What happened to Swati Maliwal at Kejriwal’s residence? | Faye D'Souza
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- Two opposite accounts have come to the fore after the former chairperson of the Delhi Commission of Women, Swati Maliwal claimed that she was assaulted by Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal’s aide at his residence last week. The Aam Aadmi Party’s version and CCTV footage portrayed a different story. Faye D’Souza dives deep into this unfortunate incident and separates lies from truth.
#SwatiMaliwal #ArvindKejriwal #AamAadmiParty #BJP #elections2024 #newdelhi #manishsisodia #raghavchadha #FayeDSouza #Beatrootnews #indianews #politicalnews #aap #aapdelhi #elections2024 #loksabhaelection2024
For more news and updates, download the Beatroot News App:
www.beatrootne...
Follow Faye D’Souza on Social Media
Instagram: / fayedsouza
Twitter: / fayedsouza
Facebook: / fayedsouzaofficial
And suddenly everyone forgot about Prajwal Revanna.
exactly. now biggest sex scandal of revanna is side tracked ..i believe after election results he will come and case will move forever atleast he will say all videos are fake
There is CCTV footage that clearly shows she was arguing and misbehaving and left the premises on her own with no signs of limping or being assaulted.
She is clearly making things up because her own statements don't add up. Women like swati are the ones who play the victim card and file false charges against men misusing the law for their own personal vendetta. If she was assaulted as badly as she described in her complain then what about the CCTV footage that shows her exiting the CM's house appearing completely fine and not limping but later she said she was badly hurt and was limping. She is just saying all the BS to make it a political issue
Good case for this lady to be arrested for lying?!
@@uurk5lo4 that wont happen even she lied bjp is back of all this drama
It is possible that the cctv footage shown by AAP is before Swati was assaulted. It's not full footage till Swati exited the building.
@@Reason_And_Feminism it is full footage of her exiting the building and unless you're saying that she forced her way into the compound again after being kicked out of the CM's house, there is no way her story is 100% true. But I doubt you will think about it logically since you seem like a feminist (judging by your username)
If this is the case then why did the mobile from which that video was recorded be formatted? Why was the CCTV footage deleted?
I think the plot is to get Kejriwal’s personal secretary arrested as they couldn’t break Kejriwal.
Kejriwal is Sarab chor like Bihar’s chara chor.. both have retained fraction of their voter base.. but most of his voters have already left them!!
Couldn't break Kejriwal?? Are you for real?🤣🤣 That guy is the epitome of lies, cheats and deceit. His own mentor says it. He is out on f**king bail. Criminals get out on bail. Wake up and smell the coffee.😅😅
If this is the case then why did the mobile from which that
video was recorded be formatted? Why was the CCTV
footage deleted?
@@pareshkamaliya1638 There are strategies that parties develop for elections. They discuss those, and then there are people who visit them or come to donate funds. Or take help. All those get exposed if everything is shown. Kinda, person who comes to donate maybe troubled. Or asked to donate to the other party. etc. That is the reason most of the cells and CCTV recordings are formatted periodically. I bet even BJP does that.
She must have been promised some huge amount by BJP to defame Kejriwal by meeting him in person. She however could not succeed and hence the Tamasha.
Lol strop crying and ik you hate bjp cope with it
@@Babayagaom Nobody hates BJP...just that everything is being mismanaged....we gave huge sum to China for INSTALLING Patel statue, and another astronomical sum for Statue of equality....even as we lost our senior army official at Galwan....we have sold away LIC.... and will be selling other PSUs too. Tell me, do you buy assets like house? At least aspire for it? Likewise, country should have its assets. Instead of privatizing, why can the government establish a benchmark system, and hire and fire system so that the public sector also starts improving.
She is trying to ditch AAP. Mark my word in coming days she will be one of the turncoats.
Swati Maliwal is no where saying why she is going there without an appointment. Why is she not coming out with why she is going to the residence when he is just out of an ordeal. Beyond any understanding. Now she is talking to the media that is all pro BJP . Her sweet language is not what she exactly used in the drawing room.
She is very senior in her public position and the party ranks to meet the CM Arvind Kejriwal even without appointment especially if the matter is of importance.
@@Subuhi61that’s not the question , the question is why? As in , what was the specific reason to visit on that particular day. Visiting is not inContention at this point, it’s the reason for the visit and the incident thereafter.
Like actor Govinda says in a branded vest commercial ( location inside a crowded Mumbai local ) to a man complaining of having being shoved : "mana hamne dhakka dhiya magar aapne liya kyun" !! 😂😂
@@Subuhi61 then how come guards said to leave and she mistraeated them with unparlimentary words
@@Subuhi61maliwar didn't paid any heeds it seems, when kejriwal were at tihar jail 😂😂😂
Thanks for the breakdown. But no one asks the question, why was she there? Did she visit on a personal capacity? Answering that question will also reveal a lot.
Maliwar visited cm house to ask money for campaigning,but cm never trusted her maybe
Questions should be asked is why did the mobile from which that
video was recorded be formatted? Why was the CCTV
footage deleted?
This was asked to Swati, but she refused to comment saying the matter is sub judice.
Her status is of an MP and he is a mere PA. He has no business to even talk aloud with her although after seeing the videos and she sounding bossy, I doubt she was physically assaulted!
Disagree. The job defines the authority. Outside the Parliament in somebody else's premises she has to behave as told by the people in authority there. MP cannot dominate people in hospitals, or in Prison. Exactly like that, MP needs to follow the rules of Kejriwal in Kejriwal's house. I agree, she was sounding bossy and as if her ego is hurt.
Of all the issues in the country, a fight within a party between two members has now got so much airtime.
May be air time for Modi got reduced!!
😂😂@@tsrini68
@@tsrini68 Worth it, don't you think? At least TV anchors and Swati Malewal are better looking than Modi, even if Modi wears new clothes everyday. LOL
Well... if Ms. Maliwal joins the BJP in the near future, we'll know exactly what happened, and why. If not, for obvious reasons, one can expect the most rigorous investigation by agencies.
Heads mai jeeta tails tu haara
If this is the case then why did the mobile from which that
video was recorded be formatted? Why was the CCTV
footage deleted?
@@pareshkamaliya1638 did you not read my comment? or did you not understand it? Isn't it what I said, if she joins the BJP, no explanations will be needed. But if she doesn't...the agencies will do a thorough job, which includes finding out why data was wiped.
She won’t join BJP
She will lose her RS MP seat if she joins BJP
She will be within AAP and give headaches to AAP leaders
More than 50% of AAP will join BJP or stay independent in the coming years
When will Police arrest the Swthi Maliwal accused of illegal recruitment case registered by the Anti-Corruption Branch?
She was working for Kejriwal.. one more case for which Kejriwal should be arrested
They won't as BJP has sealed the deal already. Washing Machined already.
Balanced analysis. We have to wait to know what happened at the CM's office and why is the AAP in a state of confusion. Raghav Chadda's silence adds to the mystery.
Her walking shows the real truth.
I will not believe BJP police in Delhi.
Delhi police is also complicit in this because they are responsible for allowing her into CMs house.
Faye is amazin, great job💐
Faye is like WhatsApp aunty.. she is padri version of Arfa khanum!!
The very best coverage of the incident. Absolutely unbiased spot on. Great work.
Whether it has any effect on electoral outcome only time will tell.
Shame on you Swathi Maliwal. She will join the BJP soon
You don't have any right to question on manipur
So she was hero of AAP before but now suddenly she become villain to you?
Bjp/Modi will not make her member after seeing her behaviour
Criminal conspiracy in this case to lower down CM
Hi Faye I was just watching your video on Maliwal. I wish to tell you that the quality of audio is not good. The voice volume goes up and down. There is a slight echo which masks clarity. I think you can do something about it.
She is lying, she gave an interview to prime mouth piece of bjp ANI; nothing else to see here
She's rs mp from AAP if she's from bjp why she hasn't resigned yet from AAP or why kejriwal did expel her from party?
@@Rahul_k532use ur common sense before speaking. It's not a good timing for her to resign right now. AAP will definitely use that to their advantage in case she resigns and her case would crumble. Besides if she has plans to side with bjp, it's better to not resign and create ruckus within the party so bjp can say aap doesn't respect women in their own party. It's complex politics. Also why will kejriwal expel her? We don't know if the case is right or wrong. Plus Swati has been with aap for very long. Expelling her will only be used by bjp to say app is anti women.
@@teamgogreen5504 wow...in brij bhushan case he's wrong and all the atheletes are right but in maliwal case there are two versions... don't tell me how to use common sense...first you clear your backyard then come for a debate
Why did she go to ANI and look at the sympathetic interview it is. Why not Ravana case and the many who were abused ANI come out with that like a serial. Your views will be in millions.
@@sabinaabraham7088
Coz Ani is leading media here ,maxm media have contract with them that's why whether it's godi media and pappu media always used Ani clip..
So through Ani,she story can penetrate the maxm level ...
Otherwise if her interview was aired in pappu media ,even other media can't used that interview clip coz of copyright here..
So Ani is better option rather than opting any other channel whose views r restricted to their viewers only.
😂😂😂what really happened is clear. She tried to ditch AAP arvind kejrewal and unfortunately she fail..what an actor bhajpa had introduce..
This is the reason because of people like you bjp does politics
Dude coz of people like u opposition r not introspecting their misdeeds..
If anyone arising mistreat against own party worker,then it should be the party duty to rectify the misfortunates under the table,so that opposition should not get any clue and positioning them vocal against and play politics over it ....
But not instead of acknowledging the misfortunates they r still blaming opposition.
Remeber if u're not going to introspect party work culture then u ll only the members who remains left in the party..
This is not a first incident that took place in AAP ..
Just googled how Yogendra yadav and Prashant Bhushan,Pro.Anand Kumar were assaulted by AAP bouncer in party general meeting
That too with whom those were the founding members of AAP..
We'll probably never know the truth !😢😢
Sanjay Singh in his statement had said "abhadrata" hui which means indecency in hindi. This was before Swati's FIR came out in public domain and based on hearing one side of the story i.e Swati's. Big mistake on Sanjay Singh's part. But doesnt mean that he actually admitted to all the details in the FIR. If some1 was beaten up like she said she was, they wouldn't be able to walk out of the house the way she did, all the way to the police station.Matter should be investigated fairly not with a bias that because a woman is complaining it has to be the entire truth.
There is her version of the truth , there is his version of the truth and then there's is the truth. Truth always has 3 sides.
@@blueheaven4838 Agree and then there is the fourth factors i.e timing. Am I to believe that a man who is out on interim bail, will ask his PA to beat a woman black and blue in his own official residence and that too a week before such an imp election? Who is gonna benefit from this whole fiasco? Not him or his party for sure. Then why? He might have gotten rough with her which is wrong but the details in the FIR seem exaggerated and motivated.
@@vaishalibasu7028 valid point. But you know this could be loss of control by his P.A. without kejriwals knowing
@@blueheaven4838 That's what I am saying. She was there without appointment and then breached security to get inside the residence. The way she is seen talking to the security shows her high handedness. If there has been manhandling it doesn't seem unprovoked. But pushing and shoving which could have well happened from both sides, doesn't amount to the kind of assault she has reported in the FIR. Proof is the way she was seen walking out of the CM residence perfectly fine. If she was beaten up that badly, why didn't she go for medical examination the same day? why not file FIR the same day?
Neither Sanjay Singh nor Arvind Kejriwal admitted that Maliwal was assaulted, only said that she would be redressed.
very good analysis faye ji
Why did you do medical after 3 days
It seems a bit fortuitous, doesn't it.
First off, you don't usually get to meet the party boss without an appointment.
But i digress.
She goes over and for some reason this dude comes out, and, what's a good euphemism, decides to for absolutely no reason unleash his inner Selmon Bhai upon her. Selmon Bhai usually only does this to his girlfriends, and clearly they're not dating.
Now, I've been on the receiving end of a few thrashings myself and been witness to a few others.
(Needless to say I don't condone any violence against anyone.)
One of the first things when you get slapped like a bag of rice at the grocery store, is that you're quite disoriented.
Then, as your wits begin to return you get out of the place. Anyone who is going to assault you might also decide 'in for a penny, in for a pound', and decide to do worse.
You get the hell out of there. You probably might even go straight to the police station.
She apparently sat around waiting for cops and didn't seem very bruised or anything when it ended.
And when she did decide to talk, it was to ANI, a news agency as believable as Selmon Bhai's alleged virginity.
The party is off guard because nobody saw this coming.
If and when she's proven to be a liar she will set back whatever miniscule amount of progress in women's rights that has been made since the days of her braving the water cannons after the Nirbhaya case.
They got to her when she was out of town.
Retire, cash out, bugger off to a foreign country, and if fate wishes she could always come back. If not the outrage eco system and party payoffs could always support her.
Well articulated reasoning
The other important aspect of the cctv footage being deleted at the CM’s office seems extremely shady. Mustn’t be missed.
I am still confused please someone give me a clear timeline.
Very sad if a lady has been assaulted.
After seeing the video of Swati Maliwal, I am convinced she is trying to frame AAP, the way she talk in the video she doesn't looks like she just got beaten Black and Blue
She is trying to introduce a new case to augment her case by telling that she was in period
The title of the video promises more than it delivers
How the word 'abhadarta' translated as assaulted in English. Feminism broadened the definition of assaulted and now argument over disagreement with women become assaulted which can be punished as a sexual offense. Western copy paste of Feminism ruined even the Indian justice system.
Why Swati is so important at this juncture just kicked out from the AAP
Comprehensive analysis, thanks for sharing. Well researched.
Ms Dsouza, you completely neglected to mention how Mr Kumar also tried to make a FIR and give his side. But this was not accepted by DP. Infact if you look at the investigation, there are questions raised because this was a pushed by DP and women's cell head even before Ms Maliwal registered and FIR.
In this case please remember the woman is the position of power. Not the man. Just because she is a woman hence she should be right, is very biased.
No rift in the party. People who don’t have the grit and honesty to stay don’t stick .
She has the most incredulous version of the story. She was using insanely foul language and belligerent behavior against Bibhav, who was admirably polite with her. Going by her version, the guy just snorted something and turned into a vicious monster suddenly and hit her. Then went back to nicely escorting her outside in another video. How naive can one be to believe this horsetrash.
You are like a breath of fresh air in the media space . A big thanks for keeping the beacon of journalism lit !
And how promptly Delhi Police n LG hv acted!
Maliwal is also leaving it to the authorities to do a thorough investigation..
she mentions she was slapped 7 8 times and the hit with legs on back and stomach
i don’t think a normal can walk straight if gets hit this much and will be in bloodshed
but she is seen fighting with security in the video
some things are notmatching up
hi Faye - Sanjay Singh did not say that an assault had taken place. Please listen in to what he said ..
Since, BJP couldn't hold him in jail , targetted Kejriwal's PA who has details of Kejriwal's election campaigns.
The heading should have been “What happened to Swati Maliwal before coming to Kejriwal’s Residence”
Shameful comments section.
Good summary of the various news on this topic.
Regarding your conclusion, that AAP does not have a strategy for this. It seems that you expect that a party will have a strategy for every kind of issue that can potentially come up. Something like a rule book or book of guidelines which everyone in the party will have to memorize. I think that AAP and Kejriwal has handled it quite well. The two clips of Swati Maliwal and also of her not registering a fir on the same day is raising a lot of questions on her. Also the language that she used in the video was very unbecoming of her as a public figure.
It is true that the real nature of a person comes out when the cameras are turned off.
She is joining BJP
But she's a known certified Drama Queen... not the first time her throwing a fit, no?
She struck a deal when Kejriwal was in Jail..in the meanwhile the BJP worked on this lady ...to create some issue .She needs to be investigated inside out ...I feel there's more to the eye...so these BJP freaks have Delhi Police etc under their control and directly under HM and LG...so it's perceived that these BJP guys just can't lose Delhi ..u must understand that it's a Lok Sabha Elections...and the alleged victim is playing to the Gallery without naming her back up supporter...If she is silent on the real facts..BJP is behind all the waiting room and every drama etc...Thats why BJP will be gone in Delhi for the 4th time...
Right.
But how will the thief order investigation on himself? 😂😂
yes
Bullshit...she is clearly seen abusing d PS Kumar...n seen coming out of CM office without any injury ..sold out to bjp.
It looks fishy, any assault is definitely a punishable offense.
But if she lied about this, it is a punishable offense, she would have tried to get someone arrested based on lies.
What about Sanjay Singh's press conference??
😂😂😂 Were is the CCTV footage?? All footages were deleted, who deleted it? MCD is under AAP... Mobile phone was formated and what about medical report??
2:26 And you think BJP will say as you please my lord. It is a political party it will certainly do politics in other parties internal issues.
I think kejriwal dodged a bullet (metaphorically )by not meeting her . But aap threw the PA under the bus if what atishi said is true.
The matter needs to be investigated. If there's been an assault then Kejriwal must take necessary action. Definitely BJP will use this issue.
I'm surprised at the fact that she chose the least credible journo to do a podcast with!
It's frame ,soon she will join bjp with fanfare
Sanjay singh didn't confirm anything
Swati , please give an interview to Karan Thapr and answer his questions. Otherwise people will not believe.
The way faye D'Souza reports non bjp related news vs bjp/modi related news is soooop different 😂
Faye, you wre a true journalist. Unfortunately our indian citizens didn't liked her struggle towards facts...
I stay away from AAP's political domain and do not have skin in the game.
If I can take a stab at describing AAP's game plan, I'd say "Smoke and Mirrors"; they make accusitions and attempt to make quick gains. It may seem juvnile at times but it has worked for them.
This incident makes me feel that AAP has gone t a self destruct mode, may be they may as well make-up to each other !
thank you for compiling all the information
She was send as a predator or a traitor to Kejriwal‘s home without prioe appointment.
Attention seeking politics. One gets arrested the other claims victimisation too. Pathetic!
I feel like what swati is saying is true. But what AAP is saying is also true, about this being BJP's ploy. The BJP could've bribed the PA and told him to assault Maliwal, so as to create an internal rift in the party; because now that he got bailed and could campaign for elections.
The mere fact of the destruction of the very crucial CCTV records at the CM's residence itself is a good indication of something bad / incriminating having happened at Kejriwal's residence if not also of Kejriwal's involvement in this murky matter.
Do you really believe this story Swathi is spinning?
This woman seems to be full of lies. It is very sad. But she should not be given any support.
What a bunch of jokers.
Swati Mole-wali is the mole of bjpee. So it was just collateral damages.
Don't try to twist Sanjay Singh's statement. We consider you out of Godi media
How superficial? You regurgitate what godi media. Said. Did not mention cctv footage where Swati is swiftly walking away out of kejriwal house? Why is it not clarified what the Delhi police staff did or say ? What does diary of the police say about cforciblee entry?
I had high regards for your journalitic objectivity.
I think , Kejriwal was targeted but the PS escaped him.
She is bjp's agent, soon to join bjp that's why all this drama. Shame on you woman.
Paid by bjp look like they didn’t make national issue of Manipur n wrestlers girls why it is made now it clearly show she was sent by bjp
who all agrees men's commission is needed
Where is the video showing her leaving the residence in police escort ?
She went and met the LG and spoken on a PODCAST of ANI.. she is being propped up by BJP ecosystem
Just give enough time for her to officially get into bjp.. then nothing is a mystery
Gone Girl ?
I don't think this is the complete picture or unbiased. You completely ignored the second set of CCTV videos, 3 CCTVs to be precise of the very same day in which she was walking perfectly fine while she was limping 3 days later, plus why did she file case after three days ?
Nothing clear after so many versions.
Do you think Delhi police, which work on Modi diktats, investigation will be fair and just? Delhi police, CBI NIA ED CVC or any other investigation agencies under Modi have any credibility.
Also .. you have chosen to not show the CCTV of her walking out of the CMs residence.
What kind of weed you people are smoking,she has a medical report from the aiims hospital showing injuries,so plz act like human being .
It seems she has nothing to report in the media?
I will not speculate about Swati Maliwal case. It needs to be investigated, cross checked and validated. Something has happened to Swati, that needs to be investigated. We might point out to conspiracy, but this is serious. Koi bhi dudh ka dhula nahi hai.
Sorry Faye this is not like you…u did not give your take on this… Somewhere even a novice one can smell a plot to malign Aap… she’s a stooge
Thought highly of you but this is really biased reporting....everyone can see her walking out uninjured
Swati Maliwal waits 3 days for everything... and is seen abusing CMs staff .. walking out briskly..and then gets the BJP support 😂😂😂
No, AAP chances will not be hurt.
People observe and quickly draw that 1+1 is 2
Why is this a major issue I dont know. There are million such abuses happen across all party lines (if at all such abuse has happened here) . Why is Arvind dragged to this. If this is the case then any Secretary or party member of BJP misbehaving with any woman should be linked to PM and he should be asked to answer!!
Poor sense of proportion , logic and rationale.
We can clearly see her abusing the people within Kejriwal’s residence in the CCTV footage.
AAP is confused as to what statements make. The senior leaders are refuting each other's statements. That is diabolical. At the fringes of a messy election for Delhi. Even the rumor of Chaddha not supporting Kejriwal can hurt and cause massive rifts in AAP. On the other hand Kumar's phone being completely formatted, the short clip releasing without context can really shift the narrative in Maliwal's direction and the way investigation and everything is headed seems like early signs of exit result for Maliwal from AAP. Complications that AAP would never would want.
Is She a liar
People like a MP of Rajya Sabha visit CM with appointment. Every official meeting requires preparation of mind.
The way Swati Mahiwal went to CM house shows her intention, to tarnish the image.
I think it's not going to affect, people also will wait for right thing to come out and law take it's own course and not to mix with ground burning issues of the country, they don't want to come into conclusions making reasons whom to vote, the present status remains as it is with Kejriwal's popularity!!!!!
Faye is like WhatsApp aunty.. she is padri version of Arfa khanum!!
Ok.
What then are you ?!
@@uurk5lo4 I am passing judgement on Faye -padri version of arfa.. just like she passes her biased judgement on others!
Though what exactly transpired at the CM’s residence (& in whose presence) may not be known anytime soon, a few things were deliberate on both sides:
1) Swati not wanting to give up her RS seat that easily, choosing to make a complaint to the Delhi Police knowing how it could be manipulated by the BJP, going to the CM’s residence without his consent (apparently), giving an interview to ANI/ Smita Prakash of all people doesn’t smell good at all but AAP jumped the gun and Atishi’s Press Conference blaming Swati & a BJP conspiracy gave Swati the freedom to go all out against AAP & thereby the interview & delayed FIR…BUT she had already made a call to the cops / helpline while still at the CM’s residence absolutely points at her ill intentions.
2) CCTV footage from the CM’s residence being wiped out was probably done to avoid Kejriwal being made a party to another “conspiracy” / case to embroil him in & he may have tried to pacify her after whatever happened but having seen it hadn’t worked, he needed to maintain silence so as not to lose his time out on bail (if he sensed all this as a conspiracy). Similarly Bibhav Kumar formatting his mobile may have other reasons behind it, it would have a lot of stuff to deal with Kejriwal’s connections to many people who probably connected to him through Bibhav and besides it also must’ve had some communications between Swati & Bibhav that he probably may not have wanted to be made public (it may or may not have anything to do with the personal lives of the two of them). The CCTV footage may have also been partly erased to avoid Kejriwal’s elderly parents or others in the family getting caught up in the web of “evidences” that Delhi Police was likely to weave or it would’ve anyway happened due to routine investigation, also the visit of many other individuals unrelated to this issue or which needn’t be made public (as per AAP) could have further caused problems for them or the footage could be leaked selectively (doctored or otherwise) once it’s in the control of the DP.
3) Initial statements by Sanjsy Singh, later on by Atishi we’re all made in a rush and probably wasn’t thought out so well & they were merely either wanting to look “fair” or were (later) convinced by the DP’s swift actions & the LG’s letter that the BJP was either behind it or was fishing in troubled waters.
4) Swati knows only too well what she can get away with (accusations by a woman & a cheerleader of women’s rights), mentioning about her menses or being kicked in the pelvic region may have been for added impact & gaining sympathies (highly deplorable if it actually happened or she was indeed assaulted, no matter what the provocation might have been)
5) What led to this whole fiasco has to do with Swati’s RS membership (which she clearly didn’t want to let go of), Kejriwal’s rush to get AM Singhvi to swap Swati’s RS membership since he was unsure of when he’d be able to get another bail could have escalated the problem which was probably encashed by Swati & the BJP (together or not, that remains to be seen)