I believe this is the definitive recording of this etude. Heard them all. Not too fast not too slow plenty of musicality and rubato worked into a piece that leaves little room for it.
@@rancidblock5615 Good point, but one thing it’s not, is a song Just because some boardroom at Apple decided on that one word for all music forms listened to on their technology is no reason to let them impoverish your language. A ‚piece‘ or ‚piano piece’ or an Etude are viable names
I agree. Have recently listened to quite a few interpretations of this work and I do think I like this the best. Pure beautiful music without striving after any special effects or quirks. A stunning piece, dramatic without crossing over into extravagance.
This performance is broad and deep, rich and intense, full of strife yet completion...one of the best i've heard. Pollini's phrasing and weightiness never fades throughout the piece -what energy and drive. I think i held my breath the whole time, then gasped at the end! Just curious, has anyone heard Guiomar Novaes play this? We have her recording of the Etudes on record, but this one was sadly not recorded. Katheryne
Novaes’s rendition is also on youtube. She is THE poetesse and hers as well as Pollini’s are my favourite recordings of the études, together with Koczalski’s.
I can imagine the ocean in a hurricane. Few reprieves to the blowing wind and tall waves. Us mere mortals are unable to describe the fury of the ocean, unlike Chopin, the immortal musician. His music shall live on forever, known as some of the best music to have ever existed.
See that is the problem with descriptive titles that were not coined by the composer. Chopin NEVER called this the "Ocean" Etude. It's like the "Moonlight" Sonata. Someone came up with it and it stuck. But it was not Beethoven's intention to picture moonlight, nor was it Chopin's to depict the ocean or the winter wind for that matter. If you want Etudes with a poetic narrative you have to turn to Liszt or Alkan. But not Chopin.
@@Quotenwagnerianer couldn't agree more. I always try to ignore these names when the composer didn't want them. It cuts down your ability to be creative.
I program MIDIs in piano roll in FL Studio, and I have fooled around with this romantic style like Chopin. It's hard to get it right, if you don't know a lot of technical music theory and just program by feel and how it sounds. Placing one note at a time on piano roll might sound tedious but I find it fun. I also have a MIDI of several Chopin pieces, including this one, but there isn't as much emphasis on the melodic notes as in this interpretation. Beautiful.
This has become my favorite Chopin etude and for decades I hardly knew it. I also think it is underrated in difficulty.
14 лет назад+6
Just few days ago I started with all op. 25.. Gift from my prof. for this semester.. :) Of coarse I played many of them before... but never in a row as 1 composition.. Happy Chopinizing myself.. :p
Buen domingo ,Pollini ha sido el mejor para Chopin ,los valses ,es su disco de oro ,, pero no lo tienen .lo he buscado ,pero no lo tienen gracias me encanta despertar con musica y tus deseos hasta mañana
It's a very grand and colorful song. Like the subtitle Ocean, there seems to be a huge wave. The enormous arpeggio of both hands seems to represent an angry sea. It was such a perfect performance.
This also has soul, speed and force. This interpretation is so powerful and honestly i dont think Pollini interpretates this piece with that much power
Maestro Pollini , r9cordo a chi non lo sa che Karajan disse che gli studi suonati da lei sono tra i pochi dischi che porterebbe con se ,,'. Da semplice ascoltatore, e non musicista, anch io in questa incisione riesco a capire la sua grandezza. Oltre alla suprema bellezza degli stufi, che mi piacerrebbe ascoltare suonati lentamente per focalizzare tutte le note . Grazie per quello che fa per la nostra amata arte ! L" Italia le e' riconoscente per la sua arte e per il prestigio che lei porta nel mondo.
I would love to see a masterful pianist attempting to learn a difficult piece for the first time. Like a Rubinstein, Pollini, or Horowitz. Would be cool to see!
Techniquement c'est la meilleure version, répétition des notes très précise quasiment partout et vitesse au-dessous des autres interprètes et musicalement a cette vitesse c'est fort ;)
@@eoooong_owo Check out my Chopin Piano Concerto animations, with the best recording (Zimerman) : ruclips.net/video/qxuCU2YgLfY/видео.html ruclips.net/video/cwLERO_JQZ8/видео.html
@0angeplume0 - Unfortunatly we can't tell who could play better. It's amazing enough that Pollini could play this, but even more amazing that Chopin could write this.
That's a lot of power.. Has anyone ever noticed or considered that around the 1:15 mark in this recording that it sounds like Chopin kind of bailed out on further expansion and just settled on a return to the A section at that point? Such a tiny transition for such a vast sounding piece, one full of so many subtle chord progressions.. something strikes me as odd about that.
+Eric Bell Eric, Yes I have noticed this. I think it has something to do with the subject matter of the piece. Just like with No. 11, he is not afraid to get repetitive. The alternate title of Op. 25 No. 11 is Winter Wind. I feel he is communicating that just when you think the winter wind should stop...it just keeps on coming. Likewise, in this piece, I can imagine someone on a ship expecting the ocean to finally calm down and instead they are greeted with only more dark choppy waves.
+Eric Bell The main reason is because this is an etude, which is literally just a practice piece. As a result, while it may suck for us (since we want a more developed piece), this is all he probably was going for.
+John Smith Appassionata, his last sonata, Moonlight, Pathetique, Waldstein, Kreutzer, these are some of the sonatas which have wonderful 1st movements. Though in Tempest's case, I agree, there's just no comparison beetwen 1st, 2nd and the third movement.
+Logan Ortega Don't forget that "winter wind" and "ocean" are nicknames that were applied by other people. Chopin never named his etudes (in fact I don't know that he nicknamed any of his pieces, period). Though I think you have a good point.
Don't put stuff into the music that is not there. The programmatic title is not Chopin's. He never gave any indication what this music should be other than an octave arpeggio etude. If you want Etudes with programmatic ideas you have to go to Liszt.
Pollini fantastico. Karajan disse che uno delle incisioni che preferiva erano il studi suonati da Pollini. Grazie maestro .ei onore dell ' italia. E non capisco l' avversione di alcuni nel suoi confronti. Es paolo isotta!@!@!
This is very good performance. Pollini did great job. There are very few vids with this study on RUclips such well played as Pollini did. Once more, Great performance!!!
RIP Pollini, you were one of the finest interpreters of Chopin etudes
Love the way he brings out the melody.
Holy crap, I've been listening to different renditions of this, and this made me gasp at the very first few bars. Such expression!
Pollini is known to play Chopin etude the best out of all musicians :3
The best chopin etude
I'm agree with you , opus 25 n 1 & 12 are my favorites
revolutionary is super sick as well
i like 10 1, 10 4, 10 12, 25 5, 25 11, 25, 12
My favourites are 10 1, 25 1, and 25 12
Mine favorite is opus 25 no 7
Pollini and Cziffra are my favorites.......sounds pretty crazy...........
This is THE recording of the etude.
I believe this is the definitive recording of this etude. Heard them all. Not too fast not too slow plenty of musicality and rubato worked into a piece that leaves little room for it.
Yes !!
Truly depicts the heights and depths of the rolling ocean!
Names were added after the songs were made, so it's more of a good name choice rather than a good depiction
@@rancidblock5615 Good point,
but one thing it’s not, is a song Just because some boardroom at Apple decided on that one word for all music forms listened to on their technology is no reason to let them impoverish your language.
A ‚piece‘ or ‚piano piece’ or an Etude are viable names
Fantastic. Transcendental.
This etude is a lot harder than it gets credit for! Most people don’t play it this clearly or at tempo
Grand ! A beautiful playing, so perfect that it is forgotten to leave place only to an extraordinary emotion. Wonderful Chopin ! Magnificent Pollini !
ruclips.net/video/K7p9UbYO_w8/видео.html
I agree. Have recently listened to quite a few interpretations of this work and I do think I like this the best. Pure beautiful music without striving after any special effects or quirks. A stunning piece, dramatic without crossing over into extravagance.
Tragica nostalgia di Chopin ... è uno studio fantastico eseguito egregiamente da Pollini
:-))
Un'interpretazione unica e storica!
This performance is broad and deep, rich and intense, full of strife yet completion...one of the best i've heard. Pollini's phrasing and weightiness never fades throughout the piece -what energy and drive. I think i held my breath the whole time, then gasped at the end!
Just curious, has anyone heard Guiomar Novaes play this? We have her recording of the Etudes on record, but this one was sadly not recorded.
Katheryne
Novaes’s rendition is also on youtube. She is THE poetesse and hers as well as Pollini’s are my favourite recordings of the études, together with Koczalski’s.
Wow! He was quite the inspired pianist. So beautiful.
He is still alive and playing at concerts, heard him 10 yrs ago in Amsterdam and hopefully next month in Vienna!
This is an amazing recording! It took me on the second watch to be able to follow the music haha AMAZING!
Chopin 💚
Absolutely brilliant
maestro pollini. lei fa onore alla musica a se stesso e all' Italia. ..
This number is the real King of all Etudes!
Simply magnificent!!!!
The most elegant and accurate performance.
Versione storica, definitiva ❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉Giuseppe Perego Monza 16.2.1962 Grazie
this is just too good...
Best recording of the piece
I can imagine the ocean in a hurricane. Few reprieves to the blowing wind and tall waves. Us mere mortals are unable to describe the fury of the ocean, unlike Chopin, the immortal musician. His music shall live on forever, known as some of the best music to have ever existed.
See that is the problem with descriptive titles that were not coined by the composer.
Chopin NEVER called this the "Ocean" Etude.
It's like the "Moonlight" Sonata.
Someone came up with it and it stuck. But it was not Beethoven's intention to picture moonlight, nor was it Chopin's to depict the ocean or the winter wind for that matter.
If you want Etudes with a poetic narrative you have to turn to Liszt or Alkan. But not Chopin.
@@Quotenwagnerianer couldn't agree more. I always try to ignore these names when the composer didn't want them. It cuts down your ability to be creative.
Completely agree with you.
Chopin is the very best there ever was.
maybe Chopin is a mortal but his music's never gonna die
imagine playing this to the end of the world's survivors
Beautiful tribute.
For me chopin is the absolute best human being to ever create sound from any instrument.
Massive fan.💚
the best etude of chopin awesome etude
I really don't know what to say...
Maybe I should just cry.
You can hear the separate notes clearly, which is what makes this recording stand out. So many pianists just reduce this etude to a wash of notes.
I program MIDIs in piano roll in FL Studio, and I have fooled around with this romantic style like Chopin. It's hard to get it right, if you don't know a lot of technical music theory and just program by feel and how it sounds. Placing one note at a time on piano roll might sound tedious but I find it fun.
I also have a MIDI of several Chopin pieces, including this one, but there isn't as much emphasis on the melodic notes as in this interpretation. Beautiful.
I'm learning this piece right now and it's kicking my ass! lol. Amazing interpretation *****
So did u learn it? 😂
@@xmedian003x9we are waiting lol
you better give us the best concert ever after learning this for 13 years
My favorite version ❤
I loved this piece when I played it. I will never forget it
RIP Pollini, and thank you for everything.
I hear my dad playing this alot, I really love it, as a violionist I could say this is my favorite piano piece
Same but am pianist mainly, although also play violin
as a competitive pisser, this too is my favorite piano piece
ポリーニのエチュードは完璧なもの。そのOp.10-1から始まり、アルペジョで締めくくる最後のエチュード。これ以上のものはない。この一言に尽きる。
ce est chopin ,magnific
This has become my favorite Chopin etude and for decades I hardly knew it. I also think it is underrated in difficulty.
Just few days ago I started with all op. 25.. Gift from my prof. for this semester.. :)
Of coarse I played many of them before... but never in a row as 1 composition..
Happy Chopinizing myself.. :p
yes i can hear blockades
Only classical music can make me cry
Buen domingo ,Pollini ha sido el mejor para Chopin ,los valses ,es su disco de oro ,, pero no lo tienen .lo he buscado ,pero no lo tienen gracias me encanta despertar con musica y tus deseos hasta mañana
It's a very grand and colorful song. Like the subtitle Ocean, there seems to be a huge wave. The enormous arpeggio of both hands seems to represent an angry sea. It was such a perfect performance.
Here because of Alejandro Aranda (Scarypoolparty) and his song Blesser.
Me too! But I loooove Chopin as well!
This is the best interpretation I've heard of this piece on RUclips! Bravo!
best interpretation ever
The interpretation of Pollin has speed... An the most important thing, has soul. The best interpreter of Chopin is Pollini.
I love everybody's interpretation of this piece. They're all different but with no less soul.
This also has soul, speed and force. This interpretation is so powerful and honestly i dont think Pollini interpretates this piece with that much power
Rubinstein is singularly better.
Pollini is better with Etude. Rubinstein is better with others like Nocturnes and Waltzes.
What about Zimmerman? And Kissin?
The best version, love Pollini
only the pianists nows we have to play with the heart and with the brain. with God in my hands.
jesus O_O
amazing...
Come suona.... È straordinario, bravissimo bravissimo bravissimp❤😂
i love it
This is badass!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
the best on youtube...the best anywhere.
A great etude.
This interpretation is powerful, love it...
Bravo!
great
💙 💜 💛 💗 💕 My absolutely favorite!
진짜 바다 같다..🌊
0:52-1:14 My daughter's favorite part!
Mine too - the rising storm!
0:00~ 2:29 My favorite part!
@@fskkejrlppa8419 0:00-2:29 is the entire piece! Thank you for this reply. She likes this piece a lot!
@@chriswanjhang6258 👍👍👍
@@fskkejrlppa8419 Thank you!
Poliini is the best!
i LOVE the flow in Pollini's version! shear brilliance.
May Pollini RIP. I have come back to the etudes again after hearing the heartbreaking news of his death.
same, im so shocked
Maestro Pollini , r9cordo a chi non lo sa che Karajan disse che gli studi suonati da lei sono tra i pochi dischi che porterebbe con se ,,'. Da semplice ascoltatore, e non musicista, anch io in questa incisione riesco a capire la sua grandezza. Oltre alla suprema bellezza degli stufi, che mi piacerrebbe ascoltare suonati lentamente per focalizzare tutte le note . Grazie per quello che fa per la nostra amata arte ! L" Italia le e' riconoscente per la sua arte e per il prestigio che lei porta nel mondo.
Here because of Alejandro Aranda's Blesser. It honestly has a likeness.
I would love to see a masterful pianist attempting to learn a difficult piece for the first time. Like a Rubinstein, Pollini, or Horowitz. Would be cool to see!
NYR Corona fuck you
Check Valentina Lisitsa's practice videos.
PIECE. NOT SONG.
what
Absolutamente que este etude es magnificiente de todos! 🙏 te amo Chopin!! 💜
Yessss ! Wishes from Bellagio itsly .Como lake . Near to liszt home !!!!
Imagine giving this guy a 5 hour energy before a concert O.O
Musical genius
WONDERFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =D
Cool!
Impressionnant. C'est mon étude préférée...
Elle est très belle cette étude...
Techniquement c'est la meilleure version, répétition des notes très précise quasiment partout et vitesse au-dessous des autres interprètes et musicalement a cette vitesse c'est fort ;)
Bonjour Pedro !
MAURIZIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, TI AMOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
Still the best interpretation of this piece available on youtube (probably anywhere).
This is fantastic but I prefer Cziffra or Horowitz,
I agree, although I love Novaes’s and Koczalski’s almost as much.
短と長が入れ替わっていくのが、深い。面白い。
ショパンて華やかで、情緒的で。理論で聴いたら、さらに楽しいのかもしれないですね。
slaying
unsurpassed. no one plays this better. no one.
That is true. The phrasings are perfect.
Frédéric François Chopin well except you Chopin himself. :D
rubinstein? ahh I would kill to hear Chopin himself
I think horowitz was better
I love Cziffra's version personally because I don't feel any emotion from any of these technically perfect renditions.
Man that modulation at 1:58 gets me every time.
muse invented chopin!!!!
More power like cziffa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Impossible to play it better. Incredible!
Impossible to play it! 😭
Bellisimo
Amazing.. It is beautiful song! :D
I love you Chopin..♡♡
ruclips.net/video/K7p9UbYO_w8/видео.html
@@almabrasileira3680 Wow😀😀
@@eoooong_owo
I also love Chopin😊
@@almabrasileira3680 😆😆😆
@@eoooong_owo
Check out my Chopin Piano Concerto animations, with the best recording (Zimerman) :
ruclips.net/video/qxuCU2YgLfY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/cwLERO_JQZ8/видео.html
@0angeplume0 - Unfortunatly we can't tell who could play better. It's amazing enough that Pollini could play this, but even more amazing that Chopin could write this.
That's a lot of power..
Has anyone ever noticed or considered that around the 1:15 mark in this recording that it sounds like Chopin kind of bailed out on further expansion and just settled on a return to the A section at that point? Such a tiny transition for such a vast sounding piece, one full of so many subtle chord progressions.. something strikes me as odd about that.
+Eric Bell
Eric, Yes I have noticed this. I think it has something to do with the subject matter of the piece. Just like with No. 11, he is not afraid to get repetitive. The alternate title of Op. 25 No. 11 is Winter Wind. I feel he is communicating that just when you think the winter wind should stop...it just keeps on coming. Likewise, in this piece, I can imagine someone on a ship expecting the ocean to finally calm down and instead they are greeted with only more dark choppy waves.
+Eric Bell The main reason is because this is an etude, which is literally just a practice piece. As a result, while it may suck for us (since we want a more developed piece), this is all he probably was going for.
+John Smith Appassionata, his last sonata, Moonlight, Pathetique, Waldstein, Kreutzer, these are some of the sonatas which have wonderful 1st movements. Though in Tempest's case, I agree, there's just no comparison beetwen 1st, 2nd and the third movement.
+Logan Ortega Don't forget that "winter wind" and "ocean" are nicknames that were applied by other people. Chopin never named his etudes (in fact I don't know that he nicknamed any of his pieces, period). Though I think you have a good point.
+Javros Oh, I never knew that the nicknames came from other people. Thanks for telling me!
I have complted 6 page. Now i do daily routine
POLLINI OWNS THE ETUDES.
I feel like this is a boss battle
it's so solid you hear no notes, only waves in the rough and stormy sea.
Don't put stuff into the music that is not there.
The programmatic title is not Chopin's. He never gave any indication what this music should be other than an octave arpeggio etude.
If you want Etudes with programmatic ideas you have to go to Liszt.
Pure Brilliance is the only thing you can describe Chopin's Work as, simple perfect
This performance has real depth and real class. A great performance of a great piece.
CRUSH CRUSH WHERE THE RUUSH
Maurizio !
el estudio trascendental de liszt "visión" debe estar inspirado en este estudio
in the deep ocean never to come back again ........
Pollini fantastico. Karajan disse che uno delle incisioni che preferiva erano il studi suonati da Pollini.
Grazie maestro .ei onore dell ' italia. E non capisco l' avversione di alcuni nel suoi confronti. Es paolo isotta!@!@!
This is very good performance. Pollini did great job. There are very few vids with this study on RUclips such well played as Pollini did. Once more, Great performance!!!