Choosing Chords for a Melody: Part 1 -- Determine the Scale

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 окт 2024

Комментарии • 95

  • @VincentHauser
    @VincentHauser 5 лет назад +70

    These videos are like the golden nuggets of the internet.

  • @efkastner
    @efkastner 5 лет назад +56

    4:15 YES! Please! I've been trying for a long time to recognize the tonic and rarely get it right. That would be such a useful video!!

    • @baisustipas9857
      @baisustipas9857 5 лет назад +5

      i agree. there is definitely a demand here

    • @zacharyfox248
      @zacharyfox248 5 лет назад +2

      Practicing ear training on a site like Toned Ear would help with that. Try the interval training. A good app is also Functional Ear Trainer.

    • @NeoArch
      @NeoArch 4 года назад

      Yes Please! i honestly feel like i am peaking over the wall but just can't seem to jump over...

    • @lugaren7290
      @lugaren7290 4 года назад

      I second this.

  • @Archangel_Michaels
    @Archangel_Michaels Год назад +1

    BEST music theory channel on UTube !!!

  • @Archangel_Michaels
    @Archangel_Michaels Год назад +1

    I LOVE YOUR CHANNEL !!!
    Clear and concise with a sense of humor, thank your so much for sharing all your hard work. Music is a gift of God and you are an angel 😇

  • @dave1812
    @dave1812 3 года назад +1

    why the F did RUclips never recommend this channel until now!?! i love those videos!

  • @molotilkin07
    @molotilkin07 5 лет назад +38

    Thank you so much for your easy to understand and devoid of confusing vocabulary music theory videos. The distilled series really helped me start making sense of tonal content of music more than any other explanation even by my friends who are professional musicians.

  • @chessplayer6632
    @chessplayer6632 5 лет назад +36

    The legend has returned!

  • @isaiahbaker3597
    @isaiahbaker3597 5 лет назад +3

    Perfect balance of simplicity without dumbing down. This series makes me want to actually practice

  • @siddhantmalviya1590
    @siddhantmalviya1590 5 лет назад +20

    Happy to see you upload again!

  • @white-oak
    @white-oak 5 лет назад +15

    If anyone is curious why the note (major seventh) of the melody did not fit into Natural Minor, but was still used.
    Every melody consists of instablities and resolutions to those instabilities. And it turns out that those resolutions sound really pleasant to our brain. So the most powerful resolution in western music is half-step up to tonic (major seventh to tonic, or say B to C, or F sharp to G).
    The most common major scale actually has this major seventh in its harmonization and it allows for powerful resolutions when the melody is in major key.
    But the problem with Natural Minor is it doesn't have major seventh in its repertoir, instead having a minor seventh.
    So actually there is a minor scale that rises its seventh note by half-step turning it from minor to major seventh (B flat to B or F to F sharp). This scale is called Harmonic Minor and it lets us use the most powerful resolution again! Unfortunately, other harmonic features come with this little innocent rise, so you may still want to use Natural Minor. But! As shown in this video you can sometimes "borrow" notes from other scales for their prominent features. So you can say that the last but one note was borrowed from a Harmonic Minor to create this beautiful resolution to the tonic.

    • @JesseOrmandMusic
      @JesseOrmandMusic 5 лет назад +2

      There is also the Melodic Minor scale which has a natural 6 and 7 while it is ascending, and a flat 6 and 7 while it is descending. This is an extremely popular minor scale in classical music, and a really good example of it is Carol of the Bells.

    • @Ernthir
      @Ernthir 5 лет назад

      @@JesseOrmandMusic ndeed

  • @samuelkuchta2836
    @samuelkuchta2836 5 лет назад +140

    "Sometimes your brain knows more than you do"
    Wait, what?!

    • @Marcus538
      @Marcus538 5 лет назад +3

      Your brain is massive , your so called intelligence screws it right up , only way to solve this , is practice ,practice & more practice

    • @AesculapiusPiranha
      @AesculapiusPiranha 4 года назад

      Ask your brain. It knows.

    • @arturfijakowski1013
      @arturfijakowski1013 4 года назад

      It's about intuition and how You accept a sound of a note by your ear. If it feels right even when the note is not on your scale than it is still fine.

    • @DTux5249
      @DTux5249 4 года назад +2

      I mean, there's a lot more to your brain than your knowledge
      Your brain is the only reason your heart is beating, and you're not thinking about it

  • @rae.workshd5060
    @rae.workshd5060 5 лет назад +4

    I'm at the age of 26 and decided to pursue music, after everything I'm doing what i love. You make it seem doable. You are much appreciated Casey. Continue with the good work. Shutout From all the way from South Africa.

  • @ssajjess
    @ssajjess 5 лет назад +3

    You're doing an excellent job at teaching, I don't think I've come across another channel as clear and concise as you are. Thank you!

  • @javierbarron2122
    @javierbarron2122 5 лет назад +3

    Yes, please. I would love a "Find the root" exercise video.

  • @MC.CG3DArt
    @MC.CG3DArt 4 года назад +1

    Very clear trilogy! Super!

  • @jj987987987
    @jj987987987 5 лет назад

    for years I have been searching for this answer, thank you so much. I now worship you.

  • @SilverWolf340
    @SilverWolf340 3 года назад +1

    I got one of your audio illusion videos is my recommended and now here I am lol

  • @ponyrang
    @ponyrang 2 года назад +1

    Wow, I will always cheer for you in Korea I'm looking forward to a great video. Have a nice day.

  • @WhoCares_Official
    @WhoCares_Official 4 года назад +1

    You've helped Soo much with my guitar playing, I'm getting more confident on scales and muscle memory

  • @RizzlaTheCat
    @RizzlaTheCat 5 лет назад +1

    So glad your back! :) I really love the way you teach musical concepts! With that said, i dont grasp everything explained immediately, but as a "musicaltheoryslowgetter..!" your stuff reaaly helps! Thank you ! Peace!.

  • @iluvsyphonfilter
    @iluvsyphonfilter 4 года назад +1

    Awesome video, good job!

  • @Marcus538
    @Marcus538 5 лет назад

    These videos are hard work , but theyre bloody good - spot on

  • @DJUnderWaterExperience
    @DJUnderWaterExperience 5 лет назад

    Another brilliantly helpful and easy to understand video. Keep up the good work, as I have no doubt that your videos have been the lightbulb moment for hundreds of beginners.

  • @ThatPoyglot
    @ThatPoyglot 5 лет назад +1

    Very useful video! Thank you!

  • @whyte1010
    @whyte1010 5 лет назад +1

    Definitely interested in a video on identification of the tonic.

  • @tiresomeandy507
    @tiresomeandy507 5 лет назад

    These videos are great man

  • @John-ip7qo
    @John-ip7qo 5 лет назад

    You articulated the idea very well. Enjoyed watching this. God bless!

  • @nobbynose4254
    @nobbynose4254 2 года назад +1

    very helpful

  • @thomaskane9464
    @thomaskane9464 5 лет назад +1

    6:32 one notable exception is the blues scale which has three notes in a row a half step apart. This is especially important if you’re playing blues or rock. Great vid though!

    • @CaseyConnor
      @CaseyConnor  5 лет назад

      Yeah, good point. I'll add that to the errata.

  • @AKThem06
    @AKThem06 5 лет назад +1

    I always knew that the Piano Roll was the ultimate way of visualising music in this day and age
    although it might have some disadvantages that i can't think of right now

    • @augusto7681
      @augusto7681 5 лет назад +1

      I use piano roll to explain music on my channel too. I find it easier to read than regular score

  • @PumpkinIssues
    @PumpkinIssues 5 лет назад

    Your videos are clear and helpful ty

  • @kelvinpostaroo5770
    @kelvinpostaroo5770 5 лет назад +1

    I´ll learn more with that

  • @AbnerLopesNoggerini7
    @AbnerLopesNoggerini7 5 лет назад +4

    tks a lot

  • @blasramones4515
    @blasramones4515 5 лет назад +3

    4:15 Can You Make The Video To Find Out The Tonic!!!

  • @martinirecords9471
    @martinirecords9471 5 лет назад

    Nice bro I kinda developed that method also but u made it formal 😊 happy to see I came with a good workflow blessings.

  • @FlorissMusic
    @FlorissMusic 5 лет назад +7

    OMG YOU UPLOADED

  • @Nivenization
    @Nivenization 5 лет назад

    Thank you.

  • @鈴木ひろ-k9j
    @鈴木ひろ-k9j 5 лет назад

    Liked to bookmark as I will watch this later! :)

  • @casperado666
    @casperado666 5 лет назад +2

    Awesome

  • @artsandtechnology
    @artsandtechnology 5 лет назад +1

    You make me learn more than what school teached me ! thank you

  • @dlinnoedlinnoe
    @dlinnoedlinnoe 4 года назад

    Was that sequence at 6:45 the same as the beginning of 'Alan Parson's Project - Old and Wise'? Sounds the same.
    And many thanks for your videos!!!

    • @CaseyConnor
      @CaseyConnor  4 года назад +1

      Yep! Good ear. :-) And you're welcome, glad you like them!

    • @Archangel_Michaels
      @Archangel_Michaels Год назад

      @@CaseyConnor I LOVE your channel !!!

  • @eminem13001
    @eminem13001 5 лет назад

    Now I know that a scale which I knew it used 7 notes instead of 12 but I didn’t know there’s total of 12 notes but I also kinda knew the modes but I didn’t know that they add like a 6 note I do know it doesn’t sound different but you taught me more

  • @michealrodriguez1111
    @michealrodriguez1111 5 лет назад

    thank you so much

  • @leonardocassante
    @leonardocassante 5 лет назад

    you are incredible.

  • @JagritiPatel
    @JagritiPatel 5 лет назад

    Simply Awesome... thanks a ton ❤

  • @zoonk9198
    @zoonk9198 5 лет назад +2

    these are extremely helpful thank you I would fail my AP music theory class if i didn't watch these

  • @drewwoodruff742
    @drewwoodruff742 5 лет назад

    TONIC VIDEO!

  • @rabiulhasannayan8220
    @rabiulhasannayan8220 4 года назад +1

    please make a tonic identifying lesson ...

  • @shahirmaged3428
    @shahirmaged3428 5 лет назад

    amazing video

  • @eutytoalba
    @eutytoalba 5 лет назад +9

    "Just remember your brain knows more than you do."
    My brain KNEW this video would be helpful.... 🤔
    (LOL, well actually it is. 😄)

  • @XuprisingiinnocenceX
    @XuprisingiinnocenceX 5 лет назад +2

    How did you make the video's graphics with the highlighted notes?

    • @CaseyConnor
      @CaseyConnor  5 лет назад +5

      All the graphics were done in Blender, with some final editing in Davinci Resolve. The audio was made in Reaper, and I just set the tempo so it would match up with a 29.97 frame rate.

  • @brownsebastian1414
    @brownsebastian1414 5 лет назад

    You're music theory distilled videos are mind blowing. But one thing please be slow in English. We are not native English speakers. That would help us to understand the concepts very easily.

  • @thewest6128
    @thewest6128 5 лет назад

    Could you please make a video about borrowd chords?

  • @blasramones4515
    @blasramones4515 5 лет назад

    This Is So Fucking Good Man!!! Thank You And Make More Video Pleade!!!

  • @archymcfyre
    @archymcfyre 5 лет назад

    This is great, a question. If I have a melody or riff I have written on guitar, what program, or app could I use to visually display each of the notes to more easily figure out the scale? It is a bit tricky when trying to figure out the specific notes and their octaves when you are on a guitar with a non-standard tuning.
    Keep up the good work

    • @andrewfortmusic
      @andrewfortmusic 3 года назад +1

      You could use Musescore or Noteflight or any MIDI representation of notes. You could even download a tuning app on your phone so you know immediately what each note is.

  • @sandrabecht4489
    @sandrabecht4489 5 лет назад

    Vielen Dank aus Berlin

  • @Ferrichrome
    @Ferrichrome 5 лет назад +1

    these videos are like crack to me lol, please keep making them

  • @mayukhbera
    @mayukhbera 5 лет назад +2

    "Sometimes your brain knows more than you"

  • @RateOfChange
    @RateOfChange 5 лет назад

    I've always been able to come up with chords for a melody, harmonies, notes to that fit scales during solos and so on. But I know nothing about music theory nor do I have an absolute ear.
    Does anyone know how is that possible?

    • @CaseyConnor
      @CaseyConnor  5 лет назад

      My personal conviction is that 90% of the music made, even by people who know lots of theory, is not coming from an intellectual place, but rather a deeper, more primal level of the brain... in the same way that we might know lots of rules about grammar and sentence structure, but when we talk we're "just talking". Theory is useful for lots of reasons, but I don't think you need it to make music. For most of us it helps, though. I've met a few people like yourself who have no concept of notes or anything but still make sophisticated music... my theory is that you have developed some kind of "visualizations" (using that term very loosely, i.e. maybe they're not actually "visual" visualizations, but rather proprioceptive), perhaps semi-consciously, that help, but I'm just guessing.

  • @raphael2692
    @raphael2692 5 лет назад

    4:15 please do man that'd be great

  • @monk8935
    @monk8935 5 лет назад +4

    "There, now you know it forever"
    uhmmm...

  • @Ernthir
    @Ernthir 5 лет назад +1

    Try this with raag marwa. :D

  • @gavinlee6196
    @gavinlee6196 5 лет назад

    knowledge of the genre... anything on melodic folk metal

  • @wizard1370
    @wizard1370 4 года назад +1

    The chords' intervals have to make sense with the melody.

  • @devooski4751
    @devooski4751 5 лет назад

    The only skill, I've managed to take on another level is taking wild guesses lmao

  • @ivanbolatti
    @ivanbolatti 5 лет назад +1

    1.8 K likes, 16 dislikes. That's more than a 100:1 ratio.

  • @ExtergeoDesigns
    @ExtergeoDesigns 5 лет назад

    It's actually crazy this has so little views.

  • @saadb.binabraham7458
    @saadb.binabraham7458 5 лет назад +2

    why i feel like am inside the matrix ?

  • @gastonjabaly
    @gastonjabaly 5 лет назад

    Kind of complicated for beginners

  • @radhammashetty9756
    @radhammashetty9756 5 лет назад

    How to play song on piano by just hearing the song

  • @strawberrylimez
    @strawberrylimez 5 лет назад

    You spent 4 minutes on how to find the root note of the scale of your melody, people got time on their hands I see

  • @iF3nd3r
    @iF3nd3r 5 лет назад

    one person dislike because he/she couldn't understand...

  • @youJohn09
    @youJohn09 5 лет назад

    inshort use your common sense