@@NinjaKiller999 that’s cool but it still makes me happy cause I don’t normally hear an exceptional amount of cheering for her but they did her good this time
This is one of their best scenarios, from being called "without expressions" and "looking like robots" since their debut, to being truly great performers. I really feel improvements because now they devour the stage with their gaze and with simple gestures, it is a pleasure to see how they improve every day and will continue to improve.
I think the styling of the girls, especially Giselle, have been great this era. Gigi really really shines this era. If you listen to Drama with the hidden vocals amplified, you can hear Gigi and Ningning basically sing the whole song in harmony and layering. Gigi does top line and bottom line harmony and it stands out so much. Gigi and Ningning are like the backbone of the group. Like Yeri/Wendy in Red Velvet. They sing the harmonies beautifully throughout all of their songs. Without them, I don’t think it would be as effective. Gigi plays a pivotal role in Aespa and I do think she deserves so much more credit than she gets.
@@lou-anneenoto7823she’s the girl with bangs and a spikey bun-she’s the main rapper and vocalist. Ningning is the first main vocal and a dancer with her hair pulled back in a ponytail. The girl with red hair is Winter, main vocal (was lead vocal but they made her main recently), dancer. Long dark hair that’s down is Karina, main dancer, lead vocal/rapper, and the leader of the girls. Hope this helps you!!
totally agree!! i actually like so so much that people started pay attention to ning2 and gigi more in this era...i mean all of them are insanely talented but only the moment sm start treating girls equally, aespa will be able to reach their full potential also can you please tell why yeri and wendy are backbone of rv?? i just recently started to stan them and don't know much bout group but i'm really curious
seeing the girls in 4k, singing LIVE.. oh my god theyre so unbelievably good!!! its true what they say about SM artists (eat CDs for breakfast) due to the fact that they sound exactly like the recording! so proud of my girls, i cant wait to see more of them!!
@@unniemoon95 can i ask how can you tell? i can hear them breathing so i feel like it’s live? (not trying to argue i just want to know how people can tell if something is live/not live!)
@@ephemismIm not sure they did it live, but it sounds like a pre-recording. I dont have any doubt the vocals of SM artists, they're all so talented. Because i've been a fan of SM artists since when TVXQ was still five members ✌🏻
@@ephemism it’s ok! Whenever someone sings live with a backtrack it sounds like their are two layers; when singing and rapping members have to sing shout due to dancing (you can also tell when the members are dancing you should be able to hear imperfections due to fast movements). Another way is if you look at facial expressions their faces should never look relaxed especially when singing a high note. Hope that helps ☺️
look at Winters neck when shes doing the highnote (2:53), you can see that her neck is totally normal, but when she would be singing live then her neck would kinda move inwards, which is not the case. (Also the breathing and blowing sounds are edited/added to make it look as if it would be live)
To me, this has to be the best performance so far! The energy of Aespa and the public, the vocals, and the lighting was amazing!!!!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 This stage was the most dramatic so far ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥👌🏻
Karina is really killing the facial expressions this time for it and I’m stunning! And Ningning consistently killing it as usual! This comeback was really good for them all. They give it their all. I hope the continue like this, new levels for them!
Hey so I have a question about your comment. I personally think Karina has literally no variation in facial expressions whatsoever. I really wish she expressed more with her facial expressions beyond a blank/staring face. Maybe I'm missing them? Could you point out where she's making any different expressions? Ty!
@@thelastmoonchild. her expressions in the whole first rap are different and being according to the lyrics, weird that you didn’t see it when it’s the first thing in the performance but let see keep telling u Her expressions changing the whole first chorus, idk if you want her to smile and then put “angry face” to see the difference or what but let me keep😃 Her expressions changing in NN raps in the back(idk if you just ignored it) But you know what happen with people like u saying she only have “black face” is you and many other fans are use to idols being cringe and 0 versatile and doing the exact same moves with their face that are 1, having a smile face, 2, being sassy and wink every 2 second(like NN is doing in this whole performance with 0 variation and just wink), that’s why you can see idols like NN watched kpop stans just liking and thinking someone is a good performer for doing wink, act sassy or smile in the stage and I’m sure she just started to doing all that to make yall happy But at the end of the day we can agree or not in this and the whole “stage presence” situation is just more subjective than objetive, and for what I see people love Karina’s expressions and that’s why she’s the one that gets viral in every comeback and the most popular and not just being hyper(like other idols) by kpop stans that don’t even support those idols in their individual activities 🥰
EXCUSE ME??!?!?!? WHY DO THEY SLAY SO HARD!!!! I really love how expressive they are with this stage and the outfits AHHH so prettyyyy!! They really showed their talents making them so cool! Thank you for this wonderful stage my ae girls!!
@@zareennawar7951 srry i didn't mean to say ur newly appreciative i was just celebrating how there's more and more supportive comments for her every video ❤️
Really love the styling for Giselle here, it suits her so much and really catches my attention. Also, I noticed great improvement in Winter's facial expressions and stage presence, she was so cool! The other members were stunning as well❤️
I kinda wish Ning Ning would take over more of the bridge part cause I find her belts more soothing. Like it’s powerful but calm and it doesn’t overpower anything.
@@sima_cianea I don’t mean any disrespect but the reason she had many views was because she looked pretty, many people agreed that she she just had a straight face in that era when she wasn’t singing, there are even whole videos explaining who had stage presence and she wasn’t in the 1st place.
@@rftg1793 most comments under her fancams are about her satisfying dancing skills. Jisoo is considered the most pretty in blackpink but her fancams are not as popular as other members'. Ning2 is also praised for her visuals during last few comebacks, but nobody watches her fancams Toxic solo stans love to diminish Winter because she's very good at everything (she can compete with Karina in dancing and Ning2 in vocals) so I'm not surprised that people are trying to find SOMETHING where Winter can be weak.
I'm loving how healthy they look this comeback! Last comeback they seemed very thin and tired, but this one they all look so happy and healthy and full of energy. I'm so happy to see them all shining and having a great time!
yes as others have said, I think this is the best performance thus far. WOW WINTER what is going on...she stood out SO MUCH!!!! Her stage presence was incredible, she has come a long way.....but even in the past she always stood out to me. great job !!🖤💛💣
SM has always had great vocal groups, for many years I thought they had peaked with Red Velvet's vocal line of Joy, Seulgi and Wendy but aespa really have stole the show for me, every single one of them is a great vocalist, I particularly love Karina's voice, it's not the strongest in the group but she has such a great sound to her voice, it lacks vibrato which gives it an almost spoken style which for some reason sounds so good
This is Ningnings best outfit !suit her so well !!!! So sassy So slay！ 👢 and her hair style sooo damn good ！and her last parrot the songs facial expression is 🔥 🎉🎉
Como se nota la mejoria en estos 3 años desde el debut, realmente estoy orgullosa de mis bebas, jamas me voy arrepentir de stannear a estas reinas♡ LAS 4 TODO TERRENO, SUS EXPRESIONES SUS BAILES, TODO EXCELENTE 👌
the camera director and staff on this show deserve a raise !!!!! all the cuts, zooms and everything was FLAWLESS, the quality is amazing too, no blinding lights to the point u can’t even see their faces, no shakey camera work, no awkward angles. so so good.
Giselle with her hair style is so pretty aaah she looks unreal like anime. thank you to the hairstylist and for the future please give her another beautiful hair style
![[4K] 241130 멜론뮤직어워드(MMA 2024) Armageddon(아마겟돈) #aespa #에스파 #Winter #윈터 직캠](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qRV7KwnXrgw/mqdefault.jpg)
![(ENG SUB) Black Mamba + Spicy - aespa [영동대로 K-POP Concert] | KBS WORLD TV](/img/1.gif)
let's go, Ning-ning. Attitude, expression on point!
Always!
Frrr
She never miss, ever since debut she's always been consistent
Ning Ning's "I'm a stunner" part is soooo addictive.
This is Giselle's best looks. My girl finally get a proper outfit
Giselle 🥰🥰
Exacto! Por que a Giselle siempre la tratan asi? Ella tambien forma parte del grupo y es chevere!!!! 😊
@@atchuuuyes I love her hairstyles. It does complete her looks
she's a great dancer
I wish the hairstyle was different..
3:14 omg so obsessed with this part ✨
also their stage presence, hairstyle and outfit are incredible especially Winter and Ningning’s ones 🩷
Sammee I love that part
The end of this song is so fire
Yo igual amo esa parte, no para de repetirse en mi cabeza
The amount of crowd cheering for Giselle at 1:40 made me so happyyyyy
often crowd cheers for kpop shows are pre-recorded and added in post editing
@@NinjaKiller999 that’s cool but it still makes me happy cause I don’t normally hear an exceptional amount of cheering for her but they did her good this time
we litterally can see the crowd here so@@NinjaKiller999
NINGNING & WINTER ARE SO STUNNING!!!
This is one of their best scenarios, from being called "without expressions" and "looking like robots" since their debut, to being truly great performers. I really feel improvements because now they devour the stage with their gaze and with simple gestures, it is a pleasure to see how they improve every day and will continue to improve.
NINGNING LOOKS SO STUNNING HERE!! the makeup and the style i love it so much she's so pretty
I think the styling of the girls, especially Giselle, have been great this era. Gigi really really shines this era. If you listen to Drama with the hidden vocals amplified, you can hear Gigi and Ningning basically sing the whole song in harmony and layering. Gigi does top line and bottom line harmony and it stands out so much. Gigi and Ningning are like the backbone of the group. Like Yeri/Wendy in Red Velvet. They sing the harmonies beautifully throughout all of their songs. Without them, I don’t think it would be as effective. Gigi plays a pivotal role in Aespa and I do think she deserves so much more credit than she gets.
wich one is Giselle ? and who's the girl with orange/red hair ?
Thats' winter Gigi is the one with a black bun and orange stripes in her hair@@lou-anneenoto7823
@@lou-anneenoto7823giselle black hair with bangs in two buns and red hair is winter
@@lou-anneenoto7823she’s the girl with bangs and a spikey bun-she’s the main rapper and vocalist. Ningning is the first main vocal and a dancer with her hair pulled back in a ponytail. The girl with red hair is Winter, main vocal (was lead vocal but they made her main recently), dancer. Long dark hair that’s down is Karina, main dancer, lead vocal/rapper, and the leader of the girls. Hope this helps you!!
totally agree!! i actually like so so much that people started pay attention to ning2 and gigi more in this era...i mean all of them are insanely talented but only the moment sm start treating girls equally, aespa will be able to reach their full potential
also can you please tell why yeri and wendy are backbone of rv?? i just recently started to stan them and don't know much bout group but i'm really curious
Ningning looks gorgeous!
Giselle and Karina here are gorgeous
Love ningning and winter ,so pretty
This is the best Ninging's facial expression!!!! Fire!!
NingNing and Winter tho their stage presence in this performance are on fire! And seriously NingNing looks stunning with this hairstyle
My girl Winter her vocals and & stage presence GOD😍😍😍🫶🏻❤️🔥❤️🔥
Her expression improved so damn hard like i watch the first 5s over and over 😭
Fr.
Winter is soo pretty ❤
@@Naomisuwa1910 absolutely I’m so happy for her🥰🥰🫶🏻
I love NPOP for not having skin filters. Its so refreshing to see idols beautiful natural tone. Aespa always bringing the dramaaaa
Exacto
Giselle's visuals are insanely beautiful 🖤🌻
NingNing she SLAYYYYYY and STUNNER !!!!!
NING's BEAUTY IS TRULY THE CLIMAX 😭😭
ningnings stage presence is UNREAL
seeing the girls in 4k, singing LIVE.. oh my god theyre so unbelievably good!!! its true what they say about SM artists (eat CDs for breakfast) due to the fact that they sound exactly like the recording! so proud of my girls, i cant wait to see more of them!!
They’re not actually singing live which is a shame as everyone knows these girls can sing.
@@unniemoon95 can i ask how can you tell? i can hear them breathing so i feel like it’s live? (not trying to argue i just want to know how people can tell if something is live/not live!)
@@ephemismIm not sure they did it live, but it sounds like a pre-recording. I dont have any doubt the vocals of SM artists, they're all so talented. Because i've been a fan of SM artists since when TVXQ was still five members ✌🏻
@@ephemism it’s ok! Whenever someone sings live with a backtrack it sounds like their are two layers; when singing and rapping members have to sing shout due to dancing (you can also tell when the members are dancing you should be able to hear imperfections due to fast movements). Another way is if you look at facial expressions their faces should never look relaxed especially when singing a high note. Hope that helps ☺️
look at Winters neck when shes doing the highnote (2:53), you can see that her neck is totally normal, but when she would be singing live then her neck would kinda move inwards, which is not the case. (Also the breathing and blowing sounds are edited/added to make it look as if it would be live)
This kind of hairstyle really looks good on Gigi
Winter looks extra beautiful here and her stage presence improve so so so much and I'm love that and like always I'm very proud of her ❤❤
2:28 this part with this fit hairstyle makeup OML!
Ningning Winter OMG their expression so damn good
Ningning absolutely ate. ALL of them did but omg Ningning looks stunning. I'm dead.
To me, this has to be the best performance so far! The energy of Aespa and the public, the vocals, and the lighting was amazing!!!!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 This stage was the most dramatic so far ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥👌🏻
Ningning beauty is another level!!!
GISELLE LOOKS STUNNING HERE @1:24 & 2:24 🤩
Winter is slaying this comeback by far
Karina is really killing the facial expressions this time for it and I’m stunning! And Ningning consistently killing it as usual! This comeback was really good for them all. They give it their all. I hope the continue like this, new levels for them!
Hey so I have a question about your comment. I personally think Karina has literally no variation in facial expressions whatsoever. I really wish she expressed more with her facial expressions beyond a blank/staring face. Maybe I'm missing them? Could you point out where she's making any different expressions? Ty!
@@thelastmoonchild. her expressions in the whole first rap are different and being according to the lyrics, weird that you didn’t see it when it’s the first thing in the performance but let see keep telling u
Her expressions changing the whole first chorus, idk if you want her to smile and then put “angry face” to see the difference or what but let me keep😃
Her expressions changing in NN raps in the back(idk if you just ignored it)
But you know what happen with people like u saying she only have “black face” is you and many other fans are use to idols being cringe and 0 versatile and doing the exact same moves with their face that are 1, having a smile face, 2, being sassy and wink every 2 second(like NN is doing in this whole performance with 0 variation and just wink), that’s why you can see idols like NN watched kpop stans just liking and thinking someone is a good performer for doing wink, act sassy or smile in the stage and I’m sure she just started to doing all that to make yall happy
But at the end of the day we can agree or not in this and the whole “stage presence” situation is just more subjective than objetive, and for what I see people love Karina’s expressions and that’s why she’s the one that gets viral in every comeback and the most popular and not just being hyper(like other idols) by kpop stans that don’t even support those idols in their individual activities 🥰
Thumbnail whithout Karina? NPOP haters Karina?
NingNing so so beautiful ❤
Ning ning so beautiful and cute. i like vocal, attitude and expression ning ning.
Ningning is the most gorgeous thing in the MFing Milky Way like holy sheeeeeeeet!!!!!!!!! 😍😍😍😍😍
EXCUSE ME??!?!?!? WHY DO THEY SLAY SO HARD!!!! I really love how expressive they are with this stage and the outfits AHHH so prettyyyy!! They really showed their talents making them so cool! Thank you for this wonderful stage my ae girls!!
OMG I LOVE NINGNING SOOOOO MUCHHHH
One of gigi's best fits 🙌🙌🙌
im so happy ppl are appreciating her more and more every comeback
@@weewooweewoo906 she's been my bias since their individual introduction videos dropped
@@zareennawar7951 srry i didn't mean to say ur newly appreciative i was just celebrating how there's more and more supportive comments for her every video ❤️
this will be probably my fave stage this era, everyone's glowing
Giselle ate that stage presence🔥. Amazing my girls
the best outfits in the industry currently!!their stylists deserve all the raises👏
3:14 sooo addictive part
NingNing is really beautiful, very attractive
Giselle is a 10 out of 10 honestly 🔥
love love love the mix of Ning Nigh and Winter's vocals starting at 00:40.... sounds so fantastic and the choreo is so cool
NingNing looks so pretty and regal with her ponytail + her outfit ❤
Ning se ve bellísima ❤
❤❤❤
Can we talk about how Ning Ning is dancing on that heels??? And her facial expressions, slaaaaay 🔥
NingNing xinh thật chứ, nhìn cuốn thật sự
Best Performance of AESPA. Queens. Slayed.
Really love the styling for Giselle here, it suits her so much and really catches my attention. Also, I noticed great improvement in Winter's facial expressions and stage presence, she was so cool! The other members were stunning as well❤️
Ningning so stunning❤
Ningning's expressions 🔥 🔥
WINTER😍
I kinda wish Ning Ning would take over more of the bridge part cause I find her belts more soothing. Like it’s powerful but calm and it doesn’t overpower anything.
Samee, Ning Ning high note had always been soothing. But Winter nailed as usual, though I wished they exchanged with each other's high note
00:19 Ningning wink so dangerously 🔥🔥🔥
their vocal are stable.... wow .. AMAZING. 🥳🥳🥳
This is not live
MYs just stop lying to yourself. They havent sung live except during Spicy era and some Us stages.
Their fans can't stop lying to themselves. I can't understand...
this is pre-recorded live vocals, so you can hear the breaths to "fake" live singing
多聽一點live就知道沒開麥、開全麥、預錄的差別了～
This is by far their best comeback. Outfits are hitting , choreo is hitting, stage presence is HITTING. Their confidence is really showing 👏👏👏
so pretty gigi
aespa is such a talented visual group!
Winter has improved her stage presence and it shows gotta give her credit for that
she was always good
@@dampcherry not in their savage era but that’s my opinion and I respect if you have a different opinion
@@rftg1793winter peaked in her popularity during savage era. Her savage fancams has millions views. “No stage presence” lol
@@sima_cianea I don’t mean any disrespect but the reason she had many views was because she looked pretty, many people agreed that she she just had a straight face in that era when she wasn’t singing, there are even whole videos explaining who had stage presence and she wasn’t in the 1st place.
@@rftg1793 most comments under her fancams are about her satisfying dancing skills. Jisoo is considered the most pretty in blackpink but her fancams are not as popular as other members'. Ning2 is also praised for her visuals during last few comebacks, but nobody watches her fancams
Toxic solo stans love to diminish Winter because she's very good at everything (she can compete with Karina in dancing and Ning2 in vocals) so I'm not surprised that people are trying to find SOMETHING where Winter can be weak.
THE STAGE PRESENCE IMPROVED ALOT
Giselle’s so stunning✨
I'm loving how healthy they look this comeback! Last comeback they seemed very thin and tired, but this one they all look so happy and healthy and full of energy. I'm so happy to see them all shining and having a great time!
winter still looks really skinny
@@ruth-gc5jd she does but I think she is naturally. She's always been small
Love Gigi's new hair style
*THEE KARINA looked just breathtaking with Wavy Hair + Black Outfit + Amazing Presence!* 💙🤩💕
2Ning always elegant and pretty
NingNing super stunning banget woooyyy 😮❤❤❤❤
yes as others have said, I think this is the best performance thus far. WOW WINTER what is going on...she stood out SO MUCH!!!! Her stage presence was incredible, she has come a long way.....but even in the past she always stood out to me. great job !!🖤💛💣
Ningning ❤❤❤ slay
2:57 LOVE IT SOOOO MUCH
SM has always had great vocal groups, for many years I thought they had peaked with Red Velvet's vocal line of Joy, Seulgi and Wendy but aespa really have stole the show for me, every single one of them is a great vocalist, I particularly love Karina's voice, it's not the strongest in the group but she has such a great sound to her voice, it lacks vibrato which gives it an almost spoken style which for some reason sounds so good
NingNing My Bias so beautiful & the best vocals ❤❤❤❤
This live ningning very beautiful🔥🔥
I'm so happy to witness Winter's growth and improvement. Also her live vocals never disappoint as usual.
このジゼルかわいすぎる
スタイリング完璧
ダンスも上手くなってる😢
2:28 my favourite part❤ ning looks absolutely stunning
Gigi need more style like this 🎉will be stunting always ❤❤❤
This is Ningnings best outfit !suit her so well !!!! So sassy So slay！ 👢 and her hair style sooo damn good ！and her last parrot the songs facial expression is 🔥 🎉🎉
Ningning main slayer!! Her stage presence is amazing and she looks so gorgeous 💯🔥
ningning looks like a princess
karina looks like a beautiful leader
giselle looks like a queen
winter looks like a goddess
Winter facial expression improved a lot. Queen💅❄️
تسريحة جيجي تجنن وطالعة جميلة فيها، ما أقدر أتخطى لبس وينتر حلوة😭💕✋
닝이 미모 감탄 나온다 ㄷㄷ 갈수록 더더더 이뻐져감
That's one of æspa's best stages❤
ウィンター可愛すぎ！！
ジゼルのミスの驚く顔かわいい！
I'm obsessed with Ningnig appearance 🤩
この冬子とニンニンのスタイリングも最高に似合ってる
Como se nota la mejoria en estos 3 años desde el debut, realmente estoy orgullosa de mis bebas, jamas me voy arrepentir de stannear a estas reinas♡ LAS 4 TODO TERRENO, SUS EXPRESIONES SUS BAILES, TODO EXCELENTE 👌
the camera director and staff on this show deserve a raise !!!!! all the cuts, zooms and everything was FLAWLESS, the quality is amazing too, no blinding lights to the point u can’t even see their faces, no shakey camera work, no awkward angles. so so good.
La estabilidad vocal que manejan DIOSSS🛐🛐🛐
Como tal no cantan en vivo y en varias partes se nota
this song is so addictive, can't help listening to it.
the hand gesture at 3''00 is super amazing!
NINGNING Es perfecta en vivo
Every single member stepped on stage Mad as HELL !!
Giselle with her hair style is so pretty aaah she looks unreal like anime. thank you to the hairstylist and for the future please give her another beautiful hair style
02:23 My goodness Ningning!!! 🔥🔥🔥
I also noticed her that part. She is super duper stunning this stage!!! The camera focused on her a lot!
NingNing❤ she is the meaning of Charisma, she's so beautiful, stunner yes girl!
Ningning truly is the one top stunner ✨✨.
Ningning tem uma presença incrível 🔥👑
ningning is so beautiful. she's the most beautiful here
She’s truly is the most beautiful outfit and hair in this stage!slayyyy
They all are like the fvck is wrong with u 😭💀 Y’all dont rlly seem genuine when Y’all say that
Karina you're so beautiful, so powerfull, so amazing, u great job bby!!!
素晴らしいステージ🌟どの番組のステージも素晴らしい🌟衣装もメイクも素晴らしい🌟