Q+A #40 - Why does modal interchange work?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 июл 2024
- Many thanks to Jesse Hampsch, Jason Blasingame, SwordOfPhoenix, L2112Lifz, MichaelBxl, Cuppa Tea, AL_2017, Noah S, and Golden K Music for your insightful questions!
Adam Neely T-shirts! (BASS)
teespring.com/stores/adam-nee...
1:50 Why do pieces I write on a short deadline turn out better received than pieces I write where I spend many months on them?
4:10 Why does modal interchange work?
5:56 How is "social skill" important in a musician's career?
6:53 Can't I just use the Lick over and over at jam sessions?
7:02 How do you listen to jazz? What sorts of things are needed in active listening?
10:30 You didn't actually learn that Cure song from that one old video of yours in real time!
11:35 On playing crappy wedding gigs
13:06 Who is like Adam Neely, but for saxophone?
14:36 How do I get a girlfriend as a bass player?
⦿ SUPPORT ME ON PATREON ⦿
/ adamneely
⦿ FOLLOW ME ON THE INTERNETS ⦿
/ adamneely
/ its_adamneely
⦿ Check out some of my music ⦿
sungazermusic.bandcamp.com
insideoutsidemusic.bandcamp.com
adamneelymusic.bandcamp.com
Peace,
Adam
![Natanael Cano x Oscar Maydon - Giza [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eXCS6-MSQ_Y/mqdefault.jpg)
the ending just killed me
eHcOZaX Rest in Pepperoni
It did kill... my hopes.
Even because we all just *know* that was a lady at the door…
Bassist don’t get girls
I haven't laughed that hard in a long while...
Was running the door at a indie rock gig where the sax soloed for 5 minutes just playing different forms of The Lick with the chord changes over the entire form of the song. This dude was playing different versions of the lick for 5 minutes. So beautiful. I don't think they have any more gigs booked though.
Is there an Adam Neely for Mayonnaise?
No but there is one for en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bass_(fish) :P
Mayonnaise is not an instrument, at least according to Squidward. Patrick already asked that question. ;)
Is there an Adam Neely for cars?
better spell it like my nickname
Is there an Adam Neely for Smash Mouth sampling?
The punchline at the end made me laugh out loud!
Dewsy Sipos what was it
It's a running joke, that bass players never get the girl. So when asked about the girlfiriend, Adam seemengly wanted to anwser by talking about the private life, but the phone "accidentaly" rang, so he had to leave. This way, the myth continues to live.
@@DewsySipos I think that was someone (presumably a lady friend) buzzing his apartment.
This video lasts 15 min 14 sec
15 x 14 = 210.
The product of the digits of 210 is 2 whereas the sum of its digits is 3 so:
210 x 2 +3 = 423.
Add each the digit:
423 + 4 + 2 + 3 = 432
Just believe man! This does not happen by random...
And no! The product of the digits of 210 is not 0. you unbeliever pagan!
LsMor I wonder how many people actually believed this comment was serious...
It would only be taken seriously had LsMor specified units such as Hz, cps, bps, or sync number. That would require the operations to conform with the principles of dimensional analysis, scale, and similarity ...
philsci-archive.pitt.edu/4474/1/SterrettSimilarity%26DimensionalAnalysis5January2009.pdf
"The product of the digits 210 is 2"
TIL 2*1*0=2
You needed to stop at 210 x 2. That's more than enough.
read the full comment :)
Clearly the best way to get a girlfriend when you're a bassist is to be able to play The Lick in any position ;)
That was pretty slick of you :3
With a teacher like Adam, how can you go wrong?
Nihl Echo are you a literary savant?
Jokes on you, they were killed by my puns years ago!
More like give her the lick
Where was the 'ya' in the intro? :(((
i hope this is answered in Q&A 41
for real wtf
me too!
Not family-friendly enough for youtube
Honestly though, I think the point was exactly to interrupt the reagular flow with the announcement concerning UMG..? (I know, "no sh*t, Sherlock", but this and some answers sounded like honestly wondering)
Adam Neely's vid deserve an active listening. I now listen to them with paper and pencils, and I take some notes.
I come in expecting just to chill and listen, but I always end up jotting stuff down in notepad and saving it to my documents for later. #thestruggle
on point
oh thank god im not the only one
@@busteronlyfullscreenmode #struggling with that name sir.
yo adam!
When people ask for someone who is like you, but not you, they mostly just want more of what you do, because your stuff is so great and it is hard to find someone who is teaches "advanced" musical theory that goes beyond the widely spread knowledge (pentatonics, major, minor, triads) and extends it with things like modal interchange, cantus firmus, musical fractals, .....
so in other words: Keep up your awesome fucking work, yo!
Agreed, I'm watching your stuff much faster than you can produce it. It's good stuff!
Your explanation of how to listen to Jazz was pretty mindblowing to me. I guess I knew some of this stuff already but it really cleared it up. Thanks Adam!
paused the video to learn what was on your shirt....played the lick
the harsh pls don't use "faggot" as an insult
the harsh also, if you're going to use it, spell it correctly.
the harsh Also, you forgot a comma.
I think it is a simplified version of the piano riff that he plays inbetween questions.
the harsh The word faggot is about the worst insult there is. The word means a cigarette, a small piece of kindling wood or the likes. As an insult the implication is that the person is only worth burning in the fires of hell. I would never wish this on anyone, even my worst enemies. I would rather see them change and become better people.
Certainly bad typing could be improved, but it's not something to send someone to hell for. In fact, in a context like this, a badly typed comment that is thoughtful and insightful is way better than a petty comment like yours.
Trust me, the desire for more Neel-eque content is not an insult. You've given people a product that they like so much they want more. That's an accomplishment. Love your channel. Started a musical journal just to keep track of all the ideas you've given me. Many thanks.
I love the nostalgic feel of the theme music you use in your videos.
Reminds me of the time I first stumbled upon your videos and binge watched them last fall :)
Could you please consider making a video about "playing ahead/behind the beat".
Adam Neely is the music teacher I wish I had when I was getting going on guitar. He’s already changed the way I think about composition and practice. Great stuff.
Hey Adam,
I just wanted to respond to a comment that you responded to in this video (a little meta, I know). It was the person asking if you knew of any channels that were like yours. I honestly wish there were more channels like yours; not because I find any problem with your videos, but because I want Adam Neely style videos every single day. I absolutely love the style of videos that you have and they are always fascinating.
I laughed audibly at the conclusion of this video. Now to watch Adam transcribe one of my favourite Cure songs.
I can confirm that women do, in fact, like when.
I half expected the "Ya!" after the phone rang. Super cheeky ending. Love it.
Great episode! 10/10 loved it
I don’t watch your videos for Bass lessons.
It’s for the entire wealth of knowledge and insight you bring. Friggin legend
Adam, I like it when you teach us musical stuff... ❤️
Great vid, some excellent points.
Great video love the content on this Channel. Great ending too
Thank you very much for what you are doing! I really appreciate the way you teach. You inspire a lot of people. Best greetings from Vienna, Austria. :) Love, Peace and Music.
The ending. Gold. Just gold
Hey Adam, just wanting to let you know i love your videos and i think you are really doing a great thing by making interesting and entertaining music content. I am a violinist myself, and i try to take the things that you discuss in your videos and apply it to my own practice. About 2 weeks ago, a friend of mine (who was very talented cellist) died tragically. He very much admired your work and loved your videos. I say this to let you know that you are impacting peoples lives in a positive way, and there is a whole wave of young musicians that really enjoy your content. Thank you for doing what you do!
Love the ending!
love that your shirt is the cue. Your answers got me subscribing lol
Adam, just thanks again man.
I know this video is super old now but I'm going through all of your uploads chronologically after getting hooked on the new ones. Thank you so much for all the amazing content!! From this video specifically, what you said about how Jazz is usually organized and how to listen to it, I find SO helpful and really eye/ear opening. Gonna be listening with that in mind from now on. Thanks again. [edit] also that ending 😆👌
Love the shirt, brother. Cheers, Daniel
Hey Adam! Just wanted to say that your videos are super cool and helpful, I'm currently a music student and your videos help me out with my compositions and overall understanding of the subject. I even got my music graduate brother into your videos as well! Thanks much.
Tremendo final Adam!!! jajaj un abrazo desde Argentina
the ending is just epic haha !!
For what it's worth, I don't need an Adam Neely for guitar and/or progressive rock/metal. The existing Adam Neely has helped expand my understanding of music in a lot of ways. As I commented in another one of your videos, you're a great teacher because you can make any subject interesting and understandable. I'm always interested in finding great teachers about basically anything but, you know, always be yourselves. Unless you can be Adam Neely.
I was binging through some of your older content and during your Q+A #20 you talked about Native Construct and Thank You Scientist.
I just wanted to say how happy it made me to hear you mention those bands. In a weird way it's validating to me. You're someone I respect, who is musically talented and educated, and whose opinions, in essence, have a little more weight (I probably shouldn't think like that but I do). I know that's not what really matters. What really matters is that I enjoy the music, but I thought it was worth mentioning because it genuinely made me happy.
I wanted to suggest another band to you. They are called Hypno5e. They are a french avant garde metal band. Their album Acid Mist Tomorrow is and probably will remain one of my top three albums I've ever listened to.
Thank you for the wonderful videos and education!
That first question reminded me of that epic scene from Wrong Cops when Officer Rough tells the music producer "You don't like my song? But I spent MONTHS working on it!" and the producer is like "Who gives a shit? 'Billie Jean' by Michael Jackson was made in four hours".
Great tips , thanks!!
Cool video, man! Keep it up.
Sounds like I really oubht to set myself deadlines. Your point about secon-guessing oneself and cannibalizing one's music is so freaking on point.
Lol, that ending though! Nice Adam, nice!
Gotta love the end! hahah
oh my soul i just understood your sweater you legend
Love how Adam gets 8-Bit Music Theory videos in his recommended
Their ideas seem to complement each other very well!
The two RUclips channels for which I turned on notifications.
these videos are the highlight of my monday (and probably my week. ) I'm buying a lick T-shirt.
Perfect ending!
AL_2017's question at 11:50 - Thank you, Adam for that answer. Too many musicians and bands in my area have that attitude. Simplifying songs to the most basic 3 or (gasp!) 4 chords (because sometimes you have to have 'the' minor one, ya know?) is all too common. When I raise objections or start a dialogue about 'raising the bar', the typical responses include: "The audience doesn't know the difference", "the venue doesn't pay enough to make it worth it" and the response that always makes me shudder a bit: "We want to make the song our own instead of copy the original". i.e. "We don't want to practice.".
Great lesson...
"How to listen to Jazz" - next video :D
Thore T. UMG video says why he can’t...
Thore T. Featuring Patrick Star
There's a book by Ted Gioia that goes by that name and is worth a read because it's essentially an elongated version of what Adam says in this video. Someone's even put together a playlist of the tracks he talks about in the book on Spotify, which is useful.
I respect you so much for what you say.
I always learn something new here
Well played Sir, well played. Oh, and Jeff Schneider.
I think it's also possible that the "Like Adam but not Adam" can also speak to a desire for more content with the same high quality as yours. To many you're not just a good YooChoober, you're a great one. And I suspect that many, like me simply want more of this. We want "Neely Level" videos.
I think the whole 'How to listen to Jazz' question could be expanded; even a series on "How to listen to "; perhaps with a list of good examples of the genre.
As a composer this first question describes my entire music degree. Thanks!
yeah, finally someone who talks about note stability in a scale.. yeahhhhhhhh thankssss
gosh darn, I want that lick shirt!
The comment at 7:00 seriously made me laugh out loud, that should be the next t-shirt.
"How to listen to jazz for those who shall take this quest" will be a great video.
Obvious answer to the last question, make sure you keep your wrist straight to prevent stress injury. Stress injuries equal no "fun time" with the ladies. ;)
About that question at 13:06, i know you know it's not meant to be insulting, but i think it's rather flattering even : It's the fact that once people have found a channel such as yours, they want more of this stuff than you could ever put out^^
I hardly believe that guy would stop watching your videos...
It's like every frame a painting or cookies, or sex. One does not just grow weary of it.
I think that scrutinizing every detail of what you are doing for any form of composition is important, but once you develop that skill set, it is often that people work better when they forced to just create without overthinking it.
When I first started learning music theory, all I thought about was theory in almost every situation, and I broke down every piece I learned or wrote into the most detailed analysis I could. Now when I write, I hardly have to think about that and it all comes out naturally. I think that's why deadlines can help get the creative juices flowing, but (usually) only after dedicated studying of the skill has been done.
I want to make a comment on passive listening. Almost all of my favorite bands or artists that I now love I used to have a disdain for listening to. I found that if I listened to such bands passively I would subconsciously get an idea of the atmosphere they were representing. When I realized I liked the overall vibe of such band or artist while listening passively I would listen to them actively to truly appreciate the music they were playing. I have learned that if I don't initially like a band or artist by listening to them actively at first, they grow on my my listen passively. As a result I have grown to love many genres and artists I used to not like as well as eventually spending time to analyze the music.
That ending was a classic! Lol
Thanks Adam. I certainly recognize myself in the first comment. Very cool insight that I will endeavor to remember and repeat to myself. Just because it was complex for me to make/understand doesn't make it complex or interesting to the listener!
I recognise myself too. The tunes I write that people usually connect with are often songs that I get bored with because they don't have complexities that I get a kick out of resolving.
My god its thursday evening and I didnt see Adams vid yet. I need to get more scheduled.
Thanks for the Bob Reynolds tip! Subscribed to him immediately.
Please make more videos on how to listen to jazz! I listen to it, but I feel like I'm not picking up as much as I could.
Hey Adam,
Great work on this channel. In this video you discuss the how helpful context is when listening to jazz. Personally, my initial attraction to jazz came during a Jazz History class that I took in college. What I found most striking about the class was the mythology of all of these players that was an essential part of the process of my education on the subject. For example, it was in this class that I learned about how Louis Armstrong grew up in and around the brothels of the french quarter. I am not really part of a musical community in my every day life, but I wonder if these kinds of anecdotes figure prominently in your social interactions with your musical community? If so, what is your favorite jazz anecdote?
One of my favorite times of the day is Question and Answer Time with Adam Neely (ya!) and singing the song and picking out new harmony interval to sing along with it. Is it just me or is the (ya!) part not exactly quantized and is like some magical micro-rhythmic subdivision?
Hey- thanks man.
Dear Adam’
Most of the time i find more than interesting the videos you broadcast, but this phone ring deserves a golden medal ! Thanks’ you made my day. By th way, what is the best intermodal exchange for making the best anti answer phone ring ?
Adam,
Keep doing what you do! I'm a trumpet player and teacher. Your insight and knowledge in all aspects of being a professional musician are a vehicle of growth for many. Thank you!
I am curious about how to listen more deeply to music. Your brief descriptions are great cliff hangers leaving me thirsting for more! Can you dive deeper into the process? I am an aspiring jazz musician but I feel I am missing something. I've been told listening deeply to the greats and iminating is the key. It would be great if you could teach us a little more in depth about this process. Like really how to listen...
Music for life!
"G-d forbid, a bass solo!!!" - Adam Neely 2017
Why do people write God like this? You mean "God", right? I only saw this "spelling" from USAnians, so I guess it's an american thing.
I honestly don't know since I'm german, and we just write Gott fully all the time. Really wanna know, 'cause I've seen it written like this in a lotta lyrics I've read.
robpiy91 mostly a Jewish practice I'd say
I think it's to do with the whole "thou shalt not misuse the name of the lord"
Basically, in ye olde times saying "oh my god" or "jesus christ" as an exclamation was seen as swearing, just like damn or shit etc. So I suppose it's essentially the same thing as typing "f**k universal music", to make it tacful :)
The funny thing is that if there is a vengeful god, it's not like you're fooling him by spelling it different.
Maybe god is an algorithm that you can trick by pitchshifting, timestretching and yes, alternative spelling. ;)
I really dig the the theme tone shirt...n.a. da da da da da dah!
I searched YT for the company so I could click on your video, and it was near the top of the first page.
A standalone video on "active" music listening would be terrific.
I'd suggest another way to listen to Jazz (music in general) which is a nice halfway house between analysis and passive listening: what is often described as 'Feeling the music'. This is never really explained in any depth, but in my experience I try to get in a meditative space (meditation helps) and really let the music come to me, as opposed to trying to grasp it.As a musician who in the past would exclusively 'spy' on the other musicians and focus intently on aspects of the music, this approach is really liberating and allows you to consume the sound as a whole and have quite a profound experience.
Lollll The ending is so funny!!
I get why you might take the question about "[Insert instrument here] version of Adam Neely" as an insult - but I would say take it as a compliment. You're right about the instrumental connection but the number of people who are willing & able to put together a good quality music channel covering the same kinds of topics isn't that high - you're rarer than you think!
Regarding the "Adam Neely for (another instrument)" question: I don't watch this channel because it relates to my instrument, because it doesn't. I found it because of an interesting video and found it useful and kept watching.
I find that because a lot of the stuff isn't aimed specifically at my instrument that I pick up bits that wouldn't perhaps be in a more obviously tailored-for-me channel and so I am applying things to my music that I just wouldn't have come across.
To be honest, a lot of the stuff goes over my head, but I find that I learn a lot from that that I can then apply to my learning when I go back to stuff that's on my level.
Hey Adam,
I loved your short explanation of how to listen to jazz. Do you think you could do a longer and more detailed video, or a live stream, on the same topic, with examples? I've been trying to get into jazz and learn about jazz history, but listening to the later bebop artists has been difficult because I have trouble following the music.
Thanks!
Hey Adam, I'd be very interested to hear more about how one should listen to jazz. Care to make a full video about that topic?
Thanks!
The question about time involved composing. I worked at one of the best Arranging and Composing schools for many years out in Los Angeles. Part of the arranging and composting program many of the top film and TV composers gave seminar. One common trait they would talk about is how they would wait to the "eleventh hour" to start writing for a project. When asked why the answer was "to force ourselves to keep it simple". So even the biggest names in film scoring do things to help them keep it simple.
Hey Adam, I've been playing music in some regard for a total of about five years, with the last two years being primarily focused on bass. The more I play music the more I want to find some way to make it my career. The idea of teaching private lessons sounds really attractive to me, I have a lot of patience with children/beginners and I absolutely love those moments when you explain something to someone in a way that they can understand and they have one of those "aha!" moments and something makes sense to them, or when someone discovers that they are finally able to do something they thought they weren't capable of. Basically I just love to see people grow. My question is this: at what point would you say someone is qualified to teach private lessons? and what things should I focus on in my own musical education if I wanted to do that?
Dear Adam, I just wanted to comment (2 years later) that I really appreciate your simple answer regarding how to listen to jazz. So thanks (better late than never, right? :)
Hahaha, love the ending
For what it's worth, I don't think anyone is trying to insult you by looking for someone 'like you but not you'! I love watching channels similar to yours, because I absolutely love all of the content that you put out, and I think people wanna be able to consume content like yours at a rate faster than it could possibly be made.
I'm training to become a secondary (age 11-18) music teacher in the UK and want to produce content somewhat inspired by creators such as you, twelvetone, etc. but geared towards stuff outside of what's contemporary - looking at some world music, like indian rags and gamelan, as well as western art music from medieval/renaissance through to romantic/20th century.... The idea being to help out students that are currently studying those styles in school. The problem being that I don't really know a lot about that stuff yet, as my degree was rock/pop based, so my knowledge of those styles is limited (hence noticing that gap in the youtube space right now - I was looking for a 'classical' Adam Neely, I guess). As I start digging deeper, maybe I'll start trying to put something together.
You should probably take it as a compliment that people want ‘Adam Neely for guitar’ or whatever. They love your stuff so much they want even more content than you’ve actually made!
Hey Adam,
You answered a relevant question in a previous Q&A, and it got me thinking about how music education affects the way we think about music from that point forward. If you were to completely scrap the constructs inherent in western music theory and start from scratch, do you think people would end up at a similar end product? How much of our view of music and its nature is tied to history and how much to fundamental physical and psychological phenomena?
I've been experimenting with designing a system that attempts to use intervalic relationships and avoids a tempered scale. For the life of me, though, I can't think of how music would sound or be transcribed in a system like this. Since I'm so conditioned to think of a note as an exact frequency derived from a single standard frequency, I have almost no concept of what to use and not use from the theory I was taught.
I want a whole video on how to listen to jazz :)
While I was watching your response to Noah S who was looking for someone like you, but not you I felt that you went from being Adam Neely to Adam Needy when you mentioned the "almost insult" bit. You started the response by mentioning someone else which was really cool, then it sounded like you were going down the path of "he's cool, but you don't have to leave MY channel," until you finished off suggesting that other people who have the ability to teach and inspire and who play a world of other instruments to start a vlog as well. That is really awesome.
I always feel that those within a community, be it vloggers, musicians, musical vloggers, whatever, who don't try to see what they do as a competition and who spread the wealth of both knowledge on a subject and their means of monetisation are the ones that I will come back to. I'm a former bass player who is now a multi-instrumentalist who gets more from your channel about the general aspects of musicianship than I do from your bass tutorials, but I just admire what you do.
I'm a Patreon patron of yours because I get so much from this channel and I feel that it's not just a bass player's view on music, but a musician's view on music... plus some bass playing stuff. Keep up the good work.
Yooooo, Adam! I've lost 6 months of my life binging your content and don't regret a second of it. Thanks for putting in the work.
One thing that really stuck out to me, because I am a musician first and a rapper second, was the comment you made regarding your interest in lo-fi hip hop. If I may paraphrase- you dig the aesthetic, but feel the music itself lacks tension. What are the chances of us getting to hear a 'Sungazer / Flying Lotus x The Music from any Guy Richie film before Sherlock Holmes' style track? I think that would be a super dope undertaking in your hands.
Keep going.
-J
You should make a whole video on active listening!
can you do a whole video about how to actively listen to jazz (and maybe other kinds of music!)?
I just sight sang the music phrase on his T Shirt and realized it's the bumper music to the Q and A. Cute
Hi Adam, love the videos. Hope you enjoy my question just as much...
When writing music is there any tips or tricks for getting back to a section? I have just come up with a nice apregio sequence, then a couple more sections follow, but none finish in a nice way to get back to the start if the arpeggios. For now it's just the intro.
I like your t-shirt :)
Hey Adam, love your vids. You really have inspired to learn more about music. I'm a percussionist at my school and jazz band is coming up. I'm going to tryout for the drum set part. Question: do you ever listen to music to get hyped for a gig? Or do you just warm up?