This reveals the games and politics delhi and local politicians in kashmir play for power and control of territory. and then blame people for all wrong doings
This is the nicest ever interview I watched from Karan Thapar. How he has unfolded step by step, the coveted meeting of an Ex intelligence officer with Mr.Abdullah. And Mr Daulat was not candid, he acknowledged every steps taken to reach Abdullah and that had culminated his freedom. Normally intelligence officers remain very secretive.
A staged interview, as Karan knew to ask nitty gritty details like knowing that Mr. Dulat had lunch and Mrs. Abdullah offered him a choice of 2 soups. Unless it's an intelligence leak, how would Karan know these precisely. Good thing he didn't ask if the soup was served in porcelain bowls or melamine. This interview looks like the "coming out" version of Mr. Dulat's Kashmir visit and the public's debriefing by Karan.
To Andh BHAKT yaha bhi AA gye..... Jab koi acchaa Sawaal puchata hai to use tum chutiye log chamcha kehte ho... Ravish Kumar....NAAM to suna hi hoga....Ramon Magsagsay award winner.... Aise hi kisi ko externally award nhi Diya jata....kuch sacchaai hota hai unme .... impartial hote hain Ravish Kumar jaise log ....jaise Abhisar Sharma, Punya Prasun Bajpayee....
@@MrJanrag Mein kisi politician ka follower nhi hoo....Tumhare jaisa Andh BHAKT bhi nhi.... I'm a follower of Ravish Kumar(Ramon Magsagsay award holder) , Abhisar Sharma, Punya Prasun Bajpayee,....and many impartial journalists.... I know in sab me tumhara koi galti nhi hai....yeh sab WhatsApp University ka kamaal hai jiska chief BJP/RSS IT Cell hai
Yeah this intelligence officers is not so intelligent and he has to face wily and cunning person, he is getting carried away at each statement. Each and every "yes" and "offcourse" this officer speaks is goint to be used by leftist media and Pakistan against India in future.
@@AnubhavTyagi1991 yes he gave so much info.? Starting democratic process here in kashmir is too much info.? Are you a fool are just pretending to be so.? Try feeling agony and pain of a common kashmiri, have little empathy. But that would not be possible for you because you don't live here, you don't know kashmir. In fact you know nothing of the history, geography and culture of J&K. You just know what you have been fed through vitriol that is being spewed against kashmiris by every mainstream media channel
Such an interview if we see in the guise of our current media situation seems like that guest is any time set to burst out and to start unleashing the interviewer as he goes deep and deep of every single point and takes out every best and clear of the guest but it doesn't, because both are mature and know well that it's what's called journalism
How this changed in last 70 days? So kashmiri were dying expensively by killing others. Further, we must forget Pakistan....for ever. We pay too much importance to Pakistan.
Arnab not journalist is a little bit of corona virus who speaks in front of his wife at night, do not hurry, nor do he speak after that Modi ji he he Modi ji he he 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is a Really great interview , it gives a clear insight on the government perspective towards Kashmir. Also the advice to continue to talk and engage with all the stakeholders for the betterment of Kashmir is a notable thing. Thanks Wire for having this precious interview.
Dear Mr Thapar, Great interview but sadly you missed discussing the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits. That an entire religious minority was ethnically cleansed and there is no talk of how to get them back??? I wish the Kashmiris well
kashmiri pandits are not important in this discussion, they are ultimate beneficiaries if the problem is solved in the next 30 or 40 years. Don't be obsessed with pandits like a brainless sanghi
How many Kashmiri Pandits have been able to get back to kashmir post 5 Aug, 2019.? People outside kashmir donot understand kashmir. Better stay out. You have created so much of a mess here already.
@@vkumar1170 yes that's right but one should avoid such remark(the last line). I am sorry but those are not good etiquettes. And answer to the question of @pd z this interview was about mr. abdullah and why? Because of the current situation so discussing about situation of J&K at large. We should not spoil a good interview by fight on other topics (not talking about k. Pundits but these childish querrals) rather we should see and acknowledge the bigger picture of who all are effected(kashmiris (pundits as well as their rest of population) if we wish to solve this issue in our generation. Mainstream media only entertains us and they are incompetent to serve pretty much anything other than statistics. I hope you get my point.
Thank you very much the Wire, Karan Thapar and Mr. Dulat for the wonderful video. Thanks for the video which is free and frank. Its a shame that out Govt. is behaving in such an inhuman manner
@@Humanwisdom313 then I used to think Modi is a doer but now I understand the mr Modi is nothing but heck of all the pot and master in Hindu Muslim , vc of WhatsApp university. .hope you get my answer.
@@MrJanrag 2 wrong never makes right. I don't think think Christianity spreading dir to Sonia Gandhi. Congress did muslim appeasement. Media was almost never tried to spread hatred what currently they are doing. .. now politicians cares about public.
how do u know? why did they not hire u because you are a lousy citizen who wishes to comment on people in the comfort of his air-conditioned room. A. S. Dulat (born Amarjit Singh Dulat in 1940) is a former special director of the Intelligence Bureau and former chief of the Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW) from 1999 to 2000. After retirement, he was appointed an advisor on Kashmir to the Prime Minister( Atal Bihari Vajpayee BJP Govt) and served there from January 2000 to May 2004. So baccha don't wear the pants that don't fit you.
Absolutely right! Situation has to be revived. Call of the day! Integral part of ours. Agony! What so ever is there, do belong to all. Who will show perspicacity? The conversation with the ex Chief RAW should be taken immediately. Good signs! Good hopes !
Brilliancy of Karan Thapar shines in each of these questions and counter-questions. The clarity in his questions and his thought process is something that all the students of journalism should adhere to.
Omar Abdullah next CM? Of course. Election results in Kashmir never been depended on voters (that's why Kashmiris are not interested to vote), it depended on how Delhi wanted.
Everyone with a brain knows that PSA is just a ruse to protect them from the wrath of their own people. If they were not taken into preventive custody, they would have been forced to call for protests, and the OGW's of LeT and JeM in the valley would have thrown a bomb or two, and used social media to make propaganda that indian forces did it. And then there would have been more blood on the streets.
@Gautam Basu , you clearly don't have one. They have always been under risk, but always had Z+ security cover.That will not change. The risk would have been to kashmiris who would have congregated to protest against abrogation of 370. The ruling parties would have been obliged to call for these protests if they weren't taken into custody. BTW, Yaqub Wani is the kashmiri here. He clearly has nothing else to say. He knows i'm right.
What a brilliant interview. This should be done by the some mainstream media anchor or journalists. But sad that they r busy in the false govt. Propaganda of Hindu and muslim. Aaj kal aisa lagta h asli journalism TV par nhi RUclips par hota h ....thank you wire.
I liked the interview but very Sad to see that Mr. Thapar wanted to fulfill his agenda. Always with his presumption against Indian government he is going to lowest possible he can go.. Get well soon🙏🙏🙏
Dear Karan Thappar: its obvious that NC represents Kashmir. But pls remember that Farooq Abdullah became RS member by getting jus 3 % votes and death of 9 people and elections were held twice. Time has changed and we youth of people don't accept Any party as our as they always has betrayed same as Congress BJP did. If India really want to resolve K-issue, they India really need to what Mr. DAULAT said talk to all. Also, Kashmir's aren't protesting, bcz there is fear among them created by Ur Doval that if they talked protested their properties would be sized along with parents they will face jail. Even you know that Newspapers aren't alloweded to publish any article regarding the atrocities India is doing in Kashmir. #kashmirwillriseagain
@@zubairnbhat Then, you tell me how you are a muslim with a bhat surname. And, don't you know hinduism and Buddhism were prevalent before islam arrived in kashmir.
@tariq Ahmed why you pakistanis always want to interfere in our internal matters. Think about your country. Take your country forward in development. I haven't seen anybody this obsessed with other countries internal affairs like pakistanis.
It's always a delight to watch 2 intelligent people talking giving lots of insight ...it is an oasis of calm that News channels like The Wire, Newslaundry, NDTV exist ...else we would have been doomed by Godi media. love & regards from Jammu.
Karan, thank you for a revelation. Whatever doubts I had have been cleared that many who are RAW are unpolished gems who served and still serve. During PM Desai’s tenure, the dismantling of the agency was a detrimental step. Can you imagine if the next POTUS will even want to dismantle the CIA? We hope that the present dispensation will use them more appropriately for our sake. Mr Dulat is a wonderfully clear-headed citizen who can help in starting a very gainful exchange for all our sake.
Karn ji i loved all of you're interviews . the ways you ask the questions. Very intelligent parson you're. God bless you for gives us a great information 👌🙏
Mr. Dulat said he was there on Feb 12 coincidentally it happened to be his 84th bday. Farooq Abdullahs bday is on 21 OCTOBER....am I getting something wrong??
Just think. If arnab goswami was sitting on karan taper chair, what questions he would ask?,,, Can he do any interview like this? Thats the difference between journalism & propogonda
Their techniques of interviews are extremely different. Karan Thapar was talking to a former RAW chief and thus questions did not delve into politics of it. Arnab Goswami would have done this differently. But that doesn't mean it would be propaganda as you would like to believe.
Mr. Dulat has been so apologetic to Abdullahs, and more interestingly to Pakistan for abrogation of 370. He also professed that Omor would be chief minister and talked about free will of Kashmirs. Funny! Could not believe he was RAW chief, looked after India's interest sometime in the past! Mr. Dulat you and I know when Kashmiri Pandits were thrown out of the valley - it was under Mr. Abdullah's watch and you are so full of praise for Abdullahs! Thank God, these kind of people are no more involved in our government.
@pk Agreed! I hope Gov has no shortage of goodwill! People are still scared of terrorism; however, recent situation indicates Gov is capable of handling the security better than anyone expected.
@pk Agreed! However, business/investment shall be coming, young would be more involved in their education/jobs/future and everyone will have their stake! Pakistan would be on it's knee, just like now - FATF and more. Hopefully terrorism will end. May be I am too much being optimistic here!
Too many ISI infiltrators in India’s Intelligent Bureau. The way Article 35A was implemented secretly reflects the IB nor the Kashmir political parties can be trusted. Who gave them the right to implement Article 35A with retroactive from 1944 when India got independence only in 1947?
@@narkelnaru2710 Also, celebrating our lockdown and helplessness, if there were few pro indian kashmiris, there is none now. I be the example. India has lost Kashmir completely.
I second that. I even think the class of bureaucrats and central employees who were not a part to the Kashmiri rights issue becuase frankly, they weren't touched, have now grown an anti administration sentiment.
Even after 30 years Kashmiri Pandits have not been given their homes back by those who occupied it and Pandits don't feel that they'll be safe in their homes even now - Kashmir's legacy.
@@MrDnag88 That's Indian Army's legacy , a few dozen PAK agents terrorised everyone in 90s and 5 lakh army couldn't do a thing to stop them. What a mighty army!
As usual great interview from Karan Thappar. It can be very difficult when the person giving the interview is very careful of the answers they are giving but Karan Thappar does not give up and collect as much information as possible.
A staged interview, as Karan knew to ask nitty gritty details like knowing that Mr. Dulat had lunch and Mrs. Abdullah offered him a choice of 2 soups. Unless it's an intelligence leak, how would Karan know these precisely. Good thing he didn't ask if the soup was served in porcelain bowls or melamine. This interview looks like the "coming out" version of Mr. Dulat's Kashmir visit and the public's debriefing by Karan.
I'm happy that Dr. Abdullah has been freed .Can Mr. Dulat say on the basis of his knowing Dr. Abdullah quite well and the psyche of J&K people being in the intelligence deptt. at its top that Delhi can use him to mould the mindset of Kashmiris to get the objectives set by it? Looking forward to a reply from him.
a very gentle dialogue though some aspects untouched….. it would be insightful if Karan could have brought issues regarding foreign delegates mess and mischievous DSP devinder chapter to the audience.
हिंदुस्तान में पढ़ा-लिखा होना कब से जुर्म हो गया? जब से चायवाला और तड़ीपार लोग ने अर्थशास्त्री और चाणक्य समझने लगे। अब गाड़ी पटरी पर तभी आएगी जब दौलत जैसे सुलझे लोग रास्ता बनाएँगे।
oh god! where is this kind of journalism these days? You get goosebumps each time karan thapar makes some unabashed conclusion about what Dulat says. So interesting. I miss Karan Thapar on mainstream journalism.
If the arguments of Mr Daulat is accepted , then what about the statement of Amit Saha in parliment that two families in Kashmir destroyed it. Back to same policies , minus Art 370.
Need to seperate politics from realities ... statemnts made are shear politics but ground reality to achieve the goals are knw by those in power ... so its like america can abuse talibans bit still they knw peace can only be assured when they are on board... so dont go into these statemnts .. everyday these leaders makes such statments , bjp abusing pdp and thn allying , congress in the past had done it , samajwadi and bsp coming togethr , or shivsena and congress .. and recent scindia and bjp , ab kitni galiyan 10 din phle in logo ne di hogi wo political compulsions hain coz thts wat public needs to hear bt behind the curtains those in powrr always protects each othr if it suits their intrests...
Rohit Kashyap what do u think , India doesn't exploit kmr! India needs Kashmir for waters , our land and our forests !!!! It's sheer colonialism, no need to come out of books n see on ground what's happening in Kashmir.....
Amb Dar when you don't have a logic u blurt out your hatred .... bdw this is our faith n here I'm not discussing our faith let's keep that to ourselves but the facts on the ground!!!!!
@@2050truthSeeker So Kashmiris don't have electricity, or food or schools or are not paid for the raw material /finished foods. Kashmiris are dying on the streets because of hunger and disease. Fact is they are not. You are just ignorant. By your definition Pakistan is a Chinese.colony and saudi Arabia is a US colony. A.lot of government money is invested into J&K for the welfare (hospitals schools , trade support). A colony would not be treated as such.
This reveals the games and politics delhi and local politicians in kashmir play for power and control of territory. and then blame people for all wrong doings
su fi I think this is all states
He is expert of J&K
This happens in all states
There are no coincidences in the Indian administration.
There are no coincidences in life.
*current administration! ;-)
Same thoughts here.
In any administration that is worth its salt, in matters of national security.
That’s true!
Two Gentleman's thinking process is learning for everyone
Have you understood their thinking process?
The real news come on The Wire. Cool video. Love these old fashioned interactions.
Not old fashioned rather idiol.
Not old fashioned but they are the original interactions. Not just like Zee news having interactions with Modi
This is the nicest ever interview I watched from Karan Thapar. How he has unfolded step by step, the coveted meeting of an Ex intelligence officer with Mr.Abdullah. And Mr Daulat was not candid, he acknowledged every steps taken to reach Abdullah and that had culminated his freedom. Normally intelligence officers remain very secretive.
EX-intelligence officer
@@prashanttiwari5686 they never become ex
@@jirasi5557 not in habit but workwise they do
@@prashanttiwari5686 watch his video on RUclips while he was anchor Pakistan's general parwaz musraf's India today's lecture.
A staged interview, as Karan knew to ask nitty gritty details like knowing that Mr. Dulat had lunch and Mrs. Abdullah offered him a choice of 2 soups. Unless it's an intelligence leak, how would Karan know these precisely.
Good thing he didn't ask if the soup was served in porcelain bowls or melamine.
This interview looks like the "coming out" version of Mr. Dulat's Kashmir visit and the public's debriefing by Karan.
Karan Thappar.....one of the DARING journalists.....Salute to him
krishna singh ..Sonia ka chamcha..
What daring think he did only barked when sonia ordered
he accepted in his book he loyal with gandhi
To Andh BHAKT yaha bhi AA gye.....
Jab koi acchaa Sawaal puchata hai to use tum chutiye log chamcha kehte ho...
Ravish Kumar....NAAM to suna hi hoga....Ramon Magsagsay award winner....
Aise hi kisi ko externally award nhi Diya jata....kuch sacchaai hota hai unme .... impartial hote hain Ravish Kumar jaise log ....jaise Abhisar Sharma, Punya Prasun Bajpayee....
@@MrJanrag
Mein kisi politician ka follower nhi hoo....Tumhare jaisa Andh BHAKT bhi nhi....
I'm a follower of Ravish Kumar(Ramon Magsagsay award holder) , Abhisar Sharma, Punya Prasun Bajpayee,....and many impartial journalists....
I know in sab me tumhara koi galti nhi hai....yeh sab WhatsApp University ka kamaal hai jiska chief BJP/RSS IT Cell hai
U must ask question about the case of Davinder Singh
Yes that was a miss.
Loved the way how Karan is extracting every bit of information and trying to connect the dots. The conversation is just so fun to watch & listen to.
Yeah this intelligence officers is not so intelligent and he has to face wily and cunning person, he is getting carried away at each statement. Each and every "yes" and "offcourse" this officer speaks is goint to be used by leftist media and Pakistan against India in future.
@@AnubhavTyagi1991 he is not so intelligent and you are too intelligent to understand kashmir.
@@bandralsumeet he may be more intelligent in knowing about kashmir, but I know how much info to give on these sensitive matters.
@@AnubhavTyagi1991 yes he gave so much info.? Starting democratic process here in kashmir is too much info.? Are you a fool are just pretending to be so.? Try feeling agony and pain of a common kashmiri, have little empathy. But that would not be possible for you because you don't live here, you don't know kashmir. In fact you know nothing of the history, geography and culture of J&K. You just know what you have been fed through vitriol that is being spewed against kashmiris by every mainstream media channel
@@AnubhavTyagi1991 And it is not your fault. What do you do "when the very fence begins feeding on the crop?"
Sorry karan you haven't ask about Devindar Singh case, what the mystery is?
Yes ur 100%correct
It is just leftists propaganda that Devinder Singh is part of bigger conspiracy .... Karan is also aware it's just propaganda
@@shreevatsarao3260 😆😆🤗
@@shreevatsarao3260 yep 44 jawans martyadom was fake news as per sanghis
@@shreevatsarao3260
Obviously, higher caste
Eligibility for appearing in this show:-
Must be atleast 65years of age.
That brings so much of experience
Not necessarily . You could be Kashmiri as well
@@nayeemurrehman4922 so not all kashmiri are bad.
@@nayeemurrehman4922 no doubt that all Kashmiri are not bad. Kashmir is Sufi culture and it's spiritual land since 5000 years.
My Best Wishes 💐
@@yog-sadhna3415 fighting for ones rights don't make a community bad
Such an interview if we see in the guise of our current media situation seems like that guest is any time set to burst out and to start unleashing the interviewer as he goes deep and deep of every single point and takes out every best and clear of the guest but it doesn't, because both are mature and know well that it's what's called journalism
"Kashmiri has decided not to die cheap." Wow. Very powerful statement. Salute to the Kashmiri spirit.
How this changed in last 70 days? So kashmiri were dying expensively by killing others.
Further, we must forget Pakistan....for ever. We pay too much importance to Pakistan.
@Danish ...true, finally they are understanding.
@@ssaha2930 close to 100000 Kashmiris were butchers by Indian army. How many people died by the hand if Kashmiri?
This talk should not have taken more than 15 mins.
I am the Kashmiri and i must say this man speaks 100% true and he have really understood the ground reality of Kashmir unlike others
Excellent Interview by Karan Thapar
don't be oversmart karan thappar. . we have seen your smartness in front of sir arif mohammad..
what a simple and gentlemen discussion where most of the questions asked and replied beautifully
Who wants to have an interview with Thapar and Modi some old memories are refreshed 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😁😁😁😁😁Dosti Bani rahe😁😁😁😁😁😁
@@RakeshGupta-qu9yj Wah Mera Bhai
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Abhi bhi dosti hai 😂😂😂😂
Who wants to have an interview of Pappu with Arnab Goswami???😜😜😜😜
Arnab not journalist is a little bit of corona virus who speaks in front of his wife at night, do not hurry, nor do he speak after that Modi ji he he Modi ji he he 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great discussion,really enjoyed with great good hopes.
Very fine interview Karan Bhai.
Dosti bani rahegi.
Interesting way of answering by the Former RAW Chief!!!! Walking on a Tight Rope!!!
This is a Really great interview , it gives a clear insight on the government perspective towards Kashmir. Also the advice to continue to talk and engage with all the stakeholders for the betterment of Kashmir is a notable thing. Thanks Wire for having this precious interview.
"Watch it on ndtv"....says it all
@student for life 17:00
True 😂😂😂
Dear Mr Thapar, Great interview but sadly you missed discussing the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits. That an entire religious minority was ethnically cleansed and there is no talk of how to get them back??? I wish the Kashmiris well
kashmiri pandits are not important in this discussion, they are ultimate beneficiaries if the problem is solved in the next 30 or 40 years. Don't be obsessed with pandits like a brainless sanghi
How many Kashmiri Pandits have been able to get back to kashmir post 5 Aug, 2019.? People outside kashmir donot understand kashmir. Better stay out. You have created so much of a mess here already.
@@vkumar1170 yes that's right but one should avoid such remark(the last line). I am sorry but those are not good etiquettes. And answer to the question of @pd z this interview was about mr. abdullah and why? Because of the current situation so discussing about situation of J&K at large. We should not spoil a good interview by fight on other topics (not talking about k. Pundits but these childish querrals) rather we should see and acknowledge the bigger picture of who all are effected(kashmiris (pundits as well as their rest of population) if we wish to solve this issue in our generation. Mainstream media only entertains us and they are incompetent to serve pretty much anything other than statistics. I hope you get my point.
Loved this interview. Loved this gentleman.
Kashmir problem is far from over.as indians we must embrace kashmiris.
Thank you very much the Wire, Karan Thapar and Mr. Dulat for the wonderful video. Thanks for the video which is free and frank. Its a shame that out Govt. is behaving in such an inhuman manner
thanks to thaperji, for this interview. dulatji for his experienced insight.
You are the only journalist who can hold me for 45 minutes to watch an interview ! ... It was worth watching and interesting
The smile says it was NSA who had called and let him to go
Karan sir once I hated u as much I could but now I can understand u r gem of journalism 💙🇮🇳✌️
Same here sir
May I know you bro why did you hate with Mr Karan? Please convey your kind response
@@Humanwisdom313 then I used to think Modi is a doer but now I understand the mr Modi is nothing but heck of all the pot and master in Hindu Muslim , vc of WhatsApp university. .hope you get my answer.
Ballu ..Sonia did more Hindu Muslim than Modi, Christianity increased bcoz of her..Modi isn’t grt, I agree SO is Sonia , Karan is her chamcha
@@MrJanrag 2 wrong never makes right. I don't think think Christianity spreading dir to Sonia Gandhi. Congress did muslim appeasement. Media was almost never tried to spread hatred what currently they are doing. .. now politicians cares about public.
Even the former RAW chief's contacts & he himself watches NDTV.
Speaks volumes, what other validation do you need.
wrost RAW chief who bribed separatists instead of hanging them. i ve seen him always drunk during his tenure in kashmir
If you were a true Kashmiri you would not want to hang the separatists. Talk Talk Talk. Fake account.
how do u know? why did they not hire u because you are a lousy citizen who wishes to comment on people in the comfort of his air-conditioned room. A. S. Dulat (born Amarjit Singh Dulat in 1940) is a former special director of the Intelligence Bureau and former chief of the Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW) from 1999 to 2000. After retirement, he was appointed an advisor on Kashmir to the Prime Minister( Atal Bihari Vajpayee BJP Govt) and served there from January 2000 to May 2004. So baccha don't wear the pants that don't fit you.
Absolutely right! Situation has to be revived. Call of the day! Integral part of ours. Agony! What so ever is there, do belong to all. Who will show perspicacity? The conversation with the ex Chief RAW should be taken immediately. Good signs! Good hopes !
Brilliancy of Karan Thapar shines in each of these questions and counter-questions. The clarity in his questions and his thought process is something that all the students of journalism should adhere to.
Agree, very precise and excellent command on laguage too.
Awe inspiring interview by K Thapar with earstwhile James bond of the dark world
Why are we talking about Farooq Abdullah? The best thing this govt. has actually done is to abrogate article 370.
Excellent interview Karan
You know it's going to be a great interview when Karan has got his bow-tie on.
Omar Abdullah next CM?
Of course. Election results in Kashmir never been depended on voters (that's why Kashmiris are not interested to vote), it depended on how Delhi wanted.
Now it's getting something better.
Arnab please watch and learn...this is journalism at it's best.
Imagine if Farooq Abdullah had become Vice President during NDA govt he would have become the Vice President slapped with PSA under NDA govt.
Everyone with a brain knows that PSA is just a ruse to protect them from the wrath of their own people. If they were not taken into preventive custody, they would have been forced to call for protests, and the OGW's of LeT and JeM in the valley would have thrown a bomb or two, and used social media to make propaganda that indian forces did it. And then there would have been more blood on the streets.
@Gautam Basu , you clearly don't have one. They have always been under risk, but always had Z+ security cover.That will not change.
The risk would have been to kashmiris who would have congregated to protest against abrogation of 370. The ruling parties would have been obliged to call for these protests if they weren't taken into custody.
BTW, Yaqub Wani is the kashmiri here. He clearly has nothing else to say. He knows i'm right.
PSA is the protector of kashmiri leaders otherwise people of Kashmir might rip them apart
@@vivekyadav1win win for central government and political parties in Kashmiris, plausible observation.
What a brilliant interview. This should be done by the some mainstream media anchor or journalists. But sad that they r busy in the false govt. Propaganda of Hindu and muslim. Aaj kal aisa lagta h asli journalism TV par nhi RUclips par hota h ....thank you wire.
Yes.... HM making great loss of hindi audiences
Sahi kaha aap ne! I also think real journalism is happening on RUclips/social media! Sad isn't it!
I liked the interview but very Sad to see that Mr. Thapar wanted to fulfill his agenda. Always with his presumption against Indian government he is going to lowest possible he can go.. Get well soon🙏🙏🙏
Once a spy always a spy!
Never seen or heard such interrogating session and sucha great diplomatic answers.... really my country has great gems....
Dear Karan Thappar: its obvious that NC represents Kashmir. But pls remember that Farooq Abdullah became RS member by getting jus 3 % votes and death of 9 people and elections were held twice. Time has changed and we youth of people don't accept Any party as our as they always has betrayed same as Congress BJP did. If India really want to resolve K-issue, they India really need to what Mr. DAULAT said talk to all. Also, Kashmir's aren't protesting, bcz there is fear among them created by Ur Doval that if they talked protested their properties would be sized along with parents they will face jail. Even you know that Newspapers aren't alloweded to publish any article regarding the atrocities India is doing in Kashmir. #kashmirwillriseagain
Inshallah
#kashmir will rise again...
To be fair, he is LS member not rs
@tariq Ahmed And don't forget your ancestors were also hindi speaking hindus but converted on the sword.
@@zubairnbhat Then, you tell me how you are a muslim with a bhat surname. And, don't you know hinduism and Buddhism were prevalent before islam arrived in kashmir.
@tariq Ahmed why you pakistanis always want to interfere in our internal matters. Think about your country. Take your country forward in development. I haven't seen anybody this obsessed with other countries internal affairs like pakistanis.
His book is simply great & great... kashmiris especially should read that book
It's always a delight to watch 2 intelligent people talking giving lots of insight ...it is an oasis of calm that News channels like The Wire, Newslaundry, NDTV exist ...else we would have been doomed by Godi media. love & regards from Jammu.
Karan, thank you for a revelation. Whatever doubts I had have been cleared that many who are RAW are unpolished gems who served and still serve. During PM Desai’s tenure, the dismantling of the agency was a detrimental step. Can you imagine if the next POTUS will even want to dismantle the CIA? We hope that the present dispensation will use them more appropriately for our sake. Mr Dulat is a wonderfully clear-headed citizen who can help in starting a very gainful exchange for all our sake.
India very much needs people like Dulat. He made my day today.
Lol he had been a disaster as RAW chief.
hi karan , thanks for such a nice interview of a great patriot Mr Dulat , who served for Mother India.
thanks to Mr Dulat too.
Karn ji i loved all of you're interviews . the ways you ask the questions. Very intelligent parson you're. God bless you for gives us a great information 👌🙏
really great interview!
Former RAW chief still talks like a great diplomat with very prudently selecting most appropriate words. I liked and enjoyed his way of talk.
Previously Kashmir is just like paradise and now become hell bcoz of hardcore human killers in this criminals government
Mr. Dulat said he was there on Feb 12 coincidentally it happened to be his 84th bday. Farooq Abdullahs bday is on 21 OCTOBER....am I getting something wrong??
he said that he is 84 years old
May be someone other's birthday maybe Mrs Abdullah or their daughter.
Brilliant interview
Much worth interview 🙌
I can't believe Karan forget Devender Singh 😠😠😠
Just think. If arnab goswami was sitting on karan taper chair, what questions he would ask?,,, Can he do any interview like this? Thats the difference between journalism & propogonda
Their techniques of interviews are extremely different. Karan Thapar was talking to a former RAW chief and thus questions did not delve into politics of it. Arnab Goswami would have done this differently. But that doesn't mean it would be propaganda as you would like to believe.
Mr. Dulat has been so apologetic to Abdullahs, and more interestingly to Pakistan for abrogation of 370. He also professed that Omor would be chief minister and talked about free will of Kashmirs. Funny! Could not believe he was RAW chief, looked after India's interest sometime in the past! Mr. Dulat you and I know when Kashmiri Pandits were thrown out of the valley - it was under Mr. Abdullah's watch and you are so full of praise for Abdullahs! Thank God, these kind of people are no more involved in our government.
@pk Agreed! I hope Gov has no shortage of goodwill! People are still scared of terrorism; however, recent situation indicates Gov is capable of handling the security better than anyone expected.
@pk Agreed! However, business/investment shall be coming, young would be more involved in their education/jobs/future and everyone will have their stake! Pakistan would be on it's knee, just like now - FATF and more. Hopefully terrorism will end. May be I am too much being optimistic here!
Karan Sir, u r one of d pillar of democracy
So we could say as it was raining and snowing it definitely helped kept your visit secret as was in clouds radar theory 🤣😂🤣😂
Very Good idea get every state knowledge before happening something keep up the great jobs, don't forget me wen u over come,,
Abdullahs are always a better messenger for delhi than mahbooba, they should've been treated differently
He is really deeply involved in Kashmir, then his wife and children. I think he will resolve Kashmir issues well.
A perfect interview .good work Mr
Thapar.
Excellent discussion!!
Mr Dolat really have knowledge and concern about Kashmir & Kashmiris
His suggestion s worth to be noticed.
Always admired mr dulat .. he speaks less but hints more ... nice one sir... thnks fr this interview ..
This Dulat seemed more political in responses than an intelligence personnel. Disappointed with his lack of clear answers.
well...... that is why he was the chief of RA&W. Retired important bureaucrats do not actually retire. They are just re-purposed.
@@successnick Well said, I agree
😊making jalebi hahaha!
ravi S true, that’s a point as well, ain’t it!!!
Priya Malhotra I think he is making khichdi more than the tastier jalebi.. lol
This is the journalism . Hindi electronic media must kearn from it.👌👌👌
A S dulat. India needs brains like him. I salute u sir.
Thapar sahib your failure to ask about his thoughts on the exodus of Kashmiri pandits is inexplicable.
Beautiful discussion
'Between the line' should be the name of this particular interview.
Karan shows maturity again.
What a lovely interview.
Too many ISI infiltrators in India’s Intelligent Bureau. The way Article 35A was implemented secretly reflects the IB nor the Kashmir political parties can be trusted. Who gave them the right to implement Article 35A with retroactive from 1944 when India got independence only in 1947?
"Kashmiri has decided not to die cheap"
India's legacy!
As an avowed Indian, there is nothing sadder than this. That we have made them feel abandoned.
@@narkelnaru2710 Also, celebrating our lockdown and helplessness, if there were few pro indian kashmiris, there is none now. I be the example. India has lost Kashmir completely.
I second that. I even think the class of bureaucrats and central employees who were not a part to the Kashmiri rights issue becuase frankly, they weren't touched, have now grown an anti administration sentiment.
Even after 30 years Kashmiri Pandits have not been given their homes back by those who occupied it and Pandits don't feel that they'll be safe in their homes even now - Kashmir's legacy.
@@MrDnag88 That's Indian Army's legacy , a few dozen PAK agents terrorised everyone in 90s and 5 lakh army couldn't do a thing to stop them. What a mighty army!
The present govt. is comfortable with the Farooq, because Dulat has made them believe, though he does not forget, he does forgives.
Karan is a great interviewer in a POISONOUS WIRE
Very good discussion about Kashmir situation with former RAW chief Dulat ji what's the reality now there after abrogation of art 370
As usual great interview from Karan Thappar. It can be very difficult when the person giving the interview is very careful of the answers they are giving but Karan Thappar does not give up and collect as much information as possible.
A staged interview, as Karan knew to ask nitty gritty details like knowing that Mr. Dulat had lunch and Mrs. Abdullah offered him a choice of 2 soups. Unless it's an intelligence leak, how would Karan know these precisely.
Good thing he didn't ask if the soup was served in porcelain bowls or melamine.
This interview looks like the "coming out" version of Mr. Dulat's Kashmir visit and the public's debriefing by Karan.
All interviews are scripted, if you don’t know
I'm happy that Dr. Abdullah has been freed .Can Mr. Dulat say on the basis of his knowing Dr. Abdullah quite well and the psyche of J&K people being in the intelligence deptt. at its top that Delhi can use him to mould the mindset of Kashmiris to get the objectives set by it? Looking forward to a reply from him.
Karan Thapar s father was responsible for Indian defeat in 1962 China war...
a very gentle dialogue though some aspects untouched….. it would be insightful if Karan could have brought issues regarding foreign delegates mess and mischievous DSP devinder chapter to the audience.
Very intelligent xofficer who must have been in charge of resolution of disputes and differences
Absolutely right. Call of the day! Situation has to be revived. Integral part of ours as it being
Such an interesting and meaningful conversation, 🔥
हिंदुस्तान में पढ़ा-लिखा होना कब से जुर्म हो गया? जब से चायवाला और तड़ीपार लोग ने अर्थशास्त्री और चाणक्य समझने लगे। अब गाड़ी पटरी पर तभी आएगी जब दौलत जैसे सुलझे लोग रास्ता बनाएँगे।
It's always very much intriguing to watch Karan Thapar interviews..
Really glad Thapad is back in his form. But something about Mr. Dulat's responses doesn't seem genuine. It feels like he is leaving stuff out.
....well KARAN,
"I WILL LIKE TO SAY HIM "RIPE-CHIEF ....than RAW-CHIEF instead...!!!..!!!"
Call him*
@@AshishSrivastav1
.....@someone,
SURE,
----why-we-can't...??
What about Davinder Singh?
oh god! where is this kind of journalism these days? You get goosebumps each time karan thapar makes some unabashed conclusion about what Dulat says. So interesting. I miss Karan Thapar on mainstream journalism.
He got full of etiquette of journalism and principles
If the arguments of Mr Daulat is accepted , then what about the statement of Amit Saha in parliment that two families in Kashmir destroyed it. Back to same policies , minus Art 370.
Need to seperate politics from realities ... statemnts made are shear politics but ground reality to achieve the goals are knw by those in power ... so its like america can abuse talibans bit still they knw peace can only be assured when they are on board... so dont go into these statemnts .. everyday these leaders makes such statments , bjp abusing pdp and thn allying , congress in the past had done it , samajwadi and bsp coming togethr , or shivsena and congress .. and recent scindia and bjp , ab kitni galiyan 10 din phle in logo ne di hogi wo political compulsions hain coz thts wat public needs to hear bt behind the curtains those in powrr always protects each othr if it suits their intrests...
Never trust on amit shah.
You are wrong MR Dulat! Kashmiris won’t give up!!!! Kashmiris have never accepted Indian colonialism!
Colonialism... Exploits the colony
...read Sashi Tharoor's book ..it may help u understand.
Rohit Kashyap what do u think , India doesn't exploit kmr! India needs Kashmir for waters , our land and our forests !!!! It's sheer colonialism, no need to come out of books n see on ground what's happening in Kashmir.....
Amb Dar when you don't have a logic u blurt out your hatred .... bdw this is our faith n here I'm not discussing our faith let's keep that to ourselves but the facts on the ground!!!!!
@@2050truthSeeker So Kashmiris don't have electricity, or food or schools or are not paid for the raw material /finished foods.
Kashmiris are dying on the streets because of hunger and disease.
Fact is they are not.
You are just ignorant. By your definition Pakistan is a Chinese.colony and saudi Arabia is a US colony. A.lot of government money is invested into J&K for the welfare (hospitals schools , trade support). A colony would not be treated as such.
please take an interview of VIKRAM SOOD also