Será el sereno pero México siempre trato de evitar el conflicto , pero los gringos querían probar el armamento que llevarían a la primera guerra mundial y al no encontrar a villa provocaron intencionalmente al ejército mexicano , y recibieron por ello una clara derrota por parte de los mexicanos, que por cierto el pueblo del Carrizal debe ser considerado heroico ya que cuando caía un soldado mexicano un civil tomaba su arma y luchaba, aún así México siempre actuó de buena fe, incluso regreso armamento decomisado y prisioneros. Viva México Cabrones!!!!
Thank you for your response. Since I don't speak or read Spanish, I had to use Google translate. You have given an interesting insight to the Mexican side. I will be doing a video on the battle of Nogales shortly would be interested in hearing your take on the battle. Google Translated version: Gracias por su respuesta. Como no hablo ni leo español, tuve que usar el traductor de Google. Has dado una interesante mirada al lado mexicano. Haré un video sobre la batalla de Nogales en breve, estaría interesado en escuchar su opinión sobre la batalla.
@@mike125520002000 it’s hard to find stability in the Mexican state prior to ceding the Northern Territory to the US. Mayans, Aztecs, conquistadors, various governments that could not even stop commanche raids. If there’s a better source let me know please
@@washingtondale Ceding? Wow. Mexico didn’t give up its territory. They fought but the massacre was too much and after almost 2 years Mexico was forced to “sell” part of its territory about 1/2 of it
This Battle has been documnted by Mexican Historians at nauseam. Unlike this video They point to sources and eye witness accounts that describe a different account of the battle. Please list your sources and let us find the truth
@@historyourheritage Funny how you people use your former property against us then give them our land and call us foreigners. Do you know how many Mexicans were hung in Texas by Germans?
For some reason comments are not showing up on the page but are showing up in the notification section. Thank you to Arnesto Quintero for your comment "Came back, still the best history Channel. Salutes sir." 3 days ago
Ni carrizal, ni Villa Fuero de paseo nomas, como dice Villa Que pensarían esos gringos tan patones que con cañones nos iban a asustar di aquí tenemos lo mero principal, huevos.
I'm not sure what you are trying to say. I don't speak Spanish so I have to use Google translate. However, thank you for your interest and your comment.
Thank you for your comment. From my research , granted it was from the U.S. side after action reports and U.S. Newspapers, the indication was that the Mexican side shot first. The American command did force the issue by continuing on his course instead of skirting around Carrizal.
@@DarkBowserr we all know the intention was to go all the way to the west coast. And even at the beginning of the 1900’s they continued the expansion and invaded Hawaii
ruclips.net/video/e9WecxD8rc4/видео.html The Mexican perspective from the historian Paco Taibo, Hopefully it will serve to learn that we are neighbors, and we must have a good coexistence, help each other, and have special considerations for Mexicans who wish to settle in stolen territories.
"Hopefully it will serve to learn that we are neighbors, and we must have a good coexistence, help each other..." My feelings a well. Thank you for your comment.
Thank you for your comments. I am sure the other side of the border has a different take on this issue. It would be great if you could give perspective for the other side. Most American's don't even know about the punitive expedition let alone Mexico's side of the story. Also, I'm not a fan of the Vera Cruz occupation or President Wilson policy towards all of Latin America. Thank you again for your comment.
Thank you for your comment and your interest. Yes there were a lot of civilians on the Mexican side shooting across the border. Private Klint's recollection does give credence to the alleged fact that Mexican troops were involved. The real hero of this story is the Mayor of Nogales, Sonora, Felix B. Peñaloza. He braved gun fire to stop the killing to save the town. He gave his life for both Nogales. That is something that should be remembered and honored, on both sides of the border not just in Mexico.
Será el sereno pero México siempre trato de evitar el conflicto , pero los gringos querían probar el armamento que llevarían a la primera guerra mundial y al no encontrar a villa provocaron intencionalmente al ejército mexicano , y recibieron por ello una clara derrota por parte de los mexicanos, que por cierto el pueblo del Carrizal debe ser considerado heroico ya que cuando caía un soldado mexicano un civil tomaba su arma y luchaba, aún así México siempre actuó de buena fe, incluso regreso armamento decomisado y prisioneros.
Viva México Cabrones!!!!
Thank you for your response. Since I don't speak or read Spanish, I had to use Google translate. You have given an interesting insight to the Mexican side. I will be doing a video on the battle of Nogales shortly would be interested in hearing your take on the battle.
Google Translated version: Gracias por su respuesta. Como no hablo ni leo español, tuve que usar el traductor de Google. Has dado una interesante mirada al lado mexicano. Haré un video sobre la batalla de Nogales en breve, estaría interesado en escuchar su opinión sobre la batalla.
Never forget who is on stolen land
Thank you for your comment
every person in the world sits on land which has changed hands by force - Mexico more than the US.
@@washingtondale Mexico is the result of Spanish people seeking independence from Spain. Mexico’s existence is younger than the US. 1821 vs 1776
@@mike125520002000 it’s hard to find stability in the Mexican state prior to ceding the Northern Territory to the US. Mayans, Aztecs, conquistadors, various governments that could not even stop commanche raids. If there’s a better source let me know please
@@washingtondale Ceding? Wow. Mexico didn’t give up its territory. They fought but the massacre was too much and after almost 2 years Mexico was forced to “sell” part of its territory about 1/2 of it
This Battle has been documnted by Mexican Historians at nauseam. Unlike this video They point to sources and eye witness accounts that describe a different account of the battle. Please list your sources and let us find the truth
The sources for this video are at the end of the video. Thank you for your comments.
Osvaldo - one problem is my sources are in English. I would love the Spanish or Mexican perspective (sincerely asking u for references)
@@historyourheritage Funny how you people use your former property against us then give them our land and call us foreigners. Do you know how many Mexicans were hung in Texas by Germans?
For some reason comments are not showing up on the page but are showing up in the notification section. Thank you to Arnesto Quintero for your comment "Came back, still the best history Channel. Salutes sir."
3 days ago
Ni carrizal, ni Villa
Fuero de paseo nomas, como dice Villa
Que pensarían esos gringos tan patones que con cañones nos iban a asustar di aquí tenemos lo mero principal, huevos.
I'm not sure what you are trying to say. I don't speak Spanish so I have to use Google translate. However, thank you for your interest and your comment.
Jamás subestimen a México
You got that right brother. Thank you for your comment.
I'm working on a new video the Battle of Guerrero. It should be up in about a week.
Why do lie and say that the Mexican soldiers shot first? Mexico did everything they can to avoid conflict.
Thank you for your comment. From my research , granted it was from the U.S. side after action reports and U.S. Newspapers, the indication was that the Mexican side shot first. The American command did force the issue by continuing on his course instead of skirting around Carrizal.
@@historyourheritage thanks for sharing
@user-ni6ht7xo3i the US wanted to keep expanding and created motives to start a war
they fired a warning shot but the americans kept coming
@@DarkBowserr we all know the intention was to go all the way to the west coast. And even at the beginning of the 1900’s they continued the expansion and invaded Hawaii
ruclips.net/video/e9WecxD8rc4/видео.html The Mexican perspective from the historian Paco Taibo, Hopefully it will serve to learn that we are neighbors, and we must have a good coexistence, help each other, and have special considerations for Mexicans who wish to settle in stolen territories.
"Hopefully it will serve to learn that we are neighbors, and we must have a good coexistence, help each other..." My feelings a well. Thank you for your comment.
Who has the military might gets the land. Is not about feelings lol
Thank you for your comment.
The other side of the border says a different story
Thank you for your comments. I am sure the other side of the border has a different take on this issue. It would be great if you could give perspective for the other side. Most American's don't even know about the punitive expedition let alone Mexico's side of the story. Also, I'm not a fan of the Vera Cruz occupation or President Wilson policy towards all of Latin America. Thank you again for your comment.
@@historyourheritage the battle was in equal cirmcunstances...200 men against 200 houndred men mostly, and mexicans won it...this battle.
They weren't Mexican troops they were civilians.
Thank you for your comment and your interest. Yes there were a lot of civilians on the Mexican side shooting across the border. Private Klint's recollection does give credence to the alleged fact that Mexican troops were involved. The real hero of this story is the Mayor of Nogales, Sonora, Felix B. Peñaloza. He braved gun fire to stop the killing to save the town. He gave his life for both Nogales. That is something that should be remembered and honored, on both sides of the border not just in Mexico.
Sorry, I thought your post was for the Battle of Nogales Video.
@@historyourheritage it’s the battle of Carrizal not Nogales