Soviet animated films: Growth Of Communist Party a
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 ноя 2024
- Two short early Soviet animated films.
#1- Our answer to the gloating capitalist world
About the continued growth of the Communist Party and the accomplishments of the USSR.
#2- Collectivization
Short advocating the formation of collective farms and discouraging patronage of private shops. This film must have certainly appeared during the NEP era and signaled the beginning of a change in policy.
"Our answer to the Gloating Capitalist World:"
*"Lenin is Dead"*
probably something to do with "Lenin is all that sustains the USSR" so if he is gone and it still exists than that claim is proven wrong
@@kaiolsen6491 Yep
But Lenenizm is living.
@@maksimb1853 ☭
Because it doesn't say 'Lenin is dead'
holy shit my great great grandfather probably watched this 90 years ago
on what? on a stove?
@@ubuntuposix he probably dont even have one back then
Slava, comrade!
@@gabrieldossantoscampos5127 Slava Dumbass
Soviet south park
Если именно в результате вашего саус парка ракеты в космос не начинают летать, не исчезает безработица, не строятся тысячи школ, больниц, университетов- то это значит, что ты нихрена не понял.
@Bayou Outlaw "south facing rocket park" yeah i think this guy needs a r/wooosh
@@runerur а еще в Южном парке люди могут поехать за границу, они живут лучше, богаче, потребляя товары более высокого качества
@Bayou Outlaw yeah lol
Why it is recommended after 11 years
Me too. It is in my feed too. Wonder why?
@@lindatisue733 Because RUclips is Communist
Why is it recomended after hundred years?
@@lindatisue733
Well it educational for the US. it shows the future of US
Maybe a hint, some kind, the past hints at the situation in the present.
I actually watched the whole thing. It got me hooked.....so this is how Communism began.
I can tell they were very uneducated to come up with a system like this... it's like 5 year old came up with it
Yes because the whole thing started as a way for formers to service winter before it became a political venture.
Well...Stalin for the most part did not organize the cooperatives as state-owned. There were two official types of farms in the USSR the sovkoz (state owned farms) and kolkhoz (worker's collective farm).
Except from the names. There was no difrence from the state owned. And workers collective farms.
@@thunberbolttwo3953 There was a big difference.
@@thunberbolttwo3953 The collective farms pooled resources and equipment among the farmers, they worked the common plots that sold it's produce to the state. Each family that their own plot of land that they could in turn sell in farmers market for their own profit. State farms were like corporate farms where the people that worked there were employees and all of the produce belonged to the state.
Вау, ребята, откуда вы все это знаете? Вы даже на русском то не говорите
@@StripesHistoryHub After a certain point Stalin had Commissars run the Kolkhoz farms anyways. I'm sure for a certain period of time there was a meaningful distinction, but after a certain point the Kolkhoz was essentially just a state owned estate anyways. Most of the Commissars, who had been college educated and put in charge despite a severe lack of experience and aggressive quotas caused a lot of suffering both for the serfs and the rest of the country as they had pretty much caused famine.
2:10 - it plays "яблочко" by red army choir
яблочко/Apple
That would be something to hear in Lupin III Part VII.
lol try watching this while smoking weed it will blow your mind man.
trippy as hell
Thank you.
For what?
Krusty: What the hell was that?!?!?
That was your experience about the USSR its valid. But when I went to Ukraine and Russia myself I spoke with others (mostly retired people) and some middle aged folks who had positive memories about the Soviet times. It can't be denied guaranteed income, housing, and health care means a lot to pensioners and younger people struggling now in the former USSR. The USSR was not perfect and it was not democratic but I can understand the nostalgia I saw when I visited.
Nostalgia for a time that never existed except in their memories.
This is very interesting. Of course cooperatives are great in principle. However, they can easily been subsummed to a burocratic and controlling and repressive and suffocating and stiff etc system like the Soviet Union, which is why that system broke down. Cooperatives exist in small numbers all over the world, but quite a few fail because corrupt leaders start taking the money for themselves (cont.)
They aren't great in principle, and it's the reason barely any are even slightly successful
Why is in my recommended after 104 years?
Isn't?! XD
@mastaODI56 Don't think that's Lenin, looks like it's a Capitalist.
It just occurred to me this is around 100 years old
With period literacy rates around 20-25% , thats an awful lot of text.
Silent film houses in Japan had readers called benshi.
The Left can’t meme
Soviet authority ceased illiteracy very fast
@@crimony3054 but that's Not japan
@@leekyungmin-t6u They might have done the same thing?
Do you want even MORE effective secrets on how to get rich and the most productive in 10 minutes?? Then give us ONLY your private properties and you will get special VIP sequel episode!!!
God this animation style is terrifying. I'm going to have nightmares after this
Emm....1924....
@@БабаКапа-в6н ?
@@rexjolles He says this animation was made in 1924 when most of the world's animation looked like this.
@@user-pf3kv4bv5s oh yeah but idk how it was relevant
@@БабаКапа-в6н 1924 doesn't mean anything. I can find better animation from the time, this one just has people who move like possessed dolls.
1925, it's interesting that the agri-co.ops are still "competing" with the richer peasants the "Kulaks", I'd have thought that by 1925 all land ownership would have already been abolished
Rajah O'bagal 1924 and 1925
It was not totally, Kulaks existed and a condition of new Kulaks rising from middle peasants were also seen.
It resulted in state intervention, which could have been a mass movement against Kulaks.
One of the errors of Stalin leadership, but nonetheless he did what he had to at his time. It was a terrific time.
И.В. Сталин:
"Отдельные товарищи полагают, что при капитализме будет процветание. Будет, но лишь для кучки буржуев и их лакеев...
Когда ловят шпиона или изменника, негодование публики не знает границ, она требует расстрела. А когда вор орудует на глазах у всех, расхищая государственное добро, окружающая публика ограничивается добродушными смешками и похлопыванием по плечу.Между тем ясно, что вор, расхищающий народное добро и подкапывающийся под интересы народного хозяйства, есть тот же шпион и предатель, если не хуже...
Ведь расстрелянные враги народа основной своей задачей ставили...восстановление капитализма и власти буржуазии в СССР, который бы в этом случае превратился в сырьевой придаток запада, а советский народ - в жалких рабов мирового империализма.
Захватив власть... эти презренные и жалкие предатели намеревались прежде всего отказаться от социалистической собственности, продав в частную собственность капиталистическим элементам важные в экономическом отношении наши хозяйственные объекты.
Под видом нерентабельных ликвидировать совхозы и распустить колхозы. Передать трактора и другие сложные сельскохозяйственные машины крестьянам-единоличникам, именуемым ими фермерами, для возрождения кулацкого строя в деревне. Закабалить страну путем получения иностранных займов.
Отдать в концессию важные для империалистических государств наши промышленные предприятия.
В тоже время осужденные враги народа стремились всеми силами подорвать боеспособность советских вооруженных сил".
Заседание ЦК ВКП б 1941г
Бред кровавого параноика!
Он и здесь оказался прав.
Это он о 90-х.... вот вам и "параноик", господа лакеи.
Ну не только параноики, но и ещё бред зависливых нищебродов!
Которых, к слову, более 80% населения. Плюньте им всем в лицо еще раз. Время пока терпит
🔥pricelss🔥
Я не говорю по-русски хорошо. Ну ... Я говорю по английски, как и большинство людей на этом сайте. Русские не единственные, кто заинтересован в советской истории.
(My response in very bad Russian
Well, I am an English speaker as are most of the viewers of this channel. The Subtitles are needed. Russians are not the only ones interested in Soviet history.)
Yes
Ладно.
The logic behind this cartoon is about as good as the quality of it
Now nobody can get rich 👍
Haha indeed lol
Too bad Rob Jay, next time we'll make sure they won't so they can sit down their asses and help the rest of society like everyone else does.
@acoronab (cont) Also, to survive, they must be driven by idealism and when they work, people start getting too comfortable for the organization to survive in a competitive world and if they work, they depend on the drive of one or two leaders. When the leader die, the organization may falter. These are a few of the many problems of cooperatvies. Of course, the opposite individualistic system is also full of flaws...
Thank you for sharing this.
Skipped the murder by starvation of millions of Ukrainians. Wonder why?
Well, the communists would say that Pahomych was rich because he exploited his workers. The attitude that the poor were that way because they were lazy and drunkards was one of the reasons that the revolution happened in the first place. Last time I was in Russia it looked like the country was doing pretty good it's one of the world's fastest growing economies. The Soviet economy didn't do too bad either they did fully industrialize within a generation under Stalin.
And the percentage of each on the agrarian economy? Here in Romania all of them were organized as state-owned after 1948, and those transformations were practically imposed by Stalinist politicians such as Anna Pauker... Also, was a workers collective farm really independent? I mean, could the workers really take all the profits as shareholders, or did the state impose them a huge tax rate?
@@ИмяФамилия-ц6д please give more information. You helped explain some of the false economy of the USSR. It appears the old system willfully ignorant of basic economics. Thank you, Comrade!
At the end Japanese empire shines
That is not accidental or coincidental. That is exactly what is being intentionally indicated. But it shall remain forever indeterminate as to what was meant by that. Either it was Japan as a future war objective or Japan as an impending bulwark or medium against Western Imperialism.
@@jonglewongle3438 wait-
@@nicocola284 What do you mean by " wait " ?
all based on CREDIT...
Lenin, Stalin and Kalinin were the best!
The same can be said about militant capitalists today.
Lol playground economics with Cainian undertones as its motive. Nice. And if you thought this idea was stupid, you were the one in Gulag.
Considering in 1920's russia, it was the third or fourth generation of starvation, any alternative from quasi feudalism was sought after
@@koalabear1984 Welp you get to suffer the consequences of killing your Kulaks. No sympathy here.
@@Spl1nter699 well, just adding 2 more generations of starvation before eventually turning it into paradise (actual food like sausages and WHITE bread)
1917: Lenin was true to his word; "What we want is a dictatorship of the Proletariat!" After desperate pleas to tone down his rhetoric Lenin backed off from this chilling declaration for a while... 1933-1950 Stalin brought Lenin's nightmare vision to life. My family escaped before the Terror began in earnest.
Rob Jay lol!
still better than Cocomelon
after “Lenin died” it was written “Leninism is alive”
Yeah that worked out well
Beginning of the video shows a turning point in USSR history which is rarely discussed - how Stalin came to power. Just a few days after death of Lenin in 1924 Party organized new mass enrolment. This shown as "100000 people join the Russian Communist Party"(party name until 1925) in the video. Many of them were simple workers who just wanted to make a quick career with a help of Party and didn't even know basics of communist theory. These "new communists" quickly outnumbered old party members who was mostly from intelligentsia and helped triumvirate Zinoviev, Kamenev, Stalin removed Trotsky and his supporters from power. Of course this trio didn't last long and soon Stalin attacked his "comrades" and paved his road to absolute power with their blood.
This is a good example what effect a "primitive" propaganda may have on uneducated people and lead to drastically changes.
PS. sorry for possible grammar mistakes.
Makes Communist Utopia -> Robs the successful -> Runs out of food and starves -> Say it wasn’t real communism -> Establish “new” Communist utopia
The USSR wasn't a communist paradise and never claimed to be.
@@StripesHistoryHub My bad, I forgot to include “attempts” to be. That’s why communists today are eager to try another experiment for it to end murderous like Pol pot, Stalin and Mao.
@@StripesHistoryHub It is the goal of USSR to be a “Communist utopia”, it will “only happen” if all of the world is communist.
@@jaycecross4110 They never claimed that either. They claimed communism could only come when the needed industry and technology would allow a post-scarcity economy.
@@jaycecross4110 If you want to talk body count the leaders of the Capitalist experiments have Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot beat by millions even with debatable death numbers anti communist claim.
It's as if the many millions who died because of the slave trade, imperialism, colonization, and forced famines under capitalism don't matter.
Согласен. Но... почему бы, вместе с дубляжом, на всеобщее обозрение не выкладывать и оригинал?
It agrees. But... why, together with dubbing-in, on a public inspection not to spread and the original?
Who killed Kenny?
По-моему мультики из 20-х или 30-х
Russian sailors dance
0:32
Soviet Black Friday sale.
Must have been hell to live in Russia during the Soviet Era.........
Alan K
exactly in the years of the release of this film - in the United States, about 8,000,000 citizens died of hunger. Industrialization and development of agriculture took place in the USSR, and in the West there was the Great Depression.
I had a Russian Doctor, she said she liked it and had a lot more freedom than she has in Sweden.
@@lindatisue733 She lies.
@@vitiachao9765 and youd know
They had free health care, free education, homes for the homeless
Meanwhile in the us: pay for healthcare pay for education pay for home…you don’t have money oh we will pay you to be a solider for empire
Must be shitty for the folk living pay check to pay check aka 70% of the US
Must be shirt to not be able to avoid a 500 dollar emergency
Must be shitty to spend all the tax money on war just to make the wealthy more rich while we have vets that are homeless on the streets..
But but gulags..
AT Least 20 million people died from starvation or execution due to communism .The numbers would have been higher if not for Hoover.
@@tropicalslav931 comunism wasnt really bad in the ussr too. you could buy a dacha just buy working in a food factory (which is what my grandfather did)
Can you prove this number? I guess you can't.
@@tropicalslav931 Well, why are the people complain when USSR was open to the world and see the truth about their living conditions compared to the rest of the world?
Dave Weller 200 trillion, you moron XD
@@ДмитрийАрсентьев-ь6с не может конечно ) Вон какие миллионы были осуждены: shop.alexanderyakovlev.org/almanah/inside/almanah-doc/55696
If I join do I get an officer’s hat with a hammer sickle emblem? Cause if so I’ll join for that
So basically instead of a private merchant overseeing 1 business you have 1 state being the merchant for everything? How did that go Russia?
What song is playing at 2:23-?
Yablochko (the apple)
bruh lenin
bruh lenin
It actually starts at 2:10 and plays to the end.
Any wrong?
"LENIN IS DEAD"
"BUT LENINISM IS ALIVE"*
"USSR is recognized by England, Italy, Norway" - question is for how much money.
Well, since Norway joined the comintern, Norway did it for free. By the way, Russia was the first country in the world to recognise Norway as a free and independent nation just 12 years before, in 1905.
Best regards, a Norwegian comrade.
@@boringpolitician the USSR was awful.
@@nobody5228 The West is awful now. And not in Propaganda - but in practice.
Also...I've got my problems with Putin myself...but there's no denying that Russia is more free today than it's ever been since at least the first Tsar. 50 years from now, I have no doubt that Russians will have a similar standard of living as Western Europeans.
That didn't age well. April 2022.
communism that really worked out
✊🚩
AOC approves this message
Слава КПСС ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
@trupoed11 americans are 300millions, what would you call this animated story for peasents who couldn t read or write??art?
I want to see rule 34 of this
.... uh
If only it had worked
no homeless free medical, free education, best army in the world fist in space and list goes on
@@lilywhite8157 yes but, poor medical facilities, poor overcrowded non maintained apartments with a 15 year waiting list, poor quality unaffordable cars, drastic overspend on the Army at the expense of few if any consumer goods. Endless queues for goods even in the eighties, political education even in schools, not allowed to leave the Country withott special permission? Internal passports? - Repression if you criticised the Government? No freedom of speech? Invading and repressing Countries who didn't want the Communist system, i.e. Hungary 1956, Czechosolvakia 1968, Elite priviledged bureaucratic elite even worse than the Capitalist countries, special shops for the party not allowed to the ordinary worker. The list is endless.
@@denisdennehy4549 Yeah, that's what Western propaganda says XD
"Repression if you criticised the Government? No freedom of speech?"
Are you talking about the modern USA - about Trump's supporters, about BLM, about elections in which the dead voted?
"who didn't want the Communist system, i.e. Hungary 1956, Czechosolvakia 1968"
And who will ask them what they want? These countries - Hitler's allies - helped him kill 27 million Soviet citizens. Even the Germans serving in the SS were shocked by the atrocities committed by the Hungarians in Ukraine. These countries - had no right to object to something - and even to have their own opinion.
Yes, the list of your propaganda to justify fascism is endless.
@@alexgainsborough4921 bruh the wait time and the lack of products is real, even in the bridge country of yugoslavia, let alone some village in siberia
art of tapeworming
Что Я понял из этого видео?
1. Купцы настолько жадные что ценники рисуют из космоса на связи с Марсом, А покупатели такие глупые и не знают что такое рыночная конкуренция!
2. Главный Капиталист ГОСУДАРСТВО монополизировал рынок и вытеснил всех неугодных с рынка!
Жду ваших мыслей а то вдруг Я что то пропустил.
1) "Купцы" не рисуют цены из космоса, они руководствуются ситуацией в экономике, за сколько у них готовы купить продукцию, себестоимость самих реализуемых товаров, наличие конкурентов, связь с ними, присутствие олигополии, либо картельного сговора и прочее. Но, например, когда случаются неурожайные года, спрос на, тот же самый хлеб и зерно, резко возрастает и купец, взвинчивает прибавочную стоимость (которая, даже может превышать саму себестоимость продукции), в угоду личного обогащения и наживы на тех, кто, зачастую, не владеет средствами производства. Именно это, во многом, вынудило власть бороться с кулачеством и частным ростовщичеством. Главная же проблема заключалась в том, что при такой ситуации , увеличивается социальное расслоение между теми, кто живет , за счёт перепродажи продукции, в производстве которого не участвует, и теми, кто непосредственно участвует в производстве товаров , но не владеет ими, либо владеет не в полной мере. А это - ужесточение классовой борьбы, что не есть хорошо, так как напоминает басню, про лебедя, рака и щуку. Потом, про какую осведомлённость о рыночной конкуренции можно говорить, в государстве, где капитализм не был построен в полной мере? Большинство людей ,поколениями, жили либо в собственности у феодалов, либо, уже позже , непосредственно арендуя землю, у них ,и только 7 лет назад, крестьянам, были даны наделы, принадлежавшие, именно, им. Это я, даже, не говорю об уровне их образования, которое , часто, заключалось в наличии 4 лет обучения, в церковно - приходской школе.
2) Тогда , государство ещё не монополизировало рынок, в полной мере, эта мультипликация времён НЭПа, когда была разрешена частная собственность на средства производства, в некоторых сферах. Сделано это было , для того чтобы экономическая ситуация, в стране, восстановилась, путём саморегуляции рынка, и для улучшения капиталистического базиса, от которого отталкивался бы дальнейший социализм , по - Ленину. Так же , не стоит сравнивать гос. капитализм с капитализмом частных лиц. Стоит сказать, что , по - Ленину, социализм - это государственная монополия, направленная на благо общества. При таком государственном капитализме, средствами производства, никто не владеет, в полной мере. Ведь государство - это не частное лицо, а целая организация, которой присуща ротация кадров, и даже в буржуазной республике, простой человек, имеет шансы попасть в гос. аппарат, не говоря уже про государство, с диктатурой пролетариата. По факту, складывается ситуация, в которой производства принадлежат всем и одновременно никому. + вся прибыль от реализации продуктов и услуг , идёт непосредственно в бюджет (а не оседает в карманах у частников) и распределяется на нужды страны (развитие инфраструктуры, поддержание основных фондов, армию, социалку и т.д.). Бывают же и иные формы госкапитализма, например, поздний Ирак, при Хусейне. Там, узкий круг владельцев средств производств, непосредственно , находился в государственном аппарате и не сменялся (точнее, сменялся, но по собственному желанию), прибыли оседались в карманах, у них, а не шли в бюджет, в полной мере. По факту, это неприкрытая диктатура капитала, а, учитывая , к тому же, огромное давление на рабочее движение, милитаризм, развязывание войн за ресурсы и рынки сбыта, идеологию корпоративизма, прикрывающуюся социализмом и антикоммунизм - представляет собой, образцовый, пример фашизма.
Если тупой выйди на рынок,но ты тупой и не поймёшь все равно как тебя облапошивают,для таких как ты снят мультфильм без сильного смыслового перегруза
@@ПетркропоткинКропоткин глистами красными завоняло
@@rotgardist1912 Глистами красными завоняло
Actually the quality of the presentation just furthers the argument for capitalism. Just another proof that a product created for profit is of a much higher quality than one made under the ideals of "from those according to their abilities, to those according to their needs".
Greed, Lust, Pride.. these things DRIVE innovation.
What did you ever do in this world to prove your judgement doesn't require proof (it's a rhetorical question, with judgements like that, you can't have done anything)
Impossible de commenter: je ne veux pas utiliser la langue de l'occupant
All the power to the SOVYETs!!!
I love how this films lies so blatantly. The collective farms were created by force. By the government. The peasant famers did not want to create them.
Many but not all willingly formed the collective farms voluntarily.
The collective farms were not created by force. They were robbod by the State.
За Фашизм! Против леваков-коммунистов
Привет
А это не Ленин
Urss NO. Is Soviet Russia .
They show this to Capitalis traitors in Siberian Gulags
Dafuq?!
LOOK!!! A democrat party platform ad!
Jesus, no wonder we won the Cold War
чо за субтитры блядь посреди экрана?!
пиздец...
по идиотски сделано. не видно ничо.
Neither America nor Russia base their laws on the Bible, Israel however does base its laws on the Torah. Russia and America are more or less secular. But my impression was mostly "I like Stalin because he modernized Russia" as in the End Justify the Means. He may have been a cruel dictator, but to some estimates a 3rd of Russians, it was necessary to modernize Russia.
Coming back in Europe very soon 🇨🇳
Yes
And the USSR is where now? It worked out well for them, didn't it? LOL!
From the fifth place to the 2nd between 1927-1939 years in the economy size. From 5% of the industrial output of Germany, Britain, France and the USA combined to somewhat equal to Germany. First atomic electric station, first atomic powered ship, first satellite, first man in space, one of the world's two countries which had its indigenous semiconductor industry.
The 6th place for today and nothing significant created for the last 30 years of the market economy. Death of the machinery, electronics, decrease in the quality of education and medicine, for everything people must pay now.
I guess it worked good. It looks that it doesn't now, if we put away shiny wrap papers, shop windows and imported cars.
In some aspects, the bigger cities won. But I can't say that in everything. The majority of the population lost. By the Gallup survey, over 50% of the former USSR population (Russia+other independent republics) find the planned economy better.
@@hepcat93 The USSR no longer exists. It was an EPIC FAIL.
@@GEToleman, u haven't just read what it achieved? Or u mean that since the economic system was lame from the beginning it was doomed to fail anyway?
@@hepcat93 It achieve squalor and death.
@@GETole weird rationale. We have about 200 countries in this world. The USSR was the second economy among these 200. Russia has been on 5-6th places by "Purchasing Power Parity GDP".
And the market economy did no positive work here. At its best it only reached or slightly exceeded Soviet Russia of 1989 in numbers. But is still relying on its infrastructure or big key factories and plants, which never existed before the USSR on this land.
The "squalor" is not an applicable word here. Simply and rationally, u're wrong.
Какая тупость!
Thanks for the algo comment
How can they stop the merchants from being party officals? Different names but the same exploitation! All the same!
Word salad what?
No. You're not even close. Please research the topic, because your overarching generalizations, hasty conclusions and lack of actual understanding of what you're talking about is painful. People like you make me weep for the future.
Lol