0:40 Do you think it is a fretless bass? I used to think so but after hearing these slides from the 12th and 8th fret, I can hear the sound of 12 and 8 fret markers........
I mean between Gilmour and Waters, while Nick Mason was in charge to keep the three together. I'll let here a link for you all to listen to a technical explanation that helped me to understand how it worked out; and why Richard Right was THE key man of the band. Check it out!
Roger was a great bass player listen to Live at Pompeii. This bass playing by Gilmour sounds more like a guitar than a bass. I wish Roger would have played it. If Dave wanted to be a bass player I am sure he would have been great, but a guitar player can not just become a bass player, you got to live it. These photos of Dave are from the Obscured By Clouds sessions BTW.
I'd agree with you in the sense that Roger is the much more EFFECTIVE. He doesn't do too much, but he does exactly what's needed of him. He's a very solid musical and rhythmic backbone. As a (hobbyist) bassist I absolutely adore Dave's bass line here, but on this song they basically swapped instruments while keeping the same roles. Roger supports on the rhythm guitar while Dave plays the lead. I don't mind it here though and it sounds very unique (and it's fun to play).
Gilmour was more profficient technically and he could do bass takes more quicklly than Roger...the pict is not from Animals sessions, right? I think is from 1972, Obscured by clouds recording
Roger was def better. Pigs has a good baseline but Roger’s playing on breathe, great gig in the sky, time, money eclipse, echoes and so many more was better than and hey you
@@nigelpisswater484Musicians in general are all a dime a dozen, it’s those with exceptional talent that make them the *exception* such as Roger and David, both very skilled at what they do best
as much of a questionable public figure as roger can be, he’s a hell of a bassist. super aggressive tone and part with some funky ass fills in there too also, out of curiosity, did you use the original ‘77 mix or the 2018 remix? i personally think the 2018 mix does the album much better justice, particularly in the rhythm section. everything is a lot clearer and punchier
@@revanasywal Not according to Pink Floyd: All The Songs by Jean-Michel Guesdon and Phillippe Margotin. Roger played rhythm live and Snowy White played the bass live but according to them, Gilmour played all the guitars and bass on the recording.
0:40 Do you think it is a fretless bass? I used to think so but after hearing these slides from the 12th and 8th fret, I can hear the sound of 12 and 8 fret markers........
definitely not a fretless
The first and second solo are played on a p-bass with flat wound strings, and the groove part with the slides and stuff are played on a fretless.
@@IntrepidFCNah it's definitely a normal p-bass all the way through, you can hear fret buzz throughout all the verse and chorus sections.
ruclips.net/video/axHr3I7y9YA/видео.htmlsi=LEr26X-62voZ2kaR
I’m not sure if he played bass for the whole album but I thought dogs was done with a fretless
David makes the bass sound like actual PIGS omg this is amazing
Fr
9:26 so bad ass.
10:03 my favorite part
That outro bassline is simply incredible
I believe Rodger was the concept, theme, mood guy. But Gilmour was the musician who turned them into masterpieces.
Richard Wright was the link between them.
I mean between Gilmour and Waters, while Nick Mason was in charge to keep the three together. I'll let here a link for you all to listen to a technical explanation that helped me to understand how it worked out; and why Richard Right was THE key man of the band. Check it out!
ruclips.net/video/axHr3I7y9YA/видео.htmlsi=LEr26X-62voZ2kaR
ruclips.net/video/axHr3I7y9YA/видео.htmlsi=LEr26X-62voZ2kaR
ruclips.net/video/axHr3I7y9YA/видео.htmlsi=LEr26X-62voZ2kaR
I can listen to this all day. So good
Always thought the vibrato was very lead guitarist like.
David was male perfection back in the 70's.
Roger was a great bass player listen to Live at Pompeii. This bass playing by Gilmour sounds more like a guitar than a bass. I wish Roger would have played it. If Dave wanted to be a bass player I am sure he would have been great, but a guitar player can not just become a bass player, you got to live it. These photos of Dave are from the Obscured By Clouds sessions BTW.
@@Allen-jn4kx Thanks for the reference. I knew it was earlier, but wasn’t too sure.
I'd agree with you in the sense that Roger is the much more EFFECTIVE. He doesn't do too much, but he does exactly what's needed of him. He's a very solid musical and rhythmic backbone.
As a (hobbyist) bassist I absolutely adore Dave's bass line here, but on this song they basically swapped instruments while keeping the same roles.
Roger supports on the rhythm guitar while Dave plays the lead. I don't mind it here though and it sounds very unique (and it's fun to play).
Gilmour was more profficient technically and he could do bass takes more quicklly than Roger...the pict is not from Animals sessions, right? I think is from 1972, Obscured by clouds recording
@@martinbarrios7920 that’s what someone else said so I imagine it’s correct. Just wanted to throw something in the screen to look at.
Thanks for uploading this, best quality I have heard of this stem. Which led me to trying to recreate it in a clip on my channel. Thanks so much 🙏🏻❤️
No problem! I love this baseline so much so I want to share the best could.
That's amazing. I wonder how he constructed it, in parts or in one go?
one go
Thank you
hey you
Fantástico obrigado por isolar o som do baixo
👍
Crazy how Gilmour was a better bass player than Waters
Not that crazy at all. Roger isn’t that good of a musician but he’s an amazing songwriter. Most great guitarists can easily play bass.
Yiu sure it is gilmour?
@@Eden_Rubin_MusicYes. Waters has admitted he wasn't a good bass player
Yeah this solos are suspicious 😂
Roger was def better. Pigs has a good baseline but Roger’s playing on breathe, great gig in the sky, time, money eclipse, echoes and so many more was better than and hey you
Por favor faça uma linha isolada da guitarra dessa musica 😍
Once a pissed David said " Bass players are a dime a dozen"
So are Guitar Players, Drummers, etc. But amazing songwriters are far and few
@@nigelpisswater484Musicians in general are all a dime a dozen, it’s those with exceptional talent that make them the *exception* such as Roger and David, both very skilled at what they do best
That is true, but good bass players are a lot more difficult to find.
@@MrChopsticktech Brian Wilson & Paul McCartney come to mind...
Holy shit, that's so fucking punchy
I wonder if the Hiwatt was being used. Or if they had it miked up for guitar parts ?
@@Ontariosound I’m pretty sure that was their amp of choice for bass but I could be wrong!
@@kevinsheppard2312 Ampeg B18 bass amp was used for The Wall sessions. They also liked the Alembic bass tube preamp.
as much of a questionable public figure as roger can be, he’s a hell of a bassist. super aggressive tone and part with some funky ass fills in there too
also, out of curiosity, did you use the original ‘77 mix or the 2018 remix? i personally think the 2018 mix does the album much better justice, particularly in the rhythm section. everything is a lot clearer and punchier
Agreed. 2018 mix sounds great and that's what I used.
Actually, not being a you know what but, I think Gilmour played bass on this track
@@matthewmccaslin6798 i thought david only did bass on dogs?
@@owenandrew8108 you may be right
@@matthewmccaslin6798 No, actually you are right, Gilmour played the bass on this track :)
En verdad gilmour grabró el bajo en esta canción?
Yes and he composed the bass line. I don't think Roger played anything on Pigs. Maybe a VC3.
@@davevasques2157 cool
@@davevasques2157 Roger playing Rhythm Guitar on Pigs
@@revanasywal Not according to Pink Floyd: All The Songs by Jean-Michel Guesdon and Phillippe Margotin. Roger played rhythm live and Snowy White played the bass live but according to them, Gilmour played all the guitars and bass on the recording.