That was amazing. Understated music, focus on the video and the dialogue overlaid, just gorgeous. It wasn't shipping for or against Johnlock either, just featuring their singularly unique friendship. Very few videos enrapture me like this one has and I just have to comment on how beautiful it was!
Oh wow, I remember watching this video a lot back in 2012/2013, when I was still really into Sherlock. (*cough* back when the show was actually good before season 3 *cough*) This brings back a lot of memories. It's bittersweet to watch because it reminds me of how much I loved these characters and how poor the writing got. I'll always love this video though, thank you.
That was....the most amazing thing I've ever seen. Seriously? Goosebumps. Not even joking. In the words of our favorite Army doctor: "That was amazing. It was extraordinary. It was quite... extraordinary."
This is the most beautiful amv I've ever seen. Its very well put together and I think it is very accurate to show thar Sherlock does love John. I ship them but I love how you presented their friendship and how its different than any other "friendships" Sherlock has made. I'm rambling, but the bottom line is that this is beautiful and I will never stop watching it.
Oh god, this is so beautiful... The music, the clips you chose, the editing - especially the moment where they are running - it's just perfect. You captured Sherlock's personality so well, this broken and lonely side of him that he doesn't understand and barely anyone even knows of. This video makes me so thoughtful and sad because I feel like getting a tiny glimpse on the side of Sherlock that he tries to hide. Thank you for the beautiful work!
okay i can't stop watching this honestly. it's the best sherlock video i've seen in forever. the music fits perfectly. it's very moving, and beautiful. the editing is top notch, and the choice of quotes and scenes is amazing as well. i especially love how you inserted all of those meaningful scenes before sherlock added "i've just got one." this actually made me tear up, thank you for making such a beautiful video!! ♥
Almost embarrassed to admit how many times I have played this- it's beautifully constructed- wonderful choice of music and selections of scenes. Wonderful. Thanks for sharing it!
Your scene choices at 1:55 and 2:07 are absolutely perfect. & finishing with Mycroft's "neither do I" is just the best. Open, when you could have shut it down with less unsure line, but it's perfect open. Sherlock is ever an enigma, after all!
I watch other Sherlock videos and there are some really good ones out there, but I always come back to this one. I love it, it's gorgeous and perfect and the music is beautiful. And I just keep watching it over and over again.
I cant even explain how I feel. You did an amazing job, the music, the scenes. It discribes their relationship so nicely. And, oh my god, the looks just explain how they complement each other.
So I always come back to this video. It's so well edited. The music is perfect. The bits of dialogue are heartbreaking and this entire video could be screen capped in sections for amazing graphics on tumblr. Needless to say I felt it important to tell you how in love I am with this video.
I keep coming back to this video again and again... It's just that I love the entire "Crimson Wing" soundtrack and you choose some of the most amazing scenes ever to go with it.... Oh God... WHY WOULD YOU DO THIS?!?!?!
*FANGIRLING* I felt the most enjoyable shiver go up my spine when Sherlock said "I've just got one". LOVE LOVE LOVE this...AND the Johnlock paring. LOVE!
Amazing, I don't have enough words for this video, not just the editing and staging are gorgeous, but the choice of the music, every clip and scene, plus the quality of the whole piece, it all gave me chills. Thank you for these two and half minutes of beauty, really.
So many epic things here! It's unbelievable. A few things that really stood out to me: At 00:20 sec Sherlock says, "All that matters to is the work" yet I loved how you showed a scene of Sherlock glancing down at watson. And Johns' stares right in some of those shots just really got to me. Love what Sherlock's brother says and I like that you wrap up with that.
I thought I've already left a comment, but I was wrong. I watch your video everyday... The song, the scenes, the editing, the voiceovers, the timing, oh my God, they're SO amazing. Everytime I think that this is such a great piece of art. So emotional, so intense... Thank you. Really.
Completely choked up. There's an artistry to this vid that just... it runs so much deeper than just "oh the feels" and well-chosen music. You've put together a convincing, eloquent narrative of Sherlock and John's incredible friendship *without* twisting canon material, and brought it all together with an incredible editing and beautiful music. This is brilliant. Thank you for sharing.
This is truly beautiful. I am suffering of post-reichenbach syndrome right now and this video is easily the best one i've seen so far of Sherlock: i'm crying.
OK, I have watched this numerous times since discovering it and I adore it more and more. I love your style. You take familiar elements and build them into so much more. It's brilliant.
Truly one of the most beautiful videos I've seen. It perfectly describes them, and this is one of the absolute most beautiful pieces of music I have ever heard. It makes me cry, some days. Thank you for making this. I love it so very much.
This is me...weeping for DAYS. That was excruciatingly emotional. You did an absolutely fantastic job with the editing. Your flow and use of audio absolutely broke me into itty bitty pieces.
Beautiful my feels are literally on the floor and will never be able to get back. Perfect in ever aspect. It reduced me to tears. Thank you and I'm amazed at your talent.
This is INCREDIBLE! You really took your time with the editing and it shows. This stands head and shoulders above the majority of the stuff out there. Please don't stop!
(Sniffles a bit, regains composure, and then goes to watch again.) Brilliant video! Your videos are helping tame the wish that series 3 arrives much sooner than they say it will have to! Love the emotion and the editing.
This is absolutely stunning. Absolutely gorgeous. This is, without a doubt, the best Sherlock video I have ever seen. GORGEOUS editing. You have some serious talent, my dear.
This is outstandingly beautiful. I don't often comment on youtube videos but this is incredible. It's a true tribute to the wonder of the show and their friendship :)
This video is art. You have done a wonderful job. I can't describe how amazing, beautiful and touching it is. Thank you so much. It's one of the best Sherlock/John videos I have ever watched.
I'm going through all my favourites and every video I see and think 'that is one of my favourite favourites' always ends with 'edited by Amy Kinely'!! Beautiful work, beautiful!!
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
I miss these old times :-(
Me too
After all these years, this video is still so beautiful and moving. Now it’s unbearably nostalgic. I miss them and their fans. 😭
Can we just create a oscar for Sherlock Fanvideo and give it to Amy?
So glad this is still up! I remember watching this when it was first posted and i cried the first time i watched it.
same!!! i adore this!!
this video still hurts, even after all these years :(
That was amazing. Understated music, focus on the video and the dialogue overlaid, just gorgeous. It wasn't shipping for or against Johnlock either, just featuring their singularly unique friendship. Very few videos enrapture me like this one has and I just have to comment on how beautiful it was!
Oh wow, I remember watching this video a lot back in 2012/2013, when I was still really into Sherlock. (*cough* back when the show was actually good before season 3 *cough*) This brings back a lot of memories. It's bittersweet to watch because it reminds me of how much I loved these characters and how poor the writing got. I'll always love this video though, thank you.
It has been years since I saw this vid for the first time....
I always find myself back here. Being just as impressed and moved.
I don't even know what to say, everything I felt while watching this was already written in the comments...*Takes a deep breath* It's...beautiful.
This is beyond beautiful
this is a masterpiece.
This Orchestral price is absolutely beautiful, good choice of music, very good choice 😌👏
This is probably the greatest Sherlock and John video I have ever found on RUclips. It's absolutely amazing.
Thanks, I've been looking for this video for so long. The moment Sherlock says, “I just have one,” tearing my heart apart.
I was captivated from the moment you gave me Mycroft's voice-over, with the Danger and Keep Out signs imposed over Sherlock. Beautiful.
the video is beautiful
the music makes it sad but also incredibly romantic .... I love it!
THIS IS GORGEOUS
Thank you so, so much for this lovely comment. I'm genuinely happy to know that people enjoy my editing, so thanks for taking the time to write!
You are really good at what you do!! I was just about to cry! Thank you for making the. :D
That was....the most amazing thing I've ever seen. Seriously? Goosebumps. Not even joking. In the words of our favorite Army doctor: "That was amazing. It was extraordinary. It was quite... extraordinary."
no it's ok. i didn't need my heart anyways
This is the most beautiful amv I've ever seen. Its very well put together and I think it is very accurate to show thar Sherlock does love John. I ship them but I love how you presented their friendship and how its different than any other "friendships" Sherlock has made. I'm rambling, but the bottom line is that this is beautiful and I will never stop watching it.
you picked out the saddest and best parts of Sherlock, the music is beautiful. They have the best friendship :)
That was stunningly beautiful... God i haven't had Sherlock feels this strong in a long time... it's like falling in love again
Still one of my favourite ones EVER.
I come here and re-watch it, every now and then... mostly every now! I love it
Every moment you used, every phrase, every scene, look, intonation...
It's just... perfection.
I come back to watch this again now and then, and still think it's perfection...
Oh god, this is so beautiful... The music, the clips you chose, the editing - especially the moment where they are running - it's just perfect. You captured Sherlock's personality so well, this broken and lonely side of him that he doesn't understand and barely anyone even knows of. This video makes me so thoughtful and sad because I feel like getting a tiny glimpse on the side of Sherlock that he tries to hide. Thank you for the beautiful work!
I seem to crying the water that sails this ship. This is absolutley beautiful!
i love how graceful this is. absolutely clean and gorgeous.
Absolutely perfect! It completely sums up the relationship between John and Sherlock.
okay i can't stop watching this honestly. it's the best sherlock video i've seen in forever. the music fits perfectly. it's very moving, and beautiful. the editing is top notch, and the choice of quotes and scenes is amazing as well.
i especially love how you inserted all of those meaningful scenes before sherlock added "i've just got one."
this actually made me tear up, thank you for making such a beautiful video!! ♥
Almost embarrassed to admit how many times I have played this- it's beautifully constructed- wonderful choice of music and selections of scenes. Wonderful. Thanks for sharing it!
Your scene choices at 1:55 and 2:07 are absolutely perfect. & finishing with Mycroft's "neither do I" is just the best. Open, when you could have shut it down with less unsure line, but it's perfect open. Sherlock is ever an enigma, after all!
i own this whole ost and have listened to it hundreds and hundreds of times, but this video will always, always be what i associate with it
This is brutally beautiful. I'm stunned. Gorgeous.
This is the coolest thing ever. Can't even describe how awesome it is. I'm crying, but I'm smiling. This was so good I can't believe it.
That was just.. Stunning. Absolutely. Stunning, beautiful,gorgeous! Almost cried half way through - loved it!
This video is absolutely breathtaking. I actually cried the first time I watched it. The music and the corresponding video fit perfectly together.
I watch other Sherlock videos and there are some really good ones out there, but I always come back to this one. I love it, it's gorgeous and perfect and the music is beautiful. And I just keep watching it over and over again.
I cant even explain how I feel. You did an amazing job, the music, the scenes. It discribes their relationship so nicely. And, oh my god, the looks just explain how they complement each other.
So I always come back to this video. It's so well edited. The music is perfect. The bits of dialogue are heartbreaking and this entire video could be screen capped in sections for amazing graphics on tumblr. Needless to say I felt it important to tell you how in love I am with this video.
My favourite Sherlock and John video ever. I am now crying.
I just cried at a fan video, I've never done that before. This is beautiful beyond words.
Keep coming back to this one...no way around it, it's the best x
This deserved so many more views. Seriously. Crying my heart out over here.
Never have I watched such a profoundly incredible video. I've watched it so many times and still can't get over how much I love it
I can't begin to express how truly wonderful this is. Fave'd.
The voiceover work, the editing, the music, all flowed so amazingly well, this is beautiful in every sense of the word.
I keep coming back to this video again and again... It's just that I love the entire "Crimson Wing" soundtrack and you choose some of the most amazing scenes ever to go with it.... Oh God... WHY WOULD YOU DO THIS?!?!?!
I will show this video to all my friends who have yet to watch or understand this show and say, "Yup, this is basically it. Respect."
I just watched that twice and my whole body is literally tingling. Oh my god. You're amazing.
This is truly, magnificently, absolutely gorgeous.
i've watched this like a thousand times oh my god beautiful flawless omg
*FANGIRLING* I felt the most enjoyable shiver go up my spine when Sherlock said "I've just got one". LOVE LOVE LOVE this...AND the Johnlock paring. LOVE!
Music: Perfect. Editing: Perfect. Effect: I am crying because I just fell in love with this video :')
THIS VIDEO. I have indescribable words about how amazing it is! I have watched it over and over and over again!
Flawless, ok, flawless. No words for this just tear and joy
This is quite possibly the most beautiful video ever made! The music, the clips, the voices- perfect! An automatic favourite!
My heart broke into a million pieces, and then reformed into the most misshapen, beautiful thing out there.
Thank you so, so much. It's really surreal for me to imagine that you watch this on your daily commute and it's very magical for me, so thank you!
Very lovely, I especially like the editing around Mycroft's line "You have to stay with him" and John turning and following Sherlock. Well done.
I've come back on here to watch this video after a while (years...) and, my God, it's like the first time.
This. Is. Amazing.
Everything about this is just perfection and beautiful
This is INCREDIBLE!!!!!! Eveything seems ot be in harmony, from the music to the wonderful film. Thank you so much for posting this.
Amazing, I don't have enough words for this video, not just the editing and staging are gorgeous, but the choice of the music, every clip and scene, plus the quality of the whole piece, it all gave me chills.
Thank you for these two and half minutes of beauty, really.
So many epic things here! It's unbelievable. A few things that really stood out to me: At 00:20 sec Sherlock says, "All that matters to is the work" yet I loved how you showed a scene of Sherlock glancing down at watson. And Johns' stares right in some of those shots just really got to me. Love what Sherlock's brother says and I like that you wrap up with that.
Stunning, Beautiful, Moving and brought me to tears. Beautiful song choice also x
I'm literally crying it's so beautiful. All of your videos just make me cry and cry and cry. You have a real talent.
I thought I've already left a comment, but I was wrong. I watch your video everyday... The song, the scenes, the editing, the voiceovers, the timing, oh my God, they're SO amazing. Everytime I think that this is such a great piece of art. So emotional, so intense... Thank you. Really.
This is literally the best sherlock fanvid I've ever seen. thank you for making this.
Everything is just so beautiful.
Completely choked up. There's an artistry to this vid that just... it runs so much deeper than just "oh the feels" and well-chosen music. You've put together a convincing, eloquent narrative of Sherlock and John's incredible friendship *without* twisting canon material, and brought it all together with an incredible editing and beautiful music. This is brilliant. Thank you for sharing.
This is truly beautiful. I am suffering of post-reichenbach syndrome right now and this video is easily the best one i've seen so far of Sherlock: i'm crying.
so beautiful♥
Best Sherlock BBC video I have ever watched!!!!
OK, I have watched this numerous times since discovering it and I adore it more and more. I love your style. You take familiar elements and build them into so much more. It's brilliant.
This is utterly gorgeous. Great choice of music.
Truly one of the most beautiful videos I've seen. It perfectly describes them, and this is one of the absolute most beautiful pieces of music I have ever heard. It makes me cry, some days. Thank you for making this. I love it so very much.
Oh my Johnlock feelings! I can't... This is too beautiful!
Without a doubt my FAVORITE part of this entire video is the editing at 1:00
You had me choking back tears. I can't even begin to say how amazing this is.
This is me...weeping for DAYS. That was excruciatingly emotional. You did an absolutely fantastic job with the editing. Your flow and use of audio absolutely broke me into itty bitty pieces.
Автору - мои искренние аплодисменты!
Прекрасное твориение!
You beautiful person, you. The editing, the song choice, the choice of lines and scenes... utterly gorgeous. I would love to see more.
Beautiful my feels are literally on the floor and will never be able to get back. Perfect in ever aspect. It reduced me to tears. Thank you and I'm amazed at your talent.
This is fantastic. Perfect song and such great quality.
This is INCREDIBLE! You really took your time with the editing and it shows. This stands head and shoulders above the majority of the stuff out there.
Please don't stop!
I'm crying. My heart is beating faster.
This fanvideo is just, Amazing.
Thank you so much for making this, I love you!
(Sniffles a bit, regains composure, and then goes to watch again.) Brilliant video! Your videos are helping tame the wish that series 3 arrives much sooner than they say it will have to! Love the emotion and the editing.
Sobbing. Hysterically. Thank you for making this video exist.
This is absolutely stunning. Absolutely gorgeous. This is, without a doubt, the best Sherlock video I have ever seen. GORGEOUS editing. You have some serious talent, my dear.
This is just perfection on so many levels. You caught the relationship between them beautifully. I could watch this over and over again! Thank you :)
That was fan-bloody-tastic and I don't usually like videos with talking in them, but I loved this one
This is outstandingly beautiful. I don't often comment on youtube videos but this is incredible. It's a true tribute to the wonder of the show and their friendship :)
Remembered this video after seven years. It's just as beautiful and heartbreaking as I recalled.
i second this. this video is perfect, and i love the effect with the "i've just got one."
This video is art. You have done a wonderful job. I can't describe how amazing, beautiful and touching it is.
Thank you so much.
It's one of the best Sherlock/John videos I have ever watched.
I'm going through all my favourites and every video I see and think 'that is one of my favourite favourites' always ends with 'edited by Amy Kinely'!! Beautiful work, beautiful!!
This is my favourite Sherlock video ever. You did a marvellous job. *drowns in the feels*