This Doctor Claims "Ayurveda" is a SCAM - BeerBiceps vs. LiverDoc

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 янв 2024
  • Watch The Full Episode Here: • Liver Health 101, Bad ...
    Check out BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Video Editing Course - bbsh.in/trsclips-launch-cpyt
    Use my referral code OFF40 to get a 40% Discount on a standard membership subscription.
    Follow BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Social Media Handles:
    RUclips : / @beerbicepsskillhouse
    Instagram : / beerbiceps_skillhouse
    Website : bbsh.in/trsclips-launch-cpyt
    For any other queries EMAIL: support@beerbicepsskillhouse.com
    In case of any payment-related issues, kindly write to support@tagmango.com
    Check out my Mind Performance app: Level SuperMind
    Android - lvl.fit/androiddownload
    Ios - lvl.fit/iosdownload
    Join the Level Community Here:
    linktr.ee/levelsupermindcommu...
    Follow Dr. Abby Philips's Social Media Handles:-
    Instagram: / theliverdr
    RUclips: / @theliverdoc
    X: x.com/theliverdr
    Reddit: / btcxwdmrwv
    🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
    open.spotify.com/show/6ZcvVBP...
    Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
    This podcast was recorded on 15th January ’2024 at The Ranveer Show studio.
    This is another medical and science-related podcast where we welcome Dr. Abby Philips popularly known as “Liver Doc”. He is an Indian hepatologist and clinician-scientist known for his critical views of alternative medicine. He has a wide social media presence where he discusses his findings and research works on the negative effects of alternative medicines.
    In this podcast, we will discuss the basic understanding of the liver and how it differs in every human. We will talk about common liver diseases, what causes fatty liver, the landscape of liver diseases in India, liver transplant infrastructure in India, and much more. We will also discuss Hepatitis B, the anti-vaccination movement, allopathy, ayurveda, and modern lifestyle changes for better liver health.
    This was an in-depth conversation about liver health and how lifestyle changes adversely affect our liver health. I hope you will enjoy this conversation and do not forget to share your thoughts in the comments.
    #liverdoctor #liverhealth
    ✅ Subscribe To Our Other RUclips Channels:-
    BeerBiceps (English Channel):
    / beerbicepsofficial
    Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
    / ranveerallahbadia
    TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
    / @theranveershowhindi
    BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
    / @bestoftrs
    Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
    / @bestoftrshindi
    RAAAZ. :
    / @raaazofficial
    RAAAZ Shorts :
    / @raaazshorts
    BigBrain Plus :
    / @bigbrain_plus
    --
    INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
    / beerbicepsguy
    WHATSAPP: BeerBiceps
    whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaA5...
    LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
    t.me/beerbicepsguy
    SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
    ----------------------------------------------
    About :
    TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
    Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.

Комментарии • 984

  • @bhuvaneshgoplani2332
    @bhuvaneshgoplani2332 4 месяца назад +138

    My father is Doctor (MBBS). I had IBS, for which I took treatment for more than 3 years, but no luck. Then my father who is doctor himself, took me to his friend who is ayurvedic doctor (vaidya). He enquired about me, my lifestyle, eating and sleeping habits examined me and then told me it would take 6 months to cure. I took the medicines for around 7-8 months. This was in 2015. From then till now it's been 9 years in 2024 I am all good without any medicine.

    • @khshah121
      @khshah121 4 месяца назад +1

      Do you have the doctor’s reference?

    • @joybiswas6819
      @joybiswas6819 3 месяца назад +1

      I also need the doctor’s number

    • @vukalyan801
      @vukalyan801 3 месяца назад +4

      Multi system or combination therapy is excellent than single therapy

    • @user-iu9pg3gz3h
      @user-iu9pg3gz3h 3 месяца назад +4

      Same I had. Ibs and I am in ayurveda now nothing worked gastro,homeopath

    • @vasujayaprasad6398
      @vasujayaprasad6398 3 месяца назад +2

      I suffered from gluten related injury and IBS from the age of 14 after introduction of wheat in Kerala. By 26 intestine snapped and started bleeding. Necrotic intestine. I survived. Most allopathic medicines like flagyl were banned. By 37 I took a Bengali with acute Entamoebic infection to a 90 years old ayurvedic sage. I also followed instructions irregularly. My Bengali friend was completely cured. I got intermittent relief. Now I am 75 I watch with scorn gastrologists still in infancy with around 16 nonsensical medicines.

  • @ignite4349
    @ignite4349 4 месяца назад +74

    Ranveer if it is debate or discussion between ayurvedic and modern medicine there should be experts from both pathy right?

    • @hariprabhakaran4527
      @hariprabhakaran4527 4 месяца назад +1

      Right 👍

    • @priyanshuvettori5179
      @priyanshuvettori5179 4 месяца назад +13

      My cousin went to BAMS, and she said that professors don't study Ayurveda themselves. So what kind of experts are you talking about.

    • @ritikaanand3161
      @ritikaanand3161 4 месяца назад

      ​​@@priyanshuvettori5179you should have sent her to a good reputed college. This is not the case everywhere

    • @_Amit_Sunil
      @_Amit_Sunil 4 месяца назад +4

      They don't show up to debate. No facts just ancient vibes ✨✨

    • @biswajogot
      @biswajogot 2 месяца назад

      Ayurveda practitioners do not respond to the debate or such discussions with proper evidence. They have faith and tradition which is default to them, no changes yet.

  • @prerakchoksi2379
    @prerakchoksi2379 4 месяца назад +119

    Ashwagandha causes liver damage he said, but that is when you take too much of this, and also there is liver damage done when taken paracetamol, multivitamin, etc

    • @avinashnagadi2700
      @avinashnagadi2700 4 месяца назад +39

      Exactly, a doc tells you the right prescription based on research. What about aswagandha, where is the research on it that shows its significance?

    • @jayanttarare6136
      @jayanttarare6136 4 месяца назад +4

      Already proven do some research yourself.

    • @raghukoundinya9115
      @raghukoundinya9115 4 месяца назад

      ​@@jayanttarare6136nothing is proven, show the research and meta analysis

    • @Hope-ml5nu
      @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад

      ​@@avinashnagadi2700 plenty of research articles have proven the neuroregenerative and cardiorespiratory endurance enhancing actions of ashwagandha. You can access the research articles by just googling.

    • @berserkhorimiya
      @berserkhorimiya 4 месяца назад

      And it's doctors themselves who told us this, modern medicine constantly finds it's own flaws and works to eliminate them. Unlike snake oil that is Ayurveda.

  • @sougatkumarsahoo8706
    @sougatkumarsahoo8706 4 месяца назад +91

    What the doctor is saying is that there are some side effects with ayervedic medicine. What he is not saying is there 1000s of side effects in modern medicines as well.

    • @WizardAmbrose
      @WizardAmbrose 3 месяца назад

      Mf ayuveda is bullshit

    • @samgarg5228
      @samgarg5228 3 месяца назад +34

      But at least those side effects are well-known and well-documented. So the patient can make an informed decision on its own. But in the case of Ayurvedic medicines, those are marketed as 'natural' and do not have any side effects. They aren't even tested.

    • @abhirao3471
      @abhirao3471 3 месяца назад +1

      Yes exactly correct

    • @DhirenVyas261
      @DhirenVyas261 3 месяца назад +3

      He has to otherwise these useless doctors will have no business. Also what medical mafia companies who pay these doctors will do ? He even dont have basic idea of Ayurved, forget expertise. and he is commenting on Ayurved.

    • @DhirenVyas261
      @DhirenVyas261 3 месяца назад

      They are. The problem is ayurved has to fight entire ecosystem of allopathic mafia companies and goernment bodies to promote its truth. you know in india, there are many scientists has been killed literally becuase they found some useful solutions of big deceases in Ayurvedic or plant based medicines ?@@samgarg5228

  • @nicolefish9285
    @nicolefish9285 4 месяца назад +29

    I am glad you are presenting on this topic - In the example you give of ' Jaundice " and that Ayurveda would treat them all the same - That is simply not true ..A skilled practitioner would not treat them all the same. they would read the pulse and examine the tounge - examine the quality of the speech, the eyes, ask about urine - color/ quality and quantity - same for stools- ask about sleep - ask about life stresses, ask ' what else has the jaundice person tried and has there been any benefit? I admit I am an Ayurvedic practitioner ( that is born in the west - so I was raised with Allopathic medicine and I value it too ). However, I would use caution to say " Allopathic medicine is a scam with the pharmacutical companies making contracts with allopathic hospitals - that ' require" MD s to " offer" what even new ( expensive ) drug that has been created -( even tho the old - or generic version may function quite well ). Please note - if I had Heb B. - I would likely go with an Allopathic route initially - to get blood work / exacting scientific tests , ect. then use all of my knowledge of Ayurveda and western herbs to support my liver. Please Please stop vilifying alternative forms of medicine - we would do better to create systems of confluence rather than exclusion

    • @user-iu9pg3gz3h
      @user-iu9pg3gz3h 3 месяца назад +1

      Same I have ibs and. Taking ayurveda before I used gastro and homeopathy nothing worked

    • @shanblues7257
      @shanblues7257 3 месяца назад

      But what different kinds of treatment would you use?

  • @HamsaHouse
    @HamsaHouse 4 месяца назад +10

    The liver is the mula(root) off the the rakta vaha srotas(blood carrying channels) and any herb that is consumed has to get processed by the liver before entering into the bloodstream to be sent to the deeper tissues. An herb like Ashwaganda which is a heavy heating and unctuous herb that should be used with caution and is even contraindicated in conditions where many toxins(āma) are present in the body(which would automatically mean the liver is a bit taxed) coupling that with the amount of self prescribed Ashwaganda usage due to its effect on building muscle and reproductive tissue people have been taking very large dosages to try to “maximize” its effectiveness. Ayurveda says each and every substance can be medicine or Can ve poison and it entirely depending upon for whom, how much and when. That goes not only for herbs but any substance. This is another reason it’s extremely important to not self prescribe if in-depth insight into the action of these powerful herbs is not understood and why if one is wanting to consume natural medicine like herbs, to consult an Ayurvedic Vaidya(Doctor)

  • @Hope-ml5nu
    @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад +26

    We can get so many research articles on paracetamol causing liver toxicity. Does that mean paracetamol shouldn't be prescribed? Does that make modern medicine a pseudoscience?
    Everywhere it's the dosage. It's that easy

    • @akshay5295
      @akshay5295 4 месяца назад

      Yes. That's why modern medicine doctors are taught about the side effects. And that's why these substances are controlled and only on prescription. That's why they are tested. And only when the risk to reward makes sense they are prescribed or approved. Nothing like this in ayurveda.

    • @shanblues7257
      @shanblues7257 3 месяца назад

      You know paracetamol causes toxicity if taken in higher dosage. You can literally search the dosage of paracetamol up and you will get the prescribed doses on the web, and also simple research articles. This level of evidence is not present in ayurveda. And this level of clarity of what happens if you take what isn't present.

    • @Ishitakapoor12
      @Ishitakapoor12 2 месяца назад

      In those same research papers there is mentioned the safe dose of paracetamol. It's 3 to 4 gms per day is safe. One can take it for few weeks. But long use and overdose can have rick of liver toxicity. That's why one needs doctors advice and priscription for any drug to use it safely and avoid it's side effects.

    • @idkwhattodo7170
      @idkwhattodo7170 Месяц назад

      bhai shilajit kha kha ke tera dimag gobar ho gya hai kya? paracetamol aur dusre drugs mein likh hua hota ki doctor se puch ke khana koi chocolate nhi hai jab bhi man kare kha le. ye sab well researched hote hain but these herbs have so low effects. thats why they dont work but your brain thinks its working. placebo effect.
      baat maan lo nhi toh in scam mein pad kisi family member ko kho doge.

  • @heminpunadiya7509
    @heminpunadiya7509 4 месяца назад +19

    I was taking citrizine to cure cold, now i use cow ghee. It works fantastic.

    • @ArjunA-ln3ov
      @ArjunA-ln3ov 4 месяца назад +7

      I got air876 in jee advanced just coz I drank cow shit shake 1 day before exam

    • @heminpunadiya7509
      @heminpunadiya7509 4 месяца назад +3

      @@DatanFactMatters hope you have seen ads about allergy rakshak. It works for me. I don’t mind your sarcasm, may be your ignorance is speaking.

    • @heminpunadiya7509
      @heminpunadiya7509 4 месяца назад +2

      @@ArjunA-ln3ov amazing, good for you.

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +1

      it is a great lubricant.

    • @drdwaipayandas6592
      @drdwaipayandas6592 3 месяца назад

      Cetirizine is an amtihistaminic drug .. allergic rhinitis or cold will go away without any drug itself .. it has a duration ...cow ghee does NOTHING

  • @chiragpawarpawar1518
    @chiragpawarpawar1518 3 месяца назад +25

    He said the formulations in our texts ( i m mbbs doctor from India so i say that ayurvedic textss are our texts) are not time tested not evidence based , he don't even know there are main 3 branches of ayurvedic treatment modalities Charak , sushrut and Vagbhat , all three have criticised same plants in different ways still reclaim each other views at some places they agree with each other and some places contradict ... What is this? Is it not use by different practitoner? The person is highly unscientific as he comments without knowledge

    • @rendezvous59
      @rendezvous59 3 месяца назад +6

      Of course you are an MBBS doctor with the picture of Charaka as your DP 😂😂

    • @shanblues7257
      @shanblues7257 3 месяца назад +3

      These arguments are not scientific. In literature or archeology, these kinds of arguments may work, but you have to conduct proper studies and prove the efficacy. It's a much better form of evidence. But we don't see the level of studies and trials conducted in the field of ayurveda.

    • @worldtitan
      @worldtitan 2 месяца назад +5

      You are an MBBS and I am the President of India.

  • @venki89
    @venki89 4 месяца назад +61

    Please do podcast with B.M Hegde, a padmabhushan awardee, and talk about ayurveda

    • @vishalkvijayan
      @vishalkvijayan 4 месяца назад +3

      He must be in the podcast

    • @sagardeep.sd_gowda
      @sagardeep.sd_gowda 3 месяца назад +3

      yes this has to happen.

    • @samgarg5228
      @samgarg5228 3 месяца назад +11

      The popular pseudoscience guy.

    • @venki89
      @venki89 3 месяца назад

      @@samgarg5228 says the circumcised brains

    • @samgarg5228
      @samgarg5228 3 месяца назад

      @@venki89 😂😂Damn!! I had to search for this word.

  • @samriddz2211
    @samriddz2211 4 месяца назад +263

    My mother was given 1.5 years by Doctors due to liver condition. With ayurvedic medicine she managed to survive 8 years. I believe in ayurvedic medicine.

    • @rajakeerti5675
      @rajakeerti5675 4 месяца назад

      Yeah. No doctor gives you 1.5 years for a liver condition until and unless it's hepatic carcinoma (cancer). Even then there are transplant options which can't cure cancer but prolong life

    • @gauthamsreeku178
      @gauthamsreeku178 4 месяца назад +6

      @@rohan.999exactly 😂

    • @yoyodude-aoe2726
      @yoyodude-aoe2726 4 месяца назад +48

      Also survival bias, many other patients being treated with ayuveda having same disease would have died. But we won't hear from those people complaining about ayurveda. But here you are because somehow your mother survived longer than the doctor said, so it's definitely because of Ayurveda

    • @vinayakhulswar7557
      @vinayakhulswar7557 4 месяца назад +3

      It's not system, it's doctor who treats, ayurveda may also have good doctor like that of morden medicine doctors

    • @theuncoolbateman3732
      @theuncoolbateman3732 4 месяца назад +6

      there are multiple factors whic can affect whatever liver condition ur mother had. also there is no gurantee tht ur doctor gave the best timings. there are multiple cases where doctors estimated the patients lives and they outlived them. so nothing new from ur interpretation

  • @JourneyWithMystics
    @JourneyWithMystics 4 месяца назад +45

    Tell them to debate with Dr. BM hegde❤

    • @sagardeep.sd_gowda
      @sagardeep.sd_gowda 3 месяца назад +1

      that's right, Dr BM Hegde should be on the podcasts too.

    • @abhyudayas2342
      @abhyudayas2342 3 месяца назад +5

      😂😂😂 kya baat karty ho.... bhaag jayega ye kapdey khol dengy Dr. HEGDE

    • @AP-eb8hd
      @AP-eb8hd 3 месяца назад +2

      BM Hegde is a joker

    • @abhyudayas2342
      @abhyudayas2342 3 месяца назад +3

      @@AP-eb8hd lol...u sound like a kid who says.. Jo pehly bolta hai wohi Hota Hai

    • @speedawayyspeed9736
      @speedawayyspeed9736 22 дня назад

      ​@@abhyudayas2342BM hegde is a joker bro don't listen him .

  • @dr.dineshrathod
    @dr.dineshrathod 3 месяца назад +19

    No ayurveda doesn't treats everybody same. Even the patients with same diseases say for example Hepatitis B, will not be treated same. Treatment protocol in ayurveda differs with Person to person, disease causation etc. A same disease may be caused with different reasons in two different person so treatment protocols will be different.
    - Registered Ayurveda Practitioner

  • @shrichandrajoshi8564
    @shrichandrajoshi8564 4 месяца назад +35

    Unfortunately in India many Doctors of modern medicine prescribe ayurvedic liquids & tablets in cases of hepatitis A.

    • @rishi7887
      @rishi7887 4 месяца назад

      That is very unfortunate. Liv 52 is one common medicine given even by doctors for any liver ailment. There is zero evidence of it being beneficial.

    • @A4Aqua
      @A4Aqua 4 месяца назад +12

      They are paid by companies to prescribe those.

    • @DhirenVyas261
      @DhirenVyas261 3 месяца назад +3

      They are doing right. Allopathy is joke.

    • @vivekc2471
      @vivekc2471 3 месяца назад +3

      @@DhirenVyas261 allopathy is evidence based .

    • @DhirenVyas261
      @DhirenVyas261 3 месяца назад

      Ayurved is not something came out from the thin air. Its already used and prooved. the only problem it faces today is medical mafia companies. which never let them enter in market easily as they have already billions of dollars invested in. also, we should also not forget that the Ayurved scriptures we have today is less compare to what we had 1000 years back. becuase in Takshashilaa and other universities tons of our books are being burnt for months by invaders. @vivekc2471 @@vivekc2471

  • @kushalkelshikar9487
    @kushalkelshikar9487 4 месяца назад +74

    The people who don't know about Ayurveda, then they don't have any right to talk on other pathy.

    • @abhisheknair3667
      @abhisheknair3667 4 месяца назад +11

      What did you think is the reason why ayurveda is not allowed to be practiced in developed countries? Unlike Yoga, why did ayurveda treatment is not common in western countries

    • @ashishgupta2938
      @ashishgupta2938 4 месяца назад +1

      Because people are in a hurry Paisa feka thik ho gaya that's why pharmacy is looting people .
      In a critical situation it's good but to not get critical is ayurveda.

    • @sanjeebmohanty616
      @sanjeebmohanty616 4 месяца назад

      ​@@abhisheknair3667You are wrongful, West has also started importing Ayurvedic medicine, Check the data on Ayurvedinc product export to developed countries

    • @ankitjain3760
      @ankitjain3760 4 месяца назад +4

      Ayurveda should test their medicine.

    • @kushalkelshikar9487
      @kushalkelshikar9487 4 месяца назад +7

      @ankitjain3760, I have questions
      why female gives birth to baby, why at morning we are enough energetic, why plant comes out from seed, why summer exhausting , why winter is pleasuring??
      most of us know that the answer is natural rules
      we can't deny it
      On the same background all the fundamental of Ayurveda are based.
      language/terminology of Ayurveda is different but something which not understand by someone that doesn't mean it is wrong.
      I think I tried my best to explain.
      and it should elaborate publicly so that everyone will understand

  • @pratiknag1336
    @pratiknag1336 4 месяца назад +5

    All the podcast skills of Ranveer are in full flow here😊

  • @KasiVGupta
    @KasiVGupta 3 месяца назад +5

    This doctor needs mental treatment.. he speaks of Ayurveda without knowing anything about it.. I wouldn’t suggest anyone to trust their lives with this pseudo doctor.

  • @lakshmis7129
    @lakshmis7129 3 месяца назад +8

    Ranveer can u stop these interviews which give complete wrong info, and also degrading indian culture?

  • @saphernpant8540
    @saphernpant8540 4 месяца назад +36

    PM Modi, a while back at an AYUSH summit, mentioned how ex-Kenyan PM’s daughter regained her lost eyesight after ayurvedic treatment. This is an influential family with access to the best medical care available in the world. The daughter who lost her eyesight because of optic nerve atrophy had tried every other treatment under the sun before finally resorting to Ayurveda. The daughter, Rosemary Odinga said “My father met the PM and was full of praise for the traditional Ayurvedic system that has helped me. He also discussed bringing traditional medicines to Africa.” There are hundreds of such testimonials. I will not write off Ayurveda just because it's known as pseudo-science. It needs revival and of course a lot of clinical trials etc. but it will get there.

    • @divyaharidasmenon
      @divyaharidasmenon 4 месяца назад +3

      She was treated at sreedhareeyam Kerala. Its true.

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +3

      @@divyaharidasmenon treat all other blinds too. nonsense.

    • @_Amit_Sunil
      @_Amit_Sunil 4 месяца назад

      Blindness rate: 👇🏿 100% 😂😂

    • @harshsangwan1185
      @harshsangwan1185 4 месяца назад

      Yeah, now why won't a politician lie, right??

    • @AP-eb8hd
      @AP-eb8hd 3 месяца назад

      See ..,this trying Ayurveda after everything... can be looked in 2 ways.. The doc explains it.

  • @banutej3437
    @banutej3437 3 месяца назад +15

    Am an Ayurvedic doctor practicing at chennai.
    Ask him to send autoimmune disease like RA etc
    End stage lung disease or whatever respiratory tract diseases including asthma , TB.
    It's a challenge to u sir...will prove u wrong by reversing and curing the disease permanently so that they don't have to continue even Ayurvedic medicine lifelong.
    People need every system of medicine including allopathy and Indian system of medicine. It will be opted accordingly.

    • @Dr.JayHidad
      @Dr.JayHidad 23 дня назад

      Kuch bhi😂

    • @banutej3437
      @banutej3437 22 дня назад

      Dr.Jayhidad where are u practicing?
      If u have guts come to Chennai. Everything is documented and u can talk to my patients.
      Use the smiley to u. In future if u have chronic liver disease . Get treated from me.

    • @soumen2023g
      @soumen2023g 10 дней назад

      ​@@banutej3437madam is there any medicine in Ayurveda for CKD, please guide

  • @51.aniketshirule93
    @51.aniketshirule93 4 месяца назад +8

    things talking about ayurveda by him all wrong

  • @smredemption
    @smredemption 4 месяца назад +51

    Kudos to you Ranveer for taking your stand on Ayurveda, its not urine according to what the modern science or like this doctor claims. These ancient texts have a wealth of knowledge but due to certain time periods in medical history they have been erased and right now there is a need of revival, as the core principle of Ayurveda has always been - | िक्षालनापदद िङकस्य दूरादस्पशवनं वरम ्। | Prevention is better than cure |

    • @vkone7162
      @vkone7162 4 месяца назад +9

      ​​@@DatanFactMattersthis itself show you don't understand anything 😂 5 bhootas doesn't mean it's literally those 5 elements in modern languages just understand it using its somethings like fluid, heat, solids/ mass, gas and volume.
      This is concept which is used for classification.
      It's just you Don't have much scientific knowledge and understanding of language to understand what they are trying to convey.

    • @vkone7162
      @vkone7162 4 месяца назад

      @@DatanFactMatters you just changed whole context and brought chemistry here and wrote big para of n0ns€nse 😂
      Do you understand what and how these categorization is used it's used in Ayurveda to categories a problem ?
      It's not chemistry but way used to classify problems like Pit, Vaat, Kapha, etc...this clearly shows you haven't read or know anything about Ayurveda
      For example if you have acidity they classify problem as problem due Pitta ie unbalanced Fluid and Heat combination...it's a vast concept.
      Leave that for second, have you ever done Anulom Vilom what we use term for Each nostril...sun and moon now is that unscientific too because sun and moon are in space ? 😂
      If you haven't read about it, have no science background to understand concepts, why are you try to act rational... first get basic understanding of science and language 🌚

    • @vkone7162
      @vkone7162 4 месяца назад +4

      @@DatanFactMatters I am not sure if my comments (just above this) is visible to you as I can just see 3 comments till now, but to add (if you can see) because you haven't read Ayurveda (out of curiosity like I did) you don't know what those 5 elements signifies and is concept used to classify problem. And thus you attached those terms with states of Matter and trying to act like some scholar. ..I mean I understand you just have read science till 10th but we are student of science and have been doing this our whole life and consider what you have written as something obvious so calm down kid. If you have to come up with an argument atleast know basic of those stuff too.
      Saying Heat is not state of matter volume actually It's Void not volume (error) but still is not state of Matter...like dude everyone know this. It's funny you wrote this 😂😂
      Even in Science their are concepts, hypothesis etc used to prove certain points and is considered base of any scientific theory or observation. It's quiet common.

    • @anujsrawat
      @anujsrawat 4 месяца назад +1

      There is big difference between principle/philosophy VS medicine, Ayurveda definitely good for life principle or philosophy that could actually motivate them for living healthy life or atleast lead them for that but as medicine INDIANS should not risk their life just for the sake of proving it right. Remember a bad Modern medicine practitioners doesn't mean Modern medicine is not good. Ayurveda text AS medicine is written at time when they had nothing byt today you have every information why wasting that amount of money or resources on it just to prove it correct, instead use that money to lead those textual observations into knowing what we should not continue anymore be it from ayurveda or modern medicine, I mean are actually giving priority to those practice which were written at time of lack of info inside of your body...

    • @DhirenVyas261
      @DhirenVyas261 3 месяца назад

      Not only that. allopathic medicine companies are also scammers. they literally learn from Ayurveda and use the same thing in their medicines with other cheap drugs. While in Ayurvedic medicines we have natural substance only. People dont know that there are many medicines in the market who uses camel urine and cow urine in different medicines. but the problem of today's hindu is, they want to defame their own legacy. Ironic.

  • @AYGAcademy
    @AYGAcademy 4 месяца назад +6

    This person is talking nonsense about Ayurveda? Yes disappointed with this content @TRS

  • @priyankathakur9122
    @priyankathakur9122 4 месяца назад +4

    There he said that when they do studies they extract the particular active principle or constituent to study its effects , what people don't understand is that we give ayurvedic drug as a whole , its never just active principle , as a whole that drug has less potency and less side effects !! Its all about creating balance ..

  • @HamsaHouse
    @HamsaHouse 4 месяца назад +6

    If you can sir please do a podcast with Dr. Vasant Ladji who is the individual who brought Ayurveda to the western world and was Dr. Robert Svobodas teacher and travels to India from July to December 🙏

  • @praveenhegde8107
    @praveenhegde8107 4 месяца назад +9

    What a attitude 😂
    Let him know fully about his own profession before commenting on ayurveda.
    Can alopathy stop death.
    From someone who has 5 doctors in my close family
    Please tell him i was cured of a autoimmune condition which on of the best endocrinologist in south India couldn't cure.
    FDA in America is hugely influenced by lobby groups .

    • @A4Aqua
      @A4Aqua 4 месяца назад +3

      Your personal experiences or claims are not accepted by the scientific methodology. It needs evidence.

    • @praveenhegde8107
      @praveenhegde8107 4 месяца назад +1

      @@A4Aqua Evidence twisted by pharma industry 😂

    • @Hope-ml5nu
      @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад

      @@A4Aqua Just google research articles on ayurveda drugs for autoimmunity. You'll find plenty of published articles.

    • @WebbedManiac
      @WebbedManiac 7 дней назад

      Ah another ayurveda apologist using the term "allopathy" without knowing what it means lol

  • @Samarth0_0
    @Samarth0_0 2 месяца назад +6

    Why did the doctor refuse to admit he believes in God? Because he said, "Show me the evidence first!"

    • @yogeshb4921
      @yogeshb4921 2 месяца назад +2

      yes show the evidence then we'll believe

    • @manaspandit26
      @manaspandit26 7 дней назад

      Life me ek baar down fall aane do saara science pichhe se nikal jayega aur muh se raam ka naam hi niklega 🤣

  • @nishchal3136
    @nishchal3136 4 месяца назад +5

    Host him in front of ayurvedic doctor then he will answer all his questions he did not know anything about ayurveda he has no right to tell anything about other pathy

  • @swathi6570
    @swathi6570 4 месяца назад +23

    I got some auto immune condition due to modern anti biotics usage And allopathy doctors gave some chemo medications and steroids for the condition. Got so many side effects post the medication. Now I am healing with ayurveda. This guy has very less knowledge on ayurveda and talking about the side effects. Many people are consuming many ayurvedic drugs over the counter and without any prescription from ayurvedic doctor. Any medicine will be toxic if used too much.

  • @debasmithmishra7871
    @debasmithmishra7871 4 месяца назад +54

    He needs security Coz half of the ppl watching him speak already they are boiling up.

    • @Hope-ml5nu
      @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад +7

      People are asking for fair debate with an actual ayurveda vaidya who has an actual degree in it. This shows that the viewers are not stupid to accept everything anymore.

    • @Immortal_lion99
      @Immortal_lion99 4 месяца назад +2

      you assume that all listeners are stupid and becoming angry. No. Viewers are open minded, they want a proper non biased podcast.

    • @hemantpahuja4114
      @hemantpahuja4114 3 месяца назад

      @@Immortal_lion99Let us be open minded if Harry Potter is real or not. Open minded means being open to all scientific possibilities, not calling pseudoscience as science. The misuse of the word "open minded" is a tale of its own to justify all ultra pseudo scientific views.

  • @prapti_thakkar
    @prapti_thakkar 3 месяца назад +3

    Modern medications are laboratory borne, thus they be tried and tested in labs. Ayurveda was DISCOVERED in तूरीय अवस्था (meditative state) so it CAN BE EVALUATED THERE!

  • @ayurmedico-rl3sg
    @ayurmedico-rl3sg 4 месяца назад +17

    You both should use ashwagandha 😂😂it has more number of benifits than your number of podcasts these people think they can question nature .... according to them lab made medicines are not harmful but medicinal herbs are don't forget you are also a part of nature 😂😂😂 literally fools who thinks they are intellectuals...

    • @Dr.JayHidad
      @Dr.JayHidad 23 дня назад

      Part of nature hei to kuch bhi khalega kya

    • @ayurmedico-rl3sg
      @ayurmedico-rl3sg 22 дня назад

      @@Dr.JayHidad kuch bhi nhi joh khane layak hai nature se woh ..jinko heal karne ke properties hai woh .. differentiate karne ke liye hi toh yeh padhayi hai

  • @GURJARkabir
    @GURJARkabir 4 месяца назад +5

    8:00 what about old age asthma 😂

  • @akhilsubramanyan2198
    @akhilsubramanyan2198 4 месяца назад +42

    Everyone should listen to what this Dr is saying . Keep out your emotions and listen it’s a matter of life and death for you and your parents.

    • @RojaJaneman
      @RojaJaneman 4 месяца назад +8

      Ayurveda has worked for our family for generations. It’s going nowhere.

    • @MariaMyself
      @MariaMyself 4 месяца назад +8

      I listen and it’s not new for me, it’s more like a amateur lesson but is only for the public.
      I don’t know if someone can ask or answer a few questions? I’m trying to get some information but ..
      1. Why a new born child is getting in the first 24h a hepatitis B vaccine if he doesn’t have an immune system yet?
      2. Why in the modern new medicine is not being used “unknown “ instead of the term “idiopathic “?
      3.Why PCR testing by amplification x200 isn’t considered pseudo testing for the same reasons why homeopathy is considered only placebo/nocebo ?
      4. The mental health care diagnostic and treatment for patients is based only by Symptoms not even measurable Signs? Is a pseudoscience? Because don’t respect the 4 postulates of nothing nobody none….
      5. I’m trying not to think of something called impossible to get a patent for natural molecules but Synthesize the structure of stuff found in nature can be done?
      6. In medicine one rule is: nothing is 100% safe, dose not mean anything?
      7. Talidomida?
      8.AZT?

    • @DakshtheGOAT
      @DakshtheGOAT 4 месяца назад +1

      What do you mean to say?@@MariaMyself

    • @DakshtheGOAT
      @DakshtheGOAT 4 месяца назад +3

      Mate, it was good for it's time. Now if you say it is better or even equal to tried and tested drugs then you are completely wrong. It was advance for it's time but not now.@@RojaJaneman

    • @sachwagh7829
      @sachwagh7829 4 месяца назад +1

      @DakshtheGOAT tested from Thousand of years , so in some cases if it is very beneficial u must use it

  • @ayomama1540
    @ayomama1540 4 месяца назад +4

    This guy is so wrong . That's so not what ayurveda says 👽👽 who told him ki there is only jaundice and not root cause ? Ayurveda ka treatment is only based on root caus eof the disease . Please bring people who have studied and not speaking what they heard on whatsapp and social media. Bruh this is so lame

  • @ND20248
    @ND20248 3 месяца назад +5

    @Dr. Abby Philips and @Ranveer Allahbadia... Anyone who hasnt heard of Liv52 must live under a rock!

  • @Ashrsna
    @Ashrsna 3 месяца назад +4

    I feel Ranveer, you are not being open to new perspectives. Don't get me wrong, but this podcast was very uncomfortable to watch as i felt the guest was being disrespected by turning it into a debate, also pointing out to him that you want more people who can defend ayurveda.
    I was your follower before few years, but then you started inclining towards a lot of unscientific things which being a science student doesn't resonate with me. I belive one should be open to new perspectives if they are to hold podcasts with people in various fields otherwise this gives an impression that you want to defend the opinions that are opposite to yours.
    I hope you understand that am not criticizing for the sake of it, i genuinely feel that the content you put forward is more inclined towards unscientific things mostly. Or at least that's what the youtube shows me, based on which the viewer creats an image of you.
    Also after reading the comments, i do understand why you make the context you make, maybe thats what a set of people want to see. In that case, everything does make sense. Though its very sad to see people having closed minds in the comments aswell.

  • @divyranjan254
    @divyranjan254 2 месяца назад +31

    All Ayurveda supporters having meltdown but none of them giving a single research paper 😂

    • @Rationalist_Thinker
      @Rationalist_Thinker Месяц назад +4

      What kind of proof do you seek could elaborate ?

    • @hashvindsivakumar3479
      @hashvindsivakumar3479 Месяц назад +3

      @@Rationalist_Thinker"research paper", read his comment again

    • @Rationalist_Thinker
      @Rationalist_Thinker Месяц назад +5

      @@hashvindsivakumar3479 Are you out of your mind I have seen his comment, I ask what kind of research paper they want could they please elaborate ?

    • @hashvindsivakumar3479
      @hashvindsivakumar3479 Месяц назад +1

      @@Rationalist_Thinker since you’re the one TRIGGERED 😂. You show me research papers of Ayurvedha supremacy

    • @hemant938
      @hemant938 Месяц назад +1

      Research vo kya hoti hain.... AY doctor😂

  • @kodfef0632
    @kodfef0632 2 месяца назад +2

    Observation: when a person mentions out of the world substance to cure something or help us with something to ranveer,he immediately agrees and puts his out of the world beliefs to make it appealing to the audience and contrary when a person with substantial evidence objects the same ,he tries his level best to take it to the direction where he tries concluding that it can be proven wrong with this or that or other wordly possibilities.
    P:s - its fine as the person with hard evidence answers his questions which further solidifies our belief in the evidence based approach.

  • @pradeepgantyada671
    @pradeepgantyada671 17 дней назад

    Is any ayurvedic or homeopathy doctor giving any bills in India while consulting and purchasing medicines?

  • @AYGAcademy
    @AYGAcademy 4 месяца назад +6

    Ayurveda is a science based on practical concepts. Its based on Praman (evidence), Anuman ( Conclusion on proper study), and Scripture (words of authority).

    • @rishi7887
      @rishi7887 4 месяца назад +9

      Your own words prove that it is unscientific.

    • @AYGAcademy
      @AYGAcademy 4 месяца назад +1

      @@rishi7887whose words?

    • @rishi7887
      @rishi7887 4 месяца назад +2

      @@AYGAcademy as an Ayurvedic practitioner would you rather believe in the above or the results of a double blinded large scale clinical trial ?

    • @AYGAcademy
      @AYGAcademy 4 месяца назад +2

      @@rishi7887 I believe in the science of Ayurveda and respect all forms of healing. However, it's disheartening when someone unfairly blames Ayurveda. Ayurveda is a proven science and I believe in promoting it for the better health and well-being of humanity.

    • @slayer6225
      @slayer6225 4 месяца назад

      Ayurveda was definitely the best medical system for its time. But it's not scientific by any means. It is not based on practical principles rather on untestable principles. For example the very basic tridosha principle, it can't be measured, tested or falsified by any means. It's philosophy not science.

  • @DhirenVyas261
    @DhirenVyas261 3 месяца назад +3

    About modern medicines, you know around 1940s USA doctors used to proscribe cigarrates as a medicine ? this went on for 20-30 years. later they found found the side effects. this is same for Allopahy medicines. look at cancer medicines, patients die because of side effects of medicines before even cancer could kill them.

  • @Denver_TDM
    @Denver_TDM 11 дней назад +2

    I'm a BAMS student and I'll say that he has no knowledge of ayurved 😂 The example of giving the same medicine for all jaundice patients is wrong, what a fool 😂 He is so desperate to save jobs of allopathic doctors 🙂

  • @vpknutrition-integrativehealth
    @vpknutrition-integrativehealth 4 месяца назад +5

    First of all kudos to Ranveer 👏👏 for watering down some of the outrageous comments made by this doc. The doc is obviously very ignorant of true Ayurvedic principles and wisdom based on basic principles of the Cosmos. You cannot learn about Ayurveda from books that you have acquired. That’s like saying , “I have all the medical books and have read them and I know all about modern medicine.”
    Ayurveda is personalized medicine based on the premise that every individual is a unique body type, prakruti and so many factors like diet, lifestyle including sleep, stress etc, emotional health, seasons, the place you live and stage of life all have an impact on our health. It is not just a disease curing science but preventing it in the first place. While Modern medicine is disease focused in treatment, Ayurveda is a holistic medicine treating the whole person body, mind and spirit.
    Jaundice is a modern term for a disease. Ayurveda does not treat diseases but imbalance in the body. These imbalances start manifesting way before it gets the modern name. By the time a person comes to a doctor, it has already gone through the first 3 to 4 stages described in Ayurveda. I can go on and on.
    Herbs are not the first course of treatment with true Ayurvedic approach. You always work on the client’s diet and lifestyle to weed out the causative factors before you think about herbal Rx. Unfortunately in the modern times the practitioners in India have adopted the modern medicine way:
    1. By starting with herbs which is not the ayurvedic way. Maybe business?
    2. Secondly the patient/client being used to taking meds to help and not taking charge of their own health, feel satisfied only when they get some medication.
    3. Third factor is many people hear from friends and family and abuse these supplements without understanding what they need.
    Ashwagandha is very heating and can cause liver damage taken by the wrong person, like a Pitta person.
    All of this is because of how Modern medicine has caused a shift in our thinking.
    Anyway like Ranveer said please have Dr.Robert Svoboda or David Frawley, westerners who have adapted this to come forward and explain it. I have studied in the US from third generation Vaidya and having begun as a dietitian in modern medicine over 30 years ago, adding Ayurveda 10 years ago to my tool box has given me more success with health and healing. My husband is a kidney doctor as well so I would never knock modern science. There is value in both systems but for the chronic illnesses we face today which are primarily lifestyle diseases, integrative Ayurveda in practice is a great boon.🙏🏻
    Last comment, this is from our vedic scriptures, so wonder if this doctor maybe biased because of that? Something to ponder about. 🤔

    • @debasmithmishra7871
      @debasmithmishra7871 4 месяца назад

      Firstly, it is crucial to acknowledge that every system of medicine has its strengths and limitations. Ayurveda, a traditional Indian system, is undoubtedly rich in its holistic approach to health. However, it is essential to avoid idealizing it and recognize that, like any system, it has evolved over time, and its principles may be interpreted differently.
      The assertion that one cannot truly understand Ayurveda through acquired books is questionable. While hands-on experience and guidance from knowledgeable practitioners are undoubtedly valuable, dismissing the significance of written knowledge seems overly restrictive. Modern medicine heavily relies on research, textbooks, and accumulated knowledge for its advancements.
      Furthermore, the comparison between Ayurveda and modern medicine oversimplifies the complexity of healthcare. Modern medicine is continually evolving, incorporating aspects of personalized medicine, genomics, and lifestyle interventions. It is not merely disease-focused but increasingly embraces preventive measures and considers individual variations.
      Lastly, insinuating bias in the doctor's perspective based on Vedic scriptures raises questions about objectivity. In the pursuit of understanding and improving healthcare, i think it is crucial to approach discussions with an open mind and avoid attributing motivations to individuals based on their background or beliefs.

    • @vpknutrition-integrativehealth
      @vpknutrition-integrativehealth 4 месяца назад +2

      @@debasmithmishra7871 thanks for your detailed response to my comment. As I mentioned in my response if you read correctly, I believe in integrating both systems for diet and lifestyle and our body can heal itself given the right conditions. I have a lot of doctors in my family including my husband and daughter. I am not idealizing Ayurveda but pointing out the tremendous value it holds for our modern lifestyle diseases.
      Unfortunately Modern medicine is very much a pill pushing system today, not blaming the doctors because that is the training and most doctors don’t have the time for much more than that. Research is also focused on pharmaceuticals and can be biased. Ayurveda in India is also being practiced like modern medicine giving a ton of herbal supplements which I have explained in detail and that is not true Ayurveda.
      Having studied Ayurveda in the last several years has opened my eyes to things that I never got out of Modern medicine. I have applied it to my own life and it has made a tremendous difference. It has made a great impact on my patients as well. So unless you have actually practiced it, there is no way for you to know. Reading books is just intellectual exercise. Enough to pick up some points to speak against it like this doctor has done. 🙏🏻
      Yes questioning if there is bias based on Vedic scriptures is not too far off since many of this knowledge which was practiced in ancient times and woven into our culture was systematically destroyed by the Britishers who invaded India to introduce their brand of medicine. Again not knocking modern medicine, just pointing out that bias is possible for self preservation.
      Anyway there is no reason to discuss further. I have clearly mentioned my credentials. I am curious to know yours if you are willing to share. Thank you!
      I do think, as Ranveer mentioned he needs to bring in an Ayurvedic expert, who understands the ancient teachings correctly to have a discussion. Dr.Lad brought Ayurveda to America over 50 years ago. Maharishi Mahesh Yogi brought it in the 70s. Yoga has been pulled out as a separate system but both are based on the same philosophy. These things will not be shining in the West unless they have value.

  • @akshayjayaraj9295
    @akshayjayaraj9295 3 месяца назад +3

    One talks against a system when he has fear inside and he doesn't trust on what he is practicing..this guy can't be called a doctor. Egoistic and talks nonsenses which he doesn't know properly.

  • @tinguzz
    @tinguzz 3 месяца назад +3

    Docs take on Ayurveda is too harsh, almost negative, though he put it nicely. But he is right on few foundational thing, just because something written and practiced from thousands of years doesn't make it good. Humans should always check, analyze, experiment and improve

  • @prestoX
    @prestoX 3 дня назад

    This guy is a freaking genius, he will be studied in next decades for debunking myths of Ayurveda.

  • @user-zw7zz4oj5x
    @user-zw7zz4oj5x Месяц назад +1

    Incidentally even western medicine began with basis in tri humours.....

  • @gauthamrao7862
    @gauthamrao7862 4 месяца назад +13

    Paracetamol, Ibuprofen is very good for liver.🙏

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +5

      mat le phir... go eat some plants. and pray.

    • @yess10
      @yess10 4 месяца назад +1

      Business comes first and then treatment in today's medical world.

    • @narenpradeep3766
      @narenpradeep3766 2 месяца назад +1

      Beautiful comment 😂

  • @vkone7162
    @vkone7162 4 месяца назад +9

    12:25 Even Finisteride cause such problems and other modern medicines too.

    • @akshay5295
      @akshay5295 4 месяца назад

      All medicines cause problems if taken unnecessary. Doctors know this. Scientists know this. That's why they are prescription drugs. That's why they are controlled substances. That's why they research the side effects. That's why they take a calculated risk to reward guess when they prescribe you medicines. The reward is you'll be free from disease. The risk is you MIGHT get a side effect. That's why they test it on hundreds of people to find out who's at risk. And they won't prescribe you that drug if you're one of the high risk ones. That's why the doctor asks you about your preexisting conditions even if it's not directly related to your current condition.
      Does ayurveda do any of this ? No. Does it learn anything new ? No. You think people who wrote it knew EVERYTHING and it NEVER needs to update ? How ignorant. How stupid.

    • @InsaneSibs
      @InsaneSibs 3 месяца назад

      But it is advertised as side effects on contrary Ayurveda advertises itself as no side effects

  • @prapti_thakkar
    @prapti_thakkar 3 месяца назад +2

    "In this case you have to give this only" seriously??
    No, in many places in samhita, acharya has said to use own intelligence of a doctor. He has just given चिकित्सा सूत्र which is the key to treatments. NOWHERE ACHARYA HAS SAID THAT IN THIS CASE GIVE THIS ONLY.

  • @chiragpawarpawar1518
    @chiragpawarpawar1518 3 месяца назад +1

    All three schools of ayurved charak sushrut vagbhat have their own lineage of deciples, madhavacharya , nagarjun , qnd many more who have made changes time to time according to changes in society and culture, nature.. still saying its rigidis fulish, And he also says that our text say no changes should be made in treatment or formulation is totally wrong.. all Acharya says examine the patients and make your own formulation according to your diagnosis...

  • @laxmikantk2930
    @laxmikantk2930 4 месяца назад +3

    Stop spreading such messages to society... otherwise we All need to further action on your channel

  • @dranayajoshi1198
    @dranayajoshi1198 2 месяца назад +1

    Glad to see so many comments taking a stand for Ayurved & against spreading the misconceptions against it

  • @Salman.XX2
    @Salman.XX2 2 месяца назад

    Insightful ❤

  • @priyanshuvettori5179
    @priyanshuvettori5179 4 месяца назад +7

    I have seen some of his posts about diagnosing diseases. Some em has just shocked me because I have yet to see a doctor this determined in real life. Who will put all his energy to find the root cause of the disease.

  • @ashishparmar9536
    @ashishparmar9536 4 месяца назад +8

    The how reserved catagory doctors looks like...🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴...........here in my area givt medical college professor took only ayurveda treatment for their family...one old man was cured by our sir with only treatment that mentioned in samhita he was patient of liver cirrhosis and took all allopathy treatment from years and still no results he was cured within 3 months ge touched our sir feet when discharged even he was older than him...other same case in my internship time one Parkinson's disease patient se 70% improvement with in 2 month of treatment ...he was taking allopathic medicine from 14 years...and had no results.....so shut up

  • @theoldy98years3
    @theoldy98years3 4 месяца назад +43

    Ranveer talks about keeping an open mind but most his veiwers doesnt have sinlge ounce of rational thinking or open mindness

    • @ignite4349
      @ignite4349 4 месяца назад

      Respected dr you can not say that ayurvedic medicine is not tested ..since it has been used from ages and ages as you say.. it has been tested on millions of populations .. Modern medication gets approval on the basis of selected populations in phase 3 studies right? still you dare to say it is validated..
      We have also pathophysiology
      Hetus..root causes..
      You didn't study ayurved so you don't know about that..

    • @KapilKumar-gg1ok
      @KapilKumar-gg1ok 4 месяца назад +5

      Except you.

    • @ashishgupta2938
      @ashishgupta2938 4 месяца назад

      😂

    • @priyaprabhat9310
      @priyaprabhat9310 4 месяца назад +1

      Then why do u watch

    • @poojapethe6213
      @poojapethe6213 4 месяца назад +1

      What is open mind according to you? Is it accepting anything?

  • @kushalkelshikar9487
    @kushalkelshikar9487 4 месяца назад +8

    Do Video with Ayurveda Doctor to justify the science, a person who didn't learn Ayurved, then how can any one talk on the science?

    • @maverickcruise
      @maverickcruise 4 месяца назад +3

      Dude read about him first. He works with ex ayurvedic doctors, who assist him in debunking the mysts of a pseudo science.

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +1

      you did not understand english na.. hahahahah no wonder you are talking about something which is already covered in the video. shame shame.

  • @deepakanandmani
    @deepakanandmani 3 месяца назад +3

    Ayurveda doctors will not discount modern medicine. However Modern Medicine cannot coexist with Ayurveda. Not everything can be measured either. Energy is one example, if someone says I feel tired can you measure the energy that that person needs?
    Conversely when some says Thyroid levels is in the normal range, does that mean it's functioning correctly for that specific person -- even though the body has symptoms, such as fatigue and insomnia? No, THEIR body needs are different.
    We can clearly see modern medine has holes in analysis.
    Analysis is not exclusive for modern medicine either. The depth of analysis can be done for Chinese, South American and Indian medicine as well.
    Poor form from the doctor here, highly biased when he says even after two decades Ayurveda reasearch cannot change.

  • @subhamandkhushi4945
    @subhamandkhushi4945 4 месяца назад +4

    The new age medicines are always good to cure, but Ayurveda is more from a preventive perspective, and it works if someone follows the lifestyle.

  • @prasannabp1885
    @prasannabp1885 4 месяца назад +16

    Hey ranveer please invite Vd. L. MAHADEVAN SIR FOR YOUR EPISODE

    • @sudhir2453
      @sudhir2453 4 месяца назад +1

      Yes, please have this great doctor 🙏

  • @GURJARkabir
    @GURJARkabir 4 месяца назад +1

    My tooth was all gone I went under root canal then my other tooth got decayed the doc advised root canal again but I went to our "GOTHIYA"(gurjar diety" devnarayanji " used to come to his body" he told me to stop eating sugar and use "SAFED MUSLI "( root plant found in sand dunes or mountains of Rajasthan " ) morning and night for 3 weeks ....I used it and my teeths got better stronger and I took it for 3 months in and out and now my tooth has filled half again....and it's healthy..and now I am using 25 rupees dabar lal powder by using it my tooth are getting much better ....so stop this bullshit argument that ayurved is bluff and all ...I think allopathy has nothing to do with health but money

  • @ND20248
    @ND20248 3 месяца назад +4

    You need to up your game. I will continue to support you Ranveer, till you get to a stage where you can bring more prominent medical professionals on your show. Especially, tbose who expose the hypocrisy of modern medicine, their associations and their practitioners. Bring Dr. David Frawley, Dr. Vasant Lad, Dr. B. M. Hegde, and the likes of Dr. John McDougall on your show please! The kind of misinformation being spread in this particular episode is just plain scary. Can you even fathom the kind of damage modern medicine aka allopathy can cause? And if you manage to bring your viewers to naively believe whats being said here, then you are equally responsible. Please be more circumspect. You owe it to your viewers.

  • @user-kq6xz1cc6u
    @user-kq6xz1cc6u 3 месяца назад +6

    Who is this person on social platform??? And why you taking interview of him..

    • @vivekc2471
      @vivekc2471 2 месяца назад

      Because ayurveda is not evidence based medicine

  • @chiragjbrahmbhatt
    @chiragjbrahmbhatt 4 месяца назад +1

    9:45 Is that is true how does Vaccination work? That is evidence based, scientific, right?

  • @kaleakshay7162
    @kaleakshay7162 4 месяца назад +12

    Mr. So called doctor - please go through PANDU - KAMALA Chikista adhyaya of Charak Samhita and read the pathogenesis thoroughly where our Acharyas have mentioned clearly about the issue

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +8

      those acharayas who did so much will be disgusted with your inability to move ahead. they went forward you look backward.

    • @drdwaipayandas6592
      @drdwaipayandas6592 3 месяца назад +2

      Where is the clinical trial ?

    • @toufiqueahmed7
      @toufiqueahmed7 3 месяца назад +1

      Pandu😂

  • @Ans-cq9ll
    @Ans-cq9ll 4 месяца назад +47

    There should be a lawsuit against him for defaming a system of medicine and deliberately spreading misinformation to millions of viewers. He has no rights to speak on something he doesn't know.

    • @ravichandranv3426
      @ravichandranv3426 4 месяца назад +28

      He gives scientific proof for everything. Why don't you file a lawsuit with scientific proof

    • @Hope-ml5nu
      @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад +1

      ​@@ravichandranv3426 the research he's referring to clearly says that the medicine was taken without a doctor's supervision and in excess quantity. In excess dosage any medicine can cause toxicity.

    • @rajak6226
      @rajak6226 4 месяца назад +3

      U do it then

    • @Immortal_lion99
      @Immortal_lion99 4 месяца назад +4

      @@rajak6226 he would have already done it if he was a lawyer. Why are you getting offended?

    • @akshay5295
      @akshay5295 4 месяца назад +14

      Truth hurts. Especially when it goes against your beliefs. But stay honest. Seek the truth. Even if it's inconvenient. And welcome to science.

  • @herambpatkar
    @herambpatkar 3 месяца назад +7

    Homeopathy: When there's no alternative..hope for the placebo effect to occur to the patient!
    Ayurveda: For lifestyle improvements or in tandem with modern medicine after confirming with your Doctor!
    Modern Medicine: Diagnosis, Treatments, prevention & cure.

    • @minihot823
      @minihot823 28 дней назад

      No ,Ayurveda says = swaasthya swathya Rakshanam atur tasaye vikar prasnam. Means Ayurveda makes the healthy person to be healthy and Ayurveda also cure the patient who is suffering from disease.

  • @lakshmipolukonda9176
    @lakshmipolukonda9176 18 дней назад +1

    Where allopathy given up Ayurveda does mitacles, after all medicine is a sibstance ,if given with evidence or observation , method is important,and suitability is the solution.

  • @tanishkaatanu344
    @tanishkaatanu344 18 дней назад

    How to get convinced that .. Ancient texts of Ayurveda got the content without research and scientific structure ? 🤔 Because it’s 3000+ years ago and we can’t speak to those people ?

  • @saphernpant8540
    @saphernpant8540 4 месяца назад +27

    We have everyone from software engineers turned cookbook authors to Allopathy doctors bashing Ayurveda all the time. IMHO, no one should have the right to criticise another stream of medicine without dedicating years to study it. Why Ranveer is so naive and expects an unbiased and educated answer is beyond me. IMHO, any doctor worth his salt should refrain from commenting on a subject that he is not an expert on, except to advise the general public to not follow social media trends and self-medicate.

    • @khushimov
      @khushimov 4 месяца назад +4

      Shows their insecurity. Like allopathy has no side effects only benefits. Any allopathy medicine has a side effect on liver first. What money they get for research is way more than ayurvedic medicine research.

    • @raghukoundinya9115
      @raghukoundinya9115 4 месяца назад +12

      ​@@khushimovthere is no such thing as allopathy. It's modern science, modern science never claimed it doesn't have any side effects.

    • @thimbaiah9005
      @thimbaiah9005 4 месяца назад +1

      @@raghukoundinya9115 Yes lmao he even said it iin the clip

    • @ankitjain3760
      @ankitjain3760 4 месяца назад +6

      Why not bash other forms of medicine that are not researched and tested destroying people's life and money?

    • @raghukoundinya9115
      @raghukoundinya9115 4 месяца назад

      @@ankitjain3760 he bashed homeopathy as well.

  • @nidakhanumlodi
    @nidakhanumlodi Месяц назад +1

    I am ayurvedic student we study both modern medicine as well ayurveda please invite Dr ravishankar polisetty a cardiac surgeon who studied both science but practice ayurveda he will shut his mouth

  • @prapti_thakkar
    @prapti_thakkar 3 месяца назад

    Dr., elemental theory or panchamahabhutas are NOT TREATMENT PRINCIPLES. They are principles of सृष्टि उत्पत्ति (beginning of universe) and basic structure of any object you look around.

  • @user-sn9rg3qz7i
    @user-sn9rg3qz7i 4 месяца назад +10

    The fact about Ashwagandha is very true .I was unknowingly allergic to it.Further when i was examined for liver malfunctioning ,the liver was severely impaired.

    • @Hope-ml5nu
      @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад +2

      That is an allergic reaction specific to one person. There are so many people allergic to penicillin. That doesn't mean that penicillin shouldn't be prescribed to other patients who need it.

    • @user-sn9rg3qz7i
      @user-sn9rg3qz7i 4 месяца назад

      @@Hope-ml5nu i mentioned that above.

    • @x4c4
      @x4c4 4 месяца назад +1

      Exactly the dr will ask u for ur allergic history and then take the call. If he dosennt do this u can sue the modern medicine doc. Can this happen in ayurvveda .....?

  • @sujithkvarghese5616
    @sujithkvarghese5616 4 месяца назад +19

    This is called real science. Proud of him.

    • @drabhibds
      @drabhibds 4 месяца назад

      haha nice catholic support..wonder what this doc stand is on catholic priest working miracle cures in Kerala ? I am sure that would be scientific as its been legitmised by the Pope

    • @sujithkvarghese5616
      @sujithkvarghese5616 4 месяца назад

      @@drabhibds This has nothing to do with catholic support. If there is a priest who does this then no one supports the priest. Our religion is science!!!

    • @sachwagh7829
      @sachwagh7829 4 месяца назад

      @sujithkvarghese5616 No science is perfect , we should concentrate on which is best work for which disease whatever its PATHY

    • @praveenhegde8107
      @praveenhegde8107 4 месяца назад +1

      ​​@@sujithkvarghese5616😂😂😂 science is a living phenomenon, what was true earlier is not now .
      This doctor is half baked .
      One face of anything is not truth

    • @sujithkvarghese5616
      @sujithkvarghese5616 4 месяца назад +1

      @@praveenhegde8107 This is the trouble when you don't have scientific temper. I don't blame you because science is not taught in our schools the way it should be. Learn and be free thats all I can say. Ultimately you have to pay the price.

  • @Dr.vaibhavsinhbhosale007
    @Dr.vaibhavsinhbhosale007 7 дней назад

    Tell me About Retinopathic management in Allopathy??🙄
    What about Renal Calculi and Cholelithiasis without any operative ??
    Which Allopathic Medicine you prescribe for IBS??
    Then why you prescribe Liv 52 😒

  • @aksata507
    @aksata507 4 месяца назад +6

    I think sir has not heard about'nidhana parivarjana' which is removing the root cause actually in ayurveda.
    There is no such word in allopathy .
    Allopathic doctors are treating by symptomatically not ayurveda vaidyas .
    Ayurveda is scientifically proven research based medicine .
    Ayurveda Acharyas were researched and documebted the knowledge in samhita .you should know about that.

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +2

      hope you got your ayurvedic covid vaccine.

    • @AP-eb8hd
      @AP-eb8hd 3 месяца назад

      😂

    • @WebbedManiac
      @WebbedManiac 7 дней назад

      Your argument is easily debunked by the mere existence of modern vaccines, anti-biotics and anti-fungal medicines. All of them treat the root cause not the symptoms.

  • @darkfilms1935
    @darkfilms1935 4 месяца назад +34

    now this is gold. a huge lesson in thinking rationally.

    • @116jaguar
      @116jaguar 4 месяца назад +5

      Say anything in English with western medicine tag,, " ya this is rational and correct,, """ bs .crap

    • @RojaJaneman
      @RojaJaneman 4 месяца назад +1

      Ayurveda works. People that know it does will never let it disappear.

    • @ArjunA-ln3ov
      @ArjunA-ln3ov 4 месяца назад +7

      ​@@116jaguar?
      Scientific method is same everywhere

    • @116jaguar
      @116jaguar 4 месяца назад

      @@ArjunA-ln3ov and what exactly is everywhere

    • @darkfilms1935
      @darkfilms1935 4 месяца назад +2

      @@116jaguar a simple statistical hypothesis testing.

  • @sanghachatwam
    @sanghachatwam 3 месяца назад +7

    Huge mistake to bring this "pseudo doc" on your show, Ranveer. Please take the episode down. Not only is he putting the Ayurvedic Doctors down, He's ignorantly ranting about a 5000 year plus ancient system of medicine and the science of Life! People who watch your podcast regularly would think twice before consulting an ayurvedic doctor.

    • @hemantpahuja4114
      @hemantpahuja4114 3 месяца назад

      How does "5000 years" prove anything about it being science? Science doesn't work by this sort of illogical fallacy. No amount of pseudo nationalism and self-glorification of past is a substitute for Science. "5000 years" or "1 billion years" or belief of 8 billion people on Earth don't make a pseudoscience science. Go for randomised double blind clinical trials and get them published in peer reviewed journal like Lancet, Nature. Then everyone will believe in Ayurveda. Otherwise keep saying whatever u or I want to say, it will not become science.

  • @kaleakshay7162
    @kaleakshay7162 4 месяца назад +3

    Any drug taken in excess will cause either side effects like your steroids in COVID, Like paracetamol in NSAID induced Fatty liver or long term usage of rantindine (rantac) in neurological issues

  • @gauthamrao7862
    @gauthamrao7862 4 месяца назад +4

    First of all did he study Ayurveda?

  • @prakharprabhat585
    @prakharprabhat585 4 месяца назад +10

    Tata is going to open an integrated cancer hospital. Ayurveda and allopathy combined. Does he know this?

    • @vkone7162
      @vkone7162 4 месяца назад +4

      Even WHO recommended to promote Traditional medicines

    • @yess10
      @yess10 4 месяца назад

      Most of the modern hospitals have ayurvedic wing nowadays. They don't want to miss out because they know it works.

  • @tanyabharti3852
    @tanyabharti3852 2 месяца назад

    Need more logical people like him🙌

  • @rendezvous59
    @rendezvous59 3 месяца назад +19

    What's funny is that none of the ayurveda experts who comment here have any actual scientific evidence to deny his claims other than anecdotes 😄

    • @TsPakku
      @TsPakku 2 месяца назад

      Sir please can you go search about clinical trials of Ayurveda in Google scholar research gate. Both null hypothesis and alternate hypothesis accepted results can be seen published. Try to research before commenting.

    • @adnanansari9941
      @adnanansari9941 23 дня назад +2

      All anecdotal evidences

    • @AbheekMaharjan-
      @AbheekMaharjan- 17 дней назад

      Science isn't trustworthy. We have seen the scientists flip flop over COVID. We have seen the science promote the big bang theory, which is just as atrocious as the Genesis creation story. The universe is a steady state and science denies that and chooses to believe their own creation story or version of it. Also ayurveda has been used for thousands of years and has worked for friends and family of mine. I'd trust personal experience over a piece of paper or internet study telling me what to believe.

    • @AbheekMaharjan-
      @AbheekMaharjan- 17 дней назад

      The "trust the science" youtube community guidelines keep deleting my comments, but the empirical evidence has been inaccurate many times. They have been inaccurate on the pandemic, they have promoted the big bang theory which is their own creation belief, they have denied that the universe is a steady state, in favor of their own big bang narrative. I would trust personal experience from several family, friends, and loved ones over a piece of paper or internet study telling me what is right

    • @AbheekMaharjan-
      @AbheekMaharjan- 17 дней назад

      The empirical evidence has been inaccurate many times. They have been inaccurate on the pandemic, they have promoted the big bang theory which is their own creation belief, they have denied that the universe is a steady state, in favor of their own big bang narrative. I would trust personal experience from several family, friends, and loved ones over a piece of paper or internet study telling me what is right

  • @androidandroid4461
    @androidandroid4461 4 месяца назад +17

    Finally a sensible man on your podcast for once 😂

    • @Hope-ml5nu
      @Hope-ml5nu 4 месяца назад +4

      Who spreads misinformation with his half-baked knowledge on the subject he's speaking on

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад +2

      @@Hope-ml5nu like 5000 year old foolishness.

    • @nidhimathur2563
      @nidhimathur2563 4 месяца назад

      Where do your so called "sensible" people go when they don't have answers to questions by patients. When more dangerous viruses will show face, these same doctors will be hiding under their beds without any solutions...that is the time when everyone one remembers "ayurveda" and other streams of healing! Stop being an ostrich that has their head stuck in the ground 😂🙏🏻

    • @Theayurvedadoc
      @Theayurvedadoc 3 месяца назад +1

      Sensible who's anti hindu and defaming ayurveda for his own benefits.

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 3 месяца назад

      @@Theayurvedadoc you are the fool preying on innocent people and making money. shame shame.

  • @Wondersofayurveda17
    @Wondersofayurveda17 2 месяца назад

    How the person who havent studied Ayurveda can commnet over Ayurveda?

    • @chickenlover42
      @chickenlover42 2 месяца назад +4

      you only need grade 10th science to comments on ayurveda

  • @Shubhangi_Fultambkar
    @Shubhangi_Fultambkar 4 месяца назад +2

    About Ashwagandha n guduchi.....they r best drugs in Ayurveda when used under medical supervision...basic difference in plant medicine n ayurveda is they r exract base which is again like dingle phytochrmucal u r using...Ayurveda recommends use if whole part of plant which us more useful like root,leaves,fruits sometimes whole plant bcos it contains other ingredients which counteracts with active ingredient giving u more side benefits not side-effects....so please refrain to consume such content from social media ...when it comes to health every science has its own limitations nothing is totally wrong n right

  • @heminpunadiya7509
    @heminpunadiya7509 4 месяца назад +6

    He is commenting on something which he doesn’t know. He should have thorough knowledge of Ayurveda before commenting.
    We do respect both the Mediceans.

    • @user-tx9ck5pk1z
      @user-tx9ck5pk1z 4 месяца назад

      but it looks like you dont respect a dictionary. you should.

  • @user-ro3sz1pp2n
    @user-ro3sz1pp2n 4 месяца назад +10

    Please do video on BHMS Doctor

  • @prapti_thakkar
    @prapti_thakkar 3 месяца назад +1

    Zero Ayurveda contribution???
    Bro Ayurveda has its own set of terminologies which we call RASA, GUNA, VIRYA, VIPAKA, PRABHAVA, KARMA,etc. There is whole brach of Ayurveda aka DRAVYA GUNA which deals with this. You need to understand those basic terms and concepts, to understand contribution of Ayurveda. 12:50

  • @snippinisq9528
    @snippinisq9528 4 месяца назад +1

    Ayurveda is also about plants 😭😭 not just believe . wtf you are saying.....

  • @shastribhaskar
    @shastribhaskar 4 месяца назад +4

    What I hate about these doctors are their Know All attitude. I agree there are bad apples in the system who have brought disrepute to holistic medicine practice, but to conclude that ancient systems are not scientific is absurd. Science itself is evolving and many reputed so called scientific theories are getting debunked every day. When he himself concludes researches are not done then how can he claim Ayurveda does not work.
    If he has the guts he should debate with Dr B M Hegde who is a medical practitioner and professor and I request Ranveer to facilitate this discussion

  • @Nanananana127
    @Nanananana127 4 месяца назад +12

    Ayurveda does not treat the symptom or the disease, it treats the person as a whole.

    • @WizardAmbrose
      @WizardAmbrose 3 месяца назад +5

      Good luck curing cancer with it

    • @akashaym9271
      @akashaym9271 3 месяца назад +5

      Repeat a lie for 1000 times and it won't become a fact.

    • @yashbehera9459
      @yashbehera9459 Месяц назад

      ​@@akashaym9271But alpathy always works in a cost 🤡

  • @ananth051284
    @ananth051284 2 месяца назад +1

    Can Dr Phillips speak about the money swindling phenomenon which happens in corporate hospitals??
    People are turning to Alternative medicine due to the fear of Allopathic doctors 😡. Not all are greedy and inhuman.
    There are good allopathic practitioners in every Indian city.
    Unless you know an allopathic doctor well, i guarantee that none can get proper attention from any corporate hospital.

  • @tusharsavanth1603
    @tusharsavanth1603 4 месяца назад +1

    This guy is paid to tell this...or he is very insecure abt his profession...cuz everything is pseudoscience and medicine is based on placebo effect most often then not..

  • @snehachakraborty1333
    @snehachakraborty1333 4 месяца назад +7

    Yes meditation n pranayam yoga n meditating under a pyramid or putting a pyramid cap n meditating n also drinking pyramid charged water are the key to heal all disease without medicine

    • @theuncoolbateman3732
      @theuncoolbateman3732 4 месяца назад +3

      okay do all these stuff and dont take any medicine even if u get a slightest bacterial infection

    • @maverickcruise
      @maverickcruise 4 месяца назад +1

      When you're on the death bed read your comment and console yourself.

    • @berserkhorimiya
      @berserkhorimiya 4 месяца назад +1

      Always do the same for yourself, a fitting darwinian survival of the fittest.

    • @stratpaul
      @stratpaul 4 месяца назад

      😂😂😂😂. Prove your comment you will become a prophet

  • @kansharma
    @kansharma 4 месяца назад +4

    so does it mean EBM has no side effects.??
    u r giving medicines to cure symptoms or the root cause which causes the symptoms of jaundice, ayurveda does the same .....
    the diff is jus tht ur medicine is based on medical blood test and ayurveda or plant based medicine is based on symptoms of the patient.
    but u cant deny, people are lot more healthier than now , when no EBM is used soo often,,, if u need proof ask ur parents and grandparents.
    sooooo soo much modern medicine is available, still no one is healthy and people are getting sick more often , whyy???

  • @sanikabhattad2711
    @sanikabhattad2711 21 день назад

    If ayurveda was a pseudo science then why would Government build institutes like AIIA.....And why would they establish Minsitry of AYUSH

  • @cheeko6166
    @cheeko6166 2 месяца назад

    This man spoke true facts....respect