Why Big Dairy Companies Struggle In India
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 июл 2019
- With its dairy-heavy diet of curries and yogurt drinks, India seemed a likely place for the French dairy company Danone to find success when it entered the country in 2011. But by 2018, Danone ceased operations of its Indian dairy division.
India is the world's top producer and consumer of dairy - in 2018 alone, the country's 75 million dairy farmers produced 410 billion pounds of milk, about 22% of global production. With this and its dairy-heavy diet of curries and yogurt drinks, the giant French dairy company Danone hoped to find success in the country, opening its own production line in 2011.
This division failed to account for more than 10% of its sales in India, the vast majority instead coming from its 'specialized nutrition' segment. Analysts say that India's highly localized, fractured dairy industry confounded Danone, a company accustomed to the relatively more consolidated dairy industries of the US and its native France.
Moreover, Danone isn't the only large dairy producer that's had trouble in the Indian market. Indian companies like Amul and Mother Dairy and multinational companies like Nestle have less than an estimated 10% of overall market share despite being in the company much longer than Danone.
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
» Subscribe to CNBC Classic: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCclassic
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
#CNBC
Why Big Dairy Companies Struggle In India
Why do foreign dairy companies fail in India?
-"Amul doodh peeta hai India."
Oh good god ... Dave thing struck my mind 🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂🙏
True😀😀
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
😂😂😂😂
They tried to *sell milk to the people who have a cow :-)*
😂😂
Exactly 😂
😂😂😂
And make yogurt themselves.
LMAO!
Why Apple fails in India
Why Netflix fails in India
Why big dairy companies fail in India
My recommendation for next video: Why CNBC fails in India
😁🤣🤣🤣🤣
Apple fails in India because Apple is too expensive and Indians prefer Value for Money.
Netflix failed in India because its Content is different from our Society thinking and useless for us.🙄
Netflix failed in india ? I think they doing pretty well actually.
@Black War ig they loosing to homegrown ott platforms
@Black War idk where u live but where I am smaller ott platforms like aha and Sun tv and many more are also famous those mostly have south indian movies and are extremely cheap.
It is as simple as:-
Why would I purchase packaged milk when someone is milking a cow right in front of me.
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
@@maheshwarbehera9590 I'm too poor and can't afford the alternatives so no thanks I'll stick to milk.
@@amoghus Today you can't afford the alternatives ! Tomorrow the Earth couldn't afford you. Anyway it will get rid of all of us one day with in decades.
Before even trying to know if it's really expensive or the milk is the one which is expensive as hell !!? You said you can't afford. But in long run most people can't afford hospital bills so anyway you can't save anything. Instead Cruelty free options are better and have all the nutrients and literally saves ourselves from lifestyle diseases as well. Just the fact is people are ignorant about what's going on and want taste and fun in life !! That's it.
It's a complete myth that alternatives are expensive. As I'm Vegan and an Indian I save tons of money annually. And I'm fittest and healthiest ever.
@@maheshwarbehera9590 no it isn’t, link your facts lol
@@maheshwarbehera9590 indians can become Vegetarian, not Vegans.
*Well you are bound to fail if you sell GEE instead of GHEE.*
Hiccup because it sounds like a PEE
loo
Lol
🤣🤣🤣🤣 yeah man
yea they should pronounce it as EGCHEE
So local farmers beat a multinational corporation.
Only in India
That's power of a common man in India
good. fk foreign companies
It happens only in India 😂😂😂
you are too dumb to see that ! multinational corporations worked in China , bigger than India , and look China SKIPED industrialization , straight from medieval to modern and we Indians are too self centered locally , even big corporations failed to introduce modern ways , better quantity ( for Indian population ) and better quality and more reliability and of course JOBSS ! , we still live in dark ages in some countries in means of educations or opportunities
This is why India failed to be new China for manpower or for business , and our economy is not big as Chinese nor in GDP PPP or in Per capita
@@mitesh2k3 More like Ignorance
That good old love between western media and old Delhi's old pictures is stronger than that of Romeo and Juliet.
@Patrick Baptist still a whole documentry on us you lose your credibility there
@Patrick Baptist then why do you click in a vedio of India if you are not interested?
@Patrick Baptist from what i have seen indians are obsessed with trashing almost every documentary about using certain music and certain places.
@Patrick Baptist but that picture is still relevant to this day
I have been there
@@drinkwoter It happens when certain music and certain pictures that show a place in a bad light are used again and again. For example, I don’t like when someone uses pictures of abandoned factories when they show Detroit, it is wrong and misleading to a certain extent.
MAKE a Video called: Why CNBC is Struggling in India?
Edit: tq for 703 likes
Now 23
Cheers lool
Cheers
64
Now 110 +1 =111
@Shweta K V soja bhai 😁
CNBC is even beating BBC in terms of old stock photos of India.
Ha ha ha ha
Remo Kiltol true!
Remo Kiltol the most epic comment ever 😂
Best burn I have seen in a while
They are not old stock photos.... they are using stock footage from 2017-2019. So its not old.
Amul is an Emotion which Companies from other Country won't understand.
*Amul doodh peeta hai India* ❤️
Even when my family owns a cow.This song...I remember in a heartbeat.
@@vishakhasaini3422 Amul is all north. Gawd you forget us deep south indians a lot.
@@varali915 , It is fine if you don't use the product. I don't either even if I am from north, I just like the song. Brings lots of childhood memories.
True
Yeah no
0:33 buffaloes chilling after destroying Danone & nestle.
🤣🤣
Lmao 😂
😂😂😂
*THE VICTORY BATH*
It's like opening barber shop in Pakistan to shave their beards.
Or in Punjab.
@@admiralgeneralAladeen chup
Updated the Channel Name recently?
Ur so racist and not all men have beards here actually if u look into it
Stop being so racist. Not all of us wear beards.
Looks like Danone didn't hear the slogan
*Amul doodh peeta hei india* 😂
😂🤣
And also Mother Dairy
@@YTworld-69 it's popular but that much compared to Amul
Kyuki
Amul doodh peeta hei india😂
😂😂😂😂✌💪
😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣
Everytime they show old Delhi to represent India.
Then I think you should show ghettos in New York to represent US
@Science Geek Fool's don't understand the real point
@Science Geek bhai point toh smj yr😂
@@rajk.9098 bhai point nhi smj paaya science geek
Newyork is only represented by ‘time square’ idk why Indians getting freaked out of it, also there is no place called ‘old delhi’. There is ‘Delhi’ and there is ‘New Delhi’. What they shown is that not part of india ? Or is that part we are ashamed of or something? Instead of improving that part which is shown in the video we talking about now showing it at all, so turning your head on something you dont like is not going to make it go away
Yes, you are right, it's an old habit of western media. They will show the same chaotic image of old Delhi even when talking something positive about India.
Living in india all my life and never heard of this brand also...😂😂
In South India, people prefer local govt owned diary companies. Other than amul cheese and butter, people don't buy anything from Amul.
@@vivekjkumar5797 I live in Maharashtra we take milk from local gaushalas not from govt owned but yeah we buy cheese, butter, shrikhand all of these and mostly prefer amul.. because we prefer A2 milk. And by south india means where? Which state excatly?
@@vivekjkumar5797 good for them i guess 🤷🏻♂️
@@vivekjkumar5797 every state does that , south is not some special place , punjab has verka haryana has vita , rajasthan has saras
I wish india can be so efficient in other sectors too. Feeling proud of Amul!
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
because milk sector have not MSP
we do milk bussiness on contract basis .
thats why its flourishing .
but other primary sector dont have contract bussiness
they have MSP on agri products thats why they only remain confine to MSP.
Depend on govt .
never tried to sell their product as we do milk bussiness .
now ,fortunately modi govt has order that we can sell product to other sellers also rather than mandis
its good thing .
I am producing products on the basis of demand in India and foreign .and selling to small coorporates and industries who uses these products as a raw material .
@Lightning Muhking govt already agreed on giving court access
India can be self sufficient in a other sector also but problem is with farmers and with food storage management.
Farmers overproduce some crops on which they get high MSP like Wheat. Every year Wheat overproduction causes problems while storage other problem with food management. Every year tonnes of crops get spoil but still many indian sleeping hungry because of poor management.
@@maheshwarbehera9590 trueee
Nice to hear that hundreds of local companies profit instead of one big international corporation
that is also a very good point. the food market is held by small enterprises which is good thing. however it is also true that the large informal economy is a stumbling block to our overall development.
Even better
It's millions of local farmers profiting instead of a corporation
@@blokin5039 And? You think a corporate cashing in on all their hard earned profit would have been better?
After that
Why India fails in everything.
@@brajeshsingh2391 it doesn't, that was the point of entire white revolution..
I was busy studying for my exams which I failed twice😅 and now I am watching how big dairy companies are struggling in INDIA.
Don't worry, dude. You're not alone. I've failed in 3 subjects in two sems.
Seriously need to study this sem. 😃
Same situation 😂😂
to all who have failed
*RISE AND GRIND FELLAS*
Depends on the grade.
If you are in lower class ( middle school ) then chill
"Amul doodh peeta hai India"(slogan of Amul) which means "India drinks Amul's Milk".
Not the whole India, mostly the poor who can't afford their own cows.
@@Maddcat1979 according to you rich people doing dairy farming...😆🤣🤣🤣
@@chahatpatel7337 it's not about rich or poor
Mostly who have vast lands or less land doesn't matter
Who belongs to farming and stuff
They usually do this and we should respect them for providing milk and feeding us
@@Maddcat1979 dude only urban people drink amul milk mostly. lol you can't sell milk to a dairy farmer lol
@@Maddcat1979 lol I am an middle class and drink Amul doodh with Almonds it's not about poor
How would you know a country when you don’t know it’s correct map
Yesss somebody said it
I am checking all the comments to find anyone commented about our map
How's it wrong?
It's correct..
Disputed states aren't included
Its the correct map, India doesnt have de facto control over areas it claims and the map taught in school
@Rohit Tiwari there is no such thing, government records mein jaake pata karlo ki line of control kya hai jammu mein. Humein school mein jo map sikhate hain wo galat hai. Pakistan ki ek poori state hai gilgit baltistan naam ki jo "correct map" (tere hisabse) mein india ke andar hai. India kya territory claim karta hai aur kya territory govern karta hai yeh do alag cheezein hoti hain, apni national pride ke chakkar mein andhe hone ka koi faeda nhi hai.
Jis territory ko tu india ka bata raha hai waha se pakistan aur china ke beech ka national highway jata hai, karakoram highway naam ka.
Aur agar yeh propoganda lag raha hai toh kabhi vpn daalke google maps pe check karlena😂😂, pakistan ke vpn pe alag dikhaega, india ke vpn pe alag, china ke vpn pe alag. USA ka vpn daalke dekhlena ki india kitna area control karta hai aur bachpan se tu gadha hi banke baitha hai😂😂
No, Indians don't eat creamy curries daily, in fact most parts of india never eat them, they are just remenants of Mughal Royal kitchen.
India consumes milk mostly in its raw form, in the form of clarified butter, yoghurt and others, most of these products are home-made.
I bet most of the outsiders don't even know how powerful is real ghee
Vishal V. Navekar the word “no indians don’t eat creamy curries daily” mean every indian eat creamy curry
@@muhammadrayhan6958 he meant ' No, Indians don't eat ....'
oh. i see
I’m Indian can confirm
I'm living in a tier 3 city in India and trust me people here don't consider buying packaged milk daily. they think that it's not that much nutritional and healthy.
instead we have small milkmans based in city who supplies milk daily on a motorcycle or recently they are opening small stores within the neighbourhood.
to me this method is far more sustainable.
my family themselves buy milk from a farmer which is milked from cows couple of hours before it's delivered to us and it tastes so much wholesome and better than the packaged ones.👍
that's the reason they struggle
packaged milk lacks *TASTE*
Bro,u serious!?people usually buy packed milk in city's mainly amul❤
@@shivam.mishra7300 not everywhere.
@@alborg4607 In my home Mother dairy milk comes and i think its really good.
You're living in fools paradise. I have seen milkman mixing tap water with milk gazillion times. I don't remember the last time I bought milk from local vendors.
@tzarbg123 purchasing milk from local farmers is the best and sustainable approach. in processing of milk by companies most of the nutrients and cream is lost
You showed wrong map of India, this is not a mistake. That's also a problem with
You people and a reason why your businesses fail. you should respect feelings of other people.
It's actually the correct map ... Stop getting butthurt
@@plowe6751 removed half kashmir and laddakh
@@rooplekhahazarika2191 How is that the correct map weirdo. You support the terrorist and communist regimes?!!
I am reporting this.
Yes... Ladakh and half of kashmir is not there..... They did not go to geography classes ig
It should be renamed as "why foreign dairy companys are struggling in india"
Haryana-A state in western India.🤣🤣
CNBC skipped geography classes.
@@gaurav0narwal north India
Yeah they’re right northwest of India
They are right
@@Rohandutt what's north then mate ?
Is that GOT effect that now only Winterfell to be called North🤣🤣🤣🤣
0:33 buffaloes chilling after destroying every goddamn multinational company selling dairy products . Thug life lol🤣🤣
😂😂 superrr s uperrrrr
That's India dude 🤗🤗😌😌😌
भाई....प्रणाम ले तू..... दिल जीत लिया....
Their milk is very thick and tasty compared to cow milk don't know y
@@rajeev188 it's also tastes good and more health. Yes may be not suitable for city people. Consume it before exercise.
Danone: We gonna come india
Amul : Amul dooth peetha he india
Game over
When i tell my milkman to stop delivering milk because he's putting a lot of water in it ..he refused and says I'm giving milk in this house before you were born... And i will continue it.
Sometimes it's not about business it's about emotions
If he wants to continue his business maybe he should stop watering it down then.
Just because he has been serving your house for years pits you under no obligation to continue with his services is it's not good.
We changed our 22 year old milk man 2 years ago and the milk quality improved a lot for just a bit higher price.
He's a scammer, if it was anything to do with emotion and honor he wouldn't scam you. This isn't how you make a living, he needs to learn to act properly and that these untruthful practices won't benifit him in the long term
@@tourmelion9221 atleast they add only water not preservatives and chemicals
private companies only work to make money and the don't work for farmers while co-operative like AMUL work for farmers who are also the owners.
Yes. But that's not to say a private company couldn't work to provide ethically and environmentally sourced food.
i think if india did not have this one strong tradition in place, they would have swallowed the country whole with their industrial packaged stuff. to me this clip is music to my ears . now how do we introduce old traditions back in this country is mystery to me.
Everyone can't be a farmer or your society won't ever advance as they will be to busy doing that. Just like every 1st world country when they learned how to mass farm their encomy grew very fast.
its because of private that dairy survived , and your so called coperatives install plant at much higher cost , sell b2b products at a subsidise rates in which actually private dairies are working and sell mass products at higher rates
if there is equal rights to private and cooperatives then farmer will win and consumer will win
Jubsy Saddinger Is that so? Well we house almost 20% of world’s population, are the cases of communal violences really more than fifth of the ones reported worldwide? Stop watching those propagandas from British media outlets.
Thanks to Dr. Verghese Kurien the dairy sector in india is free from foreign corporations.
is cow one of your god ?
@@user-xi2zt8jx3g nope,cow is considered as a sacred symbol
@@user-xi2zt8jx3g we consider cows as our mother.
@@kman6520 no, we dont
@@user-xi2zt8jx3g as said in video, Cows are common animal in India , we used to treat like pet animal eg. Dog , there attachment with them , there is worshipping part also.
I am from a tier 3 city in Maharashtra and which has one of the the biggest dairies (Gokul) in MH, yet when my daughter just started drinking milk it was from a "Gauli" or a local farmer. Trust me the fat accumulated would make heaps of curd, butter and ghee.
Best milk ever - sourced locally
I am the daughter of a nuclear family where both parents worked. My mom never made yogurt at home. But we knew best yogurt or ghee wasn't the packaged one, but those available in local halwai.
Most of the packed yogurt filled with excessive sugar.🤮
@@infinitebeing1119 Is it? If you really mean yogurt then yes, because yogurt is supposed to have sugar. It's a sweet dish.
But dahi doesn't. Even packaged dahi doesn't contain sugar as far as my experience goes.
If u sell me "gee" when i ask for "ghee" then obviously i won't disturb u again 😂😂
Lol😂😂😂
Lol
😂
?
It’s better sounding than Vegan, gluten free, organic Muhng Dahl Bowl…
CNBC kindly correct the map it’s not complete 😡
yeah bro i also noticed that
yes rights we also noticed.
Yes
Its correct bro...at that time article 370 was active so that kashmir part was not available as bussiness portion .
@@Arun_hog whatever it may be but we want the correct image should represent India
We have our own local milk producers, i don't want to drink company chemicals.
2:04 oh hello u r showing the wrong indian flag yall being such big organization with these kind of silly mistakes shame on you
that's a disputed region maybe that's why
What! what do u mean, some bodies land provoking by some one and telling its not ur land, its an disputed area. What are u teliing u stud
It's not flag it's map 🗺️
Its the correct map we Indians should accept this at this point
Showing indian map in wrong way is good way to attract fund from leftist and separatist. Understand there problem. Money and power is what they need ,no matter how many die or displace.
Haryana is western state of india?? which india map is your team looking at :P
Probably martian
Technically it's north western
It's in north india
they asked for a pre-partition draft from the raj era, clearly
East-Up map. they're lookin at the map sideways.
This is definitely a big WIN for India. More countries should realize that these evil corporations are up to no good, and keep them away by forming commercial alliances between small and local farms.
That’s how we do it here in Denmark as well, and we still have farm fresh milk in all our supermarkets, delivered daily and no more than 12-18 hours old when hitting the shelves.
Very true Thomas. Ofcourse there's Scandinavia's help in this case. Most of the cows that are milked in India are hybrids from your side of the world. Lately there has been increasing trend towards Indian cow breeds under organic dairying which give way better nutritional value but lower yield. Perhaps it will take longer time. But ppl in India are changing slowly and steadily and want a healthy lifestyle.
@@vinaykrishna8454 I didn't know about that, thanks for enlightening me!
Yea we do see the same trends here in Scandinavia, where organic produce is becoming more and more popular. Most grocery stores have even put a ban on cage eggs, and conditions for livestock are generally improving as well. Now we can buy free range meat almost anywhere, and fish is getting more popular as well.
Believe me, when I say this: The evil corporation do everything to change their image towards "healthier" products, but it's still the same crap they're selling. Basically they take a product, process it in order to raise profit margins, and resell it in a much lower quality than if it was bought as raw produce and processed in people's homes.
@@Thomas-lk5cu hope ppl understand this...that the big companies are here to make just profit and not serve ppl good product for what they charge. I can give u a small example here... While I was living in country side during my childhood days, we used get fresh milk from the milkmen who had max 5 cows...his family used to supply the milk within a square km and we would make weekly payments to them. This way everyone was happy. right now I live in Bangalore (it's a big metro and IT n start-up capital of India) and the milk we get here is sourced from small farmers through co-op societies to One of the biggest milk producer co-ops in India under brand Nandini. Yes they use all the latest tech and hygienic methods to store it for nearly 2 days. But they don't taste the way fresh milk do. Karnataka, my state is milk surplus by more than 2 million litres per day. While the demand is 6 million litres per day. Imagine the scale and number of dairy units to process and produce different kinds of products. Even the state govt provides subsidy for these ppl involved dairying and they get a decent for the produce. In way farmers are happy and consumers to an extent coz of the quality of milk and it's products. But there are other Pvt companies who have been caught with adulteration and using hazardous chemicals to process and store milk for longer time....but they stil continue to operate coz of nexus among politicians. This where ppl around the world need to understand that organic farming is a must for us to have better quality of life. So many examples of farmers using agro forestry method to produce and make good money. Natural in every way.
@@Thomas-lk5cu Yes it's true, we have 3 buffalos and we make yogurt, buttermilk, butter etc at home, sometimes ice-cream also at home, and if we have extra milk than we sell it . But we also have another reasons for we keep livestock, one important reason is for menure(natural fertilizer), we are farmer we need fertilizer every year and buying fertilizer from market is expensive. so we have 3 reasons for keep livestock .1. For home consumption 2. For fertilizer 3. We can make money from selling extra milk after home consumption. So it's important
it's the culture lol its not that deep
Having your own supply within your residence or neighborhood is such an asset to go by during lockdown #ccpvirus
I had no idea epigamia was Indian, I literally buy like 20 packets every week😂
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
@@maheshwarbehera9590 so cow drink that water or what??
@@prakshijain6861 the maintenance of shed ! The food mixture , cleaning of the filth created in farms etc not only that ! But also the fresh water pollution caused by this.
But let's imagine we have enough water but still the forced artificial insemination , dehorning , calf seperation , use of antibiotics and oxytocin etc. Are painful enough to make our gau mata go through intense labour each year for maximum milk yield. Where a cow could naturally live upto 26 years. Today the excessive demand for milk has lead to death of cows as early as 6 to 7 years.
Last but not the least ! Have you ever imagined where do those billions of cows go after serving us her milk and what about those male calves who can't give milk but take birth in the process?! Yeah sadly India is 2nd largest beef exporter in the world being a majorly hindu country.
We think people of other religions are killing the cows. But no ! They are the same cows whom weren't capable of giving us milk and illegally ended up to slaughter for maximum profit by extracting beef and leather. Milk is very important part of Indian cuisine. From sweets , bread , biscuits , many recipes , health drinks , tea , coffee , chocolates etc we don't use milk just for health ( which is a myth because today we consume mostly hormone injected milk and those desi cows are very rare )
ruclips.net/video/FIkG0wr5fh8/видео.html
@Gaurav Thakur 8025 learn to build some patience in life and have etiquettes !! Your "ffs" won't do any good to the world. You don't even have patience to completely write down "for fcuk's sake".
It's easy to say criticize other's until the wave starts hitting you personally. Wait till then !! Ohhh sorry but you don't have patience so be prepared for the worst. Good luck 😏
This is how economy should work...
Locally..
That's good for the whole ecosystem....
Not really, no.
as Indian , NO NOPE NOOOO !!
@@zuboy4272 what makes you say that?
But with increased quality.
@@narenderbadoni6670 Food safety concerns
Rename the title as 'Why Danone is failing in India'
Lmao true, Americans think if their brand isn't working in india the entire industry is fractured 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
@@maheshwarbehera9590 you're crazy or what? Cows/buffalos don't drink 600 litres of water and still they give like 5-6 litres of milk everyday🤺
@@shreyanksurve8100 Do you use water only for drinking ?! No ! Right. Only 8 glasses of water is sufficient for a day. But you can't ignore the water you flush , you bath , you wash clothes , washing vegetables etc and the list goes on. When a single person uses lots of gallons of water each day ! Can you imagine billions of cattles not only drink water but also we need tonnes of litres water just for cleaning their filth and maintaining it. Not only that when billions of animals are killed like fish , cows , chickens , pigs etc each day all over the planet and creating a huge toxic waste dump made of animal parts and that requires enormous amount of water for sure to clean the mess. Human demand for milk and meat is so high that it's creating havoc on earth and animal farming is the biggest reason for deforestation and global warming and they consume more than 78% of our agricultural produce to grow up so that humans could eat them. The list goes on....... STOP ANIMAL CRUELTY !! ruclips.net/video/dSjE8xw_-Dg/видео.html
@@maheshwarbehera9590 you are wrong we indian do not use water to clean filth because most of us have 2 or 3 cattle whose filth collected by hand and dumped in to fields and use it as manure and second cattles have no clothes and they do not bath on daily basis. I lived in my village half of my life and I know that a normal cow drink 40 ltrs of water in a day and gives an average of 8 ltrs of milk whole year we can use there filth as manure and for biogas and we love them.
06:30 People's minset gets changed as soon their life style changes due to landing on corporates for jobs.
As long we make our own food products from raw food sources, our health will be great.
Skipping our traditions means loosing our lives.
Never ever change Indian culture and we Indians never give up Our culture
Then why is Maggi so popular?
Reason...
Me - 1ltr milk Amul or motherdairy
Shopkeeper - I have Denon
Me - F##k off m going to next shop
100% Right
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nandini is way better. I skip the shop if they don't have Nandini.
I love Nandini Mysore pak and mango lassi 😋
200% accurate!
This happens when you enter market just because of the numbers instead of solid market research!
This is the truth.
Sorta like trump voters
@@reenukeeves3247 Touche😂😂
@@reenukeeves3247 yup.
agree
danoneee
should have a better name
Nobody can mess with Indian dairy company AMUL
It's more than a emotion here 😂
Half the businesses fail in India due to our moms 💕
Hope people realise their contribution in our economy some day....
Well my father is a Milkman in Guwahati,Assam. hilarious to watch video 😂
When i retire im planning to sell milk.
Same Bhai ma bhi retirement ka baas dairy best ha .
@@venuvenu2719 Han Bhai Job Toh Milney Say Rahi Pokada Bech Na Hard Hai Toh Yahi Karta Hun Dairy Wala Business
@@kanyewest7067 this not joke.
@@kanyewest7067 tu muh mei lega chutiye yeh saare busniees 5 saal phle bhi the jab job Nhi the aur abhi bhi hai
Tu Shayad bekar baith Kar prawachan na pel
In Karnataka, all these MNC companies tried their luck, but everyone failed Infront of 'Nandini' A Govt. Co operative milk federation.
Yeah...Nandini has done a revolutionary work in Rural areas....Especially the farmers are benefitted..
Nandhini and amul are best to introduce different varieties of milk products
yeah true. when i visit Karnataka its really a relief that such quality products are easily available due to nandini
Andhra and Telangana milk federation is on local corporate companies like Heritage, Jersey, Vijay hasn't capture good market
That is because Nandini is a good product. I have used lot of packaged kinds of milk in different states but Nandini seems most authentic of them.
Selling ice boxes to eskimos? Same idea. No wonder they failed.
Except polar region ice is not adulterated while a significant percent of unpackaged Indian milk is.
Why these channels keep on showing the sme old delhi pic while talking about india.
Casual Racism
For self satisfaction.
This is how every industry should be. Small and local with plenty of competition within reason. Corporations have destroyed capitalism in the US.
Corporations made capitalism not destroyed it.
@@Unknown-rj4qj I don't think you know what either of those words mean.
@@---GOD--- Capitalism should lead to competition. But here in America, they buy there competitors and that leads to a rigged system, and creates monopolies that lead to oligarchies. But the younger generations will change that here, soon enough.. So yeah I agree, Corporations and capitalism have destroyed the value of life in the US. Very true!..
WKZ On Tech Young people get more conservative as they age. As they always have. Im a millennial, used to vote for Democrats, wouldnt in a million years anymore. Theyre so extreme theyre insane. So yeah everybody always think the youth are going to change things. Infact when they get older they get wiser.
@@552mustang I'm also a millennial. And the current numbers are millennials vote left 5 to 1. You sound comical, why would they vote like a 65 year old. Old people vote that way in America because they're kinda stupid, and ignorant..
Amul, Mother dairy, Vijaya, Ananda are big dairy companies in India by any standard and seem to be doing fine . I think CNBC is worried about some Global MNCs that had to shut down.
yes bec CNBC is a american brand
except for Amul I guess remaining are owned by local Gov't
I hope all American companies shut their business in India so that local business can grow and make our economy better
@@TheMotorman1981 RUclips is American too
@@adithyahk that's the point in our country pm introduced make in india.what we need is made in india.
We still call it curd over Yogurt. And packet wala dudh over pasteurized...so its not just what we eat or drink. We have it with emotion. Not just for some sake.
Many Indians mistakenly call dahi yogurt. No idea why. Perhaps to appear cool. Actually yogurt is very different.
@@exponentialcomplexity3051 finally someone said it. Curd and yogurt are completely different
My family is well to do rich but still makes butter out of 2 litres of milk packet which has thick fat floating over it which is separated and stored.
0:52 Haryana: A state in Western India.
Haryanvi: Bhains ki aankh
Nope
Haryanvi : Rae Boli booch madm
(Bhains ki aankh is perceived as haryanvi but it isn't what we speak its more of a an unheard stereotypical proverb given by bollywood which doesn't exist in reality)
@@av7337 Meaning ?
@@sagniksarkar1503 pagal madam
@AARVYY aray bhai veg tha na tay bawli gaand k bawli film bhi kah deta
@@av7337 sbte Ghani Gaal thaili aale dudh ne ae Mille Haryane m ... People thinks "iski cream kaadh lewe s " 😂
Asia's largest milk company is amul which is successful because it is co-operative society where every farmer is owner. They sell 3.1 million litres per day !!
Gives so much happiness seeing these corporates cry . Just compare the carbon footprint of these big company made products and the locally made products . Will clearly show you who is most sustainable
The video neglected one more important point. Some states have state run diaries, which have an amazing supply chain, even Amul can't compete with them.
Omg one comment atlast lol ikr but it's still indian :))
So basically, India is like the only country doing this right.
If you must drink milk .... Then yes
ATMANIRBHAR BHARAT
we prefer to purhase indian product .
Western corporations know how to destroy the fabric of societies by making everyone dependent on large corporations for even basic stuff. As long as India restricts these leeches from entering market, we are saved from more homelessness and hunger.
One who controls food, will control the world moving forward.
Doing this right with urea ?
It's better to have 1000 you tubers having 100k subscribers than 10 having 10M subscribers.
This is what our model is.
best comment I read in a while
What? You do know that income inequality is rising in India right? The average farmer makes very little money bc of low access to markets and poor infrastructure. You have a system where millions of farmers are barely above the poverty line and a select few earning a lot of money
@@MrJuggernautishere it is not our model it just happened by probability of having right things the right time which is also not our doing.
One zero missing in calculation
@@aniketpatil793 No it's not a basic structure of farmers being empowered in general. A little less than half of our population is into farming and it is only contributing 17% of the country's GDP. That's the issues. This model is great to empower the farmers. What is the alternative to it? If it does not exist , you will have few people owing cows and milking them and how would the farmers compete where they have assurity their products will surface a decent price in the market.
While their success may have added to our GDP, I'm somewhat glad that they didn't succeed. Milk production is the type of industry which can be built from grassroot level with creation of cooperative marketing chains (like Amul). That way it benefits rural people instead of filling the pockets of an MNC.
You just got me to make this my next big project. Thank you. Very impactful video if I do.
Yeah, milk is a mandatory daily consumable in Indian diet. We like it fresh and unfiltered. I live in a city and yet we still manage to get milk through a doodhwala (milk man) who delivers fresh milk which is extracted only hours ago compared to the ones available at the stores which are at least half a day to two days old and rely on added preservatives (in short, we just avoid packed milk to the best of our abilities). And then, Indians value people selling the product more than the brand which makes it even harder to compete with the local brands like AMUL which gained reputation to be a social phenomenon.
Yes, we make curd at home which is extremely cheap and way healthier than packed yogurt (curd, in India).
The only way Danone can compete in India is through processed Dairy like Cheese, Butter and nutritional supplements etc.
Trust me, Ghee is extremely competitive too because of the local competition. We prefer to buy it from a local Ghee store who make it on a daily basis in small amounts whose quality and price is no match to packaged product.
Are you from the dark ages??
@@premjitchowdhury262 What you may perceive as being as advancement in society may be viewed from another as the complete opposite. I would much rather have several small businesses then a few large companies who value profits over people.
doodhwala i like the sound of this word. its really pretty.
Benchod
@b king American and European milk producers source milk from thousands of cows (probably in cramped unclean conditions), and then mix them all together. If any of those cows is sick or their milk contaminated, it spoils ALL the milk, which is part of why pasteurization is so important. If your bottle of milk only comes from a single cow that is cared for on a small family farm, the chance of contamination is very low.
I'd rather buy from my local Dairy... It's much fresher and is of high quality.
Or Wanna Try Danone's Watered Milk instead?
and it isn't packed in plastics. Always buy local.
Local dairy milk is not pure every tried testing go to laboratory it only cost 50 rupee to get milk tested
@tommy aronson you're just showing how ignorant and stupid western people can be
@@ravikiran4495 so how are they
Just to clarify, making yoghurt is extremely easy and requires almost no supervision. You can easily do at home along with maintaining a full time job.
Le Amul : hold my milk
Btw. Yeah we make Yogurt at home. We will always do. When we want packaged yogurt. We buy it from local shops. Not Danone
Danone isn't even a competition. Dairy co-operative like Amul in Gujrat, Verka in Punjab , Nandini in Karnataka, Mother Dairy in NCR are pretty dominant.
Aavin from Tamil Nadu as well
Red cow in west Bengal
Vijaya and Heritage in Andhra states too
Omfed in orissa, govardhan in Bangalore, milky mist in Tamil Nadu and Karnataka etc.
Sanchi in MP
I don't understand why they have problem in showing complete map of india
Kind of jealousy
maybe cause those parts are not controlled by India...
illegal capture
@@ashutoshmourya1399 true, but still capture is capture.
I noticed that too.... That was really irresponsible of them
Got here after seeing a "The Rise and Fall of Subway" and the first ad that popped up in the lefthand corner was for Subway lol gotta love it.
Same here
That baby at 5:48 is gonna sue CNBC for using his/her video without his/her permission... 😂
You shouldn't use that map of India ...that part you eliminated is Our Kashmir .....other than that good stuff
@R. K. We know where the future of Punjab lies, and we want to keep it with India, no second thoughts
@Science Geek it's fixed ..🤣just today .
@Science Geek Pakistani bhosdi spotted
@Science Geek and now we have!!!!!
@Science Geek who is UN to decide what belongs to whom?
Now u will fail in INDIA too if u don't change the map of India
😂
Wake up Pajeet, the whole world uses this map.
@@vicentgalvan70 wrong in india india has kashmir in pakistan pakistan owns kashmir and in china china owns kashmir
But outside them kashmir is basically UN owned bcs google maps
@Science Geek oh lmao i mean its india kinda normal
Me: give me half kg ghee
Danone: ok u want *gee* here it is.
Me: *No thanks, Bye Bye*
In Bangalore a large percentage buy Nandini curd than make it at home, maybe because the climate where setting takes more time
Reason
Me : 1 ltr milk plz
Shopkeeper: I have Denon
Me: fk which brand is it , m going to next shop
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
@@maheshwarbehera9590 I would respect cow/buffalo by consuming milk👍.
Please stop this nonsense.
@@wizz.8236 Did you took the permission from cow/buffalo before snatching their milk ?! Or you just showing your ignorance by the fact that it's worth torturing an animal her whole life !?
@@maheshwarbehera9590 I don't know from where you had your milks previously, but in my area I am sure they are treated well not only because we consider them holy but I have faith in my milkman that he is treating her well.
@@maheshwarbehera9590 even I would have stopped consuming milk after such machines were used on them
I live in Bangalore, Southern part of India and work in a Fortune 500 company. Despite my corporate nature of job I still prefer home made curd ( yogurt ) than packed ones due to the freshness and the taste . I wanna eat which tastes traditional unless I’m buying a pizza 🍕.
curd and yoghurt are different. They're not same
About Donone it is correct... In Indian shops I have seen only super expensive yougurts with fruit bits and sugar and a tiny packet of yogurt costs as much as half a litre of plain yogurt.
And another thing I have noticed, they generated a lot of plastic waste. Some people are concerned about disposing that too
I would like to raise the objection of the channel using a map that shows a huge part of Kashmir cut off. This is non-tolerable.
Although my family is living in a city for more than 40 years we still don't buy store bought milk. We always find some one with local diary and buy buffalo milk straight from them. This is how it is for many people in India.
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
@@maheshwarbehera9590 tru
@@maheshwarbehera9590 628 litres is a global number, tell me the Indian number.
@@Private.R It doesn't matter !! We are the no.1 producer of milk already so the no. Balances out. The problem is the dairy cows and buffaloes are later exported as beef making India 3rd largest exporter of more than 1.4million metric ton beef. So our country is blind and can't see what's going on. The milk is no more used as the purpose of drinking only. Majority of it is wasted as tea , coffee , dairy milk , biscuits , fast-food , bakery , sweets as it contains no nutritional benefits but results in high amount of cruelty an Indian can never imagine. Gone are those days when cows were really respected but now majority of them get slaughtered for leather and beef. Shame on us Indian calling cows as gau mata and be reason for cruelty on her.
Last but not the least her male calves are let to die as they are Not females and won't benefit farmers for milk. Castration , dehorning , artificial insemination , baby separation , as well as beef and leather production in India is already at peak. So does the water consumption really matters now !!? The truth is way beyond public expectations. Public knows nothing that why 1000s of indigenious cows got extinct in India.
Because they were not capable of giving large amount of milk so only few are left and majority of the market holds genetically breeded cows and buffaloes for more milk production. And it proves we don't have love towards our cattle as we used to have 100 years ago. It's not love it's bloody business that's it !!
Watch this to know more about the global impact ruclips.net/video/dSjE8xw_-Dg/видео.html
@@Private.R According to "International Journal of Environmental Science and Development, Vol. 7, No. 8, August 2016 "
A. Virtual Water
1) Indigenous cow
Total water consumed by individual indigenous cow is
calculated as:
Δ water=899 L/day
Total water productivity is given by:
σdairy, j =0.0033
Thus water intensity=1/σ=303.03
2) Crossbred cow
Total water consumed by individual cross bred cow is
calculated as:
Δ water=1127.19 L./day
And this data was true during 2016 now India is largest milk producer so imagine the amount of water consumed today at 2021 !!
―Water footprint‖ means the amount of water used by a
household or a country, or the amount used for a given task or
for the production of a given quantity of some product or crop.
The term ―water footprint‖ is often used to refer to the amount
of water used by an individual, community, business, or
nation. The water footprint of a product is the volume of
freshwater used to produce the product, measured over the
full supply chain. Water footprint is the amount of water used
in and around our home, school or office throughout the day.
It includes the water used directly (e.g., from a tap) and also
indirectly. It also includes the water it took to produce the
food we eat, the products we buy, the energy we consume and even the water we save when we recycle. We may not drink,
feel or see this virtual water, but it makes up the majority of
our water footprint. The concept of ‗‗virtual water‘‘ deserves
special mention in this regard. Virtual water trade refers to the
hidden flow of water if food or other commodities are traded
from one place to another. The concept of virtual water
enables us to realize how much water is needed to produce
different goods and services. In semi-arid and arid areas, idea
about the virtual water value of a good or service can be useful
towards determining how best to use the scarce water
available. The concept of virtual water content of a
commodity is defined as the volume of water that is actually
used to produce the commodity, measured at the place where
the commodity is actually produced. The inverse of the virtual
water content is known as the water productivity of a crop.
Danone was selling yogurt for 25rs whereas Amul and Mother dairy are selling it for 15rs.
Quality is different.... We buy 500ml curd which costs 35 of milky mist. Amul is rs 22 for the same.
Foreign brands are making something as basic as curd a luxury item
I want to ask why to compete when amul is there...
A correction here in map of india why there is some part missing on top right ????
Topic for next video : why is cnbc obsessing over india?
Trying to get some of those T-series viewers no doubt.
Because VOX Borders...
New indian interns
vieeewwwsssssss
Because India's growth Irritates the Europeans and Americans.
People prefer fresh milk in India directly from farmers than package milk in India because it is more good for health than package milk
It's not true😂😂😂😂
Amit kumar ur misleading people.
yes that's true....My dad who works at National dairy development Board also says the same thing that fresh milk is better for consumers in India but not for sellers ( because of low profit margin)
Akal nahi hai .If you want to make a statement give sources .Which
@@gobimurugesan2411 if you know the farmer and the way he treats cattle, it is true. Mother dairy uses high levels of estrogen to milk their cattle, it is poison.
My only reason to dislike this video is because of the wrong map that you've shown in this video at 2:00.
Snowflake melting
@@arivuchelvankasi at least he doesn't like being hit on both the cheeks!
@@uselesshero.official he has to blame it on his owns rather than lamenting on someone who shows him that he is hit.
The title should be: "Why all companies struggle in India"
AMUL the taste of India .. title should be why western dairy companies struggle in India
Still prefer Nandini over Amul.
Himul is huge brand in darjeling
By the way you brainless AMUL is also and indian comapny originated from Gujarat do some research before spitting here and there...
We prefer Saras and Gorus in Rajasthan.
Also Milky Mist and Heritage in South.
I wish we had more local farmers like this in the US
Yes gurl if you eat fresh dairy full fat unpasteurised like dolly Parton did your breasts will get as large as hers!!!!!!!!!
My neighbours sell me milk.
Trust: they are drinking same milk as my kids - no issue.
we do.
it's called a farmer's market and they're everywhere...
TEXAS is bigger than france those aren’t that available
Nope. Almost all these farmers are deeply in debt. I hear about farmers killing themselves every month. It's so common.
Well even an indian-American will tell you how much he misses the dairy products of india
The old-school commercial of Amul is more than enough to understand the emotions behind it.
Amul of Gujarat is really good. Their products are amazing. Ice creams by Amul and Havmor are superb.
Go Vegan Save Yourself Save Earth !!!!! 628 litres of water is used to produce just 1 litre of Milk. And producing 1kg of meat requires 5000 litres of water. Any doubt !
@@maheshwarbehera9590 and what about the amount of land you need to grow those vegetables? That same land which you're taking away by encroaching on those animals habitat. Vegans are hypocrits.
In my opinion,Amul ice cream isn’t good but I agree that their milk is amazing.
Felt proud of India's dairy industry & it's root in Indian culture. I would like @CNBC to correct India's map shown at 2:02 & onwards.
Thank you,
@@Q_QQ_Q jihadi on blast
Accept the fact abhishek it is not a part of INDIA
@@chandravideo I agree that it's been years now. But I feel the world must respect not only India's boundary rather any other country's boundary because it's a matter of pride of national integrity especially when territory is snatched from you & being used against you.
@@Q_QQ_Q you must be unemployed
Bro, they purposely do that for the sake of spilling hatred and like that. ..
First heard about this company in this video. No ads also seen in tv, people usually preferred local milk vendors than pasteurised milk
To plan & beat Amul would be like picking war with me as an individual 😁
I don't even have to think before picking Amul, I know the quality is best & the price will always be lower the any other brand.
Let people do the business, instead of big corporations where all the money stays in a few hands.
Truth
The people you refer to make barely any money. Indian farmers incomes are staggeringly low. You just have heads of corporate companies making a lot of money while farmers and workers earn nothing.
@Alberto Fuijimori Congress should come back to power, then only India breathe freely!
@Alberto Fuijimori what we are is solid foundation of Congress and LPG(Liberalisation, privatisation, globalisation) program Of Congress is one of the daring thing benefitted country.
Congress three decades are better than these BJP. Lots of corruption and threat to democracy is by BJP in my opinion.
Slowdown in economy, GDP miscalculation, Not disclosure of unemployment data , rising inflation, auto sector in complete breakdown, depreciating rupee value, Unemployment, threats to Democratic institutions like RBI , CBI(Suspension of CBI head), hate politics Of Modi, suicide Of farmers, Jio university (unborn) to Get the status of eminence in line with IITs, ED targeting only Congress politicians leaving BJP is not a sign of good things brother.
At the end illiterate, no logical people swayed away by sweet speech Of Democratic dictator is unfortunate to democracy and people don't understand and maybe people understand when it's too late.
Save country from evils!
@Alberto Fuijimori Even capitalism fails if it's not regulated properly...
Even majority of people can't withstand brutal capitalism...
Whatever the ideology, at the end It should be just and benefit maximum people.
Only dreams and speeches don't do everything!
Well,, ain't nothin better thn homemade curd😋😋
And home made ghee too 😍
homemade saltless makkhan, and mali zamake bhi...😍😍😍
@pranav chaudhary aahnn and I trust you.
@@crusanosicus562 well it's not something you directly consume rather it is an much healthier and tasty ingredient/option for butter or oil. It is filled with unsaturated fats, good cholesterol and protein. And yes it is very tasty at first you might not be able to tolerate the "different" odour but after a couple of meals it does grow on you.
@@crusanosicus562 😂😂😂 cow's milk and that to unhealthy. Bro you are talking about a different breed of cow. The cows in India are of Desi breed and the milk they give is much less but much healthier compared to the Jersey breed normally used in foreign countries. Here cows are the closest thing to a family member they have names, they are regularly cleaned, fresh grass for them daily, and most importantly they roam in a free environment unlike the dairy farms I have saw of places abroad. I guarantee you the milk we have here is much more healthy. There is a reason we Indians are the largest producer's and consumers of milk.😊
hi @CNBC the map shown of the India is wrong.
I never seen a foreign dairy company here except chocolates 😂 only amul sachi and local milk 😂