Samsung Galaxy S III vs. iPhone 4S | Pocketnow

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 585

  • @shtechvn
    @shtechvn 12 лет назад

    iPhone 4S: Nice compact design, popular, pleasant and easy to use. - Expensive compared to other smartphones at the same level. App/ File transfer on iOS is much more annoying to use compare to android.
    Galaxy S3: Functionality, faster, larger, and much more to personalize. - Newer and up-to-date. Reasonable price.

  • @AGC828
    @AGC828 12 лет назад

    Where did you get the international version? S3's to be sold in the US/Canada will be all dual-core.

  • @carpy1252
    @carpy1252 12 лет назад

    Is the screen on the same brightness? The samsung galaxy SIII seemed to have quite a dark display and that strains my eyes.

  • @MinhPham0407
    @MinhPham0407 12 лет назад

    I don't know why some people said this is a biased comparison. As an iPhone user who is intending to change to Galaxy S III, I find Pocketnow has done a good job in this video. Thank you Brandon!

  • @xip29
    @xip29 12 лет назад

    which has best speaker for music , the iphone 4s or galaxy s3 ?

  • @DavidGJ99
    @DavidGJ99 12 лет назад

    Shouldnt you have turned off the live wallpaper and widget?

  • @killTHEdeadNOW
    @killTHEdeadNOW 12 лет назад

    Hey, did you check that you set the Resoloution to the maximum at GTA III on the Galaxy SIII? On my Galaxy Nexus it looks really nice, but only if you set it to maximum.

  • @artemusmast
    @artemusmast 12 лет назад

    "The 4S won the web browsing test." Not taking into account that we couldn't see the web page on the 4S because of the screen size, while the the sIII displayed way more, where we could read the article.

  • @xip29
    @xip29 12 лет назад

    between iphone 4s , xperia S and htc one S which has best speaker ?

  • @Devendra95
    @Devendra95 12 лет назад

    is the S3 the international version used in this video?

  • @dog1619
    @dog1619 12 лет назад

    I don't know if the new software does the same thing but with android 2.3.3 you can double tap and it zooms.

  • @BewareSabotage
    @BewareSabotage 12 лет назад

    The camera app "launching" faster on the 4S means nothing: all iOS apps include a screenshot of the app in their bundle that shows when the icon is tapped. This gives the illusion of the app being loaded before it actually is.

  • @Stephen35951
    @Stephen35951 12 лет назад

    Should I get an iPhone 4S or a Samsung GALAXY S III or a HTC One X

  • @EXRaidLeader
    @EXRaidLeader 12 лет назад

    The iPhone is also available on Sprint not just AT&T & Verizon.

  • @iamHariharan0220
    @iamHariharan0220 12 лет назад

    how would it be..the s3 got more color resolution than iphone4s....?

  • @Jimbahiya
    @Jimbahiya 12 лет назад

    If you're going to say that, you should post a link.

  • @Dexion845
    @Dexion845 12 лет назад

    This is a WONDERFULL demonstration of why Quad Core does not always beat dual core, I for one am happy that in the U.S. we are getting 2GB of RAM and a faster Snapdragon S4 Dual core SOC, the S III in this test is not opening apps much faster than the 4S and its Dual Core is almost half the speed.

  • @user-qf6om9tn7u
    @user-qf6om9tn7u 7 лет назад +2

    Whoa, im the latest comment, all of the Comments are 3-4 years old.

  • @therthace
    @therthace 12 лет назад

    you dont test internet load speed like video above. two devices are too close to make signal disruption

  • @h0rnedfi3nd
    @h0rnedfi3nd 12 лет назад

    What I still don't understand is how is a comparison between a 2011 phone and 2012 phone supposed to matter? It's clear w/o any tests that the S3 will beat iphone 4s. If you really want to see a fair comparison, maybe you should wait for the iphone 5.
    I happen to own an S2 and iphone and I think these tests really don't matter.
    Does it really matter if the shutter opens with 1s faster on the S3 than on iphone or viceversa? If so, why?

  • @GunskiMod
    @GunskiMod 12 лет назад

    You're comparing screen tint when you can change the screen temperature on the GSIII. It all comes down to personal opinion.

  • @incubus26jc1
    @incubus26jc1 12 лет назад

    He did all of his tests with a live wallpaper running in the background on the s3. It still won.

  • @writemebbie
    @writemebbie 12 лет назад

    i'm not a tech genuis and as much as i love the galaxy s3, can you please say something about the music player?

  • @rogue350
    @rogue350 12 лет назад

    The SGSIII screen annoying because it doesn't get very bright? I think the only time I really need a bright display is in the sun and that isn't a problem with the HD AMOLED so I guess it won't matter.

  • @Dexion845
    @Dexion845 12 лет назад

    Don't worry they actually give you a color mode setting so you can have it look more 'LCD' like if you want. I guess he forgot to mention that.

  • @The0311biff
    @The0311biff 12 лет назад

    On the video test, why does the android (beep) come through on the (what is labeled) as the iPhone 4s video?
    Also, I agree with the other comments that it says something that ALL new phones coming out. The iPhone 4S is a little more than a year old and is just now starting to feel out-dated. The GSIII will be out dated in a few months....whether by the NEW iPhone or another Android device.

  • @uChakide
    @uChakide 12 лет назад

    Why do reviewers always complain about the s3 colour, yet they never change the settings from vibrant to natural?

  • @JoeJacksonGT3
    @JoeJacksonGT3 12 лет назад

    This comparison doesn't matter a bit to me. I'm a fan of both for small reasons. I'm a tech nerd, so I love rooting my S2 and I really enjoy the screen size. I like the iphone for it's syncing ability to my employees macs to gather data quickly. I will wait to upgrade when the next big thing comes out after the S III as my S2 seems as quick, or quicker than any current phone, and it never lets me down.. personal preference everyone. No reason to get into a dumb argument each time :)

  • @DeltaRaven97
    @DeltaRaven97 12 лет назад

    say what? Why would they remove flash from android?

  • @ryankoch38
    @ryankoch38 12 лет назад

    personally, i like the vibrant colors more than the old-looking pictures from the iphone. maybe its just me but it does seem to pop out more with the samsung display.

  • @thejrbunker5740
    @thejrbunker5740 12 лет назад

    The thing that gets me about people is when they the s3's too vibrant but you have an option in the phone to make the colors more natural like the iPhone or more colorful so its not like your limited to the default coloration. Check your facts.

  • @wilproz
    @wilproz 12 лет назад

    I think its to control the noise. The quality is fantabuloso on GSI. It gets super loud though, so that's probably why they made it quieter, if he went to a crowd of people it would probably be easier to hear him over everyone else.

  • @iced0knife
    @iced0knife 12 лет назад

    I have the 4s and when i play games i can't see what im doing because my thumb covers half the screen. I am going to get the s3 in a week or so, all the reviews i watched shows that it's boss

  • @ceejapartofdatM6
    @ceejapartofdatM6 12 лет назад

    What the fuck happen to video sound on the galaxy s 3. Very disappointed by the 1080p sound . Looks like its still a toss up between this or the HTC One X

  • @joeyomega117
    @joeyomega117 12 лет назад

    it matters so much how fast the calander app opens for me....

  • @draakisback
    @draakisback 12 лет назад

    the major issue with comparing phones or even computers using the same apps but under different operating systems is the fact that no matter what, each is using a different programming language. One of the apps could be naively java and one could be not.

  • @DonnKnee
    @DonnKnee 12 лет назад

    also at 6:52 the pinch to zoom was not smooth on the iphone, it stuttered

  • @Ben7seven7
    @Ben7seven7 12 лет назад

    Can't say I agree with you regarding the design of the iPhone 4S being dated looking. It looks no more dated than any other phone on the market. And the S3 basically looks like a cross between a iPhone 4 and 3GS design with the white or black color, with silver trim. And how can you speak of bulky in terms of thickness when the S3 may be very slightly thinner but it is huge which makes it for a more bukly clunky feel. You are completely right about the back glass being a liability.

  • @HotMetal82
    @HotMetal82 12 лет назад

    The bit about how the colors compare was flawed.
    Galaxy S3 has settings for the screen mode. Modes like "natural" and "movie" which are much more accurate then the default normal mode which is very oversaturated.

  • @boers93
    @boers93 12 лет назад

    There is a major difference in the sound of the video comparison. The sound of the S3 is just like an old telephone and the iPhone sounds just as the good sound quality of the camera recording the previous video.

  • @Guyforkz
    @Guyforkz 12 лет назад

    it's funny how the iPhone 4S is dual core, under clocked a whole year out of date, but still holds up against the latest and greatest quad core Android handset? lol.

  • @HateUTub
    @HateUTub 12 лет назад

    I disagree with the comment about the iPhone looking dated. I believe that the iPhones design was ahead of its time, so therefore is still relevant today. You can't say that something looks dated simply because it's not changed in a couple of generations...

  • @EMCHost
    @EMCHost 12 лет назад

    I've gotten the iPhone 4 and 4S multiple times for testing, business, etc. I thought maybe it was time for a change so I got the Galaxy S3 and so far i'm liking it. Maybe if the screen was a LITTLE bit smaller, just a LITTLE bit. It would be the perfect size.
    I just don't like the stock android keyboard, but install the apple keyboard emulator makes the experience better.
    Overall, i'm liking the S3 so far.

  • @electronicboy5
    @electronicboy5 12 лет назад

    yes there is a shortcut for camera on the iphone on the lock screen

  • @tsrzealot
    @tsrzealot 12 лет назад

    Not really a surprise considering that neither the mobile OSes nor games/apps are really optimized for quadcores, yet...

  • @celtic2185
    @celtic2185 12 лет назад

    Well i would think the Iphone 4s would have more sales considering the S3 came out may 29, and the 4s has been out on the market since October 14th...

  • @Mariachi842
    @Mariachi842 12 лет назад

    why does the audio quality suck so much on the S3? it's a 1080p video, but audio quality is like shit

  • @Onolisciousyes
    @Onolisciousyes 12 лет назад

    How do people drop their iPhone. Have had my iPhone 4 since launch day no case, no invisshield and no cracks.

  • @tsrzealot
    @tsrzealot 12 лет назад

    Yeah and then showed an animation until the info was displayed, which was then exactly at the same time as the S3.

  • @DeltaRaven97
    @DeltaRaven97 12 лет назад

    I don't know if you realized what i meant. I meant that if it was good for you then great, but it's not for everyone. My first comment was when everyone was bashing samsung so i tried to put a stop to it. If the phone is good for you then great. But when people start to bash companies because they compete with their favorite company, It gets annoying. Like i said, i'm not forcing people to switch, if you like your iphone then good for you. I just perfer the s3 over the iphone.

  • @sweetcheex
    @sweetcheex 12 лет назад

    Getting the S3 myself, 4s is too pricey on contract and in general. Apple have however did an amazing job of utilizing the CPU power in the 4s. Also people forget the 4s was out a fair bit before the S3, I like em both personally :) Sound quality of recording on a 4s is better in my opinion.

  • @HeirOfGlee
    @HeirOfGlee 12 лет назад

    But everyone was obviously bashing apple to, bashing back won't help at all it will just make you a fanboy. And I don't have an iPhone I'm comparing phones on which is better for me, I may be leaning towards the iPhone more but I believe in researching deeply and every video I go through (and blog) and I kid you not is 2/3 fanboys bashing apple and I expected better for some reason. I'm used to apple fanboys and now that is not even the matter

  • @aeonjoey3d
    @aeonjoey3d 12 лет назад

    comparing an iPhone 3G to an HTC G1 would also be an unmatched comparison. they aren't comparable regardless. I saw one video comparing S Voice to Siri and the person said S Voice 'beat' siri because it got the info on the screen faster in some instances - where on siri the animation was what put it 'behind', milliseconds aren't exactly comparisons. :\

  • @LookMaNoBrains
    @LookMaNoBrains 12 лет назад

    You didn't turn off the bluetooth on the iPhone 4S, This is wasting resources on the iPhone 4S as it is constantly discovering for bluetooh devices to link with, thus slows down the iPhone 4S wifi performance on the browser test.
    This is a bad oversight.

  • @Dexion845
    @Dexion845 12 лет назад

    Ok besides what the iPhone fan is saying in this review.
    Fact: Galaxy S III loads web pages faster and loads them into 4.8 inches of screen compared to 3.5 inches
    Fact: Opens apps faster
    Fact: You can adjust the color intensity
    Fact: No I don't see any pixels sorry buddy (I do see the pixels on this video though)
    Fact: You have a better video and picture viewing experience
    Fact: You went over about a 5th of the GS III's features and went over all of the iPhone's

  • @str8harry
    @str8harry 12 лет назад

    Probably because this video was in June when the iPhone 5 didn't come out for like 3 months after...

  • @RobertFahlman
    @RobertFahlman 12 лет назад

    The iPhone mic sounds way better than the S3, but quality is far superior on the S3 compared to the iPhone. The iPhone was also fairly shaky (even after you had a good grip on it). It's weird though because I remember watching a video of the S2 vs. the 4S and I remember the S2 being much better in almost everything, the S3 is great but a disappointment.

  • @chltmdwp
    @chltmdwp 12 лет назад

    this is what I don't get to all the people who reviews phones, how the hell do you know if the picture is oversaturated or not if you haven't seen it in real world? That John Mayer dude too, how do you know if he had tanned skin or paler skin at the time the photo was taken?? to me AMOLED looks better than regular LCD. once you've seen true black, you can't go back!

  • @Dexion845
    @Dexion845 12 лет назад

    No, the iPhone 4S has the A5 Chip you're talking about the A5X which is just only on the "New iPad" now. This chip will probably be on the next iPhone though

  • @AAK8164
    @AAK8164 12 лет назад

    Really really good comparison best ive seen so far!

  • @TheLegendofGiizmo
    @TheLegendofGiizmo 12 лет назад

    outdated? seriously doubt it, the 4s has a waaaay better design than the SGSIII. The iphone isn't locked down like everyone's been saying, i have a rooted galaxy nexus, and i can do everything that i do on my nexus on my iphone(and yes the nexus is waaaaaaay better than the SGSIII overall). Not hating on the SGSIII just clearing up rumors that been goin on for a while that aren't true

  • @HeirOfGlee
    @HeirOfGlee 12 лет назад

    whats so bad about small screens, If I want a wide screen for anything other than calling someone ill get a handheld. I need my phone to fit in my pocket, I need it to be heavy so i know its there,the camera is way better for me, if I want customization I can pretty much hack it and restore it with no problem its not illegal i agree on batteries but what phone don't charge over night nowadays and the costumer service is wonderful. So I win cause its for me, no baby else I'm forcing this on.

  • @SyncF
    @SyncF 12 лет назад

    @antondanielnagy Hey, i'm watching this on my phone can you tell me which is which please?

  • @Awayze
    @Awayze 12 лет назад

    I'm a iPhone 4 user and yes the S3 has better hardware by a bit BUT ICS is only made for dual core phones hence why the S3 is hardly any faster than the S2, the tiny bit of negligible increase in speed is due to each core having 200mhz or more.
    iPhone 5 here i come

  • @Dexion845
    @Dexion845 12 лет назад

    My friends have crashes and disconnected calls on their iPhone 4S with 5.1 all the time, it happens.

  • @AstraVex
    @AstraVex 12 лет назад

    The iPhone back casing cracks? o_O
    Wow, now I'm REALLY glad to have a Samsung Galaxy S3.

  • @Gamez4eveR
    @Gamez4eveR 12 лет назад

    GTA3 test was unfair. iOs never had real multitasking (It just freezes apps in background, excellent test would be launch Angry birds on both, minimize, wait a bit, maximize, the music on galaxy s3 will progress further), while android does real multitasking (Or let's say just does multitasking).

  • @DeltaRaven97
    @DeltaRaven97 12 лет назад

    the reason that android needs more cores was so it could excel at multitasking, The iphone doesn't do as much as android so it doesn't need the cores. The multitasking was great on both phones but s3 won. We don't need a comparison to know that the s3 is better, it's newer with better tech. These comparisons don't matter, we need to see what the iphone 5 brings to the table. (Plus, the galaxy nexus beat the iphone, it wasn't the processor, but android 4.0. Software was what won the day.)

  • @jk-qm7lh
    @jk-qm7lh 11 лет назад

    Should I get iPhone 4s or samsung galaxy s3

  • @ujjwalbas
    @ujjwalbas 12 лет назад

    i don't know why every reviewers say safari is one of the best browser.. it is smooth but only about 3.2 inch of the screen is useful.. It should not even be compared to android's browser..

  • @BryceRamdeo
    @BryceRamdeo 12 лет назад

    I have the Samsung S3. I like it a lot better than the iPhone. One thing is that it feels so much smoother.Its my first android phone, and it is spectacular.To me the iphone 5 width should of been updated too, cause it being 4 inches makes it look awkward for being longer without any width difference. But it is slimmer which is good. I learned that android phones has better hard ware build in them. Cause i can actually run higher demand applications.

  • @OrlyOnofre
    @OrlyOnofre 12 лет назад

    Nice that you made a video comparison, and seems that the SGIII does video nicely
    it would be nice if you compare camera (photos) performance, specially in low light

  • @MKBEntertainment
    @MKBEntertainment 12 лет назад

    software has limits.
    "i pay for quality instead of quantity (processor power/cores)"
    s3 has better/more of
    1. infinite contrast ratio
    2. display being upgraded ppi and much harder due to sub pixel design.
    3. Quad
    4. Upgraded OS thru OTA and constant development.
    5. Desktop
    6. Flexibility and choice.
    YOU ARE PAYING FOR AN INFERIOR PRODUCT. AND CLEARLY YOU ARE AN APPLE FANBOI
    And yeah it does work. It work slower... and not as nice screen and ram and so on.....

  • @CescKragge
    @CescKragge 12 лет назад

    Definitely better sound quality on the iPhone 4s in the last comparison, but both had great video quality. I'd definitely choose the Galaxy S III, though, because for me, it beat the iPhone 4s on every other aspect, but that's probably only down to preferences. Both great phones, undoubtedly, but I'm not really a fan of the iPhone; just not my cup of tea. However, right now, my two favourite phones are the Xperia S and One S, which might be surprising, but that's down to taste. Great comparison!

  • @iCasperDK
    @iCasperDK 12 лет назад

    The mic sucks on the SG3

  • @Tussharmufc
    @Tussharmufc 12 лет назад

    He said it right. Weird time to compare. I pretty sure the new iPhone will be better. But iPhone 4S (a year old phone) still did give SIII a good fight.!

  • @vovelus
    @vovelus 12 лет назад

    You know what, I have an iPhone 4S and I pretty enjoy using it... You all think that a bigger screen or more ram makes the phone, but it's not so... And who the fuck needs a micro SD slot when you have 64 GB internal storage O_o...
    I saw some comments saying that almost all apps on iPhone are paid apps, and there is no flash player and lack of customization. It's because Apple has baned most customization apps, but simply by jailbreaking the iPhone you can get more things then Android can offer.

  • @Wepaorale
    @Wepaorale 12 лет назад

    thats not fair,you have a live wallpaper on the s3,if u put a stock wallpaper the s3 will be way faster

  • @Constantine91
    @Constantine91 3 года назад

    funniest thing to check old tech videos.

  • @The0311biff
    @The0311biff 12 лет назад

    Maybe. Keep in mind the iPhone 4S came out more than a year ago. A lot of people like myself will tolerate Apple's restrictions vice having a laggy OS that always crashes. Although, Jelly Bean looks FANTASTIC!!! My boys at apple better be up to something!!

  • @Capp2015
    @Capp2015 12 лет назад

    the pebble blue is accually, a lighter blue around the bezzle

  • @FreshPayck
    @FreshPayck 11 лет назад

    "compare them in everyway that matters" first test-how fast it turns on

  • @draakisback
    @draakisback 12 лет назад

    Heres the major difference between the Iphone and the SGS3... even if stock of the SGS3 was slower then the Iphone 4s, you can modify the actual rom of the phone and thus get extra speed out of it where as with the iPhone you simply get what comes with it...

  • @cwose
    @cwose 12 лет назад

    For camera speed, the Iphone doesn't have a shortcut directly from the unlock screen, so no competition there anyway :P

  • @iLYK2PWN
    @iLYK2PWN 12 лет назад

    i dont get this whole "LCD" is more natural arguement, firstly it doesnt really matter unless your into photography and to me since ive been using super amoled for years i would say that the LCD looks washed out, not natural, thats just my opinion, and also, any display that cant display black and displays it as "Greyish" isnt really natural in the first place :P Basically, LCD better for reading, SuperAmoled better for overall viewing of videos photos and multimedia etc.

  • @MrYourThoughts
    @MrYourThoughts 12 лет назад

    Wow, according to these test, there were no noticeable differences. Just physical hardware.

  • @Nintendy123
    @Nintendy123 12 лет назад

    3:17 ''the Galaxy S3 is thinner than the iPhone 4S..'' YOU DON'T SAY.

  • @Griegalo
    @Griegalo 12 лет назад

    when do the Iphone 5 come out? :D

  • @Lincriss
    @Lincriss 12 лет назад

    Was that video made in one shot? Impressive ^^
    iPhone doesn't look that bad for a phone that's replaced soon

  • @warnerpinz
    @warnerpinz 12 лет назад

    You are definitely wrong dude. Try to search on the web about "Do iOS Apps Crash More Than Android Apps?"

  • @darkenedbiscuit
    @darkenedbiscuit 12 лет назад

    S-Voice was just an improvement of the voice recognition software already in android!
    Also Apple took the notification tray from android

  • @Apertravel
    @Apertravel 12 лет назад

    GTA3 has a frame rate cap on android. Until the devs update it the GS3/One X won't run at their full FPS potential. It's almost half of what the SGS3 can do. Not Samsung's fault, developers fault.

  • @DeltaRaven97
    @DeltaRaven97 12 лет назад

    The iphone i used wasn't a fake. Haven't you seen that iOS users experience more crashes than android users? So the galaxy s3 crashes in the video, just because it crashes here doesn't mean it crashes all the time. My friend downloaded N.O.V.A. 2 on his iphone and it crashed and wouldn't load at all. It messed up his iphone and Apple made him buy another one for $250. I bet you never even tried a galaxy s3, so just admit that the 4s lost and wait for the iphone 5 and the real comparison.

  • @aeonjoey3d
    @aeonjoey3d 12 лет назад

    NOT knocking android, just pointing out an interesting quirk: so far I've watched 6 SIII vs iPhone4 videos on youtube, and in every single one, the SIII had a crash at least once during the testing. :\

  • @Cussbagz
    @Cussbagz 12 лет назад

    So a white iPhone with stainless steel band looks dated... But a white Samsung with a silver band looks "beautiful"? CSB

  • @UnifiedGlory
    @UnifiedGlory 12 лет назад

    ironically at 8:02, there was a galaxy s3 ad on the iphone 4s :D

  • @HoltonStudios
    @HoltonStudios 12 лет назад

    yer how did u know! STALKER!
    anyways at the end of the video he was filming with a iphone and samsung and the sound quality was amazing for iphone and the samsung was echoing. also i have an iphone and you get more detail in the camera. also all over the internet people are saying iphone camera is better. like a boss.

  • @llmbs
    @llmbs 12 лет назад

    S3 tells you of a crash iphone doesnt it goes back to home screen so its null

  • @ThomasVanhelden
    @ThomasVanhelden 12 лет назад

    It's not about people liking the phone. It's about people thinking/saying the phone is better than the other.

  • @DeltaRaven97
    @DeltaRaven97 12 лет назад

    actually i thought they were about the same, siri was faster a few times and s-voice was faster a few times, They were both on a wifi network and i wouldn't say either had an advantage. Be careful on youtube though. Some people put the s3 on 3g so it's slower. The truth is that they are about the same.