Very detailed, nice use of music too. The only complaint that I have is that it is sometimes difficult to see the major events since they go by too fast, however I can't think of another way to do this.
Lingering text is the solution. Other channels have a bar on the side where events are displayed, and even if they only last a few days, you have enough time to read them
Wow! I'm a Hungarian, but i have never seen such a detalied map video about our little country, well done! I really like that you have included many towns (i was "pleased" to see my little city!), it really gives a new perspective to the fightings.
my hungarians brothers and sisters greatings from Poland Polak Węgier dwa bratanki Oba zuchy, oba żwawi niech im Pan Bóg błogosławii Lengyel magyar két társ Mindketten bátrak, mindketten élénkek Isten áldja meg őket
At the same time hungary's history it's kind of unfair at the same time, like for instance in world war I, hungray never wanted to join WW1, and then WW2 they were manipulated into attacking the Soviets, they lost all this land at the same time had different majorities, But hungry literally borders Slovakia which it's southern part of Slovakia is literally Hungarian.
4:19 According to my knowldge the announcement was about switching sides, with orders also given to the military to join the soviets. These orders were slow to reach the front lines, and the German takeover immadiately ordered to continue fighting. Some units got the first order first and joined the soviets, most did not. But this mess resulted Hungarians fighting on both sides.
@@yanxishan6575 A little bit of nitpick here, but I think you missed the Bodlíky area in northwestern Hungary. That was returned to Czechoslovakia in Paris Peace Treaties. Other than that, great work! As a person who likes playing Risk Universalis in Roblox, I am always the guy doing cities for other people role playing countries. I am amazed at your work and proud of you to do the cities and towns in the battle of Hungary 1944. Even though at some parts it was difficult to see the names, it amazes me that you have managed to fit that many. I love your channel and the mapping community because of such high-quality videos like these!
Not at all. I just read up on the announcement. Horthy said these things in short: The war is already lost. Stop fighting on the fronts for a lost german cause. The government as of yet is still in order. and in the telegraphs to the units the message was to not resist neither soviet nor german troops. In the following days Hungary was invaded by SS troops
In 1944 Hungary was occupied by German troops because they were negotiating with the Allies, so the Hungary you see after that date in the video is actually a German puppet state just like the Italian Social Republic, and most of their fighting forces were German.
@@jimstoilov doesnt change the fact that they are more important than Hungary also they have some good army unit and few good general, not all of their army is bad. Without their navy, German cant transport their troops to Libya due to lack of warship protect them (cuz German focused in U-boat), and the African front may end in 1942, their navy was experienced, make Royal Navy focus 1/3 of their ship to Mediterenean, help those U-boat in the Atlantic less pressure from RN. Also, Italia have a lot of mountain, make them become a shield for German from the South I dont think German could lasted until 1945 without them
Never heard about operation spring awakening, the last German offensive during ww2. Crazy how the German army was rapidly disintegrating and still managed to put up a final offensive. Great video!
Nice job, Hungary in the war was very interesting, one of the most important but usually forgotten parts of Hungary in WW2 was when Germany invaded Poland Hitler wanted to use Hungary to invade southern Poland (like he did with Slovakia) but Horthy refused, in fact Polish soldiers escaped and were "interned" in Hungary (where they would later "escape" and regroup with other Polish army units) and thousands of refugees were also taken in by the Hungarian gov, so its nice to see that you pointed out how relations with Poland despite German pressure, remained friendly.
RIP to this channel, I'm hoping that you are just working on something big but if this is the last video just want to say they were damn good and high quality. I was wrong, the channel lives!
As I heard from one friend, after romanians switched sides in WW2 they immediately tried to genocide carpathian hungarians and banatian germans, but were stopped by the soviets.
Bravo! What a great video! Surely you now should be considered the best mapper of youtube! It's a pity that soo few people watch your videos and are subscribed to your channel. Keep up the great work!
@@yanxishan6575 holy crap that’s a sigh of relief. We can’t lose a great mapper like you from RUclips. Also don’t rush. It’s easy to burn out that way.
Your such a legend for making this beautiful master piece, I noticed that hungarian history is a bit underrated in mapping. Thank you for doing this beautiful work.
Great video! I would be never able to do something so detailed with so much effort in a million years! can you please make a video on the turkish war of independence?
One of the best mapping videos on RUclips for WW2. It would be great if in the future you make a similar video for Poland during the Second World War. A lot was happening but there really aren't any good mapping videos for it, at least after the initial invasion. Similar situation with the Allied Invasion of Germany though.
Absolutely staggering. The effort you, Ollie bye, and khey pard put into these are unbelievable! I mean, where on earth did you find the patience to name every single one of those cities & towns?
The borders and frontlines are usually WAY harder to map out than the cities. I'm guessing most of the cities still exist today. The part I'm surprised about is the sheer detail these mappers need to make them.
This is a pretty good video, I hope you can soon make a video on the War in Afghanistan from 1978 to August 15, 2021, since I think that could be a good topic
@Абдульзефир Slavs came from Asia and Atilla gave them land there. If Slavs are allowed in Europe so the Magyars. Atilla took the Carpathians so we sit in his place. There was his capital and he defeated Rome. Romans would never let Slavs to settle here.
Great video! Hungarian here and holy sh*t I didn't know about any of the incidents with Czechoslovakia/Slovakia, they never taught about these agressions in high school. We only got the Novi Sad massacre as a footnote to follow it up with the Yugoslavian revenge later. Oh, and they didn't even say those killed were jews. Our current history curriculum really pushes the agenda of Hungary making sure in every way possible that Hungarian jews were protected from deportation and violence and only discrimination was against them. Damn historical propaganda...! One thing I'd like to add though: 1943 january, defeat at the river Don is said to be a major event for Hungary as we lost around/more than half of our main army (dead or missing) or it is said.
I graduated last year and they did talk about the border incidents with Czechoslovakia as well as the Slovak-Hungarian war. This may depend on the institution you have attended but the Holocaust in Hungary was taught in a very negative light, as well as how the average Hungarian supported it and have actively partook in the seizing of Jewish assets for themselves after deportations, and the unusually fast and efficient deportations during 1944, having highlighted that while Horthy did not support it, he did not take any additional measures to stop it for quite a while (one of the reasons is of course being blackmailed with his son). But we did have an excellent History teacher who was not afraid of the truth, so this may play a part :)
Okay... Now, you're be a legend. You make fantastic videos from some intresting things (like my favorite topic, the Russian civil war), but... You make a video about my nation... Fantastic, thank you.
Besides the vicinity of Bratislava, the frontier between Czechoslovakia and Hungary was on the Danube river. Your frontier is on today's lock build for hydro central Gabcikovo.
The upper river Tisza is wrong, in reality it can be found further to the north, at what is today the present day border of Romania and Ukraine in northern Transylvania... but that's about it. This video is awesome!
Is a great video in general. I would like to add a few notes. You describe the First Vienna Award as generous, in fact, more than 90% of the population in the region ceded from Slovakia was ethnic Hungarian. For this reason, it is rather just than generous. It was the arrangement after WW1 that was generous to the neighbouring and new countries, providing them a lot of territory which should not have been given to them based on the Wilsonian principles. Most of the areas recovered by Hungary in the period of the video were ethnic majority Hungarian, with the exception of Carpathia. All of the territories were part of Hungary before.
Hey! Don’t know if you’ll ever read this, but I don’t think you should leave RUclips. I’ve watched you since Chinese Civil War 1945 and beyond and I think you have a better style than most mappers
Hungary: we are a kingdom without king, led by an admiral in a landlocked country. We want those mountains you had, Romania, so we will go to Stalingrad on the Soviet Union to keep them, becuase Germany says so. Highly functional country btw.
hungary was the only axis member to not take part in the holocaust during national administration. the holocaust only came to hungary when germany forced horthy to step down. bravo, hungary. 🇦🇺❤🇭🇺
Зато венгры очень активно участвовали в уничтожении советского населения. Их жестокость можно было сравнить лишь с жестокостью немецких СС или хорватов
Everyone calm down about the new video, this means they’re probably coming with a massive banger video, like what oversimplified did with the punic war video
2:50 it's unclear who the people were in Újvidék/Novi Sad. Serbians claim it was serbian civilians. The allies claimed that it was jews. But in most probability it was yugoslav communist separatists
Very good video, there are some spelling inaccuracies on some frames, you spelled Horthy's name with an "ó" and sometimes you reversed the name order, but otherwise, great work.
I can no longer tolerate RUclips's business model, not to mention how frequently it keeps me awake past my bedtime. Is there anywhere else could follow your work?
I don't post my videos anywhere other than youtube, unfortunately. I completely understand your sentiment, however. I do post maps I make on alternatehistory.com, where I can be found as "Linbot".
Absolutely marvelous! I cannot believe that this amount of detail and effort can even exist. Thank you for this contribution to civilization.
you want those borders don’t you
And now it does
Здр foxy
Yeah this is cool
I see you everywhere
Very detailed, nice use of music too. The only complaint that I have is that it is sometimes difficult to see the major events since they go by too fast, however I can't think of another way to do this.
you could set the playback speed to 0.25x
I paused several times
Whats name of the music?
Lingering text is the solution. Other channels have a bar on the side where events are displayed, and even if they only last a few days, you have enough time to read them
@@evoluxman9935 I probably ought to do that, but I am not very technologically proficient.
Wow! I'm a Hungarian, but i have never seen such a detalied map video about our little country, well done!
I really like that you have included many towns (i was "pleased" to see my little city!), it really gives a new perspective to the fightings.
This little events and happenings are sacral still today. Imagine about cities and villages, regions around you in the mirror of happenings.
my hungarians brothers and sisters greatings from Poland
Polak Węgier dwa bratanki
Oba zuchy, oba żwawi
niech im Pan Bóg błogosławii
Lengyel magyar két társ
Mindketten bátrak, mindketten élénkek
Isten áldja meg őket
My country (Belgium) is smaller lol
@@ddoomsday7313 wow those words creep me out
At the same time hungary's history it's kind of unfair at the same time, like for instance in world war I, hungray never wanted to join WW1, and then WW2 they were manipulated into attacking the Soviets, they lost all this land at the same time had different majorities,
But hungry literally borders Slovakia which it's southern part of Slovakia is literally Hungarian.
The amount of detail and effort that was put in to this is astonishing! Amazing work.
4:19 According to my knowldge the announcement was about switching sides, with orders also given to the military to join the soviets. These orders were slow to reach the front lines, and the German takeover immadiately ordered to continue fighting. Some units got the first order first and joined the soviets, most did not. But this mess resulted Hungarians fighting on both sides.
The sources I looked at disagreed on the actual content of the announcement, but you're probably right.
@@yanxishan6575. I love this video! Can you made a other video the Irak or Thailand during ww2? (Sorry my bad english)
@@yanxishan6575 A little bit of nitpick here, but I think you missed the Bodlíky area in northwestern Hungary. That was returned to Czechoslovakia in Paris Peace Treaties.
Other than that, great work! As a person who likes playing Risk Universalis in Roblox, I am always the guy doing cities for other people role playing countries. I am amazed at your work and proud of you to do the cities and towns in the battle of Hungary 1944. Even though at some parts it was difficult to see the names, it amazes me that you have managed to fit that many.
I love your channel and the mapping community because of such high-quality videos like these!
Most of the units werent traitors and would not join the soviets either way.
Not at all. I just read up on the announcement. Horthy said these things in short: The war is already lost. Stop fighting on the fronts for a lost german cause. The government as of yet is still in order. and in the telegraphs to the units the message was to not resist neither soviet nor german troops. In the following days Hungary was invaded by SS troops
This is one of the most detailed World War 2 videos I have seen! D-Mapper's level of researching. Great work, Yan :D
We need a new video
@@blitzkrieg-pmkc852 It will definitely be!
О привет!
Hungary is probably a better ally than the Italian
In 1944 Hungary was occupied by German troops because they were negotiating with the Allies, so the Hungary you see after that date in the video is actually a German puppet state just like the Italian Social Republic, and most of their fighting forces were German.
Fact: Italy was about to lose whole Albania from Greece 🗿💀
Lol, their army was weak but their navy is better than German, and the air force have some quality fighters but lack of numbers
@@LamLeDuy-zv9yd But their land army lost by Greece 💀🌝
@@jimstoilov doesnt change the fact that they are more important than Hungary also they have some good army unit and few good general, not all of their army is bad. Without their navy, German cant transport their troops to Libya due to lack of warship protect them (cuz German focused in U-boat), and the African front may end in 1942, their navy was experienced, make Royal Navy focus 1/3 of their ship to Mediterenean, help those U-boat in the Atlantic less pressure from RN. Also, Italia have a lot of mountain, make them become a shield for German from the South
I dont think German could lasted until 1945 without them
Never heard about operation spring awakening, the last German offensive during ww2. Crazy how the German army was rapidly disintegrating and still managed to put up a final offensive. Great video!
Props for this man actually having so many romanian and hungarian cities compacted in there. Anyways another great vid mad lad
Nice job, Hungary in the war was very interesting, one of the most important but usually forgotten parts of Hungary in WW2 was when Germany invaded Poland Hitler wanted to use Hungary to invade southern Poland (like he did with Slovakia) but Horthy refused, in fact Polish soldiers escaped and were "interned" in Hungary (where they would later "escape" and regroup with other Polish army units) and thousands of refugees were also taken in by the Hungarian gov, so its nice to see that you pointed out how relations with Poland despite German pressure, remained friendly.
50 likes and no reply’s? Lemme fix that
@@Godzilla_kingofthemonsters whats the point
@@HOI4gaming6903 what the point of your birth
@@Godzilla_kingofthemonsters what is that sentence even supposed to mean?
Still fascists
Very good work, the history of Hungary in World War II is very detailed👍👍
It's crazy how tiny Hungary put up more of a fight than Italy for the most part
Beautiful. Your mapping is pure art!
RIP to this channel, I'm hoping that you are just working on something big but if this is the last video just want to say they were damn good and high quality.
I was wrong, the channel lives!
Soviets: _attacks Romania and Hungary_
Hungary: *don't care man, i only hate Romania*
Yes they hate them but i think they only took Romanians territorry becasue they knew that Romania couldnt hold the Soviets and tokk their Positions.
@@Miskolcz_Mapper yeah que clarely can see how romanians and soviets respected eachother's land
@@unanec Soviets were not so... mutch about respect to the countries they've gone thru
As I heard from one friend, after romanians switched sides in WW2 they immediately tried to genocide carpathian hungarians and banatian germans, but were stopped by the soviets.
@@matwiw proof 1 se have of this not being true: the hungarian population of Romania did not decrease
Hell yeah i've been waiting for this to come out for a while, fantastic job as usual Yan! :)))))
You are really hardworking, and heavily underrated creator, Yan.
yan xishan seem to be only mapper on youtube to cover those overlooked themes
Overrated ones
@@kapatidtomas Hungary in WW2 is overrated? Literally no one ever talks about it.
@@kapatidtomas commie take
Absolutely Superb! Without a doubt you are one of the most detailed and innovative channels on RUclips!
Thank you this wonderful video! From Hungary!
I am left with an open mouth. Completely impressive! Good job!
The detailing in this map is just insane !
Bravo! What a great video! Surely you now should be considered the best mapper of youtube! It's a pity that soo few people watch your videos and are subscribed to your channel. Keep up the great work!
He really isn't.
Holy shit, this is beyond amazing! Thank you so much for making this!
How many cities on frame do you want?
Yan: YES.
Believe it or not, this is a key how the war affected my very post-tribal country.
Man for the information and Editing you had in the video i think you deserve more subscribers
My man this was a marvelous work I'm very impressed keep up the good work!
Awesome!! I’ve been waiting for a video on Hungarian participation! This is by far the most detailed. Good work. Keep it up :)
Even better and more detailed than your former videos, keep doing the better work!
Its beautiful, such detailed and amazing informations. One of the best mappers, or maybe. The best.
Yan Xishan please heart my comment so I know if you are still active on RUclips. It’s been a year since you’ve last uploaded and I miss you.
5 months late.
It is likely I will upload in a video in the next few weeks.
@@yanxishan6575 holy crap that’s a sigh of relief. We can’t lose a great mapper like you from RUclips. Also don’t rush. It’s easy to burn out that way.
So much effort is in this video, fantastic work! I would love to see Romania during second world war!
Very well detailed, enjoyable video. Nice job!
Great video man I can see this had a lot of work put into it that’s a lot of cities!
Your such a legend for making this beautiful master piece, I noticed that hungarian history is a bit underrated in mapping. Thank you for doing this beautiful work.
*You're** not your.
Sorry for bothering you, have a nice time!
@@sjsound506 its been 10 months why you gotta do me like that bro 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Can't wait to see what your next video is, you always do the best stuff.
the amount of effort you put into your videos is beyond me. I am though still waiting for the interwar history of the baltics.
Incredible job Yan, this was so well made
Good video my friend
Great video! I would be never able to do something so detailed with so much effort in a million years!
can you please make a video on the turkish war of independence?
What an accurate objective and detailed video! Thank you for this masterpiece!
Excellent job!
Please make the Taliban insurgence - every week (april of 2020 - today)
One of the best mapping videos on RUclips for WW2. It would be great if in the future you make a similar video for Poland during the Second World War. A lot was happening but there really aren't any good mapping videos for it, at least after the initial invasion. Similar situation with the Allied Invasion of Germany though.
Holy crap - Even the pre-war partitions. Thanks for doing that!
This is really an excellent work!
Absolutely staggering. The effort you, Ollie bye, and khey pard put into these are unbelievable!
I mean, where on earth did you find the patience to name every single one of those cities & towns?
The borders and frontlines are usually WAY harder to map out than the cities. I'm guessing most of the cities still exist today. The part I'm surprised about is the sheer detail these mappers need to make them.
I suppose it helped with the movement of front lines. Records mention which city was captured when. Mappers use this data to paint the map.
Great work!
This is a pretty good video, I hope you can soon make a video on the War in Afghanistan from 1978 to August 15, 2021, since I think that could be a good topic
Thanks for the video!
Kösz a videóért
Thank you, from Hungary !
I like the format but it might be good if you slowed it down so that it's readable without having to constantly pause and unpause
Great job, as always!
Bro, look at this amount of cities this is amazing!! Very well detailed, this is impressive
Very good video! Fun fact: the germans did managed to broke the siege of Budapest a little bit, only to place new troops there
Funfact: You and I have watched this video and others more than once.
your maps are absolutely amazing
Sad to see how little Hungary had become . And everybody says Versailles treaty was awful ....
@Абдульзефир What about the Turks and Bulgars .
@Абдульзефир Slavs came from Asia and Atilla gave them land there.
If Slavs are allowed in Europe so the Magyars. Atilla took the Carpathians so we sit in his place. There was his capital and he defeated Rome.
Romans would never let Slavs to settle here.
The legend is back with another banger
Nice video, very detailed and good music. The text boxes went by to fast sometimes, making them impossible to read without pausing.
Well, it looks like she won't be uploading anymore. That said, it was a great run. Hats off to one of the best videomappers ever.
How do you know
she?
@@Ethereal.X1234 Yeah
@@thedarkechoes1236 I stand corrected :D
Great video! Hungarian here and holy sh*t I didn't know about any of the incidents with Czechoslovakia/Slovakia, they never taught about these agressions in high school. We only got the Novi Sad massacre as a footnote to follow it up with the Yugoslavian revenge later. Oh, and they didn't even say those killed were jews. Our current history curriculum really pushes the agenda of Hungary making sure in every way possible that Hungarian jews were protected from deportation and violence and only discrimination was against them. Damn historical propaganda...!
One thing I'd like to add though: 1943 january, defeat at the river Don is said to be a major event for Hungary as we lost around/more than half of our main army (dead or missing) or it is said.
Perhaps I should have had the map zoom over there briefly in order to show Little Saturn. Oh well. I did try to allude to it indirectly
I graduated last year and they did talk about the border incidents with Czechoslovakia as well as the Slovak-Hungarian war. This may depend on the institution you have attended but the Holocaust in Hungary was taught in a very negative light, as well as how the average Hungarian supported it and have actively partook in the seizing of Jewish assets for themselves after deportations, and the unusually fast and efficient deportations during 1944, having highlighted that while Horthy did not support it, he did not take any additional measures to stop it for quite a while (one of the reasons is of course being blackmailed with his son). But we did have an excellent History teacher who was not afraid of the truth, so this may play a part :)
Okay... Now, you're be a legend. You make fantastic videos from some intresting things (like my favorite topic, the Russian civil war), but... You make a video about my nation... Fantastic, thank you.
Very good video from Hungary!
The detail put into this is BRILLIANT
you never cease to amaze me.
Besides the vicinity of Bratislava, the frontier between Czechoslovakia and Hungary was on the Danube river. Your frontier is on today's lock build for hydro central Gabcikovo.
Great Work! A lot of information was put into this while still managing to make it look good; this is a rare gift in mapping
The upper river Tisza is wrong, in reality it can be found further to the north, at what is today the present day border of Romania and Ukraine in northern Transylvania... but that's about it. This video is awesome!
When I see Yan Kishan I click. I know this guy is going to overkill the map once again.
Is a great video in general. I would like to add a few notes. You describe the First Vienna Award as generous, in fact, more than 90% of the population in the region ceded from Slovakia was ethnic Hungarian. For this reason, it is rather just than generous. It was the arrangement after WW1 that was generous to the neighbouring and new countries, providing them a lot of territory which should not have been given to them based on the Wilsonian principles. Most of the areas recovered by Hungary in the period of the video were ethnic majority Hungarian, with the exception of Carpathia. All of the territories were part of Hungary before.
You should do Finland everyday.
Amazing video!
Hey! Don’t know if you’ll ever read this, but I don’t think you should leave RUclips. I’ve watched you since Chinese Civil War 1945 and beyond and I think you have a better style than most mappers
Thank you for the compliment. I'm not abandoning my channel, but recently it's been hard to find the time to make videos.
@@yanxishan6575 understand you...
Dont wory guys he is making history of world:every second
Jó lett
Hungary: we are a kingdom without king, led by an admiral in a landlocked country.
We want those mountains you had, Romania, so we will go to Stalingrad on the Soviet Union to keep them, becuase Germany says so.
Highly functional country btw.
Good video!
hungary was the only axis member to not take part in the holocaust during national administration. the holocaust only came to hungary when germany forced horthy to step down.
bravo, hungary.
🇦🇺❤🇭🇺
Зато венгры очень активно участвовали в уничтожении советского населения. Их жестокость можно было сравнить лишь с жестокостью немецких СС или хорватов
Why aren't you uploading? You are the best mapper. Pls upload
awesome work!
Good Job. But you haven't posted a video for a long time
Another banger video 👍
Would love to see a video like this on Romania and Bulgaria as well
Nice video!
wow, incredible work
Everyone calm down about the new video, this means they’re probably coming with a massive banger video, like what oversimplified did with the punic war video
Nice work 🌹
Why was the music so mysterious at the end, the war was over and people rejoiced
Great video.
Great work
please come back we need you
AMAZING
Wow this is unique, i only see germany and italy and japan, and at rare times romania but never hungary or bulgaria or thailand
2:50 it's unclear who the people were in Újvidék/Novi Sad. Serbians claim it was serbian civilians. The allies claimed that it was jews. But in most probability it was yugoslav communist separatists
Damn, this was a very good video. Many details and major events I didn't know before.
Thank you for this one.
Very good video, there are some spelling inaccuracies on some frames, you spelled Horthy's name with an "ó" and sometimes you reversed the name order, but otherwise, great work.
I can no longer tolerate RUclips's business model, not to mention how frequently it keeps me awake past my bedtime. Is there anywhere else could follow your work?
I don't post my videos anywhere other than youtube, unfortunately. I completely understand your sentiment, however. I do post maps I make on alternatehistory.com, where I can be found as "Linbot".
Then go to sleep little boy?
Your the best!
Brooo thats amazing! Can you make a history of manchur territories on map?
沒想到用這些工具就可以做到這麼棒的影片！還以為是自己編程出來的。