Just brilliant Rajiv Ji. Unfortunately for india, the priorities are so skewed and understanding of the international structures/ social constructs go above their heads. Very illuminating discussions with Jaggy and most informative 👌
In Tamil Nadu, waqf board is declaring villages are theirs, and govt is asking people to go mosque and get permission to do any sale. People are unaware and also the property is theirs for generations. Register office is simply refusing inspite of necessary papers. Inspite of paying taxes to govt. For generations.
If u don’t organize and fight for ur rights, what do u expect?? No one cares to learn from history. They don’t even learn. Forget prepare their kids. Phir bhugto!
@@asisdas2653 Snakes in the Ganga discusses several failures of the Indian state which continue even under this present bjp government but things are even more dire because RSS/BJP has the tendency to hide it's failures and about turns... Also, just like lutyens media used to sing Congress praises pre 2014, it sings Modi praises today and then there is the bjp social media wing. Both work overtime to keep Hindus assured that Modi is looking after our interests while he plays in the hands of Globalist left and Islamists.
From listening to this discussion it seems like power, religion, population and democracies matter. The big picture is it helps powerful countries to stifle India because of its population. Bringing India under the umbrella of one religion then it is easier to manage the power of India. Harvard has funding to do this and they use Indians to attack India. Then it will be perceived as a problem in India rather than instigated by outsiders. Like any other country India has internal problems which need to be addressed and needs ongoing resolutions. Which country does not have similar issues. Others are controlling the narrative for India. It is easy to penetrate India and use India to promote other global agenda. People and especially the elites in India have to do some introspection.
The major problem is that Indian academics either unaware of this process or ignoring it. But for sure I would say that the epistemological analysis of Rajiv Ji is much than many mainline academics in India who spent their entire life in sociology. RajivJi is developing a new perspective in Indian sociology which will provide a new lense to look at current India.
I am wondering why Rajiv Malhotra ji works are not cut in clips by youtubers and used to viralize their channel and ofcourse the greater cause to build that awareness towards nation building
i might not agree with rajiv ji but he had come on a very right time for us atleast for me. i always wanted to ifnite a battle against wokeism and to spread hindutva in my campus, with rajiv ji explaining it about engineering atleast i have one strong reason to say that the bridge is burnt and there is no other way but to fight!
@@Akaula1 well i dont like him being too blunt when he is namecalling before he puts his reasoning. i believe he is focusing two much on CRT angle and critical theory, i guess he should look at postmodernism and the gender wars in america which has a different origin and all. i also think that he is focusing too much on harvard but he think he should look at other major centres and other theories where such nonsense is spewed, but he said that he had a lot of materials and it should be seen as a good beginning towards the future, i hope he does that in future. but if he doesnt do that we will miss a lot of other threats we will miss out. i hope it satisfies you!
@@adityasinghbais6528 postmodernism is also an outcome of the response from left, when communism came to be seen defeated. But the be it post modernism, cultural Marxism and then cancel culture, and current status iare out come from the left. The intent is to break society. But it is not restricted to Harvard, many elite and not so elite universities are involved in it.
Please consider asking your readers to come up with an alternative title for this book. Doing that could be a great marketing exercise too. "An Era of Darkness" "Inglorious Empire" These were two names for Shashi Tharoor's book on the 1857 Indian War of Independence fought against the British. Is Snakes in the Ganga going to have different names in different markets? This "Snakes in the Ganga" for a book on 'Breaking India 2.0' with Critical Race Theory turned into Critical Caste Theory by Dalit Professors and their Indian collaborators, both from the Corporate World and the Indian bureaucracy doesn't seem to make for a great book title.
It is appropriate that Rajiv Ji is given a platform to briefly explain the exceptionally important alarming world movements breaking India- My question what are these interviewers who run the shows doing other than filling up the show - Can they not use their resources to collect a band of young brilliant Indians to explain, spread, alert awaken and counter, fight and bring the CRT forces to their knees. Even this interviewer, sorry to say, seems to be a bit behind times
Rajeev can you do the pointers for young Ind Ian’s. They do not read big books. May be you can you are the best Glad in small town in USA we are connected.
here are they : they can be anyone it iz not static, the more ideology spreads more people become they• small kids who are learning numbers today may be they tomorrow• from book though, he said thry are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee• Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there • So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc • now are elites they ?? no , it depends upon who accepts this ideology
Hindus can have no independent university as per the current Constitution like it used to be in the past. We have been deliberately prohibited to have our gurukulas by the LAW itself. If you want to do something even a little similar to this here, you would have to disassociate yourself or your institution from the Hindu fold. While minorities can have their own govt funded academic institutions, what we can get at max has to be achieved through minority appeasing version of Secularism only. 😁😁
Revealing questions from Jagannath ji. I am sure Rajiv ji appreciates these questions. By the way Liberal Arts is one of the money making subjects for universities. That could be the reason why this is being promoted in India. After graduating students enrolled in liberal arts don't find proper jobs to make a living after spending large sums to get educated in Liberal Arts.
Love the way Jaggi is subtly toying with this guy ….. by the way his spiritual guru is apparently Swami Nithyananda, who has been entertaining us for so long from his adobe Kailasa !!!
First a lot of guilt was infused in the sawarnas and now that guilt feeling is being exploited against the sawarnas. Now because vedic dharma is popular in different races in many countries the anti-vedic people in the world are coming together and forming a coalition against the vedic dharma and against the social order formed by vedic dharma.
crt sounds like the same thing as dravidianism. how is it different. 'dravidians' have been claiming different ancestry and oppression by brahmins for ages. it's different in that they've found a way to take the faultline global
@10:00 In theory you can ally with one enemy fighting the other. But we are not organized enough, not nearly as organized as the desert religions. To be able to work with them for our cause while resisting and fighting them back in their war against us needs fighter jet like nimbleness. It it possible to approach such nimbleness only through organization. I mean these people blow themselves up, kill others and get killed in the process of converting. While not condoning any of those acts, I would like to draw your attention to the fact that the adherents have been brainwashed into aligning themselves to their cause of painting the world in their color so much that they act as if they are mindless autonomous bots. Historically trying to ally with one enemy to fight another has not been successful for us. That should not discourage us. While scholarship like that of Rajiv Malhotra is needed, acting on the advice provided is predicated upon us organizing ourselves on massive scale, try things, change them if they don't work, change the approach at the flip of a coin. All of this needs dedicated education campaigns, first within us hindus and then educating the adherents of the desert religions on why they are following false religions. I mean how many if us even believe that those religions represent adharma or vidharma as Sai Deepak calls them ? Compare that with the fact that hesus freaks and mud-slimes believe with a mortal passion that sanatanis must be eliminated from the face of the earth.
28:00 Yes it is an important question, but how much of what happened for a 1000 years before the British arrived contributed to the loss of self esteem. It is easy to self-criiticise and lose morale, but well, like everybody everywhere else, chances are, we are products of circumstances too. So again educating, mobilizing, organizing people could potentially rectify that as well. I am in no position to tell Rajiv garu how to spend his money, but personally i believe his cause would have been better served if he spent a few of his millions in setting up a world class university in India which would create intellectual warriors instead of spending them in the western university. Atleast the folks behind gitauniversity.in are doing something on that front.
Sunil Choudhary ~ The title of the book exemplifies the issues Rajiv talked about. Rajiv has a deep knowledge of Sanatana Dharma, our Shastras (science), Shrutis, Smritis & beyond and 30-years of relentless activity in defense & support of Dharma & Dharmic people (Hindus) vis-a-vis the abrahamic world. Being a true Kshatriya, Rajiv is taking the battle right to the courtyard of the enemies of Dharma. So, snakes as an abrahamic metaphor is perfect catchy name for this book.
Dharma Yoga Ashram ~ I agree. Snakes are Divine in Sanatana Dharma. Nonetheless, your comment comes from not knowing Rajiv, his deep knowledge of Sanatana Dharma, our Shastras, Shrutis, Smritis & beyond and 30-years of tireless work in defense & support of Dharma & Dharmic people vis-a-vis the abrahamic world. If anyone understands the importance of snakes in our Samskriti, it is Rajiv. He is taking the battle right to the courtyard of the enemies of Dharma by being a true Kshatriya taking the teaching of Kautilya. So, snakes as an abrahamic metaphor fits perfectly fine to this book. Sometimes we need to sacrifice a queen to get to the king.
in today's colonised minds of hindus snakes are enemies . 90% hindus will stay away from snakes if found on their land . are u a snake charmer u took it to heart . i think it's great title .
"THEY" seems to be the most used word in this video But there's no clarity who the THEY are, except who their allies are The unknown unseen unknowable devil I guess
here are they : they can be anyone it iz not static, the more ideology spreads more people become they• small kids who are learning numbers today may be they tomorrow• from book though, he said thry are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee• Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there • So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc • now are elites they ?? no , it depends upon who accepts this ideology
Why is Rajivji taking misdirected potshots against the lower caste Hindus? When did the 'lower caste people with reservation' lead the anti-India activities in JNU, TISS etc. let alone Harvard, Columbia or Oxford?!! As far as the the breaking India forces go, the lower castes have been at best some foot soldiers in some cases, not the heavy weights. Unfortunately, it's mostly the savarna Hindu elites **(and among them also the vast majority of them are from the highest Hindu caste!)** who lead the Breaking India movement in India and abroad! Just list down the top 100 or 500 anti-Indian, anti-Hindu voices (political leaders, intellectuals, social science sepoys, reporters, editors, actors etc) **who are Hindus** - in India and abroad - you will find more than 95% of them are upper caste (savarna) Hindus, and many, if not most among them are from the highest Hindu caste. Even Rajivji mentions that it's the elites who are doing it in the later part in this video. If the vast majority of these breaking India 'snakes' are coming from the privileged section of Hindus with a clear caste pattern, why are they not being called out - knowing Rajivji for more than two decades, I don't think it's because of his ignorance or bias, perhaps he is afraid of being cancelled by the most influential section of this own support base.
Rajiv ji is not taking pot shots at anyone. He’s highlighting how India’s social/economic problems are being co-opted and used to attack Hinduism in the West. Dalit pretenders are gaining momentum as caste experts, giving training to companies, etc. They r in fact discriminating against ALL Hindus in the diaspora. ‘Caste police’ in US leaders are not even Hindus. One is Christian/Buddhist and her director is Bangladeshi Muslim! What right do these non-Hindus have to tell us how to live our faith? But they are getting access into Silicon Valley and universities! Harvard helping them & their cohorts!
hey you wrote same comment in other video as well, have u read any of his books ever ??? here is same reply I gave you there as well : and no where he said it is dalits who are actually having metaphor of snakes in his book, he said they are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee• Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there • So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc • And when he mentioned of conversion by church in breaking India book released11 years back, there church was main doer • He is not shying away in naming them, if he names all who will buy his book ? They are in book though not all but around 10
Are you from the lower castes? Your dream of being accepted by these Savarna bigots will always remain that - a dream, with a few chunks thrown to you along the way, to show you they remember you
@@carrad123456 I never said "it is dalits who are actually having metaphor of snakes in his book" - don't put words in my mouth. I have no problem whatsoever with the intent of this book (although I am yet to read it) or any of his previous books. However if you listen to this video (and the video with Madhu Kishwar) it sounds like until now it was the dalit who leading the breaking India activities, only now the upper class and privileged are also getting into it. Which is absolutely bogus - It was the upper class and privileged all along (most of whom happen to be upper caste) - even in his own earlier books most of the Hindus he named fueling 'Breaking India' activities and giving intellectual support to 'Academic Hinduphobia' are mostly upper caste. *In fact, for every Suraj Yengde Rajivji names, he hismelf mentions ten Ajantha Subramanians and Angana Chatterjis!* (I hope you have really read his books) Let's see this video itself: 5:20 Rajivji: _"then the dalits jumped in, and said we should also create a critial caste/dalit theory"_ --- No it was the handy work of mostly upper caste Hindus. Would be happy to be proved wrong. 12:44 Jaggi: _"It's not the black and the dalits that are leading this ideological fight"_ --- The lower caste never led this, if at all, they were some small fry at best! 18:03 Rajivji : _"The new problem is not coming from grassroot village people go to JNU and on a quota system and become leftist - the new problem is that the elites of India are sending their kids to private education..."_ --- This is not some new system, the privileged upper castes have led this all along! no idea why he is saying this. My problem is when the vast majority of these *breaking India 'snakes'* are coming from the privileged section of Hindus with a clear caste pattern (not just now, but from the beginning), he does not wan't to call them out as a caste - that's also okay, but why is he misdirecting the focus to the dalits and othering them even though he is well aware of the faultlines and also the fact that the dalits are not leading vast majority of the anti-Hindu narrative.
here are they : they can be anyone it iz not static, the more ideology spreads more people become they• small kids who are learning numbers today may be they tomorrow• from book though, he said thry are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee• Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there • So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc • now are elites they ?? no , it depends upon who accepts this ideology
![YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Missing Everything [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dTYeMZGzOzw/mqdefault.jpg)
Time to open gurukul university for all hindus including brahmins and dalits to learn hindu vedas sitting side by side
Rajiv ji is a true warrior for the Indic civilization. 🙏
Audio quality is poor. Swarajya should do a better job at that. A simple way would be to record using separate cameras and sync them up later.
Just brilliant Rajiv Ji. Unfortunately for india, the priorities are so skewed and understanding of the international structures/ social constructs go above their heads. Very illuminating discussions with Jaggy and most informative 👌
In Tamil Nadu, waqf board is declaring villages are theirs, and govt is asking people to go mosque and get permission to do any sale. People are unaware and also the property is theirs for generations. Register office is simply refusing inspite of necessary papers. Inspite of paying taxes to govt. For generations.
If u don’t organize and fight for ur rights, what do u expect?? No one cares to learn from history. They don’t even learn. Forget prepare their kids. Phir bhugto!
Dude smash their faces in stand up for yourself dude
@@linneshwharparameswaran6147 Dude, What are you doing about it, dude?
Listening to Rajiv Ji depresses me about the Indian situation but this depression is good. Its good to face realities.
@@asisdas2653 Snakes in the Ganga discusses several failures of the Indian state which continue even under this present bjp government but things are even more dire because RSS/BJP has the tendency to hide it's failures and about turns... Also, just like lutyens media used to sing Congress praises pre 2014, it sings Modi praises today and then there is the bjp social media wing.
Both work overtime to keep Hindus assured that Modi is looking after our interests while he plays in the hands of Globalist left and Islamists.
Thank you For Inviting Rajiv Sir..🙏
Outstanding show.
Very very informative. Inspires to work harder to save our WORLD'S ONLY LIVINING SANSKRITI so far!
Fantastic conversation.
From listening to this discussion it seems like power, religion, population and democracies matter. The big picture is it helps powerful countries to stifle India because of its population. Bringing India under the umbrella of one religion then it is easier to manage the power of India. Harvard has funding to do this and they use Indians to attack India. Then it will be perceived as a problem in India rather than instigated by outsiders. Like any other country India has internal problems which need to be addressed and needs ongoing resolutions. Which country does not have similar issues. Others are controlling the narrative for India. It is easy to penetrate India and use India to promote other global agenda. People and especially the elites in India have to do some introspection.
The major problem is that Indian academics either unaware of this process or ignoring it. But for sure I would say that the epistemological analysis of Rajiv Ji is much than many mainline academics in India who spent their entire life in sociology. RajivJi is developing a new perspective in Indian sociology which will provide a new lense to look at current India.
good questions by jaggi
This is such amazing talk.
I am wondering why Rajiv Malhotra ji works are not cut in clips by youtubers and used to viralize their channel and ofcourse the greater cause to build that awareness towards nation building
This is our last chance of saving our civilization
If we miss this boat there is no hope for us
i might not agree with rajiv ji but he had come on a very right time for us atleast for me. i always wanted to ifnite a battle against wokeism and to spread hindutva in my campus, with rajiv ji explaining it about engineering atleast i have one strong reason to say that the bridge is burnt and there is no other way but to fight!
If you don’t agree then articulate you differences. Otherwise it is just a way of boasting independent intellectualism. Nothing else.
@@Akaula1 well i dont like him being too blunt when he is namecalling before he puts his reasoning. i believe he is focusing two much on CRT angle and critical theory, i guess he should look at postmodernism and the gender wars in america which has a different origin and all. i also think that he is focusing too much on harvard but he think he should look at other major centres and other theories where such nonsense is spewed, but he said that he had a lot of materials and it should be seen as a good beginning towards the future, i hope he does that in future. but if he doesnt do that we will miss a lot of other threats we will miss out. i hope it satisfies you!
@@adityasinghbais6528 postmodernism is also an outcome of the response from left, when communism came to be seen defeated. But the be it post modernism, cultural Marxism and then cancel culture, and current status iare out come from the left. The intent is to break society. But it is not restricted to Harvard, many elite and not so elite universities are involved in it.
@@adityasinghbais6528 However you should develop your thesis and inform the public and nation.
@@Akaula1 me apne college peers ko inform kardu woh kafi hai. Literally dealing with spineless people out here!
Please consider asking your readers to come up with an alternative title for this book. Doing that could be a great marketing exercise too.
"An Era of Darkness"
"Inglorious Empire"
These were two names for Shashi Tharoor's book on the 1857 Indian War of Independence fought against the British.
Is Snakes in the Ganga going to have different names in different markets?
This "Snakes in the Ganga" for a book on 'Breaking India 2.0' with Critical Race Theory turned into Critical Caste Theory by Dalit Professors and their Indian collaborators, both from the Corporate World and the Indian bureaucracy doesn't seem to make for a great book title.
It is appropriate that Rajiv Ji is given a platform to briefly explain the exceptionally important alarming world movements breaking India- My question what are these interviewers who run the shows doing other than filling up the show - Can they not use their resources to collect a band of young brilliant Indians to explain, spread, alert awaken and counter, fight and bring the CRT forces to their knees. Even this interviewer, sorry to say, seems to be a bit behind times
Rajeev can you do the pointers for young Ind Ian’s. They do not read big books. May be you can you are the best Glad in small town in USA we are connected.
here are they : they can be anyone it iz not static, the more ideology spreads more people become they• small kids who are learning numbers today may be they tomorrow•
from book though, he said thry are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee•
Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there •
So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc •
now are elites they ?? no , it depends upon who accepts this ideology
Hindus can have no independent university as per the current Constitution like it used to be in the past. We have been deliberately prohibited to have our gurukulas by the LAW itself.
If you want to do something even a little similar to this here, you would have to disassociate yourself or your institution from the Hindu fold. While minorities can have their own govt funded academic institutions, what we can get at max has to be achieved through minority appeasing version of Secularism only. 😁😁
Revealing questions from Jagannath ji. I am sure Rajiv ji appreciates these questions.
By the way Liberal Arts is one of the money making subjects for universities. That could be the reason why this is being promoted in India. After graduating students enrolled in liberal arts don't find proper jobs to make a living after spending large sums to get educated in Liberal Arts.
🙏
Love the way Jaggi is subtly toying with this guy ….. by the way his spiritual guru is apparently Swami Nithyananda, who has been entertaining us for so long from his adobe Kailasa !!!
First a lot of guilt was infused in the sawarnas and now that guilt feeling is being exploited against the sawarnas.
Now because vedic dharma is popular in different races in many countries the anti-vedic people in the world are coming together and forming a coalition against the vedic dharma and against the social order formed by vedic dharma.
1:06:10
Trust Windows to butt in whenvit shouldn't 🤣
🐯
26:34
Boston Brahmins why are. These societies using these. Words as a elitologystic terms. Education means Brahman
crt sounds like the same thing as dravidianism. how is it different. 'dravidians' have been claiming different ancestry and oppression by brahmins for ages. it's different in that they've found a way to take the faultline global
Rebuttal and rebutting, no rebuttaling!!!
Is that your only takeaway
Hello Shashi tharoor
@10:00
In theory you can ally with one enemy fighting the other. But we are not organized enough, not nearly as organized as the desert religions. To be able to work with them for our cause while resisting and fighting them back in their war against us needs fighter jet like nimbleness. It it possible to approach such nimbleness only through organization.
I mean these people blow themselves up, kill others and get killed in the process of converting. While not condoning any of those acts, I would like to draw your attention to the fact that the adherents have been brainwashed into aligning themselves to their cause of painting the world in their color so much that they act as if they are mindless autonomous bots.
Historically trying to ally with one enemy to fight another has not been successful for us. That should not discourage us. While scholarship like that of Rajiv Malhotra is needed, acting on the advice provided is predicated upon us organizing ourselves on massive scale, try things, change them if they don't work, change the approach at the flip of a coin. All of this needs dedicated education campaigns, first within us hindus and then educating the adherents of the desert religions on why they are following false religions.
I mean how many if us even believe that those religions represent adharma or vidharma as Sai Deepak calls them ? Compare that with the fact that hesus freaks and mud-slimes believe with a mortal passion that sanatanis must be eliminated from the face of the earth.
28:00
Yes it is an important question, but how much of what happened for a 1000 years before the British arrived contributed to the loss of self esteem. It is easy to self-criiticise and lose morale, but well, like everybody everywhere else, chances are, we are products of circumstances too. So again educating, mobilizing, organizing people could potentially rectify that as well.
I am in no position to tell Rajiv garu how to spend his money, but personally i believe his cause would have been better served if he spent a few of his millions in setting up a world class university in India which would create intellectual warriors instead of spending them in the western university.
Atleast the folks behind gitauniversity.in are doing something on that front.
Rajiv will know Jaggi is in current govt camp,,he is making him squirm
Pl siscysd these in I fis tv like republic, bharat DD
This title reminds me of - snakes on a plane. It seems topic name VS content do not match
what's VS content?
Sunil Choudhary ~ The title of the book exemplifies the issues Rajiv talked about. Rajiv has a deep knowledge of Sanatana Dharma, our Shastras (science), Shrutis, Smritis & beyond and 30-years of relentless activity in defense & support of Dharma & Dharmic people (Hindus) vis-a-vis the abrahamic world. Being a true Kshatriya, Rajiv is taking the battle right to the courtyard of the enemies of Dharma. So, snakes as an abrahamic metaphor is perfect catchy name for this book.
Rajiv needs to heed his own wisdom. Listen to his interviews with two "yoga teachers" Holy Yoga and Suzin Green. He capitulates to both.
Snakes are Divine in Hindu Dharma--Nag Devata. Rajiv is subconsciously showing a Christian/Monotheistic mindset.
Dharma Yoga Ashram ~ I agree. Snakes are Divine in Sanatana Dharma. Nonetheless, your comment comes from not knowing Rajiv, his deep knowledge of Sanatana Dharma, our Shastras, Shrutis, Smritis & beyond and 30-years of tireless work in defense & support of Dharma & Dharmic people vis-a-vis the abrahamic world. If anyone understands the importance of snakes in our Samskriti, it is Rajiv. He is taking the battle right to the courtyard of the enemies of Dharma by being a true Kshatriya taking the teaching of Kautilya. So, snakes as an abrahamic metaphor fits perfectly fine to this book. Sometimes we need to sacrifice a queen to get to the king.
in today's colonised minds of hindus snakes are enemies . 90% hindus will stay away from snakes if found on their land . are u a snake charmer u took it to heart . i think it's great title .
in ur ashram do u live with snakes
"THEY" seems to be the most used word in this video
But there's no clarity who the THEY are, except who their allies are
The unknown unseen unknowable devil I guess
you😆
here are they : they can be anyone it iz not static, the more ideology spreads more people become they• small kids who are learning numbers today may be they tomorrow•
from book though, he said thry are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee•
Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there •
So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc •
now are elites they ?? no , it depends upon who accepts this ideology
Why is Rajivji taking misdirected potshots against the lower caste Hindus? When did the 'lower caste people with reservation' lead the anti-India activities in JNU, TISS etc. let alone Harvard, Columbia or Oxford?!! As far as the the breaking India forces go, the lower castes have been at best some foot soldiers in some cases, not the heavy weights.
Unfortunately, it's mostly the savarna Hindu elites **(and among them also the vast majority of them are from the highest Hindu caste!)** who lead the Breaking India movement in India and abroad! Just list down the top 100 or 500 anti-Indian, anti-Hindu voices (political leaders, intellectuals, social science sepoys, reporters, editors, actors etc) **who are Hindus** - in India and abroad - you will find more than 95% of them are upper caste (savarna) Hindus, and many, if not most among them are from the highest Hindu caste. Even Rajivji mentions that it's the elites who are doing it in the later part in this video.
If the vast majority of these breaking India 'snakes' are coming from the privileged section of Hindus with a clear caste pattern, why are they not being called out - knowing Rajivji for more than two decades, I don't think it's because of his ignorance or bias, perhaps he is afraid of being cancelled by the most influential section of this own support base.
Rajiv ji is not taking pot shots at anyone. He’s highlighting how India’s social/economic problems are being co-opted and used to attack Hinduism in the West. Dalit pretenders are gaining momentum as caste experts, giving training to companies, etc. They r in fact discriminating against ALL Hindus in the diaspora. ‘Caste police’ in US leaders are not even Hindus. One is Christian/Buddhist and her director is Bangladeshi Muslim! What right do these non-Hindus have to tell us how to live our faith? But they are getting access into Silicon Valley and universities! Harvard helping them & their cohorts!
hey you wrote same comment in other video as well, have u read any of his books ever ??? here is same reply I gave you there as well :
and no where he said it is dalits who are actually having metaphor of snakes in his book, he said they are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee•
Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there •
So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc •
And when he mentioned of conversion by church in breaking India book released11 years back, there church was main doer •
He is not shying away in naming them, if he names all who will buy his book ? They are in book though not all but around 10
Are you from the lower castes? Your dream of being accepted by these Savarna bigots will always remain that - a dream, with a few chunks thrown to you along the way, to show you they remember you
@@carrad123456 I never said "it is dalits who are actually having metaphor of snakes in his book" - don't put words in my mouth.
I have no problem whatsoever with the intent of this book (although I am yet to read it) or any of his previous books.
However if you listen to this video (and the video with Madhu Kishwar) it sounds like until now it was the dalit who leading the breaking India activities, only now the upper class and privileged are also getting into it. Which is absolutely bogus - It was the upper class and privileged all along (most of whom happen to be upper caste) - even in his own earlier books most of the Hindus he named fueling 'Breaking India' activities and giving intellectual support to 'Academic Hinduphobia' are mostly upper caste. *In fact, for every Suraj Yengde Rajivji names, he hismelf mentions ten Ajantha Subramanians and Angana Chatterjis!* (I hope you have really read his books)
Let's see this video itself:
5:20 Rajivji: _"then the dalits jumped in, and said we should also create a critial caste/dalit theory"_
--- No it was the handy work of mostly upper caste Hindus. Would be happy to be proved wrong.
12:44 Jaggi: _"It's not the black and the dalits that are leading this ideological fight"_
--- The lower caste never led this, if at all, they were some small fry at best!
18:03 Rajivji : _"The new problem is not coming from grassroot village people go to JNU and on a quota system and become leftist - the new problem is that the elites of India are sending their kids to private education..."_
--- This is not some new system, the privileged upper castes have led this all along! no idea why he is saying this.
My problem is when the vast majority of these *breaking India 'snakes'* are coming from the privileged section of Hindus with a clear caste pattern (not just now, but from the beginning), he does not wan't to call them out as a caste - that's also okay, but why is he misdirecting the focus to the dalits and othering them even though he is well aware of the faultlines and also the fact that the dalits are not leading vast majority of the anti-Hindu narrative.
@@snair8448 Pls see my reply to carrad123456 on the same thread.
here are they : they can be anyone it iz not static, the more ideology spreads more people become they• small kids who are learning numbers today may be they tomorrow•
from book though, he said thry are elites of India who can give 10 to 20 lakh as course fee•
Now who are elites are India ?? They are from multiple religions first not just hinduism, second those from hinduism have more non shudras as elites but a miniscule population of shudra varn may be also there •
So in nutshell it is hindus from non SC background majorly, other religions and elites etc •
now are elites they ?? no , it depends upon who accepts this ideology