Forced to leave Pakistan, where can Afghan refugees go? | The Take
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- Four million Afghans seeking refuge in Pakistan have been caught up in a government crackdown on immigration. What choices are left for those being forced to leave?
In this episode:
- Abid Hussain, Al Jazeera Digital Correspondent
Episode credits:
This episode was produced by Amy Walters, Sonia Bhagat and our host Malika Bilal. David Enders fact-checked this episode.
Our sound designer is Alex Roldan. Our lead of audience development and engagement is Aya Elmileik and Adam Abou-Gad is our engagement producer.
Alexandra Locke is The Take’s executive producer, and Ney Alvarez is Al Jazeera's head of audio.
Afghans are our brothers.... we don't support their forceful expulsion. Our government creates the mess.😢
Your country does not like iran, afganistan, India 😅😅
get a life people who had illegally immigrated are being force to leave like they should be
@@balajib1406 Actually it is the other way around.
@@balajib1406 We do like Iran and China. Iran was the FIRST country in the World to accept Pakistan. No one likes India... Nepal, Sri Lanka, China, Pakistan, Bangladesh. It was in Indian news that nowadays even Maldives and Bhutan is also falling in China's lap. Wink!
Pakistan betrayed afghan muslim brothers. True face of pakistan
Tell to Qatar 🇶🇦 to take all refugees. Not only given shelter to terrorists leaders from Afghanistan , give the shelter to civilians also
pajeets should mind their own business
I mean historically USA are also a terrorist nation and still is now and everybody seems to support them.
Terror sympathizer Qatar won't do that 😂
Us Pakistanis are already poor BC of this corrupt government let us live😂
@@singing_psittaculawho is saying 😂
I get the point of this but unless the international community wants to fund Pakistan for housing them, you can't blame Pakistan. Pakistan has had the largest population of refugees out of all countries over the past 20 years and has been subagated to the most abhorrent treatment by the international community for it. They blame Pakistan for OBL, even though they don't want to talk about how easy it was for him to get into Pakistan because they were forced to take in these refugees. They don't want to talk about the fact that 80,000 innocent Pakistani civilians died during the "war on terror" and this wouldn't have been the case if Pakistan hadn't taken in these refugees. They've been trying so hard to link Pakistan to Terrorism when in reality the only reason Pakistan has this label is for being the good guys and taking in millions of Afghani refugees. Pakistan will happily keep the refugees cause they're our Muslim brothers and sisters but unless the international community starts funding the Pakistani society more (eg. Not disgustingly blocking IMF funds until the democratically elected Prime Minister Imran Khan was forcibly removed and jailled under bogus charges) instead of funding it's military dictatorship, Pakistan has no other option left.
The International Community is NOT there to finance Pakistan.
@@heniakonas9439 No but they caused the refugee crisis in Afghanistan, Pakistan didn't. So again, who are you pointing fingers at?
@@mahadaalvino.. They didn't
Pakistan created this
Umma died
@@heniakonas9439 Pakistan is NOT there to house Afghans
Afghans have a large enough country named after themselves called Afghanistan
Pakistan has every right to send Afghans to Afghanistan
afganistan economy is growing at 10 percent and pakistan is begging from imf and saudi , afgans are lucky to go to the country which will be economic super power.
okay then why are you complaining you take be taking in Pakistani immigrants without documentation too right ?
Over 3 hundered thousands afghans who have no documents went back voluntary only 8 thousands were asked by government to leave. Theres is no country who allow that large numbers of illegal entries
The U.S does!
Usa.
@@lisamaloof5772you got here first..lol
Asifaamir, Are you saying the Taliban is not killing or persecuting them?
@@lisamaloof5772 only when you become their agent
Where is the moslem outrage, where are the protesters
Pakistan is crying for its Muslim brothers in Palestine and deporting its Muslim brothers of Afghanistan. 😂😂😂😂. This is called hypocrisy
Fake profiles of hindutvas getting really excited about this news. Why don't Indians take the refugees. After all they do brotherly relationship should come to fruition
There are 4 million afghans living legally in Pakistan, but no country accepts illegal immigrants without being properly registered otherwise security becomes a major risk, as seen by the recent suicide attacks ..
2.7 million living legally. 1.7 illegally. Total 4.4 million
man the islamabadi burger's in the comments have no idea how horrible afghan refugees have made this country
How about going HOME or some other MUSLIM country?
Well, what a shame that the people of Afghanistan were too cowardly to fight for their own country and their own children's future. No point complaining now.
i have just met a afghan taxi driver today...he is avoiding so called government athourities...he said paramilitary rangers came to his house draged his mother out of there when he was not at home...
later he run away and now living in a village which i will not mention
pakistani government and military high command is made up of toguts right now...literally it feels like occupied west bank here...
soon it might turn in gaza...
Its even worst than Gaza, you can trust Israeli forces but no Pakistani.
All is happening on the Order of Father America to Destabilize Afghanistan under Taliban Rule
حسبنا الله ونعم الوكيل
40 years is long periods ❤❤
Hats off to Al Jazeera 👏 for outstanding reporting!
Qatar is a good place they can go to Qatar. They will get royal treatment from the Qataris.
SHAME ON ISLAMIC COUNTRIES😢
Yes great nakba hope they will protect in streets like they do for the Palestinians. Many have never been outside Pakistan, lived there for generations.
Pakistan should stop creating this problem now
Shame on them
Gazans are dying! Afghans are mostly muslim
we should solve our own problems
Pakistan is doing this for its own security, there are explosions every day due to which the internal balance is getting disturbed, Taliban needs them now as well as the reason, they are brave and hardworking too, this is a golden opportunity to build their own country. They will also have to get identification cards from the Taliban so that wherever they go, they can be recognized as well as respected.
more crimes have been done by the locals they are muslim just like us its your govt fault for not regulating things properly they are human being have same brain you are judging them based on action of some and im pakistani btw
Lol and you guys complain when you get deported. 🤣🤣🤣
If Pakistan can do this , there is no reason non Muslim countries can't follow what Pakistan did .Nothing to do with racist or humanity
The explosions are done by your own military who treat their own people with cruelty. They go from village to village like thugs and do whatever they US tells them to do for money. They’re their dogs after all. It’s not the afghans. At least be honest.
All is happening by the Order of Father America to Destabilize Afghanistan and create new challenges for Taliban
everyone has to settle in their own country this is the right. these afghans are living illegally in Pakistan and they were selling drugs and weapons. we stand with our army and gov.
It´s simply not ok to invade other countries in masses because one´s desires are not met suffiiciently in the homeland. Every country has is its own troubles now . with homes, food and jobs. To go Pakistan without being invited or welcomed and not not leave then again, is against good behaviour in general and against Islam. To come as visitors but not leaving again is exactly the manner as Zionists use to do and they are charactericed by such attitude ... to go wherever they like and settle there even if it is not their land. It´s just not ok to stay illegally if there is any chance to return.. In India same problem was escalating into Islamophobia even. Travelling, tourist or working for a certain period - even years , it´s ok .. but to settle because of financial advantages denied in the homeland: "no". there is a saying in the West: "Guests are like fish. If they stay over too many days they start to stink to the host. " Afghanistan surely welcomes them back home and gives the returning refugees best chances to grow in character instead of ego._- We loved foreigners as visitors and to help refugees. Then we got refugees and pseudo-refugees flood in millions into EU for free medical care and quick money - it´s a catastrophe to the people and the entire heath-care system.
Very well written
Qatar is a good place they can go to Qatar. They will get royal treatment from the Qataris.
where are the protests for this?
It only happens with other religions.. same religion its called ummmahh ..😂
Seen protest agains saudi killing millions of Yameni peacefully.. .?
@LadieKatie agreed
Pakistan 😂so called Islamic country
I think Qatar Should Keep Afghan Refugees!
Pakistan’s elected prime minister has been put in jail by the military/US. Expelling them is the military/US doing.
they can go to Afghanistan as they have an stable government now
So what about the funds received by pakistan frm un, us in the name of afghan refugees.
You made Pakistan in the name of religion. So why don't you let them live in your country?
So-called Islamic Country.
@@akshaysuresh2703
They are Maha Chor.
@@akshaysuresh2703The expenses of 4 million refugees are at least 1 billion dollars per month. How much monthly funding does the US give to Pakistan?
@@danishjamal5635 I am Pakistani Zoroastrian.. and Western Pakistan (Pashtun and Baloch regions) are of Iranic origin, they are Indo-Iranians. They have nothing to do with India or Indians. Whenever I see Indians in USA, I literally faint. looool!
Ask any Muslim country to give aslum .
Good job al jazeera
There are around 51 OIC countries but most of the refugees are safe and secured in western countries, why OIC is not coming forward to take them?
Islamophobia by Pakistan 😂
Welcome to qatar and turkey ummaha nations..
Ifghanis are our brothers and sisters we supported them for years there are many legal Ifghanis that are doing their bussiness here and we still support them these are illegal ones but still our heart aches saying them goodby we condemn our govt for forcefull expulsion
Pashtuns again humiliated and called criminals and have their homes demolished and their women thrown on the street.
This is what Pakistan calls a "brother".
pashtuns=afghans
your logic is amazing
who is throwing"pashtun women on the streets"?
Will india accept them?
now where is oic 😅😮😢 muslim brotherhood
Is everyone else's video playing?? Cause i can only hear the audio.
Pakistan has never been kind to Afghans despite all the financial supports Pakistan receives from UN for Afghan immigrants.
Very balanced reporting by Aljazerea
OIC?
40 yrs is much long period
Why doesn't the Muslim countries,take Muslim refugees.Why are you hating your own religious people?Just look at Egypt
No country can allow illegal migration. It is as simple as that.
All countries allows refugees and sent out and then why they allow 😢😢😢
It's Pakistan 🇵🇰 legitimate and legal right to expel out Afghans because now there is no war in Afghanistan. So Afghans will have to go.
K so why cant Afghani refugees go back to Afghanistan?
Afghan &Pakistani.are brother both muslim
They should stay together
And stay United
They can move to Saudi Arabia, the Muslim motherland.
Why there's no anti pakistan and anti muslim and pro afghan rallies in the world?
Pak politicians always sees which side their bread is buttered.cheep opportunitists.
Dont blame poor politisiond
they are yes mans of generals
As Pakistani American I totally disagree with Pakistani government actions to deporting Afghans.
As a Pakistani Pakistani, i totally agree with Pakistani government actions to deport illegals.
You're not Pakistani ur American
This is Nakaba of Afghans. The great catastrophe.
@@omnamahshivay1461 Nakba was in 1979 when afghans occupied Pakistani lands at the behest of an indian immigrant dictator Zia.
@@Asfandyar_U are blaming India for all this, 😂
Syria
Saudi
Iran
Iraq
Yemen
Uae
Etc
So much for standing up for your Muslim brothers
BSing seems like your favorite game unknown false news paid spammer
Ummah is myth
Keep them in ind
Maybe they can go to the Taliban' Afghanistan, the representatives of true Islam, or to Qatar
Dubai , Saudi Arabia , just too name a few !!!
Yes Turkey has plenty room , take those poor people in or Iran could be a true Muslim brother and offer help.
When muslim advocating for palestine ...you think its true just look at pakistan ..kicking afhanistan out ...true muslim brotherhood 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂🎉
Every illegal Afghan must leave Pakistan.
Qatar should take them in and support them...
Nothing is higher than truth and conscious.whether it is young or old.
As a Pakistani, I am so upset by this expulsion. They should be allowed to stay and given citizenship. This is unacceptable!
Collective punishment doesn't work.
It doesn’t work only if its done by other religion majority country.. in Islam its permitted
Islamic brotherhood?😅
Pakistan should leave Afghanistan cities , which Briten gave them. It going to be alright.
In Ireland ?
Ну в Гренландию или на Луну! Куда ж ещё? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Those Afghan children who were born in Pakistan are still forced to leave Pakistan. Other countries give citizenship to new borns. Pakistan has never been kind to Afghans despite all the financial support they receive from UN for Afghan immigrants.
Tell me what "support" you are talking about. The video clearly states what led to deportation but again, you only hear what you wanna hear.
They can go to their own country or Saudi, UAE, Oman, Kuwait, Egypt, Turkey, Jordan, Iraq, Iran etc. or any of the so called Islamic countries.
It is the law of the whole world that wherever people live illegally, that country would deport that person, but Pakistan did not do this and the illegal Afghans have been given a month's notice, even after that the illegal Afghans do not leave Pakistan. The Pakistani government has the authority to deport all these illegal Afghans
im sorry to our afghan brothers and sister we love you all i promise. if i could do something i would do but we got no power against these courrpt leaders
Protest and Protest .. we don’t see anyone protesting against this
i agree with you but i cant do anything alone nor i know lots of people @@ksrawat88
@@usamakhan939 but you guys having lots of time to do a protest for Palestinians. This is an excuse as you guys don't want to do protest for own neighbouring country but you guys doing protest for 3000 km away country called as Palestine..don't forget that you guys doing trade with afganistan, not with Palestine.
theres difference between people dying and people going back to their own country and they are two different matter ones are getting killed and ones are going back to where they came from and im not defending this action idk whats your point for saying that @@sandeshnkadam
@@usamakhan939 they are not going back. You guys kicking them out. There is a difference...
Thats not whole truth, huge majority also living in Pakistan, only people living illegal have to go through this tough time, they are our brothers, Pakistan govt has also made mistake in this regard, the government didn't gave them timeline or any information before the evacuation.
😥
I am sure the EU will offer someplace nice for them, in Hungary.
send then to usa
Jazeera, don’t spoil your image.
For saying the truth 😂😂😂😂😂
I am from Pakistan and i know our military just does what Arab and america tell them to do they don't even have humanity left there.
Qatar should take them in
We don't want them to go!
To india
Umma chumma brothers in action 🤲🏿😊. Lauda hu akbar 😂😂
Translate into English of my comments and in Urdu about this story is being described by this channel.
Qatar should welcome our Afghani brothers and sisters
White Americans: “Haha based we should do that in the states”
Indigenous Americans: “cool when you going back to Europe?”
😂😂😂😂 I haven't seen a SINGLE American saying anything in the comments. I'll go look again. But what a weird place to come to make it about Americans. 😂😂😂😂
@@elizabethannedavis5176
I’ve seen it multiple times in multiple places when this story is talked about it.
Nice attempt at gaslighting though I am well aware of what I’ve seen people post.
@@blackwatertv7018 but not here. So why did you post about Americans on the pages you saw them say that? Why here, where they aren't, but somehow you brought up? Lol. That's not gaslighting sweetheart that's just making an observation about when and where you said what you said. Maybe now, hours later someone BESIDES your self will have commented. But the whole very Woke American thing you said and the fact then when called out, you went with GASLIGHTING?! Yeah. You're American, Canadian, or European. How classic.
What happened to the so-called ummah
They have sent to their own beloved homeland ... Nothing is wrong here.
I cant see video, just an image
Same here..
Forgive to enemy its Muslums identity but in the name of nation Muslim country thousand of people puting in truble .shame.
I would have never used RUclips service if i was aware the gang stalking abuse blatantly happening like its ok and acceptable coming from leadership position...
We don't want a future Palestine issue, they've stayed for 40 years. They have Afghanistan!
Oh no free Pakistan.. hypocrites
Send them to Iran 🇮🇷 and Qatar 🇶🇦 very simple , send some to Yemen 🇾🇪 too because it will be unfair if you didn’t give them 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Send them to Sinai as a forward group of refugees waiting for the Palestinian exodus from their homeland Palestine!
They should go to Qatar 🇶🇦 west should be wise , stop helping people that hate you
Just read like a scripted drama
Simply a targeted and object oriented report
Pakistan has their political crisis. They jailed Emran Khan. Don't blame afghane for that
Pakistan Military Junta Doing This On Behest Of US
US bad! 😂 because governments are incapable of being awful on their own. They have to have some sort of hidden agenda.
I hope fhat qatari gae sheiks will give citizenship to Afghan 😊. Dont forget umma chumma😊🤲🏿
Tragedy
They can go to Qatar
sad when i Saw the girls face
They should migrate to Qatar
Sweden is good country, Sweden pay free money
It's always the poor who suffer!
🥺🥺🥺🥺