Education Systems - US vs. India
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024
- Message from uploader (www.NRIconnect.com) about this video -
Education Systems - US vs. India. An interview with the maker of 2 million minutes (Compton) and the author of Teach Baby Teach. American education and Indian education have different approaches. Both are looking to further improve and this video can be a healthy starting point for thinkers on both sides (American or Asian). Lets keep the discussions focused on positive ways forward and avoid any mud-slinging.
Indians and Chinese have more motivation to succeed because they don't live comfortable lives and have to find a nice job to change that. Americans are spoiled with a comfortable life with lots of options for career paths that they don't take academics as seriously.
Well... I do agree that Jay did not see many creative indians compared to americans is because the opportunities for indians in india are very less. But that does not mean that education in india is poor compared to US. There are hundreds of thousands of talented students coming out of indian colleges every year. If everybody is given the same opportunity like american students, then India will become the top country in no matter of time. It is very sad to see that all these talents are utilized for the sake US development today. Indians can only blame the corrupted politicians and rulers...
+BRBallin1, very sensible comment. You work hard to achieve better when you live in scarcities.
you are totally right. though I live in America, I am foreign born student who recently moved from my country and I see students who has no worries about their future. my American friends have easy life, their parents pay their college fees or they take loans, but I work 35 hours a week take 16 credits, and still have higher GPA compared to them.
+BRBallin1 yes which is why they can't compete most Americans can't compete in the job market nor globally it's the western culture thats killing them in the market out there.
Pete: First thing first... use punctuation. Make use of those periods and commas.
I did my undergrad from India and I went to grad school in US, I can say I would still graduate from grad school right after high school without even going to undergrad program that's how easy education here is, but at the same time research and practical experience is way better here than in India(I think that's what makes higher education better in US)
Wind OfChange Nope you're wrong there's nothing wrong with education system, actually it's fault in goverment system
you won't get that much opportunities in india
@@axelblz6193 yes everything is government fault. A dog died on the street in front on my house. That was Modi's fault. He didn't came himself to give vaccine to the dog.
MATLAB KUCH BHI?
Sukrit Aggarwal you have no idea what you are talking, it's reality not blaming Modi nope not at all..
@@sukritaggarwal7136 he is not blaming modi ji but he is blaming government which was for 60yrs and didn't even tried to change education system , atleast NEP came now but it's time to get implemented.
@@sukritaggarwal7136 that was dumb tbh
....meanwhile in america kids focusing on makeup and partying
No Jessica, the students in America focus on business, medicine, and law among other careers. IT is not important for them or in society in the United States. Go to any college and see the how hard it is to get into business, medicine, law compared to IT field.
gopalltheway joke of the day. which traitor foreign funded NGO u belong
That isn't true. Not all of them are like you
well said
Trust me when I say the American education system is leagues better than India's. Atleast there, they make an attempt to nurture creativity. Here they try their best to kill it.
I accept one of Jay's points. Many Indians are creative. But the social system in India doesn't encourage creative people. In many cases, Indians are forced to do some jobs they don't like, to support their family. If an Indian shows a brilliant business or project idea and asks for loan, most of the time banks reject him.
Actually in india we people dont want to take risk of being creative, what i mean of being creative is that we become engineer we become doctor even if we top in the field we dont want to take risk of being the boss we just wanna play safe n get a job. no engineer tries to be Bill gates we just wanna get a job from Gates that's it. once a guy named Dheeru Bhai Ambani took the initiative to be creative nd started a mobile phone company nd now his childrens are the richest businessman in india. we are so afraid of all this.. thats all..
so indians just like to be selfish. Build up another country but not our own. help build mircrosofts but dont build an indian microsoft that can employ and empower indians.
the_truth_seeker yes yes
the_truth_seeker This is why Indians aren't Mark Zuckerberg and Bill Gates but end up as their employees
For all the comments below I would like to say just wait and watch. Irrespective of government support people have the zeal to grow. Raise of middle class is just enough to take on the world... Simple is what was your father and what you want your kid to be...
we Indians have so much competition an american university topper if comes to India he is going to come on last position in an Indian university I can bet money on that
Idk about China but as an Indian student we r encouraged to top our class or get high grades b4 we r encouraged to be creative or think differently.
Same here in the UK mate... it's not much different, I guess the creativity comes from outside classes.
I am so happy to hear that UK doesnt socially marginalized them as "nerds", "dweebs" unlike americans
same in Nepal
yea mate we have creativity but we neither get support from family nor govt the only thing which is valued is your grade no matter how much you were stressed before the examination
as indian students, we have think differently to success not because of highly dense compitition amongst ourself but also to get the status quo.
The math problems I did in 3rd grade in India, I was doing that in 12 grade here in states
Yeah you were doing Calculus in 3rd grade. Anyone would Totally believe that....
Great Wolf what? No, the average high school 12th grader would be doing algebra 11; or pre calculus. Come on dog.
+VegasStreetLights If Preet is smart enough to do 12th grade math in 3rd grade, then he should've been able to take Calculus like most above average students in the US.
No, people are doing linear algebra, ordinary differential equation, and multivariable calculus in 12th grade.
***** So I guess you guys study Sylow Theorems and Peter-Weyl theorem by the time you are in 12 grade in India if apparently you do Calculus in 3rd grade. What a joke and a lie on the face of it.
India shouldnt be proud of the fact that they are losing their top 10% classes to foreign countries with better colleges. They should be dishonored. If india had good colleges and better education, people of other nations would be flocking to India and that would show Indian dominance.
I cannot agree more , the H1B visa is made for that only , its like a discount coupon for people and they buy it , we should help and bring india to the top
I live in the US and my parents came here for that reason :)
thats dissapointing .. :-(
Im an american now. See thr thing is that the people who com here consider themselves american and america is an equal lqnd off immigrants so america is proud of all its workers!!
I just go an d comment on maby of these videos to show truth to the ibdians that make and view em
Bob is so right. Indian and Chinese students are very intelligent and hard working. They don't party or go on vacations. They study hard, get high paid jobs and become rich. Best thing Indians and Chinese are harmless people. Thumbs up
+Anju Ji still they dont get nobel peizes , still they work in big firms but cannot create big firms some dropout bill gates mark zuckerberg does that and they are rich beyond imagination, any take on that
they know how to leverage time and effort, they use these engineers to run their businesses. Americans- user, Indians-doer
andy murray Dude, not cool.
This literally made me think o that meme where obama gives a medal to himself. Anyone can mold a person into a robot but turning that same person into a creative human being is where lies all the work. And that, is where America is ahead.
How is dedicating your life to achieving money and your job by giving up your creativity, hobbies and dreams a good trade ?
Jay: please have a meeting with Google CEO microsoft CEO they both are INDIANS :P, they will tell you how creative and talented People are... i bet Jay haven't heard of IITs .
they are american Indians I think
+prabhakar kevat educated in India. born in India...america has given only jobs to brilliant minds.
and they have Indian passports as far as i know...
+prabhakar kevat No sucker, they are Indian-Americans, not american-Indians :p
+prabhakar kevat why, why did you have to abuse on the internet ?? :) anyways...Google their education, they received an education in INDIA, babe...INDIA !!
+Anup Bhatt
i didn't had any hard feelings ...
but that idiot abused me you see
The problem with the Indian education system in a nutshell: too much emphasis on rote-learning, too many coaching classes that teach students how to pass tests rather than think and process what they've learned. There are way too many automatons graduating in India. A fraction of bright and motivated students use the system to their advantage, but for the most part, a degree doesn't mean as much as it should.
Akshay Singh Jamwal I don't think there is any problem in Indian education system , but commenting cos u have Indian education...
Yes, you are absolutely right. Indians are one of the most scientifically illiterate people on the planet. They learn science in schools, and they believe religious BS, over facts. In US this is not happening, china is also much better. Students are learning for the exams, not for understanding reality. This is why India never produces Nobel price Winners, in science. All they produce is engineers (use science, but no clue on how..), not scientists. I met Indian "scientists" who thinks their gods can travel faster than light and stuff.
Paul V Barbar I'd agree to the point where you're talking about students and institutions teaching science, but the USA doesn't fare a whole lot better if you're talking about scientific literacy. 42% of the USA believes in young Earth creationism, for instance.You have similar statistics for climate change denial. I mean, look at USA's current President Elect. I think scientific literacy (or lack thereof) is a global problem. In the end, belief, anecdotes, stories, myths and legend generally trump scientific method in peoples' psyches. Ken Ham's creationist museum in Kentucky is run by a microbiology graduate... so believing in BS can clearly happen anywhere.
I'd also have to disagree about this being why India produces few Nobel laureates: India's best minds usually leave the country because there's a fantastic dearth of funding for science in India. For that matter, there's not a whole lot of scope for a life dedicated to academia either. There's even a term for it: "brain drain".
China is probably faring better, yes.
*****
In the US, among science students, the % of true science admirers are much higher(> 98%), because we teach science as science. In India, it's pathetic, that your teachers include a lot of religious BS as facts in the teachings.
Every country in the earth, including china,japan, Europe, Russia, former USSR states, and african nations, facing the so called "brain drain". Still a ton of European and Japanese scientists won Nobel Price every year. The problem is that, Indian government does not understand the importance of science, or they misunderstood technology for science. Your education system is not promoting free thinking and enthusiasm in students.
In china, they Promote Both Technology and science.This is why India never gonna top China..
Paul V Barbar sir I think you are wrong Indians do believe in science just look in to the research and development wings of any area you can see them and we do teach evaluation in school unlike most of the middle east countries and some of the orthodox Cristina missionaries in US don't.
Business is all about input and output! The US spends 5.6 % of GDP on education where as India spends about 3.6% of GDP. India's total GDP is 2,051,228 million US dollars where as the US GDP is 17,348,075 million US dollars which is roughly 7 times higher than Indian. on the contrary India has 212 million students versus 53 million students (the number is four times). The US kids get 28 times more money spent on their education (infrastructure wise) than Indian kids. Is the output propositional to input? That is what Bob Compton is asking Jay. The only difference between Jay and Bob is, Bob talks with content and Jay has mastered the art of talking for hours without any content like Indian politicians.
+Edwin Gnanaprakasam We may need to factor in cost of living too...
Fckin true👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Fun fact now it is changed india opted american education system and wanna invest 6% of its gdp
@@jayantkumar159 Whats the use? We have large population and a small economy (compared to America that is obv).
@@juice8431 d7umb
who's spelling bee champ in America for last 15 years
Deepank Yadav Haha !!👍
Vasu Srivastava I agree with you these stupid idiots won't understand that.
You know what happens when you think memorization is more important than creativity, huh, you know what happens?
You just made the list.
Deepank Yadav 😂😂
Deepank Yadav he might not have noticed,
yeah.. memorizing words is so helpful in long run... that's what my kid needs..
The fellow arguing about greater number of graduates and pass percentage in USA . Don't know about stats and data . But if u come to India just pickup and throw a stone in the air. Will probably hit an engineer or a postgraduate.
Literally its true bro
Iam an engineering student
And in one year iam gonna look for a job....and its really hard than i know
Exactly
😂😂
Very true
The reason is.
Population->Compitetion for survival->More effort in studies->Great talents.
The bald guy must have been shocked after Indians became the CEO of Microsoft & Google.
Well Indians have produced Tata and Dheerubhai Ambani.
india is shit compared to USA
Prashant Singh I don't think so, it's really hard to change the mindset of a racist, and this is coming from a racist
Doesn't really matter what education system you're in. Creativity comes by being curious and asking questions and solving real world problems. No one can teach you that.
Jay Mathews is one typical example of a person living under a rock
I am an Indian, was born and raised in India. well I think, we Indians are not good innovators,we lack innovation skills. we are more concerned about the conventional ways of education like getting a degree, and then getting a job. we are afraid to take risks, and this may be becuz we have limited resources or opportunities or and are burdened by responsibilities, so we prefer to take a safe route.Innovations require a kind of risk taking.you have to leave the safe path, and start your journey on a path that may not have been taken before. Most of the great innovators of modern day technology such as Steve jobs,Bill gates and others are Americans,they took risks, they put everything at stake and came up with things that no one had imagined.we have an education system which is good enough, but still needs to be improved. Yes we have billionaires like Ambanis, Tatas, Birlas..but they are not innovators, they are businessmen. On a global scale, Indians have proved themselves in almost every field, and its been just 67 years since we got our freedom, so we are doing good and can do better in the coming few decades. Now, the people are coming up with good Ideas,instead of being some one who is looking for a job, they are creating jobs for others.
+mindtwister24 true
I will agree, India has very less 'risk takers'.
we have it bro but we don't want to take risk
Chuck out reservations in India and India will be the best in terms of education.
i have never received reservations in my life becoz of being upper caste..but i want all the lower caste people to get reservation...becoz with the help form us and our govt poor people can also become the best ...dont be so selfish...we give free education to people who doesnt have money..what ever their caste is..upper or lower...its for good..one day we will end the reservations..but not now...
SYAM KRISHNAN.B i hope u know that reservation is cast based not income based or poverty ..
LogicalBot hmm! haha I am looking at these videos now 2015, hmm guess this is before Recession haha, otherwise USA can't have boasted like these
Dr.Aditya Dhawan First remove the caste system then.
Many people in rural areas are still treated badly
Saral Thakur u are really stupid
I am an American whom is tired of being apart of this statistic. I WILL become more educated and I WILL help make positive impacts to education.
+VegasStreetLights This is the most sensible comment!
+VegasStreetLights BEST OF LUCK!!!!
+VegasStreetLights hmm yeh u ryt
+VegasStreetLights wish you the best. Some Americans might not study afar but the ones that do go very far.
wow I am impressed with your comment.
Well I am an Indian, I have done my Undergrads from India and doing my post from the UK. What I have seen in the two system is that, in India if you are studying a subject, it is done in more depth than in the UK(and I am studying in a Uni tht is ranked 73rd in the world). Plus back in India during my undergrad, since I was doing IT, we could be asked a question from anywhere relating to that subject(at least in my Uni), but in the UK it is limited to wat is done in the lectures.
They are mixing up two very different things... Education in India isn't any better than education in the US (I am Indian and have seen both sides), its the sheer number of students that DEPEND on getting a job. The US has a social security system, and a social payout system that allows unskilled labor to live comfortably. INDIA does not have that. For most of us, if we don't make the grade, we don't get the job. For every job in India, we have over 100,000 job seekers competing. This makes us study harder - we study to survive.
It is also true that creativity and entrepreneurship were largely discouraged since they involve a fairly large amount of risk. The standard of living in India does not allow easy breaking into a new venture. Having said that, the situation has changed substantially in the last 6 years and we see people right out of college becoming job creators as opposed to job seekers.
The nations in question have remarkable CULTURAL, POLITICAL and SOCIAL differences and comparison of young children and their levels of education is unfair.
Yes Jay is ignorant but I, being an Indian, do see where he is coming from. Us asians are always pushed towards the sciences and never toward more "artsy" or "creative" pursuits. However I disagree with him in saying that the creativity is more important... science is everything.
Science is not everything. Imagination is what drive humans to achieve betterment.
+Yasmine Xo Science and Maths is everything. Think about it. You just cannot ignore Maths
+Yasmine Xo WITHOUT CREATIVITY SCIENCE IS 0
+Yasmine Xo ur wrong. engineering is all science and creativity. and not all science is everything. its more of engineering, comp sci, and physics. no one cares about bio and other sciences
I didn't mean that creativity itself is a bad thing I was referring to the more "Creative" subjects such as visual arts, music, acting, etc. Those things are of course GREAT and important but I think science (medicine, technology, etc.) is more crucial....
US education system + Indian student = 🔥
thats a cool comment really
Wrong.
Indian education system+US facilities=🔥
@@rahulsreekumar2562 👌
Both are bad, us system is just less worse as compared to india. Finland has a good system
I bet any american to join Indian institutes of tech kanpur or etc
for that u have to go through the toughest entrance exam
more harder is the IIT Delhi, I have crossed that Institute a million times on a bike and used to look at it, got into Cornell!
Nishant Sood : you USA MIT, Caltech, Cornell etc are IIT aspirants' plan-B ( back up plan) right. n most get in ...and with scholarship.
Nishant Sood : you know USA MIT, Caltech, Cornell etc are Indian IIT aspirants' plan-B ( back up plan) right. n most get in ...and with scholarship.
yes I know
rehne de bhai,gaand fat jayegi unki IIT ki tyaari karte karte
Indian education system is good for US companies as it supplies them highly skilled people for high tech and management jobs. But it is not aligned with India's political system, although things are improving now at a good pace.
See this argument is funny because they are both right, but there is a huge misunderstanding between them. The first guy is saying that the most educated people come from india and china which is right. The second guy agrees with him but is saying that the political systems in those countries does not allow creativity as much as the US. The first guy misunderstood that as the education system does not allow creativity.
I am Indian. Very few American firms (Facebook, Google, Goldman) recruits raw talent from Top Universities (India or America). They want people who provide plug and play skills in a particular sector / technology, but trained by other companies.
That is fundamentally non-meritocratic. Which is why they prefer Infosys 2 years experienced professional over IIT or MIT grad.
haha you are so innocent
Rajat Bansal "Kitna masoon hai tu" doesn't translate to "you are so innocent".. Bansal boy
+Val-schaeffer K but I actually saw this line on many sitcoms
+Val-schaeffer Anyways your claim is regarded with no proof and is very very wrong.
Rajat Bansal prove it. Most of the IT onsite guys are not hired directly
Great education in India? Joke of the year!
Santanu Ghosh I agree
Indian education system is Fucked* up
THE GREAT ONE bhai ghar ki murgi daal barabar hi lagti h !
Jo h usi m khushi raho !
People like Jay exist in every country and these are the sort of people who stops the growth of a country by simply being stubborn in denying the facts. They live with the dream of 'I am the perfect' , 'I am the greatest' , 'I don't need to learn anymore'
Even after 14 years, JAY is still right about indian education system.
After 10 yrs....things have changed...80% of us indian engineers are jobless or have no choice but to work unemployed....
The fact is that all good students of India and China want to go to the American Universities.
2022 and most of the companies CEO are Indians.THANK YOU ❤️
Pointless argument, they both kinda right.
Not everyone is creative(this goes for both the countries). Im studying in an Indian college. Some of my classmates cant even write a single leave letter(even by googling), and some of them are real talented in their own way. We have top colleges in some cities and some crap colleges somewhere else(in terms of innovative teaching, using the right tech, etc).
We have a national culture where people are attracted towards grade and raking system instead of real knowledge and researches, but hey, its not for all of them. This answers why some Indians are creative (they see the value of knowing and interested in learning more)
Since some creative people end up working in the US doesnt mean Indian engineers are top notch. The only difference I feel about the education system of two countries is that US students can be upfront and question everything they want to know, but in India, students are supposed to follow their teachers not asking why or asking too much questions(arguing with a teacher ends up in disobedience, not respecting, etc.) Thanks to the internet, it helps the introverts !
Education in India is far more cheaper than in the US. You get what you pay.
Coming back to the question, 'Which is the best education system ?'
You answer it.
That's what going on..
I am an American who has studied higher education in the US and India (earned a master's degree in an Indian college). There are merits and demerits to both educational system. No system is perfect. There are arguments that even the US system stifles creativity. Schools and colleges train people to be workers and OBEY a boss. The type of creative they talk about is entrepreneurship. There is merit in saying that true entrepreneurs get their creativity sucked out of them in college. Why did Bill Gates drop out of Harvard? There are different types of creativity. They did not have enough time to go into specifics.
I am an Indian, doing my grad studies in the US, and working for a software company. So I have seen both the education systems. India is in NO WAY inferior in education system to the US. Applying what you study is very different from studying. The quality of an engineer is in application, and the quality comes with experience rather than reading journals and books. Indian education system is far ahead of the league as far as the quality of math and cognitive skills development is concerned.
This is the main problem! Ppl like that who make bold claims without even being in the country once! There are smart ppl in India, China & all over the world! The only limiting factor is political biases and corrupt agendas! With so many ppl in India and China, it just gets noticed more often and thus ignored!
America is so good just bcoz Best of the World go to America. Eg Elon Musk.
Join the Trump University and all your problem in education will be solved for ever.
man r u serious
It's humor bro
That was also humor
You should join and see ! No one can explain this experience !
kalyug king jf,gvc
I'm from India and failed maths in 12th standard! Now I'm jobless!
No wonder you don't have a job. I mean who fails in boards exam
@@swarnadeepjosh6591 me
I`m an Indian and i tell u all my experience. I`m in class 12 and students who choose humanities and commerce are considered inferior than those who take science.And also"NO PLACE FOR EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITIES"-No sports,no dance/music. Those who do these stuff are considered out of their"TRACKS".(Parents:Are u mad dude! Go study don`t do silly stuffs).
If somebody dares to choose these careers(specially girls) then u will get these remarks:
Parents:No, Take science. No sports no games from now on wards.Become a doctor or engineer otherwise people will tease us for you.
Even i have faced these situations thats why im writing.
I completely agree with you. When i took humanities I was asked by many whether I scored less in class x. It was hard for people to understand that I wanted to study humanities and that it wasnt forced upon me.
I think American families should practice discipline. that will help the kids there to not drift away from focussing on what they are good at.
currently India is facing the problem of kids underperforming due to increasing over-liberal thinking. i think technology and luxury are main enemies but we cant shake them off... oh well. Practice self control. induce good habits right from the start. I think discipline is what is needed to conquer these problems nothing else.
+Draken Kartikay Kaul true but young generastion should also balance technology as well as good ethics so they can become intelligent and successful at the same time. if their parents schools and their communities educate them and have better influence on them starting from home young generations will be better human and half of society's problem will get solved
First thing first... use punctuation. Make use of those periods and commas.
Abhro J. Mondal Thanks for pointing that out, I will ensure to do so next time.
Draken Kartikay Kaul Sorry, I meant it for Pete Tapaskar :)
engineer says ur host is hot
The video is 240p
After reading the comment realized my engg degree is fake
OMG ..... I'm watching this video after a Decade 😅😅
Me too 😅😅
Well I had my bachelors in india and masters in usa.The difference which I observed most was that the edu system in usa is very scientific and gives you lot of freedom.In india , you have to wriggle out of all the barriers.So in effect these things made indian students more sincere and when they come in USA they become more creative than they were in India.....So in a sense we had it in a hard way than our american friends, but nevertheless they were gracious enough to accept us :) ....
Jay you are absolutely right about education system of India.
+Varun Sridhar leave india, take ur ass off. study in us.
Karan Kakkar trying for that. Do u have Any prob man, don't feel jealous, u can also try.
+Varun Sridhar lol .MATE, douce bags like you are no less then a Burden ON mother earth. jealous of ...You? go look yourself in THE mirror First.!
FYI, I AM ALREADY STUDYING ABROAD , SYDNEY. aur revoir
Bro the one who is burden on mother earth are criminals, we are just students how can we be a burden. Dont be so furious bro. sorry if i said something wrong above.
by the way in which field you are studying in?
We should serve our country and make it grow instead of growing a foreign country. We may go there to get modern education if we want and ultimately should grow our nation. We owe this much to our beautiful country. I cleared competitive xms to practice in a foreign country and serve their people, but I got enlightenment and stayed here and serving my people. I am proud
Proud to be an Indian ! I know that there are many opposition for our education system but our system is good only ! we just need a slight change in the way we carry out things ! I know my country would definitely shine one day !
Exactly but we need to have more of a problem based thinking and idea generating thing
If idian education is so good then why we're not devloped country India lags behind in research no intensional students comes to India to do research
The student competition b/w India and China is extremely very very high.
The reason for that is their population.
This video was released 18 days before Mumbai Attack.
India is the only country where we first become engineer and then we become what we want.
Thank you America for sharing that! You will not be spared.
That Jay is one big one racist !! lol.
disinformatique he's just ignorant fool, and that's what's happening to america right now.
disinformatique hahahaha.... He is in denial.....best part is... One question Jay..... Have you ever been to India? .....No Never been in India lolsss but I know all abt India lolss
disinformatique No he is not recist. He is just a nationalist who is sensitive about the whole situation and wants to defend it.
+disinformatique Basically Jay's worldview is:- There is a god, who handpicks the most talented people and puts them down in USA. Americans don't need no education, we were born "creative" and talented. While the smart people in other countries are dumb as fuck and they need our "creative" intelligence to utilize their brain.
(My personal view) More like they aren't dumb.. they are not allowed to exhibit what they can do as all you do is do the goddamned coachings for all the life. All for getting into IITs and then it's just amazing that when you expect the least work, there it storms the most. Americans are no way that "creative" they can just do whatever they desire, so long as they have the resources and the will to, while all we do is sit around waiting for when this college gets finished, go to the university, and when we attain university we grow senile and all the "Creativity" goes to hell. The MIT allows undergraduates and it never judges people by their age, (that's most important) but their experience. IIT segregates and forms up those bunch of people who are born doing coachings, they couldn't care less about what you have "creativity" or other bunch of crap, as they consider creativity and undergraduates as not "smart enough" they end up loosing their edge over the top universities of the world. While that's just how things go here, but not to point fingers on anyone, I don't mean any disrespect on american society. Sorry if I disrespect you guys in anyways. But we've got it all too tough unlike you guys. Furthermore, we appreciate you all allowing us to work with your companies, and in the future to, we hope to do so. Hope that explains how we're different, simply put we hold Maths from the day we are born while you hold Computers, that can and may be the best possible reason. And as to this whole idea of comparison, some sort of retarded minds must have thought about it, as we shouldn't compare the two as the conditions are way different.
I'm an Indian, and J is right. Our education system sucks, and it sometimes even makes me feel bad about being born in India. No expert can understand it, only the ones living in the country do.
I think even though Jay does not have much of a point here, but still the American education has been superior right from 1st grade. Being an Indian I go with Jay though, the Indian education does not encourage creativity as compared to American. Why it has become so difficult to find skilled labour, it's certainly the advance of technology that has made them lazy not not to strive hard enough than before(the transistor revolution , Internet )and also many americans are striving towards entertainment stream for their career. Indians do jobs not out of interest or curosity but for money which I hate myself. Any moron can build creative skills if it strives on the job via persiverance. If won't find any Indian doing expiriments or going out on a venture totally on its own curosity which is pretty much necessary to start a company.
+Sangram Jadhav couldn't agree more !
Indians are best
We made the cheapest mars rover possible, 40% population of nasa are indian, 45% population of microsoft are indian with us the whole computer industry collapse
Jai hind
Quality vs Quantity: Micoscoft hires, Nasa hires, Google hires: India may have had the cheapest Mars rover but not the firs! They are good followers not leaders. Nobel laureattes from US, 336, India 12 (5 Indians, 7 of Indian origin), Number of Olympic medals, USA 2522, India 28. It is nice and warm in the well and feel good but there is a big ocean outside. There is no comparision between India and USA, period.
lucky van u have lots of money to buy Olympic medals lol....🐯🐯🐯
lucky van calm down. India is a developing country. The British drained India of its wealth and has made it harder for the Indians to progress. Second thing is that we Indians are forced by our family to be on the safe side and either become a doctor or work under some big company. Our parents dont want us to take risk so we are forced to do what is told to us. We focus on making things better first, not to brag about being leaders or some shit.
lucky van Do you know Guglieol Marconi? People like to call him the creator of radio/wireless communication. It was not him though. It was Sir Jagdish Chandra Bose who was posthumously credited later. When he was asked to let the world know about his contribution, because he was the real inventor, he instead of being selfish for being credited was good enough not to do so.
lucky van does Olympic medals real matter though?
I have been a teacher in India and after coming here,I have seen my son's curriculum in America.....what I realised is Indian system of education is more "learning by heart"...or as we say 'by hearting everything" ,as the tension and competition of exams takes away the fun or curiosity of learning......American system involves,critical thinking....I wish there was a system that involved combination of both.....I see that change started in few schools in India...
🥵
Dude India have got the worst education system in the whole universe I am an Indian and I know that.
Now. After 11 years, it is clear who told the facts.
us people meant for less efficient study ! in this video mr>J thinks deeply that us people become dependent of indian intelligent people.! soo he is quite disappointed about it
How can u argue with someone who lives inside a well and thinks the world is cylindrical
It all comes down to the human factor , if the student has decent aspirations he can excel even if he is from a third rate university or school in a third rate country . But one thing is for sure General Education in India is far better than that in America . And now many schools in India are catching up with the "American Model" of education of having project work and specializations etc . Which in my time was not there . General Education is the foundation to a better world view . And it is not so bad a person can adapt quite easily to specialized study environments . Primary has always to be general education . All said and done it is the individual that matters and his attitude to studies , nothing else .Centres of excellence exist in every country , they are the exceptions and not the rule . Harvard, MIT, Stanford etc are among the best , but not everyone gets in , and not every successful person who has schooling has necessarily gone to a centre of excellence. In later life it is acumen and application of what one has learnt that matters .
the bald guy is gone nuts!! Dude india's education system is one the best in the world's and no wonder thats how we produce world class engineers and dolctors. I have studied both the indian CBSE system and america's IB and no wonder IB is a joke for me .
hahaahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
you're kidding right ? XD
Our boards are about obtaining marks, other boards are about learning to think.
Sudeb Sarkar
Have you studied in an American school before you make all that claim Sudeb Sarkar? Indians and Chinese are one of the best professionals in the world.
did you know that being a professional and havong a good education are absolutely unrelated?
"Tiny slice of indian and chinese schools are educating better than US schools".... Joke of the decade...hahahahahahaha
Americans do most of the survey in govt. schools or low level schools of india and are still admiring it.. if you do your survey in Private schools you'll probably die of heart attack then...
Nice discussion and good points are mentioned from everyone.
This platform is not to prove who is great, but only to take help from each other to make both the countries great.
Entreprenuership is one of the important way to eradicate the problems in india
Here after 14 years! I love J😍, gives us a competitive advantage.
well i am an Indian and i am doing my syjc , i have seen the american curriculum for physics , I am learning about things like nuclear fission and fusion , dual nature of matter , semiconductor electronics , atoms and communication systems , with all the electricity and magnetism that american curriculum is teaching . 5 more chapter and some of them are so radically different from each other , it helps us get insights into what will come in the future and what we have interest in so that we can choose the appropriate field
If you can do anything best("as you think")
remember there is always an Asian that can do it better than you.
what if i say i am getting a quality govt education in chemical engineering in an amount less than 200 dollars a year...govt of India paying poor and low caste people to come and study..they are like..bro..u dont have to give any fees..we will pay u ur fees,hostels,canteen,books..and even give u scholarship..u just have to come and study..
Satya Nadella went to school in the US, he came on a student visa, he has two degrees in the US, and he has been in the US since 1990 or earlier, he is the product of the US education system and work, his btech would only get him an entry level job in this country at all.
.....and then go raise us economy.how pathetic
We
SYAM KRISHNAN.B im completing my B.A from U.P College within 100$/year
I am an Indian and i agree with the guy in yellow shirt, creativity is not encouraged in Indian education system, at least this was the case when i was in school ... only time i got to apply any form of creativity when i wrote essays with out preparing for them.
***** thx for letting me know.
+Ray Zen Black mist is right and you are throwing vulgar insults instead of presenting any point in favor of your argument, you are perfect example of failure of Indian education system.
jay haven't finished his researched...does he evem know every American company has majority of foreigners
Indian Education System in my view point is the world's best education system. The only flaw i see is the kind of pressure the system puts on the students in the higher secondary level when it comes to entrance examinations for their professional studies. To some extent our education system also doesn't give importance to the student's ability to think and the students are not trained to develop their tastes and skills of interest. I hope these would soon be rectified too. On the other hand lifestyle also plays a very important role. Indian parents give very much importance for their children's education, while i dont think parents outside doesn't take this as important as Indians do. The Indian parents take strain in sitting with the children to teach them which the other parents dont do because of the kind of system that prevails there or so. A student who has studied in India would find it really very easy to adapt to the education system of other countries as they are trained here in that way and would find it rather easy. But some one who studied outside India would find it difficult to follow the system here, because they are not trained to adapt to the different education systems.
In ancient times, India had the Gurukula system of education in which anyone who wished to study went to a teacher's (Guru) house and requested to be taught. If accepted as a student by the guru, he would then stay at the guru's place and help in all activities at home. This not only created a strong tie between the teacher and the student, but also taught the student everything about running a house. The guru taught everything the child wanted to learn, from Sanskrit to the holy scriptures and from Mathematics to Metaphysics. The student stayed as long as he/she wished or until the guru felt that he had taught everything he could teach. All learning was closely linked to nature and to life, and not confined to memorizing some information. The modern school system was brought to India, including the English language, originally by Lord Thomas Babington Macaulay in the 1830s. The curriculum was confined to “modern” subjects such as science and mathematics.
The school system in India has four levels: lower primary (age 6 to 10), upper primary (11 and 12), high (13 to 15) and higher secondary (17 and 18).
There are mainly three streams in school education in India. Two of these are coordinated at the national level, of which one is under the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE). The second central scheme is the Indian Certificate of Secondary Education (ICSE). It seems that this was started as a replacement for the Cambridge School Certificate. Both the CBSE and the ICSE council conduct their own examinations in schools across the country that are affiliated to them at the end of 10 years of schooling (after high school) and again at the end of 12 years (after higher secondary). Each state in the country has its own Department of Education that runs its own school system with its own textbooks and evaluation system.
The state of Kerala has the highest literacy rate among all states, and was declared the first fully literate state about a decade back. Kerala was also the first state in the country to introduce Information Technology as a subject of study at the High School level. It was started in class 8 with the textbook introducing Microsoft Windows and Microsoft Office. The state is now moving towards IT Enabled Education. Eventually, IT will not be taught as a separate subject. Instead, all subjects will be taught with the help of IT so that the children will, on the one hand, learn IT skills and, on the other, make use of educational applications and resources in the Internet (such as textual material from sites like Wikipedia, images, animations and videos) to study their subjects and to do exercises. Teachers and students have already started using applications such as Dr. Geo, GeoGebra, and KtechLab for studying geometry and electronics. Applications like Sunclock, Kalzium and Ghemical are also popular among teachers and students.
+MINOB BRUNO A comment to remember.
What about open DEFECTION
engineering colleges in India are craaaaap ....except the IITS and few Govt ones.Rest of the engineers can even write an application of 5 lines properly.its a mockery .
They don't need to write applications, just work machinery or write codes.
have u heard of IIM, if not u can add one more to the list...i agree univerities have a long way to go
ha ha ...what a dumbass american...students who are rejected from iits get admitted to mit...lol
i think a secretary does that job better
whether crap or not indians are smart people...even someone isnt that smart the person tends to pick up things quickly when into practical scenarios!
Talent is random ! can be anywhere although IIT is prestigious that doesnt mean talent cant be found out anywhere else!...IIT is just good as getting jobs..it cant things inside by brain to invent thing!..just opportunity thats it!
I think americans are good at inventing things (basically because they get proper envionment and funding and offcourse they r more towards inventing) while indians are good at following and making practical things out of that...
After 10 Years RUclips Wants Me To See This.
Jay is 100% correct
I’m from India and can vouch his statement
Come and visit us in INDIA, our educational system is 10 time tougher than you and I can guarantee you that... ;) At least mine is...
Banana Nana it is, but it still sucks.
Better than burgers' though
5:00 Well Indias population is way way way bigger than Americas....
STOP DOING SEX
Jay have no idea about how much students in India have getting better education everyday. As an Indian., i can 100% assure that Indians getting very better education system.
I am an Indian and I agree with Jay... He is right... America is creative... India has long way to go..
India has more than 50% of its population below the age of 25 and more than 65% below the age of 35 so if you have so much competition to survive you try to get good education to earn bread and butter there is no comparison in us and Indian education how much of your population is under 25 so even our education sucks we know how to get job
If so allow Indian schools to open campus in USA. .. ...
And education doesn't necessarily mean more wealth, creativity does.
The reason many Americans are not going for higher education is I feel,is due to the high fee involved....Either super brilliant ones can get through the scholarship or the super rich ones...Well how about the average ones....on the other hand in India fees in the government colleges are quite afforable....other than the few privately owned technical or medical colleges.....Getting college degree is quite affordable
38% of the scientists in NASA are Indians and indian space agency ISRO is the third best in the world hahaha btw columbus was in search for india and he found out America thats why he called red Indians lol so the point is if no india forget about America
naveen singh first thing first 38% thing clear a false news as NASA is federal job so you atleast need green card to work there, and yeah ancient was ahead but modern India have long way to go, amd first step to develop is self realization instead of living a bubble.
That's factually incorrect
100 % of the scientists at NASA are citizens ofthe US.
@@johncena-jh3of and you don't know any facts STFU lol
@@sidhantkansal1346 So, if you know everything. State facts that you claim to know. You have to be a US citizen to work for NASA.
Chiness peoples are laughing at both of you hahahaha XDD {silence wins}. Does it make sence to both? But for sure no doubt I too respect indian Education .
SENSE*
dude grow up ... seriously
Oh well, you go finish your high school first.
Same here, we respect the Chinese Education. But this conversation is crap talk. Just pointless...
This aged well
The knowledge base is the same throughout the world. Its really up to an individual how far s/he wants to go.
American creativity :-
Scientist 1 :' We have no option but to use rocket engine to propel mars explorer all the way to mars.
Scientist 2 :- Can we pull it off?
Scientist 1 :- Yes, we can!! We are Nasa, We are Murica.
Scientist 2 :- You sure? Because you said the same last 5 times.
Scientist 1 :- Dont worry, we will be successful this time. We have spent billions of taxpayers dollars.
After launch attempt :-
Scientist 2 :- Damn, we did it again. We have wasted taxpayers money for the sixth consecutive attempt.
Indian Creativity :-
Scientist 1 :- We dont have launch vehicle big enough to launch mars explorer aka chandrayan along with its rocket engine.
Scientist 2 :- We should use earth to slingshot mars explorer all the way to mars.
Scientist 1 :- Sounds like a nice plan, but it will require precision calculation to pull off this trick.
Scientist 2 :- Dont worry we have great team of mathematicians and scientists.
After successful mission.
Scientist 1 :- I cant believe we pull it off.
Scientist 2 :- and at ridiculously low cost.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO SAY....CERTAIN AMERICANS BELIEVE THAT WE STILL PLAY WITH SNAKES.....BUT THE TRUTH IS INDIANS STARTED PLYING WITH THE MOUSE...HAHAHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Ramanuj created some theorems around 70 years back without any rigorous education No one was able to dechiper them until few years back They turned out to be unity equations of formation of black holes That is creativity:)
Its all about tough situation, guy having resources and facing less tough situation will emerge more. You give more facilities and comfort to Indian kids and you will see Indian kids will not be able to pass simple exams.
That's all makes the difference.
Indians and Chinese aren't creative? Man come on.. You got to be smoking crack to say this. But I got to admit the fact that Indians can be good for the system, but not to create a system. And it's not coz they are less talented or something. It is coz of the lack of enthusiasm on the part of the Indian Government in the field of research.
I can't speak on behalf of the U.S as I never studied there & not in India either. The fact India produces more engineers - duh! it's because of their massive population? And most parents usually want their kid to be either an 'engineer' or a 'doctor'. That's really frustrating! But it's interesting that the U.S still produces top level talent, innovation and entrepreneurs, mostly I think it's because the way culture and education both encourage creative thinking.
CEO of Microsoft is an Indian! just so you'd know.
Indians are more creative than americans.
Well said,most of the parents in India want their kid to become doctor or engineer, so most of them are forced to become an Engineer and screw up their life.Though IITs are a class apart from rest of the Indian universities,I dont think it has the class of Harvard or the MIT.Most of the graduates want to pursue their post graduation in US ,UK or Germany. So, its just a hype created by the western media about the Indian education.
NAVEEN ANU dude if indian education is not up to the mark then how come indians are
becoming successful there in America?
according to a recent statistical report, 33% of the IT professionals in America a re indians of which 25% were completly educated in India
Also 30% of scientists in America are Indians of which 20% were educated in India and rest 10 % in places like UK ,germany etc. so if indian education system is bad, why are indians successful there countries. Take Satya Nadella for example, he was born and educated in India (Hyderabad). so dont underestimate the indian education system.
NAVEEN ANU quality of education u get in INDIA , u cant get it in any other country.
Yeah we Indians are really great ..
With Superior minds..
in India just to pass means just getting 350 out of 700 in CA Ipcc you have to work at least 16 hrs a day minimum for 3 -4 months continously .
I just laughed by looking at situation today...the way they did not believed and today everyone knows that india and china are way further in smart people and developing rapidly.
we r doing something... lets go india
In india school education system is mediocre, barring few. But it is the Student effort that make the difference In higher education IIT ,IIM ,JNU and IISc are top level but only tiny tiny chunk of population get degree from these institutes and then they go to WEST....And then these gentlemen see them and think that they represent whole INDIA.
10 years later I want to say something..... Bob Sir your a legend 🔥....Your faithful Indian Boi ..10:29pm Date Sunday 6 2019