Nasser: From Dream to Disaster | History | Subtitled Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2023
- This documentary paints a nuanced portrait of the charismatic President Nasser, from the 1950s to his brutal death in 1970. Using numerous eyewitness accounts, it retraces the great battles that were Nasser’s, from the economic development of Egypt to the unfulfilled dream of a great union of Arab nations.
Развлечения
As Arabs, our biggest problem is we rely on persons rather than institutions
Not just Arabs but entire Muslim world
He was a dictator mother fucker.
The same as Iranians!
The same culture, Islamic!!
*laughs in Arab Socialist Ba'ath*
I've been deployed to the Levant, and my consensus is the overbearing necessity to be ruled by religion inhibits the growth of a nation to function properly in the modern world. Its akin to stepping back centuries in time. The amount of progress that has been lost is virtually impossible to recoup. It can be a beautiful thing as many Muslims I've met have been the most polite and caring people I've ever met, but also saddening that their religious beliefs are shrouding the potential of their society.
The french got some nerves comparing Nasser to Hitler when they were bombing Algeria with Napalm themselves.
See these super powers think they are above all the attrocities which they gave committed
@@Koceila. you do know that Algeria is nicknamed the "land of a million Shaheed" because after a 7 year long revolution over a million died because of french troops right
@@SomeArab Yeah that's FLN propaganda. The algerian war has only 150 000 deads including the frech civilians and soldiers.
The million dead story not only a lie, but also statistically impossible for the over all population of the time.
@@Koceila. "Between 500,000 and 1,000,000, from approximately 3 million Algerians, were killed in the first three decades of the conquest. French losses from 1830 to 1851 were 3,336 killed in action and 92,329 dying in hospital."
From Wikipedia
@@SomeArab the algerian war was only from 1954 to 1962. Way less people died
The mistake that Gamal Abdel Nasser committed was that he entered Egypt into many unnecessary wars, such as the war in Yemen
My father served 7 years in the army, including five years in the era of Gamal Abdel Nasser and two years in the era of Sadat, and he participated in the war of 67 and 73, and he was going to participate in the Yemen war, then his destination changed to Sinai at the last moments for the war of 67
May God have mercy on my father, he passed away in December 2019 💔
Were these wars unnecessary?
Nasser was a hero, he fought against the arrogance of the wast. He is the hero of the Islamic world.
@@casber198214 He was impulsive, not more. Politics needs a person of genius, not impulsive. What have we benefited from the many wars? We have destroyed the economy
@@1234Mwafrika Yes, the war in Yemen. We have destroyed our army and our economy in a war in which we have nothing
@@user-dj9mk8op7mi will put Nacer,kaddafi, Saddam and Boumadiane into the same basket: warmongers,reduced to the level of caporal soldiers when it comes to decisive political and diplomatic decisions.
I will dwell no more on them for the simple reason that they did much harm not only to their own populace but also to their neighbors.
I will not watch this absurdity, but the title of the video attracted me: Nasser led from the dream to a catastrophe. Well, the great powers were afraid and their skin shivered at the name Nasser. Because of Nasser, more than 3/4 of the Arab countries gained their independence, and because of Nasser, the Arabs became well educated, trained and qualified, and because of Nasser, the Soviet Union became a supportive force. For the Arabs, and because of Nasser, non-neutrality was established. Because of Nasser, Egypt entered into wars that did not concern it after it was one of the richest countries in the world, and major countries owed it. Because of Nasser, we created the Suez Canal, in which more than a million Egyptians were martyred because of the occupation and because of Nasser. We fought the tripartite aggression that tried to occupy us again, France and Britain, and the stupid little Israel, which, despite our knowledge, has no knowledge of war and needs someone to fight for it. Egypt was fighting everything American in 67 and 73. Arab nationalism existed in the conscience of the Arabs because of Nasser Revolution against the occupation and supporting revolutions against it because of Nasser The largest funeral the world has ever witnessed will be for Nasser, a person who wanted freedom for all Arab countries. Countries such as Britain, all of Europe, and America feared him. May God have mercy on Gamal Abdel Nasser ✌🏻🇪🇬🕊
He liberated the whole of Africa not only Egypt. He supported the Mao mao in Kenya, Hosted Ignatius Musaazi of Uganda when the British wanted him dead, supported the ANC in south Africa, united the Monrovia and the Casablanca factions in the 1959 Accra conference on the independence of Africa , supported the FLN in Algeria against the French, inspired the late Gaddafi to rise to power in Libya, so many other tremendous contributions to Africa as a whole. RIP Col: Abdul Gamal Nasser!
He was a disaster for Africa He was hypocrites
Some countries not whole of Africa...did nothing for Nigeria...just saying.
Whole of Africa is not made up of 7-10 nations.
he was a criminal
Colonialism was ended by the Americans creating the Brenton Woods trade system. Not Nasser
I worked in Egypt in the epoch of Nasser. I saw many historic events shown in the documentary by my own eyes. Nasser is one of the great leaders of world.
Вы это серьёзно?
@Archimedes OMG, you're saying that Nasser was a jew . Are you OK?
عبد الناصر هو أحد اسوء قادة العالم
@@anonymous-hl9pi ظالم ديكتاتور مستبد وتسبب في هزيمة نكراء لمصر
He was an amateur, totally out of his depth in the complicated world of East-West diplomacy.
Many in the comments fail to note the most important point of the documentary. Nasser allowed Jordan, Syria and Palestine to force him into a war with Israel, though he did not want this war. The result was Egypt’s humiliation, military defeat, the end of the pan-Arab movement, and growth of Islamism. Nasser chose a one party state rather than democracy, which required a secret police, imprisonment and torture of dissidents. He was so popular, he did not need to be a dictator, and could have achieved more as a democratic president.
Curse on Israel
At the Bandung Afro-Asian conference in 1955, Nehru counselled everybody to adopt Parliamentary democracy. Nasser who was the youngest attendee at Bandung responded with the argument that having elected parliaments in the Arab world would only lead to oil companies buying up the elected legislators. This was very much possible but military dictators can also be bought. At least, in an electoral system, there is a chance to elect a new govt. Nasser was a great leader and the LBJ administartion that succeeded Kennedy in 1963 totally embraced European colonialism . The open sore still in the 60s was the unresolved Palestinian refugee problem. Arab unity was essential. Resistance has to be patient. Better to build up strength and tackle Palestinian refugee issues and grievances in the meanwhile with rehabilitation assistance .
Nasser did Not Attack The attack came from the Zionists bombing almost all the air force plane on the ground that is why was the defeat tell the truth plus Jordan Saudis betrayed him
How secularism fail a nation in a few words.....
This comment is a summary of this clip.
As an Indonesian we basically learn that Gamal Abdel Nasser was a friend of our 1st president Sukarno. Just like what they tell about Sukarno, they barely tell anything about the negatives of Nasser during his reign. For me what happened to Egypt not something too far from what happened to Indonesia with periods full of power struggle between leftist politicians, corrupt military officers, radical Muslims and the masses that actually want an honest democratic government but at least unlike Egypt, we actually get our democracy. Sure nothing totally perfect, our politics still haunted by our past but we have to move on. Wish the best for both countries.
Great and true comment.
Indonesia a democratic country.
do u mean everythings our fault nt ur ideal west
@@xtreme6018 Egypt democratic no ..Why .because the people haven.t any education ..
@@xtreme6018 Egypt is now a slave off the usa ..The top of the army is now pay bij the CIA...Not they love the country .only the trade off the Suez canal...
1:48 An episode of the British detective drama "Poirot", a TV adaptation of Agatha Christie's novels and short stories, depicted King Farouk in the early 1930s, before he became king, as a fictional character. Not surprisingly, he was depicted in a very negative light. The title of the Poirot episode was "The Theft Of The Royal Ruby".
Have you a link ?
رضوان الله عليك ايها الزعيم الطاهر الخالد في قلوبنا
رمز العروبة والتاريخ
بن النيل ومصر
❤
Nice documentary , thanks.
BEN salama
Appreciate your excellent coverage
One social aspect told to me by Middle and Upper Class Egyptians of Nasser’s economic management was the gradual decline of housing standards - the imposition he made on rental increase by Landlords resulted in little or no expenditure on repairs. His heart was in the right place, like many of his policies, but he faced impossible tasks - however, he demonstrated great ability as a ‘politician’.
He probably was a great influence on Gaddafi, who wanted to achieve across Africa what Nasser attempted in the Arab World. Their deaths indicate the difference in esteem their countrymen held for them.
CİA ülkenizi parçalamaya yemin etmişken sizin yapabileceğiniz hiç birşey yok İsrail'in güvenliği için Mısır her zaman güçsüz ve iç çekişmelerle boğuşan bir devlet olarak kalmalı başarılı bir lider gelir ve Amerika'nın sözünü dinlemez ise suikast ile öldürülmeli tıpkı Japonya'da olduğu gibi Nasr gibi Abe"de CIA tarafından öldürüldü
He's a leftist nationalist after all, you cant grow a good economy if you stomping too much on middle and upper class.
@@lukaswilhelm9290 agreed. But if you have the support of the Military you will survive. Plus political astuteness to take support from whatever the way the wind is blowing!
Please do not compare Gadafi to Nasser , Gadafi was a terrorist, his fellow Arabs rejected him , that's why he wanted to lie to black Africa.
@@samateryusuf4345 I agree Gaddafi should not be compared to Nasser, only my opinion is that in his own way he could have been inspired by Nasser in his ‘International’ political objectives.
Me parece un reportaje excepcional.
Nací en el 54 y muchos de los hechos que narra me resultaron ajenos por ser una niña Española.
Para juzgar a Gamal Abdel Nasser habría que ponerse en su lugar. Quién podría haberlo hecho de otro modo que como él lo hizo?.
Muchas gracias.
Very informative documentary..
Great admiration and great respect. Your beautiful words that provide accurate, useful and wonderful information. Thank you for all the beautiful words for your great effort
Excellent documentary that I enjoyed watching.Keep it up 👍.
Well done and brilliant documentary.
This documentary film helps me a lot for my university assignment on Jamal Nasser
its Gamal
EPIC DOCUMENTARY!
Nasser proved the maxim, "The road to hell is full of good intentions", his good intentions led Egypt to disastrous outcomes over and over again.
As with all godless people, they want good but go down the wrong path.
@@raptorhacker599 "Godless Egyptians ..." ??
@@penandsword4386I think he was not conscious of it when he wrote that comment .
Very well made,good job 👌
Excellent documentary
This is fantastic.
لم يكن خائناً ولا عميل ومرتزق لأمريكا والغرب .. رحمه الله وأسكنه فسيح جناته ...
واحد فقط يحفظ اسمه: يسوع المسيح.
ههههههههه ئولتلي ، بركات السيدة تحية كاظم بنت كاااازم الفارسية حرمووووه لجمال عبدالناصر
امممممم كان ملحد اساساً .
الله يحمي مصر والشعب المصري أخوكم من سورية
اهلا بيكم !! بنحبكم جدا" !!! و منوريننا في بلدكم التانيه مصر !! ❤
@@meghan3713 الله يحفظك ويبارك فيك
@@meghan3713these r people from Iran Iraq Saudi Arabia Packistan that with war and migration the ancient Black folks were pushed out of Egypt
Peace and stability has been desired by many for many people. May this desire be realized in reality as we walk together into the future.
Gamal Abdel Nasser was the only modern leader of Arab Nation , that why we adore him
Pero el documental es muy muy bueno enhorabuena por el documental su canal lo sigo siempre y es para mí entender uno de los mejores de su género
Este documental es segun Imperialismo colonial . Nasser era su enemigo numero 1.
Lo siento, mi Espanol no es muy bien , soy Egipcio.
@@samnicolas1469u r a Arab
With maximum support of the people of Egypt, who loved their leader, it is always good to do what these beautiful need. Focus on development and peace with all. President Nasser would have seen very good years for Egypt and all Arab world. May Egypt prosper and its peace embrace peace. God bless them and their country.
and god bless you too and your people
Thank you! God bless you too ❤
Excellent
Thank you
his documentary paints a nuanced portrait of the charismatic President Nasser, from the 1950s to his brutal death in 1970. Using numerous eyewitness accounts, it retraces the great battles that were Nasser’s, from the economic development of Egypt to the unfulfilled dream of a great union of Arab nations.
well made documentary
Good job
Reportage très intéressant
7:11 look at those waves, the guy was spinning 🌊
hahahaha, I always thought he was one of the most handsome dictators out there
Muy buen documental. 👍
Valeu!
Excelente
Rest in Peace, Gamal Abdel Nasser. The LION of Egypt. Egypt's GREATEST leader. I LOVE Abdel Nasser, the Pride of Egypt.
He wanted to change things for good, but wanting something is not enough. He was thrown in the hands of Soviets.
For many things he did not had much options.
USA, UK and the West kept with Israel.
It seems he did his best.
(Nasser colonialism) plotting against Iraq
Stop blaming other countries for your failures!.
We do that in Iran too.
Same culture, Islamic!!
See what happened to Japan in WWII and review after or Korean War and after!!!
Read about Singapore how they turned their country around !
Probably you don’t like Israel but study their management, see what they have done .
A very small desert country now exporting fruits to European countries and exporting water to Jordan!!
CİA ülkenizi parçalamaya yemin etmişken sizin yapabileceğiniz hiç birşey yok İsrail'in güvenliği için Mısır her zaman güçsüz ve iç çekişmelerle boğuşan bir devlet olarak kalmalı başarılı bir lider gelir ve Amerika'nın sözünü dinlemez ise suikast ile öldürülmeli tıpkı Japonya'da olduğu gibi Nasr gibi Abe"de CIA tarafından öldürüldü
@@Malibu-ku2to ....one of the best comments
@@Malibu-ku2to Japonya Kore ABD'nin kontrolünde yükseldi. Sovyet tehdidine karsı
Ist there any concern in that documentary about napalm . Thanks for this interesting documentary .
all documentaries by Michel Rotman are quality ones
After seeing this documentary as a European I feel that he was trying to make egypt beter and that as a leader he was trying to do good
Yeah what a mystery that the Arabs only want to rape and kill you, but you always find goodness in them. Or may be it's a scam.
One of my teachers, Muhammad Qutb, who was a member of the Muslim Brotherhood dating back to the 1950s, told us in class how when Abdul Nasser was a military officer he had a good working relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood but as soon as he gained political power he imprisoned many of the Brotherhood. My teacher who had been imprisoned twice, a well as other members of his family, described how he and some of the other members of the Brotherhood were tortured and some even killed and this was Abdul Nasser policy of dealing with the Brotherhood.
May Allah have mercy on Muhammad Qutb and his brother the Shaheed.
@@talibeilm21c Ameem
Nassers islam was just a front to get the peoples support
C'est un Takhfri !
Yep. Too bad he wasn't able to get rid of all of them!
Imagine how much efforts and crucial resources Egyptians have lost due to the political ambition of one man. Not to mention that of Yemenies, Jordanians, Palestinians, Lebanese, and Syrians.
So many decisions that could have been made differently, would have entirely changed the fate of all Arab nations.
From Spain, I share what is said in another comment that one of the great problems of the Muslim world is that they are looking for a leader, when what they should do is build effective institutions. Another problem that the Muslim world has not yet resolved and that in the West was resolved with the Enlightenment and the French Revolution, is that religion should not interfere in public life.
and institutions like democracy, a free media, public health institutions...
@CarlosGarcia I do not fully agree with your comment generalising Muslim countries when there are economically wealthy, infrastructural and technologically advanced countries such as: U.A.E, Qatar, kuweit, Saudi Arabia, Malaysia etc
Some of them like Qatar and Saudi Arabia are one of the biggest investors in the west specially in the UK where I live.
Bare in mind that one of the main reason of the collapse of Credit Suisse the second largest bank in Switzerland was it's top backer the Saudi National Bank refusing to give it more money.
Qatar Investment holds 12.7% stake in Barclay bank, 17% In the Volkswagen group and Porsche and 20% of Heathrow airport in London.
It is true that we should not generalize, but it is a fact that in Islamic countries the institutions are not democratic or independent enough to confront political power. Islamic societies always go behind a leader. Regarding the wealth of the Gulf monarchies, no one can deny it, another thing is the distribution of that wealth, the freedoms that these peoples enjoy. According to my particular opinion, the Gulf monarchies are very artificial and their people do not intervene in the management of their wealth.
@carlos the issue in my opinion is the failure to understand the differences in culture and governance globally. We westerners fail to understand that our democracy may not adhere nor appeal to everyone and people have their own customs.
Like most westerners alot of the opinions are based on biased media coverage not experience of living there.
As for distribution of wealth alot of the so called sovereign islamic nations have free education including university locally and internationally free healthcare and are tax free, debts and mortgages are interest free.
We do not manage the distribution of wealth in the west as well, they are managed by appointed individuals who make economical decisions based on their opinions and expertise same as in the islamic monarchies, hence the money awarded to projects and contracts, increase an decrease of interest rates that citizens of western countries have no part in the decision making process.
As for rallying behind a leader/individual we do that as well e.g president, prime minister etc. By voting for them in expectations that they will change our lives and change direction of the countries for the best, based on their campaigns, slogans, policies.
Eg: Donald Trump, Boris Johnson, Barack Obama etc.
I believe in giving credit when some credit is due.
Am form ghana Africa I love this man
الله يرحمه ويغفر له كان عامل كرامة للشعب العربى
كرامة دى كرامة اممك دى
انت بتفهم ! أحييك
كرامة مين ياعم . ده هو السبب في دخولنا حرب مع إسرائيل وهزمنتا 1967 رئيس فاشل السادات احسن منه
@@boykamohamed1439 حرب مع مين يا صديقي ؟ انت قلتها
قلت ايه . انا بقولك هو السبب في دخولنا حرب مع بنت الكلب دي وخسرنا
The World with peace, unity and love, watching from berbera somaliland republic,, v
He was good at staging this .
As it has been claimed over the ages that the departing had been granted visions of what lay in the future, what did the soul of deceased Nasser foresee for Egypt and the rest of the Arab world in the 21st Century?
Al Kawmee or Pan Arabism, that was his dream
Nasser is the best and most honorable Arab leader in the modern era, and all the decline that happened to the Arabs happened after him. The West and America agreed on him because he was honorable.
King faisal was another great leader at a similar time
Some good vintage shit. Keep it up 🇩🇰
History indeed
1967 war defeat and the involvement of the Egyptian forces in North Yemen were two humiliations that continue to damage Nasser's legacy, even today.
Muslims always lose against Israel because the Jews are just really smart.
1967 war was over for Egypt even before it started
@@Ron-pm3qkyep Amer was very incompetent and Egypt was simply not ready for war.
That a,weird cut video at the end .
But great effort on the video
Interesting...
Rayos!
Me encantaría escuchar este documental en español, así podre hacer mi tarea tranquilo.
Lo acabo de ver pero si no lo mencionas me olvide que esta en ingles. Muy interesante
The statment that the the thousand year old jewish commjnity was not expelled is barely a half truth. Egytian Jews had their businesses and property confisacted and they were legally discrimiated against. Egyptian jews were expressly invited to leave
you forget to precise ..to leave with absolutely nothing but 1 piece of luggage .
But now Egypt is one of the few allies Israel can count
Stop radicalize people against each other
Do you know why they were asked to leave ?
Mossad operation Susanna Lavon Scandal
Don't forget dirty Zionists
Parasites
R.I.P. leader Nasser he was the only president who cared about poor people letting them be healed education job opportunities he made the high dam at Aswan to save the water for the Egyptians he helped the liberty revolutions everywhere Allah yerhamoh
When Nasser took over Egypt, we were a wealthy, and beautiful country. In only a few decades him and his system crushed our economy and everything good about our country
تحية لروح الزعيم الخالد جمال عبدالناصر 🌷🌷🌷
الزعيم الخالد بالفشل قصدك
الطاغية الخالد في جهنم بإذن الله.
@@user-oq8my3po7c هو دا اللي انت عارفه هههههههههه بتردد في الكلام روح يلا ذاكر ياض
لماذا لم يتحدث الوثائقي المتحيز عن مشروع ناصر الاقتصادي والصناعي وعن التغير الاجتماعي الكبير الذي حصل في مصر وانتشال ملايين المصريين من الفقر والجهل
صياحكم طرب
لأن كل المصادر الغربية غير محايدة
@@missmiss8359 رحم الله الزعيم جمال عبدالناصر
ههههههههههههههههه مغيب انت هههههههههههههههههههههههههههههههه
@@Kira18959 التعميم لغة الجهلاء و كدارس لتخصص التاريخ في الجزائر فان المادة العلمية (التي كتبت حديثا)باللغتين الإنجليزية والفرنسية اثرى و ادق و اكثر موضوعية في اغلب الاوقات مع و جود النقائص بالطبع و هذا ليس عيب اللغة العربية انما عيب المستوى الجد متدني حيث جامعات شعبة العلوم الانسانية عبارة عن مراكز حشو و ادلجة و نشر للشعبوية .
Nasser is a true patriot of Egypt!
We still suffering the consequences of his policy & irrational decsions
يعيش زعيم الأمة العربية وقائدها، الرحمة والجلال لروحك يا جمال عبد الناصر.
هاهاهاهاه
@@eliyonmilo9297 هاهاها ايه دخل ؟ وصل لغايت فين يلا ؟
هههههههههههههه
هههههههههههههههه شعوب تموت في الشعارات كتكم نيلة
Nasser is a classic example of what happens when you over glorify people over institutes. Treating leaders as indispensable gods is a mistake that sadly Egyptians still make to this day, moving from one undereducated military halfwit to another.
52:12 - where's the audio??
شعب يبكي على جلاده .
@22:40 saladin wasn't an Arab. He was an ethnic Kurd.
Did saladin said I'm kurd. He is muslim only.
@Zahra Alammehrjerdi today idotic people r nationalistic but at that time they r not.
I am not even a kurd so don't bash me
@@aftabahmad1263 u r not kurd but u try to divide ummah.
@@ahetasamibnesams7749 he is from indian subcontinent. We are already divided
Amazing stuff!
Why doesn't the History channel show this instead of aliens and people repairing old cars????
The history channel gave up on actual history a couple decades ago
Because the "greatest generation" are all deceased.
43:01 The radio was announcing on the basis of field reports, and it was deceptive for a certain reason, which is that the Israeli planes were equipped with spare tanks that they were disposing of in the air, so the observers thought that the plane itself had fallen
دالك اشبه بتناول جرعة من الكوكايين
كان حتميا أن ينشط الجسم لكن ينتظره انهيار شامل
لقد صنع هاؤلاء الفتيان المتحمسين أنظمة عسكرية مافيوزية مازالت الى اليوم يتحمل الناس تبعاته
لقد
Abdel Nasser was the enemy of colonialism in Africa
So the West hates Nasser
Nasser stood against French colonialism in Algeria
Nasser stood against Belgian colonialism in the Congo
Nasser stood against British colonialism in Egypt, Yemen and Ghana
Nasser stood against Portuguese colonialism in India
The Egyptian radio was speaking in 33 different African languages to support Africans against colonialism
Nelson Mandela, Fidel Castro, Malcolm X and Che Guevara all looked at Nasser with pride and said many wonderful words about him.
So they got rid of him
عمل انقلابات في العراق و اليمن و ليبيا و سوريا
Ok commie
You’re a little dim, aren’t you?
And he was defeated by Israel in two days. 🤣🤣🤣
@@nickmatatyahu9464 Because of arabs kings Are a traitor of him they show and spreand all about egyptian army location to israel , wake up , traitor is more worst than enemy
How sad..many life’s were directly affected
Thanks for Persian subtitle
Güney Azerbaycana selamlar
5:52 - Over a thousand brothers?!! - WOW! 😮 I feel sorry for the mum...
Best Nasser!
Long live Egypt ❤️🇪🇬💪
تحيا مصر ! ❤
@@meghan3713 تحيا مصر دولة أبطال
@@meghan3713 ❤️🇪🇬
@@meghan3713
رواية عز البلد اتكلمت فيها بلمحة سريعة عن بطولة التأميم و الاستقلال
ruclips.net/video/Su37dbiR9Oc/видео.html
YOUR CONTENT IS GREAT I HOPE ONE EPISODE ABOUT MOHMAD NAGIB,PLEASE.THE FIRST PERSIDENT OF EGYPT😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
The man who destroyed his nation future destroyed history, the present and the future, destroyed the pound, destroyed the agricultural land, entered wars in which he did not win, established the police state and military rule, a legacy of failure from which we still suffer. There is neither peace nor mercy for those who are wronged.
Nasser had his flaws but he was a great leader
A leader with charisma.
Yeah, he was a dictator, but he had a proper ideology and an actual vision; unlike the dickheads who followed him who only cares about lining their pockets.
True. Especially the 1967 defeat! 🙄
@@kithsirirubesinghe9202That's all he had
@@meghan3713Do you think that Egypt was only facing Israel at that time?
Good documentary, I enjoyed it thoroughly. Just one detail, however: the reference to the medieval leader Saladin is incorrect. He was not Arab, he was Kurdish
Yes he was kurdish 🌄🫒💐👍
@@Omer-hr2kx Long live Kurdistan! ✌
in the description
his brutal death?
It seems that the documentary ignored the Brotherhood's confessions of the truth (the Mansheya incident), and that was after the Egyptian revolution in 2011, when the Brotherhood thought that things were heading in their favor, so they began to open the pages of their history away from fears, and therefore Youssef Al-Qaradawi (the Grand Mufti of the Brotherhood) admitted that the incident was real, as well The Grand Guide of the Muslim Brotherhood, Mahdi Akef, admitted that the incident was not a representation, and others admitted that, and all of this is documented and published on RUclips.
Part of the Brotherhood's strategy of violence is to practice violence against others, then claim that what happened was government forgery, and issue statements and books renouncing violence.
In other words, the Muslim Brotherhood relies heavily on lying, deceit and violence...... just like other Islamic groups
Before Nasser, Egypt
1.) 1 EGP was equal to 2 pound sterling
2.) Egypt had: Darfur, Nubia and Sudan
3.) Cairo was the most beautiful city in the world
4.) Egypt had foreign communities that made up of: Greeks, Italians, Jews, Armenians and Maltese that were good for the economy
5.) Egypt was the richest country in the Middle East
6.) Egypt was the greatest producer of cotton.
Percentage wise, how many Egyptians got to enjoy and benefit from this wealth? Wasn't the farming system feudal-like?
@@Laloonie lmao, Egyptians today aren’t living the best life, 45% of them are literally under the poverty line and probably most of them are uneducated
Albanian ruling family oppressed Egyptians don’t forget that
@@Al-Shaheedi as if the modern day ones are real victims, torturing and killing their oppositions in prison 😂
@@KSalem32 I never said that modern rulers were all that great. I just mean that there must have been a reason for the revolution. No one revolts because life is good and their needs are met
29:20 there is an error here in the translation he didn't meant the " fail " or the " فشل " in arabic but he said " الفاشية " and I can't descirbe it because me english is trash
Watch you the movie of Gillo Pontecorvo,"the Algeri war".
To all Egyptians who hate foreign culture and imperialism: What language do you speak? What religion do you practice? What economic policies do you follow? None of these are Egyptian.
True!!!
Yeah they know learn English
Shut up, the Egyptians are the foundation of civilization and history, and they are Muslims, men of the true religion. You, the West, are colonial terrorists who love destruction and destruction. You fight Islam everywhere because you know the true religion, which in the future all human beings will become.
Exactly, does the west speak, practice, follow anything Egyptian?
Abdennasser was a hero of paper, he did nothing but removing royale familly
Just imagine if Nasser had made progress in any sector, what would have been the attitude towards him 😳
If Nasser hadn't made so many mistakes, the entire middle east would look very different right now. Likely one or two unified Arab states, greater prosperity, peace and trade with Israel and a much more secular, and socially functioning Arab culture. Turkey and Iran would be a buffer states.
But he chose war with Israel, dictatorship, authoritarian politics, and ultimately empowered Islamism - fulfilling the West's biggest fears and criticisms of islamic civilization.
Nasser needed the continued intervention of JFK, but he was killed far too prematurely to allow for any changes to be made in the political power structure in the Middle east.
Gamal Abd El-Nasser was the greatst Arabian leader on the modern era, got the charasmatic, the ambition, the leadership and the desire to get rid of all kinds of colonialism in the "world", not just the Arab countries.
He was different from any other leaders and helped a lot of countries in their war against colonialism like in Algeria, Cuba, South America, India ... etc.
Actually I dont believe most of this video as they interviewed some people who are already have objections on any military ruler, so their opinions wont be so right on Abd El-Nasser.
Israel 🇮🇱 embarrassed Nasser
Made him look like a little bitch
Great leader ..RIP Nasser
great in what exactly
CİA ülkenizi parçalamaya yemin etmişken sizin yapabileceğiniz hiç birşey yok İsrail'in güvenliği için Mısır her zaman güçsüz ve iç çekişmelerle boğuşan bir devlet olarak kalmalı başarılı bir lider gelir ve Amerika'nın sözünü dinlemez ise suikast ile öldürülmeli tıpkı Japonya'da olduğu gibi Nasr gibi Abe"de CIA tarafından öldürüldü
@@eliyonmilo9297 So great, he was defeated in 6 days, by a young Israel.
He is enjoying in the hell 👿 with 72 dark-eyed virgins 🤣🤣🤣
In Egypt, when a president destroy their country, they call him great leader. This is why their country is in constant decline. The more it falls, the greater he is.
Must be translated to Turkish to reach Turkish audience, they should watch and learn from similar history.
Fiecare are posibiltatea să pună traducerea în limba țării lui. Este o setare pe ecranul telefonului sau tabletei în dreapta sus în colț este o floare. Apeși pe ea și îți setezi traducerea în limba țării tale.
Teşekkürker
Nasser turned our lives upside down. One man can cause so much harm. For the Jews of Egypt he was the Pharaoh.
رحم الله الزعيم جمال عبدالناصر
wrong translation at 29:22 he said bound to "fascisim" not "fail"