Xtina has a great voice but it's like hearing someone play a piano with a chainsaw. Beyonce is a supremely talented vocalist who is arguably the best of her generation. Pink, Gaga and Florence are very underrated vocally. Anastacia when in her prime was a vocal beast . Her lows down to a C3 were well supported and she could carry her dark voice up to an A5. The clips used here however are when she is out of her prime so she's not as good
Anastacia can still belt up to A5, and her lows are actually better now. She lost some of her stamina and ease, but she still belts better than a lot of sopranos.
HellYeah! She lowered most of her songs on her last tour though in order to avoid hitting any of those big top notes and I'm not sure when the last time she hit a D3 was
There's thousands of notes below E♭3, she is really using her lower register now ruclips.net/video/DcF-kfibFXg/видео.htmlm41s ruclips.net/video/fEU1HDe2dOY/видео.htmlm25s
MEZZO VOCAL BATTLE VIDEO MAIN RULE: There's thousands of vocal battle videos on youtube and most of them feature the exactly same notes, to make the things more diversified, I'm only adding notes from each singer latest 3 eras. Also, I'm not adding notes that I used on the previous mezzo battle video, but i'm allowed to use a note from the same song, but a different live performance. Allowed eras list: P!nk - BT, TTAL, Funhouse. Beyoncé - Lemonade, Beyoncé, 4. Christina - Lotus, Bionic, B2B. Florence - All (she only have 3 albuns) Lady Gaga - Joanne, C2C, ARTPOP Anastacia - Resurrection, IaMW, HR (There's the new "Revolution" era, but it was released while the video was in development, so it doesn't counts). Only one exception was made that is Christina F#5 from Lady Marmalade, because B2B only has one decent F#5, and it was already used on the previous video. This is the main rule, further information can be provided on the comment section, have fun!
Awesome video friend! I love your editing ahhhh. Also you're the first person in like 10 years to include Anastacia in a vocal battle lol You deserve an award!
Ellie Goulding? She sounds closer to a soprano honestly, and I think Florence might be one too as she often shows discomfort singing below G3 (she said on James Corden once that she was initially going to be trained as a classical soprano but couldn't commit due to its strict regime).
You picked some great notes for P!nk, most notes I see on YT are raspy. Great video like always. I think Bey takes it for lows and belts. Florence's head voice is so beautiful so I'll be bias and say she wins that part lol.
Now that's an exciting vocal comparison!! =)I like the variety in your selection of some of the signature notes by these ladies. For me: Low Notes: Bey = Gaga > Christina (she's surprisingly good here) = Anastacia > Pink >>> Florence (she has improved here but lower range isn't her best feat) Belts: Bey = Anastacia > Pink = Gaga > Florence >>> Christina (self-explanatory) Head Voice (these are all head notes right?): Bey (such a flawless head voice) >>> Florence = Christina = Anastacia = Gaga > Pink As a whole, I'd rank them as Bey > Anastacia > Gaga > Pink > Christina = Florence. Beyonce is the most well-rounded singer overall whereas Anastacia's power is formidable. Gaga and Pink have some of the most consistent techniques among this era's pop singers. Florence is a capable vocalist but her stylistic choices can be unhealthy especially during her earlier performances. Christina has a great tone and some potential she could still develop...
So far I liked your rating more. But I would still put Anastacia above Beyonce tho. I believe that P!nk G5, A5, and christina A5 are falsetto, everything else is HV tho ;).
Currently her whole range still settles around Eb3 ("Hiding") - F#5 ("Spectrum") - Eb6 (various "Dog Days" live performances), but her control of the third octave has improved pretty decently - likewise with her pitch in general.
Walter Velvet Gregson But what about her head voice? It definitely went higher on cosmic love. Also, have you noticed even though her voice has improved technically, it’s also gotten FAR weaker and lost so much resonance since Ceremonials?
Her lows, in general, are more supported than Gaga and Florence. Her head voice, when she uses it, more developed than Pinks. She is capable of executing far more complex melisma than anyone here (except Beyonce) and when it comes to falsetto its a wrap for everyone else. We get it shes not the best belter really, but there are other aspects to singing than just belting.
@@mrvocal21 Not true. Technically speaking, Gaga actually has a far better lower register than Christina. I do agree about her agility though. The only one who loses to Christina in low notes is Florence.
@@mrvocal21 I'm sorry, but NO. You're very wrong. Even the Christina of today has worse lows than Gaga. You don't even have any reasons as to why you say so. Mine is because Gaga is able to sing lower than Christina with good technique (Gaga can sing down to a D3 with vocal freedom, while Christina can sing down to an F3 with vocal freedom. Christina is inconsistent below F#3 and Gaga is inconsistent below Eb3. So clearly Gaga has better lows than Christina).
Chacune a son talent ! Le propre d'un ou une artiste est de nous faire vibrer. Nous offrir rêverie et frissons. Chacune son univers et ses limites. Bravo à toutes. Elles sont incroyables. ⚘💖
I don't get xtina and Florence addition... And where's Sara? Also you began the head section too high even though only Beyonce and gaga support that high
@@MrPeppeRE Dramatic voices doesn't necessarely mean Dark. I already gave you this comparision to you. -Adele does not have a voice with a lot of weight. She is a Lower Light Mezzo-Soprano. Listen to her speak: ruclips.net/video/93-r90QP8E0/видео.htmlm12s -JoJo's voice has a voice with a lot of weight. She is a true natural Dramatic Mezzo-Soprano. Listen to her speak: ruclips.net/video/SNVs54owaBA/видео.htmlm1s JoJo’s voice's denser. -Here’s Adele singing: ruclips.net/video/DDWKuo3gXMQ/видео.htmlm17s -And here’s JoJo singing: ruclips.net/video/ePEW9Z7zyas/видео.htmlm1s JoJo's voice's denser Adele's voice is a litte bit deeper, since she's a Low Mezzo, but JoJo's one is clearly heavier, she's a Dramatic. Don't be deceived by the fact that she can do coloraturas.
@@alebormio4842 dramatics are also know for their booming, heroic high notes, jojo's output is still small. Anastacia and Taylor Dayne are dramatic mezzos
Nah her voice is really light, I just went to her Sydney show on the High as Hope Tour (she dropped Moderation on us a day after release and it was sooooo good) her belts and speaking voice gave away how light her voice is
A few things to note: 1. P!nk is not a spinto-soprano (spinto-sopranos have bright, warm and metallic voices. an example of a true spinto-soprano is Whitney Houston; P!nk's voice is dark, warm and smooth... she lacks the brightness and metallic quality that a spinto-soprano has. Besides, her lower register has that fullness to it which sopranos lack) 2. Mezzo-contralto isn't a thing ("light" mezzo-contralto most certainly isn't a thing either) 3. Anastacia is a dramatic mezzo-soprano (these are mezzo-sopranos with a tessitura that is close to that of a contralto; dramatic sopranos have dark, cold and metallic voices, and Anastacia possesses all three of these qualities, making her a dramatic mezzo)
@@varunravi27 what you talk about metallic voices isn't a thing, it's just the tone that anyone can have; also bright tone is a thing that depends of body resonant cavities, so not of vocal folds; Mezzo-Contralto, call it as you want, is a hybrid voice between Contralto and Mezzo-soprano and there are vocal depths like that; vocal weights can be present in each main type (so also Light; as I said, those qualities you're talking about aren't indicative of anything
@@alebormio4842 There is still no such thing as a "light mezzo-soprano" or a mezzo-contralto. These things simply don't exist in the fach system so if you wish to argue with the creator of the fach system (who probably isn't even alive right now), go on.
@@varunravi27 Leggero Mezzo-soprano exists in Opera, and in each case the fact that any role has ever specifically been written doesn't mean it can't exists the voice type; any vocal weight can be present in anyone's voice, this is a fact
Xtina has a great voice but it's like hearing someone play a piano with a chainsaw.
Beyonce is a supremely talented vocalist who is arguably the best of her generation.
Pink, Gaga and Florence are very underrated vocally.
Anastacia when in her prime was a vocal beast . Her lows down to a C3 were well supported and she could carry her dark voice up to an A5. The clips used here however are when she is out of her prime so she's not as good
Anastacia can still belt up to A5, and her lows are actually better now.
She lost some of her stamina and ease, but she still belts better than a lot of sopranos.
HellYeah! She lowered most of her songs on her last tour though in order to avoid hitting any of those big top notes and I'm not sure when the last time she hit a D3 was
There's thousands of notes below E♭3, she is really using her lower register now
ruclips.net/video/DcF-kfibFXg/видео.htmlm41s
ruclips.net/video/fEU1HDe2dOY/видео.htmlm25s
Anastacia the BEST ♥ powerfull high notes and low notes, is voice is unique ♥
those C5’s from everyone were just amazing
MEZZO VOCAL BATTLE VIDEO MAIN RULE:
There's thousands of vocal battle videos on youtube and most of them feature the exactly same notes, to make the things more diversified, I'm only adding notes from each singer latest 3 eras. Also, I'm not adding notes that I used on the previous mezzo battle video, but i'm allowed to use a note from the same song, but a different live performance.
Allowed eras list:
P!nk - BT, TTAL, Funhouse.
Beyoncé - Lemonade, Beyoncé, 4.
Christina - Lotus, Bionic, B2B.
Florence - All (she only have 3 albuns)
Lady Gaga - Joanne, C2C, ARTPOP
Anastacia - Resurrection, IaMW, HR (There's the new "Revolution" era, but it was released while the video was in development, so it doesn't counts).
Only one exception was made that is Christina F#5 from Lady Marmalade, because B2B only has one decent F#5, and it was already used on the previous video.
This is the main rule, further information can be provided on the comment section, have fun!
Awesome video friend! I love your editing ahhhh.
Also you're the first person in like 10 years to include Anastacia in a vocal battle lol
You deserve an award!
Lol, thank you bud!
Florence and gaga rockkkkk
(I wish Ellie can belt so she can be on this video LOL)
Ellie Goulding? She sounds closer to a soprano honestly, and I think Florence might be one too as she often shows discomfort singing below G3 (she said on James Corden once that she was initially going to be trained as a classical soprano but couldn't commit due to its strict regime).
Gaga and Bey's C5s😩🙏🏽 chills
You picked some great notes for P!nk, most notes I see on YT are raspy. Great video like always. I think Bey takes it for lows and belts. Florence's head voice is so beautiful so I'll be bias and say she wins that part lol.
I haven't seen you in ages LOL
Thanks bud
Haha no problem
Anastacia 😈
Now that's an exciting vocal comparison!! =)I like the variety in your selection of some of the signature notes by these ladies. For me:
Low Notes: Bey = Gaga > Christina (she's surprisingly good here) = Anastacia > Pink >>> Florence (she has improved here but lower range isn't her best feat)
Belts: Bey = Anastacia > Pink = Gaga > Florence >>> Christina (self-explanatory)
Head Voice (these are all head notes right?): Bey (such a flawless head voice) >>> Florence = Christina = Anastacia = Gaga > Pink
As a whole, I'd rank them as Bey > Anastacia > Gaga > Pink > Christina = Florence. Beyonce is the most well-rounded singer overall whereas Anastacia's power is formidable. Gaga and Pink have some of the most consistent techniques among this era's pop singers. Florence is a capable vocalist but her stylistic choices can be unhealthy especially during her earlier performances. Christina has a great tone and some potential she could still develop...
So far I liked your rating more.
But I would still put Anastacia above Beyonce tho.
I believe that P!nk G5, A5, and christina A5 are falsetto, everything else is HV tho ;).
HellYeah! Anastacia has a better voice but I think Bey is more consistent with her technique
1. Beyoncé
2. Lady Gaga
3. Pink
4. Anastasia
5. Christina
6. Florence
This is a mezzo battle, start the belts from a4 cause they start getting good there
Florence ⚡️
Anastacia's voice is so underrated
Lows: Anastacia and Gaga
Belts: Anastacia. Pink C5 e phrased F5's were really good.
Head voice: Beyoncé, by far.
Lows Beyoncé
Belts Anastacia and Beyoncé's*
Gaga's Resonance 😍😍😍
P!nk and Anastacia are just beasts. You could of included Beyoncé’s and p!nk A5’s and Bb5. They are so good and powerful
Do you think Gaga can hits an A5 and B5 in head voice?
All the A5s she's done have been head voice
I’m a man and I can go up to D6 in head voice with ease... she is a woman, if I can, she can too
Anastacia :)
P!nk, Lady Gaga and Anastacia 😍💖
Anastacia all my life!!!!❤😍
anastacia forever
BEYONCÉ ❤️
High Belts
C5: Christina
C#5: Beyoncé
D5: Pink/Florence
Eb5: PINK/Florence
E5: Anastacia/Gaga
F5: Beyoncé
F#5: Anastacia
After High as Hope would you guys says Florence has gained another octive or is she still at three octives?
Ethereal Beauty definitely gained another octave
Currently her whole range still settles around Eb3 ("Hiding") - F#5 ("Spectrum") - Eb6 (various "Dog Days" live performances), but her control of the third octave has improved pretty decently - likewise with her pitch in general.
Walter Velvet Gregson But what about her head voice? It definitely went higher on cosmic love. Also, have you noticed even though her voice has improved technically, it’s also gotten FAR weaker and lost so much resonance since Ceremonials?
Amazing video but I don't get Christina's addition.
Her lows, in general, are more supported than Gaga and Florence. Her head voice, when she uses it, more developed than Pinks. She is capable of executing far more complex melisma than anyone here (except Beyonce) and when it comes to falsetto its a wrap for everyone else. We get it shes not the best belter really, but there are other aspects to singing than just belting.
@@mrvocal21 Not true. Technically speaking, Gaga actually has a far better lower register than Christina. I do agree about her agility though. The only one who loses to Christina in low notes is Florence.
@@varunravi27 Maybe Christina of 2000 not Christina of today and that's the end of the discussion. X
@@mrvocal21 I'm sorry, but NO. You're very wrong. Even the Christina of today has worse lows than Gaga. You don't even have any reasons as to why you say so. Mine is because Gaga is able to sing lower than Christina with good technique (Gaga can sing down to a D3 with vocal freedom, while Christina can sing down to an F3 with vocal freedom. Christina is inconsistent below F#3 and Gaga is inconsistent below Eb3. So clearly Gaga has better lows than Christina).
@@varunravi27 Christina is inconsistent below E3 lmao and not everything has to do with support.
Chacune a son talent ! Le propre d'un ou une artiste est de nous faire vibrer. Nous offrir rêverie et frissons. Chacune son univers et ses limites.
Bravo à toutes.
Elles sont incroyables.
⚘💖
Anastacia!
P!nks G5 is not head it is a mixed belt
lows: bey = gaga = anastacia > pink > xtina > florence
belts/mixing: bey > anastacia > gaga > pink > florence > xtina
head voice: bey > florence > xtina = anastacia = gaga > pink
Belts Beyoncé=Anastacia or midbelts Beyoncé=Anastacia, high belts Anastacia> Beyoncé
1° florence
2°christina,gaga y pink
3°beyoncé y anastacia.
Florence most powerfull, but the video tries to hide that.
I don't get xtina and Florence addition... And where's Sara? Also you began the head section too high even though only Beyonce and gaga support that high
Everyone's except P!nk's carried support on the G5
Anastacia!!!
where is jojo? I know she is a mezzo, right?
Byron David Ojeda yes
JoJo's a true dramatic mezzosoprano
@@alebormio4842 jojo's voice is nowhere dark enough to be a dramatic
@@MrPeppeRE Dramatic voices doesn't necessarely mean Dark.
I already gave you this comparision to you.
-Adele does not have a voice with a lot of weight. She is a Lower Light Mezzo-Soprano. Listen to her speak: ruclips.net/video/93-r90QP8E0/видео.htmlm12s
-JoJo's voice has a voice with a lot of weight. She is a true natural Dramatic Mezzo-Soprano. Listen to her speak: ruclips.net/video/SNVs54owaBA/видео.htmlm1s
JoJo’s voice's denser.
-Here’s Adele singing: ruclips.net/video/DDWKuo3gXMQ/видео.htmlm17s
-And here’s JoJo singing: ruclips.net/video/ePEW9Z7zyas/видео.htmlm1s
JoJo's voice's denser
Adele's voice is a litte bit deeper, since she's a Low Mezzo, but JoJo's one is clearly heavier, she's a Dramatic. Don't be deceived by the fact that she can do coloraturas.
@@alebormio4842 dramatics are also know for their booming, heroic high notes, jojo's output is still small. Anastacia and Taylor Dayne are dramatic mezzos
Great job
Ana!
i love p!nk's technique
Anastacia! No doubt!❤️❤️
Amazing!
No Florence Welch is the best vocalist to be honest... and her music is just amamzing 😄😃😀
Beyoncé crushes
Florence is a Full Lyric Soprano.
Only natural born mezzo is Anastacia and maybe Gaga (also a sopranoish, like most of mezzos today).
Toda são maravilhosas, mas Gaga 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
beyonce range is G2-F#6 AND Christina range is A2-Eb7
Christina's is actually B2-C7/C#7, not A2-Eb7.
Beyoncé, Cristina and Anastacia are all soprano
I thought Florence was a Dramatic as well...
Nah her voice is really light, I just went to her Sydney show on the High as Hope Tour (she dropped Moderation on us a day after release and it was sooooo good) her belts and speaking voice gave away how light her voice is
Anastacia
yasss
Upper Belts will always be Ana at 1!
This will be fun! (Beyoncé's gonna win, it's pretty obvious... she's got the best technique out of the six):
Lows:
G3: P!nk (+6) > Gaga (+5) > Beyoncé (+4) > Anastacia (+3) > Florence (+2) > Christina (+1)
F#3: P!nk (+6) > Christina (+5) > Anastacia (+4) > Beyoncé (+3) > Gaga (+2) > Florence (+1)
F3: Beyoncé (+6) > Gaga (+5) > Anastacia (+4) > Florence (+3) > P!nk (+2) > Christina (+1)
E3: Beyoncé (+6) > P!nk (+5) > Christina (+4) > Gaga (+3) > Anastacia (+2) > Florence (+1)
Eb3: Beyoncé (+6) > Gaga (+5) > Anastacia (+4) > P!nk (+3) > Christina (+2) > Florence (+1)
Belted/Mixed notes:
C5: P!nk (+6) > Gaga (+5) > Beyoncé (+4) > Anastacia (+3) > Florence (+2) > Christina (+1)
C#5: Gaga (+6) > Beyoncé (+5) > Florence (+4) > Christina (+3) > P!nk (+2) > Anastacia (+1)
D5: Beyoncé (+6) > Gaga (+5) > P!nk (+4) > Florence (+3) > Christina (+2) > Anastacia (+1)
Eb5: P!nk (+6) > Gaga (+5) > Beyoncé (+4) > Christina (+3) > Anastacia (+2) > Florence (+1)
E5: P!nk (+6) > Beyoncé (+5) > Gaga (+4) > Anastacia (+3) > Christina (+2) > Florence (+1)
F5: P!nk (+6) > Beyoncé (+5) > Gaga (+4) > Christina (+3) > Anastacia (+2) > Florence (+1)
F#5: Beyoncé (+6) > P!nk (+5) > Gaga (+4) > Anastacia (+3) > Christina (+2) > Florence (+1)
Upper register:
G5: Beyoncé (+6) > Gaga (+5) > Christina (+4) > Florence (+3) > P!nk (+2) > Anastacia (+1)
G#5: Beyoncé (+6) > P!nk (+5) > Christina (+4) > Gaga (+3) > Anastacia (+2) > Florence (+1)
A5: Beyoncé (+6) > Christina (+5) > Gaga (+4) > P!nk (+3) > Anastacia (+2) > Florence (+1)
Lows - Beyoncé > P!nk > Gaga > Anastacia > Christina > Florence
Belted/Mixed notes - P!nk = Beyoncé > Gaga > Christina > Anastacia > Florence
Upper register - Beyoncé > Christina > Gaga > P!nk > Florence = Anastacia
P!nk - 67
Beyoncé - 78
Christina - 42
Gaga - 65
Florence - 26
Anastacia - 37
These are the results:
Beyoncé > P!nk > Gaga > Christina > Anastacia > Florence
ANASTACIA😍😍
I don’t think P!nks G5 is head, more mixed
Beyoncé é rainha e o resto é nadinhaa
Pink is a spinto soprano, while Anastacia is a light mezzocontralto
A few things to note:
1. P!nk is not a spinto-soprano (spinto-sopranos have bright, warm and metallic voices. an example of a true spinto-soprano is Whitney Houston; P!nk's voice is dark, warm and smooth... she lacks the brightness and metallic quality that a spinto-soprano has. Besides, her lower register has that fullness to it which sopranos lack)
2. Mezzo-contralto isn't a thing ("light" mezzo-contralto most certainly isn't a thing either)
3. Anastacia is a dramatic mezzo-soprano (these are mezzo-sopranos with a tessitura that is close to that of a contralto; dramatic sopranos have dark, cold and metallic voices, and Anastacia possesses all three of these qualities, making her a dramatic mezzo)
@@varunravi27 what you talk about metallic voices isn't a thing, it's just the tone that anyone can have; also bright tone is a thing that depends of body resonant cavities, so not of vocal folds; Mezzo-Contralto, call it as you want, is a hybrid voice between Contralto and Mezzo-soprano and there are vocal depths like that; vocal weights can be present in each main type (so also Light; as I said, those qualities you're talking about aren't indicative of anything
@@alebormio4842 There is still no such thing as a "light mezzo-soprano" or a mezzo-contralto. These things simply don't exist in the fach system so if you wish to argue with the creator of the fach system (who probably isn't even alive right now), go on.
@@varunravi27 Leggero Mezzo-soprano exists in Opera, and in each case the fact that any role has ever specifically been written doesn't mean it can't exists the voice type; any vocal weight can be present in anyone's voice, this is a fact
Florence is a soprano
Can we get Jojo in the next one?
ruclips.net/video/fquSdJAtpUY/видео.html
sweattie
Florence and Gaga would be a nonexistent Spinto Mezzo-Sopranos 😭
Nys Monroe just Florence
Lady Gaga is lyric
Christina Aguilera is not a mezzo soprano but a damaged full lyric soprano who has bad technique
I lowkey hate Florence's vibrato...why is it so shaky and uneven?
Beyoncé obviously
My top
1 Beyoncé
2 Gaga and Ana
3 Christina
4 Pink
5 Florencia
Gaga wins for me
Beyoncé>Anastacia>Gaga>P!nk= Florence>>>>>> Xtina
sorry but gaga is contralto
Definitely not.
Sorry Baby Gaga is Mezzosoprano dark!
Sorry but Gaga is a mezzo soprano
pink es contralto
Mezzo.
No
MEZZO
Pink is a spinto soprano