Me and my friends just tried this for the first time. The first time we were 7 and I think it was ok. But the second time we were 6 and I think the witches are overpowered. After the 2 witches killed one villager, they just needed to wait for the first black card. This way, which was fast, the game turned out in an impossible 4 vs 1. I think in a 6 people game it should ony existe 1 witch.
That's great insight! Even with all of the playtesting in the world, some of these games can play out differently in different groups of players - we're all for trying out house rules when you think they might improve the game for your group! Try dropping to one witch the next time you have 6 players, and if that feels too difficult for the witch player, you could see what others rules you might be able to tweak a little to give the villagers a better shot against 2 witches. Thanks for watching!
Good questions! This game does have close-your-eyes phases, similar to games like Werewolf. And it does require someone to play the Game Master or Moderator, BUT the game master gets to participate just like everyone else. You can watch me play as the Witch AND Game Master in our full playthrough here to see how that works: ruclips.net/video/ZOikfNZP9j0/видео.html The same publisher's most recent game, Hollywood 1947, has a similar feel but without close-your-eyes phases or a game master. Instead, there is just one close-your-eyes moment at the beginning so the "Communists" can identify themselves to each other: ruclips.net/video/YONluKRL150/видео.html Thanks for watching! -Andy
Me and my friends just tried this for the first time. The first time we were 7 and I think it was ok. But the second time we were 6 and I think the witches are overpowered. After the 2 witches killed one villager, they just needed to wait for the first black card. This way, which was fast, the game turned out in an impossible 4 vs 1. I think in a 6 people game it should ony existe 1 witch.
That's great insight! Even with all of the playtesting in the world, some of these games can play out differently in different groups of players - we're all for trying out house rules when you think they might improve the game for your group! Try dropping to one witch the next time you have 6 players, and if that feels too difficult for the witch player, you could see what others rules you might be able to tweak a little to give the villagers a better shot against 2 witches.
Thanks for watching!
Has this game phases where the plyers have to close their eyes? And does it need a Game Master?
Good questions! This game does have close-your-eyes phases, similar to games like Werewolf. And it does require someone to play the Game Master or Moderator, BUT the game master gets to participate just like everyone else.
You can watch me play as the Witch AND Game Master in our full playthrough here to see how that works: ruclips.net/video/ZOikfNZP9j0/видео.html
The same publisher's most recent game, Hollywood 1947, has a similar feel but without close-your-eyes phases or a game master. Instead, there is just one close-your-eyes moment at the beginning so the "Communists" can identify themselves to each other: ruclips.net/video/YONluKRL150/видео.html
Thanks for watching!
-Andy
@@BoardGameBarrister Thx for the insight
Well said it is a great game to give ppl flack and receive it haha enjoyed the vid
Thanks for watching!