Fourth Hearing: ICJ on Israeli Policies in Occupied Palestinian Territories | United Nations
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 фев 2024
- The International Court of Justice (ICJ), the principal judicial organ of the United Nations, is holding public hearings from 19 to 26 February 2024 on the request for an advisory opinion regarding the Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem. These hearings are taking place at the Peace Palace in The Hague, the seat of the Court, under the presidency of Judge Nawaf Salam, President of the Court. In this session, we heard from Colombia, Cuba, Egypt, United Arab Emirates and United States of America.
This case is not about a ceasefire. Its about clarification on the if the occupation of Palestine, by Israel is STILL considered illegal. They are trying to get that reestablished, because the USA, UK are trying to refute that which was already declared, by saying the current situation changed (via the language of the definitions) that. which is the bulk of the previous case decisions they are presenting. The ICJ decision will impact whether what's being done to Palestine (the occupation itself) is a legal action. This case impacts ALL nations.
Thanks for this brief. I'm so ashamed of the UK 🤦🏻♀️
Sincere apologies are the super glue of lasting relationships. And do make sure your apology is sincere too. Say it and mean it. Don’t bother apologizing if you’re just going to continue doing the things you said sorry for. Never ruin an apology with an excuse. Excuses are not apologies.
💯 💯 💯
The Colombian delegation did very well here. Bravo Andrea Jiménez Herrera 👏
Thank you very much for your excellent speech: for the human rights, for the justice and for the humanity.
Ich danke Ihnen vom Herzen dafuer, dass Sie so klar u so deutlich fuer die Gerechtigkeit u fuer die Humanität gesprochen haben.
In india in karnataka state police stations illegally detained the innocent people more than months without court knowledge and detained persons dead body through on the road and railway track violates the article 21of the constitution of India FBI investigation is necessary through the UNO please protect the peoples in karnataka state
What is meant for you will not pass you by.
Have they been living under a rock…. sorry this is not humane…. Love and Peace for the whole world. 🙏🏽❤️🙏🏽❤️
Global Awareness drive support International Court of Justice UNITED Nation. Join our Peace campaign.
Why ICJ need the whole week to listen it's been 75 years and the whole world watching what's going on genocide genocide genocide
Bravo Cuba.
*Palestine🇵🇸 & Syria🇸🇾 have border disputes with Israel.*
make border agreement & keep Peace!
Well, what they did to Jesus back then + they accused him of being a liar, a sorcerer and so on! Maria accused of being a prosti... and so on! Nothing about these people surprises me! Children, women, old people killing, everything that moves, that doesn't come from God, but shows me the change in God's words of a human!
Do you find in their writings that not even God can change their writings because they are not from God, the changes are not from God! But not all has be changed!
In india day by day fear of gujarat type communal clashes democracy in danger peoples are feared UNO intervention is necessary please protect the secularism in india
So many doors will open for you when you decide it's okay to start over.
ESTAN ATRAPADOS POR COMPLICES DEL TERRORISMO SI NO ES ASI ENTREGUEN A HAMAS Y LIBEREN A LOS SECUESTRADOS
What Israel does, Indonesia also does, namely the illegal and aggressive occupation of the South Moluccas."It has been established that the RMS was a legitimate and recognised State upon proclaiming its independence in 1950 . Central to the discussion of the legitimacy of the right to independence is the fact that the RMS proclaimed its independence before the establishment of the Republic of Indonesia as a unitary State.This leads to the conclusion that the consequent use of force by the Indonesian government
against the RMS was illegal and a violation of international law,more specifically Article 2(4)of the UN Charter " .
Please support the aid in Sudan..
A lot of people are dying at the moment for the lack of food and health products
Thank you very much for your excellent speech: for the human rights, for the justice and for the humanity.
Ich danke Ihnen vom Herzen dafuer, dass Sie so klar und so deutlich - ohne wenn und aber - fuer die Gerechtigkeit u fuer die Humanity gesprochen haben.
How do I find a video of this without traduction ?
The court has not only an advisory role. How can you apply different rule for ICJ and civil courts. Shouldn't we be all affected by binding rulings as all civilians are. In the end civilians are the first and last who are affected by wars.
Hav anyone noticed that when the ICJ give orders THEY FAIL TO BACK IT UP WITH PENALTIES IF THEY DISOBEY? Without announcing a sound disciplinary action if they disobey IT IS NOT A SOLID ORDER.
Pure evil
thank-you Columbia and Cuba
Why Israel depriving from as under laws? Other potentially pertinent instruments considered to constitute part of customary international law include the Genocide Convention (Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, 9 December 1948, 78 U.N.T.S. 277 [hereinafter Genocide Convention]); Statute of the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg (Agreement for the Prosecution and Punishment of the Major War Criminals of the European Axis, and Charter of the International Military Tribunal, Aug. 8, 1945, 82 U.N.T.S. 280). [190] See, e.g., Trial of German Major War Criminals, 1946, Cmd. 6964, Misc. Nº 12, at 65 and United States v. Von Leeb, 11 Trials of War Criminals Before the Nuremberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law Nº 10, at 462 (1950) (recognizing the Hague Regulations of 1907 as norms of customary international law).[191] Four Geneva Conventions, supra notes 36, 67.[192] Prosecutor v. Dusko Tadić, Case Nº IT-94-1, Trial Chamber, Opinion and Judgment, 7 May 1997, para. 577 [hereinafter Tadić TC Judgment] (referring to Tadić AC Decision Jurisdiction, supra note 163, and recognizing the customary nature of the Grave Breach provisions of the Four Geneva Conventions). The Tadić Judgment was appealed to the ICTY Appeals Chamber without challenge to this finding. See The Prosecutor v. Duško Tadić, ICTY Appeals Chamber (15 July 1999). See also U.N. GAOR, 3rd Committee, 23rd Session, UN Doc. A/C.3/SR.1534 (1968), UN GAOR, 25th Session, Supp. Nº 28 UN Doc. A/8028 (1970).[193] See, e.g., ICJ, Nicaragua Case, supra note 188, para. 77; ICTY, Prosecutor v. Delalic, Case Nº IT-96-21-T, Trial Chamber, Judgment, 16 November 1998, paras. 298-306 [hereinafter Celibici TC Judgment], affirmed on this point on appeal, The Prosecutor v. Zejnil Delalić, Zdravko Mucić, Hazim Delić and Esad Landžo, Appeals Chamber Judgment, February 20, 2001 (ICTY), paras. 143-150; ICTR, Prosecutor v. Akayesu, Case Nº ICTR-96-4-T, Trial Chamber I Judgment, 2 September 1998, paras. 604-610 [hereinafter Akayesu, TC Judgment], ICTR Appeals Chamber dismissed appeal June 1, 2001; ICTY, Prosecutor v. Kordic and Cerkez, Case No. IT-95-14/2, Trial Chamber III Decision on the Joint Defence Motion to Dismiss the Amended Indictment for Lack of Jurisdiction based on the limited Jurisdictional Reach of Articles 2 and 3, 2 March 1999, paras. 25-34 [hereinafter Kordic TC Jurisdiction Decision] (recognizing that Article 3 Common to the Four Geneva Conventions constitutes a norm of customary international law).[194] See, e.g., Tadić AC Decision Jurisdiction, supra note 163, paras. 98, 117 (recognizing that the core of Additional Protocol II constitutes customary international law); Akayesu, TC Judgment, supra note 193, paras. 604-610 (recognizing that Article 4 of Additional Protocol II constitutes customary international law); Kordic TC Jurisdiction Decision, supra note 193, para. 31 (recognizing that Articles 51(2) and 52(1) of Additional Protocol I and Article 13(2) of Additional Protocol II constitute customary international law).[195] See generally Michael J Matheson, “The United States position on the relation of customary international law to the 1977 Protocols Additional to the 1949 Geneva Conventions” in Martin D. Dupuis, John Q Heywood and Michèle Y.F. Sarko, The Sixth Annual American Red Cross-Washington College of Law Conference on International Humanitarian Law: a Workshop on Customary International Law and the 1977 Protocols Additional to the 1949 Geneva Conventions, 2 Am. U. J. Int’l L. & Pol. 419 (1987) [hereinafter Matheson]. See also Kordic TC Jurisdiction Decision, supra note 193 (recognizing that Articles 51(2) and 52(1) of Additional Protocol I and Article 13(2) of Additional Protocol II constitute customary international law).[196] See, e.g., Tadić AC Decision Jurisdiction, supra note 163, paras. 98, 117, 132; Kordic TC Jurisdiction Decision, supra note 193 (recognizing that Articles 51(2) and 52(1) of Additional Protocol I and Article 13(2) of Additional Protocol II constitute customary international law). ICJ, Advisory Opinion on the Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, supra note 73,para. 84; Matheson, supra note 195.[197] See, e.g., Tadić AC Decision Jurisdiction, supra note 163, paras. 96-127, citing, inter alia, UN General Assembly Resolution 2444, UN GAOR 23rd Sess., Supp. Nº 18, UN Doc. A/7218 (1968), UN General Assembly Resolution 2675, UN GAOR 25th Sess., Supp. No. 28, UN Doc. A/8028 (1970); IACHR Report on Colombia (1999), supra note 110.[198] See ICJ, Nicaragua Case, supra note 188, para. 77; Tadić AC Decision Jurisdiction, supra note 163, paras 98, 117, 132.[199] IACHR Report on Colombia (1999), supra note 110, at 82, Ch. IV, para. 38. See, e.g., 1907 Hague Convention and Regulations, supra note 177, Article 23(g); First Geneva Convention, supra note 67, Article 50 in fine; Second Geneva Convention, supra note 67, Article 51 in fine; Fourth Geneva Convention, supra note 36, Article 147 in fine; Additional Protocol I, supra note 68, Article 51(1) in fine.[200] See, e.g., Article 3 common to the Four Geneva Conventions; First Geneva Convention, supra note 67, Article 12; Second Geneva Convention, supra note 67, Article 12; Third Geneva Convention, supra note 67, Article 13; Fourth Geneva Convention, supra note 36, Article 14; Additional Protocol I, supra note 68, Article 11; Additional Protocol II, supra note 36, Article 4.
Cabut semua veto amerika serikat. teroris gak pantas buat veto.
Yes!!! The UAE making the point about International Law not being an Al A Carte Menu, but needing to apply to all is the root of the issue, and has always been the root of the issue! Israel has contravened International Law continuously! If it does not _recognise_ the authority of the UN then it needs to accept, by the same token, the UN can't have had the authority to Partition Palestine in the first place - meaning Israel doesn't legally exist!!! So, which is it Israel????
This a sham. The ICJ already ruled on the question of the occupation, that paved the way to the Oslo agreement. Namely, that framework for ending the occupation shall be through negotiations between the parties, and that it shall not be unilateral. In fact, a unilateral or court ordered end to the occupation cannot in good faith end the conflict and would indeed harm chances for true agreement. There exist no prohibitive ruling or international law over the settlement of temporary occupied land, as long as the annexation of land is not make official. Israel never incorporated the occupied territory or moved the lines. Moving the population in the case of an agreement is not unprecedented. India and Pakistan had exchanged millions of citizens, Israel pulled out of the entire Sinai desert and Gaza. As for the Palestinians negotiation claims. In the international stage they claim Israel is not negotiating in good faith, always making excuses not to come and deliberate. The real reason they don't come is that they are scared that their population will not like negotiating with Israel and support for Hamas and other alternatives will raise. Palestinians need a stable, unified government that can make those tough decisions with the backing of their people. This ICJ case and similar efforts and rehitoric strive to undercut the previous ruling, skip negotiations, and get a new contradictory ruling, perhaps leveraging the global sympathy as a result of the catastrophe playing out in Gaza. But remember. The only way to arrive to peace is for both sides to take responsibility, both sides to stop inciting hate, both sides to stop spreading lies, and start working for a common goal.
All aid, both currently commited by the US or planned in the future, to be given to Israel should be directly applied to the assistance of Palestinian people - infrastructre, shelter, hospitals, schools, food, etc... And all illegal settlements on Palestinian land should be vacated and turned over to the Palestian people for immediate and permanent housing to begin restitution for all that has been destroyed and stolen from them over the years.
தலைவரே நான் இறந்த பிறகு தான் பால் ஊத்த வருவீங்க போல என்னத்தலைவரே எனக்கு போன் பன்னச் சொன்னேன் பன்னவே மாட்றீங்க
The delegate from Colombia is an engaging speaker.
I've noticed that with the other female speakers being very animated in both their body language and their verbal language.
Whereas when the blokes speak, 😢 they're just fk'n tedious, repetitive, and straight-up boring, Ohh, and occasionally, they're just downright old-money obnoxious. Not mentioning any names 😅
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
And I mean one sided AI mouthpieces.
We hear all about Palestinian right to self determination and struggle of occupation. What does UN rights laws say about REASPONSIBILITIES of Palestinians? Does struggle have no responsibilities? Does self determination have no responsibilities?
Is evil of HAMAS has no responsibility?
The wall should be bigger and the control of the wall given to the Palestinians
They'll they'll also needing the iron dome type defense shield
World court of general scientific globally peace in the hunder rules regulations human rights council international court justice south Africa United
The United States argument sounds hollow because they have been the supporter of Israel and the obstacle to the Palestinians aspirations. The financial interests of American citizens in Israel plays a big role in denying the existence of a Palestinian state. The state of Palestine should be established right away/immediately and let the honest Israeli citizens work with the Palestinians people to rebuild their country. This will reduce the tensions and hostilities between the two nations, and bonds and trust will be strengthened and friendship formed between the countries and peoples. Trying the same dishonesty that the US is promoting is not going to lead anywhere except to war and violence against the people of Israel and Palestine. We have been down this crazy street for decades.
👋 ICJ.
Please come here to take action against Punjab police sargodha division bhakkar district alongwith its May 2023 1st 10 days dpo for social abusing of THE ENGLISH LITERATURE STUDENTS and CIVIL SERVICE CANDIDATES OF PAKISTAN
If you have an old passport that was issued during the 1970s or 1980s and you have cockroaches and bed bugs in your house take that passport and place it in plastic Ziploc bags and zip them be very careful when you touch them if I were you I wouldn't actually touch them I would use gloves and place them in a ziplock bag
Why does everyone think that only Israel requires to live in peace and security next Palestinian state? Egyptians and Jordanians also scared of a state of Palestine with prominent terror groups connected to Iran inside Palestinian state. That's why Jordanians nor Egyptians want to give help to Palestinian refugees even under current disaster that has unfolded on the area.
That's a disgraceful misrepresentation of their position! The issue is that Palestinians don't have a state and their determination to not give up, and to continue to fight for their rights is obviously not a fight Egypt and Jordan want done from within their borders. If Israel would get out of Palestinian territory and stop it's ongoing play to steal every inch of Palestine for themselves there wouldn't be an issue!!
The icj is taking far too long while innocent die .
Please two stated solution and permanent ceasefire now.
Who is the occupier again? Israel. Enough said.
United States of Hypocrisy
In india in karnataka state IAS officer DK RAVI Brutal murder FBI investigation is necessary through the UNO please to give justice to his mother's and some prompt officers and Docters are under life threat do their job
ICJ please call for a permanent ceasefire now permanent ceasefire now
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Nooooo hamas is overrrr
Sen la religia subprema politiko de Israelo, ne ekzistus hamah,
Is Israel occupying land, have they annexed land, have they conquered land or have they won back land? Win back means to get or have again something that you had before. That describes the current situation best in my opinion.
The steal land.
There is no legal State of Palestine. That's the problem with those who don't know the legality and when speaking of "rule of law". They may be a palestinian people just like a Jew living in another area but they aren't a state unto themselves. Independent politically and economicaly with defined borders. Is Palestine having these? If so then why do they get aid?
Why has palestinian leadership refused becoming a State with all is legalities and borders?
Because it's easier to attack Israel without being held "legally" accountable? Why isn't Hamas there to defend it's actions and ask for a ceasefire as it's turned over it's hostages?
Because Hamas isn't considered a army fighting for a State? Why hasn't Palestine booted out Hamas from it's "state" if it is really a state? Because they agree with what Hamas terrorists do?
Please! The bible is not a secure source.
@@ednadiaz4193 Native americans and australians (The Maori) didn't have a state with defined borders either, yet they are indogenous to their land because they lived there for generations, just like palestinians.
@@laithmughrabi8990 Do they have a State of their own? Don't they too have as much right as Palestinians to be recognized as and independent State? Why didn't anyone make demonstations when they were an oppressed people, when they were suffering genocide at the hands of he oppressor? What did the native Americans get? Tell me? Have they been heard? Where is the justice for us?
Arab world: send troops to free Palestine NOW!
Lol don’t hold your breathe
I ALWAYS KEEP APOLOGIZING TO ICJ LIKE AS ALL PEOPLES OF THE WORLD FOR INVESTING TIME MONEY AND HARD WORK FROM MORNING TILL EVENING INTO SECURING WORLD POPULATION.
The ICJ and these nations have no business intervene this situation, first of all no two state solution should be made because the Palestinians have such hatred for Israel that Oct 7 will occur again there will never be at peace, the ICJ and all the other countries have no business interfering for a ceasefire this is about Israel and Hamas war if they do it will be a big mistake, come on ICJ don't make this mistake! Thank you.
Satanyahu
Israelo malobservis la liberecon de religio subskribita en Parizo
Ma'am (the representatif of Colombia , what's international law according to your thinking cause it seems like you don't understand about international law
And you are ignorant for it is Colombia the country! Not Columbia
She cited the relevant international law, chapter and verse.
@@ssb1056 you didn't answer my question. You just recorrect a small thing. I don't think you have qualification for it, just talk too much but nothing at all
@@KlausJLinke I didn't think you have qualification to answer my question. I asked her and you what international law, I didn't ask about chapter and or verses.
Cuba have no any legaL or ethical right to showup in this court - In 2003, the European Union (EU) accused the Cuban government of "continuing flagrant violation of human rights and fundamental freedoms".As of 2009, it has continued to call regularly for social and economic reform in Cuba, along with the unconditional release of all political prisoners.
Cuba was ranked 19th by the number of imprisoned journalists of any nation in 2021 according to various sources, including the Committee to Protect Journalists and Human Rights Watch. Cuba ranks 171st out of 180 on the 2020 World Press Freedom Index.
This is all jurt rubbish acting. Free Palestine 🇵🇸💔
How come you racists don't cry about Russia doing the same thing in Ukraine?
Congratulations ❤
Where were all these speaker. During Ukraine war.
You go Unites state speaker. Thats how you speak the full truth. Un like all these AI mouthpieces.
the fact that those people spent so much of the hearing attacked the us simply because it had different opinion just shows how bad faith this entire case is. if they case had merit, they wouldn't spend so much time trying to illegitimatize their opposition.
US more than has a 'different opinion'! It's funding Israel!
The face of the UAE ambassador during the awful USA rep speech 😂😂😂
what time stamp? Is it the one at the end when she gives him the bombastic side eye?
🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
Our strong demand is that United National Head Office should be freed from America
And let it be transferred to another country
I ALWAYS KEEP APOLOGIZING TO ICJ LIKE AS ALL PEOPLES OF THE WORLD FOR INVESTING TIME MONEY AND HARD WORK FROM MORNING TILL EVENING INTO SECURING WORLD POPULATION.