John Mearsheimer and Jeffrey Sachs - Is India's Rise Good for the United States?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 сен 2024
- John Mearsheimer and Jeffrey Sachs debate whether India's rise is a good thing for the United States.
To support daily videos and receive special perks, please consider becoming a Liberty Vault member:
/ @liberty-vault
Original video:
• John Mearsheimer and J...
Is India's rise good for the United States? Why or why not?
For more liberty clips, subscribe to my channel and click the bell!
John is mistaken about Chinese ambition in Indian Ocean...China needs to keep Indian Ocean safe for trade purposes and to be able to prevent US from cutting off this route in time of war!!! John chooses not to understand this reality!!!
*Yes, India's rise is good for the US because the Military Industrial Complex and the Deep State will have another enemy to feed on! Right now, India is nothing more than a useful idiot for the US!*
Forget about it 😂India just will not rise , never😂 dreaming is dreaming
A difference between the two: mearscheimer talks from Western angle, while Suchs tells from an international angle.
It sure seems like Pro. Jeffrey Sachs is the only one on stage that understands what’s really going on here.
The problem is quite obvious and that’s the US.
Great….let’s tell the UN and the IMF to screw…..
The host is so dedicated to his anti China mindset he can barely contain his prejudices during the entire interview
When he mentioned Xi is self destructing, both guests were like huh ?
Right now, India still makes America feel better about herself, till she doesn’t.
@@Blixey-r9z the US will unseat Modi or any PM if they continue to pursue non alliance tradition, and I have a bad feeling that the US has high chance of prevailing because it has endless resources because of its reserve currency. Good luck to you.
@@xinfuxia3809 busy shoehorning issue 😡
@@Lululemon2023 the US likes India because Indians are smart and industrious but easy to divide and subjugate as a nation (thanks to their religious, cultural & linguistic diversity and caste system). The income inequality in India is even worse than the US. Their inability to organise and work as a collective makes India much less of a threat . That is how the British ruled India with only 100,000 British for many years.
Since when did another country's rise good for the imperial US?
👍👍👍 prof Sachs‼️👏👏👏
Everybody rise should be good for everybody. Good for trading . good for business.
US formed an alliance with China to fight USSR before. US forms an alliance with India to fight China now. What's next?
US will form an alliance with Russia to fight India if it grows to a point that threatens US hegemony. That's John's theory or tragedy as he calls.
china America alliance to fight India😂😂
Different China. The China you were talking about is now Taiwan.
the alliance you referred to never existed. it was just normalized diplomatic relation. normalized relations with Syria brought them a civil war, with China the Tiananmen Square, a failed colored revolution for both.
@@willengel2458 that was an alliance....it was not a formal alliance like a defense treaty. it allowed China to become America's sweat shop, to make Chinese workers suffer lung disease, pollute the land, control how many kids they have and create a top heavy population of aging seniors while still unable to boost agriculture.
Never ever, it's suicidal for US, and modern civilization as well.
In late last century, white British Raj only needed 100K soldiers to colonize a 300mils India. Moreover, 1.2mils even fought WW2 in Europe and elsewhere to maintain British empire. What's India's attitude or behavior today will not surprise anyone regardless whether India will remain, siding or fighting for any parties or even flip-flopping between the rivalry camps.
Get a passport a go travel the world, should be the motto in all western schools.
One up for Jrffrey Sachs and one down for John Measheimer.
I Just love professor sachs!
Jeffrey Sachs only may sence not bias of his opinion
John ignores the very fact that China is the world most trading nation surpassing even the US. So sea routes freedom of navigation and security are China's weakness but of utmost important. Unlike US or its allies, staging wars and maintaining their hegemony and dominance are their long traditional means and objectives.
More countries in the world are seeing the true nature of western values and malicious nature unlike what the West wants others to believe. Even together with their non western allies or vassal states, collectively they only represent 12% of the world populations or nations. Certainly calling themselves as "The World" is already a great mistake but propaganda jargon to mislead and manipulation of the true global opinions. Just like what Prof Kishore Mahbubani's observations and interactions with other world leaders today.
The West just want to colonizes and rules the world but not by occupation of territories and with direct control. Everyone should see them vividly and openly today.
India can get along with China...
But Pakistan...there is too much bad blood..of the partition...and continued support of anti India forces
i m flabbergasted by how narrow the host's mind is... he lives in a shell?
India and China have been living together in peace for thousands of years until the Anglo Americans came along and tried to impose their divide and conquer wet dream on the two ancient countries. Disappointment is waiting for them.
We Indians don't trust America anyway. So all his sweet talk goes in vain.
In Iraq there is an old saying from the time when the Brits "divided and rule" there. ... "If you see two fish fighting at the bottom of the Tigris River, you can know that the British have just crossed a short time ago". Today the Yanks have continued what their Brit predecessors did. They are stirring up trouble all over the world.
Divide and Rule tactics
i believe india and china only fought one skirmish during 5000 years of boarding each other! so john’s great power competition is BS. that one skirmish was a brief one, and according to both side, no atrocity was committed. it was a clean war. My roommate back in college was from india, his grandfather was in that war and saved by chinese medics and doctors after he was injured. His grandfather later became a negotiator during the 90s. my roommate said his grandfather always remembered how well he was treated and tried to bring peace between these two countries. As bad as things got notice neither side is using even rifles against each other
No it was Communism
Which divided the two great ancient civilisations.
Wait first ….when India rise into a superpower before discussing about it.
Inda used to be pretty much like Africa and the Americas before the European domination!
I am saving this video. We should take it up with the naive/deluded/copium ingesting host (guy on farthest left) 10 years from now.
9:50 Mearsheimer shall be much better off when he sticks to his J£wi$h believes!
Months before WW2 ended, US already had in their mind that their NEXT big enemy was USSR.
So now what's in the mind of US. Who will be their NEXT big enemy if they really succeed to defeat China in the years to come. Is it India. Will US allow India to grow its economy to a point like China today.
To a point it has helped China grow. And this tells a lot about the American foresightful foreign policy. These guys always do short term patch work
Hardly spoke about India
What rise? It going down.
Before british invading that region,there was no India!India was created by british,and many parts of India didn't belong to this country before british invading them!
Britain never created India. India is a million-year old country and research proves it. India is a civilizational state. Your worldview is flawed.
Utter ignorance! Britishers divided India , created Pakistan Indus Valley is whole India, Britishers looted not only India but almost the 2/3 world!
Read history the one not written by British
What is east INDIA company then
Romans were trading with India long before invasions
Europeans came in search of the wealth of India but ended in north America
Get rid of racist mentality
And please do read chronicles of Chinese and Arab travellers to India way before the invasions for greater insights
Where was british 20,000 years ago? India was there.
@@Jai-Bharat111 No,there was no India 20000 years ago.Go to study human history and read some centuries world map again.
p.s. Even the biggest size of so-called India in history was still smaller than what british created!Also the time was very short...there were always many sovereignties!
This compitation of 2 superpowers.. sacrificial lamb are always a victim..a poor country is likely to be targeted..a staging move and a decided battleground with this 2 superpower.. picking Taiwan and Philippines to be a piece to win a game in thier compitation
👍👌👍🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇳🇨🇳🇿🇦➕️👏👏👏
India has not taken. Steps to address its poor and racial problems . They are years behind .
Decades
American jokers are proud of their own ignorance
has America taken steps to address racial problems? America was a superpower in the 50's/60's while segregation and lynchings happened. Poverty cannot be eliminated. Racial problems exist in America with riots and protests.
@@martinvanburen4578 India has done far more to address caste discrimination than America has done for race. it's a joke when Americans are this deluded about reality
Not when they're taking US jobs
😝 Not true... corporate America moved manufacturing oversea‼️🥳🤡🌏🐒🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌.
Endia show off country in any aspect..but...........
*Look at China's (and ethnic Chinese's) dominance in the various science Olympiads (Maths, Physics, Biology, Chemistry). Where is India? This is not racism, just plain facts!*
Look at India's dominance in Chess. Where is China? Hell China didn't even have a grandmaster or chess champion till few years ago. The only chess champion from Asia was Indian. India was also the first Asian and Non White country to receive Nobel Prizes long before China ever did. In fact there's a photo from a Chinese university in 1920s with Chinese students posing with Indian Nobel Prize winner.
@@locusstandi8329 *You display a complete ignorance of China's history! You also did not seem to understand the meaning of INTERNATIONAL Olympiads"*
The problems with India is she considers herself as a world superpower but not too many nations think so.
India has no respect from almost all her neighbours as she constantly tries to boss around.
India with her dilapidated infra, high illiteracy rate, etc and couldn’t even get a gold medal in d recent Olympics games, has a long way to re universally recognise as a superpower.
India has a literacy rate of 77%. That's not a low number. And India is a middle power seeking middle ground in everything. India aspires to be a superpower but currently it's a middle power. And India definitely has secured 29 medals including 7 gold medals in the Paralympics.
Absolute nonsense by a foreigner who has never been to India. India is surrounded by barbaric islamic neighbourhood and they keep doing terror activities all the time in india just as israel is surrounded by terrorists islamic states who will keep doing terror activities.
Meirshimer as usual giving hard facts none of us want to hear but we know to be true
Trying to cripple ("contain" is a clumsy euphemism) China by means of sanctions is ultimately self-defeating. The US has deeper economic and technology resources than China. Those are at risk of being weakened because of policy-makers being distracted by pursuing "containment" actions that backfire in most cases.
He is right we are not allies with america. We are sovereign nation