First half of Cates run on this is pretty damn good. Halfway through it starts to drop off because Cates got into an accident and wasn't able to finish his run. They brought in other writers to finish up but it wasn't Cates vision. Same for The Hulk as he was writing that book at the same time as Thor.
Cates has some of best modern archs I’ve read, though I didn’t catch Cosmic GR. I need to upgrade from my TPBs to this “ThOmni”. Thanks for the review of a stellar run, Papa Mint! Hope that omni smells good! 😂
Same here, Never was a Thor fan but a co-worker of mine put me on to this run and i was hooked! Donny Cates writing is *Chef's Kiss* , combined with Nic Klein's amazing artwork.
Super hyped to get this Gem ! Thanks for the first look at this. And I totally agree with you Donny Cates writing always felt big and exciting. Very well said.
NIce personal history, Gem! 💎🔨🌩📚Three great ways to start! My first realization that Donald Blake was a thing (who fights Hulk, who fights Thor in MCU, I digress) was from JMS's run! So I finally understood that reference when time came in MCU Thor! And introduced to Donny Cates via his Venom run, and now THIS! Anything related to post- War of the Realms we need to know about? Yeah, his arc burgeons over time! That group shot, I want a poster! Dude, I'm excited for this Omnibus, man! LIke one story! The blurb and art in the back makes me want to dive in right away! Somehow it's like they "remembered" how to sell Omnis! Because it feels like you can dive in headlong, no prior exact knowledge* needed! Just from the look alone! *insert MCU Ragnarok GIF of MCU Thor going, (does) it though?? (At least I'm hoping that's the case!)
Man, I got hyped up just seeing you flip through this. Love anything Galactus and Silver Surfer, and have been wanting to check out Thor. I’m gonna have to break my only Star Wars omnis rule for this lol.
I had a problem with the artwork when i was reading it digitally. Not sure I’ll get this one. Is it good ? because i gave up on it Hey love that Kra Koom sound effect
Waiting for Cates to return , hopefully he bounces back. I don’t care for what Al Ewing has done with Venom, and I feel only Cates should be the one to add more substance to Knull. I loved this Thor run up until other writers took over and the new Venom stuff is like a repeat of what happened with Thor and Hulk and we’re supposed to just accept it as “what’s next” for these characters. Just my opinion, but things have gotten a little lame now and I feel we NEED Cates. Wishing him well and hope he returns with a bang.
If I didn't like Cates' Venom, Doctor Strange or Thanos (too fan fic for my taste, too many weird retcons and corny humor) - is there any chance I will like this? 😂 the art looks great and I like most Thor Ive read (even the older stuff, John Buscema's art on the Bronze Age stuff is incredible and there's some of my favorite Kirby art before that) Thanks for the overview, Gem
Everyone tries to sell Cates as the next great writer, but I’ve always felt he was overrated. Now that I have had some time away maybe I should give it a read.
First half of Cates run on this is pretty damn good. Halfway through it starts to drop off because Cates got into an accident and wasn't able to finish his run. They brought in other writers to finish up but it wasn't Cates vision. Same for The Hulk as he was writing that book at the same time as Thor.
This is my favorite kind of commentary from you, Gem -- your personal POV makes your reviews stand out. 👍
Cates has some of best modern archs I’ve read, though I didn’t catch Cosmic GR. I need to upgrade from my TPBs to this “ThOmni”. Thanks for the review of a stellar run, Papa Mint! Hope that omni smells good! 😂
Same here, Never was a Thor fan but a co-worker of mine put me on to this run and i was hooked! Donny Cates writing is *Chef's Kiss* , combined with Nic Klein's amazing artwork.
Nic Klein is a badass, he's killing it on the Hulk right now
I read a few issues way back with black winter story. Cates was on fire at the time. This omni looks great.
Anything with Cates on it I’m buying without a second thought
The omnibus for your Momulus! 🔥🔥🔥💎🐺
Totally unfamiliar with this run but got it on order as really keen to try it out and looking at your preview am glad I did. Art looks great
Super hyped to get this Gem ! Thanks for the first look at this. And I totally agree with you Donny Cates writing always felt big and exciting. Very well said.
Excellence, as always. Appreciate your work !
ayyyyy! My first members only video! Shout out to Mikey S for the sub! He's a real one.
🙌💎
@@BigRett 💎➕1️⃣ 🫡
NIce personal history, Gem! 💎🔨🌩📚Three great ways to start! My first realization that Donald Blake was a thing (who fights Hulk, who fights Thor in MCU, I digress) was from JMS's run! So I finally understood that reference when time came in MCU Thor! And introduced to Donny Cates via his Venom run, and now THIS! Anything related to post- War of the Realms we need to know about? Yeah, his arc burgeons over time! That group shot, I want a poster! Dude, I'm excited for this Omnibus, man! LIke one story! The blurb and art in the back makes me want to dive in right away! Somehow it's like they "remembered" how to sell Omnis! Because it feels like you can dive in headlong, no prior exact knowledge* needed! Just from the look alone! *insert MCU Ragnarok GIF of MCU Thor going, (does) it though?? (At least I'm hoping that's the case!)
I have heard a lot about this run, seems like a must have for sure.
Man, I got hyped up just seeing you flip through this. Love anything Galactus and Silver Surfer, and have been wanting to check out Thor. I’m gonna have to break my only Star Wars omnis rule for this lol.
Throg -> pre-order
Thanks for all your videos🎉
Im definitely looking forward to grabbing this one, my favorite THOR run🔥💯👍 but big props to Jason Aaron for setting up the bonanza 🔥🔥👏
Cates era marvel was so good. I hope hes doing well
Donny Cates is really talented.
Do you need to read the Jason Aaron run to enjoy this?
Not really, pretty sure it explains in the first arch that he’s now King… that’s all you really need to know.
This run made me buy a Thor statue for my office lol
This is a great story to collect
I feel that way about thor and still don't read a lot of thor
I need to catch up on this one.
The artwork looks badass
I had a problem with the artwork when i was reading it digitally. Not sure I’ll get this one. Is it good ? because i gave up on it Hey love that Kra Koom sound effect
I think i am actually going to be buying this one
I used to read Thor from around 2006-2011, think I liked it at the time, but can’t remember any of the stories.
I’ve only read the god butcher arc , do you think I can jump straight into this run ? Big fan of Cates !
Yes
Qué locura ❤
Donny Cates is a great writer.
one of the few omni's I'm wanting lately
Looks great
Yo gem apologies i know this is an older vid. Just wondering which are your top 3 Thor runs?
Cheers
Can You Order Pacific Rim: Amara (Vol 1)?
Yep i loved this run also
You sold me on this one.
Waiting for Cates to return , hopefully he bounces back. I don’t care for what Al Ewing has done with Venom, and I feel only Cates should be the one to add more substance to Knull. I loved this Thor run up until other writers took over and the new Venom stuff is like a repeat of what happened with Thor and Hulk and we’re supposed to just accept it as “what’s next” for these characters. Just my opinion, but things have gotten a little lame now and I feel we NEED Cates. Wishing him well and hope he returns with a bang.
Should i read jason aarons thor before this or can i jump right into it?
You can, it will pay off starting this run. But you don’t really have to. You can piece it together while reading this run.
@@GemMintCollectibles gotcha. was planning on grabbing the aaron omnis anyways so i guess I’ll hold off so this run is even better
I read them as came out. Fun read.
I think Cates was not able to finish his Thor run because of the car accident.
If I didn't like Cates' Venom, Doctor Strange or Thanos (too fan fic for my taste, too many weird retcons and corny humor) - is there any chance I will like this? 😂 the art looks great and I like most Thor Ive read (even the older stuff, John Buscema's art on the Bronze Age stuff is incredible and there's some of my favorite Kirby art before that)
Thanks for the overview, Gem
Cates was at a peak here and then started falling off….this was a great pick up after Jason Aaron but Aaron’s run was and is the best Thor run….
I hated his venom run. Is this different
Cates venom was venoms best run
@@deeem2628 i literally felt likeni was taking sleeping pills each issue
@tonycrown5155 why do you like your own comments for?
@@deeem2628 i must have hit it by mistake
Did this run end well?
I don’t really remember tbh. 1st 2 arcs were the strongest
Everyone tries to sell Cates as the next great writer, but I’ve always felt he was overrated. Now that I have had some time away maybe I should give it a read.
I miss cates Thor….
I collected the singles the run was ok nothing memorable in my opinion
Another run Cates couldn’t stick the landing 🛬 😮
I mean he got into a bad accident and got brain damage. Can’t really blame him.