[8회] 김한별 VS 윤민서 - Speechless @일대일 라이벌 미션 K-POP 패밀리 컴피티션이 시작된다! 부모 소환 십대 오디션 ＜캡틴＞ 매주 목요일 저녁 8시 30분 본방송 #부모소환십대오디션 #캡틴 #엠넷캡틴 #캡TEEN #CAP_TEEN #캡틴송 #엠넷 #Mnet
둘 다 잘했지만 나는 한별이가 개인적으로 너무 대단하다고 생각함.. 사실 저런 부담감 큰 공연에서 실수하면 멘탈이 정상이 아닐텐데 바로 마음다잡고 다음 파트로 넘어가고, 담담한 모습이 너무 멋있었음.. 나라면 저 상황에서 이미 망했다는 생각으로 어버버타다가 그냥 망했을 거 같아서..
@smple amity the video which u showed was not singing into the unknown and besides into the unknown is full of highnotes and pitch is very important in this song,one wrong note and the whole song is gone,into the unknown is a very hard song.
I honestly don't know who I would pick if I was in the judge's position. The girl in the red dress sung the song so effortlessly whereas the other girl has more of a unique voice. Although the other girl had a voice crack, she managed to save it with other high notes. Bravo to both of them though.
Hanbyul may have had a few mistakes with her voice cracking and some lyrical mistakes but on this performance, I find her tone better, especially during the early part and when they are harmonizing. It's sad to see Minseo go but I trust the judge's decision.
I also think that judge’s decision was right. i can see that Hanbyul did make a mistake but it’s not what she wanna do and everyone also. Hanbyul has a very unique voice and can mange her voice nicely from the low tone to the high tone, not forcing her tone. For minseo also did great, but her voice doesn’t seem so good, she can sing high notes and everyone can except that she can make it, but for some ppl like me, i think her voice wasn’t unique like hanbyul, she was trying so hard whenever she sing, up and down with the vocal, but those vocal come to her nose that make the starting or even the low tone sound so deep and ruining the low part of the song.
the judges were right, minseo’s singing is similar to one from a musical and hanbyul’s singing resembles one from a movie. Two different styles but are both so beautiful. I don’t think we should compare because they both are so talented! 🥺❤️
For me the girl wearing the red dress suites with theatrical songs, she has a classy and elegant voice. While the girl in the white dress has a open and wide voice range..so her voice (I feel like) suites more to songs that are loved by everyday people.
I feel like they both are friends in real life judging by the part where Hanbyul voice cracked. I feel like Minseo was caught off guard by Hanbyul's voice crack and was a bit unstable at her part. If they were a rival, I don't think Minseo would have made it way better when her rival is at a downfall. Btw, I love both. And it is sad to see Minseo eliminated but happy at the same time when the judge chose Hanbyul.
Hanbyul's voice fits the song better. However, her voice cracked and made mistakes. Besides that, damn, her voice is really amazing. Meanwhile, Minseo sang perfectly although not as impactful as the other because her voice does not suit really well to the song. I feel bad. I was rooting for SOPA girl. :(( Huhuhu
Minseo’s voice is more effortless and therefore will sound more floaty and glorious on live stages like musicals, but Minseo’s voice is a bit rougher, more unique, and emotional, putting her in a better place when it comes to recorded voices where not everything will come through live. It may not pierce as much on live stages, but it will sound better through the TV.
2:24 That girl gave me chills when she hits that high note! 0_0 Her voice sounds so unique to be honest! About the other girl from the right side, Even though she made a few mistakes but she still carries on with her singing and it sounds good and pleasant
*They both have such a beautiful and powerful voices especially the girl with red dress 💗 her voice fits perfectly with the song 👏 but I feel bad for the girl with blue dress when her voice is cracking ☹️*
한별님 노래 너무 잘 부르세요ㅜㅜㅜㅜ솔로가수로 하셔도 엄청 인기 많으실 것 같고 아버님도 옆에서 적극적으로 꿈 이뤄줄려는 모습도 보기 좋았습니다. 문자 투표도 꾸준히 했었는데 개인채널도 생기시고 저가 다 뿌듯합니다!! 보물보다 더 귀한 목소리를 갖고계신 한별님 앞으로 좋은 모습 많이 보여주세요 😍😍
The girl in the blue dress was singing well until she dodged or but despite her mistake she continued to sing super well and I feel that her tone of voice is unique
I don't know man, Minseo is a phenomenal singer but her voice isn't that special tbh and neither are her performances, just your typical musical actress I feel like. That doesn't take away from her amazing talent obviously. But Hanbyul, despite having a few mistakes here and there she conveyed the emotions a lot better and her voice is quite unique, she needs to either choose songs more suited for her range though or she should practice her high notes more. Overall I would choose Hanbyul too, her voice fits the song better and she brought the song to life tbh by her performance. She understands the song better and you can tell. They're both incredible and I hope they both hit big.
한별님 민서님 두분 다 너무너무 잘 부르시는데 잘하는 인재들이 너무너무 많다보니까 개성이 있는 분을 뽑은거 같아요. 민서님 같은 가창력을 갖고 계신분들은 많지만 한별님 같은 음색을 갖고 계신분은 많이 안 계시니까요. 실력은 연습으로 커버가 되지만 매력이나 음색은 자기스타일을 타고 태어나는 거니까 그런 것 같아요. 그리고 선곡자체가 한별님이 더 잘 어울리셔서 그런것도 있는 듯 하네요
Minseo singing that high notes so quiet is a really technical advanced move not many can do. most just shout out high notes because its easier. but singing them so sonft ist damn impressive
The effortless Minseo voice make me goosebumps, her voice like shattering my heart. They both had a good technic while singing. Hanbyeol have a power in her voice. It create a beautiful harmony.
I was rooting for these 2 to compete each other. Minseo's voice is incredible, however, Han Byul has more emotions and unique voice. I really want to hear Minseo singing Disney songs ❤. They're both awesome. But this is a conpetition, 1 has to go.
Idk since the auditions they've been letting those who make obv mistakes pass. It's kinda disrespectful to those who practiced so much to make their performances perfect
Quality of the voice itself and how well it fit the song? The girl in red has a beautiful voice but I don’t if it would fit an idol career, and I think the other girl ended up fitting this song better
@@annabethyeung8512 yup I agree the red dress girl has amazing voice but I couldn't feel her emotions but the blue dress one literally made me speechless her voice fits better and her emotions too despite the mistake
I think the reason why the one with red dress didn't won is not cuz her voice wasn't clear but it's because she's not good at english so her prononciation isn't right so she's trying to hide her accent. I think both did a wonderful performance and both have beautiful voices
I feel kinda bad since hanbyul technically shouldn’t even be there but the brought her back purely bc she’s minseo rival I feel bad for her, I like both but minseo is low-key robbed
@@ChinXinYing yeah. They want her dad's character. Lol why not get him as a judge then? I feel like he's just overacting and he kinda drains. Like just focus on the kids mnet 🤦♀️
That's not true though, they brought back one person from each eliminated team. She wasn't the only one that was brought back! Minseo was incredible but if you watched the episode and listened to what the judges say you'll understand why she wasn't the one that passed.
@@mbnr7545 ah yea ofc, it just feels sad since they’ve been painted as rivals bc of their past at singing competitions and stuff, I wish they didn’t go against each other so that they could both pass
![[ENG] [3회] 꽃말 - 말리꽃 @장르 TOP 미션#캡틴 | CAP-TEEN EP.3 | Mnet 201203 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fEmLL3U7qfo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG] [3회] 꽃말 - 말리꽃 @장르 TOP 미션#캡틴 | CAP-TEEN EP.3 | Mnet 201203 방송](/img/tr.png)
![[Full version] RIP the stage with "Voice"! Yoon Minseo vs. Kim Kyuri "Love wins all" ♪](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6E1qdIMmSOE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Special Clip] Dreamcatcher(드림캐쳐) Siyeon 'Speechless' (Movie 'Aladdin' OST)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tOBZjPuAKMQ/mqdefault.jpg)
And now 3 years later, Minseo is on "Girls on Fire" and she slayed so hard !!!
HER RIVAL HERE IS IN THE SHOW TOO, BUT ELIMINATED IN EP 3
It's just one crack. Mnet edits like someone was killed
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
Im not surprise HAHAHAH
Flashbacks to that one PeekABoo performance in P48--and Gyuri's crack wasn't even that noticeable.
INDEED
And she hit the highnotes perfectly
둘 다 잘했지만 나는 한별이가 개인적으로 너무 대단하다고 생각함.. 사실 저런 부담감 큰 공연에서 실수하면 멘탈이 정상이 아닐텐데 바로 마음다잡고 다음 파트로 넘어가고, 담담한 모습이 너무 멋있었음.. 나라면 저 상황에서 이미 망했다는 생각으로 어버버타다가 그냥 망했을 거 같아서..
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
아니....... 이둘이 붙여놓으면 남은 한명은 어카냐고.... 둘다 어마어마한 실력잔데
이때 붙여놓았으면 안됐음... 둘 다 파이널 가야했음...
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
@@한별빠 네에에에엡
@@jamiesong1974 이거 결국 누가 올라갓어용?
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
이 무대에서 누군가는 계속 도전을 이어가고 또 누군가는 떠나야하는게 너무 안타깝다 둘 다 노래로는 최고인데 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
@@한별빠 한별님 진짜 노래 너무 잘 부르세요 !!! 꼭 정식으로 데뷔해서 아버님 그리고 한별님의 꿈이 이루어 졌으면 좋겠어요 :) 끝까지 응원 하겠습니다 !!
@@do0mh03 감사합니다 오늘저녁 8시30분 실시간 문자투표 참여좀요
The red dressed girl just killed it as usual she deserves Hollywood i repeat yes Hollywood
@smple amity dude she is a teen...and she has a beautiful voice
@smple amity pls go watch her into the unknown cover
@smple amity the video which u showed was not singing into the unknown and besides into the unknown is full of highnotes and pitch is very important in this song,one wrong note and the whole song is gone,into the unknown is a very hard song.
@smple amity If you're just going to come here to talk shit and not give credit where credit is due, just leave dude
true but i heard she lost :(
김한별이 목소리가 더 선곡에 잘 어울리고 성숙한 느낌인데 윤민서가 더 안정적이고 화음도 더 높게 쌓고 잘 불렀네
경험이 탄탄하니까 화음이 남다른듯
인정
ㅇㅈ
안타깝게 실수는 했지만 저런 큰 무대에서 당황하지않고 바로 다음으로 잘 넘어가서 또 고음 저렇게 안정적으로 지르는게 진짜 대박이다.., 나였음 실수하자마자 질질짜면서 집갔음..,
ㄹㅇ진짜 여기 나온사람은 다 대단함,,,
감사합니다 우리별이 많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
한별이 너무 잘함......진짜 소름돋았음 성량이 장난아니다
심사위원분이 민서님은 뮤지컬같고 한별님은 영화같다고 했는데 마지막 눈빛으로 그게 무슨 느낌인지 한번에 와닿음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
감사합니다
진짜 실수없었으면 전설의 레전든데 편집도 실수부분 너무 비쳐줘서 아쉽다ㅜㅠ
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
2:00 실수한 다음인데 바로 딱 맘 다잡고 넘 잘해서 더 멋있어ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
감사합니다 우리별이 많이 응원해주세요
이승철 심사위원말이 딱 맞음.. 뮤지컬로 볼건가 영화로 볼건가..
이 노래는 영화에서 나온 노래라 한별이가 더 잘어울렸음..ㅜ 민서 넘 아쉽다ㅠ
근데 노래자체는 뮤지컬 스타일같은데요....
@@정의로운세상-v1d 뮤지컬영화니까요..? 영화 OST 이기도 하고 그래서 그런거죠..;
민서님이 성량 감정 강약조절 모두 우위인 것 같은데...
개인적으로 영상 봤을 때 윤민서님은 약간 호소하는 부드러운 분위기고 한별님은 눈빛이 강렬하고 목소리가 미성이라기 보단 단단해서 자스민 노래에 더 어울렸던 것 같음 이 노래 내 최애곡인데 되게 잘 부르셨다
윤민서님 입니다!
@@une2258 고쳤어요! 감사합니다
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
Those two should start performing as a duo. They are so powerful together that it gives me goosebumps
same thoughts but their parents won't get along HAHAHAHA
Dude I dont care about the voice crack this Performance was fire
감사합니다 ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
bbut after the crack the note that she hit still stalbe tho plus the vibrato, just dont mind about it she still sings it georguslyy
I honestly don't know who I would pick if I was in the judge's position. The girl in the red dress sung the song so effortlessly whereas the other girl has more of a unique voice. Although the other girl had a voice crack, she managed to save it with other high notes. Bravo to both of them though.
둘다 아주 예쁜 목소리고 잘했지만
감정을 표현하는거는 김한별님이 잘 하신것같고
무대로 봤었을때는 실수를 하지않았던 윤민서님이
잘하셨고 김한별님은 실수가있었지만 그다음에 바로 높은 고음을 잘 소화하신것같아서
무대 잘봤습니다
감사합니다 우리별이 많이 응원해주세요
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
0:55 가사실수를 했음에도 끝까지 멋진 무대를 보여준 한별이,,너무 멋있어요. 연습을 많이 했는데도 초반 실수를 하게 되면 스스로 무대에 집중이 안되기도 하고 멘탈이 나가게 되는거 누구보다 잘 아는 입장에서 본받고 싶네요!
혹시 누가 탈락 했는지 아세용?..
@@Kihaneul 윤민서님이 탈락하신거로 알고있어요!
@@bu0xng_x 아 갑사합니다^~^
@@bu0xng_x 윤민서양이 탈락한거 맞습니당^^
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
These girls should be singing for disney. They both slayed
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
I also agree
Hanbyul may have had a few mistakes with her voice cracking and some lyrical mistakes but on this performance, I find her tone better, especially during the early part and when they are harmonizing. It's sad to see Minseo go but I trust the judge's decision.
Who won? Red dress?
agree
@@manuela_lb1420 blue dress won
omg where do u watch the full episodes?
I also think that judge’s decision was right. i can see that Hanbyul did make a mistake but it’s not what she wanna do and everyone also. Hanbyul has a very unique voice and can mange her voice nicely from the low tone to the high tone, not forcing her tone. For minseo also did great, but her voice doesn’t seem so good, she can sing high notes and everyone can except that she can make it, but for some ppl like me, i think her voice wasn’t unique like hanbyul, she was trying so hard whenever she sing, up and down with the vocal, but those vocal come to her nose that make the starting or even the low tone sound so deep and ruining the low part of the song.
둘다 솔까 우승후보감인데
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
김한별님은 특히 저음에서 깊이가 느껴지고 윤민서님은 디즈니 뮤지컬 배우처럼 청량하고 동심 찾게하는 그런 음색이 있는거같고 바이브레이션 스타일이랑 너무 잘 어울리는거 같아요!!
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA 감사합니다
여러분진심으로 감사드립니다 그동안 우리별이 많이많이 응원 해주신 모든분들게 진심으로 감사드려요 우리별이 음원 나왔어요 많이많이 사랑해 💚 💕 ❤ 주세요
진짜 한별이만 첨부터 끝까지 밀었어요!! 빨리 대뷔해서 멜론차트 넘어서 빌보드까지 점령했으면 좋겠습니다!
🥳🥳
진짜로 너무잘불러요!!
한별언니 본받고 싶어요..ㅠㅠ진짜로
캡틴 첨부터 한별언니였어요!!ㅠㅠ
빨리효도해드릴수있게
언니!!크게 성공할거예요!!
❤️❤️❤️❤️
진짜 응원해요 !!!!
@@냥냥-j8b 감사합니다
윤민서 떨어진거 너무 아깝.. ㄹㅇ 가장 좋아했는데ㅜ
the judges were right, minseo’s singing is similar to one from a musical and hanbyul’s singing resembles one from a movie. Two different styles but are both so beautiful. I don’t think we should compare because they both are so talented! 🥺❤️
What is the result?
@@밥밥-o4v hanbyul won!
둘다 너무 잘하지만 왜 내 귀엔 민서님 소리가 더 명쾌해서 듣기좋은건지...ㅎㅎ
Now they're both in a show Girl's on fire
For me the girl wearing the red dress suites with theatrical songs, she has a classy and elegant voice. While the girl in the white dress has a open and wide voice range..so her voice (I feel like) suites more to songs that are loved by everyday people.
I feel like they both are friends in real life judging by the part where Hanbyul voice cracked. I feel like Minseo was caught off guard by Hanbyul's voice crack and was a bit unstable at her part. If they were a rival, I don't think Minseo would have made it way better when her rival is at a downfall.
Btw, I love both. And it is sad to see Minseo eliminated but happy at the same time when the judge chose Hanbyul.
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA ㅜㅜ
Minseo was like that overpowered character in an anime series that dies early cause she was so overpowered.
둘다 성량이 미쳤다...ㄷㅇ
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
Hanbyul's voice fits the song better. However, her voice cracked and made mistakes. Besides that, damn, her voice is really amazing. Meanwhile, Minseo sang perfectly although not as impactful as the other because her voice does not suit really well to the song. I feel bad. I was rooting for SOPA girl. :(( Huhuhu
둘다 쥰내 잘한다... 소름돋앙
아니 진짜... 이어폰 풀사운드로 틀어놨다가 연속으로 쫘라락 소름돋음... 근데 소리 줄이고 싶지 않았음 ㄹㅇ
감사합니다 우리별이 많이 응원해주세요
The blue girl hits the low note so well, you can compare
민서 진자 신기하다.. 하관도 작고 체구도 작은데 저 성량을 어디서 뽑아내는지
진짜.... 김한별의 최고 레전드 무대라 할 수 있음 나 진짜 본방 보면서 눈물 찔끔했음 ㅠㅠ 너무 잘 해...
감사합니다 ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
@@한별빠 예전부터 팔로우 했었어요!! 감사합니다 화이팅 ~.~
Literally this is the hardest song someone can sing, both did great. I got goosebumps I love this song, is very powerful.
한별님 목소리를 들으면 제 기분이 좋아지네요☺️ 언제나 힘내세요✨💗
하 둘다 너무 잘한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ근데 민서 너무 예쁜데??????
김한별씨노래개잘하네
감사합니다
아니 왜 저 둘을... 둘다 떨어지지마ㅠ 둘다 올라가ㅠㅠ 사랑해 민서한별🥺✨🧚🏿♀️🌸🦋
People be comparing these two, when they can be a duo if ever. They're good individually but hearing them together is amazing.
Minseo’s voice is more effortless and therefore will sound more floaty and glorious on live stages like musicals, but Minseo’s voice is a bit rougher, more unique, and emotional, putting her in a better place when it comes to recorded voices where not everything will come through live. It may not pierce as much on live stages, but it will sound better through the TV.
So am I
2:24 That girl gave me chills when she hits that high note! 0_0 Her voice sounds so unique to be honest!
About the other girl from the right side, Even though she made a few mistakes but she still carries on with her singing and it sounds good and pleasant
난 개인적으로 윤민서님이 감정표현부터 넘사벽으로 잘한다고 생각하는데 댓글에 김한별님 칭찬이 많네 취향이 이렇게 다르다니 신기하당..
저더 개인적으로 윤민서님이용 ㅎㅎ
저두요
둘다 잘하시는듯영ㅇ
tabi ki de minseo
@보스베이비 생긴걸로 판단 하면ㄴ 안됨 ㅋㅋ...
영상 내내 소름 돋음 ,,
이게 어떻게 고딩이야 ,,
The both have amazing beautiful voices but even if the voice of the blue girl dress cracked she's my favourite she sings with such an emotion.
I also root on the hanbyul so much emotions
Yes i support your opinions.... everyone's Can sing .... But with unique/wide voice......
WE CALL IT 'GIFT' SO DONT WASTE IT JUDGES?!???!??
@@az._.928 i think she won
Same
I liked her voice & I felt bad for her when her voice cracked
Did she win?
@@lolololo-rf6qm Yes, she did win
진짜 레전드 영상이다.....내가 진짜 이거 몇번을 보고있냐?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
*They both have such a beautiful and powerful voices especially the girl with red dress 💗 her voice fits perfectly with the song 👏 but I feel bad for the girl with blue dress when her voice is cracking ☹️*
한별님 노래 너무 잘 부르세요ㅜㅜㅜㅜ솔로가수로 하셔도 엄청 인기 많으실 것 같고 아버님도 옆에서 적극적으로 꿈 이뤄줄려는 모습도 보기 좋았습니다. 문자 투표도 꾸준히 했었는데 개인채널도 생기시고 저가 다 뿌듯합니다!! 보물보다 더 귀한 목소리를 갖고계신 한별님 앞으로 좋은 모습 많이 보여주세요 😍😍
Idk but I really love the red/brown girl because it has own style
몰라 다 모르겠고 둘다 솔로로 데뷔하면 둘다 잘됄듯 얼굴도 이쁜데 둘다 실력도 좋음..
ruclips.net/channel/UC4V7IY_7WKzRvTJnmD5ABXg 감사합니다 ㅠㅠㅠ
The girl in the blue dress was singing well until she dodged or but despite her mistake she continued to sing super well and I feel that her tone of voice is unique
난 김한별이 내스탈이당..!!왜냐면 스피크리스 자체가 얇은 목소리가 안어울리는데 김한별은 굵게 맞게 잘 부르고 실수했는데도 마음다잡고!!대박
I don't know man, Minseo is a phenomenal singer but her voice isn't that special tbh and neither are her performances, just your typical musical actress I feel like. That doesn't take away from her amazing talent obviously.
But Hanbyul, despite having a few mistakes here and there she conveyed the emotions a lot better and her voice is quite unique, she needs to either choose songs more suited for her range though or she should practice her high notes more. Overall I would choose Hanbyul too, her voice fits the song better and she brought the song to life tbh by her performance. She understands the song better and you can tell.
They're both incredible and I hope they both hit big.
wait who is minseo and who is hanbyul
@@gjh3646 thank youuu :)
@@gjh3646 nope. Minseo is the one in the red dress and Hanbyul in blue dress. Their names is on the top of the lyrics they are singing
@@Zainab-sx3yd i take it back I got it wrong sorry😅
@@kristianfelix882 sorry I read it at the wrong time I’m so embarrassed 😩😓
이거... 선택은 어뜨케 ㅠㅠㅠ 둘다 너무 잘하는데 ㅠㅠ
1:47 한별 삑사리 나서ㅠㅠㅠ
김한별이 붙음
@@최유정-l5r 윤민서가 더 잘했는데..
감사합니다 우리별이 많이많이 응원해주세요 하루에한번씩 투표좀 부탁드려요
내가 좋아하는 음색은 한별인데 왠지 모르게 민서가 더 눈길이 가고 더 잘하는듯 느껴지네...그래도 한별 음색이 더 취향저격이긴 하다
뭔가가 진심으로 노래하는게 아닌것 같은 느낌같음
한별님 민서님 두분 다 너무너무 잘 부르시는데 잘하는 인재들이 너무너무 많다보니까 개성이 있는 분을 뽑은거 같아요. 민서님 같은 가창력을 갖고 계신분들은 많지만 한별님 같은 음색을 갖고 계신분은 많이 안 계시니까요. 실력은 연습으로 커버가 되지만 매력이나 음색은 자기스타일을 타고 태어나는 거니까 그런 것 같아요. 그리고 선곡자체가 한별님이 더 잘 어울리셔서 그런것도 있는 듯 하네요
감사합니다
Minseo singing that high notes so quiet is a really technical advanced move not many can do. most just shout out high notes because its easier. but singing them so sonft ist damn impressive
와 진짜 뭐야,,,,,,,,,,, 아니,,,,,, 평가 무대가 아닌데,,,,, 너무 잘한다,,,,,,,
둘 다 오디션 볼 실력이 아닌데..? 데뷔하고도 남을 실력임 학생이잖아.. 근데 저 정도면 미래가 너무 밝은데? 눈부셔
Hanbyul improved !! Her voice cracked but I was more touched by her emotions expressed here
윤민서는 가수도좋지만 뮤지컬배우하면 대박일듯 감정이 장난아니네..
hope both of girls will success in the future...they still young...they're future for next gen main vocal....their voice is so good...
너무 잘했다 스킬풀하다 정말
나중에 와 곡 하나 써주면 고퀄 나올듯
Hanbyul is really good, I just hope her father will stop stressing her, also Idk why I liked it when her voice cracked, the sound was kind of nice
The effortless Minseo voice make me goosebumps, her voice like shattering my heart. They both had a good technic while singing. Hanbyeol have a power in her voice. It create a beautiful harmony.
I was rooting for these 2 to compete each other. Minseo's voice is incredible, however, Han Byul has more emotions and unique voice. I really want to hear Minseo singing Disney songs ❤. They're both awesome. But this is a conpetition, 1 has to go.
I think the girl with red dress voice really fit solo
내 개인적 취향은 윤민서님인데 김한별님이 자스민의 의지를 더 잘 표현한신듯
검은 머리 소녀 😍😍
I got the chills!! How would you eliminate the one that sang without mistakes? I mean wth are they judging then
Idk since the auditions they've been letting those who make obv mistakes pass. It's kinda disrespectful to those who practiced so much to make their performances perfect
Ikr it so unfair tho😭
Quality of the voice itself and how well it fit the song? The girl in red has a beautiful voice but I don’t if it would fit an idol career, and I think the other girl ended up fitting this song better
@@annabethyeung8512 yup I agree the red dress girl has amazing voice but I couldn't feel her emotions but the blue dress one literally made me speechless her voice fits better and her emotions too despite the mistake
it might be because of the tone difference
한별님은 가수같고 민서님은 뮤지컬 배우같음 둘다 너무 잘하는데 둘이 붙여놓다니 너무했다고 생각해 엠넷....
감사합니다
Both blue and red dress girl is so good 😊😊
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA ㅠㅠㅠ
@@한별빠 유튜브 채널 이름 주셔서 감사드립니다😊😊
its okyy if she cracked..but the end she really hit tht hard highnote than the low high note where she cracked..i stan her!!!😩😩😩😩💗💗💗🔥🔥🔥
Technically Minseo is better, but Hanbyul conveys the feelings better... Hard to choose
Actuallt, that was the opposite before this show.
Minseo voice sounds like Elsa singing Speechless
I think the reason why the one with red dress didn't won is not cuz her voice wasn't clear but it's because she's not good at english so her prononciation isn't right so she's trying to hide her accent. I think both did a wonderful performance and both have beautiful voices
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
Yoon min seo is so beautiful. Who end here after watch funtastic duo "vibe" yoon min soo x yoon min seo when she still junior high school
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
It’s sad to see Minseo go especially since she was my favorite
They both gave an amazing performance. But to be honest,i like the voice of the lady in blue dress more.
별이는 틀별한 음성 ...정말 많은펜들에 세게적으로 성공하길 기대하구요;;꼭 더 듣고싶읍니다
감사합니다 ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
캡틴처음보는데 민서가 그
sbs노래경연에서 다시와주라 같이부른 그 중학생아닌가 헉 그때진짜노래잘했는데 벌써다컸네
헐 대박... 나도 그 생각했는데
어린나이에 정말 대단해요 보면서 소름돋고 눈물 흘렸어요 앞으로 앞날이 기대됩니다 항상 응원할께요🥰
The red dressed girl have a good voice!
they're vocally way better than the judges, I must say!
둘다잘한다...ㄷㄷ
The red dress is very amazing voice since she sing into the unknown its very beautiful and she's like a Disney princess ❤
The red dressed girl just killed she indeed is incredible
Ikr but she being eliminated😭
@@lilmandu6934 what? But HER VOICE IS ✨CHEF KISS✨
@@Ririnthemoon IKR the blue dress girl win
@@lilmandu6934 thats fuckin unfair
@@lilmandu6934 bruh that red girl sang so effortlessly yet they eliminated her? Wtf mnet
둘다 너무 잘했다 진짜
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
민서님 판타스틱듀오 바이브편에 나온 사람인가?? 그때도 잘했는데 너무 잘하시네 성량도 대박
보는 내내 소름 돋아 너무 멋있다 저 둘
감사합니다
I feel kinda bad since hanbyul technically shouldn’t even be there but the brought her back purely bc she’s minseo rival I feel bad for her, I like both but minseo is low-key robbed
REALLY??? .... This is crazy
@@ChinXinYing yeah. They want her dad's character. Lol why not get him as a judge then? I feel like he's just overacting and he kinda drains. Like just focus on the kids mnet 🤦♀️
@@繁栄恵 mnet like to stir things up..
That's not true though, they brought back one person from each eliminated team. She wasn't the only one that was brought back! Minseo was incredible but if you watched the episode and listened to what the judges say you'll understand why she wasn't the one that passed.
@@mbnr7545 ah yea ofc, it just feels sad since they’ve been painted as rivals bc of their past at singing competitions and stuff, I wish they didn’t go against each other so that they could both pass
hate that they repeated the mistake part..
ruclips.net/channel/UCIFtigV0O-aHz1Cu9M4etuA
우왕ㅇ 한별이 아버님!!!
@@한별빠 i just visited her channel and omg her covers are amazing!!! ❤
This is pretty common i still remember how they did gyuri dirty in pd48
윤서언니는 뮤지컬하는거 같다😶💖
멍때리고 봤잖아 소름😱
Here after seeing Miseo's performance in GOF
이 노래 정말 너무 잘불렀어요
너무 너무 듣기 좋네요~
me: *SPEECHLESS*
god theyre crazy talented