Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
A good story doesn't leave people trying to sort through what happened or what events might have meant. Neither should it need an explanation. So glad someone wrote one, though, or else i wouldn't have understood the ghost's involvement at all
She's a machine, - as is evident by the wrongly-placed sentence stress on any number of occasions. Didn't want to burst your bubble 💕, and genuinely glad you enjoyed it. Her phonology is, for the most part, consistent 😊.
@@elainewhite870yes, I came here to say this too. AI narration is getting better, but it is as if a human was reading the words with absolutely no idea of the sense of the story. You have to constantly re-translate it in your head to correct it. I don't understand why so many stories these days are narrated by AI. There are enough humans about who could do it surely?
I think the ending is perfect. Its written in old style of classes and heredity homes. It is her style of writing and she very door author. The narration is perfect. I enjoyed very much
Lol I’m reminded of a story my then little daughter told me when she was about 5 yrs old. It was a nice little story as I recall, but suddenly she couldn’t think of any more to add to it, and so closed with: “so she drank poison and died”!
I beliieve that most great short stories do not have a "ending" that satifies modern day readers. They arent happily ever after, just as life is not happily ever after ... I believe the point is to give the reader something to ponder long after the story has finished. I took English lit in college but am terrible at understanding literary references (or maybe I'm just too lazy to figure them out?) Anyhow, there are some short stories I will never forget.
All the more reason to either read the actual text so that you can stop and reflect as needed. Or have the stories read by someone who actually understands the words and where pauses and emphases are needed. Not a robot as in this case 😵💫🤔😕
A story leaving a lot to one's own imagination! Also I prefer the notation of Chapter 1 , chapter 2 etc to just the numbers. But the narrator had a clear speaking voice, pleasant to listen to. Thank you
@@DeborahMcgee-t8c with pleasure ❤️. I also subscribe to Tony Walker’s podcast because after he reads the story, he gives the listener a lot of historical and cultural context, as well as background information on the author that might have influenced the themes and characters in their story. 1 . Edith Wharton is known for being vague but the readers of her time -1902 would’ve read between the lines and identified the real horror of this story : A. Marital abuse- the husband was a predator. He possibly could’ve killed the former lady’s maid, preyed on pretty servants. Remember, that the current maid was warned to keep out of his way and the physical effects of her I’ll was protected her from abuse. B. The wife was having some type of affair with the neighbor (emotional/ physical) C. The ghost of the former lady’s maid wanted to rectify a wrong. She was the facilitator of an affair between her mistress and neighbor. Wanted to protect the mistress and tell her secret to the current one. The bell is probably a reminder of past trauma (abortion/ abuse). All the household knows and that’s why it was not rung. D. The wife’s weakened state could be due to ongoing abuse, marital rape, and perhaps an abortion that took place ( abortion also facility aged by former lady’s maid- remember, the trip to the chemist) E. Ghost lead present housemaid to burial site of baby (under the tree of the neighbor). I read that ghost appearing at a site is a tool that refers to something/ someone buried F. On the last night the wife and lover were to meet, the bell rung because the present lady’s maid is called to help her mistress. The ghost appears to protect lover/ mistress and give him a chance to escape by appearing to husband. G. Lover shows up to church with a cane- probably jumped out the window from the dressing room, on the night the lady died.
Ty for these narratives. I love observing how ppl lived back in simpler times. It is somewhat relaxing and makes sense of lives move in the way it’s just supposed to go whether happy or sad.
Thank you for bringing Wharton back to mind. I haven't read any of her works since grad school, oddly enough because I enjoyed them. It is a pity that her work is not appreciated by some who visited the site. I, however, will remain a subscriber because I love literature. ❤
She won the Pulitzer for The Age of Innocence. Was very well loved in her time. Nicknamed Pussy Jones growing up (did I just type that??) Divorced. Included with great American literature. But no one mentioned this short story. Maybe not one of her most notable.
The picture of the large house looks exactly like a house I stayed at in Colwyn Bay, North Wales. My fiancee and I were staying at the house for a couple of nights. The second night the ghost of a lady dressed in old Victorian attire, whilst rocking in a rocking chair. Made us both jump out of bed and run out of the room. Next morning the landlady said. "Oh, don't worry about old Gwen she normally comes from time to time to check out our guests." 😮
About half way through I began to feel that tge story had gone on long enough. She had layed fown much foreshadowing. Now I wanted a conclusion. But she went on, and on...and on.... Endless foreshadowing of...what? Nothing. No satisfying resolution.
The ending was so abrupt its annoying, but what else is there to say? That the cranky gasbag Mr.Brympton would continue to periodically show up and drunkenly menace the staff? Not the kind of storyline people are going to stick around for.
@BenGreggSweden 1 day ago Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
I got suckered in again. Listen closely, it's an AI generated narration. Puts a good voice actor out of work. It took me a couple of listens before I realized that this youtuber uses AI. Absolutely ruined Somerset Maugham for me. I unsubscribed
Copy and pasted @BenGreggSweden 1 day ago Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
Hmmm, what is everyones thoughts on what this was about. Was there an affair? Was the dead maid keeping an eye on her mistress? Not sure why though, the hubby had no interest in her. What was the story really about?
I'm wondering the same thing. Maybe there's a synopsis of the story on wikipedia or something. There's another story you might want to listen to called The Bunner Sisters by her that's really good and full of symbolism. I couldn't find a synopsis of this short story. The Bunner Sisters was read by someone from LibraVox who read stories as volunteers. I've never done so, but the story was really good. It should still be on youtube - that's where I found it.
I suppose that Ranford WAS her lover. And that the husband had raped Anna the former maid, who had, whereupon, committed suicide. His lechery towards subsequent maids caused them to leave suddenly...as did the ghostly appearances. The wife dying, upon hearing, once again that the maids bell had rung, when she had not rung it, tipped her over the edge. Thats plausible, I guess, as we were told early on her paleness was likely due to a heart condition. But I still find the story inconclusive and dissatisfying.
Here is what I think. The neighbor was, if not a lover, at least a confidant. Emma was the lady’s faithful maid and friend for years. The husband was only passing through to likely rape his ailing wife, treating her cruelly, drunk and raging, only to leave again the next day. When the lady finally could take no more, she rang the bell for Emma in one of these moments, and the husband killed Emma when she intervened. Emma’s ghost stayed to continue to watch over her lady. The bell was no longer rung because it brought back to mind Emma’s death, and the ringing of the bell had likely prompted that. All this being said, why was Emma’s room kept locked? And I agree, the ending wasn’t satisfying, leaving too much to guess at.
Authors would often adapt a short story or novella into a full length novel. Especially if there was a demand for it, either from her readers or a publisher.
Copied this comment @BenGreggSweden 1 day ago Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
Listening to this, but when it ended, I was still waiting. I don’t get the whole thing. One made was a ghost I think but that’s it. Nothing else scary in the whole thing.
@@AnitaOHara-q8l The phrasing and pronunciation is absolutely perfect and expressive for British English. I would guess this is a professional actress, with a voice similar to Jan Francis. Nothing like AI
Was waiting for the conclusion. What on earthhadbeen going on with the 3 persons involved and what had happened to the previous maid. Very disappointing
GOOD Grand & Wonderfully Happy Morning, Our Friends....Best Wishes For Each if You To Enjoy Great Day!!! Here's A Short Story, By Edith Wharton...Warning, However, Msny Hsvr Found The Ending. On This Story to Ve Simewhar of a Bumner...See Whar Yiu Thin???❤
There seems to be no point to this story. Lots of possibilities as to the meaning of the story but a good imagination can make up almost any ending. Rather disappointing.
Sound like someone jumped from the window before the man of the house came into the room of the mistress. Her maid had saved her from seeing her lover killed and as he escape thru the window but the fright killed her.
Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
@BenGreggSweden, thanks for this great explanation!
Thanks now I can get what was happening there 😂🌹
My thoughts exactly.
I totally agree with your synopsis
A good story doesn't leave people trying to sort through what happened or what events might have meant. Neither should it need an explanation. So glad someone wrote one, though, or else i wouldn't have understood the ghost's involvement at all
Thanks, I need this instead of politics, thanks. Lovely history
Same!
Absolutely
So true!
I don’t know who the narrator is but she is just fabulous! I love how her voice adds such a calmness to the narrative.
She's a machine, - as is evident by the wrongly-placed sentence stress on any number of occasions. Didn't want to burst your bubble 💕, and genuinely glad you enjoyed it. Her phonology is, for the most part, consistent 😊.
Very frustrating listening to a story when the narrator (AI, obviously) is monologuing and not emphasising the words at the right place.
@@elainewhite870yes, I came here to say this too. AI narration is getting better, but it is as if a human was reading the words with absolutely no idea of the sense of the story. You have to constantly re-translate it in your head to correct it. I don't understand why so many stories these days are narrated by AI. There are enough humans about who could do it surely?
@@elainewhite870 yes. Extremely bizarre and annoying intonations for Mr Brympton's speech.
The ending is as if the author just grew tired of the story.
I think the ending is perfect. Its written in old style of classes and heredity homes. It is her style of writing and she very door author. The narration is perfect. I enjoyed very much
@@ironbutterfly6835 dour?
Lol yea I know right?
Lol I’m reminded of a story my then little daughter told me when she was about 5 yrs old. It was a nice little story as I recall, but suddenly she couldn’t think of any more to add to it, and so closed with: “so she drank poison and died”!
If I had known the author was going to just stop writing I wouldn’t have bothered to listen to a partial story
I beliieve that most great short stories do not have a "ending" that satifies modern day readers. They arent happily ever after, just as life is not happily ever after ...
I believe the point is to give the reader something to ponder long after the story has finished. I took English lit in college but am terrible at understanding literary references (or maybe I'm just too lazy to figure them out?) Anyhow, there are some short stories I will never forget.
All the more reason to either read the actual text so that you can stop and reflect as needed. Or have the stories read by someone who actually understands the words and where pauses and emphases are needed. Not a robot as in this case 😵💫🤔😕
A story leaving a lot to one's own imagination! Also I prefer the notation of Chapter 1 , chapter 2 etc to just the numbers. But the narrator had a clear speaking voice, pleasant to listen to. Thank you
Wonderful story❤. Love Edith Wharton.
Can you
Explain it then, please thanks in advance👍
@@DeborahMcgee-t8c with pleasure ❤️. I also subscribe to Tony Walker’s podcast because after he reads the story, he gives the listener a lot of historical and cultural context, as well as background information on the author that might have influenced the themes and characters in their story.
1 . Edith Wharton is known for being vague but the readers of her time -1902 would’ve read between the lines and identified the real horror of this story :
A. Marital abuse- the husband was a predator. He possibly could’ve killed the former lady’s maid, preyed on pretty servants. Remember, that the current maid was warned to keep out of his way and the physical effects of her I’ll was protected her from abuse.
B. The wife was having some type of affair with the neighbor (emotional/ physical)
C. The ghost of the former lady’s maid wanted to rectify a wrong. She was the facilitator of an affair between her mistress and neighbor. Wanted to protect the mistress and tell her secret to the current one. The bell is probably a reminder of past trauma (abortion/ abuse). All the household knows and that’s why it was not rung.
D. The wife’s weakened state could be due to ongoing abuse, marital rape, and perhaps an abortion that took place ( abortion also facility aged by former lady’s maid- remember, the trip to the chemist)
E. Ghost lead present housemaid to burial site of baby (under the tree of the neighbor). I read that ghost appearing at a site is a tool that refers to something/ someone buried
F. On the last night the wife and lover were to meet, the bell rung because the present lady’s maid is called to help her mistress. The ghost appears to protect lover/ mistress and give him a chance to escape by appearing to husband.
G. Lover shows up to church with a cane- probably jumped out the window from the dressing room, on the night the lady died.
@@DeborahMcgee-t8c this is just one of many explanations. I’m sure there’s more digging to do. That’s the fun of it 😄.
Ty for these narratives. I love observing how ppl lived back in simpler times. It is somewhat relaxing and makes sense of lives move in the way it’s just supposed to go whether happy or sad.
It's an engaging mystery, but if you're the sort that wants answers, this one is NOT for you.
Thank you for bringing Wharton back to mind. I haven't read any of her works since grad school, oddly enough because I enjoyed them. It is a pity that her work is not appreciated by some who visited the site. I, however, will remain a subscriber because I love literature. ❤
Great story and contrary to what some thought, the ending was perfect.
Only if you like unsolved mysteries. I felt disappointed. I followed the ghost, only to be left with NO answers.
How? Please explain.
She won the Pulitzer for The Age of Innocence. Was very well loved in her time. Nicknamed Pussy Jones growing up (did I just type that??) Divorced. Included with great American literature. But no one mentioned this short story. Maybe not one of her most notable.
Thank you for this although for some reason youtube won't let me give you a thumbs up
Thank you so very much for this beautifully told story
Thank you so much for your channel. You have brought peace into a troubled life
❤
❤😮
The picture of the large house looks exactly like a house I stayed at in Colwyn Bay, North Wales. My fiancee and I were staying at the house for a couple of nights. The second night the ghost of a lady dressed in old Victorian attire, whilst rocking in a rocking chair. Made us both jump out of bed and run out of the room.
Next morning the landlady said. "Oh, don't worry about old Gwen she normally comes from time to time to check out our guests." 😮
. . . And. . .???!!
The reader was totally grand - nuanced, calm, real, and you can’t stop listening to her. :) 🥀💙🌷🌱
Dignity, lovely story ❤️
Thank you for a lovely story.
Lovely! Thank you
It was a lovely story but a crap ending
Yeah it did end rather abruptly.
Rather anti- climactic and confusing...😮
Wow! Thanks alot!
Yes ending is crap
I don't understand what happened in the end.
This is incomplete!!
That is the whole story as written Edith Wharton
Loved the narrator's low, mellifluous voice, lovely clear diction ❤
1.25 x speed works well.
Bravo. Well done
About half way through I began to feel that tge story had gone on long enough. She had layed fown much foreshadowing. Now I wanted a conclusion.
But she went on, and on...and on.... Endless foreshadowing of...what? Nothing. No satisfying resolution.
Lovely
The ending was so abrupt its annoying, but what else is there to say? That the cranky gasbag Mr.Brympton would continue to periodically show up and drunkenly menace the staff? Not the kind of storyline people are going to stick around for.
Turn of the Screw is similar
I don’t get it.
Neither do I.
Weird
Í don't get half of what I read. 😅
I don't get half of what I read 😅😅
@BenGreggSweden
1 day ago
Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
I can't understand hahahah where's the ending?
The ending didn’t make sense …..
Not that ending was crap. THERE WAS NO ENDING. Very unsatisfactory .. but excellent reader.
I got suckered in again. Listen closely, it's an AI generated narration. Puts a good voice actor out of work.
It took me a couple of listens before I realized that this youtuber uses AI. Absolutely ruined Somerset Maugham for me. I unsubscribed
@@opheliahamlet3508 That would explain the often misplaced emphasis. Distracting, breaks the atmosphere..
Copy and pasted @BenGreggSweden
1 day ago
Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
😂👍
Hmmm, what is everyones thoughts on what this was about. Was there an affair? Was the dead maid keeping an eye on her mistress? Not sure why though, the hubby had no interest in her. What was the story really about?
I'm wondering the same thing. Maybe there's a synopsis of the story on wikipedia or something. There's another story you might want to listen to called The Bunner Sisters by her that's really good and full of symbolism. I couldn't find a synopsis of this short story. The Bunner Sisters was read by someone from LibraVox who read stories as volunteers. I've never done so, but the story was really good. It should still be on youtube - that's where I found it.
@sugarfalls1 Thanks for the tip, I'll go look for it now, I need something to fall to sleep to lol 😆
I suppose that Ranford WAS her lover. And that the husband had raped Anna the former maid, who had, whereupon, committed suicide.
His lechery towards subsequent maids caused them to leave suddenly...as did the ghostly appearances.
The wife dying, upon hearing, once again that the maids bell had rung, when she had not rung it, tipped her over the edge.
Thats plausible, I guess, as we were told early on her paleness was likely due to a heart condition.
But I still find the story inconclusive and dissatisfying.
Here is what I think. The neighbor was, if not a lover, at least a confidant. Emma was the lady’s faithful maid and friend for years. The husband was only passing through to likely rape his ailing wife, treating her cruelly, drunk and raging, only to leave again the next day. When the lady finally could take no more, she rang the bell for Emma in one of these moments, and the husband killed Emma when she intervened. Emma’s ghost stayed to continue to watch over her lady. The bell was no longer rung because it brought back to mind Emma’s death, and the ringing of the bell had likely prompted that.
All this being said, why was Emma’s room kept locked? And I agree, the ending wasn’t satisfying, leaving too much to guess at.
@HestiaBHN1 Yes between you and other comments the story is definitely between these lines.
I have heard enough stories, I would like to watch Agatha Christie, Miss Marple, but not available on RUclips anymore! 😫
I really enjoyed it but I was waiting for the end. There no conclusion to the story or an explanation.
Well... I'm stumped. There must be more. The tone of the narrators voice with her last words sounded as though she wasn't finished..
Authors would often adapt a short story or novella into a full length novel. Especially if there was a demand for it, either from her readers or a publisher.
I don't think this book is finished. Are you sure you read it all
This is only the ending of chapter 4. The story is incomplete.
That is the whole story as written by Edith Wharton
Copied this comment @BenGreggSweden
1 day ago
Hmm… spoiler (if you haven’t seen it), but my take is that Mrs. Brympton and Mr. Ranford were having an affair. The ghost of Emma Saxon knows this, and is protective of them (as she probably had been while she was still alive), and is continuing to watch over and protect Mrs. Brymton from the other side. That is why she leads Miss Hartley down to Mrs. Brympton’s room several times, with the last time being so as to warn Mrs. Brymton when Mr. Brymton arrives very unexpectedly (after having led everyone to believe that he was far far away in the West Indies). Mr. Brymton sneaks in during the middle of the night, hoping to catch his wife in the act. However, Miss Hartley’s knocking on the Mrs. Brymton’s bedroom door gives Mr. Randord time to hide in the next room, and then escape-most likely by jumping out the window-but not without making noise, which Mr. Brymton hears before rushing to try and catch his “old friend” there. Yet he is thwarted by the ghost of Emma Saxon’s sudden appearance on the threshold. We are meant to understand that Mr. Ranford made his escape via the window by the fact that he is then seen walking with a limp, with Mr. Brymton scowling at him throughout the funeral because he has guessed that as well. However, having failed to catch Ranford in the act, he has no recourse but to keep his place as a gentleman. Mrs. Brymton (who we have been made to understand was very sickly and weak) clearly dies from the shock of having nearly been caught out by her husband in the arms of Mr. Ranford (which surely would have happened if she had not been warned). But her dying is not a bad thing. We understand that it was inevitable, due to her long illness, yet at least she is allowed to die with her honor kept intact, while also knowing that her dear friend Emma is waiting for her on the other side.
Thought my phone died !
Is there a part 2 to this?
What was with the abrupt ending?
Chapter 1. 00:17
Chapter 2. 12:26
Chapter 3. 27:59
Chapter 4. 34:34
Is this the first part of this story, is there a second part? Beautifully read.
Listening to this, but when it ended, I was still waiting. I don’t get the whole thing. One made was a ghost I think but that’s it. Nothing else scary in the whole thing.
Where is the ending??!!😕
What did it matter that he leaned on a stick?
Is it being read by AI
Yes, sure it is AI as the emphasis in the phrasing is not correct and not how it would be read by a real person telling a story.
@@AnitaOHara-q8l The phrasing and pronunciation is absolutely perfect and expressive for British English. I would guess this is a professional actress, with a voice similar to Jan Francis. Nothing like AI
No
It didn't end right
Odd, unfulfilling. A story requiring a conclusion, me thinks.
JaneR
Does it end? Shouldn't Brimpton have been blessed with a mighty ailment?
Poor ending, or is there a sequel?
Great story, but what a disappointing ending. I mean, what happened to everyone?
So I guess the husband killed the Old Maid
There is no ending and that was very cruel
Excellent story!!!
Was waiting for the conclusion. What on earthhadbeen going on with the 3 persons involved and what had happened to the previous maid. Very disappointing
Ending 😮???
GOOD Grand & Wonderfully Happy Morning, Our Friends....Best Wishes For Each if You To Enjoy Great Day!!! Here's A Short Story, By Edith Wharton...Warning, However, Msny Hsvr Found The Ending. On This Story to Ve Simewhar of a Bumner...See Whar Yiu Thin???❤
Is that it
Hmmm. 🤔
At least I enjoyed the text, the Grammer.
Not so much the story.
one word ........ syntax
WT ACTUAL F. Ends so very abruptly…
Ah.... what???
Are we supposed to imagin what happend ourselfes?
What happened to characters? The ending kind of suck's? Good story up to closer of story!!!
Could have been good but the ending left many loose ends. Don't waste your time on this
You should write a book......😅
Mrs. Brimpton was not the angel that she was portrayed to be.
Quite unsatisfactory ending.
Edith Wharton
Won't listen because of the comments...😢
What! That's it? Come on that can't be the end,
I guess I'm dense, but this felt like a non-story to me.
After all that detail in the story and then it quietly fades away with no explanation for anything.
What a poor ending to a fine story!
What???
What happened?
Nothing. It was all for nothing.
Very disappointing now, as a writer myself.I have to come up with an ending to this story.In my mind as I go to bed which will be very shortlate😂😂😂
There's no second part....?
There seems to be no point to this story. Lots of possibilities as to the meaning of the story but a good imagination can make up almost any ending. Rather disappointing.
Sounds like AI read this story, the intonation was repetitive.
H
That's it? A very disappointing story, though the narration was good
It appeatd to ju
It just fizzled out.
Anyone know where I can find the rest of this story?
❤
Okay, that's it, won't be listening to this channel again.
I listened twice, don't get it?
Sound like someone jumped from the window before the man of the house came into the room of the mistress. Her maid had saved her from seeing her lover killed and as he escape thru the window but the fright killed her.
Ok so this is what Trump means when he says…. “We have it all”
_rim comments I won't watch
Well crap.
I unsuscribed and will avoid nueralsurfer from now on.
What happened?