Chuck Schumer calls on Benjamin Netanyahu to step down over war on Gaza in Senate speech
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 мар 2024
- Chuck Schumer, the US Senate Majority leader and "the highest ranking Jewish elected official" in America, spoke on Thursday to declare that Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu has "lost his way" and has "bowed to the demands of extremists" during attacks on Gaza, and should step aside if Israel is to commit to a two-state solution.
Subscribe to our new podcast now, or you're a silly goose:
linktr.ee/pubcast
A parent preaching about how their child misbehaves.... EMPTY WORDS.
Actually this is quite significant
@@dh1380Agree
@@dh1380 literally how
Have you seen this creature's record on Palestine? He is beyond odious, ditto with his niece
Really. What should he have said instead to satisfy you? EMPTY comment.
Absolutely! Condescending!
Not Muslim but Happy Ramadan and much love to my Muslim sisters and brothers!!!
Shukran Brother. May Allah guide you to the right path❤
Happy Ramadan to you too!
God bless you and your family and friends in this blessed month of peace, love and tranquility.
Thank you so very much🙏🏽🌹
If he really want Netanyahu gone he would have sent Victoria Nuland, instead of another billion of funding and weapons.
Israel = expanding territory 😂
Irony. The country supplying Israel with all the weapons waits 2 months for this speech?
And vetoing every UN resolution to hold Israel to account.
Bruh, they're STILL supplying the weapons. This is all talk.
They should send them more. Arabs colonised the lands surrounding Israel but the hypocrites never mention that.
@@blairrobert3438 if we want to go that far back, it's been shown that Lebanese people are descended from the Canaanites who had the land before a distinct Israelite people even existed.
so what? I'm not the one moaning about Israel. The Arabs are the biggest colonisers in history. The do gooders never call that out due to their double standards. Most of you are programmed by Putins little cyber team to hate your homes. Sheeeeeeeep.@@Eltener123
If you ever looked at how does the Israel government confine the freedom of movement of the Palestine people living in the West Bank you know that there will never be equal prosperity and dignity for both sides. Israel is an apartheid state and this fact won't be changed easily.
few workable solutions to make things better would be most welcome than just complaining how bad it all is.
There will never be equal prosperity and dignity as long as the billions hamass takes in from other countries is not invested into the Palestinian civilians and infrastructure which allows hamass to continue to run things as an apartheid state.
@@gunterra1 Apartheid states have no right to exist
@@gunterra1 etiher 1 state with citizenship for all or 2 states with equal sovereignty. Currently we have 1 state where over 1/3 of the population is denied citizenship and many rights in exchange for very limited autonomy.
Islam isn't a religion that co exists beside others peacefully. That's on Islam. All of Israel's neighbors want to annihilate it including Egypt(a country colonised by Islam, currently bought off by the Americans sending aid), Syria(a country colonised by Islam, Lebanon(colonised recently by Islam), Iran you get the picture. The brass neck of the most brutal colonisers in history claiming the moral high ground always exposes the moral vacuum do gooders on the modern left seek to fill in their pathetic existences. What's happening in Gaza is grim but it's also light in comparison to what Israel's neighbours and the wider Islamic world has done in it's existence yet you dare not call that out as your minders will look at you and growl. As a gay man I have a well reasoned phobia of Islam and I can't blame the Jewish for feeling the same way.
Yes, he is the greatest obstacle to peace.
Imagine thinking the problem is just Netanyahu.
It's his regime.
@@soulglo45 nope.
no its the foundation of israel on an original land, land america with native americans, back then no media so killing with no limits Israel is an occupation land that'sthe problem not netenyaho, he's just a puppet like trup, biden, bush, and more and ore
@@bothi00 yup.
Without supporting USA, UK and German Netanyahu can’t do anything, he’s a weak but those who supports are responsible this genocide
Quote “ Israel will not survive if it becomes a pariah”. Well I’ve got News, it is a pariah. !!!
Typical. The US cavalry always arrive too late, after everyone has been slaughtered. 😢
Under 1% isnt everyone lmao
@@ghostboy6420it's not everyone but that is still a significant number of people.
Except in this case they still haven't arrived. They're meekly objecting from a distance while continuing to give weapons to the slaughterers
Where are the Brits?
You may already be aware, but the history of US government has always been a history of genocidal classist 'conservatives' alternating with merely-murderous classist 'liberals' from the very beginning. US white settlers and their political allies would murderously invade and/or plunder somewhere against US Federal law, then the US Army would have to intervene...in order to protect the people who broke the law, from 'foreign' and/or 'Indian' retribution, then conservatives, and even liberals sometimes, would eventually, if not soon after, codify 'realities on the ground' - this is how the US piecemeal grabbed territory west of the 13 colonies, Florida, Texas, 55% of Mexico, 'Oregon Territory', and Hawaii - in the great American 'Lebensraum' that Nazis, Russians, and imperialist nations globally were in awe and emulative of.
5 months later, he’s finally awake.
it's IRAN who is SUPPLYING and TRAINING all the TERRORISTS.
WHY is the PRESSURE always on Israel ?
Must abolish veto power and UN to ensure peace by majority of security council members.
It’s great to know some sane sounds from USA senate
Especially since 7 of October!!!
You're rather late with this...still wonder who exactly you pray to.
Netanyahu is a friend of Trump and, like Trump, is trying to avoid prison.
Trump is anti-war, Thirsty Benjamin is very much not.
@@MrJonathanainsworth Trump is pro-dictator, himself included.
About 53%* of US 'Jews' currently have real empathy for 'Palestinians'. I'm US-Jewish, currently 42%* of US-Jews plan voting for Trump, a huge historic increase in support for a Republican (a US subculture gone nuts part due to it being unchallenged Israeli-supremacist sub-culture's life work). Since 1920s only 28%* of US-Jews voted for a Republican president, a big reason Biden walking political tightrope as is. There are twice as many US-Jewish voters as there are US-Arab+Muslim voters. World media not covering ANY of this, not even 'progressive' media (it's bizarre, in any previous general election such obvious and semi-glaring considerations would be brought up by media jockeys, but all US-media (leftwing, rightwing and 'independent') norms are off when it comes to the plight of innocent 'Palestinians' vis-a-vis 'Jews' - it wouldn't be the first time in history in the US** that such things occasionally occur.
* statistically on average, ±2% from major recent polling, or relevant historical election results.
** In the 1930s-WW2, 'fearing' Nazi spies added unto an 'incidental' virulent antisemitic biased-leadership US-military-intelligence and the US-State-Department (under 'progressive when convenient' FDR), the US Government turned away Jewish refugees from Nazi genocide in Europe: www.smithsonianmag.com/history/us-government-turned-away-thousands-jewish-refugees-fearing-they-were-nazi-spies-180957324/
encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/the-united-states-and-the-refugee-crisis-1938-41
Genocide against Native Californians (and Oregonians): en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_genocide
US genocide against Chinese immigrants:
history.princeton.edu/about/publications/chinese-must-go-violence-exclusion-and-making-alien-america
World nations' denial of some well known genocides:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denial_of_genocides_of_Indigenous_peoples
Some well known war Crimes committed by US government: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_war_crimes
Race-based theft of assets and rural-incarcerations of ALL US-mainland Japanese-American citizens by FDR administration during WW2 (although 43% of the people in the US Territory (colony without equal representation) of Hawaii in 1941 were of Japanese descent but technically US-subjects but NOT US-citizens, extremely few of them were interned or assets stolen):
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_Americans
The watershed 1898 white-supremacist unchallenged coup massacre/ethnic-cleansing against Wilmington (North Carolina) that super-expanded and codified post-Civil War Apartheid in US southern 'Dixiecrat' states (a.k.a. the 'Jim Crow Era'): en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilmington_massacre
The watershed 1921 white-supremacist unchallenged massacre/ethnic-cleansing of 'Black Wall Street' (Greenwood, Tulsa, Oklahoma) that exemplified pre-WW2 Apartheid in US southern 'Dixiecrat' states (a.k.a. the 'Jim Crow Era'): en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulsa_race_massacre
The US-colonial-conquest Filipino-American War of 1899-1902 was as socio-politically divisive in the US as the genocidal Vietnam-American War was 6 decades later (and not taught in US schools), but US forces waterboarded over 5,000 Filipino village elders and massacred 10,000s (including civilians and 2000+ children) and 300,000+ died (mostly children and the elderly) from unsanitary deliberately-inadequate conditions at US concentration camps set up for entire civilian populations of emptied villages, hamlets and some towns: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippine%E2%80%93American_War
Note: Like many people's around the world who rarely know about or acknowledge their 'own' people's genocides and/or war crimes, Filipinos have their own history of genocide against an ethnic group, in Filipino history: against Chinese settlers.
I think it more like terrorist are avoiding them. Unlike Obama and Biding snuggling up to them an giving them OUR MONEY
Mate, you're so stupid, you know nothing....
This is how Truth looks like and sounds, and the Truth shall prevail.
We believe you! Thank you Schumer.
I'm just grateful that someone spoke up
Where was this speech pre Oct 7th ??
Schumer is one of the most directly responsible for this genocide
This is an incredibly powerful speech.
Also I highly recommend the book wrestling with Zionism. By daphna levit.
He’s a staunch defender of Israel but doesn’t agree with everything it does and stands for? How does that work?
"I'm a defender of Israel" = "I don't want to lose my AIPAC sponsorships"
@@hazmancan There is definitley something to be said about money in politics, but I don't believe this is purely monetary in nature. I think that we've got to the point where we're willing to justify colonialism and imperialism as long as people who do it get to claim to be oppressed. As an anti-imperialist leftist, I don't find the arguments about needing to kick people out of their homes so you can have a safe place to live to be a convincing argument.
@@hazmancan I think on both sides, people want to see these groups as something that they aren't. The Leftists as well as the people who just hate that group of people want to make it out like the Palestinians are pure victims and that Israel is the ultimate evil. Similarly, people on the other side want to say that Israel is blameless and Palestine is nothing but fa$hests. The way I see it is this. These are two groups who are fundamentally and irreconcilably opposed due to their beliefs. While we can admit that a two-state solution is the most optimal one, very few top officials in either Israel or powerful people in Hamas want that solution. Neither side wants to recognise the statehood of the other. Neither side is the innocent victim who just wants things to end and for both to respect each other.
Once again, this is another war caused by religion, the cause of most wars. The solution is not one that either would find favourable, and that is to abandon ancient myths for modern rationality.
@@hazmancan I think on both sides, people want to see these groups as something that they aren't. The Leftists as well as the bigots want to make it out like the Palestinians are pure victims and that the other side is the ultimate evil. Similarly, people on the other side want to say that Israel is blameless and Palestine is nothing but fashes. The way I see it is this. These are two groups who are fundamentally and irreconcilably opposed due to their beliefs. While we can admit that a two-state solution is the most optimal one, very few top officials in either Israel or powerful people in Hamas want that solution. Neither side wants to recognise the statehood of the other. Neither side is the innocent victim who just wants things to end and for both to respect each other.
When we see how the US behaves these days towards its closest friend, we can immediately conclude that Russia is a much more reliable country towards its friends than the US, which is capable of kicking and abandoning its friends in a troubled time .
Nethanyahu was never ever for peace.
Evil has a new name “Gvir” or “BB”
no its mohamed.
"Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different outcome."
Aren't you calling for them to do...again...what they've already done but expect a different outcome? Wasn't Gaza a two-state solution? Wasn't Gaza permitted free elections where they freely elected Hamas into power? You want them to do more of this and expect peace? Sounds kind of insane to me.
Why couldn't this guy have uttered these sentiments months ago? Too little, too late....and so slow off the mark, Too many innocent people have been killed as the USA has dithered.
Because of this reaction.
Because its hard to speak up when much of our government is sympathetic to israels genocide
Yes Chuck about time you guys had a regime change in israhell
Will a demilitarized USA be able to live side by side with it's neighbour's...in particular Cuba
You are fool
Why call for a demilitarised Palestinians state but not a demilitarised Israel?
Bless you mate.
Absolutely right sir
After he swore a Oath on the house floor to the Apartheid State
So What are going to do about it?Give more arms to Netanyahu?
I have generally been at odds with the machinations of Senator Schumer, but his comments in this address have elevated my estimation of him. to a great degree. I believe this is one of the most courageous addresses I have ever heard from a member of the United States senate. if, for no other reason, you will always have my respect and admiration for making the speech Senator Schumer.
Finally 👏👏👏
The government must force immediate order to to terminate Netanyahu duty and revoke all his duty as a pm now
Hope he mean it's
“A demilitarised Palestinian State” 😂😂😂😂 Obviously living side by side with one of the worlds foremost military States
About time!!!
3:59 How about - just a thought - you, or Biden or all the other Jewish members of congress _make him_ disavow those members!!!? How about you stop paying him billions. You think that might help!??
This is a historic moment
Don’t pray, use your power
Do not let this war friminal speak to Congress
Real human 🙏🙏
NY and this government must go. Without this major step, they’re putting the Israelis, and Jewish people around the world in danger.
I stand for the rights for all people who want to be of peace, work towards such, and stop the violence everywhere!
Palestine would then be the only "sovereign" country in the world not being permitted an army. That sounds messed up. I hate to tell you.
I can't understand how Schumer's remarks could be seen in any way controversial.
Step down yes...
What can you not like about the man.
His voting record
Everything because he is a hypocrite. He supports his real and it's 5 months too late.
What a whole lot of rubbish. You believe in Netanyahu’s heart!?
What a great obstacle
Focka Schuma! Yes Suh!!!
Why does Natenyahu has control of Congress? He even turned up at conggres without USA s official invite
No one like terror state unless they give up to occupy other countries land. This is first time someone from America is telling the truth however many Americans politicians May didn’t like this speech.
The horse has already bolted...
Too little...too late.
After millions of poor children and babies bombed and starved snd displave and some with no families so horrific this breaks my heart.
Im praying for palastians they suffer the most.
This pm from israel must stop!
Im 🇵🇷
Take the cottage out of your eyes
Stop Genocide now
wow.. I gained some respect for Chuck... never thought I would see the day a hardcore jew like Chuck would be saying this...
Atlast the world is able to criticise Israeli govt for the first time in history. It took horrendous level of suffering in Gaza for someone powerful to speak out.
It didn't end well with Hitler and it won't end well with Netanyahu either.
Schumer's arguments are reasonable.
This report is not directly againest to PM Natanyahu but againest the people of Israel & State of Israel.
What a lone sane voice in the US amidst the chaotic madness of genoside. God bless the USA
he should be calling for the vegetable in chief here to be voted out.
blah blah blah, nothing will happen
Words can stop or start wars. Do you not know that?
@@colincampbell4261 Not when they come from career criminal politicians like Chuck Schumer
Stuff will happen. Support to their military will be withdrawn.
blah blah blah israeli bot
Correct ❤
Please consider either 2 state or one state. If one state, it has to be fair, just, equal opportunities, fairness, NO APERTHIDE STATE, DISCRIMINATION. similar to Republic of South Africa.
Someone speaking sense, from USA i am shocked. I can't believe it.
It's a propaganda my friend, They play like we care about gaza, America is a terrorist state
Too late.
It is never too late.
Brave man
It’s refreshing to hear a man pointing out that the Israeli government do not speak for the majority of Israelis and the Jewish community.
Uh, no not really. Have you seen his record on Palestine?
It's not brave to speak out against Netanyahou.
Now, let's hear him denounce the occupation and apartheid
He really isn’t at all. I’m assuming you’re not American like me & don’t know he’s an extreme Zionist & the uncle of hateful Amy Schumer who equated all Muslims as Hamas
He is not brave. He is a Zionist who, together with Biden, has fully supported Israel's genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people. His only worry is with Israel's reputation.
@@bothi00 don't look a gift horse in the mouth. This is a huge change in terms of the US's stance on the conflict.
Demilitarized Palestinian state 😱😱😱 are u crazy. That's not an equitable deal for a two state solution side by side. Palestinian state sovereignty shouldn't be shackled by demilitarization...no country in the world has ever accepted such a stupid idea. Ukraine is a good example of what a disaster demilitarization is.
It take courage to react …important speech that should awaken the Israeli people from their support to the Netanyahu government…
Chuck Schumer is really a brave man.
True
It’s only words…
Better than ww3
We humans stand with palastine ❤❤❤
Mr Schummer you have it all right. The world have our eyes glued as the Gaza war unfold. If your opinion, though an opinion of wide acceptance can take hold sooner, their is chance the war will cease and Palestinians and Jews will come to terms for peace. Your position in the US government will do much at realization of your proposal. Thank you
🙏🕊️🙏
1948 we humans stand with palastine ❤
Hypocrites
I respect Schumer for Finally saying something like this. I agree with most of what he is saiyan here. Its the start towards peace however small it may seem to some at this time.
Only in times of need you find out who is the real friend and who just pretended to be a one like that .
from here.. we are telling you that the entire of Israeli people embraces and supports all his moves of Binyamin Netanyahu and that he was elected 6 times to be the prime minister of Israel proves this clearly .
Covering his political tail
Like deployed 👍
Chuck Schemer👿
1 Thessalonians 5:3
For when they shall say, Peace and safety; then sudden destruction cometh upon them, as travail upon a woman with child; and they shall not escape.
He avoided saying apartheid so much. around 1:23 and before.
That’s too late
This speech came too late
Better late then never. So it is not" too late".
OK but why must the Palestinian state be de militarised if it is next to a militarised Israeli state? I don’t get it?
Believerbility at zero and yes trust but verify''
💜💜
Too late
Just lip service
"ISRAEL IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE THE PEOPLE FROM GOD FATHER,GOD OF HEAVEN",AND OUR GOD FROM HEAVEN IS A GOD WHO SPRAYS LOVE EVERYWHERE,SO NETANYAHU HAS TO STOP THIS NONSENSE WAR AND MAKE AN AGREEMENT WITH PALESTINIAN HEAD AND CHUCK SCHUMER TO HAVE PEACE AND FREE EVERYBODY ON BOTH SIDES,AND EVERYTHING CHUCK SCHUMER SAID I AGREE,GOD BLESS HIM AND EVERYBODY IN THE WORLD!!🙏🙏🙏🙏
Humans palastine will live for ever we humans are all palastine ❤
Trader
Get em Chuck....cause no American politician has put THEIR political survival above the U.S.'s best interest. Especially you! And while you're at it, condemn those pesky Russians for meddling in American politics, cause you would NEVER meddle in another country's politics in this speech. Right?
I find this speech powerful up until he started praying, then I just found it offensive. There is absolutely no reason to bring religion into this speech.
As someone from the US, unfortunately almost all the American politicians constantly do this because they mix religion with politics to show the cultish religious Americans (especially the southerners/rednex) “look I’m one of you, please vote for me next election”.
Alot of USA citizens like that type of thing.
Don't forgot that this is the USA. Any person who dares say they aren't religious would be booted out at the next election.
@@colincampbell4261 and a lot of IS citizens are turned off by that sort of thing. So why is someone who is supposed to be speaking to all Americans doing so in a way that alienates a large section of the US who believe that a separation between church and state should be upheld.
You're so good at regime change...change it then.
Delicious!
Also raise voice against the Putin.. R u coword to raise voice against the putin😂