driver, humilited. and now seeks vengence on whatever is easiest. turns out, not so easy. but very dangerous and Europe needs to react more strongly.
🇷🇺👌☦️
Thank you, Jonathan, for your efforts, but today's guest wasn't persuasive. She vocalized her (kind of) stream of consciousness. It seems she constantly struggled translating from Russian. She also related a bunch of obvious ideas and well-known stories. Sorry, but at my point this interview was a failure.
@14 minutes -> incoherency
Can she answer a question without going down her own rabbit hole?
Такую интеллигентную женщину можно слушать часами при условии, что её показывают в полный рост в купальном костюме
What this mumbling is about?
Its about your tsar keeping his thumb on your tail little russ 😂
What will happen to Russia. It us now a self-inflicted wound open and it will keep on bleeding. It can not be closed. There is a reckoning with the past that now is unavoidable. There is a carmic dept so deep since the eradication of Ukraine simmers since 1709. Nobody has been called to account for the millions that perished.
The collective consciousness in Ukraine has now risen that this is the time. As the collective consciousness in Russia is broken as power and greed rains Supreme. There is no way back for present and future Russia as Putin is burning up its young generation, that perhaps may shape a. New area. The collective consciousness regarding life is like a umbrella that covers a nation. All positive thoughtforms for your nation in terms of your humanity and resposabilty to one another in every aspect of life. The dismantling of the Russia as it is now is the karma being enforced. Many people will perished and it will lost a while.
I am a medium since 1985. Hold on to your hat. May long live Ukraine 🇺🇦
More ukie/nato cope 😂
The parallels between Oceania 1984 and Russia 2024 are disturbing.
I would invite everyone to listen to the 1984 dramatized audio book by Steve Parker. He does a great job.
👍👍👍
War is peace…
Ignorance is strength.
"The setting of 1984 is Oceania, a giant country comprised of the Americas; the Atlantic Islands, including the British Isles; Australia; and the southern portion of Africa." - It's pretty clear what part of the world the book was aiming at. There is exactly zero parallels with Russia. Try again.
@@ozymandias5130 Pay attention to a previous comment.
Ignorance is strength.
You and the Russian troll ilk have mastered it.
Thanks!
👍👍👍