A dream can make a person experience something they want to experience that they can't do in real life. Everything can happen in a dream, but in reality, it can't and won't happen. 😔
reality to much bitter, but dream u make it beauty. but pretty sure hard to believe that is fake. its make u more hard that why to run run run from reality, and its dangerouse for u slowly for sure. we have to make it stop.
the fact that they released a 37 min long video instead of short bursts of promotional content ( shorter videos mean more repeats hence more view counts) means they don't care about the views but just wanted to do justice to the beautiful art and music that they wanted to portray. seventeen is really beyond idols and are such sincere musicians and creator of arts. what a beautiful gift to carats before their enlistment ... getting to hear 37 mins of their soothing voices whenever we miss them 😢
I couldn't agree with you more. Seventeen isn't a group of idols. Seventeen is in a league of their own...and I adore that. THANK YOU SEVENTEEN for the story. It won't increase your fame or wealth, but you just gifted US something beyond priceless! I just can't imagine life without all 13 of you. THANK YOU for existing!
@@innermelodudeI'm not sure how youtube monetization works, but an ordinary person is less likely to watch longer videos especially those beyond the 20 minutes mark bc of short attention span. I just think the comment means to emphasize that one of the main goal of this release is to portray a story rather than focus on virality which are more possible to do with shorter videos.
“No matter how you try, you can't make things go back to the way they were. You can't take out pepper you've already stirred into soup and the same goes for lemonade you've spilled on the carpet.” im crying. 🥹😭😭
So Wonwoo became a "Nightmare" cause he had to break/wake everyone up from their "happy dreams" which was Jeonghan feeding off of just to bring back A to "life" while destroying the real & dream world. Wow, this was such an interesting story 👏🏽
@@Hellokitty_391 yes, Wonwoo actually saved both the worlds by relieving Jeonghan of his pain & past, JH needed that reality check that what's gone is gone, when that happened Wonwoo tapped on his forehead & JH woke up & everything went back to normal again.
@@Hellokitty_391 Jeonghan believed that dreams were a way to relive happy memories. So he thought he could preserve A by staying in the dream world. But in truth, he himself couldn't remember A anymore. Convincing people to stay in the dream world was to help him prevent the real world from moving on. It also gave him the opportunity to collect and dig though their memories, so that perhaps he could finally recall A's name and face, giving him his own happy memory to live in. Wonwoo was simply a dream visitor, who could cross through both the real and dream worlds and enjoyed by observation. When Wonwoo realized that Jeonghan was trying to disrupt this balance, he chose to shatter the "happy" dreams so that people could return to the real world. He becomes remembered as a vague nightmare by society. He also does this to Jeonghan, him of the pain of being stuck in the past, and allowing him to come back into reality.
When listening to this audiobook, I understood that JxW's album is more than just a collection of songs; it's a beautiful form of artistic storytelling.
after listening to the whole thing, i would say that i felt what "the man, jeonghan" was feeling. at some point in our lives, we tried so hard to stay in the dreamland to find some thing/s that we could not have in the real world. despite being aware that it won't bring back what we lost, we still somehow hope that we would find it again. and sadly, during the process of wanting to find it again, we lose more things unknowingly until we are left empty and void. to everyone who are living in the past chasing after an "A" who is covered in sheets, may we find our own "the man, wonwoo" who would push us to uncover our As to help us get our time ticking and help us move forward further than 8:47am. or maybe, may we find the strength to become our own "the man, wonwoo" and save ourselves from being in this cycle of pain and loneliness. happiness may not be guaranteed but the future has so much in store for us. who knows what it has for you, right? tight hugs for all.
I know, I listened to this exactly the time they uploaded it and fell asleep, so I listened to it yesterday and still fell asleep. Now I'm commenting so I can listen to it, lmao.
Wow... in my 8 years of stanning Jeonghan, I just realized that he is a great storyteller. His tones and the way he put emotions in his voice is so good. His first part broke my heart. I can feel how lonely he was. All he wanted is A to come back to his life 😭
원래 디스맨은 원우였는데 정한이가 꿈의 세계를 만들면서 이름도 뺏어버리고 (여기서 아름다운 디스맨은 정한인 듯? ) 사람들을 다 행복만 있는 잠들게 해버렷어 -> 계속 자는건 죽음과 다를것이 없음. 원우는 아끼던 도시가 다 잠에 들면서 활기차던 도시가 회색빛이 됨 자신의 낙이던 꿈속 산책을 해도 모두 무미건조한 행복한 꿈의 반복 더 이상 방관 할 수 없으니 사람들을 깨우고 다님 (정한이 만든 꿈에 세계에서 원우가 깨우면 슬픔을 느낄 수가 있게 됨 이건 정한이가 원한 세계가 아닌데!!!!!) 정한은 자신의 행복인 a가 보고싶어서 행복과 기쁨만 있는 환상의 도시= 꿈(dream)의 도시를 만들었는데! 원우가 깨우고 다니니까 슬픔이 섞여지는 세계가 되니 불안정 해져버림 그래서 원우를 불청객이라 느낌 서로의 세계를 지키기 위한 추격전 시작 -> 원우 승!! 정한은 목적을 잃어버렸기에 짐 ㅠㅡㅠ A를 기억하지 못해……ㅠㅠ A라고 확신했던 흰 망태기는 그저 그리움이였음…ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그래서 원우가 잠에서 깨움 드디어 시계가 움직임 = 현실세계로 돌아왔다. 정한은 슬픈 악몽을 꿨다는것만 느껴질뿐 아무것도 기억이 나지 않아.. 그저 기억나는건 긴 검정코트의 디스맨…… 크 명작입니다 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
"도망치지마 넌 여기에 도망쳐왔으므로 더 이상 도망칠 곳은 없어" 상실감에 그 그리움을 계속 찾아다니는 창백한 남자의 쓸쓸함과 그럼에도 불구하고 살아가게 하려는 검은 옷의 남자의 단단함이 저는 자신의 내부에서 싸우는 목소리로 들렸습니다 도시괴담은 결국 인간이 만들어낸 자신을 투영한 이야기 조예은 작가님과 정한원우가 만들어낸 하나의 「작품」이 계속 마음속에 남을 것 같아요
This is another proof that svt always put there everything when they make music !! Thank you jeonghan and wonwoo for you're hard work !! We all really loved it !! Edit:- a huge thanks to woozi too!! For creating such a masterpiece again!! You did well!! You never disappoint us !! I'm really happy that I got to know about someone so amazing like you! . thank you for making such a great story Cho yeeun !! We all really loved!! Thank you for your hard work!!
And a HUGE thank you to Woozi for such a masterpiece of both a story AND a song! Your genius never fails to amaze me! I thank the Universe you were born!
엄마가 불면증이 생기셔서 영상을 틀어놓지 않으면 불안하셔서 잘 못 주무시는데 이 영상 틀어드리니까 화면도 잔잔하고 두 사람의 저음 목소리가 엄마의 마음을 편안하게 만들어주는지 잘 주무세요 저 뿐만 아니라 엄마에게도 좋은 영상이 된 것 같아 기분이 좋네요 디스맨 오디오북 너무 감사하고 두 사람의 목소리가 너무 좋아요
long story short wonwoo a lucid dreamer, goes to peoples dream, the city wanted to find him but they can’t remember his face at all. jeonghan woke up and wanted to had breakfast wth A but A is missing so He find A everywhere. jeonghan wanted to bring ‘A’ back but he can’t because you just can’t change everything in the past. ‘A’ disappeared, wonu chased jh to help him get over his past because it is all for nothing. wonu made him fall asleep, jeonghan woke up and wonwoo wonders agin. the plot wanted to remind us that no matter how happy to live inside our dream we need to face the reality and we cannot just change the things that was already written in the past. after reading this (by transcript) the mv just made more sense like how they tap someones forehead, how someone turned into sands, that mysterious figure standing under the white cloths, the whispers, the soup!?, the album title, why people chose to sleep, how they smiled after the whispers, and wonwoo and jeonghans role throughout the mv (how jh woke up) “but why should people look for happiness only when they’re dreaming. “ “no matter how you try you can’t make things back to the way they were” IK IT’S PRETTY CONFUSING BUT IT TAKES TIME TO UNDERSTAND THE PLOT (i am also confused at first but i think i slowly understand it piece by piece)
@@day-ve5xtyep im pretty sure i saw someone comment and said that jeonghan trying to make everyone asleep so they will have a happy/joyous dream different than their reality (like wonwoo said at 20:30)while wonwoo trying to stop jeonghan cuz the more he does it the more he realise it’s a bad thing cuz he’s trying to make ppl forget abt their reality something like that lol im not that good at explaining
@@day-ve5xtI think so too. Jeonghan is this man, trying to take everyone into their dream world. While wonwoo is the other man, trying to find jeonghan to stop him.
@@Shqnnqq Isnt it Wonwoo being the man in his own original city while jeonghan and "A" in another city? To me it feels like jeonghan thinks that A has went to the other city so he begins looking for A by travelling to Wonwoo's city. Jeonghan then forgets who A is then gets defeated by Wonwoo?
@@Shqnnqqfrom the mv, jeonghan was the one eating the soup, also wonwoo is the one chasing jh and trying to stop jh from putting people to sleep. so jh is "this man" but who is "a" and "other man"?
jeonghan's light voice and wonwoo's deep voice paired with an amazing storyline and the background music is perfect and will help me fall asleep at night 🤍
Knowing the full story makes the MV even more worth watching so that you can catch the moments narrated in the audiobook. Like the chase scene. Wonwoo catching up with Jeonghan and A. You can feel the tension even more in the MV in all of the scenes.
this is so interesting. the full story of this man read by jeonghan and wonwoo with their calm voices. thank u so much for this, our duo, jeonghan and wonwoo !
Wonwoo's voice is very cold (in a good way) and very smooth but damn i could listen to jeonghan's voice everyday. There's something about his voice that's so calming and soothing at the same time. They delivered the story so well omg the plot is crazyyyyy i want it in a mini film aaaaaa it's tok good not to.
Jeonghan made dreamland to find A (who was already gone in the real world) and to be with him again. Wonwoo became a nightmare to bring everyone back to reality. At the last part, he tried to find Jeonghan to wake him and to make him accept the fact that “No matter how hard you try, you can’t make things go back to the way they were” -a line from the story. I rewatched the mv and it’s even better now that I get it.😭😭💕
"The face of friends long since drifted apart, botched shots at promotions, anniversaries with former lovers, exams failed by a single question, drinks and meals, apartments and illusions of money, disastrous parties, every failure, and everything that could not be returned to.. It's like Seventeen story since being trainee and what's are all the faces together . What a great storyline dear Writernim and Voice acting Hannie and Wonwoo. Your voice are so nice and soothing..
The story is wonderful and the takeaway from it is so beautiful and hard-hitting too. "No matter how you try, you can't make things go back to the way they were. You can't take out pepper you've already stirred into soup, or the lemonade you've spilled on the carpet." "But why should people look for happiness only when they are dreaming?" They are such profound lines, that leave an indelible mark on our minds and hold so much power and truth. Jeonghan has always been a wonderful narrator. His voice is so comforting, I could listen to him all day, my whole life. Wonwoo's voice was impactful and urgent, and it was amazing listening to him. The fact that we got an almost forty minutes audio of story instead of short videos for promoting says a lot about how the art was the most important aspect here. The storytelling is top notch. The storyline itself is intriguing and alluring. The way they are invested and dedicated shows how the craft itself is important rather than popularity. The love for the creation really shows. I absolutely love it so much. The acting was top notch as well as the singing. The narration was cherry on top. Manifesting for this to turn into a movie or drama with Jeonghan and Wonwoo as the actors. They have immense potential and incredible talent. They have proven themselves. It's high time someone casts them. Jeonghan especially showed a plethora of emotions throughout the whole thing. The falling to the knees scene left an everlasting impact on me. This is extraordinarily beautiful. Masterpiece!
woahh i'm so glad they made this audio book because i was so curious about the whole story behind the mv and the lyrics, it's like they granted my wish 😭🙌🥹
I have always preferred reading books rather than listening to them. This is my 1st audiobook ever and I am blown away by Jeonghan and Wonwoo’s magnetic voices and the ethereal beauty of the heart wrenching story….🖤🖤
I can't express how grateful I feel for being able to experience their art, to live in the same time as seventeen. This is truly a masterpiece, their concept, music, performance. It feels out of this world.
This is the most unique way of an album.And the story is well thought of by them and they even went to the extent of having a novel author help them. Our wonwoo and jonghan really exceeded carats expectations ❤ a story thats very unique but very relatable to this generation
I'm blown away... I need to rewatch this and savor it. It's so cozy and spooky like a bedtime story. Thank you, Cho Yeeun, for such wonderful writing and of course thank you to Wonwoo and Jeonghan!
I love stories so much, and having one connected to this album is so extraordinary, truly a piece of art. I loved how the boys read it and how it was captured, wow!!
20:41 "But why should people look for happiness only when they're dreaming? He knew reality was a tedious agonizing experience for all" These words strikes hard 🥺
I could listen to this while trying to sleep. Jeonghan and Wonwoo’s voice is so soothing. This storyline is amazing. Kudos to the writer Cho Yeeun. This is well-made. I love this JxW unit so much.
This story was so incredibly painful but beautiful to listen to. The deep message behind it will stick with me for a very long time. Reality may be painful at times but true authentic happiness is found in it, rather than living in the past or in a dream. No matter how painful it can get, happiness and good can be found in it again. That's what living is all about. Learning and growing from it. Thank you so much to Jeonghan and Wonwoo; and to the team involved in the making of this story and album. It was truly such a gift.
진심 스토리 너무 재밌다. 두 디스맨의 스토리가 진짜 너무 멋있고, 이런 괴담 실제로 있으면 좋겠고 ㅋㅋㅋ 편히 잠들지 못하는 사람에게 깊은 잠을 선물하던 원우가 정한이 사람들을 묶어두기 위해 선물한 행복한 꿈에서 깨운다는 이유로 악몽이 된다는 것이 너무.. 너무..룽해...
This is honestly so incredible I was literally getting chills the story is so immersive and their voices just suit it very well this concept is so new and artistic , creative i appreciate it so much they worked hard for this masterpiece
![[GOING SEVENTEEN] EP.119 고잉 제작기 (GOING PRODUCTION)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/650K75tw3cQ/mqdefault.jpg)
“but why should people look for happiness only when they’re dreaming?”
that hits hard
Bcz reality sucks 🙃
A dream can make a person experience something they want to experience that they can't do in real life. Everything can happen in a dream, but in reality, it can't and won't happen. 😔
reality to much bitter, but dream u make it beauty. but pretty sure hard to believe that is fake. its make u more hard that why to run run run from reality, and its dangerouse for u slowly for sure. we have to make it stop.
the fact that they released a 37 min long video instead of short bursts of promotional content ( shorter videos mean more repeats hence more view counts) means they don't care about the views but just wanted to do justice to the beautiful art and music that they wanted to portray.
seventeen is really beyond idols and are such sincere musicians and creator of arts. what a beautiful gift to carats before their enlistment ... getting to hear 37 mins of their soothing voices whenever we miss them 😢
Aaah, don't talk about enlistment😭😭😭 BTS won't even be back before Seventeen starts leaving😭😭😭
I couldn't agree with you more. Seventeen isn't a group of idols. Seventeen is in a league of their own...and I adore that. THANK YOU SEVENTEEN for the story. It won't increase your fame or wealth, but you just gifted US something beyond priceless! I just can't imagine life without all 13 of you. THANK YOU for existing!
Let's not be dramatic
Los videos mientras más largos monetizan más, además los shorts no son igual de monetizables que los videos normales.
@@innermelodudeI'm not sure how youtube monetization works, but an ordinary person is less likely to watch longer videos especially those beyond the 20 minutes mark bc of short attention span. I just think the comment means to emphasize that one of the main goal of this release is to portray a story rather than focus on virality which are more possible to do with shorter videos.
“No matter how you try,
you can't make things go back to the way they were. You can't take out pepper you've already stirred into soup and the same goes for lemonade you've spilled on the carpet.”
im crying. 🥹😭😭
So Wonwoo became a "Nightmare" cause he had to break/wake everyone up from their "happy dreams" which was Jeonghan feeding off of just to bring back A to "life" while destroying the real & dream world. Wow, this was such an interesting story 👏🏽
All what wonwoo did just to look for jeonghan, right? And help him
@@Hellokitty_391 yes, Wonwoo actually saved both the worlds by relieving Jeonghan of his pain & past, JH needed that reality check that what's gone is gone, when that happened Wonwoo tapped on his forehead & JH woke up & everything went back to normal again.
@@kobrownkid1356 so A is gone in reality so jeonghan looking for her in dreams? Or?
@@Hellokitty_391 yes.
@@Hellokitty_391 Jeonghan believed that dreams were a way to relive happy memories. So he thought he could preserve A by staying in the dream world. But in truth, he himself couldn't remember A anymore. Convincing people to stay in the dream world was to help him prevent the real world from moving on. It also gave him the opportunity to collect and dig though their memories, so that perhaps he could finally recall A's name and face, giving him his own happy memory to live in.
Wonwoo was simply a dream visitor, who could cross through both the real and dream worlds and enjoyed by observation. When Wonwoo realized that Jeonghan was trying to disrupt this balance, he chose to shatter the "happy" dreams so that people could return to the real world. He becomes remembered as a vague nightmare by society. He also does this to Jeonghan, him of the pain of being stuck in the past, and allowing him to come back into reality.
When listening to this audiobook, I understood that JxW's album is more than just a collection of songs; it's a beautiful form of artistic storytelling.
after listening to the whole thing, i would say that i felt what "the man, jeonghan" was feeling. at some point in our lives, we tried so hard to stay in the dreamland to find some thing/s that we could not have in the real world. despite being aware that it won't bring back what we lost, we still somehow hope that we would find it again. and sadly, during the process of wanting to find it again, we lose more things unknowingly until we are left empty and void.
to everyone who are living in the past chasing after an "A" who is covered in sheets, may we find our own "the man, wonwoo" who would push us to uncover our As to help us get our time ticking and help us move forward further than 8:47am. or maybe, may we find the strength to become our own "the man, wonwoo" and save ourselves from being in this cycle of pain and loneliness.
happiness may not be guaranteed but the future has so much in store for us. who knows what it has for you, right? tight hugs for all.
So true
i love this so much
I needed this. Thank you for giving comfort to me who is stuck right now.
We’re both of them “this man”?
@@Daemyanne the way i understood it, yes they were both this man but with different roles in people's dreams
it's amazing how they released this at night (11 pm kst) so this sounds like a bedtime story but for carats
I know, I listened to this exactly the time they uploaded it and fell asleep, so I listened to it yesterday and still fell asleep. Now I'm commenting so I can listen to it, lmao.
Wow... in my 8 years of stanning Jeonghan, I just realized that he is a great storyteller.
His tones and the way he put emotions in his voice is so good.
His first part broke my heart. I can feel how lonely he was. All he wanted is A to come back to his life 😭
So true. His voice suited this type story so much ! It's a great piece of art really 💯
괴담을 이렇게 해석해서 컨셉을 잡는다는게 진짜 미친것같음...
원래 디스맨은 원우였는데 정한이가 꿈의 세계를 만들면서 이름도 뺏어버리고 (여기서 아름다운 디스맨은 정한인 듯? ) 사람들을 다 행복만 있는 잠들게 해버렷어 -> 계속 자는건 죽음과 다를것이 없음.
원우는 아끼던 도시가 다 잠에 들면서 활기차던 도시가 회색빛이 됨 자신의 낙이던 꿈속 산책을 해도 모두 무미건조한 행복한 꿈의 반복
더 이상 방관 할 수 없으니 사람들을 깨우고 다님 (정한이 만든 꿈에 세계에서 원우가 깨우면 슬픔을 느낄 수가 있게 됨 이건 정한이가 원한 세계가 아닌데!!!!!)
정한은 자신의 행복인 a가 보고싶어서
행복과 기쁨만 있는 환상의 도시= 꿈(dream)의 도시를 만들었는데!
원우가 깨우고 다니니까 슬픔이 섞여지는 세계가 되니 불안정 해져버림
그래서 원우를 불청객이라 느낌
서로의 세계를 지키기 위한 추격전 시작
-> 원우 승!!
정한은 목적을 잃어버렸기에 짐 ㅠㅡㅠ
A를 기억하지 못해……ㅠㅠ
A라고 확신했던 흰 망태기는 그저 그리움이였음…ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
그래서 원우가 잠에서 깨움
드디어 시계가 움직임 = 현실세계로 돌아왔다. 정한은 슬픈 악몽을 꿨다는것만 느껴질뿐 아무것도 기억이 나지 않아..
그저 기억나는건 긴 검정코트의 디스맨…… 크 명작입니다 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
이해가 안됐었는데 이제 알겠네요. 너무 감사해요! 2새대라서 한국어가 생각보다 잘 안돼나봐요 ㅋㅋㅋ
오 정리 잘 하셨네요 감사합니다😊
감사해요 진짜 멋짐..
8시 47분에 멈추었던 시간이 8시 50분이 됨으로 정한이 현실로 돌아왔음을 알려주는 장치...미쳤다 정말❤
Hani and Wonu's voices are sooo soothing, I could listen to them tell stories everynight and I'd never get sick💎
Me too...
와악 너무 죠아요 미쵹닥
“And whenever the night fell, WONWOO would continue to walk through their dreamworlds” 🖤
It feels so lonely yet comforting to know that this man would continue protecting his people.
a story that perfectly written by Cho Yeeun 🤝 ethereal voices of Wonwoo and Jeonghan
say no more
"도망치지마 넌 여기에 도망쳐왔으므로 더 이상 도망칠 곳은 없어"
상실감에 그 그리움을 계속 찾아다니는 창백한 남자의 쓸쓸함과 그럼에도 불구하고 살아가게 하려는 검은 옷의 남자의 단단함이
저는 자신의 내부에서 싸우는 목소리로 들렸습니다
도시괴담은 결국 인간이 만들어낸 자신을 투영한 이야기
조예은 작가님과 정한원우가 만들어낸 하나의 「작품」이 계속 마음속에 남을 것 같아요
This is another proof that svt always put there everything when they make music !! Thank you jeonghan and wonwoo for you're hard work !! We all really loved it !!
Edit:- a huge thanks to woozi too!! For creating such a masterpiece again!! You did well!! You never disappoint us !! I'm really happy that I got to know about someone so amazing like you! . thank you for making such a great story Cho yeeun !! We all really loved!! Thank you for your hard work!!
And a HUGE thank you to Woozi for such a masterpiece of both a story AND a song! Your genius never fails to amaze me! I thank the Universe you were born!
Yeahh!!! How can I forget about it T_T!!
@HorangOoahGwanlanghae_carat I'm sorry I don't understand Korean T_T
와..분량 좀 봐 진짜 열일했다... 원정대가 말아주는 오디오북...목소리가 너무 좋아 목소리도 설레면 어쩌니 얘들아
Jeonghan and Wonwoo voices are so soothing 😌❤️
Feels like I'm watching a movie💕
@@readresskyyes or documentary
Try listening to it at x0.75 speed...
엄마가 불면증이 생기셔서 영상을 틀어놓지 않으면 불안하셔서 잘 못 주무시는데 이 영상 틀어드리니까 화면도 잔잔하고 두 사람의 저음 목소리가 엄마의 마음을 편안하게 만들어주는지 잘 주무세요 저 뿐만 아니라 엄마에게도 좋은 영상이 된 것 같아 기분이 좋네요 디스맨 오디오북 너무 감사하고 두 사람의 목소리가 너무 좋아요
원우랑 정한이 목소리를 이렇게 가득 들을수있다니… 너무 행복하다…
"남자는 높은 곳에서 도시를 내려다보고 있었다"이 대사..이상하게 소름 돋는다.
그 높은 곳이 어딘지는 모르겠지만 이 대사 한마디가 나를 소름 돋게 만드는거 같구만..
이거 진짜… 목소리 진짜 너무 좋고 조근조근 얘기해서 거의 백색소음… 잠온다
세븐틴 멤버들 다 책 한권씩 읽어주는 콘텐츠도 좋을거같아요
long story short
wonwoo a lucid dreamer, goes to peoples dream, the city wanted to find him but they can’t remember his face at all. jeonghan woke up and wanted to had breakfast wth A but A is missing so He find A everywhere. jeonghan wanted to bring ‘A’ back but he can’t because you just can’t change everything in the past. ‘A’ disappeared, wonu chased jh to help him get over his past because it is all for nothing. wonu made him fall asleep, jeonghan woke up and wonwoo wonders agin. the plot wanted to remind us that no matter how happy to live inside our dream we need to face the reality and we cannot just change the things that was already written in the past.
after reading this (by transcript) the mv just made more sense like how they tap someones forehead, how someone turned into sands, that mysterious figure standing under the white cloths, the whispers, the soup!?, the album title, why people chose to sleep, how they smiled after the whispers, and wonwoo and jeonghans role throughout the mv (how jh woke up) “but why should people look for happiness only when they’re dreaming. “
“no matter how you try you can’t make things back to the way they were”
IK IT’S PRETTY CONFUSING BUT IT TAKES TIME TO UNDERSTAND THE PLOT (i am also confused at first but i think i slowly understand it piece by piece)
wait,i didnt really understand this part so please correct me if im wrong.so jeonghan is 'this man' and wonwoo is the 'other man'?😅
@@day-ve5xtyep im pretty sure i saw someone comment and said that jeonghan trying to make everyone asleep so they will have a happy/joyous dream different than their reality (like wonwoo said at 20:30)while wonwoo trying to stop jeonghan cuz the more he does it the more he realise it’s a bad thing cuz he’s trying to make ppl forget abt their reality something like that lol im not that good at explaining
@@day-ve5xtI think so too. Jeonghan is this man, trying to take everyone into their dream world. While wonwoo is the other man, trying to find jeonghan to stop him.
@@Shqnnqq Isnt it Wonwoo being the man in his own original city while jeonghan and "A" in another city? To me it feels like jeonghan thinks that A has went to the other city so he begins looking for A by travelling to Wonwoo's city. Jeonghan then forgets who A is then gets defeated by Wonwoo?
@@Shqnnqqfrom the mv, jeonghan was the one eating the soup, also wonwoo is the one chasing jh and trying to stop jh from putting people to sleep. so jh is "this man" but who is "a" and "other man"?
Wonwoo's intonation is really good, maybe because he likes reading and does it often
jeonghan's light voice and wonwoo's deep voice paired with an amazing storyline and the background music is perfect and will help me fall asleep at night 🤍
하..그동안 뮤비보고 영화같다 영화네 했더니 진짜 단편영화를 만들어왔네.. 미쳤다
😮😮😮 하이요
와..진짜 원우 목소리 진심 너무 좋은거 아니냐거...이렇게까지 집중해 본적이 읎다..
뮤비도 좋지만 이 서사가득한 오디오북이 너무 좋다...
Knowing the full story makes the MV even more worth watching so that you can catch the moments narrated in the audiobook. Like the chase scene. Wonwoo catching up with Jeonghan and A. You can feel the tension even more in the MV in all of the scenes.
this is so interesting. the full story of this man read by jeonghan and wonwoo with their calm voices. thank u so much for this, our duo, jeonghan and wonwoo !
남자, 창백한 남자로 불리던 주인공들이 갑자기 정한 원우로 불릴때 진짜 짜릿함
정하니랑 원우 목소리까지 미쳤...✨️🫠도시전설...갓벽조합
원우의 한글자 한글자 꾹꾹 눌러담아 글을 써내려가는 느낌을 주는 슴슴하고 담담하면서도 힘있는 목소리가 너무 매력적이다
Their voice, the background music, the storyline, everthing about this is so PERFECT
Wonwoo's voice is very cold (in a good way) and very smooth but damn i could listen to jeonghan's voice everyday. There's something about his voice that's so calming and soothing at the same time. They delivered the story so well omg the plot is crazyyyyy i want it in a mini film aaaaaa it's tok good not to.
이번 앨범 다른 것도 다 좋지만 제일 기다린 게 오디오북이었는데 아예 통으로 유튜브로 올려줘서 너무 좋다
Jeonghan made dreamland to find A (who was already gone in the real world) and to be with him again. Wonwoo became a nightmare to bring everyone back to reality. At the last part, he tried to find Jeonghan to wake him and to make him accept the fact that “No matter how hard you try, you can’t make things go back to the way they were” -a line from the story.
I rewatched the mv and it’s even better now that I get it.😭😭💕
you can really feel the emotions in their voices ㅠㅠ
"The face of friends long since drifted apart, botched shots at promotions, anniversaries with former lovers, exams failed by a single question, drinks and meals, apartments and illusions of money, disastrous parties, every failure, and everything that could not be returned to..
It's like Seventeen story since being trainee and what's are all the faces together . What a great storyline dear Writernim and Voice acting Hannie and Wonwoo. Your voice are so nice and soothing..
Jeonghan and Woonwoo's voices match so well together, iconic duo
영상도 있으면 더 좋을거같은데
이것도 너무좋다!🩷🩵
오디오북 지금 30번은 들은듯 진짜 이런이야기 너무 좋다😊
자막을 켜고 들으세요 부디… 남자와 A에서 원우와 정한으로 바뀌는 그 순간이 얼마나 소름 돋고 좋은지…
"창백한 남자는 한쪽 입꼬리를 비틀어 웃었다"
하...정한아 나 미쳐...
원우야.. 진짜 몰입 너무 잘 되고 너무 좋다.. 휴지 두는 것도 원우가 다 해석해서 읽은 거야? 진짜 너무 기특해 대견해 우리 고양이가 못하는 게 없어어..
와 오디오북 풀버전 그냥 공개해주는거였다니🥲 이번 컨셉최고ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
I really hope that this storytelling can be used as a reference to make a small drama with Wonwoo and Jeonghan as the main roles.
목소리까지 완벽한 정한X원우잖아✨️
둘 목소리 들으면서 잠들테니 내 꿈에도 정한X원우 나와줘 제발!!!🩷🩵
스토리도 흥미롭고 정한이, 원우 나레이션이랑 bgm, 적당한 배경 화면까지 너무 너무 좋은 컨텐츠다ㅠㅠ 다음에도 다른 도시전설 컨셉으로 이렇게 재밌는 스토리 가지고 나와주길
こんなに素敵で寂しくて悲しくて切ないけど心に沁みるコンセプトでこのプロジェクトが動いてくれたことに本当に感謝してます。THIS MANたちの事をさらに知れて良かった。ジョンハン、ウォヌの2人でのユニットが生まれてよかった…！
The story is wonderful and the takeaway from it is so beautiful and hard-hitting too.
"No matter how you try, you can't make things go back to the way they were. You can't take out pepper you've already stirred into soup, or the lemonade you've spilled on the carpet."
"But why should people look for happiness only when they are dreaming?"
They are such profound lines, that leave an indelible mark on our minds and hold so much power and truth.
Jeonghan has always been a wonderful narrator. His voice is so comforting, I could listen to him all day, my whole life. Wonwoo's voice was impactful and urgent, and it was amazing listening to him.
The fact that we got an almost forty minutes audio of story instead of short videos for promoting says a lot about how the art was the most important aspect here. The storytelling is top notch. The storyline itself is intriguing and alluring. The way they are invested and dedicated shows how the craft itself is important rather than popularity. The love for the creation really shows. I absolutely love it so much.
The acting was top notch as well as the singing. The narration was cherry on top. Manifesting for this to turn into a movie or drama with Jeonghan and Wonwoo as the actors. They have immense potential and incredible talent. They have proven themselves. It's high time someone casts them. Jeonghan especially showed a plethora of emotions throughout the whole thing. The falling to the knees scene left an everlasting impact on me. This is extraordinarily beautiful. Masterpiece!
how can someone’s voice be this calming? i could sleep peacefully listening to wonwoo
I slept after listening to this
.. And had a nightmare which woke me up
woahh i'm so glad they made this audio book because i was so curious about the whole story behind the mv and the lyrics, it's like they granted my wish 😭🙌🥹
This is a freaking movie fr 😤 Their voice is so soothing that I could listen to all day 😭
凄い面白かった。どちらが正義でどちらが悪という問題でもなく。
生きていく上で大事な人を忘れてしまう悲しさ、寂しさ。
忘れてしまった自分への呆れ。虚しさ。
記憶に残らない悲しさ。
現実に向き合えば向き合うほど、厳しいことの方が多くて、辛くてやり切れないけれど。
いつか幸せを掴めると信じて日々生きていくのも人の生き方の1つなのだと思う。
オーディオブックのみならず、本でも読みたい。
우와 정한이 목소리 너무 좋다 감미로워😍😍
I have always preferred reading books rather than listening to them. This is my 1st audiobook ever and I am blown away by Jeonghan and Wonwoo’s magnetic voices and the ethereal beauty of the heart wrenching story….🖤🖤
헐 이게 뭐야 ㅜㅜ 미친 너무돟아 ㅜㅜ 윤정한 저음 사랑해요… 원우 목소리 너무좋아.. 아진짜 동서남북으로 절할게요..❤ 캐럿들의 축복이 끝이 없다..❤❤ 🐰🐈⬛
와.. 풀스토리라니 이건 진짜 선물이다...와 조예은 작가님 넘 좋아하는데 우리애들이랑 협업해주셔서 감사해요..❤
원우 저음 너무 좋다🥹 조용한 곳에서 원우 목소리 크게 들으니 몇분간 세상에 원우 목소리로 가득차 너무 좋았어🥹🥹 여기가 디스맨, 원우가 등장하는 꿈 속일까 원우야🥹🥹🥹
THEIR VOICE IS SO GOOD, ACTOR WONWOO AND JEONGHAN WHEN?!?!THE BEST OF THE BEST
I can't express how grateful I feel for being able to experience their art, to live in the same time as seventeen. This is truly a masterpiece, their concept, music, performance. It feels out of this world.
This is the most unique way of an album.And the story is well thought of by them and they even went to the extent of having a novel author help them. Our wonwoo and jonghan really exceeded carats expectations ❤ a story thats very unique but very relatable to this generation
목소리가 미쳤네!! 넘 좋아!!
목소리 너무 달다 정한아ㅠ 자면서 들어야지 너무 좋다 이런 기획❤
大切な人や事や物、喪失感よりも忘れてしまうことの怖さ。
それなら、どんな形であれ失くさず自分の中に閉じ込めておきたい。
もし、自分がその立場に立ったら、どちらを選ぶのか？
色んな事を考えながら聞き入ってしまいました。
何度も聞いて、曲と一緒に楽しめます！
素敵な作品をありがとうございます！
와 풀버전으로 듣고 싶었는데 감사합니다 원우 목소리 너무 좋아요 뮤직비디오 이해하는데 도움도 될 것 같아요
눈 감으면서 듣고 있는데
디스맨 분위기 진짜 잘 느껴짐..
정한원우 목소리 좋다!!
정한이 감정이 들어간 목소리톤 미친거같아
목소리 너무 좋 아,,....,.........😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹🥹
これ流しながら寝たい
2人の声聴くと落ち着く、、、
너무 좋다 너무 좋다아🥺
아니 윤정한 목소리 왜 이렇게 좋지...? 진짜...🥹😇
저 진짜 운전하면서 항상 오디오북 듣는게 이게 나와서 너무 좋아요!!!!!!!!!
This manのコンセプトが2人に合いすぎてすごい、、、
ジョンハンの声で今夜は寝ます
夢に出てきてね夢男さん
풀 스토리라니 진짜 미쳤다.디스맨을 이런 식으로 해석하다니, 천재신가요? 목소리에 집중하며 상상하며 듣다보니 금방 끝나버렸네. 좋은 작품 너무 감사합니다.
너무 웰메이드라 할 말을 잃었어요.
듣고있자면 뮤비도 노래가사도 하나하나 이해가 가기 시작하는게.. 오디로북 다 듣자마자 뮤비 다시 보러 가게되는 매직.
활동이 너무 짧은게 아쉽고 많은 사람들에게 더 알리고 싶어 안달나는 앨범이예요.ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ😂
단편소설한편을 이렇게 만들어주다니......조예은작가님 평소에도 좋아했는데 다시한번 빠져드네요👍👍👍
정한 원우 목소리도 너무 좋아서 아주 깊게 몰입해서 들었어요.
정말..완벽하다고 밖에 설명이 안됩니다 .👏👏👏
Jeonghan's voice is so soothing
I'm blown away... I need to rewatch this and savor it. It's so cozy and spooky like a bedtime story. Thank you, Cho Yeeun, for such wonderful writing and of course thank you to Wonwoo and Jeonghan!
다들 윤정한과 a의 서사에도 주목해줘….오로지 a가 보고싶어서 모두 다 꿈에 묻어버리고 꿈쪽의 무게를 키워서 그걸 현실로 만드려고 했던
미친 서사가 여기있다고….성별 포기 안한것도 마음에 듬….
大ボリュームすぎる。良いんですか？ありがとうございます！！！
조예은 작가님께서 써주신 스토리겠죠?🥹 소설 너무 잘 본 독자중 한명으로써 이번에 앨범 참여해주신거 너무너무 신기했어요ㅠ 앨범의 기초가 되는 스토리까지 탄탄하니 이번 유닛활동이 더더 좋은거 같아요🫶 조예은 작가님의 스토리텔링 + 정한,원우 낭독 =미친조합 🩷🩵
This was the most calming audiobook I listened to. Their voices complemented each other so well that it provided warmth overall to the story❤
와… 정한이 목소리가 이렇게 좋았었나 진짜 너무좋다
I love stories so much, and having one connected to this album is so extraordinary, truly a piece of art. I loved how the boys read it and how it was captured, wow!!
미쳤나봐....얼굴보느라 자각 못했는데 목소리까지 잘생겼어
좋아 이제부터 나 잘 때는 이거 듣고 잔다
목소리 잔잔해서 잠안올때 들으니 너무좋당❤❤
なんやこれよすぎだろ聴きながら寝れる耳が幸せ
20:41 "But why should people look for happiness only when they're dreaming? He knew reality was a tedious agonizing experience for all"
These words strikes hard 🥺
Wonwoo's low voice has the charm of helping you sleep comfortably at night
윤정한 목소리 .. ❤
원우 정한 목소리를 37분동안 들을 수 있다니 이게 축복이 아니면 뭐란 말입니까... 할렐루야...
맨날 버스에서 잘때 들어유... 정하니 워눙이 목소리 짱 좋은 asmr....❤❤
The storyline is really cool, plus Jeonghan and Wonwoo's voices are really great, so it feels like a lullaby. But the second clip is really scary 😭👏
방학때 소설 읽어야겠다 내 안에 오랫동안 쉬어있던.어떤. 무언가가 자극을 받음.
I could listen to this while trying to sleep. Jeonghan and Wonwoo’s voice is so soothing. This storyline is amazing. Kudos to the writer Cho Yeeun. This is well-made. I love this JxW unit so much.
This story was so incredibly painful but beautiful to listen to. The deep message behind it will stick with me for a very long time. Reality may be painful at times but true authentic happiness is found in it, rather than living in the past or in a dream. No matter how painful it can get, happiness and good can be found in it again. That's what living is all about. Learning and growing from it. Thank you so much to Jeonghan and Wonwoo; and to the team involved in the making of this story and album. It was truly such a gift.
진심 스토리 너무 재밌다. 두 디스맨의 스토리가 진짜 너무 멋있고, 이런 괴담 실제로 있으면 좋겠고 ㅋㅋㅋ
편히 잠들지 못하는 사람에게 깊은 잠을 선물하던 원우가 정한이 사람들을 묶어두기 위해 선물한 행복한 꿈에서 깨운다는 이유로 악몽이 된다는 것이 너무.. 너무..룽해...
This is honestly so incredible I was literally getting chills the story is so immersive and their voices just suit it very well this concept is so new and artistic , creative i appreciate it so much they worked hard for this masterpiece
자신의 세계를 지키기 위한 싸움 ….. 크…….👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
크 문장마다 뮤비가 연상 된다 너무 재밌고 탄탄해… 감사합니다
크.. 정한이 원우 목소리 미쳤자나 스토리도 미쳤자나ㅏㅏ 사랑해요 진차로..❤