Regarding ROTS and ROTJ, I would say the conversation between Luke and Leia in ROTJ made a lot of people think the opposite of the claim in this video about Padme. That conversation made a lot of us think that Padme couldn't die in ROTS (unless there was a time jump of a few years after the twins were born). For almost 20 years now fans have been coming up with all sorts of head canon as to how Leia could have remembered her mother.
Yoda in the Prequels you could arguably is at his weakest but him making mistakes does show that even someone like him can make mistakes just like anyone else
I don't mean to seem like I'm complaining cause ur channel is great but what about the Animated Shows? Like Clone Wars, Rebels, Bad Batch, TOTJ, TOTE etc. Cause they have some if the best scenes in all of star wars imo
@thegoldman25 I was thinking that. As just doing the Live action stuff is ALOT of work and the videos are already both very long. I think these videos will do well and I think people would love to see your ranking on the scenes from the animated stuff! Keep up the amazing work!
Bro Qui Gon and Maul have as much character development in PM as a plank of wood. Maul is just a dispensable bad guy pre CW and Qui gon is just really stubborn 😂 and what does it do with Obi Wan really? He sits on the ship the whole time then only trains Anakin cause he promised Qui gon. That’s not really character work
I completely disagree with saying the duel in The Phantom menace has no character work. It's a masterclas of storytelling trough fights, we see a reckles young obi wan, that in the end lets his emotions take the best of him and yes initially seems like winning but it is not until he calms himself and uses the force that he wins, in contras Qui-gon is very calm, he is a master and understands the force, when they are forced to stop he turns his lightsaber off and meditates while obiwan and maul are restless and desperate to continue. Qui-gon even ignites the lightsaber before the gate opens again, because he sensed it trough the force. It speaks more to his wisdom, and reliance on the force that his talent or raw strenght like darth maul or obi wan did. So trough the figh we undertand who each of them are. Plus, the title of the music score, duel of fates relates to the other part of the story weaving with the fight, depending on the outcome, the fate of Anakin will change, Qui-gon dies, therefore priving Anaking of a teacher that would have helped him better understand and control his emotions, a teachrr that instead of rejecting his love for padme would have encouraged it. I think the fight and the subtle hints at who where each of the characters trought he coreography showed a lot of work
George has about as many original ideas as he does scenes with brilliant dialog . He is the master at borrowing ideas, especially from Dune . Which he never gives credit or anybody else for that matter .
Had Annikin never turned to the darkside his vision wouldn't have happened thats the difference between padme and shmi visions . His mother doesn't die because he showed up but inspite of it . Padme did die because he showed up
I love all of Star Wars, but you definitely picked some of my standouts 😊, Attack of the Clones is better than the phantom menace in my opinion, a thew good scenes doesn’t beat generally better scenes for me.
@@thegoldman25Yeah, I know. I’m very bad at English because I’m not from an English speaking country. I was talking about your old ranking, so far this one has been very in depth.
The Gold Man: I recommend watching SW in the chronological order (preach, brother) Also The Gold Man: doesn't put the best scenes in the chronological order.
Thanks to Grüns for sponsoring this video! Get up to 45% off your order, just click here gruns.yt.link/tTeQuHp
Regarding ROTS and ROTJ, I would say the conversation between Luke and Leia in ROTJ made a lot of people think the opposite of the claim in this video about Padme. That conversation made a lot of us think that Padme couldn't die in ROTS (unless there was a time jump of a few years after the twins were born). For almost 20 years now fans have been coming up with all sorts of head canon as to how Leia could have remembered her mother.
Gold Man knows what peak content is
Yoda in the Prequels you could arguably is at his weakest but him making mistakes does show that even someone like him can make mistakes just like anyone else
Ya, I view it as him not yet evolved or matured into the Jedi we see in the OT. I personally love it.
I don't mean to seem like I'm complaining cause ur channel is great but what about the Animated Shows? Like Clone Wars, Rebels, Bad Batch, TOTJ, TOTE etc. Cause they have some if the best scenes in all of star wars imo
Considering a part 3 with animated shows if these do well
@thegoldman25 I was thinking that. As just doing the Live action stuff is ALOT of work and the videos are already both very long. I think these videos will do well and I think people would love to see your ranking on the scenes from the animated stuff! Keep up the amazing work!
@@thegoldman25we shall double our efforts!
@@thegoldman25They help tell the story of Star Wars and flesh out the characters. You gotta do them!
Yoda didn't use force lightning. He simply channeled the existing electrical currents to hit a specific spot.
I really love the background music in this video, i love synthwave. I'd listen to the same tracks back in 2020
Oh boy what a great video! Can't wait for part two!
oh waitaminit..
Saying the Duel of the Fates has no character work is absolutely wild
Bro Qui Gon and Maul have as much character development in PM as a plank of wood. Maul is just a dispensable bad guy pre CW and Qui gon is just really stubborn 😂 and what does it do with Obi Wan really? He sits on the ship the whole time then only trains Anakin cause he promised Qui gon. That’s not really character work
Why it should have character work in first place? Two Jedi knight, sent by Chancellor and Jedi Council fight mysterious Sith assassin.
Can you describe what the character work is
By contrast, I knew exactly what scene you were going to pick from Revenge before you even went into it
Man you’ve got some low key wild takes in this video, not gonna lie.
I completely disagree with saying the duel in The Phantom menace has no character work. It's a masterclas of storytelling trough fights, we see a reckles young obi wan, that in the end lets his emotions take the best of him and yes initially seems like winning but it is not until he calms himself and uses the force that he wins, in contras Qui-gon is very calm, he is a master and understands the force, when they are forced to stop he turns his lightsaber off and meditates while obiwan and maul are restless and desperate to continue. Qui-gon even ignites the lightsaber before the gate opens again, because he sensed it trough the force. It speaks more to his wisdom, and reliance on the force that his talent or raw strenght like darth maul or obi wan did. So trough the figh we undertand who each of them are. Plus, the title of the music score, duel of fates relates to the other part of the story weaving with the fight, depending on the outcome, the fate of Anakin will change, Qui-gon dies, therefore priving Anaking of a teacher that would have helped him better understand and control his emotions, a teachrr that instead of rejecting his love for padme would have encouraged it. I think the fight and the subtle hints at who where each of the characters trought he coreography showed a lot of work
Seeing 2025 in the title is so werid
Awesome list
Thanks!
Never been this early before
George has about as many original ideas as he does scenes with brilliant dialog . He is the master at borrowing ideas, especially from Dune . Which he never gives credit or anybody else for that matter .
I would like you to review Ms Marvel series or talk about Skeleton Crew series.
Wedges redemption
Had Annikin never turned to the darkside his vision wouldn't have happened thats the difference between padme and shmi visions . His mother doesn't die because he showed up but inspite of it . Padme did die because he showed up
Commenting for the algorithm
You didn’t put the music in the description
Yes I did…
@@thegoldman25for the padme scene, it’s not there
I can't believe your favourite scene in AotC is not "I don't like sand". My hope for you has shattered..
The problem with “I don’t like sand” thing is really just a meme at this point
@@LordMegaGamer and that's literally why I posted this :D
Video ends at 27:17
😅
Get over it
Hi😊
Hi
Just recently, channel called "Writer Brandon McNulty" made video on exact same topic.
If you exclude music, scene of Luke looking at binary sunset is pretty meaningless.
14%? Come guys, subscribe
I love all of Star Wars, but you definitely picked some of my standouts 😊, Attack of the Clones is better than the phantom menace in my opinion, a thew good scenes doesn’t beat generally better scenes for me.
i uploaded the video 8 minute ago, no way you know my picks
@@thegoldman25Yeah, I know. I’m very bad at English because I’m not from an English speaking country. I was talking about your old ranking, so far this one has been very in depth.
Do you think clone wars Yoda is in charioter
sometimes
Revenge is not an emotion
Putting rey and these generic disney plots in this turned me off just from looking at the thumbnail😂
Aotc is way better than pm
The Gold Man: I recommend watching SW in the chronological order (preach, brother)
Also The Gold Man: doesn't put the best scenes in the chronological order.
Reused content 🥵
check out part 2
new meta lol
First off. The last 3 skywalker movies are COMPLETELY TRASH there are zero good scenes period