I hate when Swifties shade eachother for not being a fan since the beginning Ive only been a Swiftie for 3 years but I still love her and her music so much 🫶
In all fairness, I do think that there’s a difference between being a big fan of her music and being a swiftie to a certain degree. I think it has a lot to do with being interested (in most cases even obsessed) in her, not just her songs.
Yup totally agree, personally I love her music but don’t wanna know about her personal life other than the stuff that adds to the music. Like it’s just not right ppl should respect ppls privacy
I wish Joey would have the contestants vote first and then talk about why they voted that person and then Joey should vote afterwards after hearing why so it doesn’t just make the contestants votes pointless
i instantly knew it was victoria… she said taylor performed at least 5 songs in 2005 and that felt like a red flag to me (yes taylor did perform in “05 to local gigs but for someone not in her state you wouldnt really know her or see her), not knowing easter eggs was massive for me, and calling rep era “the incident” it just felt off!
yes i do that too, but i prepare myself for spoilers. this dude didn't and they got pissed at the commenter like no?? people are going to comment their opinions@@lanaforever815
Im an OG swiftie, I liked tim mcgraw and teardrops on my guitar but didnt totally love them. What made me stan her was her live performance of should've said no at the ACM awards show in 2008. I watched it live and I just loved her lol I was like 14 at that time so she was just a couple years older than me and I just knew she would be the voice of my generation. Never expected her to be THIS big, I mean shes the biggest music star in the world today, but I knew she would have a long successful career!
How can these other people call themselves swifties when they didn’t immediately raise suspicions about the girl that said Taylor released her first album in 2005 when it was actually 2006
That was what I got confused about because I know her first albums all came out 2 years apart until the deleted album and I know that my brother was born the same year that fearless came out so I was like what did I do wrong
I’m not actually a Gaylor y’all 😭 they cut out a huge section where I talked about how “it’s all in good fun,” and how I would never wish to speculate on someone’s sexuality other than my own 🫶🏻
I think Taylor may want us to speculate though!!! yes, the people who actually call themselves “Gaylors” may be taking it too far LOL but you can’t deny that blondie has dropped MANY loud and clear hints for us. I was excited you brought it up because I’m pretty passionate about this topic 😂🫶
@@alexisforshey8230 would you mind giving me some examples of her loud and clear hints? I’ve always wondered about this topic so I’m glad you’re passionate about it. I know it’s controversial to some people but I’m just so curious on specific examples!! Thanks!!
I relate to Christian’s ‘rollercoaster’ fan thing… I absolutely liked Fearless and Speak Now when I was young then I did listen to Red but didn’t quite catch on … I skipped the 1989 & Reputation cd’s and listened to Lover but when Folklore I absolutely loved it again!! (I was a stubborn Teenager in the middle years😅😂)
I love this style of content its absolutely fantastic! Everyone in these videos seems like such fun and great people aswell, hoping to see more awesome content from you Joey ❤ !!
as a (kinda new) swiftie I JUST KNEW IF FROM THE START IDK WHY BUT I WAS LIKE ITS HER actually i know why i just had a feeling because of how she said it was ✨reputation✨it kinda sounded like she was lying (btw here at 316 comments 209k views, and 5.9k likes!)
Joey!! I'd love to see (and definitely participate in) both a "who isn't the rock / metal head" and a "who isn't the gamer" oml they would be so fun! Pls let me be in one or both of those🤩 How does one get to be in these videos🤔 I would ACTUALLY fly over from the UK just to do this🤩🧡
I'm a combination of Maddy and the Taylor Swift "hater." I grew up listening to her Taylor Swift and Fearless albums and highly prefer those over her pop songs, but I don't mind some of her pop songs. However, I do only know of the ones they've played on the radio
If you’re an OG on RUclips then you’d prolly remember her “Teardrops on my Guitar” music video trending. That was the start for me at least, although im not a huge Swiftie
i knew it was her mostly because she said "reputationS" instead of "reputation" and i feel like any swiftie knows how to pronounce it correctly and because she said that someone already said her easter egg
SHE HAS 16 ALBUMS TAYLOR SWIFT FEARLESS SPEAK NOW RED 1989 REPUTATION LOVER FOLKLORE EVERMORE MIDNIGHTS RED TV FEARLESS TV SPEAK NOW TV (1989 wasn’t re-recorded then) BEAUTIFUL EYES AND THE HOLIDAY COLLECTIONNN
I love Maddie cuz i feel so validated by her now (typing before i know the impostor but i trust her) cuz i was also an OG Swiftie and fell off during 1989 (HATE Shake it Off) just cuz like middle school era for me and a lot was changing in my life and i couldnt handle the complete pop shift like the Red shift was fine but my lil heart wasnt ready and i came back when i heard Folklore and weve been loving ever since
I understand why that girl said she doesn’t like Karma I don’t like it either she’s probably Christian because she’s wearing a cross and we don’t believe in karma
I knew it from the beginning, she said she saw her live a couple years before 2007…..she looked nervous and I love Taylor swift and I don’t know if I was a swift ice in 2005
Gaylors are no different to people who speculate about her straight relationships. Just say you're homophobic and move on. Gaylors do no harm to the fandom, but homophobes do
i’m with kelly bc i don’t like karma either bc i don’t like karma itself and i hate the lyrics and i don’t believe in karma (as a Christian) i noticed her cross necklace i think she might have the same values and beliefs as i
I’m guessing it’s Victoria because she didn’t really engage with the group as much and she said her favorite album was reputations with an S. She also didn’t give too much information about herself. Honestly, I think one of the facts that she knew the most with that Taylor left for a year and came back and that’s when she did reputation was probably the best fact that she had in my opinion
I hate when Swifties shade eachother for not being a fan since the beginning Ive only been a Swiftie for 3 years but I still love her and her music so much 🫶
Fr like I've been a fan since 1989 but swiftie since the day midnights was released, but that doesn't make me less of a swiftie
Yeah i couldn’t be a Swiftie from the beginning because I’m 11 and it’s not possible
@jamiemonaco8168 yeah I wasn't born when debut and fearless released
You can start liking taylor 2 minutes ago and you're stilllll valid imo ❤
@@malalias3772 fr 🖤
I don't understand why there's a "criteria" for being a swiftie. You can be a huge fan of her music and not give a crap about her personal life
Rightt
Real
In all fairness, I do think that there’s a difference between being a big fan of her music and being a swiftie to a certain degree. I think it has a lot to do with being interested (in most cases even obsessed) in her, not just her songs.
@@LavenderLoverrr True.
Yup totally agree, personally I love her music but don’t wanna know about her personal life other than the stuff that adds to the music. Like it’s just not right ppl should respect ppls privacy
I wish Joey would have the contestants vote first and then talk about why they voted that person and then Joey should vote afterwards after hearing why so it doesn’t just make the contestants votes pointless
true
was rooting for brandon the whole time…
so glad he didn’t betray us swifties in the end
FR it was so obvious he was a swiftie
You can be critical of an artist and still love them and be a huge fan.
me with melanie martinez
Exactly and you can have a rollercoaster of listening to them and not or just be a newer fan and still be a swftie
@@brendonslife4584there’s a difference between a wrongdoing and sa
@@gm.8805Wait what happened with Melanie Martinez?
@@gm.8805it was proven false, the allegations aren't true
Joey was not qualified to be making eliminations for this video 😭
facts
i wasnt but thats what made it fun!
@@JoeyGraceffa Still ate it up king
In my opinion she's made better music!! ❤❤
Joey I will need to see your license of being a swiftie and your certificate please💁😒
i instantly knew it was victoria… she said taylor performed at least 5 songs in 2005 and that felt like a red flag to me (yes taylor did perform in “05 to local gigs but for someone not in her state you wouldnt really know her or see her), not knowing easter eggs was massive for me, and calling rep era “the incident” it just felt off!
Agree by she said she released her album in 2005 but it was actually 2006
I thought it was the blonde girl that said it was released in 05? The one who said she was 3 when it came out.@@user-ox2py6jr3p
@@user-ox2py6jr3pthat wasn’t Victoria, it was the blond girl
i knew it was victoria as soon as she said her favorite album was "Reputations" at 6:02 and i'm shocked none of the other voters caught it
she didn't call rep era "the incident", she said that about the whole K*nye West thing.
justice for folklore lovers 😭 that’s her best piece of work
Thank you
NO FR because when she said that I was SHOOK
omg fr😭
@@abramsfilm Love the user!
@@breannabug3033 I audibly gasped like
the second she said "Reputations" instead of just "Reputation", I knew
Me to I’ve been a swiftie for about 3 jears already and I immediately knew it was her wenn she said “ReputationS instead of Reputation 😂
@@The_way_i_love_you_swifties time stamp?
@@Anna-if7by 6.04
Victoria said her favorite album was “reputations” with an “s” immediately i knew it was her
Can u not spoil the video 🫤
@@WombatAnimatesjust don't look in the comments?? Dont blame then when you foolishly looked at their comment. Wait till the end then.
@@alissalalalano bc when I need smth to do while watching the video i go in the comments
yes i do that too, but i prepare myself for spoilers. this dude didn't and they got pissed at the commenter like no?? people are going to comment their opinions@@lanaforever815
@@lanaforever815then don't expect to not get spoiled I guess?
I'm a Swiftie and I have to say I was shocked of who it ended up being haha but thanks Joey for a good laugh 😂❤
Thank you for not spoiling it and saying who was not
i knew it from THE INTRODUCTIONS
Meeeeee
Ikr 😂😂😂
OMG THANK GOD FOR NOT SAYING THE PERSON BC I SCROLLED TO THE COMMENTS BC OF THE ADS I WASNT DONE 😂
Justice for Brandon. He knew the most!
tbh he was kinda insufferable though 😭 very condescending
Ummm BTW what does tbh mean
13:47 did she sing those colour
I think he was testing them
the fact that the girl with the "anti-hero" tattoo...that's some dedication!!!
I’m not a Taylor fan but if there was ever one for Niall I would answer all those questions without a problem lol
Mine would be for Camila cabello
im a taylor fan, but u are 100% correct about ni lol i would get everything right😭😭 i see him in 38 dayssss
@maddyhoverter I loveeeee ur pfp
Mine would probably be Justin Bieber, although ever since he got married to Hailey, I don't keep up with him as much.
Omg hey lover!!!🇮🇪
for "whats a fact you can prove that you are a swiftie" caroline could have just said more about her anti-hero tattoo that said it all lols
Im an OG swiftie, I liked tim mcgraw and teardrops on my guitar but didnt totally love them. What made me stan her was her live performance of should've said no at the ACM awards show in 2008. I watched it live and I just loved her lol I was like 14 at that time so she was just a couple years older than me and I just knew she would be the voice of my generation. Never expected her to be THIS big, I mean shes the biggest music star in the world today, but I knew she would have a long successful career!
How can these other people call themselves swifties when they didn’t immediately raise suspicions about the girl that said Taylor released her first album in 2005 when it was actually 2006
because not every swiftie knows every fact about her life or her music
no literally
That was what I got confused about because I know her first albums all came out 2 years apart until the deleted album and I know that my brother was born the same year that fearless came out so I was like what did I do wrong
Bcz you don’t have to know everything abt her to absolutely love her and her music ?
and someone said fearless was 2009….
literally the only me that gave me true swiftie energy was the blonde in white
she also has “anti hero” tattoo on her neck
She said she started listening to TS in 2005 when her first album released in october 2006
@@stars45678she was three hahaha give her a break
Only thing that gave me swiftie vibes was a man's anus. I ran swiftly away.
I’m not actually a Gaylor y’all 😭 they cut out a huge section where I talked about how “it’s all in good fun,” and how I would never wish to speculate on someone’s sexuality other than my own 🫶🏻
I think Taylor may want us to speculate though!!! yes, the people who actually call themselves “Gaylors” may be taking it too far LOL but you can’t deny that blondie has dropped MANY loud and clear hints for us. I was excited you brought it up because I’m pretty passionate about this topic 😂🫶
my pronouns are also speak/now ur so real
@@alexisforshey8230have you heard lavender haze? taylor definitely doesn’t want people to speculate about her personal life in general
@@alexisforshey8230 would you mind giving me some examples of her loud and clear hints? I’ve always wondered about this topic so I’m glad you’re passionate about it. I know it’s controversial to some people but I’m just so curious on specific examples!! Thanks!!
@@tarynclark8011 there's none lmfao
I relate to Christian’s ‘rollercoaster’ fan thing… I absolutely liked Fearless and Speak Now when I was young then I did listen to Red but didn’t quite catch on … I skipped the 1989 & Reputation cd’s and listened to Lover but when Folklore I absolutely loved it again!!
(I was a stubborn Teenager in the middle years😅😂)
SAME
Exactly my thing.
same! but im younger so i grew up on 1989 + rep and missed lover and came back right be for evermore
Justice for Brandon. He knew the most!. justice for folklore lovers that’s her best piece of work.
The fact that the vid ended at 22:13!💜
omg yess
4 months ago but I was searching so long for this comment I almost gave up!! ❤💜💜💜🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶
@@ReputationLoverJesahbelleC53 never give up!!💗🎀
15:28 I know she was the mole but she was so kind and so sweet and innocent this part when she said “noooo…” in a dog voice just made me so sad 😢❤
they got all of the years wrong. debut was released in 2006. Fearless was in 2008
I haven't seen a group of unenergetic Swifties before! The vibe just didn't match!
I would’ve stuck by her but I heard her say ‘reputationS’ and knew instantly hahahaha
that’s me in the boots!
Hey girly I think you're so talented and go you for the drag show
I would love to go to a TS drag show. ❤️ I went to a drag show for my bachelorette in March. They did a TS song.
IKTR!!!
I haven’t kept up with taylor swift since I was like 8 years old but I somehow still knew it was victoria before she even spoke a single word
I love this style of content its absolutely fantastic! Everyone in these videos seems like such fun and great people aswell, hoping to see more awesome content from you Joey ❤ !!
i am shook at the earpiece she really went all out 😂😂
I would love to do this. I can’t shut up when it comes to Taylor lol
Can't get enough of content like this love seeing you interact with the people always good for a laugh 💛💛💛💛💛
aww glad to hear it!
i’ve been a swfitie since around 1989, I was 4-5 and my dad actually introduced me to her and supported my obsession
for a second I thought you meant 1989 the year, not the album- but same otherwise, I was like 3-4 and it was red or 1989 i believe
Sameeee, i was like 2-3 back then but i was shakin it off ever since
mine was red/1989 i was 4-5
Wow, so young 😂 I was a swiftie since she released the song love story. I was 4 years old. Do the math 😂😂😂
@@deiyoja5492 uhm cool? so you’re just older than me
14:38 hurt me poor guy knew too much he wanted to spit it all out 😂
you should do this with beyoncé fans
Not joey flipping us off at 4:50 😭
I love Karma but I do understand why she might not like the lyrics very well..😂
@ATorturedPoetSwiftie13 I’m sorry I don’t rlly remember what I was saying because I made that comment 4 months ago..
as a (kinda new) swiftie I JUST KNEW IF FROM THE START IDK WHY BUT I WAS LIKE ITS HER actually i know why i just had a feeling because of how she said it was ✨reputation✨it kinda sounded like she was lying
(btw here at 316 comments 209k views, and 5.9k likes!)
i knew it was victoria as soon as she said her favorite album was "Reputations" 6:02
Omg Maddy and I have a really similar story. I went into my emo phase then came back to Taylor (I still love heavy metal)
I mean on TikTok they have done changes to speak now and sounds really emo 😂 so it makes sense!
Laughing so loud about „my pronouns are Speak Now“ ahahahahaha
RUN!? I love Run, imma cry fr
i knew it was her from the start because she looked the most nervous😭
“my pronouns are speak/now” I LOVE.
Joey!! I'd love to see (and definitely participate in) both a "who isn't the rock / metal head" and a "who isn't the gamer" oml they would be so fun! Pls let me be in one or both of those🤩
How does one get to be in these videos🤔 I would ACTUALLY fly over from the UK just to do this🤩🧡
Reputation and Midnights girl here!
The only right answer 🐍🕰️🌌
*I LOVE THIS SM IM SUCH A BIG SWIFTIE!!! My top 5 fav albums are Speak now, evermore, midnights, 1989, red* 💜🤎💙🩵❤
You have good taste ✨✨
I'm a combination of Maddy and the Taylor Swift "hater." I grew up listening to her Taylor Swift and Fearless albums and highly prefer those over her pop songs, but I don't mind some of her pop songs. However, I do only know of the ones they've played on the radio
Calling it now it's Victoria, after she said her favourite album was "Reputations" with the s at the end I was like nope
Swiftie here, but guuurrll let's sip the tea~
Anyways I enjoy your video!
I voted for the same girl as joey until the second round when he couldnt name a vault track
When Blondie said run was her least fav song I screamed
I suspected that end girl the moment she explained how long she was a swiftie... because her eyes were a rolling to the side so hard. huge red flagggg
I have Tourette’s that’s why my eyes roll lol
I knew it was her! What gave it away was when she said her favourite album was Reputation’s
Why?
@@aleksandrac9335it’s just reputation* not the plural
At first right off i knew the first girl was a Swiftie because she litterly has a tattoo of her on her leg 😂
Claim your “here within an hour” ticket right here🏆
here!
Me
How are you doing girly
I didn't mean to write it twice
J
How did they decide to vote brandon out
haha i had to choose someone!
I KNEW WHY I LIKED YVETTE SO MUCH!!! A REPUTATION STAN AND GAYLOR??? SLAY QUEEN!
I mean the girl said “Reputations” soooo…
What music video are the elevator buttons in (the Easter eggs) at 13:32 in the video!??!?!?
BEJEWELED MUSIC VIDEO
Okay waitttt I’m obsessed with Yvette…
I love how the video was 22 minutes and 13 seconds long 22 fro her song “22” and 13 because that’s her lucky number!!
The girl in the blue shirt (sry don’t know names) literally has anti-hero on her chest as a tattoo 😂 ❤
If you’re an OG on RUclips then you’d prolly remember her “Teardrops on my Guitar” music video trending. That was the start for me at least, although im not a huge Swiftie
i need joey to make a harry styles/ one direction version of this
Swifty’s assemble
i knew it was her mostly because she said "reputationS" instead of "reputation" and i feel like any swiftie knows how to pronounce it correctly and because she said that someone already said her easter egg
13:37 the 1989 logo, with the s looking like a snake!!! biggest shock of my life fr
I don’t understand how anyone can’t love Taylor but it’s not my business or decision
I guessed right for a change! Joey, I'm surprised you're not a Swiftie. Thanks for the Guess Who isn't, see you soon!
YAY!!! I’ve been waiting for this video THANK YOU JOEY!!! ILYSM!!
8:00 what how dont you like karma. ( I respect she doesnt but im jusg shocked😂😂)
I’m a little sad at how toxic the Swiftie community has become, especially after she’s become the music industry so to speak.
SHE HAS 16 ALBUMS TAYLOR SWIFT FEARLESS SPEAK NOW RED 1989 REPUTATION LOVER FOLKLORE EVERMORE MIDNIGHTS RED TV FEARLESS TV SPEAK NOW TV (1989 wasn’t re-recorded then) BEAUTIFUL EYES AND THE HOLIDAY COLLECTIONNN
When she said debut came out in 2005 I knew it was her. Debut came out on October 24 2006 btw.
I miss you posting rescue videos. Make more videos like that❤
I love Maddie cuz i feel so validated by her now (typing before i know the impostor but i trust her) cuz i was also an OG Swiftie and fell off during 1989 (HATE Shake it Off) just cuz like middle school era for me and a lot was changing in my life and i couldnt handle the complete pop shift like the Red shift was fine but my lil heart wasnt ready and i came back when i heard Folklore and weve been loving ever since
LOVE YOU KING NOW TELL US ABOUT ETN 5
I understand why that girl said she doesn’t like Karma I don’t like it either she’s probably Christian because she’s wearing a cross and we don’t believe in karma
6:25 100000000000000000000% agree 💙💙💙
I love how I knew immediately who it was. It’s like a swiftie sense
"i forgett I just blanked" SIR. WE HAVE 4 ALBUMS WITH VAULT TRACKS. THATS OVER 20 SONGS. how do you not know a SINGLE one
i think he was just too shy and nervous
FR, even after they mentioned it, he could've said something- Red has like a bajillion vault tracks
@@LupitaGoth it's not that hard to just say a vault track though, there's like 25 now
That’s literally me and I could name all her songs in my room alone, sometimes people just get nervous? Tf
11:19 idk yvette has a point!!! i wouldn’t go as far as saying gaylor, but she has deffo dropped hints to us before .
I knew it from the beginning, she said she saw her live a couple years before 2007…..she looked nervous and I love Taylor swift and I don’t know if I was a swift ice in 2005
Joey took her 8:10 out at the beginning and said cause I’m a swifty but he didn’t even know about Taylor swift album 9:01
Take a shot every time they use the word era 😂
I knew it was Victoria from start. Like I never get these right but I just had a feeling lol
i love the album fearless. i had that album but my cat broke the cd cause she sat on it i still need to buy another one.
not the gaylor bruh 😭
@@letgobabyhippo FR I WAS LIKE 👀💀
Gaylors are no different to people who speculate about her straight relationships. Just say you're homophobic and move on. Gaylors do no harm to the fandom, but homophobes do
Ummmm how did nobody catch it when one girl said debut was made in 2005
I stan Kelly so so much like she seems so cool
I called it from the first introduction. I can spot my swifties😩
I'm a Swiftie and karma and shake it off are one of my favorites soo
Yvette was the realest
agreed!
As a swiftie, I do NOT have a least fav album or song or anything, so if that were me everyone would think im sus 😭
“My pronouns are speak/now” 😭
LETS NOT TALK ABOUT THE SEXUALITY OF A PERSON WHO SAID PUBLICLY OVER AND OVER AGAIN THAT THEY DONT FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH THIS THANK YOU BYE
Knew it was her from the beginning when each of them started talking one by one she was moving nervously nonstop
i’m with kelly bc i don’t like karma either bc i don’t like karma itself and i hate the lyrics and i don’t believe in karma (as a Christian) i noticed her cross necklace i think she might have the same values and beliefs as i
im Christian aswell and i actually loveeeee karma
I’m guessing it’s Victoria because she didn’t really engage with the group as much and she said her favorite album was reputations with an S. She also didn’t give too much information about herself. Honestly, I think one of the facts that she knew the most with that Taylor left for a year and came back and that’s when she did reputation was probably the best fact that she had in my opinion