Crucible Approach - What is differentiation (Bowen, Schnarch) and How it can change your life

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 окт 2024

Комментарии • 72

  • @unrespiro
    @unrespiro 2 года назад +10

    Thank you for this video. I read one Schnarch's book and loved it so much! What you said about therapist being differentiated first (before recommending it to the clients) I saw it in my own therapy: when I confronted my previous therapist about something I didn't like about our therapy or her treatment, she would turn defensive, I think this is not ok. With my current psychologist, trained in psychoanalysis, where they work so much with transference, I can say whatever I want to him and know he will not react, just turn it in a tool in my therapy. It is a very diferent experience and a really transformative one. I think this is differentiation.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад +2

      Thanks again for watching and commenting. Yes, therapist's level of differentiation is crucial for their ability to help their clients. I'm glad to hear that you feel free with your therapist and I hope you'll be able to raise differentiation throughout your life. Good luck!

  • @krisjazz27
    @krisjazz27 Год назад +2

    Thank you for your work! I am a mental health therapist in Washington state, and I have been learning about myself and Schnarch's work since 2003. Peggy Pace the creator of Lifespan Integration introduced his book, "The Passionate Marriage" to me. Thanks again for creating a fantastic video that explains differentiation well.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад

      Thanks so much for watching and commenting. We don't take it for granted. Take care :)

  • @AnInklingSR
    @AnInklingSR 23 дня назад

    Happy (Belated) Birthday, Dr. Assael! Thank you for the very helpful breakdown of these concepts and for the self-disclosure you shared as well.

  • @LoudPedal66
    @LoudPedal66 Год назад +2

    Your message is so clear, necessary and universal, Dr Assael. I return to your discussion often, as a reminder of how we can do better. 💪Greg

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад

      Hi Greg, Thanks so much for kind words. I really appreciate it. Take care :)

  • @asmith0271
    @asmith0271 21 день назад

    You totally simplified this for me. Thank you.!

  • @ashermarieward
    @ashermarieward 3 года назад +3

    I appreciate the time you have dedicated to this topic. I took good notes and will use this video as a reference when needed. Such an important discussion to be had. I wasn't even aware of differentiation until a few months ago and at first, I was scared/sad because I didn't even know one could have a solid sense of self. It was like an awakening to how I had been living my life. I was constantly people-pleasing in order to feed that reflected sense of self which was overly exhausting and helping no one. I hadn't even thought of how to validate my own self or how to make my own decisions- this way I can have true intimacy and not fragile connections. I'm so grateful to be building my solid sense of self. Thank you again

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад +1

      Thank you for watching and commenting. It sounds like you did some deep personal work. Good for you. Wishing you good luck on your journey!

  • @zaord
    @zaord 2 года назад +2

    Its feels that is also my birthday today ;) Thanks for those gifts ! Life is light

  • @ext1013
    @ext1013 3 года назад +8

    I picked up a book from a thrift shop on Differentiation, thinking that it's about theories of why we are different from each other. When I got home, the book is about marketing, about making more money than other people. I was intrigued that I searched for a better explanation. I stopped searching when I landed on your site. Thank you. Oh and happy birthday.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад

      Hi. Thanks for watching and commenting. I'm glad that you liked the content. Good luck!

  • @PM-zw9xz
    @PM-zw9xz 2 года назад +3

    This is just wonderful!
    I just found you!
    Thank you for the great level!

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад

      Thanks for watching and commenting. We're happy the content is helpful. Good luck!

  • @MsLadyAva
    @MsLadyAva 2 года назад +5

    Wow this is such an amazing lecture! You're a gifted teacher.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад

      Thanks again for all you comments. We’re so glad you like it!

  • @LoudPedal66
    @LoudPedal66 Год назад +2

    Thanks!

  • @briarroseO
    @briarroseO 2 года назад +1

    It's nearly your birthday again, when I found this video! Thanks for the interesting vid. Happy birthday!

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад +1

      Thanks Bryer for the birthday wishes. I'm glad you found the vid interesting. Good luck!

  • @hotdoggington6962
    @hotdoggington6962 Год назад +1

    Oh this is great, thank you for this content! You're a gifted teacher and this is an extremely worthy subject

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад

      Wow. Thanks so much. I'm glad you found this relevant. Good luck!

  • @bethaniacounseling
    @bethaniacounseling 5 месяцев назад +1

    Great explanation of differentiation!

  • @cyfisher8679
    @cyfisher8679 7 месяцев назад +1

    Great video. Thank you. Just what I was looking for.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  7 месяцев назад

      I’m so glad. Took me many years to get it into the muscle enough so I can teach it without being a hypocrite. Thanks for watching.

  • @phill8504
    @phill8504 5 месяцев назад

    That was fantastic thank you. This book is on my read list

  • @professorstarlight2268
    @professorstarlight2268 6 месяцев назад

    Wow, what an amazing video. I've recently been introduced to the concept of self differentiation by my counselor, and there's so much here that resonates with me and where I'm at in my journey. "The only way around is through, and the only way I can grow is through the pain, and the ruptures, and the repairs." -- this hit home especially. I feel like I just got a sneak preview of the next few months of my life. Thank you for posting this - looking forward to watching the other personal development videos.

  • @dickdebruijn6395
    @dickdebruijn6395 2 года назад +2

    This is SO helpful in my life as a person, a partner and a therapist ! Big thanks from Amsterdam !

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад

      Hi Dick. Thanks for watching and commenting. Good luck!

  • @celestesullivan303
    @celestesullivan303 Год назад +1

    This was an awesome video. Thank you so much.

  • @gravity1015
    @gravity1015 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for your message. Also, happy birthday!

  • @aaronwatchestuff
    @aaronwatchestuff Год назад +1

    Great vid, thank you! I appreciate how relatable you are, and it’s super helpful to have this information to reinforce things I that I am learning.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад

      Thanks so much Aaron for watching and commenting. Glad the content is helpful. Good luck!

  • @okorion75
    @okorion75 3 года назад +2

    Thanks this was a clear discussion of a very important topic.

  • @joysarahc7437
    @joysarahc7437 Год назад +1

    Thank you! This is helpful 💚

  • @biancajoseph1115
    @biancajoseph1115 3 года назад +1

    I absolutely loved this, thank you so much for making this video! Super informative and the perfect amount of personal.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад

      Thanks Bianca for watching. We're happy you find the content informative. Take care!

  • @deborahlara
    @deborahlara 3 года назад +2

    Beautiful video. Your passion for this work clearly shows through to me. You present these topics and concepts in almost a poetic way.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад

      Thanks Deborah for watching and commenting. Yes, I’m very passionate about my work. Good luck!

  • @kemgoddess1
    @kemgoddess1 3 года назад +2

    Great explanation! Thank You!

  • @oliviaf9259
    @oliviaf9259 3 года назад +1

    This video blew my mind

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад

      Thanks for watching. We're so happy that our content is helpful. Good luck!

  • @Im4Right
    @Im4Right 3 года назад +1

    I wish you were in Utah and could be my supervisor, if you are even a MFT supervisor. I really like this presentation.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад

      Thanks for watching and commenting Donald. I am indeed a certified MFT supervisor and actually offer online supervision:
      www.potentialstate.com/supervision-for-therapists.
      Glad you like the presentation.
      Good luck!

  • @nadaskafskaf7803
    @nadaskafskaf7803 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for the video, which book do you recommend for differentiation and Bowen family therapy. I am reading “ family therapy in clinical practice” but it has so much explanations about how the theory was developed and less on explaining the theory and how to increase self and family differentiation. Thank you again!

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад +1

      Thanks Nada for watching and commenting. I recommend Schnarch's book called The Passionate Marriage which breaks down Bowen's concepts to practical applications. Good luck!

  • @jilllindenbaum
    @jilllindenbaum 2 года назад +2

    I loved this video. I have been working with a therapist on self validation. I am sensing that my husband and I are actually at levels of differentiation. (He more differentiated than me, though it could just be more Independence/stubborness masked as differentiation. Could you point me to any resources for couples who are on different levels? This works also seems related to the Emotionally Focused Work of Sue Johnson author of Hold Me Tight. Seven Conversations for a Lifetime of Love. Are you familiar?

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад

      Thanks Jill for watching and commenting. I would recommend reading The Passionate Marriage by David Schnarch. You'll find in that book more practical help. This is a different view from the EFT work of Sue Johnson. Good luck!

  • @nicolebernal2628
    @nicolebernal2628 2 года назад +1

    Happy belated

  • @Hannah1980
    @Hannah1980 Год назад

    Thank you! ❤🙏❤

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад +1

      Thank you for watching!

    • @Hannah1980
      @Hannah1980 Год назад +1

      @@ThePotentialState Do you have a video about the how?

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад +1

      @@Hannah1980 How what? How to raise differentiation? Yes, Many of our videos can help you raise differentiation. Check out this playlist: ruclips.net/video/jkihtL5j3Ko/видео.html. You'll find a collection of our videos that will help you raise differentiation. Good luck!

  • @korpiz
    @korpiz 2 года назад +1

    I just discovered your channel, and this video and what you are speaking about resonated so much with me. I also started reading Bowen and then Carl Whitaker, this was after I qualified as a Systemic Psychotherapist and it fundamentally changed my entire professional and personal selves in profoundly positive ways. I have not heard about Schnarch, but I will read some of his, which book do you recommend I start with?
    I am actually at this moment also preparing a brief presentation of how differentiation as a concept, map, approach, orienting principle can be used in clinical supervision.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад

      Hi Korpiz. Thanks for your message. Glad you like the video. I recommend you start with Passionate Marriage by Dr. Schnarch. Good luck with your presentation!

  • @Im4Right
    @Im4Right 3 года назад +1

    I am an MFT student and currently trying to complete an assignment on differentiation. I have spent quite a bit of time searching for an appropriate intervention to add to the handout I have been working on. I think that from this video I can now develop an intervention based on the 4 tips you talk about here. Where can I learn more details about these 4 tips?

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  3 года назад +1

      Hi Donald, thanks for watching and commenting. You can read more about the four points of balance in Dr. Schnarch's book Intimacy and Desire. Good luck!

  • @Enjoyinglife530
    @Enjoyinglife530 Год назад +2

    What book of Scharch does he cover differentiation?

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  Год назад +1

      Taylor, He covers differentiation in all of his books. I recommend you start with The Passionate Marriage. It's a great book. Good luck and thanks for watching!

    • @Enjoyinglife530
      @Enjoyinglife530 Год назад

      @@ThePotentialState Thanks, so far I've been learning to be more self focused than other focused and trying to show up for myself more in relationship. Has been a process for sure. You made alot of great points in this video that's added to my education. Thank you

  • @HURCNchristine
    @HURCNchristine 2 месяца назад

    🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼❤️

  • @SaarLeestMee
    @SaarLeestMee 2 года назад +1

    thank you for this video i gained a lot out of it. i hope you had a great birthday although ofcourse this isn't the same moment anymore. still very gratefull for the information.

    • @ThePotentialState
      @ThePotentialState  2 года назад

      Thank you Saar for watching and commenting. And thanks for the birthday wishes. Good luck!